Divya Jyoti Mukherjee vs Union Of India And 5 Others

Court
Allahabad High Court

AFR
HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT ALLAHABAD
WRIT - A No. - 17903 of 2026
Divya Jyoti Mukherjee
.....Petitioner(s)
Versus
Union Of India And 5 Others
.....Respondent(s)
Counsel for Petitioner(s) : Faheem Ahmad, J.P. Singh
Counsel for Respondent(s) : A.S.G.I., Kartikeya Saran, Pooja
Agarwal, Tanmay Sadh

Court No. - 52
HON'BLE MRS. MANJU RANI CHAUHAN, J.
Heard learned counsel for the petitioner, Mr. Kartikey Saran, and Mr.
1.
Tanmay Sadh, learned counsel for the respondent-University, and perused
the record.
The instant petition has been filed with a prayer to quash the impugned
2.
orders / public communications dated 20.01.2025 and 30.08.2025 issued by
the Assistant Registrar (Coordination Cell), Banaras Hindu University,
Varanasi, and with a further prayer to direct the respondent No. 6,
Compassionate Appointment Committee through its Chairman, to provide
the requisite application format to the petitioner/ his mother and consider the
claim for compassionate appointment, granting age relaxation in the light of
the law laid down by the Division Bench of this Court in Special Appeal No.
820 of 2025.
3. Placing the brief facts of the case, learned counsel for the petitioner
submits that the petitioner's father - Late Vijay Mukherjee, was appointed as
Class-IV employee in the respondent-University. He died in harness on
27.09.2024. The petitioner was temporarily engaged as a Project Research
Scientist (I) on honorarium basis providing short-term economic relief by an
order dated 03.12.2024. The petitioner's mother - Suchitra Mukherjee,
submitted a formal application on 07.01.2025 through the Registrar, BHU,
requesting for compassionate appointment to her only son, the petitioner
herein.
On the aforesaid application, the Assistant Registrar communicated on
4.
20.01.2025 refusing to provide the application proforma as the petitioner had
already crossed the age of 30 years, which is the age limit for a general
category candidate for being considered for appointment on compassionate

WRIA No. 17903 of 2026
2
ground. The second application was moved, which has been rejected by the
order impugned dated 30.08.2025 on the ground that the petitioner had
already crossed the age as provided under the relevant rules for being
considered for compassionate appointment.
5. Assailing the aforesaid order, learned counsel for the petitioner has relied
upon a judgment of a coordinate Bench of this Court in
Writ A No. 3844 of
2020 (Nameirakpam Shangbanabi v. Banaras Hindu University and 4
others) , and submits that the purpose of compassionate appointment will be
frustrated in case age relaxation is not given to the petitioner. The learned
Single Judge of this Court, by order dated 05.02.2025 passed in
, has observed as follows:
Nameirakpam Shangbanabi (supra)
" I have considered the above submissions and perused the record. It appears that respondents are
9.
applying the rules of direct recruitment for the purpose of consideration of compassionate appointment,
which does not appear to be a correct approach. Rules for direct recruitment cannot govern the conditions
of compassionate appointment since the contingencies in such cases cannot predicted.
10. Even otherwise, Court of the considered opinion that though probably the object of compassionate
appointment will not be available after nine years still considering that petitioner, being a woman, who is
before this Court since 2020, therefore, in the interest of justice this writ petition is disposed of and
impugned order dated 09.03.2018 is set aside."
6. The aforesaid order came to be challenged by the concerned University by
filing Special Appeal No. 820 of 2025, Banaras Hindu University and 4
, wherein also the Division
others v. Nameirakpamshangbanabi Devi
Bench has observed in favour of the person concerned therein, making the
following observations:
" 16. Second, the Compassionate Rules come into play on occurrence of unknown events. A sudden
misfortune may visit the family of a deceased employee, irrespective of the age composition of his family
members. While seeking appointment by competing at a public examination the Recruitment Rules apply
providing for a different principle to provide equal opportunity to all citizens, the Compassionate Rules
and such provisions wherever they exist, aim to address the sudden financial hardships that arise owing to
the loss of sole breadwinner of a family. Therefore, to us, no undue reliance may be placed on the
provisions of Recruitment Rules to defeat the object of the Compassionate Rules. At the same time, if age
relaxation as contemplated under both Rules is given free play that is one in the realm governed by Article
16 of the Constitution of India and the other to the exception thereto, there would be no conflict between
the two sets of rules.
Examined in that light, the resolution of the Executive Council as has been shown to us by learned
17.
counsel for the University, is of no avail. Any decision taken in that light by the Executive Council
limiting the exercise of discretion by the relevant Committee dealing with the Compassionate Rules would
remain unenforceable being outside its jurisdiction and domain and plainly being contrary to the
Compassionate Rules itself. To the extent the Compassionate Rules having statutory force, the Executive
Council that has approved the same may not chose to not enforce any part of it without the said

WRIA No. 17903 of 2026
3
Compassionate Rules itself being amended. Here no amendment has been made to the Compassionate
Rules.
19. Compassionate Appointment by very nature looks to heal the extreme financial hardships that arise on
the family of an unsuspecting employee for reason of sudden death of such employee. It is therefore, not
permissible to assume that merely because the dependent family members of such a deceased employee
would be of age more than the upper age prescribed under the Recruitment Rules, they would face no
financial hardships or would not merit compassionate consideration, as a class. It defies logic and plain
common sense. If accepted it may lead to absurd results and may in fact defeat the very object of the
Compassionate Rules."
7. Accordingly, the petitioner is also entitled for the age relaxation for being
considered for compassionate appointment as per the observations made by
this Court in the order passed by the Division Bench in the same University.
8. Learned counsel for the respondent-University, on the other hand, submits
that the judgment is not applicable in the case of the petitioner, as the
Division Bench of this Court in
Nameirakpamshangbanabi Devi (supra)
has made the following observations regarding age relaxation in paragraph
No. 21:
" 21. Having said that we are unable to subscribe to the further view expressed by the learned Single Judge
that the Recruitment Rules have no application to Compassionate Rules inasmuch as, as noted above,
under the Eligibility Clause under the Compassionate Rules itself, on the issue of eligibility (other than
age), the Recruitment Rules have been made applicable. That effect caused in the law cannot be avoided
just as it cannot be over relied for the purpose of grant of upper age relaxation."
9. He further emphasized that the change in rules includes the age limit for
compassionate appointment as prescribed in the rules, is 18 to 30 years for
general category. There is no relaxation in upper age limit. Relevant extract
of the rules regarding relaxation is being reproduced herein below.
"B. Relaxations:
The lower age limit should, however, in no case be relaxed below 18 years of age. The age eligibility shall
be determined with reference to the date of application; Prescribed Proforma available for making
application as Appendix:-'A'.
While considering the requests of Widows of the deceased employees, the Compassionate Appointment
Committee relaxes the age bar and minimum qualification.
Recommendation of the Committee should be placed before the competent authority for a decision. If the
competent authority disagrees with the Committee's recommendations, the case may be referred to the
next higher authority for a decision."
10. Learned counsel for the respondent University next submits that the
change in rules does not relax the upper age limit, therefore there is no
illegality in the orders impugned.

WRIA No. 17903 of 2026
4
11. Heard learned counsel for the parties.
12. Before proceeding to examine the merits of the case, it would be
appropriate to refer to the relevant provisions of the rules governing
appointment on compassionate grounds in the University, approved vide
ECR No. 154 dated 07.12.2019, annexed as Annexure No.7 at page 41 of the
writ petition. The object of the said scheme is to provide appointment on
compassionate grounds to a dependent family member of a University
employee who dies in harness or is retired on medical grounds, thereby
leaving the family in penury and without any means of livelihood. The
scheme is intended to relieve the family of the University employee
concerned from financial destitution and to enable it to tide over the
emergency. As per the eligibility of dependent family members under the
aforesaid Rules, a dependent family member of a University employee who
dies while in service, may submit an application seeking appointment on
compassionate grounds. The aforesaid Rules further envisage the grant of
compassionate appointment even in cases where an earning member already
exists in the family, subject to the prior approval of the Executive Council.
Before according such approval, the Executive Council is required to satisfy
itself that the grant of compassionate appointment is justified, having regard
to the number of dependents, the assets and liabilities left behind by the
deceased University employee, the income of the earning member and his
liabilities, including whether such earning member is residing with the
family of the deceased employee and whether he is, in fact, extending
financial support to the other members of the family.
Thus, the mere existence of an earning member in the family does not,
13.
by itself, operate as an absolute bar to the grant of compassionate
appointment. The Rules contemplate an assessment of the overall financial
circumstances of the family to determine whether it continues to be in
financial distress and whether compassionate appointment is warranted in
the facts of the particular case.
14. The Scheme further prescribes that the age limit for appointment on
compassionate grounds shall be governed by the applicable Recruitment
Rules of the University. Accordingly, the prescribed age limit for candidates
belonging to the General Category is 18 to 30 years. The Scheme does not
envisage any relaxation in the minimum age prescribed for compassionate
appointment, namely, eighteen years. However, it remains silent with regard
to relaxation of the maximum age limit prescribed under the University
Recruitment Rules. It is pertinent to note that the earlier Rules expressly
provided for relaxation in the upper age limit for appointment on
compassionate grounds. However, the subsequent Scheme does not contain
any corresponding provision in this regard.

WRIA No. 17903 of 2026
5

15. In Clause 16(D) of the said Rules, under the heading 'General', further
stipulates that, since 1958, the University has introduced several welfare
measures which have brought about a significant improvement in the
financial position of the families of University employees who die in
harness. However, an application seeking appointment on compassionate
grounds cannot be rejected merely on the ground that the family of the
deceased University employee has received benefits under the various
welfare schemes. The Rules further mandate that, while considering a
request for appointment on compassionate grounds, a balanced and
objective assessment of the financial condition of the family must be
undertaken, taking into account its assets and liabilities, including the
benefits received under the aforesaid welfare schemes, as well as all other
relevant factors, such as the presence of an earning member in the family,
the size of the family, the age of the children and the essential needs of
the family, amongst other relevant considerations.
Having gone through the above-mentioned Rules, this Court is of the
16.
opinion that by the earlier rule the upper age limit was relaxed, however, the
changed rules being silent about relaxation of the upper age limit goes
against the observations made by the Division Bench of this Court, wherein
it has been observed that for the purposes of compassionate appointment, the
qualification cannot be relaxed, however relaxation in the upper age limit
cannot be done away with.
The purpose and objective of compassionate appointment is to provide
17.
immediate succour to the bereaved family whose sole bread earner has died
in harness. It enables the family to tide over the sudden situation crisis. If
compassionate appointment is not offered within reasonable time, it would
defeat the very object of assisting the family of deceased employee to tide
over the sudden crisis resulting due to the death of bread earner, leaving
his/her family in penury and without any means of livelihood.
18. Taking into account the object of the scheme for providing
compassionate appointment as mentioned above, the dependent family
member of a University employee who dies in harness, leaving the family in
penury and without any means of livelihood, has to be taken into
consideration, which has been ignored in the present case while passing the
orders impugned.
The provisions of the scheme have also gone to the extent of providing
19.
compassionate appointment to those where an earning member exists,
subject to assessment of overall financial circumstances of the family. In the
present case, the aforesaid has not been looked into, and the aspect that the
petitioner being the sole dependent who has to take care of other family

WRIA No. 17903 of 2026
6
members of the deceased employee, has not been considered as he has
crossed the upper age limit of thirty years, which is arbitrary.
20. The scheme has also gone to the extent of consideration of
compassionate appointment, not rejecting the claim merely on the ground
that the family of the deceased employee has received benefits under various
welfare schemes, thus, the only ground of rejecting the claim of the
petitioner of crossing the upper age limit is not justified in the eyes of law.
21. In the considered opinion of this Court, the mere omission of an express
provision for relaxation of the upper age limit in the subsequent scheme
cannot, by itself, be construed as an unequivocal manifestation of the
intention of the scheme-making authority to altogether dispense with such
relaxation, particularly when the preceding scheme expressly recognised
such a provision and the subsequent scheme continues to espouse the same
underlying objective of providing succour to the dependants of deceased
employees. The subsequent scheme, being essentially welfare-oriented in its
nature and purpose, must be construed holistically and purposively, having
due regard to the benevolent object sought to be achieved. It is of
considerable significance that the scheme has adopted a liberal approach by
permitting consideration of claims for compassionate appointment
notwithstanding the receipt of benefits under other welfare schemes or the
employment of another member of the deceased employee's family. Such
provisions unmistakably reflect the intention to prevent technical or
mechanical considerations from frustrating the substantive object of
extending assistance to bereaved families. Viewed in this perspective, the
silence of the subsequent scheme with regard to age relaxation cannot, in the
absence of an express exclusion or a necessary implication to that effect, be
elevated into an absolute embargo against the exercise of such power,
particularly where the same is otherwise traceable to the governing rules or
applicable executive instructions. Any contrary interpretation would risk
rendering the beneficial object of the scheme nugatory by subordinating its
humanitarian purpose to an inflexible and unduly restrictive construction.
Seeing the circumstances of the present case, wherein the petitioner is
22.
the son of the deceased employee and he is the only person to look after the
family of the deceased, (his mother still survives) thus, the petitioner is
entitled to be considered for compassionate appointment.
23. In view of the above, the orders dated 20.01.2025 and 30.08.2025 are
hereby quashed. The matter is remitted to the respondent-authority to
consider and decide the petitioner's matter afresh, expeditiously, preferably
within a period of one month from the date of production of a certified copy
of this order, considering the observations made by this Court regarding

WRIA No. 17903 of 2026
7
compassionate appointment.
The writ petition is accordingly allowed.
24.
No order as to costs.
25.

November 16, 2026
DS
(Mrs. Manju Rani Chauhan,J.)
Digitally signed by :-
DIGAMBER SINGH
High Court of Judicature at Allahabad