Manoj Kumar vs State Of Haryana And Another
- Court
- Punjab and Haryana High Court
IN TH
206
Manoj Kum
State of Ha
CORAM: HON
Present:- Mr. L
for th
Mr. P
HE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AN
D HARYANA AT CHANDIGARH
CWP-1220-
Date of De
-2020 (O&M)
ecision:- 16.11.2026
mar
… Petitioner
Versus
aryana and another
... Respondents
N'BLE MS. JUSTICE NIDHI GUPTA
A
Lalit Kumar, Advocate
he petitioner.
Parveen Kumar, DAG, Haryana.
NIDHI GUPTA, J
J .
Prese
ent Civil Writ Petition under Art
ticles 226 of the Constitution of
f
India has been
filed by the petitioner for issu
ance of a writ in the nature of
f
Certiorari for q
quashing the Revised Answer k
key issued by Respondent No.2
2
which has be
en obtained through Right t
to Information Act, 2005 on
n
13.12.2019 (An
nnexure P-5) wherein answers
of two questions are incorrect
t
and whereas,
the answers given by the Pe
etitioner of said questions are
e
correct; with a
a further prayer for the issuan
nce of a writ in the nature of
f
mandamus dir
recting the Respondent No.2
to consider the name of the
e
petitioner in fi
inal selection list of candidates
s after granting of 4 marks of
f
above said que
estions for the selection of pos
t of Draftsman under Category
y
NEELAM KUMARI
2026.11.17 17:13
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP-1220-2020 (
(O&M) - 2 -
ant to Advertisement No.7/201
No.05 in pursu
15 dated 10.07.2015 (Annexure
e
P-1). The name
e of petitioner has already been
shown as passed candidates in
n
the written exa
mination conducted by respond
dent no.1, against the Roll No. of
f
petitioner i.e.
7154100027 and the petition
ner has already appeared for
r
scrutiny of the
documents as well as in interv
iew and petitioner having been
n
obtained 150 i
n the written examination and
9 marks in interview and total
l
marks of petitio
oner is 159.
2. It is
inter alia submitted by ld. cou
unsel for the petitioner that in
pursuance to A
Advertisement No. 7/2015 dat
ted 10.07.2015 (Annexure P-1)
)
issued by respo
ondent No. 2-Haryana Staff Sele
ection Commission (hereinafter
r
referred to as
'HSSC'), petitioner had applie
ed for appointment to post of
f
Draftsman unde
er Category No. 5, in the Genera
al Category.
3. Petit
tioner had duly appeared in the
e written test and was declared
d
qualified vide r
result of the written examinatio
on dated 15.09.2018 (Annexure
e
P-1/A). Accordi
ngly, the petitioner was called f
for scrutiny of documents. Vide
e
letter dated 19.
.09.2018 (Annexure P-2), the pe
titioner was called for interview
w
scheduled for 2
28.09.2018.
4. Ld. c
counsel for the petitioner subm
its that after declaration of the
e
result of the w
written examination, the respo
ndent Commission had invited
d
objections. Upo
on which, the petitioner had file
ed objections dated 13.12.2017
7
(Annexure P-3)
against some questions as per
the booklet of the Petitioner at
t
serial number 1
14, 37, 38, 54, 83, 96, 97.
NEELAM KUMARI
2026.11.17 17:13
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP-1220-2020 (
(O&M) - 3 -
sponse thereto, respondent No.
5. In re
. 2 had provided revised answer
r
key only on dat
ted 13.12.2019 (Annexure P-5)
whereby, petitioner discovered
d
that after filling
g of specific objections, respon
dent no 2 did not consider the
e
said questions
as correct and petitioner came
to know that he got 150 marks
s
in written exam
mination and 9 marks in interview
w, totaling the marks as 159 and
d
cut off marks o
of the selected candidates in fin
nal list is 160 and each question
n
contains 2 mark
ks.
6. Ld. c
counsel submits that although
the petitioner had submitted
d
objections with
h regard to various questions, ho
owever, the petitioner does not
t
press his obje
ections qua Question No. 83
and others; and presses his
s
objections only
y qua Question No. 97. It is subm
mitted that in regard to Question
n
No. 97, the ans
swer given by the petitioner can
not be taken as wrong. Further,
,
admittedly, the
e cut-off marks for appointme
ent is 160; the petitioner has
s
secured 159 ma
arks; each question is for 2 mark
ks; and therefore, if objection of
f
the petitioner
qua Question No. 97 is accept
ted, then the petitioner will be
e
eligible for app
pointment. It is also pointed out
t that the petitioner is No. 1 on
n
the waiting list.
7. Acco
ordingly, it is prayed that the pr
resent writ petition be allowed
d
and that “ a wri
it in the nature of Certiorari be
issued for quashing the Revised
d
Answer key issu
ued by Respondent No.2 which h
has been obtained through Right
t
to Information
Act, 2005 on 13.12.2019 (Ann
exure P-5) whereby answers of
f
two questions a
are incorrect and whereas, the
answers given by the Petitioner
r
of said questio
ns are correct and also a writ
in the nature of mandamus be
e
NEELAM KUMARI
2026.11.17 17:13
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP-1220-2020 (
(O&M) - 4 -
g the Respondent No.2 to consid
issued directing
der the name of the petitioner in
n
final selection
list of candidates after granti
ing of 4 marks of above said
d
questions for t
the selection of post of Drafts
sman under Category No.05 in
n
pursuant to Ad
dvertisement No.7/2015 dated 1
10.07.2015 (Annexure P-1). The
e
name of petiti
ioner has already been shown
n as passed candidates in the
e
written examin
nation conducted by responden
t no.1, against the Roll No. of
f
petitioner i.e.
7154100027 and the petition
ner has already appeared for
r
scrutiny of the
documents as well as in intervi
iew and petitioner having been
n
obtained 150 in
n the written examination and
9 marks in interview and total
l
marks of petitio
oner is 159.”
8. Per c
contra, ld. State counsel has obj
jected to the submissions made
e
on behalf of th
he petitioner and has contende
d that while inviting objections
s
vide notice date
ed 09.12.2017, it had been mad
e crystal clear to the candidates
s
that "the objec
tions shall be considered by the
e Commission and its decision in
n
this regard sha
all be final and evaluation of
the paper shall accordingly be
e
done." Moreov
ver, it is an established position
in law that the expert opinion
n
has to prevail.
NCERT relied upon by the pe
etitioner cannot be allowed to
o
supersede the e
expert opinion.
9. It is
further submitted that the Com
mmission presently follows the
e
following proce
edure in all the cases i.e. publish
hing the answer key for seeking
g
objections, rec
ceiving objections, forwarding
the objections to the Chief-
-
Examiner, prep
paration of final answer key
y by the Chief-Examiner and
d
forwarding the
same to the Commission. The
Commission sends the revised
d
NEELAM KUMARI
2026.11.17 17:13
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP-1220-2020 (
(O&M) - 5 -
ey to the evaluator and evalu
final answer k
uation on the basis of revised
d
answer key pre
epared by the Chief-Examiner on
n the basis of the comments of
f
the Expert Com
mmittee is made by the evaluator
r.
10. It is s
submitted that the Commission
is not an expert body to decide
e
the correctnes
ss of the answer and it is le
eft to the Chief-Examiner. The
e
Commission rel
lies upon the expert report of th
he Chief-Examiner.
11. It is
reiterated that it is settled law
w that the report of the Chief-
-
Examiner canno
ot be questioned. Moreover, in t
the present world of digitization
n
and internet, t
he answers to different questio
ons may differ from site to site
e
and book to b
book. Thus, the Commission ha
as no process to ascertain the
e
correctness of
an answer at its own level and
therefore has no option but to
o
rely upon the r
report of the Chief-Examiner/Ex
pert Committee. Moreover, the
e
revised answer
key supplied by the Chief-Exam
miner has been made applicable
e
to all the cand
idates and evaluation of OMR a
answer sheets have been done
e
accordingly.
12. It is
further argued that it is set
ttled law that once the Chief
f
Examiner has f
finalized the answer key then th
he same shall be considered as
s
final as the exp
ertise in the academic matter is
left to the experts only. Further
r
in the event of
f a doubt, the benefit should g
o to the examination authority
y
rather than to t
the candidate. Hon'ble Supreme
Court in Civil Appeal No.367 of
f
2017 in case t
itled as "Ran Vijay Singh and
Others) Versus State of Uttar
r
Pradesh and Ot
thers." (decided on 11.12.2017)
.
NEELAM KUMARI
2026.11.17 17:13
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP-1220-2020 (
(O&M) - 6 -
further pointed out that in c
13. It is
compliance of the order dated
d
10.07.2026, an
n affidavit dated 09.10.2026
has been filed on behalf of
f
respondent No
o. 2 thereby informing that at
present there are four vacant
t
posts of Drafts
sman in the General including
g SBC category. It is, however,
,
submitted that
against the said vacancies, app
pointments are first liable to be
e
made from the
e waiting list. It is accordingly
y prayed that the present writ
t
petition be dism
missed.
14. No o
other argument is made on be
half of learned counsel for the
e
parties. I have h
heard ld. counsel and perused th
he case file and record in detail.
.
I find merit in th
he submissions advanced on beh
half of the petitioner.
15. Petit
tioner does not press objections
s qua any other question, except
t
Question No.97
7 which reads as follows:-
“Questio
on no 97: Apae sae Bahar hona :
:
(A) Ghar
kae bahar hona
(B) Gussa
a hona
(C) Sayam
m khona
(D) apne
ap jana”
16. In th
he present case, petitioner has
opted for Option ‘B’; whereas
s
the answer as
per the respondents’ revised
answer key is Option ‘C’. As a
a
layperson, it w
will not be incorrect to state th
hat in common parlance, both
h
options are acc
ceptable interpretations/meanin
ngs of the proverb in question.
.
As per the expe
ert opinion rendered by the NC
ERT (Annexure R-1), the Option
n
B chosen by the
e petitioner is correct. On the ot
ther hand, Ld. State counsel has
s
relied upon the
e judgment in Ran Vijay Singh (s
supra) wherein it has been held
d
NEELAM KUMARI
2026.11.17 17:13
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP-1220-2020 (
(O&M) - 7 -
tise in academic matters is left t
that the expert
to the experts only. There is no
o
dispute with th
e said proposition of law as laid
d down by the Hon'ble Supreme
e
Court. Howeve
r, the Hon'ble Supreme Court i
n the latest judgment of Siddhi
i
Sandeep Ladda
a vs Consortium of National
Law Universities and another
r
arising out of S
SLP (C) No.12786 of 2025 has di
iluted the above position in law
w
to now hold t
that Courts have the power t
to examine the correctness of
f
questions and a
answers. Relevant Para reads as
under:-
“8. Insofar as th
he present appeals are concerne
ed, at the outset, we must state
e
that in academ
mic matters, the Courts are g
enerally reluctant to interfere,
inasmuch as the
ey do not possess the requisite e
expertise for the same. However,
,
when the acade
emicians themselves act in a ma
anner that adversely affects the
e
career aspiratio
ons of lakhs of students, the Cou
urt is left with no alternative but
t
to interfere.”
17. Thus
s, in situation such as th
e present one, where the
e
question/answe
er is ambiguous, it is open to th
his Court to interfere. It is to be
e
appreciated th
at as per the NCERT book (A
nnexure R-1), Option B is the
e
correct/more a
accurate answer. Question No.
97, which seeks to assess the
e
correct interpre
etation of the Hindi idiomatic ex
xpression 'Apae se bahar hona' ,
,
has therefore, b
been erroneously evaluated in t
the revised answer key. The key
y
identifies "Saya
am Khona" [to lose self-control]
as the correct answer. However,
,
this choice wo
uld be semantically and contex
xtually inaccurate. The idiom in
n
question, as pe
er standard Hindi lexicons, NCE
RT Hindi textbooks, and widely
y
accepted peda
agogical usage, unequivocally
conveys the meaning "Gussa
a
Hona" [to beco
me angry or to lose temper].
NEELAM KUMARI
2026.11.17 17:13
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP-1220-2020 (
(O&M) - 8 -
Respondent's defense that the
18. The
revised answer is based on an
"expert opinion
n", is fundamentally flawed fo
or multiple reasons. Firstly, no
o
details of such
an expert, his qualifications, m
methodology, or credibility, have
e
been placed o
on record. Secondly, it is settle
ed law that when established
d
academic sourc
ces such as NCERT textbooks an
d official government published
d
dictionaries off
fer a clear and unambiguous
definition, those sources must
t
prevail over an
n unverified or anonymous exp
ert opinion. In this regard, the
e
Hon'ble Supre
me Court in Richal & Ors.
v. Rajasthan Public Service
e
Commission, (2
2018) 8 SCC 81 , held that:
"When a mode
el answer is found to be incorre
ect on the face of authoritative
e
academic sourc
ces, the Court is justified in step
pping in to correct the manifest
t
error and preve
ent injustice."
19. The
evaluation process in public c
competitive examinations must
t
uphold principl
es of academic accuracy, proced
dural fairness, and transparency.
.
Permitting the
use of demonstrably erroneous
s answers, especially where the
e
correct meanin
ng is conclusively supported by
y textbooks prescribed by the
e
NCERT and ot
ther government institutions,
amounts to an arbitrary and
d
irrational decis
ion-making process, in violatio
n of Articles 14 and 16 of the
e
Constitution.
20. Ld. S
State counsel has also not disput
ted the factual position that the
e
petitioner has
secured 159 marks (150 in wri
itten examination + 9 marks in
n
interview); that
t the cut-off marks for appointm
ment to the post of Draftsman in
n
Category No. 5
5 against Advertisement No.7/
/2015 is 160 marks; that each
h
question carrie
s 2 marks; that the petitioner is
s No. 1 in the Waiting List; that
t
NEELAM KUMARI
2026.11.17 17:13
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP-1220-2020 (
(O&M) - 9 -
e is no challenge to the selectio
as of now there
on of candidates in the General
l
Category; and
that as per Affidavit dated 0
09.10.2026, it is evident from
m
document date
ed 29.9.2026 (Annexure R-2/1),
, that there are presently four
r
vacancies for
the post of Draftsman agains
st Advertisement No. 7/2015,
,
Category No. 5
against General including SBC ca
ategory.
21. Acco
ordingly, keeping in view the e
entire conspectus of the afore-
-
noted facts, the
e present writ petition is allowed
d . The respondents are directed
d
to consider th
he case of the petitioner for
appointment to the post of
f
Draftsman agai
nst Advertisement No. 7/2015,
Category No. 5 against General
l
category in acco
ordance with law.
22. Pend
ding application(s), if any, also st
ands disposed of.
16.11.2026
Neelam
( N
NIDHI GUPTA )
JUDGE
Wheth
Wheth
her speaking /reasoned Yes / N
her Reportable Yes / N
No
No
NEELAM KUMARI
2026.11.17 17:13
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document