Ramlalit Dead Through Lrs Smt. Lachi Devi vs Sub Aria Manager
- Court
- Madhya Pradesh High Court
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:92081
1 WP-10293-2015
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
AT JABALPUR
BEFORE
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE ANAND SINGH BAHRAWAT
th
ON THE 19 OF NOVEMBER, 2026
WRIT PETITION No. 10293 of 2015
CNR No.: MPHC010308522015
RAMLALIT DEAD THROUGH LRS SMT. LACHI DEVI AND OTHERS
Versus
SUB ARIA MANAGER
Appearance:
Shri Aditya Awasthi - Advocate for the petitioners.
Shri Anoop Nair, learned Senior Advocate along with Shri Mihir
Lunawat, learned counsel for respondent.
ORDER
The present petition has been filed seeking the following reliefs :-
( ) -
१ यह क आलो य अवाड द. १.११.२०१३ द तावेज क. पी ९ के उस
हसे को अपा त कया जाए जसके ारा !बना !पछले वेतन के
यािचकाकता को सेवा म ( िलए जाने का आदेश है एवं यह ,ितपादत
कया जाए क बखा तगी के दौरान के संपूण वेतन भी यािचकाकता ,ा3
करने का अिधकार 5 है एवं तदानुसार ,7यथ9 को यह आदेिशत कया जाए
क ,7यथ9 यािचकाकता को यािचकाकता क : बखा तगी के दौरान का
संपूण वेतन १२ ,ितशत सालाना ;याज के साथ यािचकाकता को ,दान
करे।
( )
२ यह क ,7यथ9 को उिचत आदेश दया जाए क यािचकाकता को
िनयमानुसार िनयिमत प (शन एवं संपूण बकाया प (शन रािश १२ ,ितशत
सालाना ;याज के साथ यािचकाकता को ,दान करे।
( )
३ यह क ,7यथ9 को उिचत आदेश दया जाए क वह यािचकाकता को
सम त सेवािनवृ !> लाभ रािश १२ ,ितशत सालाना ;याज के साथ ,दान
करे।
( )
४ यह क यािचकाकता को िनलंबन दनांक से मूल वेतन ड 5.ए.
एस.ड 5.ए. नाईट एलाउंस एल.ट 5.सी. एल.एल.ट 5.सी पी.एच.ड 5. संडे
, , , ,
अंडर Bाउंड एलाउंस एड 5शनल एलाउंस चाज एलाउंस Cवाटर एलाउंस
, ,
गैस िसल (डर पैम (ट आर Dण ,मोशन ,दान कया जाए।
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: RASHMI
RONALD VICTOR
Signing time: 20-11-2026
10:46:01
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:92081
2 WP-10293-2015
( )
५ यह क ,करण क : प FरथितयG के अनुसार यािचकाकता के प D म (
एवं ,7यथ9 के !वHI अ Jय उिचत आदेश पा Fरत कए जाएं।
( )
६ यह क यािचकाकता को ,7यथ9 से यािचका Lयय दलाया जाए।
2. Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that the petitioner was
initially appointed as a Mining Sirdar and joined the services of the
respondent establishment in the year 1973. Throughout his service, he
discharged his duties with utmost devotion and diligence, and no adverse
remark was ever recorded against him. However, on 18.07.1991, a charge-
sheet was issued to him, and by the same order, he was placed under
suspension. The allegation levelled against him was that he had illegally
constructed a house over the land belonging to the respondent company.
3. It is further submitted that the petitioner had not raised any such
construction and that the construction, if any, was made by his elder son,
who was residing separately with his own family. The petitioner had no
concern with the said construction. It is also submitted that during the course
of the departmental enquiry, the management witnesses were duly cross-
examined and the petitioner was afforded an opportunity to put forth his
defence. Learned counsel further submits that the Sarpanch of the concerned
area had also furnished an affidavit stating that the petitioner had not
encroached upon the land belonging to the respondent company.
4. Learned counsel for the petitioner further submits that, without
properly appreciating the aforesaid facts and the material available on record,
the services of the petitioner were terminated vide order dated 04.06.1994.
Aggrieved thereby, the petitioner raised an industrial dispute, which was
referred to the Central Government Industrial Tribunal-cum-Labour Court,
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: RASHMI
RONALD VICTOR
Signing time: 20-11-2026
10:46:01
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:92081
3 WP-10293-2015
Jabalpur. The Tribunal, vide award dated 01.11.2013, set aside the order of
termination and directed reinstatement of the petitioner in service. However,
the Tribunal denied him the benefit of back wages.
5. It is contended that once the Tribunal had found the punishment of
termination to be disproportionate and had interfered with the order of
termination, it ought to have considered the petitioner's entitlement to back
wages as well. Learned counsel submits that the Tribunal failed to properly
appreciate the fact that the petitioner had not himself raised any construction
over the company's land and that the affidavit furnished by the Sarpanch
supported his defence. It is further submitted that the construction, if any,
was attributable to his elder son, who was living separately from the
petitioner and was not dependent upon him.
6. Learned counsel for the petitioner also submits that, before the
Tribunal, the petitioner had specifically pleaded that he was not gainfully
employed in any other establishment during the period in question. Despite
the said specific assertion, the Tribunal erroneously denied the benefit of
back wages without properly appreciating the circumstances of the case. In
support of his submissions, learned counsel places reliance upon the
judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Fisheries Department, State of
Uttar Pradesh v. Charan Singh, reported in (2015) 8 SCC 150.
7. Per contra, learned counsel appearing for the respondent submits
that the Tribunal passed the award dated 01.11.2013 after duly considering
the enquiry report, the evidence led by the management and the material
available on record. It is submitted that the management witnesses
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: RASHMI
RONALD VICTOR
Signing time: 20-11-2026
10:46:01
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:92081
4 WP-10293-2015
categorically stated that the original petitioner/workman had raised an
unauthorized construction alongside the road near Durga Temple. The
Enquiry Officer, after appreciating the evidence, recorded a finding that the
construction raised by the workman was larger in size than the wooden thela
situated alongside the road.
8. It is further submitted that the Tribunal, while considering the
evidence, also noticed that the petitioner was carrying on bicycle-repairing
work from the said construction. This circumstance clearly indicates that the
construction was being utilized for carrying on an income-generating
activity. Thus, the petitioner was not only in occupation of the unauthorized
construction but was also earning income by carrying on bicycle-repairing
work therein.
9. Learned counsel further submits that the map produced by the
respondent also supports the finding regarding the unauthorized construction.
The Tribunal, while considering the nature and extent of the misconduct,
took a lenient view and held that the punishment of termination from service
was disproportionate to the misconduct alleged and proved. The Tribunal
also observed that termination from service had serious consequences for the
entire family of the workman and accordingly, directed his reinstatement.
However, considering that the petitioner was carrying on bicycle-repairing
work and was earning income therefrom, the Tribunal rightly declined to
grant back wages. It is, therefore, submitted that the award passed by the
Tribunal is just and proper and does not warrant any interference by this
Court.
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: RASHMI
RONALD VICTOR
Signing time: 20-11-2026
10:46:01
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:92081
5 WP-10293-2015
10. Learned counsel for the respondent further places reliance upon the
judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in J.K. Synthetics Ltd. v. K.P.
Agrawal and Another, reported in (2007) 2 SCC 433, and submits that
payment of back wages is neither automatic nor an inevitable consequence of
an order of reinstatement. The entitlement to back wages is required to be
determined on the facts and circumstances of each case.
11. Reliance is also placed upon the judgment in Kendriya Vidyalaya
Sangathan and Another v. S.C. Sharma, reported in (2005) 2 SCC 363 , to
contend that the workman is required to plead and establish that he was not
gainfully employed during the period for which back wages are claimed. It is
submitted that, in the present case, the findings recorded by the Enquiry
Officer and considered by the Tribunal establish that the petitioner was
carrying on bicycle-repairing work from the unauthorized construction and
was earning income therefrom. In such circumstances, the Tribunal was
justified in denying back wages while granting the relief of reinstatement.
Learned counsel, therefore, prays for dismissal of the petition.
12. Heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the record.
13. The principal question which arises for consideration in the present
petition is whether the Tribunal was justified in denying the benefit of back
wages to the petitioner despite setting aside the order of termination and
directing his reinstatement in service.
14. At the outset, it is pertinent to observe that reinstatement in service
and payment of back wages are two distinct reliefs. Merely because an order
of termination is set aside and reinstatement is directed, it does not
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: RASHMI
RONALD VICTOR
Signing time: 20-11-2026
10:46:01
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:92081
6 WP-10293-2015
automatically follow that the workman becomes entitled to full back wages.
The question of payment of back wages is required to be determined
independently, having regard to the facts and circumstances of the case, the
nature of the misconduct, the evidence available on record and the question
of gainful employment during the intervening period.
15. In the present case, the Tribunal, after examining the enquiry
proceedings, the evidence adduced by the management and the findings
recorded by the Enquiry Officer, came to the conclusion that the petitioner
had raised an unauthorized construction over the land belonging to the
respondent company and was carrying on bicycle-repairing work from the
said premises. The Tribunal also considered the nature and extent of the
construction and the circumstances in which the petitioner was carrying on
the said activity.
16. It is true that the petitioner disputed his involvement in the
construction and sought to attribute the same to his elder son, who was
allegedly residing separately. He also relied upon the affidavit of the
Sarpanch in support of his defence. However, these submissions have to be
examined in the light of the findings recorded by the Enquiry Officer and
considered by the Tribunal on the basis of the evidence led during the
enquiry. The petitioner has not demonstrated any perversity or patent
illegality in the appreciation of evidence by the Tribunal so as to warrant
interference by this Court in exercise of its writ jurisdiction.
17. So far as the claim for back wages is concerned, the Tribunal
specifically noticed that the petitioner was carrying on bicycle-repairing
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: RASHMI
RONALD VICTOR
Signing time: 20-11-2026
10:46:01
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:92081
7 WP-10293-2015
work from the premises in question. The said finding is relevant for
determining his entitlement to back wages, as it indicates that the petitioner
was engaged in an income-generating activity. The petitioner, on the other
hand, has not been able to establish that the finding recorded by the Tribunal
in this regard is based on no evidence or suffers from any manifest illegality.
18. The contention of the petitioner that he had specifically pleaded
before the Tribunal that he was not gainfully employed in any other
organization does not, by itself, entitle him to back wages. The question is
not confined merely to whether the petitioner was employed in another
formal establishment; rather, the relevant consideration is whether he was
engaged in any activity generating income during the relevant period. The
Tribunal, upon consideration of the material available on record, found that
the petitioner was carrying on bicycle-repairing work and earning income
therefrom. This finding has a direct bearing on his claim for back wages.
19. In J.K. Synthetics Ltd. (supra), the Hon'ble Supreme Court has
held that back wages do not follow automatically upon an order of
reinstatement and that the question of payment of back wages has to be
determined by considering the facts and circumstances of each case.
Similarly, in Kendriya Vidyalaya Sangathan (supra), the Hon'ble Supreme
Court emphasized the relevance of the workman's assertion and proof
regarding absence of gainful employment while considering a claim for back
wages.
20. In the facts of the present case, the Tribunal has not denied
reinstatement to the petitioner. On the contrary, after finding the punishment
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: RASHMI
RONALD VICTOR
Signing time: 20-11-2026
10:46:01
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:92081
8 WP-10293-2015
of termination to be disproportionate to the misconduct, it granted him the
relief of reinstatement but declined to award back wages in view of the
material indicating that he was earning income through bicycle-repairing
work. Thus, the Tribunal has considered the two reliefs independently and
has assigned a rational basis for denying back wages.
21. The judgment relied upon by learned counsel for the petitioner in
Fisheries Department (supra), does not advance the petitioner's case in the
facts and circumstances of the present matter, particularly when the Tribunal
has recorded a specific finding regarding the petitioner's engagement in an
income-generating activity. The said decision does not lay down any absolute
proposition that back wages must invariably follow an order of
reinstatement, irrespective of the facts of the case.
22. It is also well settled that the jurisdiction of this Court under Article
226 of the Constitution of India is supervisory in nature. This Court does not
ordinarily sit as an appellate authority over the findings recorded by the
Industrial Tribunal and would interfere only where such findings are
perverse, based on no evidence, contrary to law or suffer from patent
illegality resulting in a miscarriage of justice.
23. In the present case, the petitioner has failed to point out any
perversity, jurisdictional error or manifest illegality in the award dated
01.11.2013. The Tribunal has considered the material available on record,
granted the relief of reinstatement by interfering with the punishment of
termination and, at the same time, declined back wages for reasons germane
to the issue. The decision to deny back wages cannot be said to be arbitrary
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: RASHMI
RONALD VICTOR
Signing time: 20-11-2026
10:46:01
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:92081
9 WP-10293-2015
or unreasonable merely because the petitioner had pleaded that he was not
employed in any other organization.
24. This Court also finds that the Tribunal has adopted a balanced
approach by setting aside the punishment of termination and directing
reinstatement, while declining back wages in view of the petitioner's income-
generating activity. No material has been brought on record to demonstrate
that the aforesaid conclusion suffers from any legal infirmity warranting
interference in the exercise of writ jurisdiction.
25. In view of the aforesaid discussion, this Court is of the considered
opinion that the petitioner has failed to make out any ground for interference
with the award dated 01.11.2013 passed by the Central Government
Industrial Tribunal-cum-Labour Court, Jabalpur, insofar as it denies the
benefit of back wages to the petitioner. The Tribunal has considered the
relevant material and has assigned cogent reasons for arriving at its
conclusion. No perversity, patent illegality or jurisdictional error is made out
warranting exercise of the extraordinary writ jurisdiction of this Court under
Article 226 of the Constitution of India.
26. Accordingly, the petition, being devoid of merit, is hereby
dismissed.
There shall be no order as to costs.
(ANAND SINGH BAHRAWAT)
JUDGE
RS
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: RASHMI
RONALD VICTOR
Signing time: 20-11-2026
10:46:01