Sri Sudhang Kr Brahma vs The State Of Assam And 6 Ors
- Court
- Gauhati High Court
Page No.# 1/9
GAHC010161102026
2026:GAU-AS:16597
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : WP(C)/4098/2026
SRI SUDHANG KR BRAHMA
SON OF LATE RATI RAM BRAHMA, R/O WARD NO 5, MIJING NWGWR, PO,
PS AND DIST KOKRAJHAR, BTC, ASSAM, PIN 783370
VERSUS
THE STATE OF ASSAM AND 6 ORS
REPRESENTED BY THE SECRETARY TO THE GOVT OF ASSAM, PUBLIC
WORKS BUILDING DEPARTMENT, DISPUR, GUWAHATI, PIN 781006
2:THE CHIEF ENGINEER
PUBLIC WORKS DEPARTMENT BUILDING ASSAM CHANDMARI
GUWAHATI ASSAM PIN 781003
3:THE ADDL CHIEF ENGINEER
PUBLIC WORKS DEPARTMENT ELECTRICAL CHANDMARI GUWAHATI
ASSAM PIN 781003
4:THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
PWD KOKRAJHAR DISTRICT AND CHIRANG DISTRICT TERRITORIAL
BUILDING DIVISION ASSAM
5:HARUNUR RASHID
SO LT ALHAJ NURUL ISLAM RO VILL NAYAPARA WARD NO 5 HASILA
BILL NEAR POWER HOUSE PO PS AND DIST GOALPARA ASSAM PIN 783101
6:RAJU CHANDRA BASUMATARY
SO BUTONG BASUMATARY RO VILL NAMALPUR BHATARMARI PO SIDLI
DIST CHIRANG BTC ASSAM PIN 783385
7:SRIMANTA SANKARDEV INFRACON PVT LTD
WARD NO 3 S S ROAD ABHAYAPURI DIST BONGAIGAON ASSAM PIN
Page No.# 2/9
78338
- B E F O R E -
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE ARUN DEV CHOUDHURY
For the petitioner : Mr. BJ Mukherjee, Adv
For the Respondents : Mr. B Chowdhury, SC, PWD
Date of reserve of the judgment : N/A
Date of pronouncement of judgment : 12.11.2026
Whether the pronouncement is of the
operative part of the judgment? : N/A
Whether the judgment has been pronounced? : N/A
J UDGMENT & O RDER ( ORAL )
1. The present writ petition is filed challenging the action of
the respondent authorities in rejecting the technical bid of the
petitioner on the ground of alleged non-fulfillment of requirement
of 4.5(A)(g).
2. A Notice Inviting Tender (NIT) was issued for the
construction of District and Sessions Judge's Quarter, Grade-I
Judicial Officers Quarter – 2 units, Grade-II Judicial Officer’s
Quarter – 4 units, Grade-III Judicial Officer’s Quarter-4 units, at
Kajalgaon in Chirang District, BTC, Assam. The petitioner, along
with some other bidders, participated in the tender process.
3. The Bid Evaluation Committee, in its meeting dated
22.07.2026, considered the bid of all eight bidders and the
Page No.# 3/9
petitioner's bid was disqualified for not satisfying the requirement
of Clause 4.5A(g). Some other bidders' bids were also disqualified
for non-fulfilling the qualification criteria, which is not subject
matter of the present proceeding. Accordingly, the bids of the
respondent Nos.5 to 7 were declared to be technically responsive
4. The clause 4.5A(g)(h) being relevant is quoted herein
below:
4.5 A. QUALIFICATION CRITERIA
g) Value of completed electrical work is of
Rs.1,20,59,523.00 (Rupees one crore twenty lakh
lakh fifty nine thousand five hundred twenty three)
only, in any one year of the last five years.
d) The bidder should possess valid electrical license for
executing electrification works of the projects. In case the
bidder is not in possession of such license, the bidder must
enter into a collaboration/tie-up arrangement with such
license holder having requisite experience. Such tie up
must be registered in court for carrying out electrification
works. Necessary documents should be furnished along
with the bid.
5. From the aforesaid, it is seen that Clause 4.5A deals with
qualification criteria, and Clause 4.5A(g) prescribes that the
contractor/bidder has to submit completion certificate of the
eligible project issued by not less than the Executive Engineer,
where the value of completed electrical work is Rs.1,20,59,523
only in any one year of the last five years.
6. The clause (d) is also relevant. Though this clause is
named as(d), in actual seriatim, the said clause is 4.5A(h) and it is
Page No.# 4/9
an admitted position that the same was a typographical error.
Therefore, for sake of clarity, the said clause is treated as
4.5A(h).
7. Be that as it may, clause 4.5A(h) further mandates that
the bidder should possess a valid electrical license for the
execution of electrical works of the project. However, an
exemption is granted to requirements of such a certificate, subject
to the condition that the bidder must enter into a collaboration/tie-
up arrangement with such a license holder who has the requisite
experience. The further qualification in this regard is that such tie-
up must be registered in court for carrying out electrification
works, and that necessary documents should be furnished along
with the bid.
8. Though the Bid Evaluation Committee's meeting reflects
that the petitioner was disqualified for not satisfying Clause
4.5A(g), however, the record reveals that the petitioner had
provided the required certificate of completed electrical works over
and above, the threshold amount of Rs.1,20,59,523 prescribed
under the aforesaid clause.
9. That being the position, the argument of the learned
counsel for the petitioner, though looks attractive that the
disqualification of the petitioner's bid was arbitrary and beyond the
scope of the tender condition, however, Mr. B Chowdhury, learned
standing counsel, PWD argues that the petitioner did not satisfy
the requirement under Clause 4.5A(d) and he contends that the
petitioner did not furnish the documents showing that the entity to
Page No.# 5/9
whom the petitioner having a tie up had the requisite experience.
10. To such an argument, Mr. BJ Mukherjee, learned counsel
for the petitioner submits that this is a new ground taken by the
Bid Evaluation Committee, which cannot be raised after a decision
was already taken by the Bid Evaluation Committee on
22.07.2026.
11. The petitioner further assails that the respondent Nos. 5
to 7 also did not have the requisite qualification, however, they
have been illegally declared to be technically responsive. They
ought to have been disqualified for the reason that they did not
satisfy the qualifying criteria under Clause 4.5A(g).
12. I have given my anxious considerations to the arguments
advanced by the learned counsel for the parties.
13. Upon perusal of the record including the original records
produced by the learned standing counsel, PWD, there is no
ambiguity that the petitioner does satisfy clause 4.5A(g),
inasmuch as, he executed an electrical work in the year 2021 to
the tune of Rs. 8,95,43,250.00 , and another work having an
electrical component to the tune of Rs.1,50,16,936.00, in the
year 24.01.2022.
14. Thus, admittedly, the petitioner satisfied the Clause
4.5A(g). However, the matter does not end here.
15. The subsequent clause, Clause (h) further requires the
petitioner to have a valid electrical license for executing the
electrification works of the project. Such certificate was not valid
on the last date of submission of this bidder, which is an admitted
Page No.# 6/9
position.
16. In that background, the petitioner entered into a tie-
up/collaboration with one Apurba Dev Sarma, who swore an
affidavit declaring that if the authority awards the contract in
question in the name of the petitioner, the electrical part of the
said work will be supervised by Sri Apurba Dev Sarma. Thus, it
can be treated as a tie-up between the petitioner and the
aforesaid Apurba Dev Sarma, and which has also been accepted
by the respondent employer.
17. However, such a declaration lacks the requisite
declaration/disclosure of experience as required under Clause
4.5A(h) by this certificate holder collaborator of the petitioner.
18. Therefore, the employer disqualified the petitioner.
Though the non fulfillment of clause 4.5A(g) was mentioned in
minutes of meetings dtd 22.07.2026, however, the reason for
actual disqualification was non fulfillment of 4.5A(h).
19. It is contended by Mr. Chowdhury that there is no
arbitrariness in such action, and admittedly, the requirement under
clause (h) was not met, and the Clauses (g) and (h) are required
to be read together.
20. It is well settled that the procuring authority retains the
power to reject bids or cancel a procurement process in
accordance with the governing statute and tender conditions.
However, such exercise of power is not immune from judicial
review. In Tata Cellular vs. Union of India, (1994) 6 SCC
651 , the Supreme Court explained the limits of judicial review in
Page No.# 7/9
contractual matters and emphasized that the court examines the
legality of the decision-making process rather than substituting its
own assessment for the administrative authority. In Jagdish
Mandal vs. State of Orissa, (2007) 14 SCC 517 , the Supreme
Court reiterated that interference in tender matters is warranted
only where the process is arbitrary or irrational and where the
public interest is affected. The Supreme Court reiterated the same
restraint in Michigan Rubber (India) Limited vs. State of
Karnataka, (2012) 8 SCC 216 .
21. These decisions, however, do not confer an unrestricted
discretion upon the procuring authority. The procuring authority
must act within the governing legal framework, based on relevant
considerations, and for a purpose which the law permits. Judicial
restraint in public contract matters does not require the court to
sustain a decision where the records fail to disclose a rational
connection between the material relied upon and the action taken.
22. Coming to the present case, this Court cannot find fault
on the respondent authorities for having rejected the tender
condition under Clause 4.5A(g). More particularly, in the opinion of
this Court, the Clause 4.5A(g) and Clause 4.5A(h) are intertwined
and interconnected.
23. The sub-clause (g) provides for the requirement of
completed work within a specific threshold, and it further requires
an electrical license. Such a requirement is exempted for those
contractors who were not having any such license, but collaborate
with another person having an electrical license. But the
Page No.# 8/9
qualification of such a collaborator is also specifically provided to
the extent that such collaborator must have the requisite
experience which is relatable to Clause 4.5A(g). Therefore, not
only both the clauses are interlinked, but are essential for a bidder
to be qualified at the technical stage.
24. When the collaboration tie-up document nowhere
discloses the experience of such collaborator, this Court cannot
find fault with the respondent authorities in disqualifying the
petitioner at the technical evaluation stage under Clause 4.5A(g).
25. This Court does not find such exercise of power to be
beyond any governing legal framework; rather, it is a decision
based on relevant considerations and in due compliance of the
qualification clauses prescribed in the tender process. There is a
rational connection between the Clause 4.5A(h) and 4.5A(g), and
therefore, such a decision cannot be termed as arbitrary.
26. Now, coming to the argument of the learned counsel for
the petitioner regarding the challenge to the qualification of the
other bidders; it is by now well settled that once it is held that the
petitioner was rightly disqualified, the writ court should not
endeavour further to look into the challenge against other bidders.
(Ref: Tata Motors Ltd. v. Brihan Mumbai Electric Supply &
Transport Undertaking (BEST), [2023 19 SCC 1])
27. For the reasons recorded, this Court finds no merit in this
writ petition. Accordingly, the same stands dismissed. Interim
orders passed earlier stands vacated.
28. The respondent shall be at liberty to proceed with the
Page No.# 9/9
tender process and bring it to a logical conclusion.
29. The parties shall bear their own costs.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant