Dibyajyoti Datta vs The Cnetral Bureau Of Investigation

Court
Gauhati High Court

Page No.# 1/14
GAHC010208852025

2026:GAU-AS:14635
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : Crl.Pet./1144/2025
DIBYAJYOTI DATTA
S/O- PRAFULLA CH. DUTTA, R/O- NILGIRI LANE, BAGHARBARI, SATGAON
ROAD, PANJABARI, GUWAHATI-37,
PRESENT ADDRESS 10 THIRUVENGADAM STREET, ADYAR, CHENNAI,
TAMILNADU, PIN-600020
VERSUS
THE CNETRAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION
REP BY ITS SPECIAL PP
Advocate for the Petitioner : MR S BORTHAKUR,
Advocate for the Respondent : MS. M. KUMARI, SC, CBI,

BEFORE
HON’BLE MRS. JUSTICE MITALI THAKURIA

Date on which judgment is reserved : 28.09.2026

: 01.10.2026
Date of pronouncement of judgment

Whether the pronouncement is of the : N/A.
operative part of the judgment?

Whether the full judgment has been : Yes.
pronounced?

Page No.# 2/14

UDGMENT RDER
J & O (CAV)


H eard Mr. S. Borthakur, learned Senior Counsel being assisted by Mr. S.
Dey, learned counsel for the petitioner. Also heard Ms. M. Kumari, learned
standing counsel appearing for the respondent CBI.
2. This is an application under Section 528 of the BNSS, 2023 for quashing
and setting aside the impugned order dated 14.08.2025 , passed by the learned
Special Judge, Addl. CBI Court No.3, Assam in Special Case No.2/2023.
3. It is submitted by Mr. Borthakur, the learned Senior Counsel that an FIR
was lodged on 10.02.2019, by one Sri T.L. Zamang, Deputy Superintendent of
Police and in-charge of the Head of Branch of the CBI, ACB, Guwahati alleging
inter alia that the petitioner while functioning as the General Manager (Sales),
Indian Oil Corporation (Assam Oil Division) during the year 2018—19 had
entered into criminal conspiracies with other accused persons and in pursuant to
the said conspiracies, he demanded and accepted illegal gratification frequently
from different private businessmen owning Petrol Pump and/or having kerosene
oil dealership in connivance with few private conduits for showing them favour
in smooth running of their business as well as for showing favour in allotment of
new retail outlets at places spread all over the North Eastern States including
Assam.
4. Accordingly, on the basis of the said FIR, a case has been registered at
CBI, ACB, Guwahati Police Station under Sections 7/7A/8/12 of the Prevention of
Corruption Act, 1988, read with Section 120B of the IPC. During the course of

Page No.# 3/14
the investigation of the said case, Rs. 3,67,000/- of Indian currency notes, one 5
Euro currency note and 2000 US Dollars (20 Nos. of 100 Dollars each) were
seized from the house of the accused Petitioner. Furthermore, the State Bank of
India Savings Bank Account No. 30014759731 held by the Petitioner in South
Guwahati Branch of State Bank of India was freezed, apart from the State Bank
of India PPF Account No. 10055711223, held by the Petitioner on behalf of his
elder son, Sri Abhigyan Datta, as father & natural guardian at SBI's Guwahati
Medical College Branch was also freezed during the investigation. On completion
of the investigation, the CBI submitted their Charge-Sheet in the case on
23.12.2022, implicating the accused petitioner and two others. In the Charge-
Sheet, basically the allegation brought against the present accused petitioner is
that he was caught red handed while taking bribe of Rs. 2,00,000/- (Rupees
Two Lakhs) only from one of the co-accused, namely, Ms. Bendangnaro Ao.
5. However, the investigation of the case was kept open for Supplementary
Charge-Sheet and during the pendency of the present petition, one
Supplementary Charge-Sheet is also filed by the I.O. During the pendency of
investigation of the case, in the Court of learned Special Judge, Addl. CBI Court
No.3, a petition was moved on 20.01.2025 under Section 451 read with Section
457 of the Code of Criminal Procedure praying for:

(i) Handing over custody of Rs. 3,67,000/- in Indian currency notes, one 5
Euro currency note and 2000 US Dollars (20 Nos. of 100 Dollars each);

(ii) De-freezing the State Bank of India Savings Bank Account No.
30014759731 held by the Petitioner at SBI's South Guwahati Branch;

Page No.# 4/14
(iii) De-freezing the State Bank of India PPF Account No. 10055711223
held by the Petitioner on behalf of his son, Sri Abhigyan Datta, at SBI's
Guwahati Medical College Branch.

6. While moving the petition before the Court of learned Special Judge, Addl.
CBI Court No.3, it is also contended by the petitioner that vide order dated
14.07.2023, the CBI had made a written prayer before the learned Trial Court
that the seized cash amount of Rs. 3,67,000/- of Indian currency notes, one 5
Euro currency note and 2000 US Dollars (20 Nos. of 100 Dollars each) are not
required to be produced before the Court during the trial and thus, the CBI had
prayed for permission to deposit the said amount in the current account of the
CBI which was accordingly allowed by the Court. Furthermore, in the written
objection filed by the CBI in connection with the above referred petition, it is
submitted that the Savings Bank Account and the PPF Account of the petitioner
may be kept freezed on the ground that due to the non-cooperation of the
accused persons, the investigation of the case was still pending. But there is no
mention that the cash amounts may not be released in favour of the petitioner.
Thus, during the pendency of the above referred petition before the Court of
learned Special Judge, Addl. CBI Court No.3, basically it is the case of the CBI
that the investigation is still pending and hence, the seized amount of money
may not be released as well as the Savings Bank Account and the PPF Account
of the petitioner may not be de-freezed, which may affect the investigation of
this case.
7. Considering all these aspects of the case, the learned Special Judge, Addl.
CBI Court No.3 passed the order dated 14.08.2025 and rejected the prayer of
the petitioner with the observation that the seized currency and the money in

Page No.# 5/14
the aforesaid Savings Bank Account as well as in the PPF Account may be the
proceeds of the crime, which may be liable for confiscation at the end of the
trial. Moreover, it is held that de-freezing of the accounts and release of the
money therein may frustrate the possible confiscation proceeding. The learned
Special Judge also had discussed some judgments of the Hon’ble Apex Court, on
which basis, passed the said order. But at this stage, the investigation is already
completed and the Supplementary Charge-Sheet has also been filed by the CBI
and hence, the question of frustrating the investigation does not arise at this
stage.
8. Mr. Borthakur, the learned Senior Counsel further submitted that the
learned Special Judge had observed that there may be problem in confiscating
the crime proceeds at the end of the trial. But there is no mention from the CBI
in regards to confiscation of the seized accounts of the accused/ petitioner. But
in the order, the learned Special Judge had observed in regards of the
confiscation at the end of the trial. Thus, the order was basically passed only
considering the submission of the CBI/respondent that the release of money
and de-freezing of the accounts may hamper in the investigation of the case
and may frustrate the investigation and in the same time, it is also observed
that the confiscation proceeding may also be frustrated if the money is released
and the accounts are de-freezed on the prayer made by the accused petitioner.

9. Mr. Borthakur, the learned Senior Counsel further submitted that there is
no mention in the Charge Sheet about the accounts which have been freezed
during investigation and the same are also not part of the charge-sheet, as
claimed by the petitioner. Further, the I.O. also seized the PPF account of the

Page No.# 6/14
petitioner, which cannot be seized or attached by a Police Officer in any
proceeding under the proviso of Section 9 and 10 of the Public Provident Fund
Act, 1968. Section 9 of the said Act gives protection to any subscriber and the
fund is not liable for attachment under any decree or order in respect of any
debt or liability incurred by the subscriber. Thus the CBI has no authority or
power to attach/freeze the PPF account of the present accused petitioner during
the investigation. In that context, Mr. Borthakur, the learned Senior Counsel also
relied on the order of the co-ordinate Bench of this Court in WP(C)
No.5074/2013 ( Jagatsinh Laljibhai Vasava vs. Central Bureau of Investigation and
others
) and in para 8, 12 & 13, it has expressed the view that the money in a
PPF Account is exempted from attachment and it is inalienable and normally no
execution is allowed for such sum. The co-ordinate Bench of this Court had also
relied on the judgment of the Hon’ble Apex Court while passing the said order.
The para 8, 12 &13 of the said judgment read as under:
“ 8. The learned counsel Shri Biswas has also relied upon the decision of the Hon’ble Apex
Court in the case of Union of India v. Hira Devi & Anr., reported in AIR 1952 SC 227 which
was also referred by the Gujarat High Court. Shri Biswas submits that as per the said judgment
of the Hon’ble Apex Court, it has been held that prohibition against the assignment or the
attachment of such compulsory deposit is based on the ground of public policy. Further it has
been held that where the interdiction is absolute, to allow a judgment creditor to get at the fund
indirectly by means of the appointment of a receiver would be to circumvent the statute which
would frustrate the very object of the legislation. The Hon’ble Supreme Court has further laid
down that money in a PPF account is exempted from attachment and is inalienable and
normally no execution would allow such sum. Reliance is also sought to be made in the
decision of the Hon’ble Apex Court in the case of Union of India v. Jyoti Chit Fund and
Finance & Ors., reported in AIR 1976 SC 1163.
12. Section 9 of the PPF Act, 1968 lays down an embargo against the attachment of any amount
standing to the credit of a subscriber. For ready reference, Section 9 of the Act is extracted
herein below:
“ 9. Protection against attachment-The amount standing to the credit of any
subscriber in the fund shall not be liable to attachment under any decree or
order of any Court in respect of any debt or liability incurred by the subscriber.”

Page No.# 7/14
13. This Court is in agreement with the submission of the learned counsel for the petitioner that
an absolute embargo is intended by the statute to protect a PPF account from orders of
attachment. Borrowing the language of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Smt. Hira
Devi (Supra), the Provident Fund money is exempted from the attachment and is inalienable.
Further, as has been held by the Division Bench of the Gujarat High Court, as long as an
amount remains invested in a PPF account of an individual the same would be immune from
any attachment from recovery of the tax dues. In the instant case, there is no dispute that the
account in question are Provident Fund Accounts and therefore, the embargo prescribed in
Section 9 of the Act will have its full effect.”.

10. Mr. Borthakur, the learned Senior Counsel also submitted that there is no
clarification or mention that the accounts which have been freezed by the I.O.
and the money which has already been seized by the police during investigation
are connected with proceeds of the crime. The learned Senior Counsel further
submitted that under Section 102 of the CrPC, the police has the
authority/power to seize the accounts/ money, if it is directly linked with the
crime proceeds. But here in the instant case, it is seen that the CBI could not
make any specification as to how those accounts and money seized by the I.O.
is directly linked with the crime proceeds. In that context also, Mr. Borthakur,
the learned Senior Counsel had cited two decisions of the Hon’ble Apex Court,
i.e. (1999) 7 SCC 685 (State of Maharashtra vs. Tapas D. Neogy) and (2012) 6
SCC 760 (M.T. Enrica Lexie and another vs. Doramma and others) . In para 12 of
the State of Maharashtra vs. Tapas D. Neogy (Supra), the Hon’ble Apex Court has
held that:
“ 12. Having considered the divergent views taken by different High Courts with regard to the
power of seizure under Section 102 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, and whether the bank
account can be held to be `property' within the meaning of said Section 102(1), we see no
justification to give any narrow interpretation to the provisions of the Criminal Procedure
Code . It is well known that corruption in public offices has become so rampant that it has
become difficult to cope up with the same. Then again the time consumed by the Courts in
concluding the trials is another factor which should be borne in mind in interpreting the
provisions of Section 102 of the Criminal Procedure Code and the underlying object engrafted
therein, inasmuch as if there can be no order of seizure of the bank account of the accused then
the entire money deposited in a bank which is ultimately held in the trial to be the outcome of
the illegal gratification, could be withdrawn by the accused and the Courts would be powerless

Page No.# 8/14
to get the said money which has any direct link with the commission of the offence committed by
the accused as a public officer. We are, therefore, persuaded to take the view that the bank
account of the accused or any of his relation is `property' within the meaning of Section 102 of
the Criminal Procedure Code and a police officer in course of investigation can seize or
prohibit the operation of the said account if such assets have direct links with the commission of
the offence for which the police officer is investigating into. The contrary view expressed by
Karnataka, Gauhati and Allahabad High Courts, does not represent the correct law. It may also
be seen that under the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988 , in the matter of imposition of fine
under sub-section (2) of Section 13 , the legislatures have provided that the Courts in fixing the
amount of fine shall take into consideration the amount or the value of the property, which the
accused person has obtained by committing the offence or where the conviction is for an
offence referred to in clause (e) of sub- section(1) of Section 13 , the pecuniary resources or
property for which the accused person is unable to account satisfactorily. The interpretation
given by us in respect of the power of seizure under Section 102 of the Criminal Procedure
Code is in accordance with the intention of the legislature engrafted in Section 16 of the
Prevention of Corruption Act referred to above . In the aforesaid premises, we have no
hesitation to come to the conclusion that the High Court of Bombay committed error in holding
that the police officer could not have seized the bank account or could not have issued any
direction to the bank officer, prohibiting the account of the accused from being operated upon.
Though we have laid down the law, but so far as the present case is concerned, the order
impugned has already been given effect to and the accused has been operating upon his
account, and so, we do not interfere with the same ” .
11. Citing the above referred judgments, the learned Senior Counsel
submitted that neither there is any specification as to whether the money which
has been seized under the said account/freezed accounts are linked with the
crime proceeds and in the same time, the police authority has no power to
attach/freeze the PPF account of the petitioner and accordingly, the learned
Senior Counsel submitted that the present petition may be allowed and the
money which has been seized, may be released and the accounts freezed during
the investigation may be de-freezed.
12. Ms. M. Kumari, the learned standing counsel appearing for the respondent
CBI submitted in this regard that it is not a case that those accounts were not
part of the Charge-Sheet as the entire seizure memo has been placed while
submitting the Charge-Sheet and from the Charge-Sheet as well as from the
seizure memo, it is seen that those seized accounts are the part of the Charge-

Page No.# 9/14
Sheet and there is specific mention in the seizure memo attached along with the
Charge-Sheet, which is considered to be part of the Charge-Sheet. She further
submitted that it is an admitted fact that the case has already been Charge-
Sheeted and the case is at the stage of consideration of charge and one
Supplementary Charge-Sheet is also submitted by the I.O. But the investigation
is still going on and it is still open for the CBI to file Supplementary Charge-
Sheet and in that event, there is every possibility of alteration of charge, even
though the formal charge is framed by the learned Special Judge. She further
submitted that one application was initially filed by the CBI for examination of
the voice sample which was rejected by the Court of learned Special Judge, CBI
and aggrieved by the said rejection order, they have moved an application
before this Court vide Criminal Revision Petition No. 145/2020, wherein the
prayer for collecting the voice sample was allowed by this Court. In pursuant to
that order, the CBI had issued several notices to the present accused petitioner
along with the co-accused persons to appear before the investigating team for
collection/ examination of their voice sample. But they never cooperated with
the investigating team and approached the Hon’ble Apex Court with a Special
Leave Petition against the said order. The said Special Leave Petition is still
pending before the Hon’ble Apex Court but there is no stay order in the order
passed by this Court in Criminal Revision Petition No. 145/2020. Thus, the
investigation is still open and the examination/collection of the voice sample,
which is most essential part of the investigation, especially in a case of
corruption and that too in a trap case, is not yet completed due to non-
cooperation of the accused person.
13. Ms. M. Kumari, the learned standing counsel for the CBI further submitted
that the investigation of the case is still going on and it cannot be held that the

Page No.# 10/14
entire investigation has been completed, as submitted by the learned Senior
Counsel for the petitioner. During the trial only, it may come out that the money
which is seized, may be of crime proceeds. Ms. Kumari, the learned standing
counsel further submitted that the PPF Accounts are generally utilized by a
person after his retirement and hence, there is no necessity of de-freezing the
PPF Account at this stage. She further submitted that the prayer for de-freezing
of the accounts and releasing the money was rejected by the learned Special
Judge, considering the view of the Hon’ble Apex Court. The learned Special
Judge rightly held that granting zimma of the seized Indian currency and de-
freezing of the accounts at this stage, may frustrate the confiscation proceeding
at the end of the trial, if it is established that the said accounts of the accused
petitioner are from the crime proceeds. Accordingly, Ms. Kumari, the learned
standing counsel for the CBI raised vehement objection and submitted that the
prayer for release of the seized money and de-freezing the accounts of the
accused petitioner may not be considered at this stage, where investigation is
still under process and voice sample of the accused petitioner is yet to be
collected by the investigating agency.
14. After hearing the submissions made by leaned counsel for both sides, I
have also perused the case records and the order passed by the learned Special
Judge, which is under challenge.
15. It is an admitted fact that during investigation, some accounts as well as
cash amount along with some foreign currencies were seized in connection with
this case including a State Bank of India PPF Account of the accused/petitioner
which is in the name of his son Abhigyan Dutta. It is also an admitted fact that
the case has already been charge sheeted and after subsequent investigation, a

Page No.# 11/14
Supplementary Charge-Sheet is also filed against the accused/petitioner and the
hearing on the consideration of the charge is also completed. It is the main
contention of the petitioner that the investigation has already been completed
even the Supplementary Charge-Sheet has also been filed during the pendency
of this case and hence, further requirement of freezing the accounts of the
accused petitioner as well as attachment of the money does not arise.
16. More so, Mr. Borthakur, the learned Senior Counsel for the petitioner
stressed on the point that the investigating team of the CBI did not find any
necessity for production of those freezed accounts as well as the seized money
along with the foreign currencies before the Court, for which the prayer for
depositing the same in the current account of the CBI has been made and said
prayer was also allowed. But it cannot be held that the seized money including
the foreign currencies which were deposited in the current account of the CBI is
not the crime proceeds or may not be required for the purpose of investigation,
even if it is considered that production of the seized money including the foreign
currencies may not be required at the time of the trial. But for such prayer of
depositing the money in the current account of the CBI cannot be the only
ground to consider that there was any admission on the part of the CBI that
those freezed accounts as well as the seized money are not required in the
present case at the end of the trial or these are not the crime proceeds, which
may not also be required for confiscation at the end of the trial. A simple prayer
for depositing the seized money in the current account of the CBI cannot be the
sole ground to consider that the seized money is not the crime proceeds or will
not be required at the end of the trial or even during the trial. It is better to
keep the seized money in the current account of the CBI, as it may not be so
safe to keep the same in the malkhana of the investigating team.

Page No.# 12/14
17. Mr. Borthakur, the learned Senior Counsel for the petitioner , by citing the
decisions of the Hon’ble Apex Court had submitted that under Section 102 of
the CrPC, the police has the authority to attach the accounts/seized money, if it
has direct link with the crime proceeds. In the present case also, the bank
accounts were freezed and the money was seized from the possession of the
accused petitioner, considering it to be the crime proceeds who is stated to be
involved not only in the case wherein he was trapped while taking bribe of
Rs.2,00,000/- from one of the co-accused but there are various allegations
against the present accused petitioner who is also alleged to have committed
similar kind of offences with private businessmen owning Petrol Pump and/or
having kerosene oil dealership in connivance with few private conduits for
showing them favour in smooth running of their business as well as for showing
favour in allotment of new retail outlets.
18. It is seen that the case is still under investigation and the trial is yet to
commence and as such, it cannot be held at this stage that the savings account
which has been freezed during the investigation including the seizure of money
from the possession of the accused petitioner are not the crime proceeds or not
directly linked with the crime.
19. Coming to the issue of de-freezing the PPF Account of the petitioner in the
name of his elder son, Sri Abhigyan Datta. As per Sections 9 and 10 of the Public
Provident Fund Act, 1968, gives the protection against the attachment and it
read as “the amount standing to the credit of any subscriber and the fund is not
liable for attachment under any decree or order of any Court in respect of any
debt or liability incurred by the subscriber.” The co-ordinate Bench of this Court,
as relied by Mr. Borthakur, the learned Senior Counsel for the petitioner, also

Page No.# 13/14
held that there is an absolute embargo intended by the statute to protect the
PPF Account from orders of attachment and the provident fund money is
exempted from attachment and is inalienable.
20. In the present case also, the investigating agency/CBI had freezed the
PPF Account of the petitioner in the name of his elder son, while freezing his
other Bank accounts including seizure of money. But considering the provision of
Section 9 of the Public Provident Fund Act, 1968 as well as considering the view
expressed by the Hon’ble Apex Court and the co-ordinate Bench of this Court, it
is seen that the PPF Account cannot be attached by the Investigating Officer
and it is exempted from such attachment and at the same time, it is inalienable.
In view of the above, it is the opinion of this Court that the PPF Account, which
has been freezed by the Investigating Agency during the investigation of the
case, may be de-freezed immediately.
21. But as discussed above, it is seen that the case is still under investigation
wherein the CBI is still under process for collecting/examining the voice sample
of the accused petitioner and there is no stay order from the Hon’ble Apex Court
against the order of this Court passed in Criminal Revision Petition No.
145/2020, wherein prayer for examining the voice sample of the accused
petitioner was allowed by this Court. In absence of any order, the CBI is still
investigating the case and is trying to collect the voice samples from the
accused persons for examination. Thus, even after filing of the Supplementary
Charge-Sheet , the case is still under investigation and the investigating authority
has the power to file another Supplementary Charge-Sheet and there is even
scope of altering/modifying the charge, if the formal charges are already framed
by the learned Special Judge.

Page No.# 14/14
22. Apart from that, it cannot be held at this stage that the money which has
been seized during investigation and the seized Bank Accounts of the petitioner,
which are being freezed by the CBI are not the crime proceeds or they are not
directly linked with the crime proceeds for de-freezing them immediately.
However, during the trial it may come out as to whether those accounts are
directly linked with the crime proceeds or not. So, at this stage, this Court is of
the opinion that release of the seized money along with the foreign currency
and de-freezing the other Bank Accounts of the petitioner may not be justified
at this stage, wherein the investigation is still under process.
23. Considering the detail above, the prayer for: (i) handing over the custody
of Rs. 3,67,000/- in Indian currency notes, one 5 Euro currency note and 2000
US Dollars (20 Nos. of 100 Dollars each) and (ii) de-freezing the State Bank of
India Savings Bank Account No. 30014759731 held by the Petitioner at SBI's
South Guwahati Branch, are rejected at this stage. However, the State Bank of
India PPF Account No. 10055711223 held by the petitioner on behalf of his son,
Sri Abhigyan Datta, at SBI's Guwahati Medical College Branch is hereby de-
freezed and the concerned authority is to take immediate steps for de-freezing
the account.
24. With the above observation and direction, the present petition stands
disposed of.
JUDGE
Digitally signed by Manoranjan Barman
DN: c=IN, o=Personal, postalCode=781353, l=Nalbari,
st=Assam, street=12/190 GOPALBAZAR, Sandheli, Pachim
Nalbari Assam India 781353 NEAR GOPAL THAN,
title=2306,
2.5.4.20=29db4acf51a76f18a8b02da116d99d9a830067d0
e1ee9ade3211eba147de7638,
serialNumber=f62c6d212ff0a19bb91eb2be0de18d2d5675
f8515740ee4f44960ef878267138,
[email protected], cn=Manoranjan
Barman
Date: 2026.10.01 13:16:52 +05'30'
Manoranja
Comparing Assistant
n Barman