DHOOT REALTORS PRIVATE LIMITED AND ANOTHER vs APURBA KUMAR JANA
- Court
- Calcutta High Court
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
CRIMINAL REVISIONAL JURISDICTION
APPELLATE SIDE
Present:-
HON’BLE JUSTICE CHAITALI CHATTERJEE DAS.
CRR 4309 OF 2024
DHOOT REALTORS PVT. & ANR.
VS.
APURBA KUMAR JANA
For the Petitioner : Mr. Ayan Bhattacharjee, Sr. Adv.
Mr. Shounak Mondal, Adv.
Ms. Moumita Bhattacharjee, Adv.
For the Opposite
Party : Sk. Mainuddin, Adv.
Heard On : 17.11.2026
Judgement on : 17.11.2026
Uploaded on : 17.11.2026
CHAITALI CHATTERJEE DAS, J.:-
1. This revisional application is filed under Section 482 of code of Criminal
Procedure, 1973 corresponding to Section 528 of BNSS, 2023 by the
petitioners for quashing of the proceedings of complaint case no.
3407/2022, under Section 406/420 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 pending
st
before the Court of Learned Judicial Magistrate, 1 class, Bidhannagar,
Page 1 of 12
North 24 Parganas, including the order dated August 24, 2022 and April 9,
2024.
2. Factual matrix of the case, demonstrate that the petitioner No.1 is a
company and petitioner no. 2 is the director of petitioner no. 1 .On August
24, 2022 by the complaint was filed by the opposite party alleging against
them for commission of offences under Section 406/420 of the Indian Penal
Code against the petitioners herein. Vide an order dated August 24, 2022
the learned ACJM took cognizance and transferred the case to the court of
st
learned Judicial Magistrate, 1 class, Bidhan Nagar, North 24 Parganas.
After a number of intervening dates on April 9, 2024, the opposite party was
examined on solemn affirmation in terms of section 200 of the Cr.P.C and
vide an order dated April 9, 2024 on the basis of purported petition of
complaint, pre-summoning evidence, and other materials passed and order
to issue process under section 406/420 of the IPC for appearance of the
petitioner on July 9, 2024.
3. The petitioner no. 2 entered appearance and filed an application in terms of
section 205 of Cr.P.C seeking exemption from personal appearance and
such prayer was allowed and fixed the matter on November 7, 2024 for
evidence before charge. According to the petitioner, the proceedings has
been instituted by suppressing material facts and the Opposite Party has
not acted uberimma fides and has not disclosed material facts in the
purported petition of complaint.
4. The Genesis of the complaint pertains to non-payment of the balance
amount in connection with a work order issued in favour of the
complainant. The work order was dated 7.1.2024 for landscaping work at
Page 2 of 12
their project Prathama at 26, B.T Road, Kolkata 700058 and a subsequent
work order issued on 14.1.2020 . The grievance of the de-facto complainant
is that though the entire work was completed and the bill raised on
completion of the entire work of ₹ 27, 77, 840, the petitioners paid an
amount of ₹ 17, 50, 000 keeping a balance amount of ₹ 10, 27, 840. Despite
several request made to them to pay the balance amount, the petitioners
failed and neglected to pay the same. A demand notice was served upon the
company on 26.8.2020 through their advocate, but even on receipt of the
same, they failed and neglected to pay the unpaid due. Another notice was
also sent on 3.12.2020 and lastly, a legal notice was sent on 19.7.2021 and
thereafter on 10.5.2022 the complainant made the complaint to the Officer-
in-Charge, electronics complex Police Station to take appropriate legal action
against the accused persons. Since no action was taken by the concerned
police station, the opposite party had to move before the court by filing the
written complaint.
5. The learned Senior Advocate Mr. Ayan Bhattacharya on behalf of the
petitioners submits that it is evident from the content of the written
complaint that there was a commercial transaction between the parties and
accordingly a work order was issued and after the bill was raised by the
Opposite party ,a considerable amount was paid in terms of the bill so
raised. Therefore, in view of the settled proposition of law, there cannot be
any intention or mens rea to deceive the opposite party. The charge under
Section 420 of the IPC is a misnomer and the definition of cheating and
dishonestly inducing delivery of property as enactment defines, is absolutely
not applicable in the instant case. The Opposite Party no. 2 has tried to
Page 3 of 12
convert a civil dispute into a criminal prosecution, which is notable in the
eye of law. Mere use of the expressions like cheating, deception and
inducement is of no consequence. The story projected by the opposite party
has no relevance to attract offence of cheating by the petitioner and hence
no proceeding could have been initiated against them. In addition the charge
under Section 406 of IPC, the penal provisions apropos the offence of
criminal breach of trust as defined under section 405 of the IPC is again
misplaced. The essential requirement to constitute an offence of criminal
breach of trust is absolutely missing in the instant case since on bare
perusal of allegations, it is apparent that the petitioners had not been
entrusted with any property of the opposite party, which could have been
misappropriated by the petitioners. In absence of the element of
entrustment in favour of the petitioners and misappropriation thereof, no
case for commission of the offence of criminal breach of trust can at all be
said to have been committed.
6. The learned Senior Advocate further submits that the order issuing process
in the nature of summons is bad in law in as much as the learned Trial
Magistrate failed to record the reasons which weighed with the opinion
formed by learned Magistrate regarding existence of sufficient and prima
facie ingredients of the concerned offences. In this regard to put reliance in
1
the decision of Sunil Bharti Mittal versus CBI reported in , that order
issuing process must be a reasoned order sufficiently reflecting as to what
actually weighed with the concerned court in deciding the commission of a
prima facie offence by the accused. Further relied upon the decision of
1
(2015) 4 SCC 609
Page 4 of 12
2
State of Haryana versus Bhajanlal and others . The other point raised is
the long delay in lodging the written complaint and further no explanation
or reasoned explanation can be found in the written complaint which was
also not considered by the learned magistrate while taking cognizance.
7. On behalf of opposite party, the learned advocate raises objection and
submits that their conduct of the petitioners clearly demonstrate, they had
an intention from the very inception to deceive the opposite party, since they
induced the opposite party and issued work order in favour of the
complainant. It is for subjects that the entire work was completed by the
complainant and he submitted the bill for payment to the accuse persons on
3.1.2020 of an amount of ₹ 27, 77, 840 out of which accused person paid
only ₹ 17.50, 000 and refuse to pay the balance amount of ₹ 10, 27, 840. The
complainant had to run from pillar to post and several communications
were made to the petitioners who, despite having full knowledge and even
after receiving the letters and the legal notice did not give any reply and this
act on their part, manifest their intention to defer the opposite party.
8. It is his further contention that the learned Magistrate rightly took
cognizance after examining the proprietor of M/S Agro consultancy services
on solemn affirmation. He has specifically stated on affidavit that he
personally visited to the office of the petitioners with a request to pay the
balance amount, but despite their repeated request, the accused persons
failed and neglected to pay the balance amount to him. The recent ecision
of Hon’ble Supreme Court in V. Ganesan versus State represented by the
2
1992 Supp (1) SCC 335
Page 5 of 12
3
Sub- Inspector of police in . Supreme Court took note of the decision of
4
Iridium India telecom Limited versus Motorola Inc. , the ingredients of
an offence of cheating as defined in section 415 of IPC was laid down.
9. Having heard the submissions of the learned Counsels representing the
respective parties and considering the brief facts of the case it appears that
the provisions of the Indian Penal Code are to be revisited .In the decision as
relied upon by the Learned Advocate of the opposite party, it has been
observed that section 415 of IPC has two parts. (a) The first part makes it
necessary that the deception by the accused of the person deceived, must be
fraudulent or dishonest. Such deception must induce the person to either a
delivered property to any person or b) consent that any person shall retain
any property.
Section 415 IPC reads as:
Cheating— whoever, by deceiving any person,
fraudulently, or dishonestly, induces the person
so deceived to deliver any property to any
person, or to consent that any person shall retain
any property, or intentionally induces the person
so deceived to do or to do anything which he
would not do automate if he were not so deceive,
and we act or omission causes is likely to cause
damage or harm to that person in body, mind,
repetition, or property, is said to cheat.
The Hon’ble Court further observed that that deception is a necessary
ingredient for the offence of cheating under both parts of this section. In the
3
2026 INSC 265
4
2011 (1) SCC 74
Page 6 of 12
case before the Hon’ble Supreme Court, was that the initial payment of
money by the complainant to the appellant was for a movie project, on
promise of a share in profits. Additional money was paid later for its
completion under promise of an enhanced share in the profits. The letter
issued to refund the principal amount because of an objection taken by de-
facto complainant to the release of the movie. Since no denial was there
about completion of the movie and ultimately it was released, what was
cleared that the promise to make a movie was not false, so it cannot be said
that applicant made a false promise.
10. Similarly in the case of Vijay Kumar ghai vs the state of West
5
Bengal a commercial transaction was there between the parties and it was
held and observed in paragraph 21 that, time and again the Supreme Court
has questioned about converting civil disputes into criminal cases. In Indian
oil Corporation, the Supreme Court noticed the prevalent impression that
civil court remedies are time consuming and do not adequately protect the
interest of lender creditor. It was further observed that any effort to settle
civil disputes and claim which do not involve any criminal offence, by
applying pressure through criminal prosecution, should be deprecated and
discouraged. It was held that there can be no doubt that mere breach of
contract is not in itself, a criminal offence and gives rise to the civil liability
of damages.
11. The Supreme Court of the case of Hriday R anjan Prasad, Verma, and
6
other state of Bihar discussed the distinction between breach of contract
5
MANU/SC/0348/2022
6
(2000) 4 SCC 168
Page 7 of 12
and cheating, which is a criminal offence and is a fine one. While breach of
contract cannot give rise to criminal prosecution for cheating, fraudulent or
designed intention is the basis of the offence of cheating which was not
disclosed in the written complaint.
12. The decision relied upon by the Ld. Advocate representing the Opposite
Party, passed by Ld. Single Judge, High Court at Calcutta in CRR 2997 of
2019 , Rupayan Bhattacharya vs State of West Bengal & Anr. Wherein
it was held that-
“ Accordingly the aforesaid proceeding from the
stage of examination of complainant under
section 200 and issuance of process against
accused persons under section 204 of the code
i.e. order dated 19.08.2019 and all subsequent
orders stands quashed……………. Liberty is
given to the complainant to appear before the
Magistrate for sworn statement along with his
witnesses, if any.”
7
In the decision of M.N.G Bharateesh Reddy vs Ramesh Ranganathan ,
where a contract styled as a Consultancy Agreement was entered into
between the first respondent and the hospital on 1 April 2013 containing his
terms of engagement. One of the terms of the engagement was that either
party may terminate the agreement, with or without cause, by giving a prior
notice of thirty days. Hon’ble Apex Court discussed the offence of Cheating
as spelt out in Section 415, IPC and took note of Hridaya Ranjan Prasad
Verma v. State of Bihar (supra) and held-
7
Crl. A. 1273/2022
Page 8 of 12
“In determining the question it has to be kept in
mind that the distinction between mere breach of
contract and the offence of cheating is a fine one.
It depends upon the intention of the accused at
the time of inducement which may be judged by
his subsequent conduct but for this subsequent
conduct is not the sole test. Mere breach of
contract cannot give rise to criminal prosecution
for cheating unless fraudulent or dishonest
intention is shown right at the beginning of the
transaction, that is the time when the offence is
said to have been committed. Therefore it is the
intention which is the gist of the offence. To hold
a person guilty of cheating it is necessary to
show that he had fraudulent or dishonest
intention at the time of making the promise. From
his mere failure to keep up promise subsequently
such a culpable intention right at the beginning,
that is, when he made the promise cannot be
presumed.”
8
Hon’ble Apex Court further took note of Dalip Kaur v. Jagnar Singh
regarding presence of elements of Section 420 IPC in a dispute arising out of
a breach of contract and held that-
“Applying the above principles, the ingredients of
Sections 415 and 420 are not made out in the
present case. The grievance of the first
respondent arises from the termination of his
services at the hospital. The allegations indicate
that there was an improper billing in respect of
the surgical services which were rendered by the
8
(2009) 14 SCC 696
Page 9 of 12
complainant at the hospital. At the most, the
allegations allude to a breach of terms of the
Consultancy Agreement by the Appellant, which
is essentially in the nature of a civil dispute.”
It was further held that-
“The allegations in the complaint are
conspicuous by the absence of any reference to
the practice of any deception or dishonest
intention on behalf of the Appellant. Likewise,
there is no allegation that the complainant was
as a consequence induced to deliver any
property or to consent that any person shall
retain any property or that he was deceived to
do or omit to do anything which he would have
not done or omitted to do if he was not so
deceived. The conspicuous aspect of the
complaint which needs to be emphasized is that
the ingredients of the offence of cheating are
absent in the averments as they stand.”
13. On the contrary, the latest decision made by the Apex Court relied upon
by the petitioner in Yogesh Premjibhai Suvariya & Anr. vs State Of
9
Gujarat & Anr. , it was held that-
“ The sine qua non for attracting Section 415 IPC
is ‘fraudulence’, ‘dishonesty’ or ‘intentional
inducement’. Absence of the aforesaid elements
would debase the offence of cheating.”
9
2026 SCC OnLine SC 2211
Page 10 of 12
In this case, the ownership of Hans Ispat Ltd. was earlier with the Barnala
Group with its Head Office at Muzaffarnagar, Uttar Pradesh. From the
Barnala Group, Electrotherm India Pvt. Ltd. had purchased the company
with effect from 01.06.2010. From the aforesaid company, Hans Ispat Ltd.
took over the ownership. An amount of Rs.2,00,00,000/- was paid by the
appellants to the aforesaid company during the period from 01.12.2006 to
15.02.2007 when the Barnala group owned the company and such amount
deposited by the appellants were required to be taken care of by Barnala
Group and not by the new owners of the company. It was observed that-
“……it is evident that the money was paid by the
appellants to the company when the Barnala
group owned the company. Appellants are
insisting on repayment, failing which they have
adjusted the dues of Respondent No. 2.
According to respondent No. 2 this amount
should be 8 repaid by the Barnala group and not
by the present owners. Therefore, the amount
due to him should be paid by the appellants.
Thus, the dispute raised by Respondent No.2 is
pre-eminently a civil one.”
14. Therefore, on careful perusal of entire facts and circumstances of this
case, it is evident that the work order was issued and accordingly work was
completed, bill was raised by the complainant of Rs ₹ 27, 77, 840. The
present petitioner paid total amount of Rs.17,50,000/- keeping a balance of
Rs. 10,27,840/- which was not paid later on, giving raise to lodging of the
present complaint.
Page 11 of 12
Therefore in the touchstone of the law laid down by Hon’ble Apex Court in
the catena of decisions, it can be averred that necessary ingredients to
constitute offence under Sections 420 IPC is missing from the complaint.
15. It is true that in the given circumstances, a civil remedy may be available
to the complainant and that itself cannot be a ground for criminal trial. The
real test lies with allegation in the complaint if disclosed any criminal
offence at all. Having gone through the complaint/ FIR, no such averment in
the FIR can be found, which can constitute an offence under Section 420
IPC. It is clear that payment was not fully paid, keeping a balance due and
hence civil remedy is the appropriate forum. It is also evident that no
entrustment of property or dominion was not in existence to constitute an
offence under section 406IPC.
16. Hence this criminal Revisional application is hereby allowed.
17. The entire proceeding of complaint case no. 3407/2022, under Section
406/420 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 pending before the court of Learned
Judicial Magistrate, first class, Bidhannagar, not 24 Parganas is hereby
quashed against the petitioners .
18. All other connected applications, if any, hereby stand disposed of.
19. Urgent Photostat certified copies of this order, if applied for, be supplied to
the parties upon compliance of all necessary formalities.
[CHAITALI CHATTERJEE (DAS), J.]
Page 12 of 12