M/s. Beta Wind Farm Private Limited vs Andhra Pradesh Electricity Regulatory Commission & Ors

Court
Appellate Tribunal For Electricity

Judgement in Appeal No. 600 of 2023 and batch

IN THE APPELLATE TRIBUNAL FOR ELECTRICITY
(Appellate Jurisdiction)

APPEAL No. 600 OF 2023 & IA No. 1900 OF 2026 & IA No. 1965 OF 2026
APPEAL No. 242 OF 2024
APPEAL No. 747 OF 2023
APPEAL No. 932 OF 2023
APPEAL No. 109 OF 2024
APPEAL No. 110 OF 2024
APPEAL No. 137 OF 2024
APPEAL No. 141 OF 2024
APPEAL No. 142 OF 2024
APPEAL No. 143 OF 2024
APPEAL No. 148 OF 2024
APPEAL No. 177 OF 2024
APPEAL No. 178 OF 2024
APPEAL No. 179 OF 2024
APPEAL No. 180 OF 2024
APPEAL No. 181 OF 2024
APPEAL No. 182 OF 2024
APPEAL No. 289 OF 2024
APPEAL No. 387 OF 2024
APPEAL No. 388 OF 2024
APPEAL No. 746 OF 2023
APPEAL No. 934 OF 2023
APPEAL No. 936 OF 2023
Dated: 17.11.2026
Present :
Hon’ble Mr. Virender Bhat, Judicial Member

Hon’ble Mr. Ajay Talegaonkar, Technical Member
In the matter of:

APPEAL No. 600 OF 2023 & IA No. 1900 OF 2026 & IA No. 1965 OF 2026

M/s. Beta Wind Farm Private Limited
Through its Vice-President – Legal
Bascon Futura, IV Floor,
10/1, Venkatanarayana Road,
.... Appellant(s)
Page 1 of 65

Judgement in Appeal No. 600 of 2023 and batch

T. Nagar, Chennai – 600017.
Versus
1. Andhra Pradesh Electricity Regulatory Commission,
Represented by its Secretary,
th
11-4-660, 4 Floor, Singareni Bhavan,
Red Hils Road, Khairatabad,
Hyderabad, Telangana – 500004.
.... Respondent(s)

2. Southern Power Distribution Company of Andhra
Pradesh Limited,
Represented by Chief General Manager,
D. No. 19-13-65/A, Srinivasapuram,
Tiruchanoor Road,
Tirupati – 517503, Andhra Pradesh.


3. ReNew Vayu Urja Pvt. Ltd.
Through its Legal Manager,
138, Ansal Chambers – II,
Bhikaji Cama Place,
New Delhi – 11006.
Respondent(s)

Counsel for the Appellant(s) : Anand K. Ganesan
Swapna Seshadri
Harini Subramani
Ashabari Basu Thakur
for App. 1

Counsel for the Respondent(s) : Gaichangpou Gangmei
Arjun D Singh
Ankita Sharma
Yashvir Kumar
Vishnu Thulasi Menon
Rajat Srivastava
Yashvir Kumar
Lothungbeni T. Lotha
Yimyanger Longkumer
for Res. 1

Yelamanchili Shiva Santosh Kumar
Rudrajit Ghosh
Page 2 of 65

Judgement in Appeal No. 600 of 2023 and batch

for Res. 2

Sajan Poovayya, Sr. Adv.
Vishrov Mukerjee
Janmali Gopal Rao Manikala
Yashaswi Kant
Girik Bhalla
Pratyush Singh
Ameya Vikram Mishra
Damodar Solanki
Priyanka Vyas
Juhi Senguttuvan
Deepak Thakur
Anumeha Smiti
Sai Snigdha Nittala
Snehal Upadhyay
for Res. 3

APPEAL No. 242 OF 2024

Danu Wind Parks Private Limited
Plot No. 1202, 1215A, Door No. 8-2-293/82/A/1202,
S.L. Jubilee, Road No. 61, Jubilee Hills,
Hyderabad, Telangana – 500033.
Authorized Signatory, Umadevi Jaladi.
.... Appellant(s)
Versus
1. Andhra Pradesh Electricity Regulatory Commission,
th
4 Floor, Singareni Bhavan,
Red Hills, Hyderabad,
Telangana – 500004.
Represented by its Secretary.














....

2. Southern Power Distribution Company of Andhra
Pradesh Limited,
19-13-65/A, Raghavendra Nagar,
Kesavayana Gunta, Tiruchanoor Road,
Tirupati, Andhra Pradesh – 517501,
Rep. by its Managing Director.


3. The Transmission Corporation of Andhra Pradesh,
Page 3 of 65

Judgement in Appeal No. 600 of 2023 and batch

Vidyut Soudha Building, Khairatabad Road,
Near Eenadu, Hyderabad,
Telangana – 50004.
Rep. by its Chairman and Managing Director.










Respondent(s)

4.
Andhra Pradesh Power Co-ordination Committee,
A.P. Transco, Vidyut Soudha, Gunadala,
Vijayawada, Andhra Pradesh – 500082.
Rep. by its Joint Mannaging Director.


Counsel for the Appellant(s) : Prerna Singh
Ravi Kishore
Niraj Singh
Guntur Pramod Kumar
Keshav Singh
for App. 1

Counsel for the Respondent(s) : Gaichangpou Gangmei
Arjun D Singh
Mukunda Rao Angara
Ankita Sharma
Yashvir Kumar
Vishnu Thulasi Menon
Nisha Pandey
for Res. 1

Yelamanchili Shiva Santosh Kumar
Rudrajit Ghosh
Maria Jerome J
Khyati Chhabra
for Res. 2

Yelamanchili Shiva Santosh Kumar
Rudrajit Ghosh
Maria Jerome J
Khyati Chhabra
for Res. 3

Yelamanchili Shiva Santosh Kumar
Page 4 of 65

Judgement in Appeal No. 600 of 2023 and batch

Rudrajit Ghosh
Maria Jerome J
Khyati Chhabra
for Res. 4

APPEAL No. 747 OF 2023

Southern Power Distribution Company of Andhra
Pradesh Limited,
19-13-65/A, Raghavendra Nagar,
Kesavayana Gunta, Tiruchanoor Road,
Tirupati, Andhra Pradesh – 517501.
.... Appellant(s)
Versus
1. Andhra Pradesh Electricity Regulatory
Commission,
th
4 Floor, Singareni Bhavan,
Red Hills, Hyderabad – 500004.

....













Respondent(s)

2. ZR Renewable Energy Pvt. Ltd.
nd
No. 11, 2 Floor, Alcazar Plaza & Towers,
6-3-249/6, Banjara Hils, Hyderabad – 500033.
Rep. by its Managing Director.


3. The Transmission Corporation of Andhra
Pradesh,
(APTRANSCO)
Vidyut Soudha Building, Khairatabad Road,
Near Eluru Road, Gunadala,
Vijaywada, Andhra Pradesh – 520004.



Counsel for the Appellant(s) : Yelamanchili Shiva Santosh Kumar
Rudrajit Ghosh
for App. 1

Counsel for the Respondent(s) : Gaichangpou Gangmei
Arjun D Singh
Ankita Sharma
Yashvir Kumar
Vishnu Thulasi Menon
Page 5 of 65

Judgement in Appeal No. 600 of 2023 and batch

Rajat Srivastava
Lothungbeni T. Lotha
Maitreya Mahaley
Yimyanger Longkumer
for Res. 1

Aniket Prasoon
Utsav Mukherjee
Priya Dhankar
Aman Sheikh
Rishabh Bhardwaj
Aditya Tiwari
Sanjeev Singh Thakur
for Res. 2

APPEAL No. 932 OF 2023

Mytrah Vayu (Tungbhadra) Private Limited
8001, Survey No. 109, Q-City,
Nanakramguda, Gachibowli,
Hyderabad, Telangana – 500032.
.... Appellant(s)
Versus
1. Andhra Pradesh Electricity Regulatory
Commission,
th
4 Floor, Singareni Bhavan,
Red Hills, Hyderabad,
Telangana – 500004.
Represented by its Secretary.
.... Respondent(s)

2. Southern Power Distribution Company of
Andhra
Pradesh Limited,
Represented by Chairman & Managing
Director,
19-13-65/A, Srinivasapuram,
Tiruchanoor Road, Chittoor District,
Tirupati – 517503, Andhra Pradesh.


3. The Transmission Corporation of Andhra

Pradesh,
Page 6 of 65

Judgement in Appeal No. 600 of 2023 and batch

Vidyut Soudha, Gunadala, Eluru Road,
Vijayawada,
Andhra Pradesh – 520004.
Rep. by its Managing Director.

4. New & Renewable Energy Development
Corporation of Andhra Pradesh Ltd.,
12-464/5/1, River Oaks Apartment,
CSR Kalyana Mandapam Road,
Tadepalli, Guntur District – 522 501.
Through its Managing Director.


Counsel for the Appellant(s) : Aditya K. Singh
Anukriti Jain
Tanya Sareen
Ayushi R. Saxena
for App. 1

Counsel for the Respondent(s) : Gaichangpou Gangmei
Arjun D Singh
Ankita Sharma
Lothungbeni T. Lotha
Maitreya Mahaley
Yimyanger Longkumer
for Res. 1

Yelamanchili Shiva Santosh Kumar
Khyati Chhabra
Maria Jerome J
Rudrajit Ghosh
for Res. 2

Yelamanchili Shiva Santosh Kumar
Rudrajit Ghosh
Khyati Chhabra
Maria Jerome J
for Res. 3

APPEAL No. 109 OF 2024

Hetero Wind Power (Pennar) Private Limited .... Appellant(s)
Page 7 of 65

Judgement in Appeal No. 600 of 2023 and batch

7-2-A2, Hetero Corporate,
rd
3 Floor, Industrial Estate, Sanath Nagar,
Hyderabad, Telangana – 500018.
Rep. by its Authorized Signatory, Mr. Varre Veerababu.
Versus
1. Andhra Pradesh Electricity Regulatory
























Respondent(s)
Commission,
th
11-4-660, 4 Floor, Singareni Bhavan,
Red Hills, Hyderabad,
Telangana – 500004.
Represented by its Secretary.

....

2. Southern Power Distribution Company of Andhra
Pradesh Limited,
19-13-65/A, Raghavendra Nagar,
Kesavayana Gunta, Tiruchanoor Road,
Tirupati, Andhra Pradesh – 517501,
Rep. by its Managing Director.


3. The Transmission Corporation of Andhra Pradesh,
Vidyut Soudha Building, Khairatabad Road,
Near Eenadu, Hyderabad,
Telangana – 50004.
Rep. by its Chairman and Managing Director.


4. Andhra Pradesh Power Co-ordination Committee,
A.P. Transco, Vidyut Soudha, Gunadala,
Vijayawada, Andhra Pradesh – 500082.
Rep. by its Joint Mannaging Director.


Counsel for the Appellant(s) : Prerna Singh
Ravi Kishore
Niraj Singh
Guntur Pramod Kumar
Keshav Singh
for App. 1

Counsel for the Respondent(s) : Gaichangpou Gangmei
Arjun D Singh
Page 8 of 65

Judgement in Appeal No. 600 of 2023 and batch

Ankita Sharma
Rajat Srivastava
Lothungbeni T. Lotha
Maitreya Mahaley
Yimyanger Longkumer
for Res. 1

Yelamanchili Shiva Santosh Kumar
Rudrajit Ghosh
Khyati Chhabra
Maria Jerome J
for Res. 2

Yelamanchili Shiva Santosh Kumar
Rudrajit Ghosh
Khyati Chhabra
Maria Jerome J
for Res. 3

Yelamanchili Shiva Santosh Kumar
Rudrajit Ghosh
Khyati Chhabra
Maria Jerome J
for Res. 4

APPEAL No. 110 OF 2024

Hetero Wind Power Ltd.
7-2-A2, Hetero Corporate,
rd
3 Floor, Industrial Estate,
Sanath Nagar,
Hyderabad, Telangana – 500018.
Represented by its Authorized Signatory,
Mr. Varre Veerababu.
.... Appellant(s)
Versus
1. Andhra Pradesh Electricity Regulatory Commission,
th
11-4-660, 4 Floor, Singareni Bhavan,
Red Hills, Hyderabad,
Telangana – 500004.
Represented by its Secretary.





....
Page 9 of 65

Judgement in Appeal No. 600 of 2023 and batch




















Respondent(s)
2. Southern Power Distribution Company of Andhra
Pradesh Limited,
A company registered under the Company Act,
1956,
Having its Office at 19-13-65/A, Raghavendra
Nagar,
Kesavayana Gunta, Tiruchanoor Road,
Tirupati, Andhra Pradesh – 517501,
Rep. by its Managing Director.


3. The Transmission Corporation of Andhra Pradesh,
Vidyut Soudha Building, Khairatabad Road,
Near Eenadu, Hyderabad,
Telangana – 50004.
Rep. by its Chairman and Managing Director.


4. Andhra Pradesh Power Co-ordination Committee,
A.P. Transco, Vidyut Soudha, Gunadala,
Vijayawada, Andhra Pradesh – 50082.
Rep. by its Joint Mannaging Director.


Counsel for the Appellant(s) : Prerna Singh
Ravi Kishore
Niraj Singh
Guntur Pramod Kumar
Keshav Singh
for App. 1

Counsel for the Respondent(s) : Gaichangpou Gangmei
Ankita Sharma
Rajat Srivastava
Lothungbeni T. Lotha
Maitreya Mahaley
Yimyanger Longkumer
for Res. 1

Yelamanchili Shiva Santosh Kumar
Rudrajit Ghosh
Khyati Chhabra
Page 10 of 65

Judgement in Appeal No. 600 of 2023 and batch

Maria Jerome J
for Res. 2, 3 & 4

APPEAL No. 137 OF 2024

Southern Power Distribution Company of Andhra
Pradesh Limited,
19-13-65/A, Srinivasapuram, Tiruchanoor Road,
Tirupati, Andhra Pradesh – 517503,
Rep. by its General Manager – Mr. P. Venkateshwara
Rao.
.... Appellant(s)
Versus
1. Andhra Pradesh Electricity Regulatory Commission,
























Respondent(s)
th
4 Floor, Singareni Bhavan,
Red Hills, Hyderabad,
Telangana – 500004.
Represented by its Secretary.
....

2. Mytrah Vayu (Indravati) Private Limited
8001, Survey No. 109, Q-City,
Nanakramguda, Gachibowli,
Hyderabad, Telangana – 500032.
Authorized Rep. by Director


3. The Transmission Corporation of Andhra Pradesh
Ltd.
(APTRANSCO),
Vidyut Soudha, Eluru Road, Vijayawada,
Andhra Pradesh – 520004.
Rep. by its Managing Director.


4. New & Renewable Energy Development Corporation
of Andhra Pradesh Ltd.,
12-464/5/1, River Oaks Apartment,
CSR Kalyana Mandapam Road,
Tadepalli, Guntur District – 522 501.
Through its Managing Director.


Page 11 of 65

Judgement in Appeal No. 600 of 2023 and batch

Counsel for the Appellant(s) : Yelamanchili Shiva Santosh Kumar
Rudrajit Ghosh
Khyati Chhabra
Maria Jerome J
for App. 1

Counsel for the Respondent(s) : Gaichangpou Gangmei
Arjun D Singh
Ankita Sharma
Yashvir Kumar
Rajat Srivastava
Lothungbeni T. Lotha
Maitreya Mahaley
Yimyanger Longkumer
for Res. 1

Aditya K. Singh
Anukriti Jain
Tanya Sareen
Ayushi R. Saxena
for Res. 2

APPEAL No. 141 OF 2024

Southern Power Distribution Company of Andhra
Pradesh Limited,
A company registered under the Company Act, 1956,
Having its Office at 19-13-65/A, Raghavendra Nagar,
Kesavayana Gunta, Tiruchanoor Road,
Tirupati, Andhra Pradesh – 517501,
Rep. by its Managing Director.
.... Appellant(s)
Versus
1. Andhra Pradesh Electricity Regulatory Commission,








th
4 Floor, Singareni Bhavan,
Red Hills, Hyderabad,
Telangana – 500004.
Represented by its Secretary.
....

2. Mytrah Vayu (Tungabhadra) Private Limited

8001, Survey No. 109, Q-City,
Page 12 of 65

Judgement in Appeal No. 600 of 2023 and batch

Nanakramguda, Gachibowli,
Hyderabad, Telangana – 500032.
Authorized Rep. Sri Jayavardhan Shankotai.
















Respondent(s)

3. The Transmission Corporation of Andhra Pradesh,
Vidyut Soudha, Gunadala, Eluru Road, Vijayawada,
Andhra Pradesh – 520004.
Rep. by its Managing Director.


4. New & Renewable Energy Development Corporation
of Andhra Pradesh Ltd.,
12-464/5/1, River Oaks Apartment,
CSR Kalyana Mandapam Road,
Tadepalli, Guntur District – 522 501.
Through its Managing Director.


Counsel for the Appellant(s) : Yelamanchili Shiva Santosh Kumar
Rudrajit Ghosh
Khyati Chhabra
Maria Jerome J
for App. 1

Counsel for the Respondent(s) : Gaichangpou Gangmei
Arjun D Singh
Ankita Sharma
Rajat Srivastava
Lothungbeni T. Lotha
Maitreya Mahaley
Yimyanger Longkumer
for Res. 1

Aditya K. Singh
Anukriti Jain
Tanya Sareen
Ayushi R. Saxena
for Res. 2

APPEAL No. 142 OF 2024


Page 13 of 65

Judgement in Appeal No. 600 of 2023 and batch

Southern Power Distribution Company of Andhra
Pradesh Limited,
19-13-65/A, Srinivasapuram, Tiruchanoor Road,
Tirupati, Chittoor District,
Andhra Pradesh – 517503,
Rep. by its General Manager – Mr. P. Venkateshwara
Rao.
.... Appellant(s)
Versus
1. Andhra Pradesh Electricity Regulatory Commission,























Respondent(s)
th
4 Floor, Singareni Bhavan,
Red Hills, Hyderabad – 500004.
Represented by its Secretary.
....

2. Mytrah Vayu (Krishna) Private Limited
8001, Survey No. 109, Q-City,
Nanakramguda, Gachibowli,
Hyderabad, Telangana – 500032.
Authorized Rep.Sh. Jayavardhan Shankotai.


3. The Transmission Corporation of Andhra Pradesh
Ltd.,
Vidyut Soudha, Gunadala, Eluru Road, Vijayawada,
Andhra Pradesh – 520004.
Rep. by its Chairman &Managing Director.


4. New & Renewable Energy Development Corporation
of Andhra Pradesh Ltd.,
12-464/5/1, River Oaks Apartment,
CSR Kalyana Mandapam Road,
Tadepalli, Guntur District – 522 501.
Through its Managing Director.


Counsel for the Appellant(s) : Yelamanchili Shiva Santosh Kumar
Rudrajit Ghosh
Khyati Chhabra
Maria Jerome J
for App. 1

Counsel for the Respondent(s) : Gaichangpou Gangmei
Arjun D Singh
Page 14 of 65

Judgement in Appeal No. 600 of 2023 and batch

Ankita Sharma
Rajat Srivastava
Lothungbeni T. Lotha
Maitreya Mahaley
Yimyanger Longkumer
for Res. 1

Aditya K. Singh
Anukriti Jain
Tanya Sareen
Ayushi R. Saxena
for Res. 2

APPEAL No. 143 OF 2024


Southern Power Distribution Company of Andhra
Pradesh Limited,
19-13-65/A, Srinivasapuram,
Tiruchanoor Road,
Tirupati, Chittoor District,
Andhra Pradesh – 517503,
Through its Authorized Signatory P. Venkateswara Rao.
.... Appellant(s)
Versus
1. Andhra Pradesh Electricity Regulatory
Commission,
Through its Secretary.
th
4 Floor, Singareni Bhavan,
Red Hills, Hyderabad – 500004.
















....

2. Mytrah Vayu (Krishna) Private Limited,
8001, Survey No. 109, Q-City,
Nanakramguda, Gachibowli,
Hyderabad – 500032,
Telangana.
Through its Authorized Representative
Sri Jayavardhana Shankotai.


3. Transmission Corporation of Andhra Pradesh

Limited,
Page 15 of 65

Judgement in Appeal No. 600 of 2023 and batch

Vidyut Soudha Gunadala, Eluru Road,
Vijayawada, Andhra Pradesh – 520004.
(Through its Managing Director)











Respondent(s)

4.
New & Renewable Energy Development
Corporation of Andhra Pradesh Limited,
Through its Managing Director,
12-464/5/1, River Oaks Apartment,
CSR Kalyana Mandapam Road,
TAdepalli, Guntur District – 522501.
Through its Managing Director.


Counsel for the Appellant(s) : Yelamanchili Shiva Santosh Kumar
Rudrajit Ghosh
Khyati Chhabra
Maria Jerome J
for App. 1

Counsel for the Respondent(s) : Gaichangpou Gangmei
Arjun D Singh
Ankita Sharma
Rajat Srivastava
Lothungbeni T. Lotha
Maitreya Mahaley
Yimyanger Longkumer
for Res. 1

Aditya K. Singh
Anukriti Jain
Tanya Sareen
Ayushi R. Saxena
for Res. 2

APPEAL No. 148 OF 2024

Southern Power Distribution Company of Andhra
Pradesh Limited,
Represented by Chairman & Managing Director,
D. No. 19-13-65/A, Srinivasapuram,
Tiruchanoor Road,
.... Appellant(s)
Page 16 of 65

Judgement in Appeal No. 600 of 2023 and batch

Tirupati – 517503, Andhra Pradesh.
Versus
1. Andhra Pradesh Electricity Regulatory
Commission,
th
4 Floor, Singareni Bhavan,
Red Hills, Hyderabad,
Telangana – 500004.
Represented by its Secretary.
























Respondent(s)
....

2. Mytrah Vayu (Krishna) Private Limited
8001, Survey No. 109, Q-City,
Nanakramguda, Gachibowli,
Hyderabad, Telangana – 500032.


3. The Transmission Corporation of Andhra
Pradesh,
Vidyut Soudha, Gunadala, Eluru Road,
Vijayawada,
Andhra Pradesh – 520004.
Rep. by its Managing Director.


4. New & Renewable Energy Development
Corporation of Andhra Pradesh Ltd.,
12-464/5/1, River Oaks Apartment,
CSR Kalyana Mandapam Road,
Tadepalli, Guntur District – 522 501.
Through its Managing Director.



Counsel for the Appellant(s) : Yelamanchili Shiva Santosh Kumar
Rudrajit Ghosh
Khyati Chhabra
Maria Jerome J
for App. 1

Counsel for the Respondent(s) : Gaichangpou Gangmei
Arjun D Singh
Ankita Sharma
Rajat Srivastava
Lothungbeni T. Lotha
Page 17 of 65

Judgement in Appeal No. 600 of 2023 and batch

Maitreya Mahaley
Yimyanger Longkumer
for Res. 1

Aditya K. Singh
Anukriti Jain
Tanya Sareen
Ayushi R. Saxena
for Res. 2

APPEAL No. 177 OF 2024

Southern Power Distribution Company of Andhra
Pradesh Limited,
19-13-65/A, Raghavendra Nagar,
Kesavayana Gunta, Tiruchanoor Road,
Tirupati, Andhra Pradesh – 517501,
Rep. by Mr. P. Venkateshwara Rao-GM.
.... Appellant(s)
Versus
1. Andhra Pradesh Electricity Regulatory
Commission,
th
4 Floor, Singareni Bhavan,
Red Hills, Hyderabad,
Telangana – 500004.
Represented by its Secretary.





















....

2. Danu Wind Parks Private Limited
Plot No. 1202, 1215A,
Door No. 8-2-293/82/A/1202,
S.L. Jubilee, Road No. 61,
Jubilee Hills, Hyderabad – 500033.
(Through its Director).


3. The Transmission Corporation of Andhra
Pradesh,
(APTRANSCO)
Vidyut Soudha Building, Khairatabad Road,
Near Eenadu, Hyderabad,
Telangana – 500004.
Rep. by its Managing Director.

Page 18 of 65

Judgement in Appeal No. 600 of 2023 and batch




Respondent(s)
4. Andhra Pradesh Power Coordination
Committee,
A.P. Transco, Vidyut Soudha, Gunadala,
Gunadala, Vijaywada – 500082. .
Rep. by its Managing Director.


Counsel for the Appellant(s) : Yelamanchili Shiva Santosh Kumar
Rudrajit Ghosh
Khyati Chhabra
Maria Jerome J
for App. 1

Counsel for the Respondent(s) : Gaichangpou Gangmei
Arjun D Singh
Ankita Sharma
Yashvir Kumar
Rajat Srivastava
Lothungbeni T. Lotha
Maitreya Mahaley
Yimyanger Longkumer
for Res. 1

Prerna Singh
Ravi Kishore
Niraj Singh
Guntur Pramod Kumar
Keshav Singh
for Res. 2

APPEAL No. 178 OF 2024

Southern Power Distribution Company of Andhra
Pradesh Limited,
19-13-65/A, Raghavendra Nagar,
Kesavayana Gunta, Tiruchanoor Road,
Tirupati, Andhra Pradesh – 517501,
Rep. by Mr. P. Venkateshwara Rao-GM.
.... Appellant(s)
Versus
Page 19 of 65

Judgement in Appeal No. 600 of 2023 and batch

1. Andhra Pradesh Electricity Regulatory
Commission,
th
4 Floor, Singareni Bhavan,
Red Hills, Hyderabad,
Telangana – 500004.
Represented by its Secretary.
.... Respondent(s)

2. Aeolus Wind Parks Private Limited,
Plot No. 1202, 1215A,
Door No. 8-2-293/82/A/1202,
S.L. Jubilee Road No. 61, Jubilee Hills,
Hyderabad – 500033, Telangana
(Through its Director).


3. The Transmission Corporation of Andhra
Pradesh,
(APTRANSCO)
Vidyut Soudha Building, Khairatabad Road,
Near Eenadu, Hyderabad,
Telangana – 50004.
Rep. by its Managing Director.


4. Andhra Pradesh Power Co-ordination
Committee,
A.P. Transco, Vidyut Soudha, Gunadala,
Gunadala, Vijaywada – 500082. .
Rep. by its Mannaging Director.


Counsel for the Appellant(s) : Astha Sharma
Yelamanchili Shiva Santosh Kumar
Rudrajit Ghosh
Khyati Chhabra
Maria Jerome J
for App. 1

Counsel for the Respondent(s) : Gaichangpou Gangmei
Arjun D Singh
Ankita Sharma
Yashvir Kumar
Rajat Srivastava
Page 20 of 65

Judgement in Appeal No. 600 of 2023 and batch

Lothungbeni T. Lotha
Maitreya Mahaley
Yimyanger Longkumer
for Res. 1

Prerna Singh
Ravi Kishore
Niraj Singh
Guntur Pramod Kumar
Keshav Singh
for Res. 2

APPEAL No. 179 OF 2024

Southern Power Distribution Company of Andhra
Pradesh Limited,
19-13-65/A, Raghavendra Nagar,
Kesavayana Gunta, Tiruchanoor Road,
Tirupati, Andhra Pradesh – 517501,
Rep. by Mr. P. Venkateshwara Rao-GM.
.... Appellant(s)
Versus
1. Andhra Pradesh Electricity Regulatory
Commission,
th
4 Floor, Singareni Bhavan,
Red Hills, Hyderabad,
Telangana – 500004.
Represented by its Secretary.



















....

2. Danu Wind Parks Private Limited
Plot No. 1202, 1215A,
Door No. 8-2-293/82/A/1202,
S.L. Jubilee, Road No. 61,
Jubilee Hills, Hyderabad – 500033.
(Through its Director).


3. The Transmission Corporation of Andhra
Pradesh,
(APTRANSCO)
Vidyut Soudha Building, Khairatabad Road,
Near Eenadu, Hyderabad,

Page 21 of 65

Judgement in Appeal No. 600 of 2023 and batch

Telangana – 50004.
Rep. by its Chairman and Managing Director.





Respondent(s)

4. Andhra Pradesh Power Coordination
Committee,
A.P. Transco, Vidyut Soudha, Gunadala,
Gunadala, Vijaywada – 500082. .
Rep. by its Chief General Manager.



Counsel for the Appellant(s) : Yelamanchili Shiva Santosh Kumar
Rudrajit Ghosh
for App. 1

Counsel for the Respondent(s) : Gaichangpou Gangmei
Arjun D Singh
Ankita Sharma
Rajat Srivastava
Lothungbeni T. Lotha
Maitreya Mahaley
Yimyanger Longkumer
for Res. 1

Prerna Singh
Ravi Kishore
Niraj Singh
Guntur Pramod Kumar
Keshav Singh
for Res. 2

APPEAL No. 180 OF 2024


Southern Power Distribution Company of Andhra
Pradesh Limited,
19-13-65/A, Raghavendra Nagar,
Kesavayana Gunta, Tiruchanoor Road,
Tirupati, Andhra Pradesh – 517501,
Rep. by Mr. P. Venkateshwara Rao.
.... Appellant(s)
Versus
Page 22 of 65

Judgement in Appeal No. 600 of 2023 and batch

1. Andhra Pradesh Electricity Regulatory
Commission,
th
4 Floor, Singareni Bhavan,
Red Hills, Hyderabad,
Telangana – 500004.
Represented by its Secretary.
























Respondent(s)
....

2. Dindore Wind Parks Private Limited
Plot No. 1202, 1215A,
Door No. 8-2-293/82/A/1202,
S.L. Jubilee, Road No. 61,
Jubilee Hills, Hyderabad – 500033.
(Through its Director).


3. The Transmission Corporation of Andhra
Pradesh,
(APTRANSCO)
Vidyut Soudha Building, Khairatabad Road,
Near Eenadu, Hyderabad,
Telangana – 500004.
Rep. by its Chairman & Managing Director.


4. Andhra Pradesh Power Coordination
Committee,
A.P. Transco, Vidyut Soudha, Gunadala,
Gunadala, Vijaywada – 500082.
Rep. by its Chief General Manager.


Counsel for the Appellant(s) : Yelamanchili Shiva Santosh Kumar
Rudrajit Ghosh
Khyati Chhabra
Maria Jerome J
for App. 1

Counsel for the Respondent(s) : Gaichangpou Gangmei
Arjun D Singh
Ankita Sharma
Rajat Srivastava
Lothungbeni T. Lotha
Maitreya Mahaley
Page 23 of 65

Judgement in Appeal No. 600 of 2023 and batch

Yimyanger Longkumer
for Res. 1

Prerna Singh
Ravi Kishore
Niraj Singh
Guntur Pramod Kumar
Keshav Singh
for Res. 2

APPEAL No. 181 OF 2024

Southern Power Distribution Company of Andhra
Pradesh Limited,
19-13-65/A, Raghavendra Nagar,
Kesavayana Gunta, Tiruchanoor Road,
Tirupati, Andhra Pradesh – 517501,
Rep. by Mr. P. Venkateshwara Rao.
.... Appellant(s)
Versus
1. Andhra Pradesh Electricity Regulatory
Commission,
th
4 Floor, Singareni Bhavan,
Red Hills, Hyderabad,
Telangana – 500004.
Represented by its Secretary.




















....

2. Fujin Wind Parks Private Limited
Plot No. 1202, 1215A,
Door No. 8-2-293/82/A/1202,
S.L. Jubilee, Road No. 61,
Jubilee Hills, Hyderabad – 500033.
Rep. Umadevi Jaladi.


3. The Transmission Corporation of Andhra
Pradesh,
Vidyut Soudha Building, Khairatabad Road,
Near Eenadu, Hyderabad,
Telangana – 50004.
Rep. by its Managing Director.

Page 24 of 65

Judgement in Appeal No. 600 of 2023 and batch




Respondent(s)
4. Andhra Pradesh Power Co-ordination
Committee,
A.P. Transco, Vidyut Soudha, Gunadala,
Gunadala, Vijaywada – 500082. .
Rep. by its Chief General Manager.



Counsel for the Appellant(s) : Yelamanchili Shiva Santosh Kumar
Rudrajit Ghosh
Khyati Chhabra
Maria Jerome J
for App. 1

Counsel for the Respondent(s) : Gaichangpou Gangmei
Arjun D Singh
Ankita Sharma
Rajat Srivastava
Lothungbeni T. Lotha
Maitreya Mahaley
Yimyanger Longkumer
for Res. 1

Prerna Singh
Ravi Kishore
Niraj Singh
Guntur Pramod Kumar
Keshav Singh
for Res. 2

APPEAL No. 182 OF 2024

Southern Power Distribution Company of Andhra
Pradesh Limited,
19-13-65/A, Raghavendra Nagar,
Kesavayana Gunta, Tiruchanoor Road,
Tirupati, Andhra Pradesh – 517501,
Rep. by its Managing Director.
.... Appellant(s)
Versus
Page 25 of 65

Judgement in Appeal No. 600 of 2023 and batch

1. Andhra Pradesh Electricity Regulatory
























Respondent(s)
Commission,
th
11-4-660, 4 Floor, Singareni Bhavan,
Red Hills, Hyderabad,
Telangana – 500004.
Represented by its Secretary.

....

2. Hetero Wind Power (Pennar) Private Limited
7-2-A2, Hetero Corporate,
rd
3 Floor, Industrial Estate, Sanath Nagar,
Hyderabad – 500018.
Through its Director.


3. The Transmission Corporation of Andhra Pradesh,
Vidyut Soudha Building, Khairatabad Road,
Near Eenadu, Hyderabad,
Telangana – 50004.
Rep. by its Chairman and Managing Director.


4. Andhra Pradesh Power Co-ordination Committee,
A.P. Transco, Vidyut Soudha, Gunadala,
Vijayawada, Andhra Pradesh – 500082.
Rep. by its Joint Mannaging Director.


Counsel for the Appellant(s) : Yelamanchili Shiva Santosh Kumar
Rudrajit Ghosh
Khyati Chhabra
Maria Jerome J
for App. 1

Counsel for the Respondent(s) : Gaichangpou Gangmei
Arjun D Singh
Ankita Sharma
Yashvir Kumar
Rajat Srivastava
Lothungbeni T. Lotha
Maitreya Mahaley
Yimyanger Longkumer
for Res. 1
Page 26 of 65

Judgement in Appeal No. 600 of 2023 and batch


Prerna Singh
Ravi Kishore
Niraj Singh
Guntur Pramod Kumar
Keshav Singh
for Res. 2

APPEAL No. 289 OF 2024

Southern Power Distribution Company of Andhra
Pradesh Limited,
19-13-65/A, Srinivasapuram, Tiruchanoor Road,
Tirupati, Chittoor District, Andhra Pradesh – 517503,
Rep. by its General Manager – Mr. P. Venkateshwara
Rao.
.... Appellant(s)
Versus
1. Andhra Pradesh Electricity Regulatory Commission,



















th
4 Floor, Singareni Bhavan,
Red Hills, Hyderabad,
Telangana – 500004.
Represented by its Secretary.
....

2. Mytrah Vayu (Tungbhadra) Private Limited
8001, Survey No. 109, Q-City,
Nanakramguda, Gachibowli,
Hyderabad, Telangana – 500032.
Authorized Rep. Mr. S. Nagarajuna Reddy


3. The Transmission Corporation of Andhra Pradesh
Ltd,
Vidyut Soudha, Gunadala, Eluru Road, Vijayawada,
Andhra Pradesh – 520004.
Rep. by its Managing Director.


Page 27 of 65

Judgement in Appeal No. 600 of 2023 and batch

4. New & Renewable Energy Development Corporation





Respondent(s)

Counsel for the Appellant(s) : Yelamanchili Shiva Santosh Kumar
of Andhra Pradesh Ltd.,
12-464/5/1, River Oaks Apartment,
CSR Kalyana Mandapam Road,
Tadepalli, Guntur District – 522 501.
Through its Managing Director.

Rudrajit Ghosh
Khyati Chhabra
Maria Jerome J
for App. 1

Counsel for the Respondent(s) : Gaichangpou Gangmei
Arjun D Singh
Ankita Sharma
Nisha Pandey
Maitreya Mahaley
for Res. 1

Aditya K. Singh
Anukriti Jain
Tanya Sareen
Ayushi R. Saxena
for Res. 2

APPEAL No. 387 OF 2024


Axis Wind Farms (Rayalaseema) Pvt. Ltd.
Through Director, Legal (Mr. Rohan Ghosh)
Plot No. 47, 48, 49, Street No. 1,
nd
2 Avenue, Patrika Nagar, Madhapur,
Seri Lingampalli (M), Rangaredi,
Hyderabad, Telangana, India, 500081.
.... Appellant(s)
Versus
1. Andhra Pradesh Electricity Regulatory Commission,
Vidyut NIyantrana Bhavan,
Adjacent to 220/132/33/11 KV AP Carbides Sub
Station,
Dinedevarapadu Road,





....
Page 28 of 65

Judgement in Appeal No. 600 of 2023 and batch

Kurnool, Andhra Pradesh – 518002.
Through its Secretary.
























Respondent(s)

2. Southern Power Distribution Company Limited,
19-13-65/A, Raghavendra Nagar,
Kesavayana Gunta, Tiruchanoor Road,
Tirupati, Andhra Pradesh – 517501,
Rep. by its Managing Director.


3. The Transmission Corporation of Andhra Pradesh,
Vidyut Soudha, Gunadala, Eluru Road,
Vijayawada, Andhra Pradesh – 50004.
Rep. by its Chairman and Managing Director.


4. New & Renewable Energy Development
Corporation of Andhra Pradesh Ltd.
Through its Managing Director,
12-464/5/1, River Oaks Apartment,
CSR Kalyana Mandapam Road,
TAdepali, Guntur District – 522501.


5. Indian Wind Power Association
Through its Chairman,
th
E, 6 Flor, Shakti Towers -1, 76,
Anna Salai Chennai, Tamil Nadu – 600002.


Counsel for the Appellant(s) : Syed Jafar Alam
Deep Rao Palepu
Arjun Agarwal
Ashwin Ramanathan
Ankita Kamath
Parth Parikh
Tarang Saraogi
for App. 1

Counsel for the Respondent(s) : Gaichangpou Gangmei
Arjun D Singh
Yimyanger Longkumer
Ishat Singh
Vishnu Thulasi Menon
Page 29 of 65

Judgement in Appeal No. 600 of 2023 and batch

Maitreya Mahaley
Nisha Pandey
for Res. 1

Yelamanchili Shiva Santosh Kumar
Rudrajit Ghosh
Medha Kolanu
Khyati Chhabra
for Res. 2

Yelamanchili Shiva Santosh Kumar
Rudrajit Ghosh
Medha Kolanu
Khyati Chhabra
for Res. 3

Aditya K. Singh
Anukriti Jain
Ayushi R. Saxena
Priya Singh
Divyansh Singh
for Res. 5

APPEAL No. 388 OF 2024

Axis Wind Farms (Anantpur) Private Limited,
Through its Director, Legal (Mr. Rohan Ghosh)
Plot No. 47, 48, 49, Street No. 1,
nd
2 Avenue, Patrika Nagar,
Madhapur,
Seri Lingampalli (M), Rangareddi,
Hyderabad, Telangana, India, 500081.
.... Appellant(s)
Versus
1. Andhra Pradesh Electricity Regulatory Commission,
Through its Secretary.
Vidyut Niyantrana Bhavan,
Adjacent rto 220/132/33/11 KV AP Carbides Sub
Station,
Dinnedevarapadu Road,
Kurnool, Andhra Pradesh – 518002.







....
Page 30 of 65

Judgement in Appeal No. 600 of 2023 and batch

























Respondent(s)
2. Southern Power Distribution Company of Andhra
Pradesh Limited,
19-13-65/A, Raghavendra Nagar,
Kesavayana Gunta, Tiruchanoor Road,
Tirupati, Andhra Pradesh – 517501,
Rep. by its Managing Director.


3. The Transmission Corporation of Andhra Pradesh,
Vidyut Soudha Gunadala, Eluru Road,
Vijayawada, Andhra Pradesh – 520004.


4. New & Renewable Energy Development
Corporation of Andhra Pradesh Limited,
Through its Managing Director,
12-464/5/1, River Oaks Apartment,
CSR Kalyana Mandapam Road,
TAdepalli, Guntur District – 522501.



5. Indian Wind Power Association
Through its Chairman,
th
E, 6 Floor, Shakti Towers-1, 76,
Anna Salai Chenai, Tamil Nadu – 600002.


Counsel for the Appellant(s) : Syed Jafar Alam
Deep Rao Palepu
Arjun Agarwal
Ashwin Ramanathan
Ankita Kamath
Parth Parikh
Tarang Saraogi
for App. 1

Counsel for the Respondent(s) : Gaichangpou Gangmei
Arjun D Singh
Yimyanger Longkumer
Ishat Singh
Vishnu Thulasi Menon
Nisha Pandey
Maitreya Mahaley
Page 31 of 65

Judgement in Appeal No. 600 of 2023 and batch

for Res. 1

Yelamanchili Shiva Santosh Kumar
Rudrajit Ghosh
Medha Kolanu
Khyati Chhabra
for Res. 2

Yelamanchili Shiva Santosh Kumar
Rudrajit Ghosh
Medha Kolanu
Khyati Chhabra
for Res. 3

Aditya K. Singh
Anukriti Jain
Ayushi R. Saxena
Divyansh Singh
Priya Singh
for Res. 5

APPEAL No. 746 OF 2023

Southern Power Distribution Company of Andhra
Pradesh Limited,
Represented by General Manager,
19-13-65/A, Kesavayana, Gunta,
Tiruchanoor Road,
Tirupati – 517501, Andhra Pradesh.
.... Appellant(s)
Versus
1. Andhra Pradesh Electricity Regulatory
Commission,
Represented by its Secretary,
th
4 Floor, Singareni Bhavan,
Red Hils Road, Hyderabad– 500004.








Respondent(s)
....

2. Beta Wind Farm Private Limited
Bascon Futura, IV Floor,
10/1, Venkatanarayana Road,
T. Nagar, Chennai – 600017.

Page 32 of 65

Judgement in Appeal No. 600 of 2023 and batch



Counsel for the Appellant(s) : Yelamanchili Shiva Santosh Kumar
Rudrajit Ghosh
for App. 1

Counsel for the Respondent(s) : Gaichangpou Gangmei
Arjun D Singh
Ankita Sharma
Yashvir Kumar
Vishnu Thulasi Menon
Rajat Srivastava
Lothungbeni T. Lotha
Maitreya Mahaley
Yimyanger Longkumer
for Res. 1

Anand K. Ganesan
Swapna Seshadri
Ritu Apurva
Kriti Soni
Amal Nair
Archita Kashyap
Aishwarya Subramani
for Res. 2

APPEAL No. 934 OF 2023

Mytrah Vayu (Indravati) Private Limited
8001, Survey No. 109, Q-City,
Nanakramguda, Gachibowli,
Hyderabad, Telangana – 500032.
.... Appellant(s)
Versus
1. Andhra Pradesh Electricity Regulatory
Commission,
th
4 Floor, Singareni Bhavan,
Red Hills, Hyderabad,
Telangana – 500004.
Represented by its Secretary.
.... Respondent(s)

Page 33 of 65

Judgement in Appeal No. 600 of 2023 and batch

2. Southern Power Distribution Company of
Andhra
Pradesh Limited,
Represented by Chairman & Managing
Director,
D. No. 19-13-65/A, Srinivasapuram,
Tiruchanoor Road,
Tirupati – 517503, Andhra Pradesh.


3. The Transmission Corporation of Andhra
Pradesh,
Vidyut Soudha, Gunadala, Eluru Road,
Vijayawada,
Andhra Pradesh – 520004.
Rep. by its Managing Director.


4. New & Renewable Energy Development
Corporation of Andhra Pradesh Ltd.,
12-464/5/1, River Oaks Apartment,
CSR Kalyana Mandapam Road,
Tadepalli, Guntur District – 522 501.
Through its Managing Director.


Counsel for the Appellant(s) : Aditya K. Singh
Anukriti Jain
Tanya Sareen
Ayushi R. Saxena
for App. 1

Counsel for the Respondent(s) : Gaichangpou Gangmei
Arjun D Singh
Ankita Sharma
Lothungbeni T. Lotha
Maitreya Mahaley
Yimyanger Longkumer
for Res. 1

Yelamanchili Shiva Santosh Kumar
Rudrajit Ghosh
Khyati Chhabra
Maria Jerome J
Page 34 of 65

Judgement in Appeal No. 600 of 2023 and batch

for Res. 2

Yelamanchili Shiva Santosh Kumar
Rudrajit Ghosh
Khyati Chhabra
Maria Jerome J
for Res. 3

APPEAL No. 936 OF 2023

Mytrah Vayu (Tungabhadra) Private Limited
8001, Survey No. 109, Q-City,
Nanakramguda, Gachibowli,
Hyderabad, Telangana – 500032.
.... Appellant(s)
Versus
1. Andhra Pradesh Electricity Regulatory
Commission,
th
4 Floor, Singareni Bhavan,
Red Hills, Hyderabad,
Telangana – 500004.
Represented by its Secretary.
.... Respondent(s)

2. Southern Power Distribution Company of
Andhra
Pradesh Limited,
Represented by Chairman & Managing
Director,
D. No. 19-13-65/A, Srinivasapuram,
Tiruchanoor Road,
Tirupati – 517503, Andhra Pradesh.


3. The Transmission Corporation of Andhra
Pradesh,
Vidyut Soudha, Gunadala, Eluru Road,
Vijayawada,
Andhra Pradesh – 520004.
Rep. by its Managing Director.


Page 35 of 65

Judgement in Appeal No. 600 of 2023 and batch

4. New & Renewable Energy Development
Corporation of Andhra Pradesh Ltd.,
12-464/5/1, River Oaks Apartment,
CSR Kalyana Mandapam Road,
Tadepalli, Guntur District – 522 501.
Through its Managing Director.


Counsel for the Appellant(s) : Aditya K. Singh
Anukriti Jain
Tanya Sareen
Ayushi R. Saxena
for App. 1

Counsel for the Respondent(s) : Gaichangpou Gangmei
Arjun D Singh
Ankita Sharma
Lothungbeni T. Lotha
Maitreya Mahaley
Yimyanger Longkumer
for Res. 1

Yelamanchili Shiva Santosh Kumar
Rudrajit Ghosh
Khyati Chhabra
Maria Jerome J
for Res. 2

Yelamanchili Shiva Santosh Kumar
Rudrajit Ghosh
Khyati Chhabra
Maria Jerome J
for Res. 3

JUDGEMENT
PER HON’BLE MR. AJAY TALEGAONKAR, TECHNICAL MEMBER
Background and Factual Matrix
1. This batch of twenty-three appeals challenges orders passed by the Andhra
Pradesh Electricity Regulatory Commission (“APERC”/ “Respondent No. 1”/
Page 36 of 65

Judgement in Appeal No. 600 of 2023 and batch

“State Commission”) concerning payment for wind energy supplied beyond the
normative Capacity Utilisation Factor (“CUF”). The appeals have been preferred
by wind power generators (WPGs) and Southern Power Distribution Company of
Andhra Pradesh Limited (“APSPDCL”). The details of the Impugned orders are
as follows:
Sl. No. Appeal No. Original Petition No. Date of Impugned
Order
1. 600 of 2023 and 746 of
85 of 2021 26.09.2022
2023
2. 747 of 2023 66 of 2021 26.09.2022
3. 242 of 2024 and 177 of
19 of 2023 04.10.2023
2024
4. 109 of 2024 and 182 of
23 of 2023 04.10.2023
2024
5. 110 of 2024 18 of 2023 04.10.2023
6. 178 of 2024 24 of 2023 04.10.2023
7. 179 of 2024 22 of 2023 04.10.2023
8. 180 of 2024 20 of 2023 04.10.2023
9. 181 of 2024 21 of 2023 04.10.2023
10. 932 of 2023 and 289 of
47 of 2023 18.10.2023
2024
11. 934 of 2023 and 137 of
46 of 2023 18.10.2023
2024
12. 936 of 2023 and 141 of
50 of 2023 18.10.2023
2024
13. 142 of 2024 48 of 2023 18.10.2023
14. 143 of 2024 49 of 2023 18.10.2023
15. 148 of 2024 45 of 2023 18.10.2023
16. 387 of 2024 26-27 of 2024 24.07.2024
Page 37 of 65

Judgement in Appeal No. 600 of 2023 and batch

17. 388 of 2024 27 of 2024 24.07.2024

2. APSPDCL is a distribution licensee in the State of Andhra Pradesh and the
procurer of electricity under the Power Purchase Agreements (“PPAs”) entered
into with individual WPG. It is the Appellant in Appeal Nos. 746 and 747 of 2023
and Appeal Nos. 137, 141, 142, 143, 148, 177, 178, 179, 180, 181, 182 and 289
of 2024 and a Respondent in the remaining appeals.

3. The WPGs arrayed as Appellants are Beta Wind Farm Private Limited in
Appeal No. 600 of 2023; Danu Wind Parks Private Limited in Appeal No. 242 of
2024; Mytrah Vayu (Tungabhadra) Private Limited in Appeal Nos. 932 and 936 of
2023; Mytrah Vayu (Indravati) Private Limited in Appeal No. 934 of 2023; Hetero
Wind Power (Pennar) Private Limited in Appeal No. 109 of 2024; Hetero Wind
Power Limited in Appeal No. 110 of 2024; Axis Wind Farms (Rayalaseema) Private
Limited in Appeal No. 387 of 2024; and Axis Wind Farms (Anantpur) Private
Limited in Appeal No. 388 of 2024.

4. The WPGs arrayed as Respondent No. 2 in APSPDCL’s appeals are Beta
Wind Farm Private Limited, ZR Renewable Energy Private Limited, Mytrah Vayu
(Indravati) Private Limited, Mytrah Vayu (Tungabhadra) Private Limited, Mytrah
Vayu (Krishna) Private Limited, Danu Wind Parks Private Limited, Aeolus Wind
Parks Private Limited, Dindore Wind Parks Private Limited, Fujin Wind Parks
Private Limited and Hetero Wind Power (Pennar) Private Limited.

5. ReNew Vayu Urja Private Limited is Respondent No. 3 in Appeal No. 600 of
2023. Transmission Corporation of Andhra Pradesh (“APTRANSCO”), a
Respondent in the relevant appeals, is the State Transmission Utility and performs
Page 38 of 65

Judgement in Appeal No. 600 of 2023 and batch

transmission functions under Sections 39 and 40 of the Act. New & Renewable
Energy Development Corporation of Andhra Pradesh Limited (“NREDCAP”), also
a Respondent in the relevant appeals, is the State nodal agency for approval of
renewable energy projects. Andhra Pradesh Power Co-ordination Committee is
also a Respondent in the relevant appeals. Indian Wind Power Association is
Respondent No. 5 in Appeal Nos. 387 and 388 of 2024.

6. The factual background set out below concerns Appeal No. 600 of 2023,
filed by Beta Wind Farm Private Limited (“BWFPL”) and the corresponding Appeal
No. 746 of 2023, filed by APSPDCL, arising from the order dated 26.09.2022 in
O.P. No. 85 of 2021. The facts in respect of other WPGs are similar except that
their capacity, date of Tariff Order, normative CUF, applicable generic tariff and
date of Impugned Orders may be different.

7. By order dated 03.05.2009, the then Andhra Pradesh Electricity Regulatory
Commission (for the unified state of Andhra Pradesh) determined a generic tariff
of ₹ 3.50 per unit for wind power projects. Guttaseema Wind Energy Private
Limited challenged that order in Appeal No. 194 of 2009. By judgment dated
03.05.2011, this Tribunal allowed the appeal and remanded the matter for
redetermination of tariff on the parameters of capital cost, return on equity, CUF
and interest on working capital.

8. Pursuant to the remand, the State Commission, by order dated 15.11.2012
in O.P. No. 13 of 2012, determined a preferential generic levelised tariff of ₹ 4.70
per unit for wind power projects entering into PPAs between 15.11.2012 and
31.03.2015. The tariff was determined on a cost-plus basis using normative
parameters including a CUF of 23% and was applicable for twenty-five years from
the Commercial Operation Date (“COD”). The order permitted dispatch of 100%
Page 39 of 65

Judgement in Appeal No. 600 of 2023 and batch

of the available capacity without reference to merit order dispatch, subject to
system constraints and required the parties to obtain the State Commission’s
consent to their PPAs.

9. Following APSPDCL’s request dated 12.02.2013, the State Commission, by
communication dated 14.03.2013, approved the PPA proposed to be executed
with BWFPL. The parties executed the PPA on 29.05.2013, incorporating a firm
tariff of ₹ 4.70 per unit for twenty-five years from COD. BWFPL commissioned its
50.4 MW wind power project on 27.07.2013 and commenced supply to the
distribution licensee. However, while processing the invoice for July 2017,
APSPDCL restricted payment for the period from 27.07.2016 to 27.07.2017 by
applying a CUF of 23% and treated the supply beyond that level as free of cost.
BWFPL objected, maintaining that the normative CUF was a parameter for tariff
determination and did not limit the quantum payable under the PPA.

10. APSPDCL subsequently corrected the treatment of other periods but the
disputed payment for 27.07.2016 to 27.07.2017 remained unresolved. Against
2,33,77,000 units billed, APSPDCL allegedly admitted 1,07,59,061 units, leaving
1,26,17,939 units unpaid. BWFPL has quantified the unpaid principal amount at
₹5,93,04,313.

11. BWFPL approached the State Commission in O.P. No. 85 of 2021 for
adjudication of the dispute. By the Impugned Order dated 26.09.2022, the State
Commission held that the normative CUF of 23% was to be applied over the life
of the PPA with adjustments for excess generation and shortfall. It fixed payment
at ₹ 0.50 per unit for energy generated and supplied beyond the prescribed CUF,
subject to such adjustments and directed calculation and payment or adjustment
of the amounts within two months of receipt of the order.
Page 40 of 65

Judgement in Appeal No. 600 of 2023 and batch

12. Aggrieved by the said order, BWFPL filed Appeal No. 600 of 2023 and
APSPDCL filed Appeal No. 746 of 2023. The remaining appeals challenge the
other orders identified above concerning payment for wind energy supplied
beyond the normative CUF.

13. The Appellant has prayed for the following relief from us:
“ (a) Allow the appeal and set aside the order dated 26/09/2022 passed by the
Andhra Pradesh Electricity Regulatory Commission in O.P. 85 of 2021 to the
extent challenged in the present appeal.
(b) Direct Respondent No. 2 to pay a sum of Rs. 5,93,04,313/- (Rupees Five Crore
Ninety Three Lacs Four Thousand Three Hundred And Thirteen Only) together
with interest in accordance with Article 5.2 of the PPA, computed from the date

when the amounts became due till such time the payment is made.
(c) Pass such other Order(s) and this Hon’ble Tribunal may deem just and proper.”
Issues for Consideration
14. We note that the crux of the submission of the WPGs is that the APERC has
erred in prescribing a different commercial treatment for energy generated in
excess of the energy corresponding to normative CUF, and that the generic tariff
determined in ₹ per unit ought to be equally applicable to such excess generation.
On the other hand, the Discoms, in their cross-appeals, contend that generation
in excess of the energy corresponding to normative CUF should not be entitled to
any payment at all.

15. After hearing the Learned Counsel for the Appellant and the Learned
Counsels for the Respondent at length and carefully considering their respective
submissions, we have also examined the written pleadings and relevant material
Page 41 of 65

Judgement in Appeal No. 600 of 2023 and batch

on record. Upon due consideration of the arguments advanced and the documents
placed before us, we find that the issues for our consideration in the present
Appeal can be identified as under:
Issue No. 1: Whether APERC was right in prescribing a different
commercial treatment for energy generated in excess of the energy
corresponding to normative CUF?
Issue No. 2: If Issue No. 1 is answered in the affirmative, whether the
APERC was justified in determining the tariff for such excess energy
generated at the rate of ₹0.50 per unit?
Our Analysis and Conclusion
Issue No. 1: Whether APERC was right in prescribing a
different commercial treatment for energy generated in
excess of the energy corresponding to normative CUF?
Submissions of the RE Developers
16. The RE Developers have submitted that Articles 1.5, 2.1, 2.2 and 6.2 of the
PPAs mandate purchase of “all the Delivered Energy” at the contracted tariff.
Articles 5.1 and 5.6 provide for monthly billing and payment for such energy with
any disallowance to be notified within a reasonable time along with reasons.
Invoices are payable within 30 days from the meter-reading date. There is no
provision restricting billing or payment to the normative CUF.

17. Explanation 2 to Article 1.5 limits delivered energy to the capacity agreed for
export multiplied by the hours of operation during the billing month. While
approving the standard-form PPA by Order dated 30.03.2010 in O.P. No. 40 of
Page 42 of 65

Judgement in Appeal No. 600 of 2023 and batch

1
2010, APERC clarified that energy beyond 100% PLF would not be accounted
and paid for while observing that wind generation would never exceed 100% PLF.
APSPDCL accepted payment up to 100% PLF and cannot now introduce a CUF-
based restriction. Its contention that no CUF had then been prescribed is incorrect
since APERC had already fixed CUF at 24.5% by Order dated 01.05.2009 in O.P.
Nos. 6 and 7 of 2009.

18. CUF, like capital cost and interest cost, is a normative parameter for
determining generic tariff and not a ceiling on energy generated, delivered or
billed. Neither the applicable tariff orders nor the regulatory framework
distinguishes between energy supplied up to and beyond CUF for payment. Once
2
the tariffs of ₹4.83/ ₹4.84/ ₹4.70 per unit were determined, purchase of power
was governed by Article 2.1. Reading an implied CUF-based billing ceiling into the
PPAs is contrary to Nabha Power Limited v. Punjab State Power Corporation
Limited, (2018) 11 SCC 508 .

19. Any gain or loss arising from deviation from normative parameters is to the
account of the generator; no true-up is required. Reliance is placed on Haryana
Power Generation Corporation Limited v. Haryana Electricity Regulatory
Commission, judgment dated 31.07.2009 in Appeal Nos. 42 and 43 of 2008
and Chhattisgarh Biomass Energy Developers Association v. Chhattisgarh
State Electricity Regulatory Commission, judgment dated 29.04.2013 in

1
The terms Capacity Utilisation Factor (CUF) and Plant Load Factor (PLF) are conceptually
synonymous, both denoting the ratio of actual energy generation to the maximum energy that
could have been generated through continuous operation at the entire installed capacity during
the relevant period. In the context of wind power projects, the term CUF is generally used.

2
Different rates of generic tariff were determined by the APERC in tariff orders issued at different
points in time.
Page 43 of 65

Judgement in Appeal No. 600 of 2023 and batch

Appeal Nos. 63, 66 and 144 of 2012 . The former judgment is under challenge in
Civil Appeal No. 1358 of 2017 and batch without any stay. In Appeal No. 600 of
2023, the normative capital cost was also lower than the actual project cost and
the additional transmission-line expenditure was incurred by the Appellant.

20. Regulation 9 of the APERC Tariff Regulations, 2015 confers must-run status
on wind power plants. The Government of Andhra Pradesh’s communication dated
11.09.2018 and the MNRE directions also require procurement of the entire wind
generation without curtailment. Rule 3 of the Must Run Rules, 2021 prohibits
curtailment on commercial considerations except for grid-related technical
constraints or grid security. These provisions were placed before APERC but were
not considered in the Impugned Orders.

21. The issue is covered by National Solar Energy Federation of India v.
Tamil Nadu Electricity Regulatory Commission, judgment dated 28.11.2022
in Appeal No. 119 of 2021 (NSEFI Judgment) . This Tribunal held that normative
CUF is intended for determining generic tariff and does not regulate the quantum
of procurement where the tariff orders and agreements contain no such restriction.
TANGEDCO had consumed and commercially utilised the excess energy and was
directed to compensate the generators at 75% of the EPA tariff. The Hon’ble
Supreme Court dismissed Civil Appeal No. 1271 of 2023, TANGEDCO v. B.S.
Apparel, finding no error in this Tribunal’s order. Further submitted that these
findings rest on the absence of a contractual or regulatory restriction and are not
peculiar to solar generation.
Submissions of the DISCOMs
22. The Counsel for the DISCOMs submitted that generic tariff is determined
and payable only for annual generation at the prescribed CUF. The Tariff Order
Page 44 of 65

Judgement in Appeal No. 600 of 2023 and batch

dated 15.11.2012 prescribed 23% CUF and a levellised tariff of ₹4.70 per unit for
25 years. Regulation 21 of the 2015 Tariff Regulations prescribes 23.5% CUF, on
which the subsequent generic tariff orders are based. The WPGs governed by the
earlier 2009 Tariff Order entered into the same model PPAs, receive generic tariff
only up to annual generation at CUF and have not claimed such tariff for excess
generation.

23. The tariff calculation working sheet demonstrates that the cost of generation,
including returns, is divided by annual generation in MU at CUF. The same
generation is considered for two months’ receivables forming part of working
capital. Higher CUF would therefore lower the generic tariff. The WPGs receive
full tariff monthly until annual generation reaches the CUF limit, ordinarily covering
the wind season ending in October; billing restrictions operate thereafter when
generation is minimal.

24. The PPAs must be read harmoniously with the applicable tariff orders and
regulations which prevail in the event of inconsistency. Clause 8, Article 7 and
Article 11.2 expressly subject the PPAs to APERC’s regulatory framework and
modifications. Reliance is placed on Amplus Sun Solutions (P) Ltd. v. Haryana
Electricity Regulatory Commission, 2026 SCC OnLine APTEL 18 . Acceptance
of the generic tariff under Article 2.2 cannot be construed as agreement to pay that
tariff for generation beyond the CUF on which it was determined.

25. Explanation 2 to Article 1.5 states that delivered energy “shall be limited to”
energy calculated “based on” the capacity agreed for export and operating hours;
it does not equate delivered energy with their unrestricted product. It also
expressly excludes payment for excess energy. Since the model PPA predates the
2012 Tariff Order and the 2015 Tariff Regulations, any latent ambiguity must be
Page 45 of 65

Judgement in Appeal No. 600 of 2023 and batch

resolved by reference to that framework. Reliance is placed on Section 98 of the
Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023; Food Corporation of India v. Abhijit Paul,
(2023) 15 SCC 40; Anglo American v. MMTC, (2021) 3 SCC 308; and Bank of
India v. K. Mohandas, (2009) 5 SCC 313.

26. Further submitted that energy in excess of CUF cannot constitute “Delivered
Energy” under the PPA. Explanation II neither clarifies the manner of computing
excess energy nor provides that the entire capacity agreed for export is payable
without regard to the CUF prescribed under the applicable tariff order and
regulations.

27. The Order dated 30.03.2010 merely approved model PPAs as guidelines
before tariff determination and did not consider the applicable CUF; it cannot
override subsequent tariff orders and regulations. Further, National Solar v.
TNERC, 2022 SCC OnLine APTEL 120 , recognise that increased CUF reduces
generic tariff and that payment of full tariff beyond normative CUF would unjustly
enrich generators. Accordingly, the finding that generic tariff is not payable beyond
annual generation at CUF deserves to be upheld.
Our Analysis and Conclusion
28. At the outset, we note that the central premise underlying the reasoning in
the Impugned Order, as well as the submissions of the Discoms, is that generation
in excess of the energy corresponding to normative CUF results in ‘undue
enrichment’ of the WPGs. Before examining this premise, it would be appropriate
to briefly set out the rationale underlying the adoption of normative CUF for tariff
determination.

Page 46 of 65

Judgement in Appeal No. 600 of 2023 and batch

29. The principal cost components associated with a wind power project, such
as cost of capital, operation and maintenance expenses, interest on working
capital and depreciation, are essentially fixed costs and do not vary directly with
the quantum of electricity generated. Unlike a thermal generating station, there is
no fuel cost that varies with the actual generation of electricity. However, the tariff
is ordinarily expressed in ₹ per unit of electricity generated, as this provides a
convenient and uniform basis for payment. It is, therefore, necessary to determine
a representative level of annual generation against which the annual fixed costs
of the project can be apportioned to arrive at a per unit tariff. For this purpose, a
normative CUF is adopted, having regard to factors such as the technology
employed, the characteristics of the wind resource at the project site, the height of
the wind turbine hub and other relevant technical considerations. The annual fixed
costs, suitably levelised by applying the prescribed discounting methodology, are
then apportioned over the normative energy generation to arrive at the generic
tariff expressed in ₹ per unit.

30. It is important to appreciate that normative CUF is a benchmark adopted for
tariff determination; it is not necessarily a measure of the actual generation that a
project will achieve in a particular year. Given the variability of wind conditions,
actual generation may be either higher or lower than the generation corresponding
to normative CUF. The likelihood of actual generation precisely matching the
normative CUF is, therefore, very small. The normative CUF serves as a common
basis for determining the per unit tariff, taking into account the expected generation
over the relevant period. It does not, by itself, create two distinct categories of
energy, one up to normative CUF and the other in excess thereof thereby attracting
different payment treatment.

Page 47 of 65

Judgement in Appeal No. 600 of 2023 and batch

31. Keeping the aforesaid background in view, we now proceed to examine the
findings recorded in the Impugned Order and the contentions advanced by the
parties.

32. The WPGs have relied on the following provisions of the PPA (since all the
PPAs are similarly worded, we will use PPA of Beta Wind Farm Private Limited, or
“BWFPL” in short) to buttress their contention that there is no separate treatment
for energy generated in excess of that corresponding to CUF (for the sake of
convenience, we shall call the energy generation corresponding to normative CUF
as “normative CUF energy”):

“1.5 Delivered Energy: means, with respect to any Billing Month, the kilo watt hours
(kWh) of electrical energy generated by the Project and delivered to the DISCOM
at the Interconnection Point as defined in Article 1.10, as measured by the common
energy meter at the Interconnection Point during that Billing Month. As indicated
in the preamble, the delivered energy recorded by the common meter shall be sum
of energy delivered by all Wind power projects connected to the Pooling
Substation.

Explanation 1:……..

Explanation 2: The delivered energy in a Billing Month shall be limited to the energy
calculated based on the Capacity agreed for export to network for sale to DISCOM
as mentioned in Preamble and Schedule - 1, multiplied with number of hours and
fraction thereof the project is in operation during that billing month. In case any
excess energy is delivered no payment shall be made for the same.

Explanation 3: ……..


Page 48 of 65

Judgement in Appeal No. 600 of 2023 and batch

1.6 Due Date of Payment: means the date on which the amount payable by the
DISCOM to the Wind Power Producer hereunder for Delivered Energy, if any,
supplied during a Billing Month becomes due for payment, which date shall be
thirty (30) days from the Metering Date provided the bill is received by DISCOM
within 5 days from metering date, and in the case of any supplemental or other bill
or claim, if any, the due date of payment shall be thirty (30) days from the date of
the presentation of such bill or claim to the designated officer of the DISCOM.

…

2.1 All the Delivered Energy at the interconnection point for sale to DISCOM will
be purchased at the tariff provided for in Article 2.2 from and after the date of
Commercial Operation of the Project. Title to Delivered Energy purchased shall
pass from the Wind Power Producer to the DISCOM at the Interconnection Point.

2.2 The Wind Power Producer shall be paid tariff for energy delivered at the
interconnection point for sale to DISCOM, which shall be firm at Rs. 4.70 per unit
for a period of 25 years from the Commercial Operation Date (COD) as per APERC
order No 13/2012 dt. 15.11.2012.

…

5.1 For Delivered Energy purchased, Wind Power Producer shall furnish a bill to
the DISCOM calculated at the rate provided for in Article 2.2, in such form as may
be mutually agreed between the DISCOM and the Wind Power Producer, for the
th
billing month on or before the 5 working day following the metering date.
…
…

…


Page 49 of 65

Judgement in Appeal No. 600 of 2023 and batch

SCHEDULE 1
Particulars of the Project
(referred to in the Preamble to the Agreement)
Name of the
Location No. of Wind
Capacity of
the Project *
Energy
Converters
Project
M/s. Beta
Wind Farm
Private
Limited
Kadavkallu in Sy. Nos.
1422-1 of Cherlopalli
(V), Sy. Nos. 542, 543,
544, 545-1, 546-1, 547-
1, 548, 550 to 560 of
Chalavemula (V), Sy.
Nos. 662 to 666 of
Chintalapalli (V) & Sy.
Nos. 701 to 704 of
Chilamakur (V),,
Anantapur District,
Andhra Pradesh.
29 Nos.
50.4 MW
(28 Nos x

1.8 MW
each)

Out of 50.4 MW, 0.252 MW is for Auxiliary Consumption and 50.148 MW is for export *
to grid for sale to DISCOM.”
33. A plain reading of the definition of “Delivered Energy” in Article 1.5 of the
PPA makes it clear that it refers to the energy delivered by the Project at the
Interconnection Point, as measured by the meter. The definition does not
distinguish between normative CUF Energy and energy delivered in excess of
normative CUF Energy. In fact, none of the relevant provisions of the PPA
extracted above makes any reference to CUF or contemplates any distinction in
the commercial treatment of normative CUF Energy and energy delivered in
excess thereof.

34. A conjoint reading of Articles 2.1 and 2.2 of the PPA also indicates that the
Delivered Energy is payable in accordance with the tariff determined under the
relevant APERC Tariff Order. Article 2.2 specifies the applicable rate per unit,
Page 50 of 65

Judgement in Appeal No. 600 of 2023 and batch

though the date, Case No. and rate specified in the Tariff Order differ across the
PPAs. Article 5.1, which deals with billing, further provides for billing of the
Delivered Energy at the rate specified in Article 2.2. Thus, these provisions, when
read together, do not envisage any distinction in the tariff or payment for normative
CUF Energy and energy delivered in excess of normative CUF Energy.

35. Similarly, Schedule-I to the PPA, which sets out the particulars of the Project,
does not provide for any separate categorisation of the Project's capacity or the
energy delivered therefrom based on the applicable CUF. It specifies the installed
capacity of the Project and the capacity agreed for export to the Discom, but does
not identify any separate tranche of energy corresponding to the CUF or prescribe
any different commercial treatment for energy delivered beyond that level. A
conjoint reading of the aforesaid provisions of the PPA, therefore, supports the
contention of the WPGs that the parties did not intend to differentiate, for the
purpose of payment, between energy delivered up to normative CUF Energy and
that delivered in excess thereof.

36. One of the principal arguments advanced by the Respondents in support of
their contention that normative CUF Energy and energy delivered in excess
thereof are to be treated differently is founded on Explanation 2 to the definition of
“Delivered Energy” in Article 1.5. The Discoms have also relied upon reference to
the APERC Tariff Order in Explanation 2 under Article 2.2 of the PPA. They have
argued that, since the tariff was determined by the State Commission on the basis
of a normative CUF, any generation in excess of the corresponding normative CUF
Energy would result in unjust enrichment of the WPG. On this basis, they have
contend that the expression ‘excess energy’ in Explanation 2 must be understood
as energy generated in excess of the normative CUF Energy.

Page 51 of 65

Judgement in Appeal No. 600 of 2023 and batch

37. We are unable to accept this contention. The language of Explanation 2 is
clear and unambiguous. It prescribes the limit with reference to the Capacity
agreed for export and the number of hours in the billing period. There is no
reference whatsoever to CUF, normative generation or any annual generation
threshold in this Explanation. Nor does this Explanation or any other provision of
the PPA provides for a different tariff or payment mechanism for energy delivered
beyond CUF Energy. As we have seen in earlier part of our analysis, the Tariff
Order also does not create two distinct categories of energy, one up to normative
CUF and the other in excess thereof thereby attracting different payment
treatment. Thus, in our view, the Discoms are seeking to read into Explanation 2
a restriction based on CUF which is not to be found in its language. The
Explanation merely prescribes a monthly ceiling on the quantity of energy that can
qualify as Delivered Energy, calculated on the basis of the agreed export capacity.
It does not prescribe a CUF based ceiling, much less provide for differential
commercial treatment of energy delivered beyond CUF Energy.

38. For instance, in the case of the PPA executed by BWFPL, the Project has
an installed capacity of 50.5 MW. Schedule-I, after accounting for Auxiliary
Consumption of 0.252 MW, specifies the capacity available for export to the grid
for sale to the Discom as 50.148 MW. Accordingly, for a billing month comprising
30 days, the maximum energy computed in terms of Explanation 2 would be:
50.148 MW × 720 hours (i.e. 30 days × 24 hours)
= 36,106.56 MWh, i.e., 36,106,560 units.

39. The fact that the tariff was determined with reference to the normative CUF
cannot, by itself, justify importing that parameter into Explanation 2. The
contractual provision must be given effect to in accordance with its terms, and a
limitation which the parties have not incorporated therein cannot be read into it
Page 52 of 65

Judgement in Appeal No. 600 of 2023 and batch

merely on the ground that payment for generation beyond normative CUF Energy
may, according to the Discoms, result in an undue financial benefit to the WPG.

40. It is also relevant to bear in mind that CUF, unless the context otherwise
requires, is an annual measure of the energy generated by a generating station
expressed as a proportion of the maximum energy that could theoretically have
been generated at its installed capacity, assuming continuous utilisation of the
entire capacity throughout the year. The State Commission has also adopted a
single normative CUF for the year for the purpose of determining the generic tariff
in its Tariff Order. Thus, the normative CUF represents an average measure for
the year. Actual generation may be quite high during months when wind conditions
are favourable, while it may be negligible during certain other months. In these
circumstances, applying the annual normative CUF separately to each monthly
billing period would be conceptually inappropriate, as it would effectively treat an
annual benchmark for tariff determination as a monthly generation ceiling.

41. The reason for incorporating such a monthly ceiling in Explanation 2 is not
immediately apparent. We can, however, envisage two possible explanations.
First, these PPAs appear to belong to an early phase of wind power procurement,
when the contractual framework may have drawn upon, or adapted provisions
from PPAs originally designed for conventional generating stations, such as coal-
based generating stations. In the case of conventional generating stations, a
monthly ceiling based on the contracted export capacity multiplied by the number
of hours in the month may serve a meaningful contractual purpose. Second, it is
possible that a WPG could have allocated only a part of its installed capacity for
sale to the Discom and intended to sell the remaining capacity through open
access or other arrangements. In such a situation, the monthly ceiling based on
the capacity agreed for export to the Discom would ensure that the Discom was
Page 53 of 65

Judgement in Appeal No. 600 of 2023 and batch

not required to account for energy attributable to capacity that had not been
contracted to it. In other words, the ceiling may have been intended to restrict the
quantity of energy that could be claimed from the Discom to the extent of the
capacity actually earmarked for sale to it.

42. We need not, however, conclusively determine the precise rationale behind
Explanation 2 for the purposes of the present controversy. It is sufficient to note
that neither of these possible purposes suggests an intention to differentiate
between normative CUF Energy and energy delivered in excess thereof. In any
event, during the course of hearing, in response to a specific query from the
Bench, it was clarified that all the WPGs involved in this batch of appeals had
earmarked their entire installed capacity for sale to the respective Discoms.

43. The above discussion leads us to the conclusion that Explanation 2 to Article
1.5 read with Tariff Order of APERC does not provide any basis for drawing a
distinction between normative CUF Energy and energy delivered in excess
thereof. It merely prescribes a monthly ceiling on the quantity of energy that can
qualify as Delivered Energy, calculated with reference to the agreed export
capacity and the total number of hours in the relevant billing month. It neither
incorporates a CUF based restriction nor provides for differential commercial
treatment of energy delivered beyond normative CUF Energy. The attempt of
Discoms to derive such a distinction from Explanation 2 to Article 1.5 is not
supported by the language of the PPA. Had the parties intended to prescribe a
different commercial treatment for energy delivered in excess of normative CUF
Energy, the PPA could have expressly provided for the applicable CUF, the manner
of identifying such excess energy and the tariff or payment consequences thereof.
No such stipulation is to be found in the relevant provisions of the PPA.

Page 54 of 65

Judgement in Appeal No. 600 of 2023 and batch

44. It is noted from the Impugned Order that the APERC has read a limit on CUF
Energy into the PPA as an implied term, on the premise that the generic tariff was
determined on the basis of normative CUF and that payment for generation in
excess of CUF Energy would result in unjust enrichment of the WPG. We are
unable to agree with this conclusion.

45. Firstly, as held in the preceding paragraphs, a proper interpretation of the
relevant provisions of the PPA, read as a whole, leads to the conclusion that the
PPA does not distinguish between generation up to normative CUF Energy and
generation in excess thereof for the purpose of payment. The express terms of a
contract cannot be rewritten, nor can an additional term be introduced merely
because it is considered necessary to achieve a more equitable or commercially
desirable outcome. The Hon’ble Supreme Court has consistently held that Courts
and Tribunals must give effect to the contractual bargain and cannot make a new
bargain for the parties (Nabha Power Ltd. v. Punjab State Power Corporation
Ltd., (2018) 11 SCC 508; Haryana Power Purchase Centre v. Sasan Power
Ltd., (2024) 1 SCC 247). An implied term can be read into a contract only where
the strict legal tests for implication are satisfied; it cannot contradict, vary, or
override the express provisions of the contract. (Satya Jain v. Anis Ahmed
Rushdie, (2013) 8 SCC 131; Transmission Corpn. of Andhra Pradesh Ltd. v.
GMR Vemagiri Power Generation Ltd., (2018) 3 SCC 716) .

46. Secondly, the conclusion of unjust enrichment cannot be drawn merely by
examining one aspect of the PPA in isolation. While, at first glance, payment for
generation in excess of normative CUF Energy may appear to yield revenue
exceeding the WPG’s reasonable costs, including return on equity, the overall
contractual arrangement and the risks allocated to the WPG must also be
considered. In this regard, we note the following:
Page 55 of 65

Judgement in Appeal No. 600 of 2023 and batch

(i) The PPA contains neither a Change in Law clause nor a Force Majeure
clause. While such clauses may, depending on their terms, afford protection
to either party, they are also important risk-mitigation mechanisms for a
generator against events that may adversely affect its costs or ability to
perform its contractual obligations. The absence of such protection is
therefore a relevant consideration in assessing the overall allocation of risks
under the PPA.
(ii) Generation from a wind power project is inherently dependent on wind
availability and wind velocity, and these parameters may vary considerably
from year to year. In years when wind conditions are unfavourable, actual
generation may fall substantially below the normative CUF, for which the PPA
provides no corresponding compensation. Further, the PPA empowers the
Discom to curtail generation during system emergencies (Article 4.19 of the
PPA). If such constraints persist for a prolonged period, the WPG may be
unable to generate and deliver energy corresponding even to the normative
CUF, again without any express provision for compensation for the resulting
shortfall in revenue as compared to annual costs.
47. These considerations demonstrate that the PPA exposes the WPG to
material risks that may adversely affect its generation and revenue. The possibility
of earning revenue from generation in excess of CUF Energy cannot, therefore,
be viewed in isolation as establishing unjust enrichment. The application of the
same generic tariff to actual generation, whether below or above the normative
CUF Energy, may well have been envisaged as a means of ensuring symmetrical
commercial treatment. The contractual arrangement must be assessed as a
whole, taking into account both the potential rewards and the risks borne by the
parties.

Page 56 of 65

Judgement in Appeal No. 600 of 2023 and batch

48. It is also relevant that, under the cost-of-service-based regime prevalent
during the initial years of renewable energy development, the model PPA was
finalised by the State Commissions after publication of a draft and invitation of
comments from stakeholders. Under the present regime, in which a substantial
portion of renewable energy capacity is procured through competitive bidding
under the guidelines issued by the Central Government under Section 63 of the
Act, the process of stakeholder consultation is also followed in formulating such
guidelines. The contractual terms thus form part of a regulatory and procurement
framework within which the parties enter into their respective PPAs. If a ceiling on
payment by reference to CUF Energy was intended, it could have been expressly
incorporated into the PPA. In the absence of such a stipulation, and where the
relevant provisions, properly interpreted, do not impose such a ceiling, the State
Commission cannot introduce it as an implied term merely on the ground that
payment for generation beyond CUF Energy may confer an additional financial
benefit on the WPG. Such an approach would amount to rewriting the contractual
bargain rather than interpreting and enforcing it.

49. The Respondents have further contended that, when the PPA is read in the
context of the Tariff Order and the APERC RE Regulations, 2015, a ‘latent
ambiguity’ emerges in the definition of Delivered Energy. In support of this
contention, the Discoms have relied upon the following:
(i) The expression ‘based on’ used in Explanation 2 while prescribing the limit
on Delivered Energy. According to the Discoms, the WPGs have incorrectly
construed the expression ‘based on’ to mean ‘equal to’.
(ii) Explanation 2 provides that no payment shall be made for excess energy,
but does not separately specify the manner in which such excess energy is to
be calculated.
Page 57 of 65

Judgement in Appeal No. 600 of 2023 and batch

(iii) Article 2.2 provides that the WPG shall be paid the tariff for energy
delivered, as determined by the APERC. Since the generic tariff determined
by the APERC is based on normative CUF, the Discoms contend that the
same tariff cannot be applied to energy generated in excess of the normative
CUF.
50. We are unable to accept these contentions. Firstly, the use of the expression
‘based on’ does not, by itself, permit the introduction of an additional parameter,
such as CUF, for determining the limit on Delivered Energy. Where Explanation 2
identifies the basis for computing the limit, a further parameter, which is neither
expressly provided for in the Explanation nor otherwise discernible from the
relevant provisions of the PPA, cannot be introduced. The expression ‘based on’
cannot be construed as conferring an unrestricted discretion to add another
parameter to the contractual formula.

51. Secondly, the contention that Explanation 2 does not specify the manner of
calculating excess energy is also without merit. The first sentence of Explanation
2 prescribes the limit on Delivered Energy. Once that limit is identified, the
expression ‘excess energy’ used in the subsequent sentence has a clear and
natural meaning; it refers to energy injected in excess of the prescribed limit. There
is, therefore, no ambiguity in this regard.

52. We have already covered the third contention while analysing the rationale
of the Impugned Order about ‘unjust enrichment’. As we have already concluded,
if the intention was to prescribe a different commercial treatment for energy
generated in excess of, or below, the normative CUF, such a distinction would
have to be expressly provided for in the relevant Regulations or incorporated in
the PPA. In the absence of any such provision, the mere fact that the tariff has
been determined by reference to normative CUF cannot justify restricting its
Page 58 of 65

Judgement in Appeal No. 600 of 2023 and batch

applicability to energy corresponding to that CUF. The tariff so determined would
apply to the actual energy delivered under the PPA, whether such generation is
higher or lower than the generation corresponding to normative CUF, subject, of
course, to the other express terms and conditions of the PPA.

53. In view of the foregoing, we find no merit in the Discoms’ contention that a
latent ambiguity arises in the definition of Delivered Energy when the PPA is read
in the context of the Tariff Order and the APERC RE Regulations. Nor do we find
any basis for introducing CUF as an additional parameter for determining the limit
on Delivered Energy, as contended by the Discoms. In the absence of any
ambiguity in the contractual provisions or any demonstrated necessity to read an
additional limitation into the PPA, we see no justification for altering the contractual
arrangement. As the well known maxim attributed to Lord Falkland (1641) puts it:
“ If it is not necessary to change, it is necessary not to change”.
54. Another way of testing the correctness of a proposition is to examine its
practical and economic consequences. If the contention of the Discoms is
accepted, namely, that no payment is to be made for energy generated in excess
of the normative CUF Energy, there would be no commercial incentive for the
WPGs to continue generation once that level is reached. This would effectively
discourage the WPGs from utilising their generating assets to the extent that the
available wind resource permits. Indeed, it would create an anomalous situation in
which a WPG would have no economic incentive to generate electricity even when
wind conditions are favourable and the generating station is capable of supplying
additional energy to the grid. We find it difficult to accept that such a consequence
could have been intended by the parties, particularly when no such restriction is
expressly provided for in the PPA.
Page 59 of 65

Judgement in Appeal No. 600 of 2023 and batch

55. The judgment dated 28.11.2022 in National Solar Energy Federation of
India v. Tamil Nadu Electricity Regulatory Commission, Appeal No. 119 of
2021 and batch , supports the proposition that a normative CUF adopted for tariff
determination does not, by itself, constitute a contractual ceiling on the energy
payable and that the procurer cannot consume energy supplied beyond such CUF
without payment. We are conscious that the Tribunal, in that case, awarded
compensation at 75% of the PPA tariff by adopting the mechanism contemplated
in the Solar Bidding Guidelines dated 03.08.2017. That relief must be understood
in the context of the agreements and regulatory framework considered therein and
cannot be mechanically applied to every PPA.

56. In the present appeals, the PPAs expressly provide for payment of the
contracted tariff for all Delivered Energy, without prescribing a separate rate for
energy supplied beyond the normative CUF. Equally, no provision has been shown
which assures the generators payment for energy corresponding to the normative
CUF when their actual generation falls below that level. The generators thus bear
the consequence of lower generation while payment remains linked to the energy
actually delivered. In these circumstances, the normative CUF cannot be
selectively converted into a ceiling on payment when generation exceeds that
norm. Giving effect to the PPAs as executed, we hold that the contracted tariff is
payable for all Delivered Energy in accordance with their terms.

57. Based on the foregoing analysis of Issue No. 1, we have come to the
conclusion that APERC has erred in prescribing differential commercial treatment
to the energy generated by the WPGs in excess of energy corresponding to their
CUF.

Page 60 of 65

Judgement in Appeal No. 600 of 2023 and batch

Issue No. 2: If Issue No. 1 is answered in the affirmative, whether
the APERC was justified in determining the tariff for such excess
energy generated at the rate of ₹0.50 per unit?
Submissions of the RE Developers
58. The Counsel for the RE Developers submitted that introducing a CUF based
restriction and prescribing ₹0.50 per unit for excess generation rewrites the
express terms of the PPAs, contrary to Articles 1.5, 2.1, 2.2, 5.1 and 5.6. Reliance
is placed on Haryana Power Purchase Centre v. Sasan Power Limited, (2024)
1 SCC 247 and MSEDCL v. MERC, (2022) 4 SCC 657 , for the proposition that
express contractual rights and obligations cannot be altered by reading in a
contrary bargain.

59. In the NSEFI judgment, compensation at 75% of the EPA tariff was based
on Clause 5.2.1(b) of the Solar Bidding Guidelines dated 03.08.2017. Clause
6.2.1(b) of the Wind Bidding Guidelines, 2023 expressly contemplates purchase
of excess wind generation at the PPA tariff itself. The RE Developers accordingly
claim 100% of the contracted tariff and seek directions applicable to all affected
RE Developers.

60. Without prejudice, ReNew submitted that if a CUF-based upper limit is
upheld, the methodology under Point No. 2 and the illustration accompanying the
Impugned Order should be followed calculating CUF cumulatively at the end of
each operating year from COD.

61. The RE Developers seek release of all withheld principal amounts with
applicable late payment surcharge under Article 5.2, within four weeks, and
payment of the full PPA tariff for all delivered energy without CUF deductions
Page 61 of 65

Judgement in Appeal No. 600 of 2023 and batch

thereafter. It is submitted that granting these reliefs would not cause tariff shock to
consumers.
Submissions of the DISCOMs
62. The Counsel for the DISCOMs submitted that prescribing ₹0.50 per unit and
cumulative adjustment alters the determined tariff already committed to the public.
Such alteration requires proceedings under Sections 62 and 64 of the Electricity
Act, 2003, involving public notices, stakeholder hearings and technical analysis.
APERC could not determine compensation in the same adjudicatory proceedings
after holding that generic tariff was unavailable beyond CUF. Reliance is placed
on GUVNL v. Solar Semiconductor, (2017) 16 SCC 498 . The issue affects
approximately 220 WPGs and cannot appropriately be determined through
disputes brought by a few generators. The DISCOMs refer to I.A. No. 1743 of 2026
and W.P. Nos. 10583 of 2026, 31417 of 2025, 12472 of 2025 and 12473 of 2025
before the Andhra Pradesh High Court to demonstrate the multiplicity of
proceedings. They also refer to pending W.P. PIL No. 96 of 2021 concerning, inter
alia , issuance of tariff orders without notice. The power to amend the 2015 Tariff
Regulations and the generic tariff orders is pending before the Hon’ble Supreme
Court in Civil Appeal Nos. 10282-10295 of 2025.

63. Further submitted that the generator-intervener (ReNew Vayu Urja Pvt. Ltd.)
approached APERC only in 2025 and sought intervention before this Tribunal (IA
No. 1743 of 2026) without any order of APERC against which relief could be
sought. Any direction concerning amendment or modification of the 2015 Tariff
Regulations and the generic tariff orders is likely to be subject to the Hon’ble
Supreme Court’s determination in Civil Appeal Nos. 10282-10295 of 2025.

Page 62 of 65

Judgement in Appeal No. 600 of 2023 and batch

64. Without prejudice, ₹0.50 per unit was fixed solely because it was twice the
₹0.25 per unit incentive applicable to thermal plants. This comparison is irrelevant
as wind generation beyond CUF depends on weather rather than plant efficiency
and wind plants incur no fuel expenditure. Once generic tariff is paid up to CUF,
the WPG has no further cost or returns to recover whereas thermal plants continue
to incur fuel expenditure.

65. By Order dated 06.02.2023 in O.P. Nos. 27-34 of 2021 and batch, APERC,
after stakeholder consultation and public hearings, treated excess generation of
projects governed by the 2009 Tariff Order as inadvertent energy for which no
payment was due. The amount, if any, payable for excess energy in the present
cases should similarly be left to appropriate tariff proceedings.

66. Cumulative calculation across years is also arbitrary because tariff is
calculated, discounted and levellised annually. Carrying excess generation
forward permits payment in subsequent years for energy not actually delivered in
the concerned billing period, contrary to the tariff framework and the PPAs and
results in unjust enrichment.

67. The Counsel therefore seek setting aside of the directions prescribing ₹0.50
per unit and cumulative adjustment, while upholding the finding that generic tariff
is unavailable beyond annual generation at CUF and also seek remand to APERC
for appropriate tariff proceedings to determine what amount, if any, is payable for
such excess energy.
Our Analysis and Conclusion
68. Since we have concluded the Issue No. 1 in negative, it naturally follows that
the tariff applicable for generation in excess of the CUF energy need to be same
Page 63 of 65

Judgement in Appeal No. 600 of 2023 and batch

as generic tariff. Thus, it is unnecessary for us to get into the question of rate of
₹0.50 per unit fixed by the APERC for such excess generation.

69. We are unable to accept the DISCOMs’ submission that the matter requires
remand to the State Commission for determination of the amount payable for
energy supplied beyond the normative CUF. Our conclusions neither amend the
applicable Tariff Regulations or generic tariff orders nor alter the contractual
bargain embodied in the PPAs. We have interpreted and given effect to the existing
provisions requiring payment of the contracted tariff for all Delivered Energy
without introducing any additional restriction or prescribing a separate tariff for
energy supplied beyond the normative CUF. It is the Impugned Orders which
introduce such a distinction in payment.

70. Consequently, no fresh tariff determination is required and no ground for
remand is made out. The pendency of Civil Appeal Nos. 10282-10295 of 2025,
concerning the State Commission’s power to amend or modify the 2015 Tariff
Regulations and the generic tariff orders thereunder, as pointed out by the
DISCOMs, does not warrant a different course, since we have neither exercised
nor pronounced upon that power. Our determination is confined to enforcement of
the existing PPAs and is without prejudice to the issues pending before the Hon’ble
Supreme Court.

71. We are conscious that, in view of the conclusions and directions contained
in this judgment, the WPGs would become entitled to payment of amounts withheld
towards energy supplied beyond the normative CUF. Accordingly, such amounts
shall be paid together with the applicable interest in accordance with the relevant
provision of the respective PPA.

Page 64 of 65

Judgement in Appeal No. 600 of 2023 and batch

ORDER

For the foregoing reasons as stated above, we are of the considered view that
the Impugned Orders in the captioned Batch of Appeals suffered from an error to
the extent that APERC decided to prescribe a different commercial treatment to
the energy generated in excess of that corresponding to normative CUF. The
consequential directions of the APERC, including calculation of CUF at the end
of each year cumulatively, and fixation of incentive of ₹0.50 per unit for energy
generated in excess of that corresponding to normative CUF are set aside. We
accordingly direct that the energy generated by the wind power generator shall
be paid as per applicable generic tariff, irrespective of whether or not the actual
generation in the year is more than that corresponding to normative CUF.
The amounts payable pursuant to this judgment shall carry applicable interest in
accordance with the relevant provision of the respective PPA.
The Captioned Appeal and pending IAs, if any, are disposed of in the above terms.
th
PRONOUNCED IN THE OPEN COURT ON THIS 17 DAY OF NOVEMBER,
2026.

(Ajay Talegaonkar)
(Virender Bhat)
Judicial Member

REPORTABLE / NON-REPORTABLE
Technical Member
mg/kns/mkj/kks
Page 65 of 65