Chitra vs C. Natarajan

Court
Supreme Court

1
2026 INSC 781
Non-Reportable
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
Civil Appeal No.9774of 2026
[ @ Special Leave Petition (C) No.28911 of 2025 ]
CHITRA & ANR. ….APPELLANTS
Versus
C. NATARAJAN ….RESPONDENT
O R D E R
Leave granted.
2. The appellant, the defendant in a suit for recovery of
money is aggrieved by the impugned order, which
permitted amendment of the plaint at the appellate stage,
when the suit was dismissed on that principal aspect,
which is now sought to be brought in by way of
amendment. The District Court, in which the appeal was
pending, rejected the application by Annexure A5.
3. The appellant, a partnership firm, through its
Manager, filed a plaint for recovery of money asserting
Signature Not Verified
Digitally signed by
VISHAL ANAND
Date: 2026.08.01
11:43:47 IST
Reason:
that the first defendant had purchased a motor vehicle
under a higher purchase agreement from the plaintiff and
Page 1 of 4

2
had committed default of the amounts due. The specific
contention in the plaint was that the defendant purchased
a vehicle numbered as TN-31-K-9533. The suit was
dismissed inter alia on the ground that, while in the suit
the registration number was noticed as above, in the
agreement the registration number was TN-31-F-9533. The
suit was dismissed by Annexure P3 dated 27.03.2015.
4. An appeal was filed as A.S. No.96 of 2015 much later,
in the year 2016. The subject IA was filed seeking
amendment of the plaint. The Principal District Judge,
Salem, according to us, rightly dismissed the application
finding that Order VI Rule 17 does not apply, specifically
referring to the decision of this Court in Rajkumar
Gurawara (dead ) Thr. Lrs. v. S.K. Sarwagi & Co. Pvt. Ltd.
1
and Anr. This Court on an interpretation found Order VI
Rule 17 permits pre-trial amendments liberally than those
which are sought after commencement of the trial. While
the first part of the rule makes it abundantly clear that at
any stage of proceedings, parties are free to alter and
amend their pleadings so as to bring forth the real
questions in controversy; it is subject to the proviso, which
1 (2008) 14 SCC 364
Page 2 of 4

3
restricts amendment after the trial has commenced to be
allowed only if the Court comes to the conclusion that, in
spite of due diligence, the party could not have raised the
matter before the commencement of trial.
5. With this principle in mind, we look at the facts of the
present case. The order of the District Judge, Salem,
Annexure A4 rejecting the IA, observes that the notice
issued by the appellant also indicated the registration
number as TN-31-K-9533. The reply notice issued by the
respondent specifically pointed out that there was no
purchase of such a vehicle and they had purchased only
TN-31-F-9533, despite which the plaint was filed with a
different number. The loan transaction was also denied.
Definitely before commencement of trial, the mistake
could have been corrected, as a matter of right.
6. As noticed above the proviso to Order VI Rule 17
specifically speaks of amendment after commencement of
trial to be permitted only if the party, despite having
exercised due diligence, could not have raised the matter
before the commencement of trial. In the present case, it
is sheer carelessness, which the plaintiff has to necessarily
Page 3 of 4

4
suffer. Even if an application was filed after
commencement of trial, the Court could not have
concluded as per the proviso. In that circumstance, there is
no question of amendment after the suit itself stood
dismissed. True, the appeal is a continuation of the original
proceeding but insofar as amendment, Order VI Rule 17
regulates the matter and puts the claim of the
plaintiff/appellant in peril.
7. We find absolutely no reason to sustain the impugned
order and set aside the same. The First Appeal is said to be
pending before the Principal District Judge, Salem which
shall be considered on its merits.
8. The civil appeal stands allowed with the above
observations.
9. Pending application(s), if any, shall stand disposed of.
.……………………………... J.
(J. B. PARDIWALA)
..………….…………………. J.
(K. VINOD CHANDRAN)
NEW DELHI;
JULY 28, 2026.
Page 4 of 4