MS. ANUSHKA BASAVARAJ MAIDUR D/O BASAVARAJ H MAIDUR vs NATIONAL TESTING AGENCY (NTA)

Court
Karnataka High Court

- 1 -
WP No. 107041 of 2026


Reserved on : 28.10.2026
Pronounced on : 19.11.2026

IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT DHARWAD


R

TH
DATED THIS THE 19 DAY OF NOVEMBER, 2026

PRESENT

THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE M.NAGAPRASANNA
AND

THE HON'BLE MRS JUSTICE HEMA KULKARNI

WRIT PETITION NO.107041 OF 2026 (EDN-EX)


BETWEEN:

MS. ANUSHKA BASAVARAJ MAIDUR,
D/O. BASAVARAJ H. MAIDUR,
AGED ABOUT 20 YEARS,
RESIDING AT D.NO. 216,
KHB COLONY, MEDLERI ROAD,
RANIBENNUR, HAVERI DISTRICT,
KARNATAKA – 581 115.






…PETITIONER
(BY SRI. SHIVANAND MALASHETTI &
SRI. GIRISH KUMAR R., ADVOCATES)

AND:

1. NATIONAL TESTING AGENCY (NTA),
FIRST FLOOR, NSIC MDBP BUILDING,
OKHLA INDUSTRIAL ESTATE,
NEW DELHI – 110 020,
REPRESENTED BY ITS DIRECTOR GENERAL.

2. NATIONAL MEDICAL COMMISSION (NMC),
POCKET 14, SECTOR 8, DWARKA,
PHASE - 1, NEW DELHI – 110 077,
REPRESENTED BY ITS SECRETARY.

3. MEDICAL COUNSELLING COMMITTEE (MCC),
DIRECTORATE GENERAL OF HEALTH SERVICES,
NIRMAN BHAWAN, NEW DELHI – 110 108,
REPRESENTED BY ITS DIRECTOR.




Digitally signed
by RAKESH S
HARIHAR
Location: High
Court of
Karnataka,
Dharwad Bench

- 2 -
WP No. 107041 of 2026

4. STATE OF KARNATAKA,
DEPARTMENT OF MEDICAL EDUCATION,
M.S. BUILDING, DR. AMBEDKAR VEEDHI,
BENGALURU – 560 001,
REPRESENTED BY ITS PRINCIPAL SECRETARY.

5. KARNATAKA EXAMINATIONS AUTHORITY (KEA),
TH
18 CROSS, SAMPIGE ROAD,
MALLESHWARAM, BENGALURU – 560 012,
REPRESENTED BY ITS EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR.
…RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI. ARAVIND KAMAT, ASGI FOR
SRI. MRUTYUNJAYA HALLIKERI, ADVOCATE FOR R1 & R3;
SRI. ANOOP DESHPANDE, ADVOCATE FOR R2;
SMT. GIRIJA S. HIREMATH, HCGP FOR R4;
SMT. SURABHI KULKARNI, ADVOCATE FOR R5)

THIS WRIT PETITION IS FILED UNDER ARTICLES 226 AND 227 OF
THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA, PRAYING TO CALL FOR THE ENTIRE
RECORDS PERTAINING TO THE UFM PROCEEDINGS INITIATED AGAINST
THE PETITIONER UNDER FILE NO.19/NTA/NEET (UG)/2026, INCLUDING
THE CENTRE REPORT, AUDIT MATERIAL, COMMITTEE PROCEEDINGS,
RECOMMENDATION AND FINAL DECISION, IF ANY. TO ISSUE A WRIT OF
CERTIORARI OR ANY OTHER APPROPRIATE WRIT, ORDER, OR DIRECTION
QUASHING THE SHOW CAUSE NOTICE DATED 17.06.2026 VIDE
ANNEXURE A1. TO ISSUE A WRIT OF CERTIORARI OR ANY OTHER
APPROPRIATE WRIT, ORDER OR DIRECTION QUASHING THE ACTION OF
RESPONDENT NOS. 2 AND 3 REFLECTED IN THE NEET (UG) 2026 SCORE
CARD DATED 16/07/2026, VIDE ANNEXURE-A, INSOFAR AS THE
PETITIONER’S RESULT IS MARKED RESULT WITHHELD/R/W, AND QUASH
ANY CONSEQUENTIAL ORDER OR DECISION WITHHOLDING THE
PETITIONER’S RESULT. TO ISSUE A WRIT OF MANDAMUS OR ANY OTHER
APPROPRIATE WRIT, ORDER, OR DIRECTION COMMANDING RESPONDENT
NO. 1 (NTA) TO IMMEDIATELY AND UNCONDITIONALLY RELEASE THE
WITHHELD RESULT AND THE ORIGINAL SCORECARD OF THE PETITIONER
FOR THE NEET (UG) 2026 RE-EXAMINATION (ROLL NO. 2720104005). TO
ISSUE A WRIT OF MANDAMUS DIRECTING RESPONDENTS 2, 3, 4, AND 5
TO PERMIT THE PETITIONER TO REGISTER FOR AND PARTICIPATE IN THE
ONGOING UNDERGRADUATE MEDICAL COUNSELING FOR THE ACADEMIC
YEAR 2026-27 BASED ON HER LAWFULLY SECURED SCORE OF 570
MARKS AND ETC.


THIS WRIT PETITION HAVING BEEN HEARD AND RESERVED ON
28.10.2026, COMING ON FOR PRONOUNCEMENT THIS DAY
M.NAGAPRASANNA J., MADE THE FOLLOWING:-

- 3 -
WP No. 107041 of 2026

CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE M.NAGAPRASANNA
AND
HON'BLE MRS JUSTICE HEMA KULKARNI

CAV ORDER
(PER: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE M.NAGAPRASANNA )


The petitioner, a participant in the NEET (UG) examination
for the academic year 2026, is before this Court seeking the
following prayer:
a) Call for the entire records pertaining to the UFM
proceedings initiated against the Petitioner under File
No.19/NTA/NEET (UG)/2026, including the centre
report, audit material, committee proceedings,
recommendation and final decision, if any.


b) ISSUE a writ of Certiorari or any other appropriate writ,
order, or direction quashing the Show Cause Notice
dated 17.06.2026 Vide Annexure A1 .


c) Issue a writ of certiorari or any other appropriate writ,
order or direction quashing the action of respondent
Nos.2 and 3 reflected in the NEET (UG) 2026 Score Card
dated 16/07/2026, vide Annexure - A , insofar as the
Petitioner’s result is marked ‘RESULT WITHHELD/R/W’,
and quash any consequential order or decision
withholding the petitioner’s result.

d) ISSUE a writ of Mandamus or any other appropriate
writ, order, or direction commanding Respondent No. 1
(NTA) to immediately and unconditionally release the
withheld result and the original scorecard of the
petitioner for the NEET (UG) 2026 Re-examination (Roll
No.2720104005).


e) ISSUE a Writ of Mandamus directing respondents 2, 3,
4, and 5 to permit the petitioner to register for and
participate in the ongoing undergraduate medical
counseling for the academic year 2026-27 based on her
lawfully secured score of 570 marks.

- 4 -
WP No. 107041 of 2026



f) PASS any such other and further orders as this Hon’ble
Court deems fit and proper in the facts and
circumstances of the case, in the absolute interest of
justice, equity, and good conscience.

2. Heard Sri Shivanand Malashetti and Sri Girish Kumar R.,
learned counsel for the petitioner, Sri Arvind Kamath, learned
Additional Solicitor General of India for Sri Mrutyunjaya Hallikeri,
learned counsel for respondent Nos.1 and 3, Sri Anoop
Deshpande, learned counsel for respondent No.2, Smt. Girija S.
Hiremath, learned High Court Government Pleader for
respondent No.4 and Smt. Surabhi Kulkarni, learned counsel for
respondent No.5.
3. Shorn of details, facts germane, are as follows:

The genesis of the lis, lies in the events surrounding
the conduct, cancellation and subsequent re-conduct of
the National Eligibility-cum-Entrance Test
(Undergraduate) – NEET (UG), 2026. The petitioner, an
aspiring medical student, initially appears for NEET (UG), 2026,
conducted on 03.05.2026, (hereinafter referred to as ‘the
scrapped examination’ for the sake of brevity). The said
examination, however, becomes a casualty of a widespread

- 5 -
WP No. 107041 of 2026

leakage of question papers, resulting in its cancellation in its
entirety. The examination thus stood obliterated, necessitating a
fresh examination to restore the sanctity of the selection
process.
3.1. Consequent upon such cancellation, a public
notification comes to be issued on 15.05.2026, announcing the
conduct of a re-examination on 21.06.2026. The petitioner, like
every other eligible aspirant, is issued a fresh admit card bearing
a different roll number, entitling her to participate in the re-
examination. Curiously, after about three days of issuance of the
fresh admit card, a show cause notice comes to be issued to the
petitioner on 17.06.2026, alleging that the petitioner had carried
a mobile phone into the examination premises during the
examination conducted on 03.05.2026, an examination which, by
then, had already been scrapped / shelved.
3.2. The petitioner, armed with a valid admit card and
possessing the requisite eligibility, appears for the re-
examination conducted on 21.06.2026. Thereafter, on
25.06.2026, an Unfair Means Committee, constituted to examine
the alleged irregularities and illegalities that had marred the

- 6 -
WP No. 107041 of 2026

scrapped examination, is convened. Upon conclusion of the
proceedings before the Committee, the results of the
re-examination come to be declared on 16.07.2026. While the
results of other candidates see the light of day, the result of the
petitioner alone is withheld ostensibly on the strength of the
allegation pertaining to the earlier, cancelled examination.
3.3. The petitioner addresses repeated representations to
the authorities seeking declaration of her result. Those
representations, however, fall on deaf ears. Neither is the result
released nor is the petitioner afforded the relief sought. It is in
these circumstances that the petitioner knocks at the doors of
this Court, calling in question the adverse remarks reflected in
the scorecard of the re-examination, the show cause notice
issued against her and seeking such other consequential reliefs
as would secure her entitlement in law.
4. This Court, noticing the peculiar circumstances obtaining
in the case at hand and the fact that the counselling process was
already underway, by an interim order dated 08.09.2026,
permits the petitioner to participate in the ongoing counselling
process. The said indulgence, however, is hedged with the

- 7 -
WP No. 107041 of 2026

express condition that the petitioner shall not claim any equity
on the strength of such participation, in the event the petition
were to be dismissed. The case is thus heard.
SUBMISSIONS:

PETITIONER:
5. Sri Shivanand Malashetti and Sri Girish Kumar, learned
counsel appearing for the petitioner would vehemently contend
that the petitioner is a student whose merit has now spoken for
itself. In the re-examination conducted on 21.06.2026, the
petitioner has secured high marks, earned a seat purely on merit
at the Belagavi Institute of Medical Sciences and has been
pursuing her medical education for the past one month. He
would submit that an allegation of resorting to unfair means in
an examination which has been completely scrapped cannot be
permitted to cast its shadow upon an entirely fresh examination,
much less eclipse the merit demonstrated by the petitioner
therein.
5.1. He would contend that the very concept of unfair
means must be understood in the context of the unfair
advantage that a candidate seeks to secure over others in a

- 8 -
WP No. 107041 of 2026

competitive examination. An unfair means allegation, according
to him, must bear a rational nexus to the examination in which
an unfair advantage is alleged to have been obtained. Where the
examination itself has been cancelled in its entirety, the question
of the petitioner deriving any advantage in marks or stealing a
march over other candidates in that examination would pale into
insignificance. An examination which has been effaced from the
reckoning cannot, according to the learned counsel, be
resurrected solely for the purpose of visiting the petitioner with a
penalty that would destroy her prospects in a subsequent and
independent examination.
5.2. He would further submit that even the least of the
penalties contemplated under the Information Bulletin cannot be
imposed mechanically, without a determination of culpability in
accordance with law. The withholding of the petitioner's result,
he would contend, is itself a unilateral and ex parte exercise,
undertaken without a reasoned determination of the allegation or
its consequences. The authorities, according to him, have chosen
to impose a penalty first and determine its justification later,
thereby turning the elementary principles of fairness on their
head. The consequence is that merit, which ought to be the

- 9 -
WP No. 107041 of 2026

governing consideration in admission to professional education,
is made to yield to an allegation emanating from an examination
that no longer survives. He would therefore, seek interference at
the hands of this Court.
RESPONDENTS - The LEARNED ADDITIONAL SOLICITOR
GENERAL OF INDIA:
6. Per contra , Sri Arvind Kamath, learned Additional
Solicitor General of India appearing for respondent Nos.1 and 3 –
National Testing Agency, would stoutly defend the impugned
action. Drawing the attention of this Court to the Information
Bulletin governing NEET (UG), 2026, particularly the provisions
defining unfair means , he would submit that the prohibition
against carrying a mobile phone into the examination premises is
categorical and admits of no exception. The very act of carrying
a prohibited electronic device, according to him, constitutes an
unfair means practice, irrespective of whether the candidate is
ultimately shown to have derived any actual advantage
therefrom. The prohibition, he would contend, is intended to
preserve the purity, integrity and credibility of an examination in

- 10 -
WP No. 107041 of 2026

which lakhs of aspiring students compete for a limited number of
medical seats.
6.1. The learned Additional Solicitor General of India would
further contend that the consequences prescribed for resorting to
unfair means cannot be diluted merely because the petitioner
has subsequently performed well in the re-examination. The
least of the penalties contemplated under the governing
framework, according to him, is withholding of the result, and
the petitioner cannot seek immunity from the consequences of
her conduct by placing reliance upon her subsequent academic
performance. Merit, however commendable, cannot become a
shield against the operation of the rules governing examination
discipline.
6.2. The learned Additional Solicitor General of India would
also place considerable emphasis upon the interim order passed
by this Court on 08.09.2026. He would submit that the
permission granted to the petitioner to participate in the
counselling process was expressly made subject to the condition
that no equities would be claimed in the event the petition were
to fail. The petitioner, having accepted the benefit of the interim

- 11 -
WP No. 107041 of 2026

order subject to such a condition, cannot now seek to convert
her admission into an indefeasible right merely because the
petitioner has secured a merit seat and commenced attending
classes. An interim indulgence, he would submit, cannot be
permitted to mature into a substantive entitlement contrary to
the governing regulations.
6.3. To fortify these submissions, the learned Additional
Solicitor General would place reliance upon the celebrated
judgment of the Apex Court in Tata Cellular v. Union of India
reported in (1994) 6 SCC 651 , wherein the Apex Court has
delineated the contours of judicial review of administrative action
and reiterated that the Court, in exercise of such jurisdiction, is
ordinarily concerned with the legality of the decision-making
process rather than substituting its own decision for that of the
competent authority. He would particularly emphasize the
principles of Wednesbury reasonableness, contending that unless
the action of the authority is demonstrated to be vitiated by
illegality, irrationality or procedural impropriety, judicial
interference would be unwarranted.

- 12 -
WP No. 107041 of 2026

6.4. The learned Additional Solicitor General of India would
thus submit that the action of the National Testing Agency is
neither arbitrary nor capricious, but is founded upon the express
stipulations of the Information Bulletin, which bind every
candidate participating in the examination. The petitioner, having
allegedly breached those stipulations, cannot seek a dispensation
founded upon sympathy or subsequent merit. On these
premises, the learned Additional Solicitor General of India would
seek dismissal of the petition.
7. We have given our anxious consideration to the
submissions made by the respective learned counsel for the
parties and have perused the material on record.
CONSIDERATION:
UNFOLDING OF EVENTS:
8. The afore-narrated facts are not in the realm of
controversy. They are borne out by the record and speak for
themselves. The genesis of the present controversy lies in the
examination conducted on 03.05.2026, which subsequently
stood scrapped in its entirety. The petitioner is alleged to have
carried a mobile phone into the examination premises, an act

1 of 2026
- 13 -

WP No. 107041

ng Agency,
which, according
to respondent No.1 – National Testin
, 2026.
runs contrary to t
the instructions governing NEET (UG),
26 became
9. The ex
xamination conducted on 03.05.202
f question
embroiled in wi
idespread allegations of leakage o
authorities
papers and oth
her malpractices, compelling the
y. A press
themselves to ca
ancel the examination in its entirety
ncing such
release dated 12
2.05.2026 came to be issued annou
ny efficacy
cancellation. Thu
s, the examination ceased to have a
tlement to
for the purpose
of determining merit, rank or entit
as follows:
admission. The p
ress release dated 12.05.2026 reads a





- 14 -

1 of 2026

WP No. 107041

9.1. The ca
ancellation of the examination was fol
lowed by a
public notification
n dated 15.05.2026, announcing the
conduct of
a fresh examin
nation on 21.06.2026. The notific
cation was
intended to affo
rd all eligible aspirants a fresh oppo
ortunity to
demonstrate the
eir merit in an examination untaint
ed by the
irregularities that
t had consumed in the earlier examin
nation. The
public notification
n reads as follows:

- 15 -

1 of 2026

WP No. 107041




Both the
afore-quoted communications ema
nate from
respondent No.1
– National Testing Agency. The cons
sequence is
unmistakable. Th
he examination conducted on 03.05.2
2026 stood
cancelled and a
fresh examination was notified for 2
1.06.2026.
In furtherance o
of the notification, the petitioner wa
s issued a
fresh admit card,
, bearing a different roll number, perm
mitting her
to participate in t
the re-examination.
10. It is a
at this juncture that the sequence
of events
assumes signific
ance. After issuing the fresh admit
card, the
National Testing
Agency chose to issue a show ca
use notice
dated 17.06.202
26, alleging that the petitioner had
carried a
mobile phone
into the premises during the ex
xamination
conducted on 03.
.05.2026. The allegation thus, had its
roots in an
examination whi
ch, by then, had already been canc
celled. The
show cause noti
ce was issued barely four days befo
ore the re-
examination, at
a time when the petitioner, like ev
very other
aspirant, was ex
xpected to devote her undivided at
ttention to

- 16 -

1 of 2026

WP No. 107041

prepare for an e
examination that could determine the
e course of
her academic futu
ure.
11. The ju
xtaposition of these events is strikin
ng. On the
one hand, the Na
ational Testing Agency issued a fresh
admit card
recognising the
petitioner's eligibility to participate
in the re-
examination; on
the other, it initiated proceedings fou
unded upon
an alleged infrac
tion committed in the scrapped exam
mination by
the said show
cause notice. The show cause no
tice dated
17.06.2026, read
ds as follows:

- 17 -

1 of 2026

WP No. 107041

11.1. Arme
ed with the fresh admit card, the
petitioner
appeared for th
he re-examination conducted on 2
1.06.2026.
There is no alleg
gation placed on record of the petitio
ner having
resorted to any
unfair means in the said re-examin
nation. Her
participation was
s pursuant to the admit card issue
ed by the
National Testing A
Agency itself. The admit card reads as
s follows:

11.2. On th
he very day of the re-examination, r
respondent
No.1 addressed
an electronic mail (e-mail) to the
petitioner,
intimating that t
the Unfair Means Committee, which h
had earlier
been scheduled
to convene on 20.06.2026, wou
ld instead
convene on 25
5.06.2026. The reason assigned
for such

- 18 -
WP No. 107041 of 2026

adjournment was the re-examination scheduled for 21.06.2026.
The time for submission of the petitioner's reply was extended
up to 03:00 p.m., on 24.06.2026. What is of further significance
is that, the very same communication directed the petitioner to
treat paragraph 2 of the show cause notice dated 17.06.2026 as
blank, the said paragraph having been incorporated, according to
the Agency, on account of a typographical error. Thus, even the
show cause notice, which was to become the foundation of the
proceedings against the petitioner, required correction by the
issuing authority itself. The e-mail communication reads as
follows:
“Please refer to the trailing email. It is submitted that
Paragraph 2 of the Show Cause Notice issued vide this office
Letter No. 19/NTA/NEET (UG) 2026 dated 17 June 2026 may
kindly be treated as "Blank", as the same was inadvertently
included in the notice due to a typographical error.
This is to inform you that the meeting of the UFM
Committee for the NEET UG Examination which was
scheduled on 20 June 2026 at 04:00 P.M, to examine
your case, was adjourned in view of the NEET UG re-
examination scheduled on 21 June 2026. Accordingly,
the meeting has been rescheduled to 25 June 2026.
Therefore, you are hereby informed that the deadline
for submission of your reply to the Show Cause Notice
sued to you vide our email dated 17 June 2026 has
been extended up to 24 June 2026 at 03:00 P.M.
You are requested to ensure that your reply to the
aforesaid Show Cause Notice reaches this office
through your registered email address not later than
24 June 2026 at 03:00 P.M.

- 19 -
WP No. 107041 of 2026

Thanks & Regards,
Office of Director Exam
National Testing Agency”
(Emphasis added)

The afore-quoted communication is of some consequence.
It demonstrates that the proceedings initiated against the
petitioner were not free from procedural irregularity even at their
inception. An allegation contained in the show cause notice had
to be withdrawn as an inadvertent inclusion. The Committee's
proceedings were rescheduled owing to the conduct of the re-
examination. The petitioner was consequently required to
respond to an allegation arising from the cancelled examination
almost contemporaneously with her participation in the fresh
examination.
12. The Unfair Means Committee thereafter convened on
25.06.2026 and proceeded to take an ex parte decision to
withhold the petitioner's result in the re-examination. The
decision, therefore, visited the petitioner with an immediate
adverse consequence, not in relation to the examination in which
the alleged infraction had occurred, but in relation to the
subsequent examination in which the petitioner had participated
pursuant to a fresh admit card.

- 20 -
WP No. 107041 of 2026

13. Upon declaration of the results on 16.07.2026, the
petitioner's scorecard carried the remark "RESULT WITHHELD
(R/W)" . The petitioner, confronted with the prospect of losing an
academic year notwithstanding her participation in the re-
examination, submitted a representation on 17.07.2026 seeking
release of her result. That representation was followed by several
others, all imploring the authorities to reconsider the decision.
14. In the representation dated 17.07.2026, the petitioner
specifically complained of the overlapping timelines of the show
cause proceedings and the re-examination, the alleged absence
of any unfair advantage, the error in the show cause notice
subsequently acknowledged by the Agency itself, and the
disproportionate consequences of withholding the result of an
examination in which no malpractice was alleged. The
representation reads as follows:

“Respected Sir,

My name is Anushka Basavaraj Maidur. I am writing to you in
deep distress regarding my NEET UG 2026 results declared
on 16.07.2026. My official scorecard has been generated with
the remarks "RESULT WITHHELD (R/W).

I have already filed urgent grievances on the CPGRAMS
portal (Registration Nos:DSEHE/E/2026/0013215) My portal
and results have been blocked due to an ex-parte Unfair

- 21 -
WP No. 107041 of 2026

Means (UFM) decision dated June 25th, which I was unable
to defend against due to severe administrative overlaps.

I humbly request your immediate personal
intervention to review my case based on the following
critical facts:

Violations of Natural Justice (Overlapping Timeline):
The Show Cause Notice was issued on June 17, with a
June 24 deadline and a June 25 hearing. This crucial
window directly overlapped with my intense
preparation and total study lockdown for the sudden,
nationwide Re-Exam held on June 21. Passing a
career-ending ex-parte decision without ensuring the
student was practically able to represent themselves is
highly unfair.

The May 3rd Exam Was Cancelled. The alleged
infraction occurred during the May 3rd examination,
which the Ministry of Education has officially cancelled
and declared legally void nationwide. Punishing my
honest, clean, and highly secure June 21st re-exam
performance for an alleged event in a cancelled exam
is entirely disproportionate.

Errors in NTA's Notice: The initial Show Cause Notice issued
to me falsely accused me of being involved in a "CBI
Investigation." NTA subsequently had to retract this via
email, admitting it was a "typographical error" and
instructing me to treat that paragraph as blank.
Sir, with medical counseling registrations rapidly
approaching, keeping my clean June 21st re-exam
performance withheld will cause irreparable damage to my
future and cost me an academic year.

I beg you to kindly review my CPGRAMS file, condone the
delay in my response caused by the overlapping exam dates,
and provisionally release my June 21st scorecard. I have
attached my withheld scorecard, my June 21st admit card,
and the relevant NTA email correspondences for your urgent
reference.
Thank you for your time, justice, and compassionate
consideration.

Yours faithfully,
Anushka Basavaraj Maidur

- 22 -
WP No. 107041 of 2026

Application No: 260410446933
Re-Exam Roll No: 2720104005”

(Emphasis added)

The anguish expressed in the representation is not
difficult to comprehend. For an aspiring medical student,
the declaration of an examination result is not a mere
administrative formality. It is the culmination of years of
preparation and the gateway to a professional career.
15. The petitioner thereafter, submitted a detailed reply on
19.07.2026, seeking condonation of the delay in reply to the
show cause notice. It reads as follows:
“Roll No: 2720104005.
Application number :260410446933
Respected Chairperson and Members of the NTA Unfair
Means Committee,

I am writing to formally submit my explanation regarding the
Unfair Means (UFM) case registered against me during the
NEET-UG examination held on May 3, 2026. I most humbly
request the Committee to condone the delay in my
submission and evaluate the true facts of the case outlined
below on merit, in order to protect my academic future.

1. Justification for the Delayed Submission
The formal Show-Cause Notice was issued via email on June
17, 2026, setting a reply deadline of June 24, 2026. At that
exact time, I was undergoing immense mental stress and
anxiety preparing for the sudden, official NTA Re-
Examination scheduled for June 21, 2026. Because my entire
focus was single-mindedly dedicated to preparing for this
high-stakes re-test, I inadvertently failed to check my digital

- 23 -
WP No. 107041 of 2026

correspondence during that week. I request the Committee
to take a compassionate view of this delay, given that I was
actively preparing for an exam conducted by your agency.

2. Actual Facts Concerning the Mobile Phone
Regarding the incident on May 3, 2026, I wish to place the
absolute truth before the Committee:

•
Inadvertent Oversight: The mobile phone was left in
my pocket purely due to extreme panic, rush, and
severe examination anxiety during entry. I
completely forgot to turn it off or deposit it outside
the hall.
•
Absolute Non-Usage: The device remained completely
untouched inside my pocket during the test. I did not
access any digital materials, websites, or
communication networks, nor did I intend to.
•
Immediate Return of Device: Upon detection, the
center authorities checked the device, verified that
no active cheating or digital malpractice had taken
place, and did not find any Incriminating activity.
Consequently, they safely returned the mobile phone
to me immediately after the examination hours
without any physical seizure or police complaint.

3. Crucial Context: Third Consecutive NEET Attempt
I most humbly request the Committee to note that this is my
third consecutive year attempting the NEET-UG examination.
I have dedicated multiple years of gruelling hard work,
emotional energy, and financial resources toward fulfilling my
dream of a medical career [skills: load]. Knowing the severe
consequences of malpractice, I would never consciously or
intentionally jeopardize my three years of hard work by
trying to use a mobile phone in a strictly monitored hall. This
incident was a tragic, accidental byproduct of severe exam
pressure.

4. Critical Time Constraint: Karnataka NEET Counselling
I wish to bring an matter of extreme urgency to the attention
of the Committee. The Karnataka Examination Authority
(KEA) is scheduled to commence the Karnataka State NEET
Counselling registration this upcoming Friday.
Without the declaration of my score, I am entirely barred
from registering for the state counselling process. Missing
this registration deadline will permanently eliminate my
chances of securing an MBBS/BDS seat in my home state for

- 24 -
WP No. 107041 of 2026

this academic year, completely invalidating years of
preparation.

5. Direct Prayer to the Committee
My performance for the re-examination held on June 21,
2026, is currently marked as "Withheld" pending your final
decision. Since the May 3 examination was already cancelled
nationally and no actual cheating took place on my part, I
pray that the Committee:

1. Condones the procedural delay in submitting this
response.
2. Refrains from imposing any career-ending multi-year
debarment.
3. Directs the immediate release of my withheld June 21,
2026 re-examination result on merit before Friday so that I
do not lose my eligibility for the Karnataka State
Counselling.”
(Emphasis added)

In the reply, the petitioner attributed the delay due to the
extraordinary circumstances surrounding the sudden re-
examination and the anxiety attendant upon preparing for it. In
the explanation, the petitioner did not dispute the presence of
the mobile phone in her pocket during the examination
conducted on 03.05.2026. The petitioner, however, asserted that
its presence was wholly inadvertent, occasioned by examination
anxiety and the rush at the time of entering the examination
premises. The petitioner categorically denied having used the
device for accessing any material, communicating with any
person or securing an unfair advantage. It was further asserted
that the examination centre authorities had examined the device,

- 25 -
WP No. 107041 of 2026

found no incriminating activity and returned it to her without
seizure or registration of any complaint.
16. These assertions are, of course, the petitioner's
defence and cannot, merely by their narration, be elevated to
findings of fact. They nevertheless constitute material
circumstances which the competent authority was required to
consider while determining the nature of the alleged infraction
and the consequences that ought to follow.
17. The petitioner further pleaded that this was her third
consecutive attempt at NEET (UG), that the petitioner devoted
years of preparation to securing admission to a medical
institution and that the withholding of her result would render
those efforts futile. The petitioner sought condonation of delay,
reconsideration of the allegation and release of the result of the
re-examination.
18. The explanation brings into sharp focus the distinction
between the allegation of possessing a prohibited device and the
allegation of actually employing that device to secure an unfair
advantage. Whether such distinction would alter the
consequence prescribed by the Information Bulletin is a matter

- 26 -

1 of 2026

WP No. 107041

to be examined
in the light of its governing provisi
ions. What
cannot be overlo
oked is that the petitioner had placed
d a specific
defence before t
the authority, which called for consid
deration in
accordance with
law.
19. The sub
bsequent development lends a further
dimension
to the controvers
sy. By a communication dated 28.07
7.2026, the
National Testing
g Agency itself disclosed the p
petitioner's
performance in t
the re-examination. The evaluated O
OMR sheet
revealed that t
the petitioner had answered 148
questions
correctly and 22
2 incorrectly, securing an aggregat
te of 570
marks . The com
mmunication reads as follows:

- 27 -
WP No. 107041 of 2026

The merit secured by the petitioner in the re-examination
is an independently ascertainable fact. Whether that merit
could be denied recognition on account of the allegation
relating to the earlier examination is the legal
controversy. It is in this factual setting that the petitioner
approached this Court, seeking redressal of her grievance. The
petition was instituted on 13.08.2026, calling in question the
show cause notice, the decision to withhold the result and the
consequential denial of an opportunity to participate in the
medical counselling process.
20. The urgency was palpable. The counselling process
had commenced and was approaching its conclusion. If the
petitioner were denied participation at that stage, even an
eventual success in the writ petition could have proved illusory,
for the academic calendar would not wait upon the outcome of
litigation.
21. This Court, therefore, by an interim order dated
08.09.2026, permitted the petitioner to participate in the
counselling process, expressly making such participation subject
to the final outcome of the petition and clarifying that no equities

- 28 -
WP No. 107041 of 2026

could be claimed on the strength of the interim protection. The
interim order dated 08.09.2026, reads as follows:
“The petitioner is before the Court seeking the
following prayer:
“a) Call for the entire records pertaining to the UFM
proceedings initiated against the Petitioner under File
No.19/NTA/NEET (UG)/2026, including the centre
report, audit material, Committee proceedings,
recommendation and final decision, if any.
b) ISSUE a Writ of Certiorari or any other appropriate
writ, order, or direction quashing the Show Cause
Notice dated 17.06.2026 Vide Annexure A1.
c) Issue a writ of certiorari or any other appropriate
writ, order or direction quashing the action of
Respondent Nos.2 and 3 reflected in the NEET (UG)
2026 Score Card dated 16/07/2026, vide Annexure-
A, insofar as the Petitioner's result is marked
'RESULT WITHHELD/R/W', and quash any
consequential order or decision withholding the
Petitioner's result.
d) ISSUE a Writ of Mandamus or any other
appropriate writ, order, or direction commanding
Respondent No. 1 (NTA) to immediately and
unconditionally release the withheld result and the
original scorecard of the Petitioner for the NEET (UG)
2026 Re-examination (Roll No. 2720104005);
e) ISSUE a Writ of Mandamus directing Respondents
No. 2, 3, 4, 5 to permit the Petitioner to register for
and participate in the ongoing undergraduate medical
counseling for the academic year 2026-27 based on
her lawfully secured score of 570 marks;
f) PASS any such other and further orders as this
Hon'ble Court deems fit and proper in the facts and
circumstances of the case, in the absolute interest of
justice, equity, and good conscience.”
The prayers are manifold. The subject petition is
preferred on 13.08.2026 and has been pending. The co-
ordinate Bench of this Court had reserved liberty to the
petitioner to move the matter once the counseling would

- 29 -
WP No. 107041 of 2026

be announced. Therefore, the petitioner has moved the
matter for urgent hearing.
The issue is with regard to permitting the petitioner
to participate in the counseling. The backdrop of the
permission that is now sought is the electronic mail
communication issued to the petitioner by the 1st
respondent, which reads as follows:

“Dear Candidate,
With reference to your representation, it is to
inform you that as per the evaluation of your OMR
sheet, you have 148 correct, 22 incorrect and your
total score is 570. Your actual score card has been
published on the website neet.nta.nic.in and also
emailed to you. Kindly note that any tampering with
your downloaded OMR sheet will result in proceedings
under the Public Examinations (Prevention of Unfair
Means) Act 2024.
Yours faithfully.
Sd/-
Director (Exams)”

The total score of the petitioner is 570. Therefore, the
learned counsel submits that on merit, the petitioner is
meritorious and has all the chances of securing a medical
seat, as per merit.
The Additional Solicitor General, Sri. Arvind Kamath
representing the National Test Academy (‘NTA’) would
oppose the grant of any permission to participate in the
counseling on the score that the petitioner in the earlier
NEET examination was found in possession of a mobile
phone. Though the examination stood cancelled and a re-
examination was done, the learned ASG submits that the
allegation of carrying a mobile phone earlier cannot be
brushed aside.
While it is true cannot be brushed aside, which
however, would be subject to the outcome of the final
orders that this Court would pass, the impending urgency
in the matter is that the counseling has now commenced
and would end at 2:00 pm on 09.09.2026.
Several High Courts have in an identical circumstances
permitted the candidate to participate in the counseling.

- 30 -
WP No. 107041 of 2026

The High Court of Bombay in the case of Viraj Pramod
Pawar and another vs. Union of India and others in Writ
Petition (ST.) No.10916/2026 following the earlier order
passed by the Bench of the High Court of Bombay at
Aurangabad in Writ Petition No.8589/2026 has held as
follows:
“6. Considering that the Petitioners are similarly placed as
the Petitioners in Writ Petition No.8589 of 2026 and Writ
Petition No.8912 of 2026, which are the subject matter of
the Order dated 10th August 2026, we pass a similar
interim order in the present matter as under:
a. Though the last date for registration - reporting /
joining as per Schedule – II for CAP-1 of MBBS/BDS
(Group A) of Round 1 of Re-NEET (UG) 2026 is
22nd August 2026, Ms.Kapadia, the learned counsel
for the Respondent No.5 State CET Cell, states that
there is further revision and the schedule will be
made available to this Court in the course of today.
b. We, as and by way of interim order, direct
Respondent No.2 NTA to declare the Re-NEET 2026
Examination result of the Petitioners by today and
allow the Petitioners to participate in CAP-1 of
MBBS/BDS by registering through offline mode.

c. Respondent No.1 shall file its Affidavit in Reply to
the Writ Petition within a period of one week from
today, i.e. on or before 28th August 2026.

d. This order is subject to the outcome of the
present Petition and the Petitioner shall not claim
any equities by virtue of this order being passed.

e. Writ Petition shall be placed for further
consideration on 11th September 2026.

g. At this stage, Ms.Kapadia, the learned counsel for
Respondent No.5, has shared with this Court the
Revised Schedule II for CAP-1 for admission to
MBBS/BDS (Group A) for academic year 2026-27
vide Notice No.10 issued on 19th August 2026
where it is mentioned that Online / Offline
Registration and Session shall be applicable from
20th August 2026 to 21st August 2026 upto 8 p.m.”

- 31 -
WP No. 107041 of 2026

The High Court of Delhi in the case of Aditya Vinod
Swami and another vs. National Testing Agency and
others in W.P.(C) 11212/2026 & CM Appl.54270/2026 on
24.08.2026 also grants an interim order of participation or
announcement of results and even participation in the
counseling.

“16. Admittedly, the petitioners have not been
arrayed as accused in the charge-sheet filed
by the CBI and have, instead, been cited as
witnesses. At this stage, therefore, the
petitioners cannot be treated as persons
against whom criminal culpability has been
established or as having been found guilty of
any illegality.
17. The charge-sheet filed by the CBI is yet to
be tested in accordance with law, and the
allegations contained therein would
necessarily have to be established by leading
appropriate evidence. The submissions
advanced by learned Standing Counsel for the
CBI are also based upon the findings
contained in the charge-sheet, which are yet
to be tested in trial. At this stage, therefore,
no final conclusion can be drawn regarding
the culpability of the petitioners.
18. The petitioners are at a nascent stage of
their academic careers. In these
circumstances, I am of the view that the
withholding of their results, merely on the
basis of allegations which are yet to be tested
in accordance with law, would cause serious
prejudice to them. The petitioners ought to be
permitted to know their results and, subject
to the outcome of the proceedings, participate
in the further rounds of counselling conducted
by the NTA. At best, the petitioners can only
be charged for unfair means, which will be
tested once the parties have led detailed
evidence.
19. To deny the petitioners an opportunity to
participate in the counselling process at this
stage may result in consequences which

- 32 -
WP No. 107041 of 2026

cannot subsequently be adequately remedied.

20. For the aforesaid reasons, I am satisfied that
the petitioners have made out a prima facie case.
The balance of convenience also lies in their favour,
and they are likely to suffer irreparable loss and
injury if their results continue to remain withheld.
Loss of an academic year or an opportunity to
participate in the counselling process may have
consequences which cannot be adequately
compensated in terms of money.
21. Accordingly, the results of the petitioners
shall be declared within 24 hours from the
time the present order is uploaded. On the
basis of the results so declared, the
petitioners shall be permitted to participate in
the further rounds of counselling conducted
by the NTA, subject to their otherwise
fulfilling the applicable eligibility criteria.
22. The petitioners whose counseling results
were not declared till now will be permitted to
apply offline.”
(Emphasis supplied)
In the aforesaid circumstances, owing to the
urgency of the matter, we hereby permit the petitioner to
take part in the counseling that is now on, which would
come to an end at 2:00 pm on 09.09.2026 making it clear
that the petitioner on whatsoever ground cannot claim
equities in the event the petition would go against the
petitioner. It is only an interim order permitting
counseling to preserve the right of the petitioner, as if the
counseling gets over, the right of the petitioner would get
vanished, and in the event, the petitioner would later
succeed in the petition, she would be neither here nor
there.
To enable the petitioner to participate in the
counseling, all that is needed to be done by the
respondent shall be done without brooking any delay.
In these peculiar circumstances, we permit the
petitioner to participate in the counseling which would
remain subject to the result of the petition. The petition

- 33 -
WP No. 107041 of 2026

shall be posted on 17.09.2026, to be heard and disposed
as pleadings stand complete today.
The petitioner shall forthwith approach the
Karnataka Examination Authorities as soon as the NTA
releases the results of the petitioner and the KEA shall
again without brooking any delay permit the petitioner to
participate in the counseling in accordance with law.”

While passing the afore-quoted interim order, this Court
noticed similar interim protection extended by the High Court of
Bombay in VIRAJ PRAMOD PAWAR AND ANOTHER V.
UNION OF INDIA AND OTHERS in Writ Petition (ST.)
No.10916 of 2026 and by the High Court of Delhi in ADITYA
VINOD SWAMI AND ANOTHER V. NATIONAL TESTING
AGENCY AND OTHERS in W.P.(C) No.11212 of 2026 . The
common thread running through those interim orders was the
necessity of preserving the academic opportunities of students
while leaving the underlying allegations to be determined in
accordance with law.
22. The object of the interim order was to ensure that the
doors of medical education were not irretrievably closed before
the legality of the impugned action could receive judicial
consideration. The interim order thus preserved the subject
matter of the lis ; but did not predetermine its outcome.

- 34 -
WP No. 107041 of 2026

23. The subsequent events are equally significant.
Pursuant to the interim protection, the petitioner participated in
the counselling process, secured a seat purely on merit at the
Belagavi Institute of Medical Sciences and has since commenced
pursuing medical education. These facts are not in dispute.
24. The controversy, therefore, now stands at a
delicate interplay of examination discipline, administrative
fairness and demonstrated academic merit. On one side
lies the unquestionable authority of the examining body to
preserve the sanctity of competitive examinations and punish
proven violations of the governing rules. On the other lies the
claim of a student who has secured 570 marks, out of 620, in a
fresh examination, against whose conduct in that examination no
allegation of unfair means is made, but whose academic future is
sought to be affected by an allegation arising from an earlier
examination cancelled in its entirety.
25. It is against this backdrop that the action of the
National Testing Agency must be tested on the touchstone of the
governing Information Bulletin, the principles of natural justice
and the permissible limits of judicial review.

- 35 -
WP No. 107041 of 2026

26. A perusal at the information bulletin of examination
with regard to the unfair means would clearly indicate that it
solely rests upon unfair advantage. Unfair means a practice that
allows a candidate to gain an unfair advantage. The information
bulletin of the examination reads as follows:
“ CHAPTER 14
UNFAIR MEANS PRACTICES AND BREACH OF
EXAMINATION RULES
1. Definition
Unfair means practice is an activity that allows a
candidate to gain an unfair advantage over other
candidates. It includes, but is not limited to:
a. Being in possession of any item or article which
has been prohibited or can be used for unfair
practices including any stationery item,
communication device, accessories, eatables,
ornaments, or any other material or information
relevant or not relevant to the examination in the
paper concerned.


b. Using someone to write the examination
(impersonation) or preparing material for copying;


c. Breaching examination rules or any direction issued by
NTA in connection with the conduct of the NEET (UG)-
2026 examination from time to time.


d. Assisting other candidates to engage in malpractices,
giving or receiving assistance directly or indirectly of
any kind or attempting to do so;


e. Writing questions or answers on any material other
than the answer sheet given by the Centre
Superintendent for writing answers.


f. Tearing/Defacing of filled OMR Sheet, any page of the
test booklet, etc.

- 36 -
WP No. 107041 of 2026



g. Contacting or communicating or trying to do so with
any person, other than the Examination Staff, during
the examination time in the Examination Centre.


h. Taking away the answer sheet (Original OMR/Office
Copy of OMR) out of the examination hall/room.


i. Smuggling out of Question Paper or its part or
smuggling out answer sheet or part thereof.


j. Threatening any of the officials connected with the
conduct of the examination or threatening any of the
candidates.


k. Using or attempting to use any other undesirable
method or means in connection with the examination.


l. Manipulation and fabrication of online documents viz,
admit card, rank letter, self-declaration, etc.


m. Forceful entry/exit in/from Examination Centre/Hall.


n. Use or attempted use of any electronic device after
entering the Examination Centre,


o. Affixing/uploading of wrong/morphed photographs on
the application form/admit card/proforma.


p. Erasing or obliterating any information printed on the
OMR Answer Sheet.


q. Providing incorrect information and/or overwriting of
the Roll No./ Test Booklet No. /own Name of the
Candidate / Father's Name / Mother's Name / own
Signature, on the OMR Answer Sheet.


r. Making fake claims by manipulating the responses in
the OMR sheet by/on tampering it in any way
whatsoever, uploaded on the website for the challenge
before or after the declaration of the result.


s. Creating obstacles in smooth and fair conduct of the
examination.

- 37 -
WP No. 107041 of 2026


t. Any other malpractices declared as Unfair means by
the NTA.


u. Any other unfair means practice covered under Clause
3 of Chapter II under Public Examinations (Prevention
of Unfair Means) Act, 2024.

2. PUNISHMENT FOR USING UNFAIR MEANS
PRACTICES
During the course of, before, or after the examination
if a candidate indulges in any of the above or similar
practices, he/she shall be deemed to have used unfair
practices and booked under UNFAIR MEANS (U.F.M.) case.
The candidate would be debarred upto 3 years from NTA
examination (depending on the gravity of unfair means) in
future and shall also be liable for criminal action and/or any
other action as declared in Public Examinations (Prevention
of Unfair Means) Act, 2024.
3. CANCELLATION OF RESULT

a. The result of NEET(UG)-2026 of the candidates
who indulge in Unfair means Practices will be
cancelled and will not be declared.


b. Similarly, the result of those candidates who appear
from the Centre other than the one allotted to them,
write on the Test booklet/OMR Sheet of other
candidates or allow other candidates to write on
their Test Booklet/OMR Sheet will be cancelled
(and will not be declared)”
(Emphasis added)
Both the afore-quoted notifications and the information
bulletin of examination emanate from respondent No.1 –
National Testing Agency. The consequence of the first
notification is unmistakable. The examination conducted on
03.05.2026 stood scrapped in its entirety, thereby losing its

- 38 -
WP No. 107041 of 2026

efficacy as a measure of merit or as a foundation for determining
the inter se ranking of candidates. The second notification dated
15.05.2026 heralded the conduct of a fresh examination on
21.06.2026, intended to afford the aspiring candidates a
renewed opportunity to establish their merit in an examination
untainted by the irregularities. Pursuant thereto, the petitioner
is issued a fresh admit card, bearing a different roll number,
permitting her to participate in the re-examination.
27. It is at this juncture that the sequence of events
assumes a peculiar complexion. After having issued the fresh
admit card, thereby recognising the petitioner's eligibility to
participate in the re-examination, the National Testing Agency
issues a show cause notice dated 17.06.2026, alleging that the
petitioner had carried a mobile phone into the examination
premises on 03.05.2026. The allegation, therefore, traces its
origin to an examination which, by then, had already been
cancelled by the very authority that seeks to initiate proceedings
against the petitioner. What lends further significance to the
matter is the timing of the show cause notice. It is issued barely
four days before the re-examination, at a time when the
petitioner was expected to devote her undivided attention to an

- 39 -
WP No. 107041 of 2026

examination that could shape the course of her academic
destiny.
28. The juxtaposition of these events presents a striking
circumstance. The authority, on the one hand, permits the
petitioner to enter the portals of a fresh examination and,
on the other, seeks to pursue an allegation arising out of
an examination that had already been extinguished for the
purpose of determining merit. Whether the alleged infraction
in the scrapped examination could legitimately travel beyond the
cancellation of that examination and cast its penal shadow upon
the petitioner's performance in a subsequent and independent
examination is the question that lies at the heart of the
controversy. Equally, whether the mere allegation of possession
of a prohibited device, without a determination of its
consequences in accordance with the governing rules, could
justify withholding the fruits of demonstrated merit in the re-
examination is a matter that calls for judicial scrutiny.
29. The issue that now emerges for consideration, in the
peculiar and rather extraordinary circumstances obtaining in the
case at hand, is:

- 40 -
WP No. 107041 of 2026

Whether a student, who has demonstrated her
academic excellence by securing high marks in a duly
conducted re-examination and has, on the strength of
such merit, earned a seat in the prestigious Belagavi
Institute of Medical Sciences, should be made to suffer the
forfeiture of her academic future on account of an alleged
infraction committed during an earlier examination which
itself stood cancelled, scrapped and consigned to oblivion?
30. The issue is not merely one of adherence to
examination discipline. It traverses beyond the sanctity of merit,
the proportionality of administrative action, the distinction
between an inadvertent infraction and a deliberate attempt to
secure an unfair advantage, and, above all, whether the
machinery established to recognise excellence can itself become
an instrument for extinguishing it.
31. Before embarking upon an examination of the issue, it
becomes apposite to advert to the very object and philosophy
underlying the National Eligibility cum Entrance Test (NEET). The
examination is not an end in itself. It is a means to an end
— an institutional mechanism designed to identify merit,

- 41 -
WP No. 107041 of 2026

preserve academic excellence, secure uniformity in
standards and ensure that admission to the noble
profession of medicine is governed not by privilege,
patronage or pecuniary prowess, but by demonstrated
intellectual ability.
32. The primacy of merit in medical admissions is neither a
matter of administrative convenience nor a principle of recent
vintage. It has received the imprimatur of the Apex Court in a
catena of judgments. The Apex Court, in the case of SIDDHANT
1
MAHAJAN v. STATE OF RAJASTHAN , holds as follows:
“ …. …. ….
40. Before adverting to the facts of the present case, it is
imperative to clarify that admissions to MBBS and BDS
courses in all government and private medical colleges are
to be undertaken solely on the basis of NEET merit. This
position has been settled in the case of Sankalp Charitable Trust
(supra). The relevant portions of orders passed in the said case are
reproduced as follows:
“ 23. In view of the request made by the
learned Solicitor General, hearing is adjourned to 9-
5-2016. However, it is clarified that no examination
shall be permitted to be held for admission to MBBS
or BDS studies by any private college or association
or any private/deemed university.
xxx
33. Prima facie, we do not find any infirmity
in the NEET regulation on the ground that it affects
the rights of the States or the private institutions.
Special provisions for reservation of any category are
not subject-matter of NEET nor are the rights of

1
2025 SCC OnLine SC 2864

- 42 -
WP No. 107041 of 2026

minority in any manner affected by NEET. NEET only
provides for conducting entrance test for eligibility for
admission to the MBBS/BDS course.
xxx
37. In view of the above, it is also clarified
that only NEET would enable students to get
admission to MBBS or BDS studies.”
41. The NEET examination functions as a mechanism
which not only upholds the high standards of medical
education across the country through its recognition of
merit but also ensures a level-playing field for medical
aspirants . Consequently, all admissions to medical
institutions must strictly conform to the standards and
regulations prescribed for the conduct of NEET, so as to
safeguard the primacy of merit . A three-Judge Bench of this
Court, while upholding the constitutional validity of NEET in
Christian Medical College Vellore Association v. Union of India ,
(2020) 8 SCC 705, also laid emphasis on the significance of
regulatory norms in enhancing the quality of professional education
in the country. The relevant portions of the said judgment are
reproduced for your perusal hereinbelow:
“ 55. The prescription of NEET is definitely in
order to improve the medical education, co-related to
the improvement of public health, thus, it is a step in
furtherance of the duty of the State enshrined in the
directive principles of State policy contained in Article
47 of the Constitution of India. Similarly, Article 46
aims at promotion of educational and economic
interests of the Scheduled Castes, Scheduled Tribes,
and other weaker sections. By prescription of one
equivalence examination of NEET, the interest
of their merit is also equally protected and its
aims of preventing various malpractices, which crept
into the system and prevent economic exploitation
by selling seats with which malady the professional
medical education system suffered. Article 51-A(j)
deals with the duty to strive towards excellence
in all spheres of individual and collective
activity so that the nation constantly rises to
higher levels of endeavour and achievement.
For that purpose, recognition of merit is
necessary, and one has to be given a full
opportunity in pursuit of his/her aim. The
prescription of NEET is to provide equal
opportunity and level launching platform to an
individual to perform his duty as enshrined
under Article 51-A(j). Thus, we find that there is
no violation of the aforesaid provisions as argued by

- 43 -
WP No. 107041 of 2026

the appellants, rather action is in furtherance of the
constitutional aims and directions to achieve
intendment of Article 51-A(j) and is in the national
interest.
xxx
62. Thus, it is apparent that the provisions in
question which have been incorporated in the Act
relating to Medical/Dental education, the
Government, MCI and DCI cannot be said to be an
invasion of the fundamental rights. The intendment is
to ensure fairness in the selection, recognition of
merit, and the interests of the students. In the
national interest, educational institutions are
basically for a charitable purpose. By and large, at
present education is devoid of its real character of
charity, it has become a commodity. To weed out
evils from the system, which were eating away
fairness in admission process, defeating merit and
aspiration of the common incumbent with no means,
the State has the right to frame regulatory regime
for aided/unaided minority/private institutions as
mandated by directives principles, Articles 14 and 21
of the Constitution. The first step has been taken to
weed out the evils from the system, and it would not
be in the national interest to step back considering
the overall scenario. If we revert to the old system,
posterity is not going to forgive us. Still, complaints
are galore that merit is being ignored by private
institutions; there is still a flood of litigation. It seems
that unfettered by a large number of regulatory
measures, unscrupulous methods and malpractices
are yet being adopted. Building the nation is the
main aspect of education, which could not be ignored
and overlooked. They have to cater to national
interest first, then their interest, more so, when such
conditions can be prescribed for recognition,
particularly in the matter of professional education.
….
67. Resultantly, we hold that there is no
violation of the rights of the unaided/aided
minority to administer institutions under
Articles 19(1)(g) and 30 read with Articles 25,
26 and 29(1) of the Constitution of India by
prescribing the uniform examination of NEET
for admissions in the graduate and
postgraduate professional courses of medical
as well as dental science. The provisions of the
Act and Regulation cannot be said to be ultra

- 44 -
WP No. 107041 of 2026

vires or taking away the rights guaranteed
under the Constitution of India under Article
30(1) read with Articles 19(1)(g), 14, 25, 26
and 29(1). Accordingly, the transferred cases,
appeal and writ petitions are disposed of. No
costs .”

In the afore-quoted judgment, the Apex Court, while
considering the object of NEET and the inviolability of merit in
admissions to medical courses, has unequivocally declared that
admissions must be founded upon NEET merit and that the
examination serves the twin purposes of maintaining excellence
in medical education and ensuring a level playing field for every
aspiring medical student.
33. The Apex Court, drawing sustenance from the
Constitution Bench pronouncement in the case of CHRISTIAN
MEDICAL COLLEGE VELLORE ASSOCIATION v. UNION OF
2
INDIA , in the afore-quoted judgment underscores, that the
prescription of NEET is intended to advance the constitutional
aspirations embodied in Articles 14, 21, 46, 47 and 51-A(j) of
the Constitution of India. The recognition of merit is thus
not merely an academic imperative; it is an essential
component of constitutional governance in the realm of
professional education.

2
(2020) 8 SCC 705

- 45 -
WP No. 107041 of 2026

34. The elucidation of law by the Apex Court in the afore-
quoted judgment would unmistakably reveal that merit is the
soul of the NEET examination; fairness is its foundation;
and excellence is its ultimate destination. The regulatory
framework is conceived to protect these principles, not to defeat
them. The rules governing an examination undoubtedly
command obedience, but their application must remain faithful
to the purpose for which the examination itself has been
conceived.
35. An examination designed to discover merit cannot, by
an unduly mechanical application of its disciplinary provisions,
become the very instrument for destroying merit, particularly
when the alleged infraction pertains to an examination which has
ceased to possess any legal or academic efficacy. It is against
this constitutional and legal backdrop that the case of the
petitioner must be considered.
36. The petitioner is a young student standing at the
threshold of a professional career in medicine. The petitioner has
successfully undertaken the re-examination conducted by
respondent No.1 — National Testing Agency, secured high

- 46 -
WP No. 107041 of 2026

marks, earned a medical seat purely on the strength of her merit
at the Belagavi Institute of Medical Sciences and is now pursuing
the course. Her academic excellence is not a matter of
conjecture. It stands demonstrated by her performance in the
subsequent examination.
37. Yet, respondent No.1 seeks to cast a shadow over this
achievement, not on the allegation of any malpractice in the re-
examination which earned her the seat, but on the premise that
the petitioner had carried a mobile phone into the examination
premises during the earlier examination — an examination
which, by the subsequent decision of the very same Agency,
stood cancelled and scrapped. The distinction is fundamental.
It is not a distinction without a difference.
38. In her explanation to the show cause notice, the
petitioner has categorically asserted that the mobile phone was
carried inadvertently, owing to the anxiety and stress attendant
upon an examination of such magnitude. The explanation is one
of an unintentional lapse and not of a calculated endeavour to
secure an unfair advantage.

- 47 -
WP No. 107041 of 2026

39. It must be remembered that the mere possession of
a mobile phone, though capable of constituting a breach
of examination instructions, cannot, without regard to the
governing rules and attendant circumstances, invariably
be equated with the actual use of unfair means to secure
an undeserved academic advantage. A breach of discipline
and the procurement of merit by deception are not necessarily
synonymous.
40. The Court is conscious that examination discipline is
sacrosanct. The sanctity of a competitive examination cannot be
compromised at the altar of misplaced sympathy. A candidate
who deliberately resorts to unfair means, manipulates the
examination process or secures a rank through dishonest
practices cannot seek shelter under the umbrella of equity. Merit
obtained by malpractice is no merit in the eye of law. But, the
case at hand presents an entirely different picture.
41. The examination in which the alleged infraction
occurred was itself scrapped. Its results were rendered
inconsequential. No academic advantage flowing from that
examination has been carried forward to the benefit of the

- 48 -
WP No. 107041 of 2026

petitioner. The petitioner thereafter appeared in a fresh
examination, competed with other aspirants and emerged with
high merit. No allegation of malpractice in the subsequent
examination is placed against her. Therefore, the examination
that was scrapped cannot be resurrected merely to eclipse
the merit earned in the examination that survived.
42. Had the petitioner repeated the alleged conduct in the
re-examination, or had her present ranking been shown to be
the product of unfair means, the matter would have stood on an
entirely different footing. No indulgence could then have been
claimed merely on the strength of a high score. But those are not
the facts obtaining in the case at hand.
43. Rules are framed to secure fairness, not to
become instruments of disproportionate forfeiture.
Discipline is intended to protect merit, not to punish
excellence for its own sake.
44. The object of NEET is to discover merit. The
object of examination discipline is to preserve the
integrity of that discovery. Neither object can be

- 49 -
WP No. 107041 of 2026

permitted to defeat the other by an application divorced
from the peculiar circumstances of the case.
45. The petitioner has not secured admission on the
strength of the examination in which the petitioner is alleged to
have carried a mobile phone. That examination has been
scrapped. The petitioner has secured admission on the strength
of a subsequent, independent and valid examination. Her present
merit is not the offspring of the alleged infraction; it is the
outcome of a fresh assessment of her academic ability.
46. The submission of the learned Additional Solicitor
General of India, seeking to sustain the impugned action on the
basis of the earlier examination, therefore, does not merit any
acceptance, in the peculiar facts obtaining in the case at hand.
47. A cancelled examination may remain a matter of
history; it cannot, without sufficient legal justification, be
permitted to become a perpetual impediment to a
student's future.
48. The petitioner has earned her seat through merit. The
petitioner has commenced the pursuit of medical education. To
now uproot her from that pursuit, on the sole premise of

- 50 -
WP No. 107041 of 2026

an explained infraction in an examination which no longer
forms the foundation of her admission, would, in the
circumstances of the case, amount to allowing the
consequence to overwhelm the cause.
49. There is yet another facet which cannot be lost
sight of. A seat in a medical college is not merely an
admission to an academic institution. It is the culmination
of years of preparation, perseverance, sacrifice and
aspiration. For a young student, it represents the
threshold of a profession dedicated to the preservation of
human life.
50. Before parting with this issue, it must be observed that
the future of a meritorious student ought not to be made a
casualty of an infraction which, in the peculiar circumstances of
the case, has not been shown to have contributed to the merit
on which her present admission rests. The law must be firm
against dishonesty, but it need not be unforgiving towards every
inadvertent lapse. An examination authority must be vigilant
against malpractice, but vigilance cannot degenerate into rigidity
that defeats the very purpose of the examination.

- 51 -
WP No. 107041 of 2026

51. Merit must never become a shield for
malpractice; but an allegation of malpractice must equally
not become a sword to destroy independently established
merit without sufficient justification.
52. The petitioner has crossed the threshold of merit in a
fresh examination. The examination that preceded it has been
effaced. To permit the shadow of that effaced examination to
permanently darken her professional horizon, in the absence of
adequate justification for such a consequence, would be to
elevate the alleged infraction above the very excellence that
NEET is designed to recognise. The doors of medical
education, opened by merit, cannot be shut by an action
that fails the test of fairness and proportionality.
EPILOGUE:
Merit is not a matter of charity; it is the reward of
perseverance, discipline, dedication and relentless pursuit
of excellence. More so, in a competitive examination for
admission to a medical course, where lakhs of aspiring
students compete for a handful of coveted seats, merit
assumes significance far beyond mere numerical
achievement. A meritorious student carries not merely

- 52 -
WP No. 107041 of 2026

the marks secured in an examination, but the toil of
countless sleepless nights, the sacrifices of formative
years and the cherished aspiration of entering the noble
profession of medicine. To deny such a student the fruits
of demonstrated merit on the altar of procedural
technicalities or inconsequential trivialities would be to
permit form to triumph over substance and arbitrariness
to eclipse excellence.
The doors of medical education must undoubtedly
remain guarded against unfair means and undeserving
claims, but those very doors cannot be slammed upon
genuine merit without compelling justification founded in
law. Merit must be nurtured, not neutralised; excellence
must be encouraged, not extinguished. A system that
sacrifices genuine merit at the altar of technical rigidity
does not merely wrong a student; it does disservice to the
larger public interest, for society itself is the ultimate
beneficiary of a meritorious doctor.
53. For the praefatus reasons, the following:
ORDER

a. The writ petition is allowed.

- 53 -
WP No. 107041 of 2026


b. The show cause notice dated 17.06.2026, issued
against the petitioner and the score card dated
16.07.2026, indicating the remark that ‘RESULT
WITHHELD/R/W’, stand quashed.

c. The seat secured by the petitioner on the basis of the
merit stands sustained.

d. Respondent No.1– National Testing Agency is directed
to issue the marks card / score card of the petitioner
without any observation of her result being withheld or
cancelled.


e. All other impugned actions would stand obliterated.

All pending I.As’. stand disposed, as a consequence.
Ordered accordingly.
Sd/-
(M.NAGAPRASANNA)
JUDGE


Sd/-
(HEMA KULKARNI)
JUDGE


nvj
CT: ASC