Muthuraj vs The State of Tamilnadu
- Court
- Madras High Court
CRL.A.(MD)No.364 of 2025
BEFORE THE MADURAI BENCH OF MADRAS HIGH COURT
Reserved On: 25.09.2026
Delivered On: 13.11.2026
CORAM:
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE A.D.JAGADISH CHANDIRA
and
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE B.MURUGESAN
CRL A(MD) No. 364 of 2025
CNR:{HCMD010319812025}
Muthuraj ... Appellant
Vs.
1.The State of Tamilnadu
Rep by The Deputy Superintendent of Police,
Srivilliputtur Sub Division,
Krishnankovil Police Station,
Virudhunagar District.
Crime No.84/2018.
2.Rakkammal
3.Annalakshmi ... Respondents
(R3 is impleaded as per order of this court dated 12.08.2026 in
Crl.Mp(MD).16698/2026 in Crl.A.(MD).364/2025)
PRAYER: Criminal Appeal filed under Section 425 BNSS to call for the
records of the impugned judgment made in Spl.S.C.No.40 of 2018 on the
file of the learned Special Court for Trial of SC/ST(POA) Act Cases,
Virudhunagar District at Srivilliputhur dated 03.02.2025 and set aside the
same.
For Appellant : Mr. M.Jegadeesh Pandian
For R1 : Mr.G.Karuppasamy Pandiyan,
Additional Public Prosecutor
For R3 : Mr.M.Sudha Rani
Legal Aid Counsel
__________
Page 1 of 28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 04:03:19 pm )
CRL.A.(MD)No.364 of 2025
JUDGMENT
[Judgment of the Court was made by B.MURUGESAN, J. ]
Assailing the judgment dated 03.02.2025 of the learned Sessions
Judge, Special Court for Trial of SC/ST (POA) Act Cases,
Virudhunagar District @ Srivilliputhur, hereinafter referred to as ‘the
trial court’, in Spl.SC.No.40/2018, convicting the appellant/sole
accused and sentencing him as detailed hereunder, the appellant/sole
accused has preferred this criminal appeal.
02. Conviction and sentences would read as under:
Conviction Under Imprisonment Fine and Default
Sentence
1 S.450 IPC 5 years RI Rs.1,000/- i/d
1 month SI
2 S.366 IPC 5 years RI Rs.1,000/- i/d
1 month SI
3 S.376(2)(l) IPC
r/w
S.3(2)(v) SC/ST
Imprisonment for Life Rs.1,000/- i/d
1 month SI
(POA) Act
4 S.3(1)(w)(i) SC/ST
Rs.1,000/- i/d
1 year RI
(POA) Act
1 month SI
Sentences have been ordered to run concurrently, and the accused has
been given the benefit of set off under S.428 Cr PC.
__________
Page 2 of 28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 04:03:19 pm )
CRL.A.(MD)No.364 of 2025
03. Victim is a physically challenged and mentally retarded
woman, suffering from locomotor dysfunction and from speech and
hearing disability.
04. Case of the prosecution would run as under:
(1) De facto complainant, Rakkammal, is the mother of the
victim, belonging to hindu parayar community coming under Schedule
Caste, and residing at Venkatrayapuram, Watrap Taluk, and they are
surviving with the old age pension given to the mother and the stipend
given to the victim.
(2) Accused is a nearby villager, belonging to thevar community
coming under Non Schedule Caste.
(3) On 18.05.2018 at about 17.00 hrs, when the mother of the
victim went to a nearby shop to purchase some household things
leaving the victim alone at her house, the accused knowing that the
victim is a member of Scheduled Caste and knowing that the victim is
a girl suffering from such mental and physical disabilities as aforesaid,
trespassed into her house, lifted the victim, carried her into thorny
bushes behind her house and committed rape on her. As and when the
witnesses, Guruvan and Muthumari, raised an alarm, the accused
dropped the victim and ran away.
__________
Page 3 of 28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 04:03:19 pm )
CRL.A.(MD)No.364 of 2025
(4) On 23.05.2018, the mother of the victim lodged a complaint
with Krishnan Kovil Police Station, and accordingly, FIR in Cr No.
84/2018 on the file of Krishnan Kovil Police Station was registered.
(5) Pursuant thereto, PW18/DSP took the case for investigation
in pursuance of the proceedings dated 23.05.2018 of the
Superintendent of Police, inspected the place of occurrence and
prepared the observation mahazar and rough sketch in the presence of
the witnesses, Palanisami and Muthukannan. PW18 recovered the
dresses of victim under a seizure mahazar in the presence of the
witnesses, Palanisami and Muthukannan. PW18 examined
Rakkammal, Guruvan, Muthumari, Palanisami, and Muthukannan and
recorded their statements. PW18 filed a section alteration report after
getting the AR copy. PW18 examined Annalakshmi, Murugeswari and
recorded their statements. PW18 sent a requisition to the doctor for
issuing a final report. PW18 sent a requisition to the Headmaster, CSI
High School for Disabled, Sivakasi, for arranging an interpreter. PW18
sent a requisition to the Thasildhar, Srivilliputhur, for issuing
community certificates for the victim and the accused. PW18 arrested
the accused on 26.05.2018 near Sundarapandiyam Vilakku and
recorded his confession in the presence of Vellaisami and Muthusami.
__________
Page 4 of 28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 04:03:19 pm )
CRL.A.(MD)No.364 of 2025
PW18, in pursuance of such confession, recovered the dresses of the
accused from his house. PW18 caused the accused remanded to
judicial custody. PW18 sent a requisition to Srivilliputhur GH for the
potency test of the accused. PW18 examined the interpreter and
recorded his statement. PW18 caused the statements of Rakkammal,
Guruvan and Muthumari recorded under S.164 CrPC. PW18 handed
over the case records to the regular DSP.
(6) PW19/DSP took the case for investigation and examined SI
Palvannanadhan, Constable Murugeswari, Dr Sara and Dr
Jeganathaprabhu and recorded their statements. PW19 examined the
Constables Veerakumar and Balakrishnan on 08.06.2018. PW19
examined the Thasildhar Ramanadhan and recorded his statement.
PW19 caused the case properties sent to the court under Form 91. On
18.07.2018, PW19 examined Constable Jayamani and recorded his
statement. PW19 examined Govindaraj, who conducted chemical
examination, and recorded his statement. After such investigation,
PW19/IO filed a final report against the accused for the offences
punishable under S.450, S.366, S.376(2)(j)(i) IPC r/w S.3(2)(va)
SC/ST(POA) Act and S.3(1)(w)(i) SC/ST(POA) Act.
05. On appearance of the accused before the trial court, he was
__________
Page 5 of 28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 04:03:19 pm )
CRL.A.(MD)No.364 of 2025
furnished free of cost with the copies of the records relied on by the
prosecution, as required under S.207 CrPC.
06. Thereupon, the learned Public Prosecutor opened the case
before the trial court, as under S.226 CrPC, and the learned counsel for
the accused was also heard. On due consideration thereof, charges
were framed by the trial court against the accused under S.450, S.366,
S.376(2)(l) IPC r/w S.3(2)(v) SC/ST(POA) Act and S.3(1)(w)(i)
SC/ST(POA) Act and the same were read over and explained to him by
trial court, as under S.228 CrPC.
07. Accordingly, the accused was questioned by the trial court as
to the charges framed against him, and he denied the charges as not
true, pleaded not guilty and claimed to be tried.
08. Pursuant thereto, trial was ordered, and the prosecution
produced evidence in support of its case, and therefore, the
prosecution, before the trial court, examined PW1 to PW19, and
marked Ex.P1 to Ex.P25 and MO1 to MO4 through the competent
witnesses.
09. Details of the witnesses and the exhibits on the side of the
__________
Page 6 of 28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 04:03:19 pm )
CRL.A.(MD)No.364 of 2025
prosecution before the trial court are as under:
(1) PW1 is Rakkammal, the mother of the victim, who would
speak of the presence of the victim in the house on the date of
occurrence, the lifting of the victim from the place of occurrence to the
house, the lodging of the police complaint, Ex.P1, and the recording of
her statement under S.164 CrPC, Ex.P2.
(2) PW2 is Guruvan who would speak of the physical status of
the victim, the events on the date of occurrence, the lifting of the
victim from the place of occurrence to the house and the recording of
his statement under S.164 CrPC, Ex.P3.
(3) PW3 is Muthumari who would speak of the physical status of
the victim, the events on the date of occurrence, the lifting of the
victim from the place of occurrence to the house and the recording of
her statement under S.164 CrPC, Ex.P4.
(4) PW4 is Palanisami, meant for observation mahazar and
seizure mahazar, who has been declared hostile. Ex.P5 is his signature
in observation mahazar and Ex.P6 is his signature in the seizure
mahazar. PW5 is Muthukannan, meant for observation mahazar and
seizure mahazar, who has been declared hostile. Ex.P7 is his signature
in observation mahazar and Ex.P8 is his signature in the seizure
mahazar. PW6 is Vellaisami, meant for the confession, who has been
__________
Page 7 of 28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 04:03:19 pm )
CRL.A.(MD)No.364 of 2025
declared hostile. PW10 is Muthusami, meant for the confession, who
has been declared hostile. Ex.P12 is his signature in the confession.
(5) PW7 is Annalakshmi whose evidence is hearsay. PW11 is
Murugeswari whose evidence is hearsay.
(6) PW8 is Dr Sara, and the AR copy of victim is Ex.P9 and the
medical report about the victim is Ex.P9. PW9 is Dr Jaganathaprabhu
who issued the report, Ex.P11, as to the potency test of the accused
(7) PW12 is Ramanadhan, Thasildhar, who issued the
community certificate of the victim, Ex.P13, and the community
certificate of the accused, Ex.P14.
(8) PW13 is Micheal Ponsuresh, the interpreter, who would
speak about the failure/inability to get information from the victim.
(9) PW14 is Constable Murugeswari who would speak about her
role in taking the victim for medical examination. PW15 is Constable
Veerakumar who would speak about his role in taking the accused for
potency test. PW16 is Constable Jayamani who would speak about her
role in getting the report from RFSL, Ramanadhapuram. PW17 is SI
Palvannanadhan who would speak of the registration of FIR.
(10) PW18 is DSP Muthupandian who would speak about his
role in the investigation. Ex.P16 is the observation mahazar, Ex.P17 is
rough sketch, Ex.P18 is seizure mahazar referable to the dresses of the
__________
Page 8 of 28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 04:03:19 pm )
CRL.A.(MD)No.364 of 2025
victim, MO1 is the chudidar top and MO2 is the shirt worn by the
victim, Ex.P19 is section alteration report, Ex.P20 is the admissible
portion in the confession and Ex.P21 is the seizure mahazar referable
to the dresses of the accused, MO3 is shirt of the accused and MO4 is
lungi of the accused.
(11) PW19 is DSP Raja who would speak about his role in the
investigation and in filing the final report. Ex.P22 is Form 91. Ex.P23
is the report of the chemical examiner. Ex.P24 is the section alteration
report. Ex.P25 is the report from RFSL, Madurai.
10. While questioning under S.313 CrPC in respect of the
incriminating materials appearing against him in the evidence of the
prosecution, the accused answered before the trial court that all such
evidence is false and that this is a false case.
11. On the other hand, there is no evidence, either oral or
documentary, on the side of the accused.
12. Finding him guilty, the trial court has convicted the accused
for the offences under S.450, S.366, S.376(2)(l) IPC r/w S.3(2)(v)
SC/ST(POA) Act, 1989, and S.3(1)(w)(i) SC/ST(POA) Act, 1989, and
__________
Page 9 of 28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 04:03:19 pm )
CRL.A.(MD)No.364 of 2025
sentenced him as aforesaid.
13. Assailing such conviction and sentences of the trial court, the
accused has preferred this criminal appeal before us.
14. We have heard the learned counsel for the appellant/accused
and the learned counsel for the State (Criminal Side), and we have also
perused the records carefully.
15. Learned counsel appearing for the appellant/accused would
submit that the inordinate delay of 5 days in lodging the complaint
with the police is fatal to the case of the prosecution, that the evidence
of PW1 and PW2 are obviously hearsay, that the evidence of PW1 is
against the medical evidence, that the evidence of PW1 is against the
forensic evidence, that the medical and forensic evidence are against
the case of the prosecution, that the absence of hymen would not
substitute the proof of penetrative sexual assault, that the witnesses
meant for observation mahazar, rough sketch, seizure mahazar for the
dresses of the victim, confession and related seizure mahazar have
turned hostile, that the foundational facts for the offences under
SC/ST(POA) Act, 1989, have not been established by the prosecution,
__________
Page 10 of 28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 04:03:19 pm )
CRL.A.(MD)No.364 of 2025
that there is nothing on record to show the commission of trespass or
of kidnapping/abduction, that the complaint itself is shrouded in
mystery and that therefore, a judgment reversing the finding and
sentences of the trial court, and acquitting the accused of all the
charges levelled against him needs to be passed.
16. Per contra , the learned counsel for the State (Criminal Side)
would submit that since the accused is the resident of the same village,
he would have the knowledge that the victim is a member of Schedule
Caste, that the delay in lodging the complaint has been duly explained,
that the evidence of PW3 per se would bring home the offences, that
even though the forensic and medical evidence did not support the case
of the prosecution, the ocular evidence of PW3 would prove the case
of the prosecution, that the prosecution has proved its case to the hilt,
that the judgment of the trial court does not suffer any infirmities and
that therefore, the criminal appeal filed by the accused deserves for
dismissal.
17. Point for determination in this appeal is whether the trial
court is right in finding the appellant/accused guilty and thereby
convicting and sentencing him under S.450, S.366, S.376(2)(l) IPC r/w
__________
Page 11 of 28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 04:03:19 pm )
CRL.A.(MD)No.364 of 2025
S.3(2)(v) of SC/ST(POA) Act, 1989, and S.3(1)(w)(i) of SC/ST(POA)
Act, 1989?
18. For the better appreciation of facts, we divide our discussions
under two heads, (1) offences under SC/ST(POA) Act, 1989, and (2)
offences under IPC.
19. Offences under SC/ST (POA) Act, 1989
(1) Insofar as the offences punishable under SC/ST(POA) Act,
1989, are concerned, this court would like to refer to the relevant
provisions of SC/ST(POA) Act, 1989, which the prosecution has relied
on against the accused.
3. Punishments for offences atrocities.—
(1) Whoever, not being a member of a Scheduled Caste
or a Scheduled Tribe,
(w) (i) intentionally touches a woman belonging to a Scheduled
Caste or a Scheduled Tribe, knowing that she belongs to a
Scheduled Caste or a Scheduled Tribe, when such act of
touching is of a sexual nature and is without the recipients
consent;
shall be punishable with imprisonment for a term which shall not
be less than six months but which may extend to five years and
__________
Page 12 of 28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 04:03:19 pm )
CRL.A.(MD)No.364 of 2025
with fine.
(2) Whoever, not being a member of a Scheduled Caste or a
Scheduled Tribe,
(v) commits any offence under the Indian Penal Code (45 of
1860) punishable with imprisonment for a term of ten years or
more against a person or property, knowing that such person is a
member of a Scheduled Caste or a Scheduled Tribe or such
property belongs to such member, shall be punishable with
imprisonment for life and with fine;
It is clear that S.3(1)(w)(i) of SC/ST(POA) Act, 1989, speaks of
intentional touch of sexual nature against a woman of scheduled
caste/tribe, but not against a member of other caste and that the offence
presupposes the offender, before committing the offences, has known
the victim is a member of scheduled caste/tribe. It is further clear that
S.3(2)(v) of SC/ST(POA) Act, 1989, does specifically speak the
commission of such offences as prescribed against a member of
scheduled caste/tribe knowing that he/she is a member of scheduled
caste/tribe. In other words, S.3(2)(v) of SC/ST(POA) Act, 1989, would
not come into play against a person who is a total stranger to the victim
and/or who has no knowledge about the caste of the victim. Because,
__________
Page 13 of 28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 04:03:19 pm )
CRL.A.(MD)No.364 of 2025
such total stranger who has no knowledge about the caste of the victim
cannot not be said to have committed such offences against a member
of scheduled caste/tribe as such.
(2) Of course, it is true S.8(c) of SC/ST(POA) Act, 1989,
provides for a presumption where too, such personal knowledge about
the victim or his/her family is a sine qua non as under:
8. Presumption as to offences.— In a prosecution for an offence
under this Chapter, if it is proved that
(c) the accused was having personal knowledge of the
victim or his family, the Court shall presume that the accused
was aware of the caste or tribal identity of the victim, unless the
contrary is proved.
(3) Further, we would like to refer to the decision of Hon’ble
Supreme Court in Hitesh Verma V State of Uttrakhant and another
(2020 (10) SCC 710), and the relevant portion thereof would read as
under:
‘ 13 …… All insults or intimidations to a person will not
be an offence under the Act unless such insult or intimidation is
on account of victim belonging to Scheduled Caste or Scheduled
Tribe.
__________
Page 14 of 28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 04:03:19 pm )
CRL.A.(MD)No.364 of 2025
18 . Therefore, offence under the Act is not established
merely on the fact that the informant is a member of Scheduled
Caste unless there is an intention to humiliate a member of
Scheduled Caste or Scheduled Tribe for the reason that the
victim belongs to such caste…’
Yet, another decision of Hon’ble Supreme Court in Khuman Singh V
State of Madhya Pradesh (2019 SCC OnLine SC 1104) would also
be of noteworthy, and the relevant portion thereof would read under:
‘ 13 ….. the offence must be such so as to attract the offence
under section 3(2)(v) of the Act. The offence must have been
committed against the person on the ground that such person is a
member of Scheduled Caste and Scheduled Tribe.’
(4) It is therefore clear that the prosecution, in order to bring
home the offences punishable under SC/ST (POA) Act, 1989, must
establish (1) that the accused has committed such offences against the
victim either with the knowledge that the victim is a member of
scheduled caste/tribe, or with the personal knowledge about the victim
or his/her family, inviting the aforesaid presumption, and (2) that the
accused has committed such offences against the victim on the sole
ground that the victim is a member of scheduled caste/tribe.
__________
Page 15 of 28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 04:03:19 pm )
CRL.A.(MD)No.364 of 2025
(5) In this case on hand, the question, therefore, is whether the
prosecution has established (1) that the accused has committed such
offences against the victim either with the knowledge that the victim is
a member of scheduled caste, or with the personal knowledge about the
victim or his family, inviting the aforesaid presumption, and (2) that
the accused has committed such offences against the victim on the sole
ground that the victim is a member of scheduled caste?
(a) Insofar as such knowledge or personal knowledge as
aforesaid is concerned, it is, of course, true there is no dispute as to the
fact that the victim is a member of schedule caste, and the accused did
not deny his knowledge about the caste of victim. Therefore, the
accused can be held to have had such knowledge or personal
knowledge that the victim is a member of scheduled caste.
(b) Insofar as the commission of such offences against the victim on
the sole ground that she is a member of scheduled caste is concerned,
even though the complaint, Ex.P1, where PW1 has affixed her thumb
impression, has been artistically drafted inviting the offences under
SC/ST (POA) Act, 1989, PW1, in her evidence, did not say anything to
the effect that the accused has committed such offences against the
victim on the sole ground that the victim is a member of scheduled
caste.
__________
Page 16 of 28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 04:03:19 pm )
CRL.A.(MD)No.364 of 2025
(6) In such circumstances that the accused is said to have
committed such offences against the victim not on the sole ground that
the victim is a member of scheduled caste, we, in view of the aforesaid
decisions, have no other option than to hold that the prosecution has
failed to make out a case punishable under SC/ST (POA) Act, 1989.
20. Offences under IPC
(1) 28 years old victim woman, who is suffering from spastic
cerebral palsy, is a physically challenged and mentally retarded woman
with locomotor dysfunction and with speech and hearing disability, as
certified by the doctor, PW8, vide Ex.P9.
(2) On account of such physical and mental disabilities, PW13,
the special interpreter, was not able to converse with victim even by
sign language, and as the result thereof, the victim could not be
examined by the police, as spoken to by PW13.
(3) For the aforesaid reason, the victim was not examined on the
side of the prosecution before the trial court.
__________
Page 17 of 28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 04:03:19 pm )
CRL.A.(MD)No.364 of 2025
(4) Evidently, the case of the prosecution would hinge upon the
evidence of PW1, PW2 and PW3.
(5) PW2 would admit in his chief examination itself that he has
not actually witnessed any occurrence and that he was only informed
by his wife, PW3. Therefore, the evidence of PW2 would not assume
any importance.
(6) PW1, the mother of the victim, would state that after she
returned to her house at about 17.30 hrs, she lifted and carried the
victim from the thorny bushes and that there were blood injuries, with
bleeding, in the body, legs and private part of the victim. But, PW3
would state that during 20.00 hrs – 20.30 hrs, she only lifted and
carried the victim from the thorny bushes and that PW1 was not there.
Further, PW18/DSP would admit that the dress materials involved in
this case did not contain any blood stains or any other stains.
Therefore, it would be unsafe to rely on the evidence of PW1.
(7) What remains is the evidence of PW3. PW3 would state in
her chief examination inter alia that one day, some five or six years
ago, during 20.00 hrs – 20.30 hrs, when she was in her house, a dog
__________
Page 18 of 28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 04:03:19 pm )
CRL.A.(MD)No.364 of 2025
was barking, that her husband had slept, that she came out of her house
and found the accused lifting/carrying the victim into thorny bushes
grown near her house, that as and when she shouted at him, the
accused dropped the victim and left the place, that thereafter, the
victim crawled towards her house and that she took the victim to the
house of the victim. In essence, the evidence of PW3 is that when she
came out of her house, she found the accused lifting/carrying the
victim into thorny bushes grown near her house and that as and when
she shouted at him, the accused dropped the victim and left the place.
(8) At this juncture, it would be appropriate to point out that a
suggestion has been put forward to PW1 as if the accused lifted and
carried the victim in order that she would answer the nature’s call,
implying or admitting the presence of the accused during the relevant
time.
(9) Now, the question is whether such suggestion put forward by
his counsel, implying or admitting the presence of the accused during
the relevant time would bind the accused? Of course, Balu Sudam
Khalde V State of Maharashtra (2023 SCC OnLine SC 355) is a
case where the Hon’ble Supreme Court, while dealing with the
__________
Page 19 of 28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 04:03:19 pm )
CRL.A.(MD)No.364 of 2025
probative value of suggestions in the cross examination, has held as
under:
‘ 38 . Thus, from the above it is evident that the suggestion made
by the defence counsel to a witness in the cross-examination if
found to be incriminating in nature in any manner would
definitely bind the accused and the accused cannot get away on
the plea that his counsel had no implied authority to make
suggestions in the nature of admissions against his client.
39 . Any concession or admission of a fact by a defence counsel
would definitely be binding on his client, except the concession
on the point of law….’
Therefore, in view of the aforesaid decision, we have no other option
than to hold that the accused is deemed to have admitted not only his
presence near the house of the victim during the relevant time but also
his lifting/carrying of the victim during the relevant time. In addition
thereto, PW3 affirms not only the presence of the accused near the
house of the victim during the relevant time but also his
lifting/carrying of the victim during the relevant time.
(10) Offence under S.376 (2)(l) IPC ( de hors SC/ST (POA) Act,
1989)
__________
Page 20 of 28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 04:03:19 pm )
CRL.A.(MD)No.364 of 2025
(a) As discussed earlier, PW3, the one and only witness who saw
the accused near the house of the victim during the relevant time,
would state that when she came out of her house, she found the
accused lifting/carrying the victim into thorny bushes grown near her
house and that as and when she shouted at him, the accused dropped
the victim and left the place. In other words, PW3 does not speak about
any act of the accused referable or attributable to the offence of rape.
Therefore, the evidence of PW3 would not help the prosecution in
order to prove the offence of rape.
(b) PW8, Dr Sara, who examined the victim on 23.05.2018 at
about 20.45 hrs, would state that no injury of whatsoever was found in
or around the private part of the victim but admit that the hymen of the
victim was not intact.
(c) It is trite that mere torn or damaged hymen of the victim,
without any supporting material against the accused, will not connect
the accused with the offence of rape.
(d) What is available on record against the accused with
reference to the offence of rape is only spermatozoa which were
detected in vaginal smears of the victim, vide Ex.P10. But, Ex.P25, the
report from RFSL, Madurai, would reveal that the result of grouping
test is inconclusive.
__________
Page 21 of 28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 04:03:19 pm )
CRL.A.(MD)No.364 of 2025
(e) It is apposite to point out here that when the occurrence is
said to have taken place on 18.05.2018, the victim was examined and
vaginal smear/swab was taken only on 23.05.2018, that is to say, after
five days. Therefore, such delay of five days, with reference to the
torn/damaged hymen of the victim and to the detection of spermatozoa
in vaginal smears of the victim, would obviously assume much
significance against the case of the prosecution.
(f) In such circumstances, we hold, with no other option, that the
prosecution has failed to prove that the accused has committed the
offence of rape on the victim punishable under S.376 (2)(l) IPC.
(11) Offence under S.366 IPC
(a) S.366 IPC would read as under:
366. Kidnapping, abducting or inducing woman to compel her
marriage, etc.—
Whoever kidnaps or abducts any woman with intent that
she may be compelled, or knowing it to be likely that she will be
compelled, to marry any person against her will, or in order that
she may be forced or seduced to illicit intercourse, or knowing it
to be likely that she will be forced or seduced to illicit
intercourse, shall be punished with imprisonment of either
description for a term which may extend to ten years, and shall
also be liable to fine; and whoever, by means of criminal
intimidation as defined in this Code or of abuse of authority or
__________
Page 22 of 28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 04:03:19 pm )
CRL.A.(MD)No.364 of 2025
any other method of compulsion, induces any woman to go from
any place with intent that she may be, or knowing that it is likely
that she will be, forced or seduced to illicit intercourse with
another person shall be punishable as aforesaid. (italics supplied
by this court)
In simple, in order to bring home the offence punishable under S.366
IPC, there must be kidnapping or abduction of a woman with the
intention of, or for the purpose of, marriage against her will or illicit
intercourse.
(b) Here is a case where it is proved by PW3 that the accused
lifted/carried the victim into thorny bushes grown near her house
during 20.00 hrs – 20.30 hrs and as and when PW3 shouted at him, he
dropped the victim and left the place. That apart, the accused, by the
aforesaid ‘suggestion’, is deemed to have admitted not only his
presence near the house of the victim during the relevant time but also
his lifting/carrying of the victim during the relevant time.
(c) Therefore, the factors that the victim, a physically and
mentally disabled, alone was at her house, that the time was
20.00/20.30 hrs on 18.05.2018, that the accused lifted and carried the
victim into thorny bushes, and that as and when PW3 shouted at him,
the accused dropped the victim and left the place would prove that the
accused has kidnapped the victim with the intention of, or for the
__________
Page 23 of 28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 04:03:19 pm )
CRL.A.(MD)No.364 of 2025
purpose of, illicit intercourse with her.
(d) In view of the above discussions, we hold the prosecution has
proved beyond all reasonable doubt that the accused has committed the
offence punishable under S.366 IPC.
(12) Offence under S.450 IPC
(a) S.450 IPC would read as under:
450. House-trespass in order to commit offence punishable with
imprisonment for life.—
Whoever commits house-trespass in order to the
committing of any offence punishable with imprisonment for
life, shall be punished with imprisonment of either description
for a term not exceeding ten years, and shall also be liable to
fine.
(b) As held earlier, the accused has kidnapped the victim with
the intention of, or for the purpose of, illicit intercourse with her,
punishable under S.366 IPC. Therefore, the intended offence is nothing
but rape punishable with the maximum sentence of imprisonment for
life.
(c) When the accused, in such way as aforesaid, has kidnapped
the victim, a physically challenged and mentally retarded woman with
locomotor dysfunction and with speech and hearing disability, that too,
when the mother of the victim had gone to a nearby shop to purchase
__________
Page 24 of 28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 04:03:19 pm )
CRL.A.(MD)No.364 of 2025
some household things leaving the victim alone at her house, the
accused can be held to have committed the offence of house trespass,
punishable under S.450 IPC, in order to commit rape on a woman
suffering from physical and mental disabilities.
(d) Ergo, this court holds the prosecution has proved beyond all
reasonable doubt that the accused has committed the offence
punishable under S.450 IPC.
21. Even though there is a delay of five days in lodging the
complaint, neither PW1, the de facto complainant, nor PW17, who
registered the FIR, nor PW18/DSP, who did initial investigation, nor
PW19/DSP, who filed the final report, has been cross examined on
such delay, and that is nothing on record to the effect that such delay is
fatal to the case of the prosecution.
22. Resultantly, this court holds that
(a) the trial court is right in finding the appellant/accused
guilty and thereby convicting and sentencing him under S.450 IPC,
(b) the trial court is right in finding the appellant/accused
guilty and thereby convicting and sentencing him under S.366 IPC,
__________
Page 25 of 28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 04:03:19 pm )
CRL.A.(MD)No.364 of 2025
(c) the trial court is not right in finding the
appellant/accused guilty and thereby convicting and sentencing him
under S.376(2)(l) IPC r/w S.3(2)(v) of SC/ST(POA) Act, 1989, and
(d) the trial court is not right in finding the
appellant/accused guilty and thereby convicting and sentencing him
under S.3(1)(w)(i) of SC/ST(POA) Act, 1989, and the point is
answered, accordingly.
23. In fine, this criminal appeal is hereby partly allowed,
(a) maintaining the conviction and sentence of the trial
court under S.450 IPC,
(b) maintaining the conviction and sentence of the trial
court under S.366 IPC,
(c) reversing the conviction and sentence of the trial court
under S.376(2)(l) IPC r/w S.3(2)(v) of SC/ST(POA) Act, 1989,
(d) reversing the conviction and sentence of the trial court
under S.3(1)(w)(i) of SC/ST(POA) Act, 1989,
(e) acquitting the appellant/ accused of the charge
punishable under S.376(2)(l) IPC r/w S.3(2)(v) of SC/ST(POA)
Act, 1989,
(f) acquitting the appellant/accused of the charge
__________
Page 26 of 28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 04:03:19 pm )
CRL.A.(MD)No.364 of 2025
punishable under S.3(1)(w)(i) of SC/ST(POA) Act, 1989,
(g) directing the fine amounts payable for the offences
punishable under S.376(2)(l) IPC r/w S.3(2)(v) of SC/ST(POA)
Act, 1989 and under S.3(1)(w)(i) of SC/ST(POA) Act, 1989, if
already paid by the appellant/accused, to be refunded to him,
(h) leaving other incidental orders/directions of the trial
court unaltered.
[A.D.J.C., J.] [B.M., J.]
13.11.2026
gns
To
1.The Deputy Superintendent of Police,
Srivilliputtur Sub Division,
Krishnankovil Police Station,
Virudhunagar District.
2.The Special Court for Trial of SC/ST(POA) Act Cases,
Virudhunagar District at Srivilliputhur
3.The Additional Public Prosecutor,
Madurai Bench of Madras High Court,
Madurai.
__________
Page 27 of 28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 04:03:19 pm )
CRL.A.(MD)No.364 of 2025
A.D.JAGADISH CHANDIRA, J.
AND
B.MURUGESAN, J.
gns
Judgment made in
CRL.A.(MD)No.364 of 2025
13.11.2026
__________
Page 28 of 28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 04:03:19 pm )