The Union Of India vs Pramod Kumar Khindri Dead Through Lrs Smt. Savita Khindri

Court
Madhya Pradesh High Court

NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:90237
1 WPS-12610-2004
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
AT JABALPUR

BEFORE
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE VIVEK RUSIA
&
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE PRADEEP MITTAL
th
ON THE 17 OF NOVEMBER, 2026
WRIT PET. (SERVICE) No. 12610 of 2004
CNR No.: MPHC010441622004
THE UNION OF INDIA
Versus
PRAMOD KUMAR KHINDRI DEAD THROUGH LRS SMT. SAVITA
KHINDRI
Appearance:
Shri Piyush Bhatnagar - Standing Counsel for the petitioner/Union of
India.
Shri Akash Choudhury - Advocate for the respondent.
Reserved on : 01.10.2026
Pronounced on : 17.11.2026
.....................................................................................................................................
ORDER
Per: Justice Vivek Rusia
The present writ petition under Article 227 of the Constitution of
India has been filed by the Union of India through its Secretary, Ministry of
Communications, challenging the order dated 16.08.2004 passed by the
Central Administrative Tribunal, Jabalpur Bench, Jabalpur, in Original
Application No. 570/2002 (Shri P.K. Khindri vs. Union of India and others) ,
whereby the Tribunal set aside the order of penalty dated 27.06.2002
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: ASHISH KOSHTA
Signing time: 17-11-2026
17:40:39

NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:90237
2 WPS-12610-2004
imposed upon the respondent.

FACTS OF THE CASE
2. The respondent was working as Chief General Manager
(Telecom), Railway Electrification Project Circle, Nagpur, during the period
from 15.02.1994 to 31.07.1998. Disciplinary proceedings were initiated
against him under Rule 16 of the Central Civil Services (Classification,
Control and Appeal) Rules, 1965 (hereinafter referred to as "the CCS (CCA)
Rules, 1965"), vide Memorandum No. 8/70/2000-Vig.II dated 06.06.2001.
3. The allegations levelled against the respondent were that, while
functioning as Chief General Manager (Telecom), Railway Electrification
Project Circle, Nagpur, he had allegedly disregarded the existing rules and
regulations as well as the specific departmental instructions contained in
Circular Letter No. 51-6/91-MMC/Pt. dated 12.01.1993. It was alleged that
he had approved the purchase of huge quantities of 2/2 VHF Radio Systems
from two specified firms without inviting tenders, beyond his delegated
financial powers and without obtaining the requisite approval. It was further
alleged that the equipment so procured was non-standard and was inducted
into the Telecom network without inspection by the prescribed inspecting
authority, namely, the Telecom Quality Assurance Circle.
4. On the basis of the aforesaid allegations, the respondent was
charged with committing gross financial impropriety and violating, inter alia,
Rule 60 of the P&T Financial Hand Book, Volume-I. His conduct was
alleged to constitute misconduct, failure to maintain absolute integrity, lack
of devotion to duty and conduct unbecoming of a government servant,
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: ASHISH KOSHTA
Signing time: 17-11-2026
17:40:39

NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:90237
3 WPS-12610-2004
thereby contravening Rule 3(1)(i), (ii) and (iii) of the CCS (Conduct) Rules,

1964.
5. During the disciplinary proceedings, the respondent sought
permission to inspect a document titled "Report to Examine the Issue of 2/2
Systems" for the purpose of preparing his statement of defence. The said
request was considered by the departmental authorities. However, the
competent authority decided that the report, being confidential and not
relevant to the defence of the officer charged, should not be made available
to him.
6. Before the aforesaid decision could be communicated to him, the
respondent submitted his statement of defence dated 07.09.2001, raising
various objections to the charges. He specifically pointed out that the
aforesaid report had not been supplied to him. He also raised an objection
regarding alleged interpolations in one of the relevant departmental files.
Subsequently, upon being informed of the decision declining inspection of
the report, the respondent submitted a further representation dated
21.10.2001.
7. The departmental authorities considered the representations
submitted by the respondent and prepared paragraph-wise comments thereon.
The departmental notings dated 11/N to 15/N are relevant in this regard. The
said notings record that, having regard to the nature of the allegations and the
contentions raised by the respondent, a more objective conclusion regarding
each element of the charge could be arrived at only on the basis of evidence
to be adduced during a full-fledged oral inquiry.
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: ASHISH KOSHTA
Signing time: 17-11-2026
17:40:39

NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:90237
4 WPS-12610-2004
8. The departmental authorities also took note of the fact that Shri

S.K. Singh Gautam, the then DE/Director, and Shri Bheemaiah, the then
CAO, Railway Electrification Project Circle, Nagpur, were facing
departmental proceedings under Rule 14 of the CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965, in
respect of their respective roles in the purchases in question. In the aforesaid
circumstances, a proposal was made for preparation of a revised charge-sheet
in the prescribed proforma under Rule 16(1)(b) of the CCS (CCA) Rules,
1965, and for placing the same before the competent authority for approval.
9. The record further indicates that the procurement of 2/2 VHF
Radio Systems had also given rise to disciplinary proceedings against other
departmental officials. In this connection, the role of Shri K.V. Chalapathi
Rao, who was functioning as Director (Finance and Accounts) and Internal
Financial Adviser, was examined in separate disciplinary proceedings. The
allegations against Shri K.V. Chalapathi Rao substantially related to his
alleged failure to discharge his responsibilities as Director (Finance and
Accounts) and Internal Financial Adviser, particularly in granting financial
concurrence to the procurement of 2/2 VHF Radio Systems by the General
Manager, Guntur Telecom District, without ensuring compliance with the
applicable financial rules and departmental instructions.
10. It was alleged in the said proceedings that purchases had been
made without following the prescribed tender procedure, beyond the
delegated financial powers and by splitting the purchase orders to bring the
individual orders within the financial limits of the purchasing authority. It
was also alleged that the equipment was non-standard and was inducted into
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: ASHISH KOSHTA
Signing time: 17-11-2026
17:40:39

NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:90237
5 WPS-12610-2004
the Telecom network without inspection by the prescribed inspecting

authority.
11. The Union Public Service Commission (UPSC), upon examining
the relevant records and the defence of Shri K.V. Chalapathi Rao, observed
that the allegations against him were substantially similar to those levelled
against the General Manager, Guntur Telecom District, Shri M.
Ramachandran. The Commission noted that, in the case of the General
Manager, the allegations concerning non-observance of the departmental
circular dated 12.01.1993, absence of authorisation for the purchases and
splitting of purchase orders had not been proved. The Commission further
observed that the relevant items were not included in the list of centrally
procured items under the departmental circular dated 12.01.1993. It also
noticed that the mere fact that the items were not available through
centralised procurement did not necessarily establish that the purchases were
unauthorised or that the prescribed rules had been violated.
12. With regard to the allegation of splitting of purchase orders, the
Commission observed that the purchases related to different components and
different areas. It was noticed that the purchase orders dated 08.02.1996
related to different components of the VHF Radio Systems, including high-
band and low-band systems and associated antenna equipment. The
Commission, therefore, found that the placing of separate purchase orders
did not, in the circumstances examined, constitute splitting of purchases to
avoid obtaining the sanction of a higher authority. The Commission also
observed that the evidence on record did not establish the allegations levelled
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: ASHISH KOSHTA
Signing time: 17-11-2026
17:40:39

NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:90237
6 WPS-12610-2004
against Shri K.V. Chalapathi Rao and ultimately advised that he be

exonerated and the case records be closed. The aforesaid observations form
part of the material relating to connected disciplinary proceedings arising out
of procurement transactions concerning 2/2 VHF Radio Systems.
13. According to the petitioner, after considering the material
available on record, the representations submitted by the respondent and the
advice tendered by the UPSC, the President imposed a penalty upon the
respondent vide order dated 27.06.2002. By the said order, the pay of the
respondent was reduced by two stages, from Rs.21,900/- to Rs.20,900/-, in
the time scale of Rs.18,460-500-22,400 for a period of two years with
immediate effect. It was further directed that the reduction would not have
the effect of postponing future increments. Being aggrieved by the aforesaid
penalty order dated 27.06.2002, the respondent preferred Original
Application No. 570/2002 before the Central Administrative Tribunal,
Jabalpur Bench, challenging the penalty on various grounds.
14. The UOI contested the Original Application by filing a detailed
reply and an additional reply along with relevant documents. The stand
before the learned Tribunal was that the penalty order had been passed after
due consideration of the entire material available on record, the
representations submitted by the respondent and the advice tendered by the
UPSC. It was further contended that the prescribed procedure under the CCS
(CCA) Rules, 1965, had been followed and that the principles of natural
justice had not been violated. The petitioner also submitted that disciplinary
proceedings had been initiated against other officials involved in the
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: ASHISH KOSHTA
Signing time: 17-11-2026
17:40:39

NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:90237
7 WPS-12610-2004
procurement. It was stated that Shri S.K. Singh Gautam and Shri Bheemaiah

were facing major penalty proceedings, whereas the respondent, along with
Shri V.H.R. Rao and Shri F.R. Briyani, had been awarded minor penalties.
15. Upon consideration of the rival submissions, the Central
Administrative Tribunal passed the impugned order dated 16.08.2004, setting
aside the penalty order dated 27.06.2002. Aggrieved by the aforesaid order,
the petitioner-Union of India has preferred the present writ petition under
Article 227 of the Constitution of India, challenging the legality, validity and
propriety of the order passed by the Tribunal. During the pendency of the
present writ petition, the original respondent, Shri Pramod Kumar Khindri,
expired on 31.01.2023. Thereafter, an application for substitution was filed
on behalf of his legal representative, accompanied by a copy of the death
certificate dated 31.01.2023, marked as Annexure TA/1.By the aforesaid
application, it was prayed that the wife of the deceased respondent, Smt.
Savita Khindri, being his legal heir, be substituted in his place and be
permitted to be brought on record as the respondent in the present
proceedings. An affidavit in support of the application was also filed.
16. The applicant accordingly sought permission of this Court to
substitute the name of the deceased Shri Pramod Kumar Khindri with that of
Smt. Savita Khindri so that the proceedings may continue and the
controversy involved in the writ petition may be adjudicated in accordance
with law.
Appreciation & Conclusions
17. Learned counsel appearing for the petitioner submitted that the
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: ASHISH KOSHTA
Signing time: 17-11-2026
17:40:39

NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:90237
8 WPS-12610-2004
impugned order passed by the Central Administrative Tribunal is contrary to

the material available on record and is liable to be set aside. It was contended
that the respondent, while functioning as Chief General Manager (Telecom),
Railway Electrification Project Circle, Nagpur, had approved the
procurement of huge quantities of 2/2 VHF Radio Systems from specified
firms without inviting tenders, beyond his delegated financial powers and in
disregard of the prescribed departmental instructions. It was further
submitted that the equipment procured pursuant to the respondent's approval
was non-standard and was inducted into the Telecom network without
inspection by the prescribed inspecting authority. Such conduct, according to
the petitioner, amounted to gross financial impropriety and violation of the
applicable financial rules and departmental instructions.
18. Learned counsel for the petitioner submitted that disciplinary
proceedings were initiated against the respondent under the CCS (CCA)
Rules, 1965, and that he was allowed to submit his defence. His
representations dated 07.09.2001 and 21.10.2001 were duly considered by
the competent authority before passing the penalty order. It was further
contended that the respondent's request for inspection of the report relating
to the 2/2 VHF Radio Systems was declined on the ground that the document
was confidential and not relevant to his defence. According to the petitioner,
the decision did not cause any prejudice to the respondent and the
disciplinary authority had sufficient material available before it to arrive at its
conclusion.
19. Learned standing counsel further submitted that the penalty was
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: ASHISH KOSHTA
Signing time: 17-11-2026
17:40:39

NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:90237
9 WPS-12610-2004
imposed by the President after examining the departmental records and

obtaining the advice of the UPSC. The penalty was a minor penalty and was
proportionate to the misconduct alleged against the respondent. It was also
submitted that the proceedings against Shri K.V. Chalapathi Rao related to
his separate role as Director (Finance and Accounts) and Internal Financial
Adviser. Therefore, the findings recorded by the UPSC in those proceedings
could not automatically determine the culpability of the respondent, whose
role as Chief General Manager was distinct and required independent
examination. It was further contended that disciplinary proceedings against
other officers involved in the procurement were initiated in accordance with
their respective roles and responsibilities. The respondent could not claim
discriminatory treatment merely because different penalties or proceedings
were adopted against other officials.
20. That the deceased delinquent had specifically sought inspection
of the report titled "Report to Examine the Issue of 2/2 Systems", which was
relevant to the allegations levelled against him and the request was illegally
declined on the ground of confidentiality and non-relevance which had
deprived him an effective opportunity to defend himself against the charges.
21. Learned counsel for the respondent further invited the attention
of this Court to the departmental notings dated 11/N to 15/N, wherein the
departmental authorities themselves had recorded that a more objective
conclusion regarding each element of the charge could be reached only after
a full-fledged oral inquiry. The department had also proposed preparation of
a revised charge-sheet under Rule 16(1)(b) of the CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965,
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: ASHISH KOSHTA
Signing time: 17-11-2026
17:40:39

NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:90237
10 WPS-12610-2004
for that purpose. Despite such observations in the departmental file, the

penalty order was ultimately passed without the proposed inquiry being
conducted.
22. The findings recorded by the UPSC in the connected disciplinary
proceedings concerning Shri K.V. Chelapathi Rao substantially arose out of
the same procurement transactions and were substantially similar to those
levelled against the respondent. The UPSC had examined the procurement
transactions and found that the allegations concerning violation of the
departmental circular dated 12.01.1993, absence of authorisation and
splitting of purchase orders were not established in the connected
proceedings. The Commission had specifically observed that the purchases
related to different components and different areas and that the placing of
separate purchase orders did not, by itself, constitute splitting of purchases to
avoid obtaining the sanction of a higher authority. Apart from this, it is
important to mention here that Shri K. Muthuswamy, Shri M. Ramchandran
and Shri K. V. Chelapati Rao, who were either exonerated by the department
from the similar charges or succeeded in the Tribunal, were holding inferior
posts to the present respondent. The present respondent, being Chief General
Manager, after having fulfilled all formalities, directed the purchase of the
systems in question.
23. The learned Central Administrative Tribunal rightly held that the
penalty order suffered from procedural irregularity, denial of reasonable
opportunity and non-consideration of relevant material. The department has
not suffered any loss. The aforesaid facts clearly show that no misconduct
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: ASHISH KOSHTA
Signing time: 17-11-2026
17:40:39

NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:90237
11 WPS-12610-2004
has been committed by this respondent.

24. In view of the above, we do not find any ground to interfere
with the well-reasoned order passed by the Central Administrative Tribunal
under Article 227 of the Constitution of India, especially after the death of
the respondent. Hence, the writ petition is dismissed.
(VIVEK RUSIA)
(PRADEEP MITTAL)
JUDGE
JUDGE
ak
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: ASHISH KOSHTA
Signing time: 17-11-2026
17:40:39