M/S Mosaic India Private Limited And Ors vs State Of Punjab
- Court
- Punjab and Haryana High Court
1
CRM-M-467
794-2017(O&M)
IN T
AB AND HARYANA
DIGARH
CRM-M-46794-2017(O&M)
Date of decision:16.11.2026
THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJA
AT CHAND
C
D
130
M/S SANDEE
EP FERTILIZERS SALES CO
ORP AND ANR.
…PETITIONERS
VERSUS
STATE OF P
M/S MOSAIC
STATE OF P
PUNJAB
...RESPONDENT
C INDIA PRIVATE LIMITED
CRM-32200-2022
D AND ORS
….PETITIONERS
VERSUS
PUNJAB
…RESPONDENT
Sr.
No.
Particu
ulars
1. The day
y when the judgment is reserved
08.10.2026
2. The day
y when the judgment is pronounc
ced 16.11.2026
3. The day
website
y when the judgment is uploaded
e
d on 16.11.2026
4. Whethe
pronoun
er only operative part of the judg
gment is
Full
nced or full judgment is pronoun
nced
5. The del
judgme
lay, if any, of the pronouncemen
ent and reasons thereof
nt of full Not applicable
CORAM: HO
ON'BLE MS. JUSTICE SHALI
Mr. Arun Chandra, Advocate
INI SINGH NAGPAL
Argued By : M
Fo
M
M
M
fo
M
or the petitioner(s) in CRM-M-4
46794-2017.
Mr. Abhilaksh Grover, Advocate,
Ms. Lohitaksh Shively, Advocate
Ms. Tapreet Brar, Advocate
,
(through VC) and
or the petitioner(s) in CRM-M-32
2200-2022.
Mr. Akash Yadav, AAG, Punjab.
*
JYOTI
2026.11.17 19:35
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
2
CRM-M-467
794-2017(O&M)
SHALINI SIN
1. T
NGH NAGPAL, JUDGE
his common order determines t
two petitions under Section 482
2
Cr.P.C. for q
quashing of complaint No.COM
MA/8865-2015 titled State of
f
Punjab versus
M/s Sandeep Fertilizers Sales
Corporation and Others under
r
Section 19(a) o
of the Fertilizer (Control) Order
1985 read with Section 3 of the
e
Essential Com
mmodities Act, 1955 punishable u
under Section 7 of the Essential
l
Commodities A
Act, 1955.
2. C
CRM-M-32200-2022 has been fil
led by M/s Mosaic India Private
e
Limited along
g with Mohit Chandra alleged to
o be responsible person of M/s
s
Mosaic India P
Private Limited and Manish Gup
pta, its Regional Manager, Sales
s
and Marketing
g.
3. C
CRM-M-46794-2017 has been
instituted by the dealer M/s
s
Sandeep Fertil
lizers Sales Corporation and its p
partner Sh. Ishwar Parkash.
4. Fa
acts of the case, as disclosed
in the complaint are that on
n
24.07.2013, Sh
h. Ram Singh, Agricultural Deve
elopment Officer, Daheru Block
k
Khanna, along
g with Darshan Singh, Agricult
tural Officer, Khanna inspected
d
the premises o
of M/s Sandeep Fertilizers Sales
Corporation, Shop No.77, Grain
n
Market, Khann
na, Ludhiana. Ishwar Parkash G
Gupta was present in the shop.
.
Sh. Ram Sing
gh checked the fertilizer stock r
register and license of the firm.
.
638x50 kgs
bags of Diammonium Phosp
phate (imported) NI8% P46%
%
“Mosaic” imp
ported and packed by M/s M
Mosaic India Private Limited,
,
Gurgaon were
found in the retail firm. The ma
achine stitched bags of fertilizer
r
were numbere
ed from 1 to 638 at spot. Six ba
ags were randomly selected for
r
taking sample
e under Clause 28(1)(b) of Fert
tilizer (Control) Order 1985 to
o
check the qua
ality of the fertilizer. After follo
owing requisite procedure, three
e
JYOTI
2026.11.17 19:35
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
3
CRM-M-467
794-2017(O&M)
test samples, e
each approximately 400 gms in
n weight were prepared, put in
n
three neat, cle
an, empty and dry polythene en
nvelopes and transferred to three
e
cloth bags, dul
ly sealed in the presence of Ishw
war Parkash Gupta and Darshan
n
Singh, Agricu
ultural Development Officer, K
Khanna at spot. Four copies of
f
Form ‘J’ were
filled at the spot, three copies o
of Form ‘K’ were prepared. One
e
sealed sample
e portion with a copy of Form
m ‘K’ duly filled was sent to
o
Analytical Ch
emist Incharge Notified Fertiliz
zers Quality Control Laboratory
y
Faridkot vide o
office letter dated 26.07.2013.
5. T
The sample was analyzed in l
laboratory and was not found
d
according to s
specifications, failing in nutrien
nt contents and solubility. Show
w
cause notice a
along with the copy of the ana
alysis report was served on the
e
dealer firm M/
/s Sandeep Fertilizers Sales Cor
rporation, Khanna to explain the
e
matter. Show
cause notice was also sent to th
he manufacturing/pool handling
g
agency and its
s responsible officer. Dealer fir
rm submitted reply to the Chief
f
Agricultural O
Officer, Ludhiana on 10.09.2013
and filed appeal for re-testing of
f
the reference
sample before the Appellate A
Authority. One reference sealed
d
portion was se
ent to Analytical Chemist Inchar
rge Regional Fertilizers Quality
y
Control Labor
ratory Navi Mumbai for re-a
analysis. Upon re-analysis, the
e
sample was n
not found according to specific
cation, failing in total nitrogen
n
contents and w
water soluble P205 contents. Th
he analysis report was conveyed
d
to the dealer
firm. Show cause notice was
sent to the dealer firm and its
s
partner to subm
mit reply on 10.01.2014. Show c
cause notice was also sent to the
e
Manufacturing
g/pool handling company. The
e manufacturing/pool handling
g
company ackn
nowledged the notice and submi
itted reply to Chief Agricultural
l
Officer, Ludhi
iana on 10.01.2014 and 20.01.20
014. The retail license-cum-letter
r
JYOTI
2026.11.17 19:35
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
4
CRM-M-467
794-2017(O&M)
of authorizatio
on was cancelled due to the vi
iolation of Clause 19(a) of the
e
Fertilizer (Con
ntrol) Order 1985. In appeal, t
the appellate authority partially
y
restored the li
cense. Complaint was then filed
d in the Court of learned Chief
f
Judicial Magis
strate against the dealer, its wo
orking partner and M/s Mosaic
c
India Private L
Limited and its responsible perso
ons.
6. L
earned counsels for the petitione
ers have argued that M/s Mosaic
c
India Private L
Limited had no concern with the
e manufacturing of the fertilizer.
.
The sample o
of DAP was drawn from mach
hine stitched bags stored in the
e
premises of th
e dealer M/s Sandeep Fertilizers
s Sales Corporation, Khanna and
d
M/s Mosaic In
ndia Private Limited being the im
mporter, was not responsible for
r
the non-standa
ard fertilizer. There was no alleg
gation in the complaint that the
e
dealer did not
t store the fertilizer in proper c
condition, at the time when the
e
sample was dr
rawn. The conflicting reports o
of analysis/re-analysis were also
o
not sustainable
e in the eyes of law. M/s Mosaic
c India Private Limited imported
d
the fertilizer
and the dealer firm received
d the material vide bill dated
d
18.07.2013 fro
om the importer. Petitioners, h
having no connection with the
e
production of
the material, the complaint de
eserved to be quashed qua the
e
importer as a
also the dealer firm. To supp
port their submissions, learned
d
counsels relied
d upon CRM-M-28723 of 2010
0 Date of decision 30.07.2012,
,
titled Ghanvir
r Singh versus State of Punjab
b and Another, CRM-M-33168-
-
2011 titled T
The Lodhiwala CASS Limited
d versus State of Punjab and
d
Others, CRM
M-M-4582-2008 date of decis
ision 15.12.2009 titled Manoj
j
Grover versu
s State of Punjab, CRM-M-
-19185-2019 date of decision
n
06.04.2019 titl
tled M/s S.S. Fertilizers and An
nother versus State of Punjab,
,
CRM-M-3605
52-2021, date of decision 19.12
2.2023 titled M/s Brij Lal and
d
JYOTI
2026.11.17 19:35
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
5
CRM-M-467
794-2017(O&M)
Sons and Ano
other versus State of Punjab,
CRM-M-19157-2019 date of
f
decision 28.05
5.2024 M/s R S Fertilizers Ludh
hiana and Ors. Versus State of
f
Punjab and O
Others, M/s FMC India Pvt. L
Ltd. And others versus State of
f
Haryana.
7. L
earned State Counsel, not dis
sputing that M/s Mosaic India
a
Private Limite
ed was the importer argued t
that since the petitioners sold,
,
stocked, offe
ered for sale and distributed
d non-standard Diammonium
m
Phosphate N
18% P205 46%, they were lia
able as per Clause 19(a) of the
e
Fertilizer (Con
ntrol) Order 1985 and violation
n of Section 3 of the Essential
l
Commodities
Act 1955. He, however, conced
ded that the sample of fertilizer
r
was drawn fro
m original machine stitched bag
gs. It was argued that the offence
e
committed by
the petitioners being punishable
under Section 7(i) (a) (ii) of the
e
Essential Com
mmodities Act, 1955, there was no
o limitation to file the complaint
t
as the maximu
um punishment under Section 7
7 of the Essential Commodities
s
Act, 1955 was
s seven years. To support his s
submissions he referred to M/s
s
Mosaic India
Private Ltd. and Another vers
rsus State of Punjab, CRM-M-
-
date of decision 03.03.2025.
10531-2025, d
8. T
he issue of limitation has not
been raised by the petitioners.
.
That the comp
plaint has been filed within the p
eriod of limitation prescribed, is
s
not disputed.
9. A
Annexure P-13 in CRM-M-32
2200-2022, instituted by M/s
s
Mosaic India
Private Limited and Others is F
Form A-2, acknowledgement of
f
the Directorate
e of Agriculture Punjab. The sa
aid document is a license dated
d
25.05.2011 he
eld by the petitioner, which stat
tes that the source of supply of
f
JYOTI
2026.11.17 19:35
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
6
CRM-M-467
794-2017(O&M)
DAP 18.46%
of M/s Mosaic India Private Lim
mited is ‘imported’. The license
e
was valid from
m 06.05.2011 to 05.05.2014.
10. A
Annexure P-14 is the Analysis
report of decanalised fertilizer
r
dated 27.12.20
012 of Central Fertilizer Quality
y Control and Training Institute,
,
Faridabad whi
ch records as under:
(i) Nam
me of the fertilizer: DAP 18.46%
(ii) Nam
me of importer: M/s Mosaic India
a Pvt. Ltd.
(iii) Nam
me of exporting country:USA
(iv) Nam
me of vessel: M.V. Dragon Glory
(v) Qual
lity: 50349.570 Mts.
11. N
No dispute has been raised with
h regard to Annexure P-13 and
d
Annexure P-14
4, by learned State counsel.
12. R
Relevant portion of para No.21 (A
Annexure P-1) of the complaint
t
filed in the C
Court of Learned Chief Judicial
Magistrate, Ludhiana reads as
s
below:
“ That this D.A.P. (Diamm
monium Phosphate) N18% P205
5
46
6% was imported, marketed an
nd packed by M/s Mosaic India
a
P
Private Limited, Gurgaon and tr
ransferred to the Branch Office.
Th
This sub-standard fertilizer had b
been supplied to this authorized
d
de
ealer from this company’s own
n branch premises vide invoice
e
N
No.5058000457 dated 18.07.2013
3 from Deepak Complex, 80-81,
r
3
rd
Floor, New Grain Market
t, Gill Road, Ludhiana. This
s
m
manufacturer/pool handling comp
pany is under legal obligation to
o
JYOTI
2026.11.17 19:35
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
7
CRM-M-467
794-2017(O&M)
su
upply good quality of fertilizer
rs as per prescribed standards
s
un
nder the provisions of the fertiliz
zer (Control) Order 1985.
Since this sample of D.A
A.P. (Diammonium Phosphate)
)
N
N18% P205 46% “Mosaic” im
mported packed, marketed and
d
di
istributed by this company taken
n on 24.07.2013 from the retail
l
de
ealer firm M/s Sandeep Fertil
lizers Sales Corporation, Shop
p
N
No.77, Grain Market, Khanna (L
Ludhiana) had been found to be
e
su
ub-standard “not according to
specifications as per Fertilizer
r
(C
Control) Order 1985.
That accused No.5 as m
mentioned in the title of this
s
co
omplaint Sh. Manish Gupta was
s working as Regional Manager
r
Sa
ales and Marketing in this Comp
pany at Ludhiana at the time of
f
fa
ailure of this sample. He had fa
ailed to check the supply of this
s
su
ub-standard fertilizer while wor
rking in this company. Since he
e
w
was looking the business of th
his company at Branch Office
e
Lu
udhiana thus responsible for day
y to-day business of this Branch
h
of
f this company. He had issued
d Invoice No.5058000457 dated
d
18
8.07.2013 regarding supply/dis
stribution of this D.A.P. to this
s
de
ealer, hence had violated the pr
rovisions of Clause 19(a) of the
e
F
Fertilizer (Control) Order 19
985 along with this offence
e
”
ommitted by this company.
co
13. C
Concededly, petitioner M/s Mos
saic India Private Limited and
d
Others is the i
importer of the fertilizer which
was supplied/sold to the dealer
r
M/s Sandeep
Fertilizers Sales Corporation an
nd another in machine stitched
d
bags vide Inv
voice No. 5058000457 dated 18
8.07.2013. It is not the case of
f
JYOTI
2026.11.17 19:35
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
8
CRM-M-467
794-2017(O&M)
respondent tha
at the bill/invoice was not genui
ine. The consistent view of this
s
Court in such
matters is that the supplier/mar
rketer and dealer cannot be held
d
or misbranding of “ fertilizer ” w
responsible fo
which was not manufactured by
y
them. No crim
minal liability can thus be fastene
ed on the importer/marketer and
d
the dealer in th
he absence of any act or omissio
on attributed to them resulting in
n
deterioration o
of the quality of the fertilizer.
14. In
n Manoj Grover versus State o
of Punjab, CRM-M-4582-2008
8
on 15.12.2009 , this Court held
d that no offence under Section
n
date of decisi
7(1)(a) of Ess
sential Commodities Act, 1955
is made out qua the petitioner,
,
who is only a d
dealer and is not responsible for
the sub-standard fertilizer in the
e
bag lying in h
his custody duly stitched, sealed
d and which was ordered from
m
Indian Potash
Company Limited, Ludhiana, w
who had further actually received
d
the DAP from
m M/s Oswal Chemicals and Fer
rtilizers Misadia, Village Orissa.
.
Neither the Go
overnment Agency Indian Potas
sh Limited nor petitioner’s firm
m
M/s Deepak F
ertilizers and Chemicals, Amloh
h or M/s Gurunanak Khad Store,
,
Fatehgarh Sah
hib were actual manufacturers o
of the said DAP (Oswal) which
h
was recovered
d by the complainant, there is no
allegation that the stitched bags
s
were tampered
d with. Thus, the non-complianc
ce of the standard, if at all, can
n
only be attribu
uted to the manufacturer M/s O
Oswal Chemicals and Fertilizers
s
Misadia, Villa
age Orissa and not to either th
he M/s Deepak Fertilizers and
d
Chemicals or
the Chief Manager, Indian P
Potash Company Limited. The
e
petition was al
llowed and the complaint was qu
uashed.
15. In
n Ghanvir Singh versus State of
f Punjab, CRM-M-28723-2010,
,
on 30.07.2012 also, a Coordinat
te Bench of this Court observed
d
date of decisio
that liability
could not be imposed on the d
distributor. In that case, the
JYOTI
2026.11.17 19:35
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
9
CRM-M-467
794-2017(O&M)
sample of DA
AP manufactured by Oswal Ch
hemical and Fertilizer Limited
d
Paradeep, Oris
ssa, supplied by Indian Potash Li
imited was drawn from machine
e
stitched bags.
Since the petitioner was not m
manufacturer of the insecticides,
,
but the suppli
ier, the Court held that he cou
uld not be held responsible for
r
misbranding th
he insecticide which was not m
manufactured by him when there
e
was nothing o
on record to suggest that the ins
secticides has not been properly
y
stored by the p
petitioner before its supply. The p
petitioner being the supplier had
d
no way of asc
ertaining that insecticide in any
way contravened any provision
n
of the Act.
16. Si
imilarly in Arun Kumar and O
Others versus State of Punjab
b
R (Criminal) 231, the accused pu
urchased bags of fertilizer from
m
1995 (3) RCR
National Ferti
lizer Limited and kept the sam
me in original form, without any
y
tampering. Sam
mple from bags was found to b
be sub-standard. The Court held
d
that it could
not be said that accused had
any culpable mental state for
r
committing of
ffence and for manufacturing d
defect, accused cannot be held
d
responsible.
17. In
n CRM-M-16232 of 2010 titled
“Kulwinder Singh versus State
e
ecided on 09.11.2010, this Cou
urt observed that there are no
o
of Punjab de
allegations tha
at stitched bags were tampered w
with and the non-compliance of
f
the standard, if
f at all, can only be attributed to
the manufacturer and not to the
e
petitioner, wh
ho had admittedly purchased/
d/got supplied the bags from
m
distributor firm
m.
18. St
till further in M/s S.S. Fertil
lizers Ludhiana and Another
r
3
versus State o
of Punjab, CRM-M-19185-201
9, date of decision 23.01.2023
petitioners we
ere summoned in a complaint
filed under Clause 19 of the
e
JYOTI
2026.11.17 19:35
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
10
CRM-M-467
794-2017(O&M)
Fertilizer (Co
ontrol) Order, 1985 read with
h Section 3 of the Essential
l
Commodities
Act, 1955 punishable under S
Section 7 of the said Act vide
e
summoning or
rder dated 07.03.2019. This Cou
urt, relying upon the judgment in
n
gh’s case supra and M/s Kisan
Ghanvir Sing
Beej Bhandar, Abohar versus
s
Chief Agricul
ltural Officer, Ferozepur and
another, 1990 Supreme Court
t
623 held that the sample was dra
awn from machine stitched bags
s
Cases (Crl.) 6
and, thus, the r
ratio of the said judgment is squ
arely applicable. The complaint,
,
the summonin
g order and subsequent proceedi
ings were, accordingly, quashed
d
qua the petition
ners.
19. In
n M/s Brij Lal and Sons and A
Another versus State of Punjab,
,
2023 as well the Court held that
t
CRM-M-3605
52-2021, date of decision 19.12.2
the petitioners
s who were dealers of the ma
anufacturers could not be held
d
vicariously lia
able and penalized for misbrandi
ing of the product as the sample
e
was drawn fr
rom original packing for the
purpose of sampling and the
e
petitioners wer
re not at all involved in manufac
cturing process.
20. In
n M/s R.S. Fertilizers Ludhian
na and Others versus State of
f
ate of decision 28.05.2024 also,
,
Punjab and O
Others, CRM-M-19157-2019, da
the complaint
under Section 19(a) of the Ferti
ilizer (Control) Order 1985 read
d
with Section
3 of the Essential Commoditie
es Act, 1955 punishable under
r
Section 7 of
the Essential Commodities Ac
ct, 1955 was quashed qua the
e
petitioners (de
ealer firm) as the sample of ferti
ilizers was drawn from machine
e
stitched bags a
and the dealer was not held liab
ble. Similar position of law was
s
reiterated in M
M/s FMC India Private Limite
d and Another versus State of
f
Haryana 2026
6(1) R.C.R. (Criminal) 786.
JYOTI
2026.11.17 19:35
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
11
CRM-M-467
794-2017(O&M)
21. T
The fact that M/s Mosaic India P
rivate Limited is the importer of
f
the misbrande
ed fertilizer DAP is not denied
d or disputed. The sample was
s
collected from
m the premises of the dealer fi
irm i.e. M/s Sandeep Fertilizer
r
Sales Corpora
ation during an inspection co
onducted on 24.07.2013. The
e
fertilizer was
sold by M/s Mosaic India Priva
ate Limited and Another to M/s
s
Sandeep Fert
tilizer Sale Corporation vide
bill No. 5058000457 dated
d
18.07.2013. Th
he genuineness of the invoice is
s not disputed. It is not the case
e
put forth in th
he complaint that the sample w
was not properly stored or was
s
found in unse
aled condition. Since the admit
tted position is that the sample
e
was drawn fro
m original machine stitched bag
gs, no criminal liability under the
e
Essential Com
mmodities Act, 1955 can be fas
stened on the dealer or on the
e
importer who
sold the fertilizer to the dealer,
, in the absence of allegation in
n
the complaint
regarding tampering, improper
storage, knowledge of the sub-
-
standard qualit
ty or involvement in the manufa
acturing process resulting in sub-
-
standard qualit
ty of the fertilizer.
22. Pe
etitioners cannot be prosecuted
d for the manufacturing defect,
,
over which th
hey had no control. As such, pr
rosecution of the dealer and the
e
importer and t
their officials/partner for offenc
ces under Section 19(A) of the
e
Fertilizer (Co
ontrol) Order 1985 read with
h Section 3 of the Essential
l
Commodities A
Act, 1955 must be terminated by
y exercising inherent jurisdiction
n
under Section
n 482 Cr.P.C. Subjecting the p
petitioners to the rigmarole of
f
criminal trial, w
would be abuse of the process of
f law and cannot be perpetuated.
23. B
Both petitions are, therefore, allow
wed. The complaint No.COMA-
-
8865-2015 dat
ted 15.12.2015 under Section 1
9(A) of the Fertilizer (Control)
)
JYOTI
2026.11.17 19:35
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
12
CRM-M-467
794-2017(O&M)
Order 1985 re
ead with Section 3 of the Essent
tial Commodities Act, 1955 and
d
all subsequent
proceedings are hereby quashed
d qua the petitioners.
(SHALINI SINGH NAGPAL)
)
JUDGE
16.11.2026
Jyoti-V
Whether Speaking/Reasoned :
Whether Reportable :
Yes/No
Yes/No
JYOTI
2026.11.17 19:35
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document