M/S Anil Service Station And Another vs Union Of India And Others
- Court
- Allahabad High Court
AFR
2026:AHC:234806
Reserved :
November 03, 2026
Delivered :
November 17, 2026
HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT ALLAHABAD
WRIT - C No. - 33055 of 2010
M/s Anil Service Station and another
…..Petitioner(s)
Versus
Union of India and others
…..Respondent(s)
Counsel for Petitioner(s) : Anil Kumar Mehrotra, Rajeev
Trivedi, Shashi Kant Shukla, Srijan
Mehrotra
Counsel for Respondent(s) : A.S.G.I., Anand Tiwari, P. Padia,
Pramod Kumar Rai, S.C.
Court No. - 36
HON'BLE SAURABH SHYAM SHAMSHERY, J.
1. This is second round of litigation. The petitioners have earlier
approached this Court when Appellate Authority has dismissed the
appeal filed by petitioners on 04.04.2008 upholding that order of
termination of dealership of petitioners was legally sustainable. For
reference, order dated 04.04.2008 passed in Writ C No. 30556/2008 is
quoted below in its entirety :-
“Heard Sri M.D. Singh ‘Shekhar’, learned
Senior Advocate assisted by Sri Sanjay Kumar
Singh, learned counsel for the petitioner, Sri
Prakash Padai, learned counsel for respondent
nos. 2 to 4 and learned Additional Solicitor
General of India for Union of India.
2
WRIC No. - 33055 of 2010
Petitioner was appointed as dealer for sale of
oil and oil products of Indo-Burmah Petroleum
Corporation Limited (for short IBP
Corporation’) under letter of the Divisional
st
Manager, IBP Corporation dated 31 October,
2005(Annexure-2 to the writ petition). An
agreement was also executed between the
st
petitioner and IBP Corporation on 31 October,
2005 (as is admitted in paragraph-4 of the
writ petition), a copy of the same has been
produced before this Court at the time of
hearing (neither the execution nor the terms
and conditions of the agreement are in dispute
between the parties.
IBP Corporation has since been merged with
Indian Oil Corporation Ltd. With all rights
and obligations. The dealers appointed by the
IBP Corporation are treated to be the dealers
of Indian Oil Corporation on same terms and
conditions. There is no dispute in that regard
between the parties.
th
On 25 June, 2007 samples of Motor Spirit and
High Speed Diesel were drawn from the nozzle
of the delivery pump established at the retail
outlet of the petitioner. A ‘Market Test’ was
carried out by the representatives of SGS
th
India Private Limited. On 26 June, 2007,
sales and supplied of the petroleum products
from the retail outlet of the petitioner was
suspended as the samples failed the Marker
Test, under order of the Deputy Manager
(Retail Sales, Indian Oil Corporation Ltd.,
th
Varanasi. On 28 June, 2007, the petitioner
stated to have sent a letter to the Indian Oil
Corporation with a prayer that fresh
inspection should be made and samples be drawn
in the presence of the petitioner. This was
th
followed by another letter dated 16 August,
2007 for the said purpose.
th
However, under letter dated 11 October, 2007,
the petitioner was invited to appear for
th
testing of the second sample drawn on 25
June, 2007 at the laboratory at Mughalsarai
th
Terminal on 15 October, 2007 at the time
fixed. Laboratory test of the retained sample
th
was done at Mughalsarai Terminal on 15
October, 2007 in the presence of the
representative of the petitioner and the
samples again failed the Marker Test.
3
WRIC No. - 33055 of 2010
For the purposes of carrying out the Marker
Test after nearly five months of the date on
which the samples were drawn from one Nozzle
of the retail outlet of the petitioner at
Mughalsarai Terminal, approval was also
obtained from the competent authority, which
added a note that for delay of five months,
explanation of the officers concerned be
called for.
On the basis of the failure of the samples, a
show cause notice was issued to the petitioner
calling upon him to submit a written
explanation for the irregularities mentioned
in notice itself within ten days, falling
which the Corporation will have no other
option but to take action against the
dealership of the petitioner as per Marketing
Discipline Guidelines 2005 and relevant
clauses of standard dealership agreement.
Petitioner instead of submitting his reply to
the notice issued filed Civil Misc. Writ
Petition No. 52580 of 2007, which was disposed
th
vide order dated 30 October, 2007 by
providing that the petitioner may submit his
reply within ten days from the date of order
and General Manager, Indian Oil Corporation
Ltd., U.P. State Office-II, Kapoorthala
Complex, Aliganj, Lucknow was directed to
conclude the proceedings within fifteen days
thereafter.
Petitioner submitted his reply to the notice
th
so issued vide letter dated 5 November, 2007
and pointed out that under Clause- 2.10 of the
Marketing Discipline Guidelines, samples
collected from the retail outlet of the
petitioner should have reach the laboratory
for testing, within ten days and the testing
must have been carried out at the laboratory
within 20 days. Results of such testing are
required to be communicated to the dealer
within next 5 days. The total aforesaid period
would work out to 35 days only. It was pointed
out that in the facts of the case, the Indian
Oil Corporation had taken 110 days for testing
the samples, which was per se illegal. It was
further pointed out that TT Retention Samples
were available at the retail outlet, and an
information to that effect was sent by a
letter, however, the TT Retention Samples were
not collected nor tested. Other discrepancies
4
WRIC No. - 33055 of 2010
in taking of the samples were also pointed
out.
The Indian Oil Corporation did not find the
explanation furnished by the petitioner
satisfactory. Accordingly the dealership of
the petitioner was terminated, having been
found guilty of adulteration, as per order of
the General Manager, U.P. State Office,
Lucknow of Indian Oil Corporation dated 24th
January, 2008. It has been recorded in the
order that delay in testing of samples will
not affect the quality of samples, hence no
prejudice has been caused to the petitioner.
It is further recorded that TT Retention
Samples were not made available to M/s SGS
Indian Private Limited as per its report dated
25th June, 2007 as they were not properly
sealed. The explanation that the TT Retention
Samples were kept in Almirah was therefore,
not accepted.
The termination order of the dealership of the
petitioner itself provided that as per clause
no. (iv) of the 'Notes' in Chapter 6 of
Marketing Discipline Guidelines-2005, the
petitioner has a right of an appeal against
the order before the Executive Director
(Retail Sales), Indian Oil Corporation
Limited, Indian Oil Bhawan, G-9 Ali Yavar Jung
Marg, Bandra (East), Mumbai-51.Petitioner
accordingly preferred an appeal before the
Executive Director. The appeal filed by the
petitioner has also been dismissed under the
order of the Executive Director dated 4th
April, 2008. It is against these two orders
that the present writ petition has been filed.
An amendment application has been filed ,
which has been allowed vide order dated dated
24th April, 2009 for bringing on record the
amendments made under the Government Order
dated 31st December, 2008, to the Motor Spirit
and High Speed Diesel Regulation of Supply
Distribution and Prevention of Malpractices)
Order, 2005 (hereinafter referred to as the
'Order, 2005'), whereby w.e.f. 12th January,
2009, the Marker Test for judging adulteration
in the petroleum products has been
discontinued.
Learned counsel for the petitioner contended
that there has been inordinate delay in
testing of the samples drawn from the nozzle
5
WRIC No. - 33055 of 2010
of the retail outlet of the petitioner,
further the TT Retention Samples were neither
taken nor tested. Lastly, it is submitted that
the very basis on which the dealership has
been cancelled, namely Marker Test itself has
been found to be dis- effective/inconclusive
to judge adulteration, therefore, discontinued
under the Government Order w.e.f. 12th
January, 2009.
A heavy reliance has been placed upon Clause
2.10 of Chapter-2 (Industry Guidelines For
Sample Collection and Testing) of Marketing
Discipline Guidelines, with reference to time
frame provided for collection of the sample,
transmission of the same to laboratory and
testing thereof as well as for communication
of the test report.
Learned counsel for the petitioner clarifies
that the time framed fixed under Clause 2.10,
has to be strictly followed and the total
period provided would work out to 35 days from
the date of drawal of the sample. In the facts
of the present case the Indian Oil Corporation
has taken 110 days to test the samples from
the date of drawal, which makes the entire
exercise illegal.
On behalf of the respondents a counter
affidavit has been filed and a preliminary
objection has been raised, with regard to the
maintainability of the present writ petition,
with specific reference to Clause 62 (a) of
the agreement executed between the parties,
which provides that any dispute in relation
to, or arising thereto, as per the agreement,
shall be referred to sole arbitrator i.e. the
Director (Marketing) of IBP Corporation, who
may either himself act as the Arbitrator or
nominate some other officer of IBP to act as
the Arbitrator, with a specific condition that
no objection can be raised with regard to
appointment of such arbitrator on the ground
that the arbitrator is an officer of IBP.
Reliance in that regard has been placed upon
the Division Bench Judgement of Lucknow Bench
of this Court in the case of M/s Balaji
Filling Station Ltd. & Anr. vs. Bharat
Petroleum Corporation Ltd & Anr. passed in
Civil Misc. Writ Petition No. 10867 (MB) of
2008, decided on 3rd December, 2008 as well as
upon the judgements of the Hon'ble Supreme
Court of India in the case of P. Anand
6
WRIC No. - 33055 of 2010
Gajapathi Raju vs. P.V.G. Raju reported in
(2000) 4 SCC 539, Hindustan Petroleum
Corporation Ltd. vs. Pink City Midway
Petroleum, reported in (2003) 6 SCC 503,
A.B.L. International Ltd. vs. Export Credit
Guarantee Corporation, reported in (2004) 3
SCC 553, Rashtiya Ispat Nigam Ltd. vs. Verma
Transport reported in (2006) 7 SCC 275, Bharat
Sewa Sansthan vs. U.P. Electronics Corporation
Ltd. reported in (2006) 7 SCC 737, Agra Gold
Exims Ltd. vs. Sri Laxmi Knits & Woven
reported in (2007) 3 SCC 686, The Empire Jute
Co. Ltd. vs. The Jute Corporation of India
Ltd. Reported in JT 2007 (12) SC 391, National
Highways Authority of India vs. Ganga
Enterprises reported in (2003) 7 SCC 410,
Sanjana M. Wig vs. Hindustan Petroleum
Corporation Ltd. reported in (2005) 8 SCC 242,
Kerala SEB vs. Kurient E. Kalathil reported in
(2000) 6 SCC 293.
On merit it has been explained that although
there has been some delay in sending of the
samples and testing of the same at laboratory,
but in view of Clause 2.5 of Marketing
Discipline Guidelines, it is apparently clear
that time prescribed is only for streamlining
the system and is not in any way related to
the quality and result of the product. It is
stated that one of the reason for delay in
testing of samples was because of merger of
the IBP Corporation ltd. with Indian Oil
Corporation Ltd.
In rejoinder it has been stated on behalf of
the petitioner that since the appellate order
has been passed by the Executive Director
(Retail Sales) Indian Oil Corporation Ltd.
(Marketing Division), Mumbai, any arbitration
by the same officer as has been provided under
Clause- 62 of the agreement between the
parties would virtually be an appeal from
ceaser to ceaser's wife.
I have considered the submissions made by the
learned counsel for the parties and have gone
through the records of the present writ
petition.
The Court may first consider the preliminary
objection qua the remedy of arbitration. The
order impugned as has been passed by the
Executive Director, Marketing in his capacity
as the Appellate Authority under the Marketing
7
WRIC No. - 33055 of 2010
Discipline Guidelines. Arbitration application
as per clause 62 (a) of the dealership
agreement has to be filed before him He is to
act as the Arbitration or can appointment some
other officer or the same. In the aforesaid
factual background, the reply of the
petitioner to preliminary objection i.e.
asking the petitioner to avail the remedy of
arbitration under Clause-62 would only be an
remedy from ceaser to ceaser's wife is
justified. Alternative remedy should a real
remedy and not a mere formality.
In the facts of the present case, this Court
is satisfied that the preliminary objection
qua the matter being referred for arbitration
has to be rejected. This Court may record that
with the enforcement of Marketing Discipline
Guidelines-2005, which provide for an appeal
against cancellation of dealership, a dealer
has been provided two remedies one by way of
appeal and the other by way of arbitration,
both before the same authority i.e. Director
Marketing. If the dealer has chosen the remedy
of appeal, I am of the considered opinion that
the remedy of arbitration is lost, inasmuch as
once the appellate authority has decided the
matter in that capacity, he cannot hear and
decide the same matter in a different
capacity. (Reference Dr. Bishambhar Dayal vs.
Aligarh Muslim University through Vice-
Chancellor & Ors; 1993 ALR (22) 213). The
judgements relied upon by the learned counsel
for the respondents are clearly
distinguishable on facts noticed above. It has
been repeatedly held by the Hon'ble Supreme
Court that a little difference in the facts or
additional facts may make a lot of difference
in the precedential value of a judgment
(Reference Bhavnagar University vs. Palitana
Sugar Mills (P) Ltd. & Ors. reported in 2003
(2) SCC, 111, which has recently been followed
in the case of Rajveer Singh vs. Chaudhary
Devi Lal, reported in AIR 2008 SCW 5817). The
Court holds that in the facts of the present
case, arbitration would not be the proper
remedy.
Now turning to the merits of the case. The the
appellate order has only recorded that the
time prescribed for testing of the samples is
only for streamlining the proceedings and does
not affect the quality of the samples as per
clause 2.5 of the Marketing Discipline
8
WRIC No. - 33055 of 2010
Guidelines. What has not been examined by the
appellate authority is as to whether infact
the delay of 110 days in testing of the
samples would adversely affect its quality and
as to whether such delay would in any way
affect the testing report obtained thereof.
This Court may also note that in between the
Government of India has itself done away with
Marker Test as is established from the
amendments made in Order, 2005 vide
notification dated 31st December, 2008, which
has been brought on record as Annexure-22 to
the writ petition (by way of amendment
application). The issuance of the said
notification is not in dispute between the
parties.
Thus, two issues are up for consideration
before this Court (a) whether delay of 110
days in testing of the samples would in any
way affect its quality or not and (b) whether
such delay is technical in nature and does not
substantially affect any rights of the
petitioner. The aforesaid issues need
examination in the background that the
Government of India has itself done away with
Marker Test, as is established from the
amendments made in Order, 2005 vide
st
notification dated 31 December, 2008. It has
to be kept in mind that establishment of
retail outlet incurs heavy expenditure and is
bread and butter to the dealer concerned. The
same is not to be cancelled unless there is
conclusive evidence of adulteration by the
dealers. This Court feels that impact of
withdrawal of marker test, which had remain in
force only for a short duration of two years
also needs examination in the aforesaid
background. The Corporation is the best judge
to satisfy itself as to whether the dealership
is liable to be cancelled on the baiss of
marker test only specifically in the
background that such test at laboratory was
done after 11 days of the drawal of the
samples and when the marker test itself has
been withdrawn by the Government of India
basically for the reason that the marker test
has not been found to conclusive for coming to
the conclusion that there has been
adulteration in the petroleum product, meaning
thereby that the authencity of such marker
test itself has been found to be doubtful.
9
WRIC No. - 33055 of 2010
In such circumstances, the order passed by the
appellate authority i.e. Marketing Director
th
dated 4 April, 2008 cannot be legally
sustained and I hereby quashed.
Let the Marketing Director examine the matter
afresh in light of the observations made above
and pass a reasoned speaking order, preferably
within four weeks from the date a certified
copy of this order is filed before him.
The writ petition is allowed subject to the
observations made above.”
2. The I.O.C.L. has filed a review application, however, same was
dismissed by following order dated 05.02.2010 :-
“Hon. Arun Tandon, J.
Heard learned counsel for the applicant.
This review application is disposed of by
providing that the matter shall be examined in
nd
light of the judgment of this Court dated 02
July, 2009 by the authority who had passed the
appellate order dated 04.04.2008.”
3. In pursaunce of above order, the Appellate Authority has passed a
fresh order on 10.05.2010 and relevant part thereof is quoted below :-
“In pursuance of Hon'ble High Court's order, I
have examined the matter in the light of
specific observations of the Hon'ble Court
that the issue needs to be examined
specifically in the background that such test
at the laboratory was done after 110 days of
the drawal of sample and when the Marker Test
itself has been withdrawn by the Govt. of
India basically for the reason that the Marker
test has not been found to be conclusive for
coming to the conclusion that there has been
adulteration in the petroleum products.
My observations on both the issues are as
under:
As per information available, Markers
remain stable and active over very long
periods, which is proved in this case
also by the mere fact that the test
conducted after 110 days showed the same
10
WRIC No. - 33055 of 2010
result as was observed in on the spot
test.
Further, Marker tests results are not
reflective of/related to/affected by the
intrinsic quality of the fuel (in this
case HSD) being tested, but confirm
whether the fuel has been adulterated by
an adulterant, which is marked by Marker.
Positive result both on the spot and
after 110 days confirms that the fuel (in
this case HSD) had been adulterated.
2. It is also confirmed that Marker test is a
fully conclusive test with respect to
adulteration of the fuel with Marker doped
adulterant and the positive results
conclusively prove that the product has been
adulterated with Marker doped Kerosene. The
discontinuation of the Marker system since
January 2009 was in no way related to the
reason that it was found to be an inconclusive
test.
The merits of the case, hence, have not at all
been affected by testing of retention sample
after 110 days as detailed above and also due
to the fact that positive result of the Marker
test always conclusively indicate that the
produce has been adulterated.
My observations on other grounds against
termination mentioned by the appellant in her
appeal dated 28.02.2008 are as under:
The dealership had committed
irregularities on 17.05.2007 by refusing
SGS to conduct Marker Test at the RO.
However, as per MDG 2005, this
irregularity does not attract the penal
action of termination in the first
instance and the dealership has not been
terminated for the same. The termination
is on account of adulteration detected at
the RO in subsequent marker test carried
out by SGS on 25.06.2007.
The contention of the dealer that TT
Retention samples were properly sealed
but were kept in lock and keys with the
person not present as such could not be
provided, is not correct. SGS
representative has mentioned on the test
report prepared by him that the TT Sample
11
WRIC No. - 33055 of 2010
was without seal or sample label and
therefore the same was not collected. The
report has also been signed by the
Appellant's representative.
Depot retention sample was could not be
tested in presence of dealer as the same
was already tested on 03.08.2007 and test
report was produced by lab officials to
the team present to witness the test. As
per the test report the depot retention
sample had passed in marker test.
The HSD sample of the RO failed in Marker test
conducted by SGS on 25.6.07. Moreover, the
retention sample also failed during lab test
on 15.10.07. Since the dealer had not
maintained TT retention sample properly
(without seal or sample lebel), it could not
be tested. The TLF sample was tested earlier
and had passed the marker test. The test
report was produced by the Lab Official to the
team present to witness the test. Thus, under
the guidelines, adulteration at the subject RO
has been established. Having examined the case
afresh in light of specific observations of
Hon’ble High Court, it is considered that
there is nothing to interfere with the order
of termination dt. 24.01.2008 or the order of
earlier Appellate Authority dt. 04.04.2008.
The appeal, therefore, stands dismissed.”
4. Aforesaid order dated 10.05.2010 is under challenge in present
writ petition.
5. According to order sheet, there is no interim order, therefore,
petitioners’ dealership is still under termination.
6. Sri Srijan Mehrotra and Ms. Falguni Mehrotra, learned advocates
for petitioners have vehemently referred order passed by this Court in
earlier round of litigation and directions made therein that it was not
decided that marker test conducted after 110 days was legally
permissible or not since it will not remain stable after such a long period.
Effect of a fact that marker test was discontinued in the year 2009 was
also not considered that it was not reliable. The TT retention sample was
12
WRIC No. - 33055 of 2010
not collected despite they were available in a safe place. Principles of
natural justice were also violated.
7. Learned advocates for petitioners have placed reliance upon
judgments of Supreme Court in Harbanslal Sahnia and another vs. Indian
Oil Corporation Ltd and others, (2003) 2 SCC 107 and Hindustan
Petroleum Corporation Limited and others vs. Super Highway Services
and another, (2010) 3 SCC 321 and for reference, relevant paragraphs of
Hindustan Petroleum (supra) is quoted below :-
“32. In the instant case, we are inclined to
agree with Mr Bhatt's submissions that the High
Court did not commit any error in allowing the
writ petition filed by Respondent 1 herein, upon
holding that notice of the laboratory test to be
conducted at Barauni Terminal had not been
served upon Respondent 1, which has caused
severe prejudice to the said respondent since
its dealership agreement was terminated on the
basis of the findings of such test. Admittedly
the dealership agreement was terminated on the
ground that the product supplied by the
petitioner Corporation was contaminated by the
respondent. Such contamination was sought to be
proved by testing the TT retention sample in the
laboratory at Barauni Terminal.
33. The guidelines being followed by the
Corporation require that the dealer should be
given prior notice regarding the test so that he
or his representative also can be present when
the test is conducted. The said requirement is
in accordance with the principles of natural
justice and the need for fairness in the matter
of terminating the dealership agreement and it
cannot be made an empty formality. Notice should
be served on the dealer sufficiently early so as
to give him adequate time and opportunity to
arrange for his presence during the test and
there should be admissible evidence for such
service of notice on the dealer. Strict
adherence to the above requirement is essential,
in view of the possibility of manipulation in
the conduct of the test, if it is conducted
behind the back of the dealer.
34. In the present case, there is no admissible
evidence to prove service of notice on the
respondent or refusal of notice by the
13
WRIC No. - 33055 of 2010
respondent. Further, the notice dated 28-5-2008
which was allegedly refused by the respondent,
did not give him adequate time to arrange for
the presence of himself or his representative
during the test to be conducted at 3.00 p.m. on
29-5-2008. It is also to be noted that the
endorsement regarding the alleged refusal is
dated 29-5-2008 itself. Thus, the termination of
the dealership agreement of the respondent was
arbitrary, illegal and in violation of the
principles of natural justice.”
8. Per contra, Sri P.K. Rai, learned counsel for respondents has
supported impugned orders that direction made by this Court in earlier
round were complied with. The Appellate Authority has considered the
directions and held that marker test remained vital even after 110 days
since adulteration was still found. The validity of marker test was upheld
by this Court as well as by the Supreme Court. The marker test was
discontinued in the year 2009 would not mean that earlier it was not
scientifically proved. There is a limited scope of judicial review of such
cases where test was found positive.
9. I have considered submissions of learned advocates for rival
parties and perused the records.
10. This Court while disposing off Writ C No. 30556/2008 has
remitted the matter to Appellate Authority to give specific consideration
in regard to two issues that there was delay of 110 days in testing the
sample and whether such delay would effect right of the petitioners or
not as well as marker test was discontinued later on or not. The Appellate
Authority has considered above issues, however, returned a finding in
negative that marker test remained viral and sustainable even after such a
long period and no prejudiced was caused to petitioners as well as that
TT retention sample was not properly sealed.
11. The Supreme Court in M/s HPCL and others vs. Dharamnath
Singh and others, 2024 INSC 449, in similar circumstances, has held as
follows :-
14
WRIC No. - 33055 of 2010
“ 8. It is necessary to refer to certain Rules,
Regulations/provisions of documents for being
part of the record to examine the issue in the
present lis . For ease of reference, they are
extracted hereunder:
Provisions of the Agreement and other relevant
documents
I. Agreement inter se parties
Certain clauses of the agreement between the
parties dated 1.2.1997, relevant to the present
dispute:
“4. The licence and permission granted as
aforesaid for the use of the outfit shall
terminate immediately on the termination of this
Agreement or on any breach of any of the terms
thereof.
Xxx
26. The dealer shall be responsible for all
loss, contamination, damage or shortage of or to
the products whether partial or entire, and no
claim will be entertained by the corporation
therefor under any circumstances except in cases
where the corporation is satisfied that loss
arose from leakage from underground tanks or
pipes which the dealer could not reasonably have
discovered and of which the dealer gave
immediate notice in writing to the corporation
on discovery. Corporation will consider
compensation only from the date of receipt of
notice till leakage is rectified.
27. All the products supplied by the Corporation
to the dealer hereunder shall be in accordance
with the specifications laid down by the
Corporation from time to time. The dealer shall
take every possible precaution against
contamination of the corporation's products by
water, dirt or other things injurious to their
quality and shall not in any way directly or
indirectly alter the specifications of the said
products as delivered. The Corporation shall
have the right to exercise at its discretion at
any time and from time to time quality control
measures for products marketed by the
corporation and lying with the dealer the
opinion of the Chief Regional Manager for the
time being at the corporation's Regional Office
at Calcutta as to whether any product of the
15
WRIC No. - 33055 of 2010
corporation has been contaminated shall be final
and binding upon the dealer, in the event of the
said Chief Regional Manager finding that the
contamination has been due to any Act or default
of the dealer or of his servants or Agents, the
corporation shall have the right, without being
bound to do so, to remove the contaminated
product and to destroy or otherwise deal with
the same without making any payment therefor to
the dealer and without prejudice to the
corporation's right to terminate this Agreement
forthwith.
Xxx
39. The Corporation will be entitled to all
times to enter into the premises and inspect the
management of the retail outlet by the said
dealer in all respects and the dealer shall be
bound to render all assistance and give all
information to the corporation and its duly
authorized representatives in that behalf and
produce to the corporation and/or its duly
authorised representatives in that behalf
whenever required to do so, receipts, for all
payments which it is dealer's duty to make
whether under the terms of this agreement or
otherwise.
Xxx
44. The dealer undertakes faithfully and
promptly to carry out, observe and perform all
directions, or rules given or made from time to
time by the corporation for the proper carrying
on of the dealership of the corporation. The
dealer shall scrupulously observe and comply
with all laws, rules regulations and
requisitions of the central/state government and
of all authorities appointed by them or either
of them including in particular the chief
controller of explosives, government of India,
and/or municipal and/or any other local
authority with regard to the storage and sale of
such petroleum products.
Xxx
58. Notwithstanding anything to the contrary
herein contained, the Corporation shall also be
at liberty to terminate this Agreement forthwith
on or at any time after the happening of any of
the following events, namely:
16
WRIC No. - 33055 of 2010
xxx
H) If the dealer does not adhere to the
instructions issued from time to time by the
corporation in connection with safe practices to
be followed by him in the supply/storage of the
Corporation's products or otherwise.
I) If the dealer shall contaminate or tamper
with the quality of any of the products supplied
by the Corporation.
M) If the dealer shall either by himself or by
his servants or agents commit or suffer to be
committed any act, in the opinion of the Chief
Regional Manager of the Corporation on the time
being at Calcutta whose decision shall be final,
is prejudicial to the interest or good name of
the Corporation or its products the Chief
Regional Manager shall not be bound to give
reason for such decision.”
II. The Motor Spirit and High Speed Diesel
(Regulation of Supply, Distributor and
Prevention of Malpractices) Order, 2005
“2. Definitions - in this order, unless the
context otherwise requires:
(a) “adulteration” means” [presence of marker in
motor spirit and high speed diesel and/or] the
introduction of any foreign substance into motor
spirit or high speed diesel illegally or
unauthorisedly with the result that the product
does not conform to the requirements of the
Bureau of Indian Standards specifications number
IS 2796 and IS 1460 for motor spirit and high
speed diesel respectively or any other
requirement notified by the Central Government
from time to time;
(b) “authorized officer” means an officer
authorized under the provisions of clause 7;”
xxx
“7. Power of search and seizure - (1) any
Gazette Officer of the Central Government or a
State Government or any Police Officer not below
the rank of Deputy Superintendent of Police duly
authorized, by general or special order of the
Central Government or a State Government, as the
case may be, or any officer of the oil company,
not below the rank of sales officer, may, with a
17
WRIC No. - 33055 of 2010
view to securing compliance with the provisions
of this Order, or for the purpose of satisfying
himself that this Order or any order made
thereunder has been complied with or there is
reason to believe that all or any of the
provisions of this Order have been and are being
or are about to be contravened, -
(a) enter and search any place or premises of a
dealer, transporter, consumer or any other
person who is an employee or agent of such
dealer or transporter or consumer;
(b) stop and search any person or vehicle or
receptacle used or intended to be used for
movement of the product;
(c) take samples of the product and seize any of
the stocks of the product and the vehicle or
receptacle or any other conveyance used or
suspected to be used for carrying such stocks
and thereafter take or authorize the taking all
measures necessary for securing the production
of stocks or items so seized before the
Collector or District Magistrate having
jurisdiction under the provisions of
the Essential Commodities Act, 1955 and for
their safe custody pending such production;
(d) inspect, seize and remove with, such aid or
assistance as may be necessary, books,
registers, any other records or documents of the
dealer, transporter, consumer or any other
person suspected to be an employee or agent of
the dealer, transporter or consumer;
(2) While exercising the power of seizure
provided under sub-clauses (c) and (d) above,
the authorized officer shall record in writing
the reasons for doing so and a copy of such
recording shall be provided to the dealer,
transporter, consumer or any other concerned
person, as the case may be.
(3) The provisions of S. 100 of the Criminal
Procedure Code, 1973 (2 of 1974) , relating to
search and seizure shall, as far as may be,
apply to searches and seizures under this Order.
III. Marketing discipline guidelines, 2005
“Chapter – 2
18
WRIC No. - 33055 of 2010
INDUSTRY GUIDELINES FOR SAMPLE COLLECTION AND
TESTING (3-TIER) SAMPLING SYSTEM)
xxx
2.2.2 AT RETAIL OUTLETS
At the Retail outlets, samples are required to
be drawn by the following:
2.2.2.1 By the dealer/his representative on
receipt of each supply through tank lories at
the retain outlet.
2.2.2.2 Oil companies have to draws the samples
from all tanks of retail outlets as given below:
a) From 1% of total No. of retail outlets under
each divisions/controlling office every month
till 31.12.05.
b) From 10% p.m. of the total number of retail
outlets w.e.f. 01.01.2006 which will be
progressively increased to 20% p.m. from
01.01.2007 and 50% p.m. from 01.01.2008.
2.2.2.3 Persons/agencies authorized to draws
samples are:
Oil company officials
Mobil labs
Agencies authorized by oil companies.
However, in case of stock variation beyond
permissible limits, density, failure, filter
paper test failure and during special
drives/campaigns or in case of specific
complaint against the retail outlets. Company
officials are to draw samples and forward them
for testing as per laid down procedure.
Samples are to be drawn from nozzle (s) of the
dispensing units from all tanks of both MS and
HSD by the persons/agencies as referred above.
All the inspecting officials shall bring their
own aluminum containers for drawing samples.
They will pay the cost of samples collected by
them and obtain cash memo for the same.”
Consideration and Conclusion
19
WRIC No. - 33055 of 2010
xxxxxxxx
10. What falls from the extract quoted above is
that any person who contravenes the Control
Order is liable to be punished by the Court.
Therefore, for a person to be prosecuted for
violating the provisions relating to search and
seizure contained in Clause (7) thereof, such a
person will have to be brought to the book,
particularly, for having violated the said
Control Order.
11. In contrast, as has been submitted by the
learned counsel for the appellants, the
respondent was sought to be prosecuted only for
the violation of the terms of the
agreement inter se the parties and not for any
other alleged violation, if any. 11
12. Keeping in view the aforesaid, the
submission of the respondents that R.M. Service
Centre (supra) does not aid the case of the
appellants, cannot be accepted. As already
noticed above, the respondent has not been
prosecuted for violation of the Control Order.
Reliance on Allied Motors (supra) in our
considered opinion, does not help the case of
the respondent, for therein, what was alleged
and ultimately held proved that the dealership
was terminated without a show cause notice and
in violation of principles of natural justice.
That is not the pleaded case of the respondent
herein.
13. In Hindustan Petroleum Corporation
Limited v. Super Highway Services 12 this Court
observed as under:
“ 31. The cancellation of dealership agreement of
a party is a serious business and cannot be
taken lightly. In order to justify the action
taken to terminate such an agreement, the
authority concerned has to act fairly and in
complete adherence to the rules/guidelines
framed for the said purpose. The non-service of
notice to the aggrieved person before the
termination of his dealership agreement also
offends the well-established principle that no
person should be condemned unheard. It was the
duty of the petitioner to ensure that Respondent
1 was given a hearing or at least serious
attempts were made to serve him with notice of
the proceedings before terminating his
agreement.
20
WRIC No. - 33055 of 2010
Xxx
33. The guidelines being followed by the
Corporation require that the dealer should be
given prior notice regarding the test so that he
or his representative also can be present when
the test is conducted. The said requirement is
in accordance with the principles of natural
justice and the need for fairness in the matter
of terminating the dealership agreement and it
cannot be made an empty formality. Notice should
be served on the dealer sufficiently early so as
to give him adequate time and opportunity to
arrange for his presence during the test and
there should be admissible evidence for such
service of notice on the dealer. Strict
adherence to the above requirement is essential,
in view of the possibility of manipulation in
the conduct of the test, if it is conducted
behind the back of the dealer.”
14. The crux of the above decision is that when
a dealership agreement is to be cancelled, it
has to be so done strictly in consonance with
Rules/Guidelines framed in that regard. When a
sampling test is being conducted a dealer is to
be given prior notice so as to ensure his or his
representative's presence can be secured. In the
present facts, the respondents have taken issue
with the process of collection of samples, being
aggrieved by the fact that a third party,
namely, SGS India was appointed to take samples
and not with the lack of service of notice or
any other such non-compliance of the principles
of natural justice as discussed in the said
judgment.
15. We have also perused the decision
in Harbanslal Sahnia v. Indian Oil
Corporation 13 . This judgment deals with the
correctness of writ proceedings in respect of
contractual matters. It was observed the
petitioner's dealership which was their “bread &
butter” came to be terminated for an irrelevant
and non-existent cause. As such, a writ petition
would be maintainable. The maintainability is
not an issue before us. Therefore, this judgment
is not applicable to the present case.
16. That apart, the observations in National
Insurance Company Ltd. v. Pranay Sethi , 14 tell
us that in deference to judicial discipline and
decorum, the judgments/orders passed by a
coordinate Bench are to be respected by another
21
WRIC No. - 33055 of 2010
Bench of co-equal strength. As such, we follow
the holding in R.M. Service Centre (supra).”
12. As observed above, since cancellation of dealership agreement of
a party is a serious business, therefore, it cannot be taken lightly. The
authority concerned has to act fairly and in complete adherence to the
rules/guidelines framed for the said purpose.
13. The guidelines referred above provides that all sample should be
safely collected before sending them to Laboratory for testing within a
period of 10 days from drawing sample, therefore, in case sample is
being examined after 110 days i.e. after more than 100 days’ delay, there
must be some justification for causing said delay, however, despite there
was an observation on proceedings that explanation must be provided,
still no explanation was provided. Even Appellate Authority has not
considered said issue and only on a ground that even after 110 days, test
remained positive that it was an adulterated petrol would not mean that
above scheme was strictly complied with as well as there was no
occasion that sample was adulterated by foreign elements. The
maximum limit of 45 testing was also expired.
14. There is nothing on record that sample was kept in a proper place
where no adulteration could be caused by anyone, therefore, in absence
of such explanation and discussion and consideration, Court is of the
view that there was no justification why sample was tested after 110
days of collection and therefore, petitioners are highly prejudiced.
15. In above background, an important factor that marker test was
discontinued in the year 2009 is also considered, since a reason to
discontinue it, was that it was not properly conducted though it would
not mean that every test conducted before 2009 was bad in law, however,
in present case, since it was conducted after 110 days, without even
material that it was at a place where no foreign element can be made
sample bad. No proper notice was issued to petitioner to remain present
during test being conducted after 110 day, this is also a violation of
safeguards.
22
WRIC No. - 33055 of 2010
16. Other consideration is about TT retention sample. Since it is a
categorical stand of petitioners that it was available on the date of
inspection but could not be provided since keys were not available,
therefore, when an opportunity was granted to collect the sample
afterwards, attempt was made by respondents to collect it which is also
gone against respondents and in favour of petitioners.
17. In aforesaid circumstances, Court is of the view that proper
procedure was not complied with. There was unexplained delay in
conducting test, therefore, fairness lacks.
18. Accordingly, both impugned orders are set aside and it is directed
that petitioners’ dealership be restored expeditiously preferably within
four weeks from today.
19. Writ petition is accordingly allowed.
(SAURABH SHYAM SHAMSHERY, J.)
November 17, 2026
<Nirmal>
Digitally signed by :-
NIRMAL SINHA
High Court of Judicature at Allahabad