M/S Angan Lal Raj Kumar vs Bharat Petroleum Corporation Ltd.

Court
Madhya Pradesh High Court

NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:91518
1 WP-10349-2010
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
AT JABALPUR

BEFORE
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE SANJEEV S KALGAONKAR
th
ON THE 17 OF NOVEMBER, 2026
WRIT PETITION No. 10349 of 2010
M/S ANGAN LAL RAJ KUMAR
Versus
BHARAT PETROLEUM CORPORATION LTD. AND OTHERS

Appearance:
Shri Prabhat Shukla - Advocate for the petitioner.
Shri Kapil Jain - Advocate for the respondent Nos.1, 2 and 3.
ORDER
This writ petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India is filed
requesting for following reliefs:-
"(i) That, this Hon'ble Court may be pleased to quash the impugned order and
the very enquiry conducted by the respondent No.1 of which the proceedings
have been recorded on 7.5.2010 and 18.5.2010 and fresh agency preferably
enquiry be ordered by an independent judicial officer, in the interest of by a
retired justice.
(ii) Any other order or orders that this Hon'ble Court deems fit and proper under
the facts and circumstances of the case may also kindly be passed along with the
cost of the petition."
2. The petitioner M/s Angan Lal Raj Kumar was operating retail outlet in
furtherance of dealership agreement dated 2.8.1966 with Burma Shell Oil
Storage and Distributing Company Ltd. (Annexure P/1). The Bharat
Petroleum Corporation Ltd., the successor of Burma Shell Company Ltd.,
continued dealership agreement with the petitioner for operating retail outlet
of petrol and diesel. The Inspector of Weights and Measure Department,
Rewa, inspected the dispensing units of petitioner on 28.8.2005 and
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: NIDHI DAVE
Signing time: 18-11-
2026 10:07:00

NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:91518
2 WP-10349-2010
submitted report (Annexure P/2). The technician of Bharat Petroleum Co.

Ltd. also inspected the dispensing units of petitioner on 24.9.2005 and
submitted report (Annexure P/3). Both the reports found no impropriety in
the dispensing unit of the petitioner.
3. The Quality Control Cell Team of Bharat Petroleum Corporation Ltd.
conducted a surprise inspection of dispensing units of the petitioner on
28.9.2025. The Quality Control Cell Team found that the double gear
assembly were fitted and operated through a mechanism of pin in four
dispensing units of the petitioner retail outlet. When the double gear
assembly mechanism was operated, the dispensing units dispensed lesser
quantity of fuel. On the basis of report of Quality Control Cell Team dated
28.9.2005 (Annexure P/4), a show cause notice was issued to the petitioner.
Thereafter, the dealership agreement of petitioner was terminated vide letter
dated 13.10.2006.
4. The petitioner assailed the order dated 13.10.2006 terminating his
dealership by the Bharat Petroleum Corporation Ltd. in W.P.
No.15556/2006. The Co-ordinate Bench of this Court vide order dated
13.9.2007 (Annexure P/5) disposed the writ petition. The Order dated
13.9.2007 passed in W.P.No.15556/2006 was assailed in writ appeal.
5. The Division Bench vide Order dated 15.12.2009 passed in W.A.
No.1514/2007 allowed the appeal and directed that the Committee
comprising officials/technicians of the Corporation and the Company, which
manufactured the dispensing units and the nominee of the Controller of
Weights and Measures, Government of Madhya Pradesh shall conduct a
fresh inquiry and the committee shall submit the report within a period of 3
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: NIDHI DAVE
Signing time: 18-11-
2026 10:07:00

NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:91518
3 WP-10349-2010
months. This order was assailed before the Supreme Court. The Supreme

Court, vide order dated 26.3.2010 passed in Civil Appeal No. 2759/2010,
partly allowed the appeal and directed that if the inquiry is not completed in
terms of the directions given by the High Court, the needful must be done
within a period of 2 months.
6. Accordingly, the meetings of the committee constituted in furtherance of
the order dated 15/12/2009 passed in W.A. No.1514/2007 were conducted.
Bharat Petroleum Corporation Limited reaffirmed the earlier termination
order dated 13/10/2006 vide letter dated 11/6/2010 (Annexure P/11) in
furtherance of the report of the committee.
7. The learned counsel for the petitioner, in addition to the facts and
grounds mentioned in the petition, contended that the Inspector of Weights
and Measures had inspected the dispensing units of the petitioner's retail
outlet on 28/8/2005. Further, the technician of the respondent company had
also inspected the dispensing units on 24/9/2005 and verified the proper
functioning of the dispensing units. Thereafter, on 28/9/2005 itself, the
Quality Control team opened the seal of the Weights and Measures
Department and reported certain discrepancies and improprieties in
dispensing the proper quantity of fuel by manipulation of the dispensing
units. The conduct of the Quality Control team was improper. Therefore, the
petitioner assailed the termination of the dealership agreement dated
13/10/2006.
8. Learned counsel further contended that the committee comprising
officials and technicians from the respondent organization, the original
equipment manufacturer and the nominee of the Weights and Measures
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: NIDHI DAVE
Signing time: 18-11-
2026 10:07:00

NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:91518
4 WP-10349-2010
Department did not conduct the inquiry in compliance with the order in

W.A. number 1514/2007 and the order of the Supreme Court dated
26/3/2010. The committee, without inspecting the dispensing units,
concluded that manipulation of the dispensing units was visible without
breaking the seal affixed by the Weights and Measures Department. The
report of inquiry committee is erroneous for the reason that the dispensing
unit installed at Mangawan in District Rewa was not physically inspected by
the members of the committee. The outcome of the meeting of the committee
was assailed by filing an objection dated 21/5/2010 (Annexure P-10), which
was not considered before reaffirming the dealership termination order dated
13/10/2006 by Respondent No. 1. The conduct and actions of Respondent
No. 1 are malafide and improper. Therefore, the dealership agreement
deserves to be restored.
9 . Per contra, learned counsel for Respondent Nos. 1 to 3 submitted that
the committee was duly constituted in furtherance of the directions in the
order dated 15/12/2009. The committee considered all aspects of the matter
in compliance with the order dated 26/3/2010 of the Supreme Court. Learned
counsel, referring to the minutes of the meeting of the committee, submitted
that apparently, the petitioner has manipulated the dispensing unit by
installing a double gear assembly to dispense a lesser amount of fuel from
the dispensing unit. The officials of the original equipment manufacturer i.e.
MIDCO and L&T have specifically stated that their dispensing units are not
fitted with any double gear or non-standard gear assembly at the time of
manufacturing. It goes to show that the petitioner had installed a double gear
assembly in the dispensing unit for wrongful gains. The Learned counsel
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: NIDHI DAVE
Signing time: 18-11-
2026 10:07:00

NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:91518
5 WP-10349-2010
contended that there is no impropriety in the conduct of the committee and

its outcome. Therefore, no case is made out for restoration of the dealership
agreement in favor of the petitioner. The learned counsel also pointed out
that the land on which the petitioner was operating the retail outlet was leased
in favour of Bharat Petroleum Corporation Limited. The lease has expired
and the possession is no longer available with Bharat Petroleum Corporation
Limited. Therefore, the petition is rendered infructuous.
10. Heard both the parties.
11. The Division Bench vide Order dated 15.12.2009 passed in W.A.
No.1514/2007(Annexure P-6) observed as under-
“It was, therefore, incumbent upon the respondent Corporation to have
included the officials of the Weights and Measures Department in the inspection
which was carried out on 10.10.2006 in pursuance to order dated 16.3.2006
passed in WP.No.4688/2006. Having failed to do so the opinion which is based
on presumption have no sanctity of law because the presumption howsoever
strong they may be cannot take the place of proof.
This Court is therefore, left with no option but to quash the order dated
13.10.2006, consequently, the order dated 13.09.2003 passed in W.P.
no. 1556/2006 is also set aside, but not without caveat.
Since the department of Weights and Measures vide their letters dated
16.11.2005 and 15.4.2006 had expressed their concern over the complaints
regarding short supply of petrol and diesel to the Consumers and that double
gear assembly were seized from four dispensing units, a fresh enquiry be held
by the team comprising of the officials/technicians of the Corporation and the
Company which manufactured the dispensing units in question and the nominee
of the Controller, Weights and Measures, Govt. of Madhya Pradesh who should
not be below the rank of Deputy Controller, wherein the appellant should also
be permitted to participate.
The committee shall furnish the report within a period of three months from
the date of communication of this order. In case the findings is recorded against
the appellant he shall be at liberty to take recourse to remedy available in civil
law. Till such decision is taken the retail outlet of the appellant situated at
National Highway No. 7, Mangwan, District Reawa be restored and the
appellant be allowed to operate the same subject to final outcome of the
enquiry."
12. The Supreme Court vide order dated 26.3.2010 passed in Civil
Appeal No. 2759/2010 (Annexure P-7), dismissed the appeal and directed as
under-
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: NIDHI DAVE
Signing time: 18-11-
2026 10:07:00

NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:91518
6 WP-10349-2010
If the appellant has already not completed enquiry in terms of the

direction given by the High Court, the needful must be done within a
period of two months from today. The officers of the Weights and
Measures Department of the Government of Madhya Pradesh should,
without fail, assist the team constituted by the appellant.
13. In compliance with the order dated 15.12.2009, a committee was
constituted, which held meetings on 07.05.2010 and 18.05.2010. The minutes
of the meeting dated 07.05.2010 (Annexure P/8) reveal that Shri Anil
Dalmia, representing the petitioner contended that no additional fitting could
be installed without tampering with the seal affixed by the Weights and
Measures Department. The representatives of MIDCO and L&T stated that
their dispensing units were not fitted with any double gear or non-standard
gear assembly at the time of manufacture. Shri Yogesh Gupta, representing
MIDCO, specifically confirmed this position in respect of the three MIDCO
units bearing Serial Nos. 9B3276, 6K 1504 and 02B2051 installed at the
retail outlet of the petitioner. Shri Ashish Shrivastav, representing L&T,
made a similar statement regarding the unit bearing Serial No. DWL&T 159.
Shri K.K. Bhawsar, Deputy Controller, Weights and Measures, stated that
the issue could not be decided on verbal statements alone. He considered it
necessary to examine the approved technical drawings, photographs, physical
assemblies and relevant product literature.
14. The minutes of the subsequent meeting dated 18.05.2010 (Annexure
P/9) reveal that the sealed envelope bearing the signatures of the dealer and
the inspecting team was opened in the presence of the participants. Four
seized double gear fittings, comprising three from MIDCO units and one
from an L&T unit and a clip with a wire were displayed. The metering
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: NIDHI DAVE
Signing time: 18-11-
2026 10:07:00

NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:91518
7 WP-10349-2010
assemblies of both manufacturers were also placed before the members for

examination. After examining the photographs and seized parts, the MIDCO
representative confirmed that the double gear fittings and the opening in the
gear cover were not supplied by the company and that the unit had been
modified. The L&T representative examined the approved drawings and
seized assembly and confirmed that the assembly was non-standard and had
not been manufactured or supplied by L&T. The L&T representative and the
Deputy Controller stated that the gear assembly of the modified L&T unit
could be removed and replaced by removing the connecting rod without
disturbing the seal. This was not possible in an unmodified unit. As regards
the MIDCO units, it was stated that the opening in the gear cover permitted
insertion of a pin or clip to alter delivery without disturbing the seal.
However, the MIDCO representative could not confirm whether the entire
double gear fitting could be installed without breaking the seal. Shri C.K.
Matlani, technician, also stated that the modifications permitted operation of
the non-standard fittings without disturbing the seal. The officials of the
Weights and Measures Department explained that verification involved
checking the accuracy of delivery. If a unit containing an unauthorised fitting
delivered fuel within permissible limits during testing, it could be stamped
and sealed without examination of the internal gear assembly. The
representatives of Bharat Petroleum Corporation Limited stated that the
Corporation did not supply non-standard gear fittings to its retail outlets.
They further stated that all four units at the retail outlet of petitioner had been
found tampered with and delivering fuel below permissible limits during the
surprise inspection. According to the Corporation, the petitioner was the sole
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: NIDHI DAVE
Signing time: 18-11-
2026 10:07:00

NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:91518
8 WP-10349-2010
beneficiary of such short delivery. Apparently, the committee and members

reached their conclusions regarding the tampered dispensing units and non-
standard gear assemblies through a clear, multi-step investigative process.
15. However, Shri Anil Kumar Dalmia, Partner representing the petitioner
disputed these findings. In his written objection to the committee report
(Annexure P/10), he contended that the committee had declined to conduct
physical verification of the dispensing units at the retail outlet at Mangawan
and had relied on unverified and irrelevant photographs. He further alleged
that he had been threatened and compelled to sign the proceedings under
duress. According to him, the committee had suppressed and distorted the
statements of the technical experts, who had stated that the seized double
gear assembly could not be installed or removed without breaking the seal
affixed by the Weights and Measures Department. He also contended that the
committee had used vague references to “modifications” to draw conclusions
adverse to the petitioner.
16. The question is whether the fresh inquiry by the committee complied
with the directions of the Division Bench and the Supreme Court and
whether the decision based on that inquiry was fair and supported by relevant
material. In case of Tata Cellular v. Union of India , reported in (1994) 6
SCC 651, the Supreme Court explained that the writ Court does not sit in
appeal over the administrative decision. It may, however, interfere where the
decision is illegal, irrational or procedurally unfair.
17. In case of Hindustan Petroleum Corporation Ltd. & Others v. Super
Highway Services & Another, reported in (2010) 3 SCC 321, the Supreme
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: NIDHI DAVE
Signing time: 18-11-
2026 10:07:00

NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:91518
9 WP-10349-2010
Court held that termination of a dealership is a serious matter. The

Corporation must act fairly and comply with the applicable rules and
guidelines. The dealer must have an effective opportunity to participate in
the proceedings. The technical nature of the dispute does not dispense with
these requirements.
18. The committee included representatives of the Corporation,
manufacturers and the Weights and Measures Department. The petitioner
also participated in the proceedings. The minutes show that the seized gear
fittings and the metering assemblies were placed before the members for
examination. The manufacturers confirmed that the seized double gear
assemblies were not manufactured or supplied by them. The finding that the
dispensing units contained non-standard assemblies was based on relevant
technical material and not merely on a presumption or surmise.
19. The main contention of the petitioner is that manipulation was not
possible without breaking the seals affixed by the Weights and Measures
Department. However, the committee examined how the modified
mechanism could alter delivery while the seals remained intact. The
possibility of installing an entire assembly is distinct from the possibility of
operating an assembly after modification. The MIDCO representative’s
inability to confirm whether the entire assembly could be installed without
breaking the seal does not negate the explanation regarding operation of the
modified mechanism. The earlier inspection reports recording proper
delivery also do not disprove the subsequent finding of manipulation of
dispensing units. The officials of concerned department explained that
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: NIDHI DAVE
Signing time: 18-11-
2026 10:07:00

NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:91518
10 WP-10349-2010
verification of delivery did not necessarily involve examination of the

internal gear assembly.
20. The Order dated 15.12.2009 (Annexure P-6) mandated a fresh inquiry
by a committee comprising specified officials and representatives and
permitted the petitioner to participate in its meetings. There was no specific
direction regarding inspection at the retail outlet by the committee. The
committee examined the seized parts, metering assemblies, photographs and
technical material. Therefore, the findings of committee cannot be discarded
merely because the members did not visit the retail outlet. This Court cannot
substitute its own technical opinion merely because the petitioner disputes
the conclusion of the committee. (Tata Cellular (supra) relied)
21. Further, the petitioner participated in the inquiry and disputed the
technical findings. His objection regarding the seals was considered by the
committee. Mere disagreement with the technical findings does not warrant
another inquiry.
22. The inquiry clearly established that the dispensing units were
manipulated to deliver a lesser quantity of fuel and the petitioner was the
beneficiary of such short delivery. The existence of intact seals does not
displace this finding for the reasons discussed above.
23. In view of foregoing discussion, no ground is made out for discarding
the findings of the committee merely because the seals affixed by the
officials of Weights and Measures Department, were intact or no site
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: NIDHI DAVE
Signing time: 18-11-
2026 10:07:00

NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:91518
11 WP-10349-2010
inspection was conducted. The request for a fresh inquiry cannot be accepted

on these grounds. The relief of restoration at the former premises is also
unavailable in view of expiry of the lease and loss of possession by the
respondent Corporation. Thus, the petition is liable to be
dismissed. Accordingly, the writ petition is dismissed.
24. The liberty to pursue the remedy available in civil law, expressly
reserved by the Division Bench, shall remain unaffected. However, no
opinion on the maintainability, limitation or merits of any such claim is
expressed.
(SANJEEV S KALGAONKAR)
JUDGE
nd

Signature Not Verified
Signed by: NIDHI DAVE
Signing time: 18-11-
2026 10:07:00