Mathu Alias Jagdish vs State Of Uttrakhand
- Court
- Supreme Court
NON-REPORTABLE
2026 INSC 658
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
CRIMINAL APPEAL NO. 2024 OF 2012
MATHU ALIAS JAGDISH APPELLANT(S)
VERSUS
STATE OF UTTARAKHAND RESPONDENT(S)
J U D G M E N T
UJJAL BHUYAN, J.
This criminal appeal is directed against the
judgment and order dated 25.07.2012 passed by the High
Court of Uttarakhand at Nainital (briefly, ‘the High Court’
hereinafter) in Criminal Appeal No. 241/2002 ( Manua @
Puran & Others Vs. State of Uttaranchal) .
2. Be it stated that the three appellants and one
Kaley alias Kaloo were prosecuted by the State under Section
304/34 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 (IPC) in the Court of
Signature Not Verified
Digitally signed by
Deepak Guglani
Date: 2026.06.25
14:09:18 IST
Reason:
Sessions Judge, Dehradun (briefly, ‘the Sessions Court’
hereinafter) in Sessions Trial No. 86/1997. By the judgment
and order dated 23.09.2002, the learned Sessions Court had
acquitted Kaley alias Kaloo but convicted the other three
accused Manua alias Puran, Ramu and Mathu alias Jagdish
under Section 304/34 IPC and sentenced them to undergo
rigorous imprisonment (RI) for a period of five years each and
to pay fine of Rs. 2000.00 each with a default stipulation.
3. Aggrieved by their conviction and sentence, the
three appellants had preferred Criminal Appeal No.
241/2002 before the High Court. By the impugned judgment
and order, the High Court while affirming the conviction and
sentence awarded to the three appellants, dismissed the
criminal appeal.
4. The three appellants thereafter filed SLP
(Criminal) No. 7224 of 2012 before this Court. Vide order
dated 21.09.2012, this Court had issued notice while
rejecting the prayer for bail of the appellants. Subsequently,
this Court vide the order dated 10.12.2012 granted leave and
directed release of the appellants on bail to the satisfaction of
the Sessions Court concerned.
5. During the pendency of the appeal, the first
appellant Manua alias Puran and the second appellant Ramu
2
passed away. As such, the appeal qua the aforesaid two
appellants stands abated. The present criminal appeal is,
thus, confined to the third appellant Mathu alias Jagdish.
6. The case of the prosecution as per the first
information report is that 15 days prior to the date of the
incident which is 12.02.1997, deceased Padam Singh Shahi
had sold a watch to Manua alias Puran for Rs. 500.00. It
appears that Manua did not like the watch. So, he went back
to the house of Padam Singh to ask him to take his watch
back. It has come on record that the residence of Padam
Singh was in the close vicinity of the residence of Manua. For
reasons not explained, Manua went back to his residence and
after some time, Padam Singh came to the residence of
Manua. This incident of purchase of watch and the attempt
to return the same soon escalated into altercations and
scuffle. Soon Ramu and Mathu alias Jagdish joined Manua
and assaulted Padam Singh who was standing on the edge of
a dry canal. While assaulting Padam Singh, the three accused
persons pushed him into the empty canal. It was alleged that
the present surviving appellant i.e. Mathu alias Jagdish gave
a blow on the head of Padam Singh by a heavy stone because
3
of which Padam Singh fell down into the dry canal and
sustained serious injuries. Padam Singh’s father Roop Singh
Shahi, PW-2, and brother-in-law Ramesh Chand Kshetri,
PW-3, took the injured Padam Singh to the Doon Hospital
where he succumbed to his injuries.
7. PW-2, Roop Singh Shahi, is the father of the
deceased. He stated in his examination-in-chief that the
incident happened on 12.02.1997 at around 10:30 PM to
10:45 PM. On that day, his son-in-law PW-3 had come to his
house. The accused were his neighbours. Manua had come
to his house and had told Padam Singh that the wrist watch
that was sold by him about 15 days back was defective and
that he did not want to keep the watch with him. Therefore,
he asked Padam Singh to take back his watch from his home.
Padam Singh went alongwith Manua. PW-2’s daughter-in-law
who had gone out to feed his pet dog at about 10:30 PM heard
quarrelling noise between the accused persons and her
brother-in-law Padam Singh. She also heard the voice of
Kaley. According to PW-2, when he came out of the house, he
saw the accused persons and Kaley jointly pushing Padam
Singh into the canal which was dry. Then, after pushing
4
Padam Singh into the canal, Kaley and Mathu alias Jagdish
threw stones at Padam Singh which hit his head. He and his
son-in-law, PW-3, then rushed to the canal to rescue his son.
On seeing them, the accused persons fled from the scene. His
neighbour PW-1 also came out of his residence and saw the
incident. Though Padam Singh was taken to the hospital, he
was declared dead.
7.1. In his cross-examination, PW-2 stated that he did
not mention the name of Kaley in the first information as
accused Kaley had threatened him in the Doon Hospital,
though, thereafter, he did not threaten him. He said that the
stone thrown by Kaley had hit the head of his son whereas
the stone thrown by Mathu had hit at some other place.
8. In his deposition, PW-3 Ramesh Chand Kshetri
narrated the incident more or less on the same lines as
PW-2. In his cross-examination, he stated that while the
accused persons had pushed Padam Singh into the canal,
Kaley and Mathu had thrown stones at him. However, he had
not seen the stones which had hit Padam Singh while rushing
to the place of incident.
5
9. Though PW-1, Vijay Singh, a neighbour of both
the deceased and the accused, had deposed in court, he was
declared hostile at the instance of the prosecution. He had
stated in his examination-in-chief that it was Kaley who had
pushed the deceased Padam Shahi into the canal and
thereafter he had thrown one stone which hit the deceased
Padam Shahi on his head. However, in his cross-
examination, he stated that though he had seen Kaley
throwing a stone at Padam Singh, he was not sure whether
the stone had hit him or not.
10. As per post-mortem report (Exhibit A-4), the
following injuries were noted on the dead body of the
deceased:
(i) Lacerated wound 17 cm x 5 cm x brain cavity deep
on front & middle of skull & forehead and face between two
eyes with compound comminuted fracture of underlying
bone.
(ii) Lacerated wound 4 cm x 1.5 cm x bone deep on outer
side of face, just lateral to left eye.
(iii) Lacerated wound 3.5 cm x 1 cm x bone deep on
occipital region of skull.
6
11. It is evident from the nature and extent of the
aforesaid injuries that those could only have been suffered by
the deceased because of his fall into the dry canal with a rock
bed. Though PW-9, the Investigating Officer, had stated in his
evidence that he had seized one stone from the place of
occurrence and had sent the same for forensic examination
to find out the presence of any human blood stain therein and
whether such bloodstain matched that of the blood of the
deceased, no such forensic report was exhibited. In any case,
the three injuries could have been suffered by the deceased
only because of his abrupt fall into the dry canal and not by
getting hit by stone(s) which could be lifted by a human being
and thrown with force. Therefore, the accusation that the
present appellant had thrown stones at the deceased which
had resulted in grievous injuries to the deceased causing his
death is, in our view, not a plausible scenario.
12. At this stage, we may examine Section 304 IPC
which reads as under:
304. Punishment for culpable homicide not
amounting to murder.—
Whoever commits culpable homicide not amounting
to murder shall be punished with imprisonment for
7
life, or imprisonment of either description for a term
which may extend to ten years, and shall also be
liable to fine, if the act by which the death is caused
is done with the intention of causing death, or of
causing such bodily injury as is likely to cause
death,
or with imprisonment of either description for a term
which may extend to ten years, or with fine, or with
both, if the act is done with the knowledge that it is
likely to cause death, but without any intention to
cause death, or to cause such bodily injury as is
likely to cause death.
12.1. Thus, Section 304 IPC has got two parts. The first
part is attracted if the act by which the death is caused is
done with the intention of causing death or of causing such
bodily injury as is likely to cause death. If the first part is
attracted, then the punishment is either imprisonment for life
or imprisonment of either description for a term which may
extend to ten years and shall also be liable to fine.
12.2. The second part of Section 304 IPC would be
attracted if the act by which the death is caused is done with
the knowledge that it is likely to cause death but without any
intention to cause death or to cause such bodily injury as is
likely to cause death.
8
13. Considering the evidence on record, though the
Trial Court as well as the High Court has not specified as to
which part of Section 304 IPC is attracted, nonetheless we
are of the view that it is part II of Section 304 IPC which is
applicable in the facts of this case.
14. The incident had occurred on 12.02.1997. From
the materials on record, it is seen that appellant was at that
point of time, 33 years old. Today, we are in 2026, almost
three decades have gone by since then. Appellant is now well
over 60 years of age. We have also noted the genesis of the
altercation between the deceased and the accused which
escalated into a scuffle leading to fall of the deceased into the
dry canal. All the injuries as noted above, around the face or
on the skull of the deceased, clearly occurred because of the
fall of the deceased into the dry canal which had a rock-bed.
15. It has also come on record that appellant
Mathu alias Jagdish has undergone imprisonment for a
period of over one and a half years. At this distant point of
time, we are of the view that it would meet the ends of justice
if we alter the sentence of imprisonment from RI for five years
9
to the period already undergone while maintaining the
conviction.
16. Ordered accordingly.
17. Since the appellant is already on bail, the bail
bond stands discharged.
18. Criminal Appeal is allowed to the extent indicated
above.
………………………………J.
[UJJAL BHUYAN]
.……………………………J.
[ARUN PALLI]
NEW DELHI;
JUNE 25, 2026.
10