BHUBANESSWAR NAG vs STATE

Court
Odisha High Court

IN THE HIGH COURT OF ORISSA AT CUTTACK
,
CRLREV No.620 of 2006
CNR No.ODHC010373792006
(In the matter of an application under Section 397 read
with Section 401 of Cr.P.C.)
------------------
1. Bhubaneswar Nag
2. Harisingh Nag
…. Petitioners
-versus-
State of Orissa …. Opposite Party
For Petitioners : Mr. S. K. Joshi, Advocate
For Opposite Party : Mr. C.R. Swain, AGA
CORAM:
JUSTICE V. NARASINGH
DATE OF HEARING : 10.11.2026
DATE OF JUDGMENT : 17.11.2026
V. Narasingh, J.
Heard Mr. Joshi, learned
counsel for the Petitioners and Mr. Swain, learned
Additional Government Advocate for the State.
1. This Criminal Revision has been filed assailing
the judgment dated 18.05.2006 passed by the
Additional District & Sessions Judge, Nuapada in Crl.
Appeal No.22 of 2005, thereby modifying the
Page 1 of 9
CRLREV No.620 of 2006

judgment of conviction and sentence dated
18.03.2005 passed by the learned Asst. Sessions
Judge, Nuapada in S.C. Case No.14/4 of 1988-2005
arising out of G.R. Case No.168 of 1987 qua the
Petitioners to one under Sections 324/34 of the IPC,
directing them to undergo R.I. for a period of two
years and pay a fine of Rs.10,000/-, in default, to
undergo R.I. for a further period of six months
subject to setting off the period of detention already
undergone.
It is apposite to note that by its judgment, the
Trial Court convicted the Petitioners under Sections
307/34 of the IPC and sentenced the Petitioners to
undergo R.I. for a period of three Years and to pay a
fine of Rs.10,000/- (Rupees Ten thousand) and, in
default of payment of fine, to undergo R.I. for a
period of six months.
2. The prosecution case, in short, is that on
24.12.1987, at village Kasaipani, the injured Jido @
Jagat Harijan (P.W.2), father of the informant- Kusal
Page 2 of 9
CRLREV No.620 of 2006

Singh Jagat (P.W.1), was sitting on the outer
verandah of his dwelling house when both the
accused- Petitioners arrived there. It is alleged that
Petitioner No.2 assaulted the injured by means of a
stick, whereas Petitioner No.1 assaulted him with a
tangia, causing multiple injuries on his person. On
the basis of the report lodged by the informant, the
local police registered a case and took up the
investigation.
Upon completion of the investigation, a charge-
sheet was submitted against both the accused
Petitioners for commission of offences punishable
under Sections 307 read with Section 34 of the I.P.C.
3. To drive home the charge, the prosecution
examined as many as ten witnesses. Their details are
stated below in tabular form;
P.W.1 Informant and son of the injured
P.W.2 Injured
P.W.3 Daughter-in-law of the injured
Page 3 of 9
CRLREV No.620 of 2006

P.W.4 wife of the injured
P.W.5 Seizure witness
P.W.6 Amin of Khariar Tahasil Office, who
deposed about the previous land
dispute between the parties
P.Ws.7, 8 and 9 The I.Os
P.W.10 The Medical Officer, who examined
the injured
Several documents were also exhibited and
marked as Exts.1 to 9/2. Weapons of offence were
marked as M.O.I. and II.
Neither oral nor documentary evidence was
adduced on behalf of the defence.
The plea of the defence was one of complete
denial and false implication.
4. On consideration of the evidence on record, the
Trial Court convicted the Petitioners under Sections
307/34 of the IPC and sentenced them to undergo R.I.
for a period of three Years and to pay a fine of
Page 4 of 9
CRLREV No.620 of 2006

Rs.10,000/- (Rupees Ten thousand) and, in default of
payment of fine, to undergo R.I. for a period of six
months.
The Appellate Court, on going through the
evidence on record, modified the judgment of
conviction to one under Sections 324/34 of the IPC
and directed the Petitioners to undergo R.I. for a
period of two years and pay a fine of Rs.10,000/-, in
default, to undergo R.I. for a further period of six
months subject to setting off the period of detention
already undergone.
Assailing the same, the Petitioners are before
this Court.
5. Mr. Joshi, learned counsel for the Petitioners,
submits that the appreciation of the evidence by the
Trial Court as well as the Appellate Court being
perverse, merits consideration and interference by
this Court in exercise of its revisional jurisdiction.
6. Mr. Swain, learned Additional Government
Advocate for the State, opposes such prayer and
Page 5 of 9
CRLREV No.620 of 2006

submits that there is no infirmity in the judgment of
the Appellate Court warranting interference at the
stage of revision.
7. The guidelines restated by the Apex Court in the
case of Kuntegowda v. Thurubaiah, 2026 SCC
OnLine SC 1485, are to be borne in mind while
exercising revisional jurisdiction. However, since the
allegation of perversity in appreciation of evidence
cannot be examined without adverting to the
evidence on record, for such limited purpose this
Court considers it appropriate to scan the evidence.
For convenience of ready reference, the relevant
paragraph of the judgement of the Apex Court in the
case of Kuntegowda(supra) is extracted hereunder;
“xxx xxx xxx
7.3. The contours for exercise of revisional
jurisdiction has been well settled by the judicial
dicta of this Court wherein time and again it has
been observed that the High Court shall not
interfere with the orders of the lower court unless:
i. The order or finding of the lower court is perverse,
grossly erroneous, glaringly unreasonable or wholly
unreliable or untenable in law.
Page 6 of 9
CRLREV No.620 of 2006

ii. The lower court has passed the impugned order
after considering an immaterial or irrelevant
material or no material at all.
iii. There is a non-consideration of any relevant
material or the judicial discretion has been
exercised arbitrarily or capriciously.
xxx xxx xxx”
8. On careful scrutiny of the evidence on record,
more particularly the statement of P.W.2, the injured,
and P.W.10, the doctor, who has opined that the
injuries sustained are simple in nature and upon
consideration of the rival submissions and the
guidelines envisaged by the Apex Court in the
Kuntegowda (supra) , this Court finds no infirmity in
the appreciation of evidence by the Appellate Court in
modifying the conviction and sentence so as to
warrant interference in the exercise of revisional
jurisdiction. Accordingly, the conviction and sentence,
as modified by the Appellate Court, stand affirmed.
9. At this stage, learned counsel for the Petitioners
submits that, by the time the order of sentence was
passed, the Petitioners had already undergone 29
Page 7 of 9
CRLREV No.620 of 2006

days of incarceration. It is further submitted that the
occurrence dates back to the year 1987 and that the
Petitioners are now aged about 58 and 52 years and
they have not involved themselves in any other
criminal activity in the intervening period. In view of
the aforesaid circumstances, learned counsel submits
that taking into account the punishment prescribed,
the benefit of the Probation of Offenders Act, 1958
(hereinafter referred to as ‘P.O. Act’) may be extended
to the Petitioners.
10. Learned counsel for the State does not seriously
oppose such submission and does not dispute that in
the interregnum the Petitioners have not involved
themselves in any other offence.
11. Taking into account the rival submission and in
the light of the judgment of the Apex Court in the case
of Chellammal v. State represented by the
Inspector of Police , 2025 SCC OnLine SC 870 , this
Court finds substance and force in the submissions of
the learned counsel for the Petitioners and holds that
Page 8 of 9
CRLREV No.620 of 2006

this is a fit case where the provisions of the P.O. Act
are to be invoked.
12. Hence , in the given factual matrix of the case at
hand and in view of the evidence on record as well as
the judgments cited above, while maintaining the
conviction recorded against the Petitioners by the
Appellate Court, but, having regard to the facts and
circumstances as noted above, this Court is inclined to
direct the release of the Petitioners on probation under
Section 4 of the P.O. Act, on conditions to be settled by
the Trial Court.
In the facts and circumstances of the case at
hand, the imposition of fine is waived.
13. Accordingly, the CRLREV stands disposed of.
(V. Narasingh)
Judge
Orissa High Court, Cuttack
th
Dated the 17 November, 2026/Santoshi
18.11.2026/Uploaded
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed
Signed by: SANTOSHI LENKA
Designation: Sr. Stenographer
Reason: Authentication
Location: High Court of Orissa, Cuttack
Date: 18-Nov-2026 20:53:02
Page 9 of 9
CRLREV No.620 of 2006