RAGHAVENDRA S KATTIMANI vs STATE OF KARNATAKA
- Court
- Karnataka High Court
- 1 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:3225-DB
WA No. 200152 of 2025
C/W WA No. 200219 of 2025
WA No. 200270 of 2025
CNR: KAHC030067912025
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
KALABURAGI BENCH
TH
DATED THIS THE 15 DAY OF OCTOBER, 2026
PRESENT
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ASHOK S. KINAGI
AND
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SUBRAMANYA R
WRIT APPEAL NO. 200152 OF 2025 (S-RES)
C/W
WRIT APPEAL NO. 200219 OF 2025 (S-REG)
WRIT APPEAL NO. 200270 OF 2025 (S-RES)
IN WA No. 200152/2025
BETWEEN:
1.
PRAKASH
S/O GOLLALAPPA TALIKOTI,
AGE: 38 YEARS,
OCC: ASSISTANT ACCOUNTS CONSULTANT,
R/O OPEC HOSPITAL,
B BLOCK-5, OPEC HOSPITAL CAMPUS,
HYDERABAD ROAD, RAICHUR-584102.
2. SURESH
S/O SHANKARMURTHY
AGE: 38 YEARS,
OCC: M AND E COORDINATOR CONSULTANT,
R/O BEHIND TATA MOTORS,
BHARATI COLONY, LINGASUGUR ROAD
Digitally signed
by SHIVALEELA
D UDAGI
Location: HIGH
COURT OF
KARNATAKA
- 2 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:3225-DB
WA No. 200152 of 2025
C/W WA No. 200219 of 2025
WA No. 200270 of 2025
CNR: KAHC030067912025
RAICHUR-584101.
3.
SHIVANAND
S/O GANGARAM PAWAR, AGE: 46 YEARS,
OCC: ASSISTANT DIRECTOR (O.P.),
R/O C/O S.D. BAJAJ, PLOT NO.141,
NEAR JAYATEERTH KALYAN MANTAP,
UDNOOR ROAD,
KALABURAGI-585102.
4. MALLIKARJUN
S/O KUDLAPPA KAMALAPUR
AGE: 50 YEARS,
OCC: ASSISTANT TECHNICAL CONSULTANT,
R/O C/O AMBRUTHGOUDA PATIL,
PLOT NO.3 AND 4, SANTOSH COLONY,
KALABURAGI-585102.
…APPELLANTS
(BY SRI. B.K.PATIL, ADVOCATE)
AND:
1. STATE OF KARNATAKA
BY ITS PRINCIPAL SECRETARY
DEPARTMENT OF RURAL DEVELOPMENT AND
PANCHAYAT RAJ, M.S. BUILDING,
DR. B.R. AMBEDKAR ROAD,
BENGALURU-1.
2.
THE COMMISSIONER
KARNATAKA RURAL DRINKING WATER AND
SANITATION DEPARTMENT,
2ND FLOOR, E BLOCK, KHB COMPLEX,
CAUVERI BHAVAN, BENGALURU-9.
- 3 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:3225-DB
WA No. 200152 of 2025
C/W WA No. 200219 of 2025
WA No. 200270 of 2025
CNR: KAHC030067912025
3. THE DIRECTOR
KARNATAKA RURAL DRINKING WATER AND
SANITATION DEPARTMENT,
2ND FLOOR, E BLOCK, KHB COMPLEX,
CAUVERIBHAVAN,
BENGALURU-9.
4. THE PRINCIPAL SECRETARY
KARNATAKA RURAL DRINKING WATER AND
SANITATION DEPARTMENT,
2ND FLOOR, E BLOCK, KHB COMPLEX,
CAUVERI BHAVAN, BENGALURU-9.
5. THE CHIEF EXECUTIVE OFFICER
RAICHUR, DISTRICT, RAICHUR-584101.
6. THE CHIEF EXECUTIVE OFFICER
KALABURAGI, DISTRICT
KALABURAGI-585101.
7. THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
R.D.W.S AND S, DIVISION,
RAICHUR-584101.
8.
THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
R.D.W.S AND S, DIVISION,
KALABURAGI-585101.
…RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI. VEERANAGOUDA MALIPATIL, AGA FOR
R1 TO R4, R7 AND R8;
SRI. GOURISH S. KHASHAMPUR, ADVOCATE FOR R5;
SRI.KARTHIK PATIL, ADVOCATE FOR R6)
- 4 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:3225-DB
WA No. 200152 of 2025
C/W WA No. 200219 of 2025
WA No. 200270 of 2025
CNR: KAHC030067912025
THIS WRIT APPEAL FILED U/SEC. 4 OF THE KARNATAKA
HIGH COURT ACT, PRAYING TO, ALLOW THE APPEAL BY
SETTING ASIDE ORDER PASSED IN WP NO.205275/2019
DATED 12.11.2024 IN THE INTEREST OF JUSTICE.
IN WA NO. 200219/2025
BETWEEN:
1.
RAGHAVENDRA S KATTIMANI
AGED ABOUT 49 YEARS
OCC: ASSISTANT TECHNICAL CONSULTANT (ATC),
R/O PLOT NO.67, SHAKTI NAGAR,
BEHIND CENTRAL BUS STAND,
KALABURAGI -585 101.
...APPELLANT
(BY SRI. B. K.PATIL, ADVOCATE)
AND:
1.
STATE OF KARNATAKA
BY ITS PRINCIPAL SECRETARY
DEPARTMENT OF RURAL DEVELOPMENT AND
PANCHAYAT RAJ, M.S. BUILDING,
DR. B.R. AMBEDKAR ROAD,
BENGALURU-1.
2. THE COMMISSIONER
KARNATAKA RURAL DRINKING WATER SUPPLY AND
SANITATION DEPARTMENT, 2ND FLOOR,
E BLOCK, KHB COMPLEX, CAUVERI BHAVAN,
BENGALURU-9.
- 5 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:3225-DB
WA No. 200152 of 2025
C/W WA No. 200219 of 2025
WA No. 200270 of 2025
CNR: KAHC030067912025
3. THE DIRECTOR
KARNATAKA RURAL DRINKING WATER
SUPPLY AND SANITATION DEPARTMENT,
2ND FLOOR, EBLOCK, KHB COMPLEX,
CAUVERI BHAVAN, BENGALURU-9.
4. THE PRINCIPAL SECRETARY
KARNATAKA RURAL DRINKING WATER SUPPLY
AND SANITATION DEPARTMENT,
2ND FLOOR, E BLOCK, KHB COMPLEX,
CAUVERI BHAVAN,
BENGALURU-9.
5.
THE CHIEF EXECUTIVE OFFICER
ZILLA PANCHAYAT,
KALABURAGI
DIST KALABURAGI 585102.
THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
R.D.W.S. AND S, DIVISION,
KALABURAGI-585102.
6.
...RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI. VEERANAGOUDA MALIPATIL, AGA FOR R1 TO 4;
SRI.KARTHIK PATIL, ADVOCATE FOR R5 AND R6)
THIS WRIT APPEAL FILED U/SEC. 4 OF THE
KARNATAKA HIGH COURT ACT, PRAYING TO ALLOW THE
APPEAL BY SETTING ASIDE ORDER PASSED IN WP NO.
226043/2020 DATED 12-11-2024 IN THE INTEREST OF
JUSTICE.
- 6 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:3225-DB
WA No. 200152 of 2025
C/W WA No. 200219 of 2025
WA No. 200270 of 2025
CNR: KAHC030067912025
IN WA NO. 200270/2025
BETWEEN:
1.
VASANTKUMAR S/O YELLAPPA
AGED ABOUT 42 YEARS,
OCC: ASSISTANT ACCOUNTANT
R/O H.NO.2-907/76
PRAGATI COLONY SEDAM ROAD
KALABURAGI 585105.
...APPELLANT
(BY SRI. B.K.PATIL, ADVOCATE)
AND:
1. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA
BY ITS PRINCIPAL SECRETARY
DEPARTMENT OF RURAL DEVELOPMENT AND
PANCHAYAT RAJ, M. S. BUILDING,
DR. B. R. AMBEDKAR ROAD,
BENGALURU-1
2. THE COMMISSIONER
KARNATAKA RURAL DRINKING WATER SUPPLY
AND SANITATION DEPARTMENT,
2ND FLOOR, E BLOCK, KHB COMPLEX,
CAUVERI BHAVAN,
BENGALURU-9
3. THE DIRECTOR
KARNATAKA RURAL DRINKING WATER SUPPLY
AND SANITATION DEPARTMENT,
2ND FLOOR E BLOCK, KHB COMPLEX,
CAUVERI BHAVAN,
- 7 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:3225-DB
WA No. 200152 of 2025
C/W WA No. 200219 of 2025
WA No. 200270 of 2025
CNR: KAHC030067912025
BENGALURU-9
4.
THE PRINCIPAL SECRETARY
KARNATAKA RURAL DRINKING WATER SUPPLY
AND SANITATION DEPARTMENT,
2ND FLOOR E BLOCK,
KHB COMPLEX, CAUVERI BHAVAN,
BENGALURU-9
5. THE CHIEF EXECUTIVE OFFICER
ZILLA PANCHAYAT, KALABURAGI
DIST KALABURAGI 585102
6. THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
R.D.W.S AND S, DIVISION
KALABURAGI 585102
...RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI.VEERANAGOUDA MALIPATIL, AGA FOR R1 TO R4;
SRI.KARTHIK PATIL, ADVOCATE FOR R5 AND R6)
THIS WRIT APPEAL FILED U/SEC. 4 OF THE
KARNATAKA HIGH COURT ACT, PRAYING TO ALLOW THE
APPEAL BY SETTING ASIDE ORDER PASSED IN WP NO.
223136/2020 DATED 12.11.2024 IN THE INTEREST OF
JUSTICE.
THESE APPEALS, COMING ON FOR ORDERS, THIS DAY,
JUDGMENT WAS DELIVERED THEREIN AS UNDER:
CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ASHOK S. KINAGI
and
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SUBRAMANYA R
- 8 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:3225-DB
WA No. 200152 of 2025
C/W WA No. 200219 of 2025
WA No. 200270 of 2025
CNR: KAHC030067912025
ORAL JUDGMENT
(PER: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SUBRAMANYA R )
W.A.No.200152/2025 is filed assailing the order dated
12.11.2024 passed in W.P.No.205275/2019;
W.A.No.200219/2025 is filed assailing the order dated
12.11.2024 passed in W.P.No.226043/2020; and
W.A.No.200270/2025 is filed assailing the order dated
12.11.2024 passed in W.P.No.223136/2020 by the learned
Single Judge, dismissing the Writ Petitions filed by the
Appellants herein.
2. The facts, in a nutshell, are that the Appellants
were stated to have been appointed as Assistant Accounts
Consultant, M and E Coordinator Consultant, Assistant Director
(O.P.), Assistant Technical Consultant (ATC), and Assistant
Accountant by the Respondents initially for a period of three
years, and subsequently their services were continued from
time to time.
3. It is claimed that the State Government introduced
a Scheme for the Rural Water Supply and Sanitation Agency,
- 9 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:3225-DB
WA No. 200152 of 2025
C/W WA No. 200219 of 2025
WA No. 200270 of 2025
CNR: KAHC030067912025
which was aided by the World Bank’s financial assistance. It is
further stated that the Appellants began working in a new
department, the Karnataka Rural Water Supply and Sanitation
Department, under the Ministry of Rural Development and
Panchayat Raj. The Appellants claim that their appointments
were pursuant to the issuance of a notification and the conduct
of written and oral examinations. The Appellants assert that,
instead of issuing appointment orders, the Respondents
entered into a consultancy agreement, and the Appellants were
compelled to execute it, as they had no other option.
4. The Appellants contend that they worked
continuously for 10 years and, as such, are entitled to
regularisation. However, the Appellants state that the
Authorities issued the impugned orders dated 30.03.2019,
08.07.2019 and 25.03.2019, by which the Appellants were
relieved from temporary service on the basis that their services
were no longer required.
5. The Appellants contend that the aforementioned
impugned orders dated 30.03.2019, 08.07.2019 and
25.03.2019 were challenged before the learned Single Judge in
- 10 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:3225-DB
WA No. 200152 of 2025
C/W WA No. 200219 of 2025
WA No. 200270 of 2025
CNR: KAHC030067912025
W.P.No.205275/2019; W.P.No.226043/2020; and
W.P.No.223136/2020, and that they further sought a Writ of
Mandamus directing the Respondents-Authorities to regularise
the Appellants' services, taking into account the services
rendered by them over a period of 10 years, including the grant
of all consequential benefits.
6. Considering the Writ Petitions filed by the
Appellants, the learned Single Judge erroneously dismissed
them on the ground that the Appellants were not appointed on
a permanent or regular basis. However, the Appellants were
appointed on a consultancy basis under an agreement to
provide consultancy services. The Appellants claim that the
order passed by the learned Single Judge is liable to be set
aside and that the Writ Petitions filed by them should be
allowed, granting the reliefs sought, including the regularisation
of their services.
7. Heard learned counsel for the Appellants, the
learned Additional Government Advocate, and learned counsel
for the Respondents, and perused the material on the record.
- 11 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:3225-DB
WA No. 200152 of 2025
C/W WA No. 200219 of 2025
WA No. 200270 of 2025
CNR: KAHC030067912025
8. The facts pertaining to the Appellants and the
documents relating to appellant No. 1 in W.A.No.200152/2025
form the basis for deciding the issue in the present appeals, as
the issues are common to all the above appeals.
9. The Appellants were appointed as individual
consultants under the agreement for consultancy services
executed on 12.10.2009 between the Director, Karnataka Rural
Water Supply and Sanitation Agency, and the Appellants. The
agreement set out certain terms and conditions, as annexed to
the letter of agreement. Clause No. 6 of the agreement, in
particular, indicates that the Appellants’ services were rendered
as consultants and that the Authorities fixed the consultancy
fee. The relevant clauses in the agreement entered into
between the Appellants and the Respondents are extracted
herein.
AGREEMENT FOR CONSULTANCY SERVICES
th
The agreement is made on this day, the 12 October
2009 between the Director, Karnataka Rural Water
Supply & Sanitation Agency (KRWSSA), and Mr.
Suresh, whose services are procured on Individual
consultancy basis to work as M & E Co-ordinator in
Zilla Panchayath-District Support Unit, Raichur District.
- 12 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:3225-DB
WA No. 200152 of 2025
C/W WA No. 200219 of 2025
WA No. 200270 of 2025
CNR: KAHC030067912025
The terms and conditions of the agreement are as
per the attached letter of Agreement.
World Bank Assisted Second Karnataka Rural Water Supply &
Sanitation Project
"JAL NIRMAL" PROJECT
Consulting Services
Letter of Agreement for Short Term Assignments of
Individual Consultants
Name of Assignment: M & E Co-ordinator
Name of Consultant: SURESH
Name of the Client: Karnataka Rural Water
Supply & Sanitation
Agency
1. We herewith confirm your consulting
appointment to carry out the above-mentioned
assignment specified in the attached Terms of
Reference (TOR).
2. For administrative purposes, Project Manager/Deputy
Project Manager, D.S.U. has been assigned to
administer the assignment and to provide the Consultant
with all relevant information needed to carry out the
assignment. The services will be required in Zilla
Panchayath-District Support Unit, Raichur District for
st
about 3 months, during the period from 1 October
2009 to 31 December 2009. In the event of termination,
the consultant shall be paid for the services rendered for
carrying out the assignment to the date of termination,
and will provide the KRWSSA with any reports or parts
thereof, or any other information documentation
gathered under this Agreement prior to the date of
termination.
6. Subject to submission of prescribed reports and
achievements indicated in the attached Terms of
Reference, you will be paid monthly consultation
- 13 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:3225-DB
WA No. 200152 of 2025
C/W WA No. 200219 of 2025
WA No. 200270 of 2025
CNR: KAHC030067912025
fee within 15 days from the date of receipt of
invoice, at the rate of Rs 13,000/- (Rupees
Thirteen thousand only) per month as follows:
Currency: Indian Rupees
Rate per Month:
1. Consultancy Fee - Rs. 13,000.00
2. House Rent Allowance - -
3. Conveyance Allowance - -
Total - Rs.13,000.00
The agreement and the terms and conditions make it clear that
the Appellants were not employees of the Respondents but
were engaged by the Respondents-Authorities as individual
consultants. The Appellants' claim that they were appointed on
a permanent basis and are entitled to seek regularisation, since
they have completed or continued to work for more than 10
years, would be unavailable to them.
10. The documents on record would show that the Jal
Nirmal Project is a World Bank-assisted Karnataka Rural Water
Supply and Sanitation Project. The terms of reference
authorised the Respondents to appoint individual
consultants . The relevant portion of the terms of reference is
set out below:
1. The Government of Karnataka is implementing
the World Bank assisted Second Karnataka Rural Water
- 14 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:3225-DB
WA No. 200152 of 2025
C/W WA No. 200219 of 2025
WA No. 200270 of 2025
CNR: KAHC030067912025
Supply and Sanitation Project the "Jal Nirmal" Project in
11 districts of Karnataka namely Uttara Kannada,
Belgaum, Bijapur, Bagalkot, Dharwad, Gadag, Haveri,
Gulbarga, Bidar, Raichur and Koppal. The broad
objectives of the Project are: A) Increasing rural
communities' access to improved and sustainable
drinking water and sanitation services and B)
institutionalizing decentralization of RWSS service
delivery to Gram Panchayats and user groups.
2. The Government of Karnataka has set up
Karnataka Rural Water Supply & Sanitation Agency
(KRWSSA) as a functionally autonomous registered
society under the Karnataka Societies' Registration Act,
1960 at the State level for project planning &
monitoring. At the district level, the Zilla Panchayat (ZP)
is responsible for project implementation. The KRWSSA
has set up a multidisciplinary dedicated District Support
Unit (DSU) for supporting the ZP in project
implementation.
D. Schedule for the Assignment
1. The service of the consultant is procured
for a period of 3 months commencing from
1" "October 2009 to 31" December 2009.
2.Facilities to be provided by ZP-DSU: The ZP-
DSU would supervise the assignment. The
consultant will be provided with space at the
office of ZP-DSU, Computer and other facilities to
carry out the assignment.
E. Output of the consultants
•
Submit Monthly physical and financial progress
reports within the stipulated time period,
Annual Reports and Specific reports on M&E
activities, such as report on methodology and
tools for both pre-implementation and post-
implementation baseline data collection and
- 15 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:3225-DB
WA No. 200152 of 2025
C/W WA No. 200219 of 2025
WA No. 200270 of 2025
CNR: KAHC030067912025
impact evaluation, consolidated household and
village baseline reports as prescribed in the
definite format prepared by KRWSSA.
•
Strategy for Implementation of M&E action
plan and Annual budgeting.
•
M&E capacity building programmes/
reorientation programme at GP level is
conducted.
•
Documentation of experiences, lessons learnt,
case studies, success stories, etc. are done.
•
Reports on staff meetings, monthly / quarterly
/ half yearly / annual reports are prepared.
•
Data entry in the MIS and maintain its
functionality.
•
Updating the District progress information and
best practices in the Website
•
Note-The list as above is only illustrative and
not exhaustive.
F. Payment to the Consultants : This consultancy
will have fixed cost, time based contract. The
consultants will be paid with monthly consolidated
consultancy fee of Rs 13000/-. The payment will
be made by the DSU by the end of each month or
at the beginning of subsequent month.
The terms of reference make it clear that the Appellants were
engaged as individual consultants and that the Respondents did
not treat them as regular employees. The records show that
the Appellants were paid the consultation fee based on the
assignment of work or the proportion of work carried out.
- 16 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:3225-DB
WA No. 200152 of 2025
C/W WA No. 200219 of 2025
WA No. 200270 of 2025
CNR: KAHC030067912025
11. The Government of Karnataka is implementing the
World Bank-assisted Second Karnataka Rural Supply and
Sanitation Project – the ‘Jal Nirmal’ Project – across 11
districts of the State. Gram Panchayats are the focal point for
project implementation and are primarily responsible for
planning, procurement, construction, operation and
maintenance, and management of rural water supply and
sanitation facilities, with technical support from the Zilla
Panchayat and the Panchayat Raj Engineering Divisions. The
State Government, assisted by the World Bank, required the
services of consultants and professionals to implement the
project. Accordingly, the Karnataka Rural Water Supply and
Sanitation Project was constituted, and applications were
invited for consultancy services .
12. The Appellants and similarly placed persons appear
to have submitted their applications, and, upon consideration,
the consultancy services agreement was executed. The
Appellants and similarly placed persons were paid consolidated
fees of Rs.7,000/-, initially fixed at that amount, which appears
to have been increased subsequently to Rs.13,000/-.
- 17 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:3225-DB
WA No. 200152 of 2025
C/W WA No. 200219 of 2025
WA No. 200270 of 2025
CNR: KAHC030067912025
Accordingly, the Appellants cannot claim that their services are
to be regularised merely because the Respondents continued
them by extending the consultancy period.
13. Unquestionably, the Appellants were not appointed
by the Respondents-Authorities against any sanctioned posts.
Further, the Appellants were not appointed after following the
due selection process. The initial appointments of the
Appellants were not made pursuant to the invitation of
applications against the sanctioned posts, which is not in
dispute. Indeed, the Appellants have not placed any material
on record to substantiate their claim that they were appointed
pursuant to the notification inviting applications against the
sanctioned posts.
14. In this context, the learned Single Judge considered
the Appellants' claim for regularisation in extenso and
thereafter rejected it on the ground that the Appellants were
engaged on an individual consultancy basis to provide specific
services for the implementation of the project undertaken by
the Respondents-Authorities. The learned Single Judge also
held that, since the Appellants were not appointed against a
- 18 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:3225-DB
WA No. 200152 of 2025
C/W WA No. 200219 of 2025
WA No. 200270 of 2025
CNR: KAHC030067912025
sanctioned post on a regular basis, their services under the
consultancy agreement could not be equated to employment
under the State or to a Civil post.
15. The Appellants’ services were engaged as
consultants under an agreement executed, including the terms
and conditions appended to it. Having accepted the said
agreement and the assignment as consultants, with their eyes
open, the Appellants cannot now contend that they were
appointed against a sanctioned post and that their services are
to be regularised. Since the Appellants have accepted the terms
of assignment as individual consultants and have executed the
agreement for consultancy services, they cannot be permitted
to seek to regularise their services.
16. The consultancy or contractual engagement does
not confer any right on the Appellants to seek permanent
absorption unless specifically provided for in the terms of
appointment. The State Government and the Authorities that
engaged the Appellants as consultants would be at liberty to
discontinue their consultancy services when they were no
longer required, or when the project for which they were
- 19 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:3225-DB
WA No. 200152 of 2025
C/W WA No. 200219 of 2025
WA No. 200270 of 2025
CNR: KAHC030067912025
engaged ceased. The State Government or the Authorities
cannot be compelled to absorb or regularise their services,
despite their initial engagement as individual consultants .
17. The learned Single Judge has committed no error in
dismissing the Writ Petitions filed by the Appellants. The
Appellants contend that they were continued by virtue of an
interim order granted in the Writ Petitions, and that the
Respondents have not taken any steps to move the Court to
vacate that order. Accordingly, the Appellants contend that
their services are still required by the Respondents-Authorities
and, as such, the Respondents-Authorities should be directed to
continue their services and further regularise them.
18. In our view, the aforementioned contentions do not
stand to reason and are recorded herein only to be rejected.
The Appellants were not appointed by the Respondents-
Authorities to a sanctioned post or in accordance with the due
procedures required under the relevant cadre and recruitment
Rules. The Appellants have failed to establish that their
appointments withstand the strict scrutiny of Articles 14 and 16
of the Constitution of India. If the Appellants' contentions were
- 20 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:3225-DB
WA No. 200152 of 2025
C/W WA No. 200219 of 2025
WA No. 200270 of 2025
CNR: KAHC030067912025
accepted, it would open Pandora’s box and run counter to the
constitutional ethos and mandate, with evil consequences for
the entire administration and functioning of the Government.
19. The Appellants were engaged as individual
consultants to implement the Jal Nirmal Project , which is
assisted by the World Bank. The Respondents – Authorities
engaged the Appellants as individual consultants to implement
and execute the project. Such consultancy services or
assignments entrusted to the Appellants would not, ipso facto,
give rise to the Appellants’ right to seek regularisation of their
services, thereby flouting the statutory provisions governing
the mode and manner of appointment to civil posts under the
State. The nature of the Appellants’ service with the
Respondents – Authorities is that of consultants, and their
services can be discontinued or disengaged at any time, in the
discretion of the Respondents – Authorities.
- 21 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:3225-DB
WA No. 200152 of 2025
C/W WA No. 200219 of 2025
WA No. 200270 of 2025
CNR: KAHC030067912025
20. The Hon'ble Supreme Court, in the case of State of
1
Karnataka & Others vs. Umadevi & Others , has held as
follows:
"2. …. Our constitutional scheme envisages employment
by the Government and its instrumentalities on the basis
of a procedure established in that behalf. Equality of
opportunity is the hallmark, and the Constitution has
provided also for affirmative action to ensure that
unequals are not treated as equals. Thus, any public
employment has to be in terms of the constitutional
scheme."
" 11 . In addition to the equality clause represented by
Article 14 of the Constitution, Article 16 has specifically
provided for equality of opportunity in matters of public
employment..…The Constitution does not envisage any
employment outside this constitutional scheme and
without following the requirements set down therein."
" 43. Thus, it is clear that adherence to the rule of equality
in public employment is a basic feature of our Constitution
and since the rule of law is the core of our Constitution, a
court would certainly be disabled from passing an order
upholding a violation of Article 14 or in ordering the
overlooking of the need to comply with the requirements
of Article 14 read with Article 16 of the Constitution.
Therefore, consistent with the scheme for public
employment, this Court while laying down the law, has
necessarily to hold that unless the appointment is in
terms of the relevant rules and after a proper competition
among qualified persons, the same would not confer any
right on the appointee. If it is a contractual
appointment, the appointment comes to an end at
the end of the contract ... …The High Courts acting
under Article 226 of the Constitution, should not ordinarily
issue directions for absorption, regularisation, or
permanent continuance unless the recruitment itself was
1
(2006) 4 SCC 1
- 22 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:3225-DB
WA No. 200152 of 2025
C/W WA No. 200219 of 2025
WA No. 200270 of 2025
CNR: KAHC030067912025
made regularly and in terms of the constitutional
scheme."
21. The Hon’ble Supreme Court, in Vibhuti Shankar
2
Pandey vs. The State of Madhya Pradesh & Ors. , has held
as follows:
“ 2. The case of the appellant is that he was engaged in
1980 as a Supervisor, on daily-rated basis, under a
project of the State Water Resources Department of
Madhya Pradesh. The appellant sought regularisation on
the post of Supervisor/Time Keeper. Admittedly, the
minimum qualification for the said post was matriculation
with mathematics; a qualification which the appellant did
not possess. These qualifications were relaxed by a
Government Circular dated 31-12-2010 and the appellant
sought his regularisation on the post of Supervisor/Time
Keeper, as he was qualified for the post and had been
working on daily-wage basis for a long period of time. In
fact, in another Writ Petition (WP No. 13997 of 2010)
filed by the appellant earlier, the High Court of Madhya
Pradesh vide order dated 2-11-2017, had given directions
to the State Government to decide the claim of the Writ
Petitioner in accordance with law .”
“ 3. Vide order dated 18-6-2018 issued by the Office of
Chief Engineer, Rani Avanti Bai Lodhi Sagar Project, the
claim of the appellant for regularisation was rejected for
the reasons that though the minimum qualifications of
matriculation with mathematics will not come in the way
for his regularisation, but the fact remains that the
appellant was never appointed against any post.
Moreover, his appointment was never made by the
competent authority and there were no posts available at
the time for regularisation. The appellant on the other
2
2023 LiveLaw (SC) 91
- 23 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:3225-DB
WA No. 200152 of 2025
C/W WA No. 200219 of 2025
WA No. 200270 of 2025
CNR: KAHC030067912025
hand, had set his claim for regularisation as persons who
were junior to him as daily-wagers were regularised in
the year 1990 or even before .”
“ 5. In view of the law laid down by the Constitution
Bench of this Court in Umadevi (3), the appellant had no
case for regularisation. There is no scope, hence, for our
interference with the order of the Division Bench of the
Madhya Pradesh High Court. The appeal is dismissed .”
22. The Hon’ble Supreme Court, in State of Gujarat
3
and others vs. R.J.Pathan and others , has held as follows:
"6 . ... when the Respondents were appointed on a
fixed term and on a fixed salary in a temporary unit
which was created for a particular project, no such
direction could have been issued by the Division
Bench of the High Court to absorb them in
Government service and to regularise their
services. The High Court has observed that even while
absorbing and/or regularising the services of the
Respondents, the State Government may create
supernumerary posts. Such a direction to create
supernumerary posts is unsustainable. Such a direction is
wholly without jurisdiction. No such direction can be
issued by the High court for
absorption/regularization of the employees who
were appointed in a temporary unit which was
created for a particular project and that too, by
creating supernumerary posts. "
"8. Now, so far as the reliance placed upon the decision of
this Court in the case of Umadevi (supra) and the
subsequent decision of this Court in the case of Narendra
Kumar Tiwari (supra), relied upon by the learned counsel
appearing on behalf of the Respondents is concerned,
none of the aforesaid decisions shall be applicable to the
3
2022 LiveLaw (SC) 313
- 24 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:3225-DB
WA No. 200152 of 2025
C/W WA No. 200219 of 2025
WA No. 200270 of 2025
CNR: KAHC030067912025
facts of the case on hand. The purpose and intent of
the decision in Umadevi (supra) was, (1) to prevent
irregular or illegal appointments in the future, and
(2) to confer a benefit on those who had been
irregularly appointed in the past and who have
continued for a very long time. The decision of
Umadevi (supra) may be applicable in a case where
the appointments are irregular on the sanctioned
posts in regular establishment. The same does not
apply to temporary appointments made in a
project/programme. "
23. The Hon’ble Supreme Court, in Madan Singh and
4
others Vs State of Haryana and Others , has held that
regularising persons who were not appointed through any
process of advertisement or interview would be arbitrary and
violative of the constitutional scheme of public employment.
The Hon'ble Supreme Court has reminded that the one-time
measure doctrine, as propounded in Umadevi ( supra ), is a
limited exception intended to regularise employees who are
irregularly appointed and have long years of service. In other
words, the Hon'ble Supreme Court has indicated that a “one-
time measure” cannot be invoked repeatedly.
4
2026 SCC OnLine SC 628
- 25 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:3225-DB
WA No. 200152 of 2025
C/W WA No. 200219 of 2025
WA No. 200270 of 2025
CNR: KAHC030067912025
24. The Hon’ble Supreme Court, in Chief Executive
Officer, Zilla Parishad, Thane and others vs Santosh
5
Tukaram Tiware and others , held that merely because the
parties continued to work on a contract basis, the order of
regularisation cannot be passed.
25. In light of the law laid down by the Hon'ble
Supreme Court and the reasons assigned by the learned Single
Judge, we find no error or infirmity in the order passed by the
learned Single Judge in dismissing the Writ Petitions, which is
rightly done.
26. The Appellants cannot claim regularisation as a
matter of right, inasmuch as their services were engaged as
individual consultants under a particular project. The other
contentions of the Appellants, that they were continued for a
longer period and, as such, are entitled to seek regularisation,
are recorded only to be rejected. Merely because the Appellants
were continued under the agreement, that too as individual
consultants, they cannot seek regularisation, inasmuch as they
are governed by the agreement for consultancy services
5
(2023) 1 SCC 456
- 26 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:3225-DB
WA No. 200152 of 2025
C/W WA No. 200219 of 2025
WA No. 200270 of 2025
CNR: KAHC030067912025
executed and the terms and conditions appended to such
agreement. The Appellants, therefore, cannot insist that the
Respondents-Authorities shall convert their consultancy
services into one employment as a civil post under the State.
Accordingly, we are not inclined to interfere with the order of
dismissal passed by the learned Single Judge. Hence, we
proceed to pass the following:
ORDER
The Writ Appeals are hereby rejected .
Sd/-
(ASHOK S. KINAGI)
JUDGE
Sd/-
(SUBRAMANYA R)
JUDGE
SDU
LIST NO.: 2 SL NO.: 6