G. NAGRAJAN vs THE GOVERNMENT OF TAMILNADU

Court
Madras High Court

W.P.No.34990 and 37033 of 2007
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS
Reserved on :03-11-2026
Pronounced on :17.11.2026
CORAM
THE HON'BLE DR. JUSTICE G. JAYACHANDRAN
AND
THE HON'BLE MR.JUSTICE E.MANOHARAN
W.P.No.34990 of 2007 AND
W.P.No.37033 of 2007
and
M.P.Nos.1 & 2 /2007 and 1 & 2 of 2007
CNR:{HCMA010142672007}
G. Nagrajan
S/o P. Govindan,
4, Tachers Colony,
Gudiyatham,
Vellore 632 602.
..Petitioner
Vs
1. The Government of Tamil Nadu
Rep.by its Secretary Agriculture Department,
Fort St. George,Chennai 600 009.
2. The Chief Engineer
Agricultural Engineering Department,
Chennai 600 005
3. The Tamil Nadu Public Service Commission,
Government Estate, Chennai 600 002
__________
Page1 of 36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 06:35:10 pm )

W.P.No.34990 and 37033 of 2007
4. V. Sridhar,Assistant Engineer,
O/o Chief Engineer,
Agricultural Engineering Department,
Nandanam, Chennai 600 035
(Respondent 4 is also in a representative
capacity to represent all other Assistant
Engineers appointed by recruitment by transfer
nd
by 2 respondent)
..Respondents
W.P.No.37033 of 2007
CNR:{HCMA010147812007}
Confederation of Agricultural Engineers
Rep. by its President,
B2, Officials Quarters,
Tamil Nadu Agricultural University,
Coimbatore 641 003.
..Petitioner
Vs
1. The Government of Tamil Nadu
Rep. by its Secretary,
Agriculture Department,
Fort St. George, Chennai 600 009.
2. The Chief Engineer
Agricultural Engineering Department,
Chennai 600 036.
3. The Tamil Nadu Public Service Commission,
Government Estate, Chennai 600 002.
4. V.Sridhar
Assistant Engineer,
O/o Chief Engineer,
Agricultural Engineering Department,
Nandanam, Chennai 600 035.
..Respondents
__________
Page2 of 36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 06:35:10 pm )

W.P.No.34990 and 37033 of 2007
W.P.No.34990 of 2007:
Writ Petition has been filed under Article 226 of the Constitution of India
praying to issue a Writ of Declaration declaring the Rules 2(a), 3 and other
Rules to Tamil Nadu Agricultural Engineering Service in so far as
permitting appointment to the category of Assistant Engineer by recruitment by
transfer as illegal and unconstitutional and consequently direct the respondents
1 to 3 to notify all the vacancies in the category of Assistant Engineer as on
date, including the vacancies now occupied by the Assistant Engineers,
rd
appointed by recruitment by transfer after 19.7.1994 by the 3 respondent for
selecting candidates by direct recruitment for appointment as Assistant
Engineers in Tamil Nadu Agricultural Engineering Department within a time
frame as may be fixed by this Hon’ble Court.
W.P.No.37033 of 2007:
Writ Petition has been filed under Article 226 of the Constitution of India
praying to issue a Writ of Declaration declaring the Rules 2(a), 3 and other
Rules of Special Rules to Tamil Nadu Agricultural Engineering Service in so far
as permitting appointment to the category of Assistant Engineer by recruitment
by transfer as illegal and unconstitutional and consequently direct the
respondents 1 to 3 to notify all the vacancies in the category of Assistant
Engineer as on date, including the vacancies now occupied by the Assistant
Engineers appointed by recruitment by transfer by the 3rd respondent pursuant
to the impugned Rules for selecting candidates by direct recruitment for
appointment as Assistant Engineers in Tamil Nadu Agricultural Engineering
Department within a time frame as may be fixed by this Hon’ble Court.
__________
Page3 of 36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 06:35:10 pm )

W.P.No.34990 and 37033 of 2007
For Petitioner:
(in both cases)
:N.Subramaniyan
For Respondents
(in both cases)
:Mr.S.Illamvaludhi,
SGP for R1 and R2
Mr.B.Vijay, Standing counsel for R3
in W.P.No.34990 of 2007
Mr.I.Abrar Md.Abdulla,
St.Counsel for R3 in
W.P.No.37033 of 2007
No appearance for R4
COMMON ORDER
Dr.G.Jayachandran, J.
and
E.Manoharan, J.
The above writ petitions are filed to declare Rules 2(a) and 3 and other
Rules of Special Rules to Tamil Nadu Agricultural Engineering Service in so far
as permitting appointment to the category of Assistant Engineer by recruitment
by transfer as illegal and unconstitutional and consequently direct the
respondents 1 to 3 to notify all the vacancies in the category of Assistant
Engineer as on date, including the vacancies now occupied by the Assistant
Engineers appointed by recruitment by transfer by the 3rd respondent, pursuant
to the impugned Rules for selecting candidates by direct recruitment for
appointment as Assistant Engineers in Tamil Nadu Agricultural Engineering
Department within a time frame as may be fixed by this Hon’ble Court.
__________
Page4 of 36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 06:35:10 pm )

W.P.No.34990 and 37033 of 2007
2. One petition is by an individual, who possess Agricultural Engineering
Degree and another by the President of the Confederation of Agricultural
Engineers. However, the relief sought in both the writ petitions are almost
identical.

3. Thiru.G.Nagarajan, the petitioner in W.P.No.34990 of 2007 is a B.E.,
Graduate in Agricultural Engineering. He claims that he completed his B.E.,
course in the year 1993. Though he is fully qualified to be appointed as
Assistant Engineer by direct recruitment in the Tamil Nadu Agricultural
Engineering Department, he could not get appointment, despite being a person
from Schedule Caste community, because the Recruitment Rules been amended
to give preferential treatment to the in-house candidates serving in the
department as Assistant Soil Conservation Officer, Junior Drafting Officer and
Agricultural Foreman. Earlier, the post of Assistant Engineer in the Agricultural
Engineering Department was exclusively filled with Engineering Graduates by
direct recruitment. Later, the Recruitment Rules were amended to provide yet
another feeder category (ie) recruitment by Transfer from Tamil Nadu
Subordinate Service, such as, Assistant Soil Conservation Officer, Junior
Drafting Officer and Agricultural Foreman, who possess Engineering Degree in
the ratio of 24:1. Later, the ratio changed into 91:9 from 09/11/1995 as per
G.O.Ms.No.582, Agriculture (AA-III) Department, Dated 09/11/1995. By
__________
Page5 of 36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 06:35:10 pm )

W.P.No.34990 and 37033 of 2007
providing quota for the in-house candidates, who have close proximity with the
higher officials, the Engineering Graduates, who have completed the course
long ago, are not able to get employment. The priority to the in-house candidate
deprives the fair opportunity of deserving candidates waiting for employment.
Filling up the post of Assistant Engineer in the Agricultural Engineering
Department with the in-house candidates, who have acquired B.E., degree
through part-time Engineering Course and after several attempts at the cost of
efficiency is against Article 335 of the Constitution of India. Further, filling up
the post of Assistant Engineer through recruitment by transfer without following
the communal roaster is against law. Therefore, the Special Rules governing
the Tamil Nadu Agricultural Engineering Service – specifically Rule 2(a) and
the proviso thereunder – in so far permitting the appointment of in-service
candidates to the category of Assistant Engineer through recruitment by transfer
is illegal and unconstitutional.
4. Thiru.G.P.Kamaraj, President of the Confederation of Agricultural
Engineers representing its members, who are un-employed Agricultural
Engineering graduates in his writ petition W.P.No:37033 of 2007 states that,
the post of Assistant Engineer in the Agricultural Engineering Department is a
Class V post governed by Special Rules to Tamil Nadu Agricultural
Engineering Service. Whereas, the post of Junior Engineer and other lower
categories, like, Assistant Soil Conservation Officer, Junior Drafting Officer
__________
Page6 of 36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 06:35:10 pm )

W.P.No.34990 and 37033 of 2007
and Agricultural Foreman are governed by Tamil Nadu Agricultural
Engineering Subordinate Service. The vacancies arising in Assistant Engineers
post and Junior Engineers post used to be apportioned in the ratio of 75:25.
5. Initially, the Assistant Engineers were filled by direct recruitment.
Subsequently, through G.O.Ms.No.582, dated 09/11/1995, the recruitment Rule
got amended with retrospective effect, by including the recruitment by transfer
from the categories of Soil Conservation Officer, Junior Drafting Officer and
Agricultural Engineering Foreman in Tamil Nadu Agricultural Subordinate
Rules on acquiring the B.E., degree. The amendment Rule does not prescribe
any minimum service period in the lower category or any test to examine their
suitability for the higher post. Subsequently, the Recruitment Rules got further
amended vide G.O.Ms.No.431, Agriculture Department, dated 20.10.1996
permitting redesignation of Junior Engineers as Assistant Engineers on
acquiring B.E. degree with effect from the date following the last date of
examination. The said amendments have enabled the department to fill all the
vacancies in the post of Assistant Engineers from recruitment by transfer from
lower categories or by redesignation of Junior Engineers on acquiring B.E.
degree. This has deprived the fresh Engineering un-employed graduates to get
employment as Assistant Engineers in the Agricultural Engineering
Department. Instead of calling for application to fill-up the quota reserved for
the Agricultural Engineering graduates by direct recruitment agency, the
__________
Page7 of 36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 06:35:10 pm )

W.P.No.34990 and 37033 of 2007
department continue to make illegal appointment contrary to Rules. To give
undue advantage for the in-service candidates, through G.O.Ms.No.479,
Agriculture (AA-3) Department, dated 16.11.2007, the respondents had
upgraded 399 Assistant Soil Conservation Officers with Diploma as Junior
Engineers on their completion of 20 years service been re-designated as Junior
Engineers thereby the quota for the direct recruit Assistant Engineers has
absolutely become Nil. The advantage given to the in-house candidates in
various forms have been unduly denied the employment for the members of the
Confederation, who are waiting for their chance of getting employment under
the Direct Recruitment Quota. The fundamental right of the Members of the
petitioner-Confederation is seriously affected, since for the past 10 years there is
no direct recruitment of B.E., graduates to the post of Assistant Engineers. That
apart, while recruiting through transfer, 69% reservation policy is not followed.
Lesser efficient persons are recruited, contrary to Article 335 of the Constitution
of India. The change in the recruitment for the post of Assistant Engineers in
the Agricultural Engineering department has totally deprived the employment
opportunity of B.E. graduates. The filling up of the vacancies in the post of
Assistant Engineers through recruitment by transfer and re-designation are
contrary to the Recruitment Rules and ultra vires to Article 309 of the
Constitution of India.
6. The Counter affidavit filed by the Chief Engineer, Agricultural
__________
Page8 of 36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 06:35:10 pm )

W.P.No.34990 and 37033 of 2007
Engineering Department, states that, the method of appointment to the post of
Assistant Engineer (Agricultural Engineering) falls under the purview of Tamil
Nadu Public Service Commission (in short “TNPSC”). The qualification and
method of appointment to the said post are as below:-
Sl.
No.
Name of Post Qualification Method of Appointment
1. Assistant
Engineer
(Agri.Engg.)
BY DIRECT
RECRUITMENT
Direct Recruitment and by
transfer and by promotion
from the holders of degree in
Engineering in the post of
Agricultural Engineering
Foreman, Assistant Soil
Conservation Officer and
Junior Draughting Officer in
the ratio of 91:9
(i)B.E.(Agri) (or)
B.Tech
(Agril.Engg.) (or)
B.Sc.(Agri.Engg.) (or)

(ii) B.E.(Mech.) (or)
B.E.(Civil) (or)
B.Tech. (Automobile
Engg.) (or) B.E.
(Production Engg.) (or)
B.E.(Industrial
Engineering)
By recruitment by
transfer
B.E.(Civil)
B.E.(Mechanical)
7. The Special Rules for Tamil Nadu Agricultural Engineering Service
was amended in G.O.Ms.No.582 dated 09/11/1995 directing that for
appointment to the substantive posts of Assistant Engineer (Agricultural
Engineering) the proportion between the Direct Recruitment and recruitment by
transfer from the holders of the post of Assistant Soil Conservation Officer,
Junior Draughting Officer, Agricultural Engineering Foreman in Tamil Nadu
__________
Page9 of 36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 06:35:10 pm )

W.P.No.34990 and 37033 of 2007
Agricultural Service shall be 24:1 with effect from 27/12/1990 and 91:9 with
effect from 09/11/1995. Thereafter, in G.O.Ms.No.431, dated 22/10/1996,
proviso was added which read as below:-
“Provided that Junior Engineer(Agricultural
Engineering) in the Tamil Nadu Agricultural
Subordinate Service on acquiring a degree in
Engineering or a Pass in Section “A” and “B” of the
A.M.I.E. shall be re-designated as Assistant Engineer
(Agricultural Engineering) in the Tamil Nadu
Agricultural Engineering Service from the date
following the last date of examination, notwithstanding
the procedure to be followed for appointment by
recruitment by transfer”
8. The quota for B.E. graduates through direct recruitment at the entry
level post of Assistant Engineer in the department was initiated after the ban on
recruitment lifted in the year 2005. Steps to file 36 posts of Assistant Engineer
was taken through TNPSC in the year 2006 and notification was also issued to
fill up 36 vacancies through Direct Recruitment. However, the same was
challenged in W.P.No:4816 of 2008 and in view of the interim stay, the process
of direct recruitment did not proceed. In the light of the above circumstances
and taking note of the fact that at the given point of time, there were more
number of Assistant Soil Conservation Officers (herein after referred to as
“ASCO”) who have put in more than 20 years of service without any promotion
and no scope for promotion till their retirement. Hence, based on the proposal
__________
Page10 of 36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 06:35:10 pm )

W.P.No.34990 and 37033 of 2007
given by the Chief Engineer (Agricultural Engineering), the ASCO with 20
years of service were re-designated as Junior Engineers. Further, the
departmental hierarchy was re- structured by increasing the number of Section
Officers (Assistant Engineers and Junior Engineers) from 5 to 8 in each sub
divisions and reduce equal number of ASCO. The upgradation of ASCO post to
Junior Assistant and filling it with ASCO, having more than 20 years service
was an administrative decision, based on the proposal given by the Chief
Engineer of the Department.
9. The Learned Special Government Pleader further submitted, the
amendment to the Recruitment Rule arose to meet out the administrative
exigencies. The Rules were amended time to time to protect the interest of the
serving officers. Those, who have put in more than 20 years of service, without
any promotion, were considered to be re-designated as Junior Engineers for
them to have chance of promotion as Assistant Engineers. Neither the individual
petitioner nor the Association can question the method of recruitment by
transfer provided in the Special Rules for Tamil Nadu Agricultural Engineering
Service. The petitioners, who are not in service, have no locus to question the
vires of the Service Rules.
10. The case of the respondent in short is that, the direct recruitment for
Assistant Engineers through open competition could not be carried between
__________
Page11 of 36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 06:35:10 pm )

W.P.No.34990 and 37033 of 2007
2001-2005 due to ban on recruitment. Later, when Notification to fill 36 posts
through open competition under the aegis of TNPSC , the same was stayed by
the High Court. Meanwhile, in-house candidates, who got B.E., degree were
considered for the post of Assistant Engineer under the category of recruitment
by transfer. Later, those, who were stagnated for more than 20 years in the
feeder category with Diploma, were re-designated as Junior Engineers for being
considered for the promotional post of Assistant Engineer. For these category,
it is a promotional post by transfer from one service to another. Therefore, Rule
of reservation is not applicable. Only in the entry level, Rule of reservation is
followed in the Agricultural Engineering Department. Providing reasonable
quota for in-house candidate in promotion, when there are more than one source
of feeder category is not in violation of Constitution.

11. Heard the Learned Counsels and perused the records.
12. Mr.N.Subramaniyan, the learned counsel for the petitioners made his
detailed submissions to buttress his case, how the respondents by not appointing
Assistant Engineer, through open competition following Rule of reservation has
affected the future of young Engineering Graduates, who are anxiously waiting
for an opportunity to get a Government job, whereas the respondents only
promote the interest of the in-service candidates at the cost of the petitioners in
violation of Constitution of India. Whereas, the Learned Special Government
__________
Page12 of 36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 06:35:10 pm )

W.P.No.34990 and 37033 of 2007
Pleader marshalled the facts and the circumstances under which and reason for
which the recruitment Rules were amended time to time and why the writ
petitions are not maintainable.
13. The relief sought for in these writ petitions is to declare Rule 2(a) and
3 of the Special Rules for Tamil Nadu Agricultural Engineering Service Rules
as illegal and unconstitutional, since it is contrary to the mandate of the
Constitution of India and Section 5 of the Tamil Nadu Reservation Act, 1993.
Further, it is discriminatory and violation of Article 14 of the Constitution of
India, since it enables the in-service candidates to be eligible for recruitment by
transfer as a feeder category to the post of Assistant Engineer in the Agricultural
Engineering Department. The writ petitioners also seek for a direction to the
respondents to notify all the vacancies in the category of Assistant Engineer as
on date for selection through Direct Recruitment. The petitioners want the
vacancies filled through recruitment by transfer and by re-designation also to be
notified as vacant and to be filed with Direct Recruits.
14. Rule 2(a) of the Special Rules to Tamil Nadu Agricultural
Engineering Services, 1981 at the time it came into force, categorised Assistant
Executive Engineer ( Agricultural Engineering ) under Class IV and Assistant
Engineer (Agricultural Engineering) under Class V. Rule 2 (a) which deals
with the method of appointment to the service of different classes, prescribed
__________
Page13 of 36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 06:35:10 pm )

W.P.No.34990 and 37033 of 2007
the feeder categories for Class IV and V as below:-
Class
Asssistant Executive
i) By Direct recruitment.
IV
Engineer (AE)
ii) By promotion from among
holders of the posts in class V and
iii) By Recruitment by transfer
among the holders of the post of
Junior Engineer (AE) in the
Tamilnadu Agricultural
Subordinate Service.
Class
Assistant Engineer
By Direct Recruitment.
V
( AE)
15. B.E.(Agricultural) or B.Tech.(Agricultural Engineering) or B.Sc.,
(Agricultural Engineering), B.E. (Mechanical) or B.E (Civil) or B.E. (Auto
mobile Engineering) was the minimum education qualification for the post of
Assistant Engineer (A.E.) filled through Direct recruitment. The next
promotional avenue for Assistant Engineer (Agri. Engineering) being Assistant
Executive Engineer (A.E.E.), Rule 2(b) fixed ratio among the three different
feeder categories to Class IV (i.e.) Assistant Executive Engineer (A.E.E) in the
ratio of 1:3:2 and the roaster was also prescribed. We also find that by inserting
a proviso to Rule 2(b) in the year 1984, the quota for direct recruits through
open competition was stopped for a period of 8 years and the ratio among the
rest of the two feeder categories, (i.e.) (i) Direct recruitment by transfer and (ii)
by promotion was fixed as 3:3. The consequence of this amendment was, atleast
from 1984 for long years, there was no recruitment through open competition
__________
Page14 of 36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 06:35:10 pm )

W.P.No.34990 and 37033 of 2007
for the post of Assistant Engineers (AE) in the respondent department. The
quota meant for Direct Recruits been filled up either by promotion or by
recruitment by transfer from the in-service candidates in Agricultural
Subordinate Service holding BE Degree or Diploma.
16. In the year 1995, the Special Rules was amended further in G.O.Ms.
No:582 dated 09/11/1995 with effect from that day, wherein Rule 2(a) got
amended as below:-
Amendment
In the said Special Rules:-
(1)in rule 2,
(2)in sub-rule (a) in the Table, in column (3) against the
entry “Assistant Engineer (AE)” in column (2) for the entry
“By direct recruitment”, the following entry shall be
substituted, namely:-
(i)By direct recruitment; and
(ii)By recruitment by transfer from among the
holders of the posts of Assistant Soil Conservation Officer,
Junior Draughting Officer and Agricultural Engineering
Foreman in the Tamil Nadu Agricultural Subordinate
Service.”
(iii)after sub-rule (c) the following sub-rule shall be
added, namely, “(d)The proportion for appointment to the
vacancies arising in class V by direct recruitment and
recruitment by transfer shall be 24:1.
(iv)In sub-rule (d) as so added, for the expression
“24:1”, the expression “91:9” shall be substituted;
(2)to rule 3, the following proviso shall be added, namely:
__________
Page15 of 36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 06:35:10 pm )

W.P.No.34990 and 37033 of 2007
“Provided that, for appointment to the post in Class V by
recruitment by transfer, such list shall be prepared with
reference to the seniority of the candidates, based on the date
of acquiring B.E.(Civil) or B.E.(Mechanical) degree”.

17. The reason for the amendment as explained in the G.O. seems to be,
the 2% quota given to the holders of the posts of Assistant Soil Conservation
Officer, Junior Draughting Officer and other categories of posts in the
Subordinate Services, who have acquired a degree in Engineering, was not
adequate. Therefore, to reward them with suitable fitment in their career for
smooth and harmonious functioning of the Department, the Chief Engineer
(CE) had suggested to increase the quota from 3 % to 5% .
18. The Government, after examining the proposal of Chief Engineer
(CE), instead of increasing the percentage decided to prescribe proportional
representation among direct recruit and recruitment by transfer from the holders
of the post of Assistant Soil Conservation Officer, Junior Draughting Officer,
Agricultural Engineering Foreman in the Subordinate Services at the ratio of
24:1 in the substantive post (465 being the working strength of Assistant
Engineer (AE) on the date of GO ). The GO was given retrospective effect from
27/12/1990 till the date of GO (i.e.) 09/11/1995 and thereafter in the ratio of
99:1.
__________
Page16 of 36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 06:35:10 pm )

W.P.No.34990 and 37033 of 2007
19. For better and clear understanding, the preamble to the Government
Order No:582 dated 09/11/1995 is extracted below:-
“In the G.O.second read above, it was ordered that 2%
of the post of Assistant Engineer (Agrl.Engg.) in the combined
strength of Assistant Engineer (Agrl.Engg.) in the combined
strength of Assistant Engineer (Agrl.Engg.) and Junior
Engineer (AE) be filed up by recruitment by transfer from
among the holders of the posts of Assistant Soil Conservation
Officer, Junior Draughting Officer and other categories of posts
in the Subordinate Service who have acquired a degree in
Engineering through part time course based on the date of
acquiring such degree pending amendment to the special rules
for Tamil Nadu Agricultural Engineering Service in view of the
reason that those persons working in lower categories but
acquired a degree in Engineering should be rewarded with
suitable fitment in their career for smooth and harmonious
functioning of the department. The Chief Engineer (AE) has
accordingly sent draft amendment proposal.
2. In the meantime, the Chief Engineer (AE) by considering the
large number of degree holders working in the subordinate
posts such as Assistant Soil Conservation Officer etc. has
requested the Government that the 2% of posts allocated for
them may be enhanced to 5% in the combined cadre strength of
the post of Assistant Engineer (AE) and Junior Engineer
(Agrl.Engg.). When the question of taking into account the
posts of Assistant Engineer (AE) alone for the purpose of
arriving such percentage, a question has arisen due to the fact
that the posts of Assistant Engineer (Agrl.Engg.) and Junior
Engineer (Agricultural Engineering) are Governed by separate
Special Rules. The above views were put to Chief Engineer
__________
Page17 of 36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 06:35:10 pm )

W.P.No.34990 and 37033 of 2007
(Agrl.Engg.) for remarks, the Chief Engineer (AE) in his letter
fifth read above has stated that 465 Assistant Engineer (AE)
selected by Tamil Nadu Public Service Commission for
appointment to the post of Assistant Engineer (AE) (being the
substantive posts) are now working in the Department and that
those 465 posts may be taken as basis for arriving at such
percentage and as and when direct recruitment is made by the
Tamil Nadu Public Service Commission, those posts may be
considered as total post for the purpose.
3. The Government have carefully examined the proposal they
have decided to prescribe proportion for appointment to the
substantive-post of Assistant Engineer (AE) between direct
recruitment and by recruitment by transfer instead of
percentage for purpose.
4. Accordingly, the Government, in partial modification of the
orders issued in para 2 of the G.O. second read above, direct
that for appointment to the substantive posts of Assistant
Engineer (AE), the proportion between direct recruitment and
recruitment by transfer from the holders of the posts of
Assistant Soil Conservation Officer, Junior Draughting Officer,
Agricultural Engineering Foreman in Tamil Nadu Agricultural
Subordinate service shall be 24:1 with effect from 27.12.1990
till the date of issue of this order.
5. The Government also direct that the proportion of 24:1
ordered in para 4 above for appointment to the substantive post
Assistant Engineer (AE) by direct recruitment and by
recruitment by transfer be enhanced to 91:9 with immediate
effect.
20. Hardly a year later, the next G.O.Ms.No.431 dated 22/10/1996 issued
__________
Page18 of 36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 06:35:10 pm )

W.P.No.34990 and 37033 of 2007
which amended Rule 2 (a) of the Special Rules for the Tamil Nadu Agricultural
Engineer Service wherein the Junior Engineer (JE) on acquiring a degree in
Engineering or Passing ‘A’ and ‘B’ of A.M.I.E were re-designated as Assistant
Engineer (A.E.) from the date following the last date of examination. Further,
Rule 6-A was inserted for fixation of seniority among the directed appointed
Assistant Engineer (A.E.) and those Junior Engineers re-designated Assistant
Engineers on acquiring B.E. degree or on pass of A.M.I.E. The proposal for the
amendment emanated from the Chief Engineer (C.E.) and the preamble of the
G.O.Ms.No.431 reads as under:-
“3.The Government have examined the proposal of
Chief Engineer (Agricultural Engineering) in consultation
with the Tamil nadu Public Service Commission. The
Tamil Nadu Public Service Commission is of the view that
if the Junior Engineer (Agrl.Engg.) on acquiring at degree
etc., is appointed as Assistant Engineer (Agrl.Engg) by
recruitment by transfer, then the usual procedure of
drawing up of Panel becomes necessary but in this case it
is not practicable also. The Commission has therefore
suggested that in order to enable the Junior
Engineers(Agrl.Engg.) to be appointed as Assistant
Engineer(Agrl.Engg.) automatically, instead of resorting
to the method of appointment by recruitment by transfer, it
would be enough a suitable provision may be incorporated
under the Table in sub-rule (a) of rule 2 of Tamil Nadu
Agricultural Engineering) for the purpose of determining
the seniority in a calendar year prior to 1.2.81, the list of
persons selected by the Commission for the post of
Agricultural Engineering Supervisor (later designated as
Junior Engineer (Agrl.Engg.) Assistant
Engineer(Agrl.Engg.) may also be taken in account.
4.The Government after careful examination have
decided to accept the views of Tamil Nadu Public Service
Commission and to amend the Special Rules for Tamil
Nadu Agricultural Engineering Service accordingly and in
pursuance of the order issued in the Government letter
second read above and the Government order Forth read
above.
__________
Page19 of 36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 06:35:10 pm )

W.P.No.34990 and 37033 of 2007
5.The following Notification will be published in the
Tamil Nadu Government Gazette.
NOTIFICATION
In exercise of the powers conferred by the proviso
to Article 309 of the Constitution of India, the Government
of Tamil Nadu hereby makes the following amendments to
the Special Rules for the Tamil Nadu Agricultural
Engineering Service (Section 38 in volume II of the Tamil
Nadu Services Manual, 1969).
2.The amendments hereby may shall be deemed to
st
have come into force with effect on and from 1 February,
1981.
AMENDMENTS
In the said Special Rules:-
(1)In Rule 2, in sub-rule (a), in the Table, in column
(3) against the entry “Assistant Engineer (Agricultural
Engineering) in column (2) the following Proviso shall be
added, namely:-
“Provided that Junior Engineer(Agricultural
Engineering) in the Tamil nadu Agricultural Subordinate
Service on acquiring a degree in Engineering or a Pass in
Sections ‘A’ and ‘B’ of the A.M.I.E shall be re-designated
as Assistant Engineer(Agricultural Engineering) in the
Tamil Nadu Agricultural Engineering service from the
date following the last date of examination, not
withstanding the procedure to be followed for appointment
by recruitment by transfer”.
(2)after rule 6, the following rule shall be inserted,
namely:-
“6-A Seniority between the Assistant Engineer
(Agricultural Engineering) directly appointed and those
re-designated as Assistant Engineer(Agricultural
Engineering):
The Junior Engineer (Agricultural Engineering) on
re-designation as Assistant Engineer(Agricultural
Engineering) in a calendar year shall be assigned rank
below the last Assistant Engineer (Agricultural
Engineering) in the list of candidates selected by the Tamil
Nadu Public Service Commission in that calendar year. If
no selection is made by the Tamil Nadu Public Service
Commission in the category of Assistant
Engineer(Agricultural Engineering) in that calendar year,
the Junior Engineer (Agricultural Engineering) so
__________
Page20 of 36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 06:35:10 pm )

W.P.No.34990 and 37033 of 2007
redesignated as Assistant Engineer(Agrl.Engg.) shall be
assigned rank below the last Assistant
Engineer(Agrl.Engg.) in the list lastly communicated for
this purpose. For this purpose, the date of communication
the list by the Commission shall be the criteria to decide
the calendar year to which the list belongs”.
Provided that for determining the last Assistant
Engineer (Agricultural Engineering) in a calendar year
prior to 1.2.81 the list of persons selected by Tamil Nadu
Public Service Commission for the post of Agricultural
Engineering Supervisor shall be taken into account.
//By order of the Governor//
21. The writ petitioners contend that, the Special Rules for Tamil Nadu
Agricultural Subordinate Service was amended in the year 2004 vide
G.O.Ms.No.533 dated 14.12.2004. The recruitment by transfer for the post of
Assistant Engineer (AE) is considered from this category which falls under
Class IV. The post of Assistant Engineer (AE) is Class V and it is governed by
the Special Rules for Tamil Nadu Agricultural Engineering Services. The effect
of the G.O.Ms.No.533 has further made worse the scope of a Young
Engineering graduate getting appointment as A.E. directly in the Agricultural
Engineer Department.

22. To appreciate this submission, we extract below the G.O.Ms.No.533
dated 14.12.2004:
__________
Page21 of 36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 06:35:10 pm )

W.P.No.34990 and 37033 of 2007
__________
Page22 of 36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 06:35:10 pm )

W.P.No.34990 and 37033 of 2007
__________
Page23 of 36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 06:35:10 pm )

W.P.No.34990 and 37033 of 2007
__________
Page24 of 36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 06:35:10 pm )

W.P.No.34990 and 37033 of 2007

23. Thus, from the amendments and reason stated in the respective
Government Orders, it is clear that though initially the post of Assistant
Engineer in the Agricultural Engineering Department was exclusively for direct
recruits through TNPSC, over a period of time, by subsequent amendments the
post had been opened for in-service candidates, who acquired B.E. degree and
their seniority re-fixed with retrospective effect. As a consequence, the quota
for direct appointment through TNPSC also amended and got reduced. Above
all, the direct recruitment for A.E. from among the freshers through TNPSC
never took place for years together. This has prompted one of the unemployed
Engineering graduate in Agricultural Engineering and the Association of
unemployed Agricultural Engineering to file these writ petitions.
24. The Government derives it power to frame Rules for recruitment in
public services from Article 309 of the Indian Constitution. The power to issue
Executive Orders touching upon the public services is not an absolute power. It
has to withstand the scrutiny of constitutional validity. No Rule which governs
public employment shall be in violation of Article 14 or 16 of the Constitution
of India. The Rules must be free from Arbitrariness and any person aggrieved
by a Rule which bristles with arbitrariness or discriminatory, then he is entitled
to knock the doors of justice invoking Article 226 of the Constitution of India.
In case ‘malice in law’ or ‘malice in fact’ is apparently found in the Service
__________
Page25 of 36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 06:35:10 pm )

W.P.No.34990 and 37033 of 2007
Rule so framed, Court cannot refuse to examine the case and turn down the
person aggrieved at the threshold. Any person or collection of persons if
aggrieved and able to demonstrate that the Service Rules so framed is per se
arbitrary or discriminatory or in gross violation of Constitutional ethos, the
Court is duty bound to scrutiny the constitutional validity of such Rules
exercising the power of judicial review.
25. From the G.O’s issued periodically, we find that the Service Rules
particularly Rule 2(a) of the Special Rules for Tamil Nadu Agricultural
Engineering Service, the quota fixed for B.E. graduates to be appointed as A.E.
by Direct Recruitment not only substantially diminished, but even that quota
had not been filled by conducting direct recruitment process through TNPSC.
Hence, we hold that the writ petitioners have made out prima facie case to
entertain their petitions. However, the Court has to examine whether the
petitioners claim that all the AEs appointed by recruitment by transfer after
19/07/1994 is unconstitutional and to be declared as illegal and consequentially,
the vacancies must be filled through TNPSC from among the eligible B.E.
graduates by direct recruitment is sustainable.
26. To buttress his submission that undue advantage to the in-service
candidates given by the Government by frequent amendments to the recruitment
Rules at the cost of the young engineering graduates waiting for employment in
__________
Page26 of 36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 06:35:10 pm )

W.P.No.34990 and 37033 of 2007
public service, the Learned Counsel for the writ petitioners, rely on the
judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court rendered in K.Narayanan and others -
vs- State of Karnataka and others (1994 Suppl (1) SCC 44 ) and B.Thirumal -
vs- Ananda Sivakumar and others (2014 (16) SCC 593).
27. Per contra, the Learned Special Government Pleader submit that, the
aspirants for a public service cannot be equated with the persons who are
already in service. They are not equals and the amendment to Rule 2 (a) of the
Special Rules is in no way discriminate the aspirants to the service and the
persons already in service. The prayer in the writ petitions suffers a
fundamental infirmity. Writ petitions filed in the year 2007 to reverse all the
recruitments made to the post of Assistant Engineer (A.E.) by transfer after
19/07/1994. Except alleging that the amendment to the Service Rules had
favoured the in-service candidates, no malice of law or fact made out. The
preamble to the amendments clearly explains the reason and object for those
amendments. Both the judgments cited by the writ petitioners are between the
direct recruits and promotees in respect of giving retrospective effect to the
amendments relating to fixation of seniority. Same cannot be cited as precedent
for a dispute between aspirants and in service candidates.
28. In K.Narayanan case (cited supra), which is a dispute between direct
recruited Assistant Engineers and promotees from Junior Engineers as Assistant
__________
Page27 of 36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 06:35:10 pm )

W.P.No.34990 and 37033 of 2007
Engineers in PWD, Karnataka, the Hon’ble Supreme Court introduces the facts
of the case as below and proceeds further:-
“2. Engineering services in the Public Works
Department (PWD) of the country can justly feel proud for
having contributed largest number of decisions from this
Court touching upon nearly every aspect of service law the
most common being seniority. This has resulted to a large
extent due to different set of rules framed in different States
to accommodate and benefit one set of employees over
another either to mitigate injustice arising out of peculiar
circumstances as in the State of Andhra Pradesh due to
merger of the State of Hyderabad, or because of
sympathetic consideration of supposed injustice as in the
State of Karnataka or due to pressure and pull depending
on the strength of the Association of Employees of one or
the other group coupled with if the Chief Engineer in the
State was a promotee or direct.” 
29. The above said observation is equally applies to the Agricultural
engineering department in Tamil Nadu also. However, a vital difference is in
the case cited, the amendment to the Service Rules in the year 1985, was
challenged by persons who were already in service and directly aggrieved by
the amendment which has given retrospective effect from 01/01/1976. The
challenge was made immediately before the Karnataka Administrative Tribunal
and reached finality in 1994.
__________
Page28 of 36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 06:35:10 pm )

W.P.No.34990 and 37033 of 2007
30. Further, the amendment to the Rules is slightly different. The Apex
Court in K.Narayanan case (cited supra) had particularly disapproved giving
retrospective effect to the amended Rule causing apparent inequality among
Direct Recruits and Promotees. Hence, we extract the relevant Rule for easy
comparison with the Rule impugned in their writ petitions.
“ For Direct recruitment :
Should be a holder of a degree in Civil Engineering or Mechanical
Engineering depending upon the requirements, as the case may be or
of a Diploma certificate from a recognised Institute of Engineers that
he has passed parts A and B of the Associate Membership
Examination of the Institute of Engineers or equivalent qualification.
Age: Must not have attained the age of thirty-five years.
For transfer :
Must possess B.E., or AMIE (India) qualification in Civil
Engineering, or Mechanical Engineering.
Note (1).— The option of the Junior Engineer shall be obtained before
such transfer within the time stipulated by the Government.
Note (2).— The transfer shall be effective from the date of
graduation subject to the availability of vacancies without
ignoring the inter se seniority among those eligible for such
transfer.
Note (3).— A Junior Engineer who is appointed by transfer as
Assistant Engineer on or after January 1, 1976 shall be entitled to
count one-third of the service rendered by him as Junior Engineer
prior to appointment as Assistant Engineer, subject to a
maximum of 4 years, as if he had been in the post of Assistant
Engineer for the purpose of consideration for promotion to the
one post of Assistant Executive Engineer Division-I and subject to
__________
Page29 of 36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 06:35:10 pm )

W.P.No.34990 and 37033 of 2007
the following conditions, namely:
( i ) The seniority of a Junior Engineer who is appointed as Assistant
Engineer shall be fixed in the category of Assistant Engineers with
reference to the notional date arrived at after giving weightage of
service as aforesaid;
( ii ) A Junior Engineer who is appointed as Assistant Engineer shall
put in a minimum service of two years, on duty as Assistant Engineer,
after such appointment and a total service of five years as Assistant
Engineer, inclusive of the service given as weightage to become
eligible for promotion as Assistant Executive Engineer Division-I.”
31. The Apex Court in K.Narayanan case (cited supra) on due
consideration of the facts observed:-
“4. Are the rules violative of Articles 14 and 16 of the
Constitution? Do the rules framed in 1985 with effect from 1976
suffer from inherent vice of discrimination? What is the import of
Notes (2) and (3) of the Rules? Does it mean that seniority should be
taken back to the date of acquiring degree and then four years more
for having rendered service as diploma engineer or four years in all
from before the date of appointment by transfer? What is apparent
from the historical background is that the diploma-holder Junior
Engineers formed a different class than degree-holder Junior
Engineers. They were treated differently by the rule-making authority
and when the High Court equated them the Legislature intervened
and they were classified as different class statutorily. It is further
clear that the cadre of Assistant Engineer was different from Junior
Engineer. The method of recruitment, selection, pay scale and
promotional avenues were all different. A Junior Engineer could
move up to Assistant Executive Engineer Division II whereas an
Assistant Engineer was entitled to be promoted as Assistant
Executive Engineer Division I. This distinction founded on valid
__________
Page30 of 36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 06:35:10 pm )

W.P.No.34990 and 37033 of 2007
classification both on the nature of job and the qualification, existing
in service since long could not be obliterated and the two, that is, the
Junior Engineer and Assistant Engineer belonging to two different
cadres could not be treated as one only because the diploma holder
in course of service acquired the degree.
5. Demarcation of cadres or gradation in the same cadre on
higher and lower qualification is a common phenomenon for fixing
hierarchy in services. It is a valid basis of classification as held by
this Court in State of Mysorev. P. Narasing Rao [(1968) 1 SCR 407 :
AIR 1968 SC 349 : (1968) 2 LLJ 120] , Union of India v. Dr S.B.
Kohli (Mrs) [(1973) 3 SCC 592 : 1973 SCC (L&S) 136] , State of
J&K v. Triloki Nath Khosa [(1974) 1 SCC 19 : 1974 SCC (L&S)
49] , P. Murugesan v. State of T.N. [(1993) 2 SCC 340 : 1993 SCC
(L&S) 445 : (1993) 24 ATC 149 : JT (1993) 2 SC 115] Engineering
services throughout the country, normally, maintain distinction
between Junior and Assistant Engineer on diploma and degree. It
existed in the State of Karnataka right from the day the rules were
framed. It has been done away with on assumption by the Cabinet
that some of the duties performed by the two were common. The
Tribunal did not agree with it, and in our opinion rightly. But that
alone is not sufficient to strike down the rule. A policy decision taken
by the Government is not liable to interference, unless the Court is
satisfied that the rule-making authority has acted arbitrarily or in
violation of the fundamental rights guaranteed under Articles 14 and
16. Appointment by transfer in the same service or from the different
cadre or service but equal in rank and status is well known. But
transfer from lower to higher cadre not by promotion but direct
appointment only because the incumbent became eligible without any
selection, test or criteria may not be in consonance with service
discipline. 
Rules were thus bent and made retrospective as a sympathetic
consideration as many Junior Engineers who were working since
__________
Page31 of 36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 06:35:10 pm )

W.P.No.34990 and 37033 of 2007
long would not have derived any benefit otherwise. May be true but if
the extension of such benefit impinges upon the constitutional
guarantee of equality then it cannot be upheld. And that does stand
disturbed. Nothing further need be said. Nor it is necessary to
pronounce on the validity of a rule which in the class of appointment
by direct recruitment includes appointment by transfer resulting in
entry of one class by competition or selection and other by
acquisition of minimum qualification as the appellants did not
challenge the rule of appointment by transfer but confined their
claim to its operation retrospectively.
The Apex Court finally concluded as below:-
9. For the reasons stated above these appeals and writ petition
succeed and are allowed. The following directions are issued:
(i) The order of the tribunal dated October 21, 1988 is set aside.
The second paragraph of the 1985 Amendment Rules making it
operative from January 1, 1976 is struck down as ultra vires.
(ii) Note (2) shall be read as providing eligibility only.
(iii) The respondents are directed to prepare fresh gradation list in
light of observations made above.”
32. In so far the judgment in B.Thirumal -vs- Ananda Sivakumar and
others (cited supra), it is in respect of re-designation of Diploma Holder Junior
Engineers (JEs) as Assistant Engineers (AEs) on acquiring degree qualification.
The challenge to the said re-designation was on the ground that, it provides dual
promotional channel to the post of Assistant Executive Engineer in the Tamil
Nadu Engineering Service. The appellant B.Thirumal who was a Junior
Engineer (Electrical) in Public Works Department, Tamil Nadu governed by
Special Rules for Engineering Sub-ordinate Service aggrieved by the practise of
__________
Page32 of 36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 06:35:10 pm )

W.P.No.34990 and 37033 of 2007
empanelling Assistant Engineers (Electrical) for promotion to the post of
Assistant Executive Engineer (Class IV) in the 25% quota reserved for members
of Subordinate Engineering Services. The appeal was dismissed with the
following observation:-
“ 31. The upshot of the above discussion is that the degree-
holder Junior Engineers continue to be members of the Subordinate
Engineering Service even after they are redesignated as Assistant
Engineers upon them getting a degree qualification. They can,
therefore, be considered only against the 25% quota reserved for the
Subordinate Service and not against 75% reserved for the State
Service members directly recruited to that service or appointed by
transfer in terms of the Rules. To the extent the redesignated
Assistant Engineers have been considered in the past for promotion
in the quota reserved for Assistant Engineers in the State Service,
the consideration was legally bad. Having said that, we do not
propose to interfere with what has been done in the past especially
when there is no challenge before us to the appointment of the
redesignated Assistant Engineers as Assistant Executive Engineers
against vacancies falling in 75% quota. The settled position need
not, therefore, be unsettled at this stage in these proceedings.”
33. To sum up, the challenge to the Service Rules by persons not in
service or outside the service is generally not sustainable. Providing
promotional avenues to the in-service candidates cannot be questioned by any
outsider or aspirants for the post of Assistant Engineer. The re-designation of
the post for administrative reasons also falls beyond the purview of the judicial
review. However, the grievance exposed by the writ petitioners does not stop
__________
Page33 of 36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 06:35:10 pm )

W.P.No.34990 and 37033 of 2007
with challenging the Rules. On examination of the facts in detail, it reveals
continuous deprivation of the opportunity for members of the confederation
who are unemployed engineering graduates in Agricultural Engineering to
participate in the selection process.
34. Multiple amendments to the rules and failure on the part of the
respondents to conduct periodical recruitment process for direct recruitment to
fill the quota reserved for them is taken judicial notice. Though the prayer in
these writ petitions cannot be granted at this point of time, since it will unsettle
the settled position, we direct the respondents to determine the number of
substantive posts for Assistant Engineer (Agricultural Engineering) and the
number of posts reserved for Engineering graduates to be appointed through
TNPSC. If these posts are not filled up by directly recruited Engineering
graduates through the TNPSC, but occupied by other feeder category, such
number of posts to be filled up by direct recruitment. For those occupying the
posts of Assistant Engineer in the slots meant for Direct recruitment,
supernumerary posts are to be created till they join the mainstream by applying
Catch-up Theory as and when the slots for promotees recruitment transfer fall
vacant. This process of appointing Engineering graduates as Assistant Engineers
in the Agricultural Department through Direct Recruitment should commence
within two months from the date of receipt of this order and the same should get
completed within nine months thereafter.
__________
Page34 of 36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 06:35:10 pm )

W.P.No.34990 and 37033 of 2007
35. With the above directions, these Writ Petitions are disposed of.
There shall be no order as to costs. Consequently, connected Miscellaneous
Petitions are closed.
(G.J.,J.) (E.M.,J.)
17-11-2026
Index: Yes
Speaking/Non-speaking order
Neutral Citation: Yes/No
ari
To
1. The Secretary
Government Of Tamil Nadu
Agriculture Department,
Fort St. George, Chennai 600 009
2. The Chief Engineer
Agricultural Engineering Department,
Chennai 600 005
3. The Tamil Nadu Public Service Commission,
Government Estate, Chennai 600 002
__________
Page35 of 36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 06:35:10 pm )

W.P.No.34990 and 37033 of 2007
DR.G.JAYACHANDRAN J.
AND
E.MANOHARAN J.
ARI
delivery Common order made in
W.P.No.34990 of 2007
AND
W.P.N o .37033 of 2007
and
M.P.Nos.1& 2/2007 and 1 & 2/2007
17.11.2026
__________
Page36 of 36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 06:35:10 pm )