GOPAL KRISHNA CHAKRA vs SATYAPRIYA SAMANTRAY
- Court
- Odisha High Court
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ORISSA AT CUTTACK
MACA No.292 of 2011
CNR No. ODHC010018672011
(An appeal Under Section 173(1) of MV Act, 1988).
Gopal Krishna Chakra … Appellant
-versus-
Satyapriya Samantaray and
another
Respondents
…
For Appellant : Mr. S. Mohanty, Advocate
For Respondents : Mr. N. Ghose, Advocate
(for R-2)
CORAM: JUSTICE G. SATAPATHY
DATE OF HEARING & JUDGMENT:16.11.2026 (ORAL)
G. Satapathy, J.
1. The appellant-claimant by way of this Appeal
U/S.173(1) of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 (In short, “the
Act”) seeks to challenge the quantum of compensation and
the liability to pay compensation to the claimant.
1.1. By the impugned judgment dated 31.01.2011
st
passed in MAC Case No.269 of 1996, the learned 1 Motor
Accident Claims Tribunal, Keonjhar
(In short, “the
Tribunal”) while dismissing the claim against R2-cum-New
India Assurance Co. Ltd. (In short, “the insurer”) has
MACA No.292 of 2011 Page 1 of 7
directed the owner of the offending Car-cum-R1 to pay the
compensation of Rs.1,43,000/- together with simple
interest @ 6% per annum w.e.f. 02.11.1996 till actual
realization to the claimant with default interest of 9% per
annum, if the award is not satisfied within a month.
2. The facts in this case, being largely undisputed
are not reiterated to avoid prolixity; but the appellant
challenges the impugned judgment on quantum of
compensation and liability to pay the compensation.
Further, the appellant claims that the insurer should be
made liable to pay the compensation to the claimant, but
not the owner of the offending Car.
3. Heard, Mr. Srinibas Mohanty, learned counsel
for the appellant and Mr. Netaji Sabyasachi Ghose, learned
counsel for R2. The notice issued against R1 had returned
unserved, but since R1 having set ex-parte by the learned
Tribunal, the re-issuance of notice against him stands
dispensed with in view of the provision under Order XLI
Rule 14(4) of the CPC.
MACA No.292 of 2011 Page 2 of 7
4. After having considered the rival submissions
and upon perusal of record, this Court while turning to the
challenge of the appellant to the quantum of compensation,
considers it appropriate to reiterate the finding of the
learned Tribunal on this issue of quantum of compensation,
which has been discussed at paragraph-6 under Issue No.2
and the same reads as under : -
“ 6. The Orthopaedic Specialist of District
Headquarters Hospital, Keonjhar Dr.BK Mohapatra
has certified that the extent of disability of the
petitioner is 45%. The petitioner has claimed that
his monthly income is Rs.4000/- per month from
business. While deposing in the Court he has
stated nothing regarding his income and from
what source he is earning. But during cross-
examination it reveals that he is an employee
under Baitarani Gramya Bank since 1988. Though
in the cross-examination he has deposed that he
is an employee under the Baitarani Gramya Bank
since 1988 but his monthly salary has not been
disclosed by him. On the other hand, his claim
petition reveals that his occupation is business and
he is earning Rs.4000/- per month. The same has
also not been explained by the petitioner while
deposing in the Court as to what type of business
he was doing. However, in the cross-examination
he has initially stated that he was doing transport
business and he had a Bus and the bus has been
auctioned as he could not pay the loan amount.
Since the petitioner is hoodwinking his real income
and is not definitely stating about the monthly
income of himself, I have to hold that he is a non-
earning person and therefore, his annual income is
to be taken as Rs.15,000/-. He was aged about 38
years as revealed from Ext.6, the discharge
MACA No.292 of 2011 Page 3 of 7
certificate from District Headquarters Hospital,
Keonjhar. In that view, multiplier 16 is to be
applied in this case. Therefore, the petitioner is
entitled to compensation of Rs.15,000/- x 16 x
45%=1,08,000/-. Besides that, the petitioner is
also entitled to Rs.10,000/- towards pain and
sufferings. With respect to medicine expenses,
some medicine bills of the year 2000 has been
filed. Since the accident occurred in 1996 the
medicine bills are of no value. However, since it is
found that he has sustained multiple fractures a
sum of Rs.10,000/- is granted towards medical
expenses of the petitioner. Besides that, as the
petitioner has sustained 3 nos. of grievous
injuries, he is entitled to compensation of
Rs.15,000/-. In total the petitioner is entitled to
get compensation of Rs.1,43,000/-.”
5. On a careful scrutiny of the aforesaid finding,
this Court does not find any infirmity or illegality, since the
appellant has not been able to prove his avocation/
profession and his income. Further, no material has been
produced or brought to the notice of this Court to differ with
the finding of the learned Tribunal on quantum of
compensation. It appears to the Court that the learned
Tribunal has rightly assessed the income by taking the
annual income of the injured-claimant at Rs.15,000/- at the
relevant time of accident and, therefore, the quantum of
compensation as computed/assessed by the learned
Tribunal needs no interference.
MACA No.292 of 2011 Page 4 of 7
6. On coming to the next question as to the
liability to pay compensation, it appears that the learned
Tribunal has dismissed the claim against the insurer on the
ground that the injured-claimant was travelling in the
offending Car as a gratuitous passenger, but in a somewhat
similar situation, the Apex Court in a very recent decision in
Sunita & Ors. Vrs. United India Insurance Co. Ltd. &
th
Ors.; Civil Appeal No.9538 of 2025 disposed of on 17
July, 2025 has held in paragraphs-15 to 17 as under: -
15. The above position has been followed by this
“
Court in Anu Bhanvara v. IFFCO Tokio General
Insurance Co. Ltd.; (2020) 20 SCC 632 ,
wherein the injured person was travelling as a
gratuitous passenger and was not covered
under the Insurance Policy, the driver and
owner of the vehicle was held liable for
payment of compensation amount. This Court
applied the principle of “Pay and Recover”
and directed the Insurance Company to pay
the amount and, thereafter, recover the
same from the owner of the vehicle.
16. The aforementioned principle was adopted by
this Court in various judgments of this Court in
Amrit Lal Sood v. Kaushalya Devi Thapar;
(1998) 3 SCC 744; New India Assurance Co.
Ltd. v. C.M. Jaya; (2002) 2 SCC 278; National
Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Challa Upendra Rao;
(2004) 8 SCC 517; New India Assurance Co.
Ltd. v. Vimal Devi; 2010 SCC OnLine SC 49;
National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Saju P. Paul;
(2013) 2 SCC 41; Manuara Khatun v. Rajesh
Kumar Singh; (2017) 4 SCC 796; and
MACA No.292 of 2011 Page 5 of 7
Puttappa v. Rama Naik; 2018 SCC OnLine SC
3496.
17. Applying the above expositions of law, the
Courts below ought to have directed the Insurance
Company to indemnify the amount and thereafter
recover the same.”
7. In the aforesaid facts and circumstance and on
consideration of the principle laid down by the Apex Court
in the decisions referred to above, this Court has no
hesitation to hold that the learned Tribunal has committed
error in dismissing the claim of the appellant against the
insurer, instead of directing the insurer to pay the
compensation amount at first and recover the same
thereafter. Consequently, no other challenge being
advanced by the appellant, the Appeal filed by the claimant
needs to be considered for modifying the liability of paying
compensation to the claimant. The learned Tribunal has
also imposed default interest @ 9%, but the same is not
permissible and such finding is, accordingly, set-aside.
8. In the result, the Appeal stands allowed on
contest against R2 and ex parte against R1, but no order as
to costs. Ergo, the R2-cum-New India Assurance Co. Ltd. is
hereby directed to pay the compensation to the claimant
MACA No.292 of 2011 Page 6 of 7
together with simple interest @ 4% per annum w.e.f.
02.11.1996 till actual realization within eight weeks hence.
The insurance company after satisfying the award is at
liberty to recover the same from the owner of the offending
Car in a separate proceeding by establishing the fact that
the deceased was travelling in the offending car as a
gratuitous passenger.
9. On deposit of the compensation amount together
with accrued interest thereon before the tribunal, the same
shall be disbursed to the claimant-appellant by keeping
70% of it in a fixed deposit in the name of claimant-
appellant in Nationalized Bank for five years.
(G. Satapathy)
Judge
Orissa High Court, Cuttack,
th
Dated the 16 day of November, 2026/Subhasmita
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed
Signed by: SUBHASMITA DAS
Designation: Sr. Stenographer
Reason: Authentication
Location: High Court of Orissa, Cuttack
Date: 17-Nov-2026 16:42:39
MACA No.292 of 2011 Page 7 of 7