KULWINDER SINGH vs STATE OF HP
- Court
- High Court of Himachal Pradesh
2026:HHC:39173
High Court of H.P.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA
Cr.MP No. 3368 of 2026 in Cr. Appeal (C-
DB) No. 43 of 2026
Reserved on: 9.9.2026
Decided on: 15.9.2026
Uploaded on: 15.9.2026
Kulwinder Singh. …Appellant/Applicant.
Versus
State of H.P. …Respondent.
Corum
Hon’ble Mr. Justice Vivek Singh Thakur, Judge.
Hon’ble Mr. Justice Bhupesh Sharma, Judge.
1
Whether approved for reporting? Yes.
For the Applicant. Mr. Virbahadur Verma and Mr.Aditya Singh
Rathore, Advocates.
For the Respondent : Mr.I.N. Mehta, Senior Additional Advocate
General.
Vivek Singh Thakur, Judge
This application has been preferred by respondent-State
under Section 432 of Bharatiya Nagrik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 (for short
‘BNSS’) (old Section 391 of Cr.P.C.), for placing on record additional
documents i.e. Matriculation Certificate of child victim and to
re-examine/examine child victim and Principal/Superintendent of
1
Whether the reporters of the local papers may be allowed to see the Judgment? Yes
::: Downloaded on - 15/09/2026 13:13:04 :::CIS
2
2026:HHC:39173
Cr.M.P No. 3368 of 2026
High Court of H.P.
Government Senior Secondary School, Swahan/Open School registered
from State or custodian of relevant record in order to prove and exhibit the
additional documents proposed to be placed on record.
2. The main appeal has been preferred by appellant against
even dated impugned judgment and order dated 19.12.2025 passed in
Sessions Trial No. 13/7 of 2020 titled as State of H.P. Vs. Kulwinder Singh
arising out of FIR No. 25/2020 dated 27.2.2020 registered at Police Station
Kot-Kehloor, District Bilaspur, H.P. under Sections 354A, 354D, 376, 506 of
the Indian Penal Code and Section of the Protection of Children from
Sexual Offences Act, 2012 (for short ‘POCSO Act’), whereby appellant has
been convicted for commission of offences under Sections 354A, 354D,
376, and 506 IPC and Section 4(2) of the POCSO Act and has been
sentenced to undergo rigorous imprisonment for 20 years under Section
4(2) of the POCSO Act; to further undergo simple imprisonment of 6
months each under Sections 354A, 354D, and 506 IPC and also to pay a
fine of 2,000/- under Section 354D IPC, and in default of payment of fine, ₹
to further undergo simple imprisonment for two months.
3. We have heard learned Senior Additional Advocate General
for the applicant/State as well as learned counsel for
non-applicant/appellant and have also gone through the material available
on record.
::: Downloaded on - 15/09/2026 13:13:04 :::CIS
3
2026:HHC:39173
Cr.M.P No. 3368 of 2026
High Court of H.P.
4. To prove age of victim, prosecution has examined PW-20
Sodhi Ram, Secretary, Gram Panchayat Bhakhra, Tehsil Naina Devi,
District Bilaspur, H.P. by proving the Date of Birth certificate, Ex. P-1/PW-
20, issued by him under the Registration of Births and Deaths Act, 1969,
read with the Himachal Pradesh Registration of Births and Deaths Rules,
2003, as local Registrar Births and Deaths and Marriage registration Gram
Panchayat Ghawandal, indicating date of birth of victim as 9.8.2004. PW-
23 Neelam Kumar, Investigating Officer, has also proved on record copy of
the Pariwar Register, Ex. P-4/PW-23, indicating the date of birth of the
victim as 9.8.2004.
5. Learned Senior Additional Advocate General has submitted
that during the course of preparation of final arguments, it transpired that
prosecution had not produced the date of birth of victim from the school
record, whereas at the time of incident, victim had passed matriculation
examination and thus her Matriculation Certificate was available which was
and is required to be proved her date of birth under Section 94 of the
Juvenile Justice Act, 2015, as applicable to the present case. Further that
it appears that either for ignorance or mistake committed by Investigating
Officer, Matriculation Certificate of victim was not taken into possession
and/or produced in evidence during the Trial, whereas the said certificate
was and is necessary to adjudicate the issue of age of victim and thus was
::: Downloaded on - 15/09/2026 13:13:04 :::CIS
4
2026:HHC:39173
Cr.M.P No. 3368 of 2026
High Court of H.P.
and is required to be proved on record to indicate her date of birth recorded
in the school record/Matriculation Certificate.
6. In response learned Senior Additional Advocate General has
submitted that State intends to prove age of victim by producing
Matriculation Certificate and School record by reexamining PW-1 victim and
examining Record Keeper/Office Superintendent/Principal of the concerned
School, by production of Matriculation Certificate of victim alongwith School
record related thereto.
7. It has been submitted by learned Senior Additional Advocate
General that it is not a case where the prosecution has not led any
evidence regarding the date of birth of victim during trial, but efforts were
made as per prudence or knowledge of the Investigating Officer to
lead/produce evidence of date of birth of the victim by placing on record Ex.
P-1/PW-20 and Ex. P-4/PW-23 and thus, it is not a case of 'no evidence'
led by the prosecution, but it is an inadvertent mistake, and, therefore, in
the interest of justice as well as to protect the interest of minor victim and
also to act in accordance with the essence of the POCSO Act, the
application deserves to be allowed.
8. It has been further submitted on behalf of State that non-
production of Matriculation Certificate was an inadvertent mistake which
was neither intentional nor deliberate and was beyond the control of the
::: Downloaded on - 15/09/2026 13:13:04 :::CIS
5
2026:HHC:39173
Cr.M.P No. 3368 of 2026
High Court of H.P.
victim, for whose protection and safeguarding the interest present criminal
proceedings were initiated.
9. It has been further submitted that no new fact is proposed to
be brought on record, but the evidence, necessary to substantiate the
already claimed and proved fact on record, has been proposed to be
produced on record in evidence by examining the victim and Record
Keeper/Office Superintendent/Principal of concerned School.
10. It has been submitted by learned Senior Additional Advocate
General that for doing substantial justice and to arrive at just decision,
evidence, proposed to be proved on record, is necessary and no prejudice
is going to be caused to the non-applicant/appellant, as he will have
opportunity to cross-examine the witness on the issue on which evidence is
being proposed to be led as additional evidence and also for the fact that
no new case is being set up by the prosecution by leading any evidence on
the fact which has not been disclosed, set up or relied upon by the State
during the trial.
11. It has also been submitted that in similar circumstances in
another case, an application Cr.MP No. 3682 of 2024 in Cr. Appeal No. 233
of 2022, was allowed and prosecution was permitted to lead evidence at
appellate stage under Sections 311 and 391 of the Code of Criminal
Procedure for just decision and to meet the ends of justice.
::: Downloaded on - 15/09/2026 13:13:04 :::CIS
6
2026:HHC:39173
Cr.M.P No. 3368 of 2026
High Court of H.P.
12. It has also been submitted in the application that in similar
circumstances an application Cr.MP No. 5315 of 2025 in Cr. Appeal No.
225 of 2021, was allowed and prosecution was permitted to lead evidence
at appellate stage under Sections 311 and 391 of the Code of Criminal
Procedure for just decision and to meet the ends of justice.
13. For opposing the prayer made in the application, detailed
reply has been filed on behalf of non-applicant/appellant, taking numerous
objections, including that the application is not maintainable, as this stage.
14. Learned counsel for non-applicant/appellant submits that as
the prosecution has failed to place on record and prove the date of birth of
victim by not producing Matriculation Certificate during the trial, but has
relied upon only Birth Certificate issued under the Registration of Births and
Deaths Act as well as Pariwar Register, which can only be considered in
case there is no Matriculation Certificate or school record of date of birth is
available, now at the appellate stage, respondent-State cannot be allowed
to lead additional evidence to prove the date of birth of victim by placing on
record copy of Matriculation Certificate as additional evidence and thus
neither respondent-State can be allowed to produce the Matriculation
Certificate, nor there is any necessity of examining/re-examining the victim
or summoning the witnesses to that effect, as proposed. Therefore, it has
been prayed that the application deserves to be dismissed.
::: Downloaded on - 15/09/2026 13:13:04 :::CIS
7
2026:HHC:39173
Cr.M.P No. 3368 of 2026
High Court of H.P.
15. It has been contended on behalf of learned counsel for the
applicant that power under Section 391 of Cr.P.C. now Section 432 of
BNSS, is not to be exercised in a routine or casual manner, as a disguise
for a re-trial or to fill up gaps lacunas and serious omissions caused by the
negligence or laches or undue delay on the part of prosecution during
original trial.
16. Learned counsel for the non-applicant/appellant, to oppose
the prayer made in the application, has placed reliance upon judgments of
the Apex Court in Swapan Kumar Chatterjee Vs. Central Bureau of
Investigation, (2019) 14 SCC 328 , wherein it has been observed by the
Apex Court that where prosecution evidence has been closed long back
and reasons for non-examination of witness earlier are not satisfactory re-
summoning of witness at belated stage would cause grave prejudice to
accused and should not be allowed.
17. Learned counsel for non-applicant/appellant has referred
judgment of this High Court in Jagdeep Kumar Vs. Himachal Pradesh
State Cooperative Bank Limited, 2019 (3) SLC 1354 , wherein it has been
observed that Section 391 of Cr.P.C. (now Section 432 of BNSS) is not
intended to remedy the negligence or laches of the party.
18. It has also been contended by learned counsel for the non-
applicant/appellant that facts and circumstances for allowing the application
for additional evidence in Cr. Appeal No. 233 of 2022 and Cr. Appeal No.
::: Downloaded on - 15/09/2026 13:13:04 :::CIS
8
2026:HHC:39173
Cr.M.P No. 3368 of 2026
High Court of H.P.
225 of 2021 were totally different in comparison to facts and circumstances
of the present case and thus order passed in the same is not applicable to
present case.
19. Referring the provisions of Sections 348 and 432 of the
BNSS, learned Senior Additional Advocate General has justified filing of the
application at this stage with submission that even in absence of this
application, Court has power to call for additional evidence which is
considered to be necessary for ends of justice, and to justify the necessity
of additional evidence, he has re-iterated the averments made in the
application and submissions made in support thereof referred supra.
20. For determining the issue involved in present application, it
would be relevant to refer provisions of Section 348 and 432 of BNSS
(Section 311 and 391 of Cr.P.C.), which read as under:-
“348. Power to summon material witness, or examine person
present. -Any Court may, at any stage of any inquiry, trial or other
proceeding under this Sanhita, summon any person as a witness,
or examine any person in attendance, though not summoned as a
witness, or recall and re-examine any person already examined;
and the Court shall summon and examine or recall and re-examine
any such person if his evidence appears to it to be essential to the
just decision of the case.
[ Old Corresponding Section : Sc. 311 of the Code of Criminal
Procedure, 1973.]
432. Appellate Court may take further evidence or direct it to
be taken .---(1) In dealing with any appeal under this Chapter, the
Appellate Court, if it thinks additional evidence to be necessary,
::: Downloaded on - 15/09/2026 13:13:04 :::CIS
9
2026:HHC:39173
Cr.M.P No. 3368 of 2026
High Court of H.P.
shall record its reasons and may either take such evidence itself, or
direct it to be taken by a Magistrate or, when the Appellate Court is
a High Court, by a Court of Session or a Magistrate.
(2) When the additional evidence is taken by the Court of Session
or the Magistrate, it or he shall certify such evidence to the
Appellate Court, and such Court shall thereupon proceed to
dispose of the appeal.
(3) The accused or his advocate shall have the right to be present
when the additional evidence is taken.
(4) The taking of evidence under this section shall be subject to the
provisions of Chapter XXIV, as if it were an inquiry.”
21. Perusal of order dated 20.9.2024 passed in Cr.MP No. 3682
of 2024, depicts that the issue involved in the said application was almost
similar to the issue involved in present matter. The following paras of the
said order are also relevant to be referred in present matter:-
“7. It is settled law that Section 311 Cr. P.C. confers a very wide
power on the Courts to summon any person as a witness at any
stage of any inquiry, trial or other proceeding and examine or recall
and reexamine any such person, if his evidence appears to be
essential to the just decision of the case.
8. The scope of Section 311 of the Cr.PC has been considered
by the Hon’ble Supreme Court inter alia in Natasha Singh Vs.
Central Bureau of Investigation, (2013) 5 SCC 741, wherein the
Court, after reference to earlier authorities, stated the principle in
the following terms:
“8. Section 311 Cr. P.C. empowers the court to summon a
material witness, or to examine a person present at “any
stage” of “any enquiry”, or “trial”, or “any other
proceedings” under the Cr.P.C., or to summon any person
::: Downloaded on - 15/09/2026 13:13:04 :::CIS
10
2026:HHC:39173
Cr.M.P No. 3368 of 2026
High Court of H.P.
as a witness, or to recall and re-examine any person who
has already been examined if his evidence appears to it, to
be essential to the arrival of a just decision of the case.
Undoubtedly, the Cr.P.C. has conferred a very wide
discretionary power upon the court in this respect, but such
a discretion is to be exercised judiciously and not
arbitrarily. The power of the court in this context is very
wide, and in exercise of the same, it may summon any
person as a witness at any stage of the trial, or other
proceedings. The court is competent to exercise such
power even suo motu if no such application has been filed
by either of the parties. However, the court must satisfy
itself, that it was in fact essential to examine such a
witness, or to recall him for further examination in order to
arrive at a just decision of the case.
xxxxx
15……….. The power conferred under Section 311 Cr.
P.C. must therefore, be invoked by the Court only in order
to meet the ends of justice, for strong and valid reasons,
and the same must be exercised with great caution and
circumspection. The very use of words such as ‘any Court’,
‘at any stage”, or ‘or any enquiry, trial or other
proceedings’, ‘any person’ and ‘any such person’ clearly
spells out that the provisions of this section have been
expressed in the widest possible terms, and do not limit
the discretion of the Court in any way. There is thus no
escape if the fresh evidence to be obtained is essential to
the just decision of the case. The determinative factor
should therefore be, whether the summoning/recalling of
the said witness is in fact, essential to the just decision of
the case.”
::: Downloaded on - 15/09/2026 13:13:04 :::CIS
11
2026:HHC:39173
Cr.M.P No. 3368 of 2026
High Court of H.P.
9. In Varsha Garg Vs. State of Madhya Pradesh, AIR 2022 SC
3707 , it has been held as under:-
“25 Further, the Court while relying upon the earlier
decisions in J.K. International v. State (Govt. of NCT of
Delhi)14, Zahira Habibulla H. Sheikh v. State of Gujarat15,
Manu Sharma v. State (NCT of Delhi)16, Mohanlal Shamji
Soni v. Union of India, Rajendra Prasad v. Narcotic Cell,
noted:
“31 …a criminal court cannot remain a silent
spectator. It has got a participatory role to play
and having been invested with enormous powers
under Section 311 CrPC, as well as Section 165
of the Evidence Act, a trial court in a situation like
the present one where it was brought to the notice
of the court that a flagrant contradiction in the
evidence of PW 18 who was a statutory authority
and in whose presence the test identification
parade was held, who is also a Judicial
Magistrate, ought to have risen to the occasion in
public interest and remedied the situation by
invoking Section 311 Cr.PC, by recalling the said
witness with further direction to (2001) 3 SCC 462
(2004) 4 SCC 158 (2010) 6 SCC 1 (1991) Supp
(1) SCC 271 (1999) 6 SCC 110 the Public
Prosecutor for putting across the appropriate
question or court question to the said witness and
thereby set right the glaring error accordingly. It is
unfortunate to state that the trial court miserably
failed to come alive to the realities as to the nature
of evidence that was being recorded and
::: Downloaded on - 15/09/2026 13:13:04 :::CIS
12
2026:HHC:39173
Cr.M.P No. 3368 of 2026
High Court of H.P.
miserably failed in its duty to note the serious flaw
and error in the recording of evidence of PW 18.”
10. In S wapan Kumar Chatterjee Vs. Central Bureau
of Investigation, (2019) 14 SCC 328 , which has been
relied upon by the learned counsel for the
non-applicant/appellant, it has been held as under:-
“11. It is well settled that the power conferred
under Section 311 should be invoked by the court
only to meet the ends of justice. The power is to
be exercised only for strong and valid reasons and
it should be exercised with great caution and
circumspection. The court has vide power under
this Section to even recall witnesses for
reexamination or further examination, necessary
in the interest of justice, but the same has to be
exercised after taking into consideration the facts
and circumstances of each case. The power
under this provision shall not be exercised if the
court is of the view that the application has been
filed as an abuse of the process of law.”
11. Our own High Court in Sonu Vs. State of Himachal
Pradesh, 2020 (1) Shim. LC 567 has held as under:-
“12. ….. The legal principles culled out on the
basis of the law so discussed reads as follow:
i) Lacuna in the prosecution case must be
understood as the inherent weakness or
latent wedge in the matrix thereof.
ii) the advantage of a lacuna in the
prosecution case normally go in favour of
the accused but an oversight during the
::: Downloaded on - 15/09/2026 13:13:04 :::CIS
13
2026:HHC:39173
Cr.M.P No. 3368 of 2026
High Court of H.P.
course of trial cannot be treated as
irreparable lacuna.
iii) the function of the criminal courts is
administration of criminal justice and not to
count errors committed by the parties during
the course of trial. The object of Section 311
of the code is that there may not be failure
of justice on account of mistake of either
party in bringing the valuable piece of
evidence on record or leaving ambiguity in
the statements of witnesses examined by
either side.
iv) The determinative factor is as to whether
it is essential to re-examine a witness for the
just decision of the case.
v) The only object underlying Section 311 of
the code is to bring on record the evidence
not only from the point of view of the
accused and the prosecution but also from
the point of view of the orderly society.
vi) The nature, scope and object of Section
311 of the Code dealing with the principles
for exercise of discretionary power is that
the power under Section 311 of the Code
though is vast one and can be exercised at
any stage of the trial. However, should be
exercised only in those cases where the
evidence to be tendered by the witness on
re-call is germane to the issue involved. In
case such evidence could not be adduced
or brought on record due to an
::: Downloaded on - 15/09/2026 13:13:04 :::CIS
14
2026:HHC:39173
Cr.M.P No. 3368 of 2026
High Court of H.P.
inadvertence, the power is not limited to re-
call a witness for further cross-examination
with reference to his previous statement but
also to take additional evidence for any
reasons at a just decision
vii) This discovery of truth is essential
principles of any trial or inquiry to render a
just decision after discovering all relevant
facts.
viii) Of course power must be exercised
judiciously and not capriciously or arbitrarily
as any improper or capricious power may
lead to undesirable results.
ix) The additional evidence must not be
received as a disguise for retrial or to
change the nature of the case against either
of the parties.
x) The opportunity to cross-examine the
witness qua the additional evidence
recorded on re-examination and to produce
rebuttal evidence, if any, should be given to
the other party.
xi) The very use of words such as “any
Court”, “at any stage”,or “or any inquiry, trial
or other proceedings”, “any person” and“any
such person” clearly spells out that the
provisions of Section 311 of the Code have
to be exercised in the widest possible terms
and do not limit the discretion of the Court in
any way. Fair trial entails the interest of the
accused, the victim and of the society,
::: Downloaded on - 15/09/2026 13:13:04 :::CIS
15
2026:HHC:39173
Cr.M.P No. 3368 of 2026
High Court of H.P.
therefore, fair trial includes the grant of fair
and proper opportunities to the parties.
Where the offence is against society, it is
the unfortunate victim, who is the actual
sufferer,hence it is imperative for the
prosecution to ensure that no stone is left
unturned to bring guilt home to the accused.
xii) That the power under Section 311 of the
Code must be exercised with caution and
circumspection and only for strong and valid
reason as recall of a witness already
examined is not an opportunity as a matter
of course and discretion given to the court in
his regard has to be exercised judicially to
prevent failure of justice.
xiii) that delay in filing the application for re-
calling a witness is one of the important
factor and the same should be explained in
the application.”
12. Thus the object underlying Section 311 of the Code is
that there may not be failure of justice on account of
mistake of either party in bringing the valuable evidence on
record or leaving ambiguity in the statements of the
witnesses examined from either side. The determinative
factor is whether it is essential to the just decision of the
case. The section is not limited only for the benefit of the
accused, and it will not be an improper exercise of the
powers of the court to summon a witness under the section
merely because the evidence supports the case of the
prosecution and not that of the accused. The section is a
general section which applies to all proceedings, enquiries
::: Downloaded on - 15/09/2026 13:13:04 :::CIS
16
2026:HHC:39173
Cr.M.P No. 3368 of 2026
High Court of H.P.
and trials under the Code and in this section, the
significant expression that occurs is "at any stage of any
inquiry or trial or other proceeding under this Code”.
22. In this regard pronouncement of the Apex Court in Rajeshwar
Prasad Misra Vs. The State of West Bengal and Another, AIR 1965 SC
1887 , are relevant, which are as under:-
“9. Additional evidence may be necessary for a variety of reasons
which it is hardly necessary (even if it was possible) to list here. We
do not propose to do what the Legislative has refrained from doing,
namely, to control discretion of the appellate Court to certain stated
circumstances. It may, however, be said that additional evidence
must be necessary not because it would be impossible to
pronounce judgment but because there would be failure of justice
without it. The power must be exercised sparingly and only in
suitable cases. Once such action is justified, there is no restriction
on the kind of evidence which may be received. It may be formal or
substantial. It mus, of course, not be received in such a way as to
cause prejudice to the accused as for example it should not be
received as a disguise for a retrial or to change the nature of the
case against him. The order must not ordinarily be made if the
prosecution has had a fair opportunity and has not availed of it
unless the requirements of justice dictate otherwise. Commentaries
upon the Code are full of cases in which the powers under S. 428
were exercised. We were cited a fair number at the hearing. Some
of the decisions suffer from the sin of generalization and some
others from that of arguing from analogy. The facts in the cited
cases are so different that it would be futile to embark upon their
examination. We might have attempted this, if we could see some
useful purpose but we see none. We would be right in assuming the
existence of a discriminatory power in the High Court and all that we
::: Downloaded on - 15/09/2026 13:13:04 :::CIS
17
2026:HHC:39173
Cr.M.P No. 3368 of 2026
High Court of H.P.
consider necessary is to see whether the discretion was properly
exercised.”
23. Following paras of judgment of the Apex Court passed in
Rambhau and others Vs. State of Maharashtra, (2001) 4 SCC 759 are
also relevant:-
“2. A word of caution however, ought to be introduced for guidance,
to wit: that this additional evidence cannot and ought not to be
received in such a way so as to cause any prejudice to the accused.
It is not a disguise for a retrial or to change the nature of the case
against the accused. This Court in the case of Rajeswar Prasad
Misra v. State of W.B AIR 1965 SC 1987 in no uncertain terms
observed that the order must not ordinarily be made if the
prosecution has 52 had a fair opportunity and has not availed of it.
This Court was candid enough to record however, that it is the
concept of justice which ought to prevail and in the event, the same
dictates exercise of power as conferred by the Code, there ought
not to be any hesitation in that regard.
3. Be it noted that no set of principles can be set forth for such an
exercise of power under Section 391, since the same is dependent
upon the fact-situation of the matter and having due regard to the
concept of fair play and justice, well being of the society.
4. Incidentally, Section 391 forms an exception to the general rule
that an Appeal must be decided on the evidence which was before
the Trial Court and the powers being an exception shall always have
to be exercised with caution and circumspection so as to meet the
ends of justice. Be it noted further that the doctrine of finality of
judicial proceedings does not stand annulled or affected in any way
by reason of exercise of power under Section 391 since the same
avoids a de novo trial. It is not to fill up the lacuna but to sub-serve
the ends of justice. Needless to record that on an analysis of the
::: Downloaded on - 15/09/2026 13:13:04 :::CIS
18
2026:HHC:39173
Cr.M.P No. 3368 of 2026
High Court of H.P.
Civil Procedure Code, Section 391 is thus akin to Order 41 Rule 27
of the Civil Procedure Code.
5. ….. ….. …..
6. Before going into the factual score further, it is convenient to
note at this juncture that during the course of hearing of this appeal,
the High Court thought it fit to conduct an additional examination of
both the accused persons with a reasoning as below: “We have
examined them to rectify the irregularity as cropped up and pointed
out by the defence.” The word “irregularity” in common English
parlance means and implies contrary to rule. This Court in the case
of Martin Burn Ltd. v. The Corporation of Calcutta, AIR 1966 SC 529
while explaining the meaning of irregularity observed:
“A point was, however, made that Section 131 (2)(b)
apply only to a cancellation on the ground of irregularity,
that is a procedural defect such as, absence of notice,
omission to give a hearing etc., There is, however, no
reason to restrict the ordinary meaning of the word
irregularity and confine it to procedural defects only.
None has been advanced. Such a contention was
rejected and we think rightly in Corpn. of Calcutta V.
Chandoolan Bhai Chand Modi, AIR 1953 Cal 773. That
word clearly covers any case where a thing has not been
done in the manner laid down by the statute, irrespective
of what that manner might be.”
Black’s Law Dictionary defines the word as “not according to rule
and not regular” i.e. which stands contrary to rule. As noticed above,
the purpose of introduction of Section 391 (earlier Section 428) in
the statute-book has been for the purpose of making it available to
the court nor to fill up any gap in the prosecution case but to
oversee that the concept of justice does not suffer. The High Court
itself records “to rectify the irregularity”, the issue therefore, is
::: Downloaded on - 15/09/2026 13:13:04 :::CIS
19
2026:HHC:39173
Cr.M.P No. 3368 of 2026
High Court of H.P.
whether this rectification by an additional evidence is a mere
irregularity or goes to the root of the issue and instead of sub-
serving the ends of justice, the same runs counter to the concept of
justice.”
24. In Ashok Tshering Bhutia Vs. State of Sikkim, (2011) 4
SCC 402 , the Apex Court has held as under:-
“28. Additional evidence at appellate stage is permissible, in case of
a failure of justice. However, such power must be exercised
sparingly and only in exceptional suitable cases where the court is
satisfied that directing additional evidence would serve the interests
of justice. It would depend upon the facts and circumstances of an
individual case as to whether such permission should be granted
having due regard to the concepts of fair play, justice and the well-
being of society. Such an application for taking additional evidence
must be decided objectively, just to cure the irregularity.
29. The primary object of the provisions of Section 391 Cr.P.C. is
the prevention of a guilty man's escape through some careless or
ignorant action on part of the prosecution before the court or for
vindication of an innocent person wrongfully accused, where the
court omitted to record the circumstances essential to elucidation of
truth. Generally, it should be invoked when formal proof for the
prosecution is necessary. [Vide Rajeswar Prasad Misra v. State of
W.B., AIR 1965 SC 1887; Ratilal Bhanji Mithani v. The State of
Maharashtra, (1971) 1 SCC 523; Rambhau v. State of Maharashtra,
(2001) 4 SCC 759; Anil Sharma v. State of Jharkhand, (2004) 5
SCC 679; Zahira Habibulla H. Sheikh v. State of Gujarat, (2004) 4
SCC 158; and Manu Sharma v. State (NCT of Delhi), (2010) 6 SCC
1).
::: Downloaded on - 15/09/2026 13:13:04 :::CIS
20
2026:HHC:39173
Cr.M.P No. 3368 of 2026
High Court of H.P.
30. This Court in State of Gujarat v. Mohanlal Jitamalji Porwal,
(1987) 2 SCC 364 , dealing with the issue held as under: (SCC pp.
370-71, para 5)
“...To deny the opportunity to remove the formal defect
was to abort a case against an alleged economic
offender. Ends of justice are not satisfied only when the
accused in a criminal case is acquitted. The community
acting through the State and the Public Prosecutor is
also entitled to justice. The cause of the community
deserves equal treatment at the hands of the court in the
discharge of its judicial functions. The community or the
State is not a persona non grata whose cause may be
treated with disdain. The entire community is aggrieved if
the economic offenders who ruin the economy of the
State are not brought to book. A murder may be
committed in the heat of moment upon passions being
aroused. An economic offence is committed with cool
calculation and deliberate design with an eye on
personal profit regardless of the consequence to the
community. A disregard for the interest of the community
can be manifested only at the cost of forfeiting the trust
and faith of the community in the system to administer
justice in an even-handed manner without fear of
criticism from the quarters which view white collar crimes
with a permissive eye unmindful of the damage done to
the national economy and national interest."
31. In Rambhau (supra), a larger Bench of this Court held as
under: (SCC p. 762, para 4)
"Incidentally, Section 391 forms an exception to the
general rule that an Appeal must be decided on the
evidence which was before the Trial Court and the
::: Downloaded on - 15/09/2026 13:13:04 :::CIS
21
2026:HHC:39173
Cr.M.P No. 3368 of 2026
High Court of H.P.
powers being an exception shall always have to be
exercised with caution and circumspection so as to meet
the ends of justice. Be it noted further that the doctrine of
finality of judicial proceedings does not stand annulled or
affected in any way by reason of exercise of power under
Section 391 since the same avoids a de novo trial. It is
not to fill up the lacuna but to subserve the ends of
justice. Needless to record that on an analysis of the Civil
Procedure Code, Section 391 is thus akin to Order 41,
Rule 27 of the Civil Procedure Code. " (emphasis added)
32. In view of the above, the law on the point can be summarised to
the effect that additional evidence can be taken at the appellate
stage in exceptional circumstances, to remove an irregularity, where
the circumstances so warrant in public interest. Generally, such
power is exercised to have formal proof of the documents etc. just to
meet the ends of justice. However, the provisions of Section 391
Cr.P.C. cannot be pressed into service in order to fill up lacunae in
the prosecution's case.”
25. Observations made by the Apex Court in V.N. Patil Vs. K.
Niranjan Kumar and others, (2021) 3 SCC 661 , are also relevant to be
referred which read as under:-
“7. Learned counsel for the respondents made various submissions
in questioning the application filed under Section 173(5) read with
Section 311 Cr.PC when the trial reached the stage of hearing and
contended that the witnesses cited to be summoned for the purpose
of examining them on behalf of the prosecution, are neither the
witnesses examined by the investigating officer during the course of
his investigation, nor cited as the prosecution witnesses in the final
report……..
xxx xxx xxx
::: Downloaded on - 15/09/2026 13:13:04 :::CIS
22
2026:HHC:39173
Cr.M.P No. 3368 of 2026
High Court of H.P.
14. The object underlying Section 311 Cr.P.C is that there may not
be failure of justice on account of mistake of either party in bringing
the valuable evidence on record or leaving ambiguity in the
statements of the witnesses examined from either side. The
determinative factor is whether it is essential to the just decision of
the case. The significant expression that occurs is “at any stage of
any inquiry or trial or other proceeding under this Code”. It is,
however, to be borne in mind that the discretionary power conferred
under Section 311 Cr.P.C has to be exercised judiciously, as it is
always said “wider the power, greater is the necessity of caution
while exercise of judicious discretion.”
xxx xxx xxx
17. The aim of every Court is to discover the truth. Section 311
Cr.P.C is one of many such provisions which strengthen the arms of
a court in its effort to unearth the truth by procedure sanctioned by
law. At the same time, the discretionary power vested under Section
311 Cr.P.C has to be exercised judiciously for strong and valid
reasons and with caution and circumspection to meet the ends of
justice.”
26. In present case by leading proposed evidence, no prejudice is
going to be caused to the accused as it would not amount to have been
received as a disguise for re-trial or to change the nature of the case
against him, because from very beginning the case of the prosecution is
that date of birth of the victim is 9.8.2004 and to substantiate the same,
State has already proved on record documents Parivar Register Ex.
P-4/PW-23 and date of birth certificate Ex. P-1/PW-20. Though
Investigating Officer/prosecution could have obtained record related to date
::: Downloaded on - 15/09/2026 13:13:04 :::CIS
23
2026:HHC:39173
Cr.M.P No. 3368 of 2026
High Court of H.P.
of birth from the School concerned, but for negligence of the Investigating
Officer or ignorance about the provisions of Section 94 of the J.J. Act,
2015, no such record was procured and produced in the Court, however,
such negligence or ignorance on the part of Investigating Agency cannot be
a ground to deny leading of additional evidence, which is not going to be
establish or substantiate any new fact other than the case already
propounded by the prosecution against non-applicant/appellant.
27. It is also apt to record that non-applicant/appellant shall have
right to cross-examine the witness on the issue of date of birth and fact
related to date of birth sought to be re-asserted by prosecution by placing
on record additional evidence in conformity of requirement of law,
especially in view of the pronouncements of the Supreme Court.
Application has been filed to produce on record additional evidence to
rectify the irregularity for subserving the ends of justice which does not run
counter to the concept of justice. It is not a defect incurable in nature, but is
a mere irregularity which, in our considered opinion, required to be cured in
the ends of justice.
28. Investigating Officer committed irregularity by not collecting
date of birth record from the concerned School, resultantly Record
Keeper/Office Superintendent/Incharge of the School record was not cited
as a witness by the prosecution in charge sheet. However, Investigating
Agency had collected other evidence with respect to date of birth of the
::: Downloaded on - 15/09/2026 13:13:04 :::CIS
24
2026:HHC:39173
Cr.M.P No. 3368 of 2026
High Court of H.P.
victim from the concerned Panchyat, Registrar Births and Deaths, but in
view of interpretation by the Court of the provisions of J.J. Act, the evidence
collected by the Investigating Officer with respect to date of birth of the
victim may not be sufficient to substantiate the date of birth of the victim as
the same may not be taken in consideration on technical ground, whereas
for the ends of justice and to arrive at just decision of the case, it would be
essential to ascertain age of the child victim by allowing the State to
produce on record Matriculation Certificate/School record to prove the date
of birth in consonance with the pronouncements of the Court with respect to
provisions of Section 94 of J.J. Act, 2015.
29. Courts are not precluded from, rather have been empowered
to summon any person as a witness, examine, re-call or reexamine any
person already examined and to permit leading of additional evidence to
arrive at just decision of the case.
30. It is duty of the Court whenever it is possible without causing
any prejudice to the opposite party to ensure production of necessary and
essential evidence to ascertain the truth to arrive at just decision for the
ends of justice.
31. For the discussion herein before, we are of the opinion that
judgments referred supra by learned counsel for non-applicant/appellant
are of no help.
::: Downloaded on - 15/09/2026 13:13:04 :::CIS
25
2026:HHC:39173
Cr.M.P No. 3368 of 2026
High Court of H.P.
32. In the given facts and circumstances of the case we are of the
considered opinion that it is essential and necessary to allow the additional
evidence/re-call PW-1 and Incharge of record/Record Keeper/
Superintendent/Principal of the concerned school/Board for re-
examination/examination for limited purpose of producing Matriculation
Certificate/relevant record in evidence and proving date of birth of the victim
in accordance with law.
33. Accordingly, State/prosecution is permitted to re-examine PW-
1 victim and examine record keeper/Office Superintendent/Incharge of the
record/Principal of concerned School alongwith necessary record to prove
on record Matriculation Certificate in evidence as well as record of date of
birth of the victim and these witnesses are directed to be summoned
alongwith entire relevant record for recording their statement with respect to
the Matriculation Certificate and date of birth record of the victim in School
record.
34. While hearing various Criminal Appeals and Revisions, it had
been noticed in large number of cases that for lapse in investigation,
especially with respect to collecting evidence related to age proof of child in
conflict with law as well as minor victim, the prosecution cases fail.
Therefore, before parting, in order to avoid similar lapse in investigation,
Director General of Police, Himachal Pradesh is directed to circulate
provisions of Section 94 of the Juvenile Justice (Care and Protection of
::: Downloaded on - 15/09/2026 13:13:04 :::CIS
26
2026:HHC:39173
Cr.M.P No. 3368 of 2026
High Court of H.P.
Children) Act, 2015 alongwith necessary guidelines/ instructions to all
Investigating Officers in Himachal Pradesh, directing them that for
collecting evidence with respect to age proof of child in conflict with law as
well as minor victim, not only strictly adhere to mandate of Section 94 of the
J.J. Act by collecting preferential evidence, but also to collect all available
evidence regarding proof of date of birth by obtaining date of birth
certificate from the school, Matriculation or equivalent certificate from the
concerned examination Board/School, birth certificate issued by
Corporation or Municipal Authority or Panchayat as the case may be and
also other corroborating supporting documents indicating the same date of
birth and in absence of any documents or doubtful documents, to resort to
option of ossification test or any other latest age determining test by taking
orders of the Committee or the Board/Court if required.
35. The Investigating Officer also be directed to make a effort to
cite all those persons in the list of witnesses, who are necessary to be
examined to prove the contents of such documents as well as those who
are author of entry, legal custodian of the record, documents and/or
certificate issuing official/author and also witnesses in whose presence
such documents are obtained/taken in possession.
36. Investigating Officers also be directed to make an endavour to
prove date of birth by all means to avoid any adverse impact on the
prosecution case due to different interpretation and explanation rendered
::: Downloaded on - 15/09/2026 13:13:04 :::CIS
27
2026:HHC:39173
Cr.M.P No. 3368 of 2026
High Court of H.P.
by the Court regarding nature of document relied upon for proving the date
of birth and mode of proof of such document. Necessary instructions be
th
issued at the earliest, latest by 15 October, 2026 .
37. Learned Senior Additional Advocate General to transmit copy
of this order to Director General of Police, Himachal Pradesh for
th
compliance. List before Registrar (Judicial) on 28 September, 2026 for
fixing a date for recording of additional evidence.
38. Steps for re-calling/summoning witnesses be taken within
three days and notice be issued to these witnesses for next date to be fixed
for recording additional evidence by Registrar (Judicial) of this Court.
The application is allowed and disposed of in aforesaid terms.
(Vivek Singh Thakur),
Judge.
(Bhupesh Sharma),
Judge.
th
15 September, 2026
(Keshav)
::: Downloaded on - 15/09/2026 13:13:04 :::CIS