AMIT KUMAR MULLICK vs UNITED BANK OF INDIA & ORS
- Court
- Calcutta High Court
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
Civil Appellate Jurisdiction
APPELLATE SIDE
Present:
The Hon’ble Justice Tapabrata Chakraborty
&
The Hon’ble Justice Partha Pratim Roy
FMA 1814 of 2018
+
IA No. CAN 3 of 2022
+
IA No. CAN 4 of 2022
Sri Amit Kumar Mullick
Versus
The United Bank of India & Ors.
For the Appellant : Mr. Biswaroop Bhattacharyya,
Mr. Dipayan Kundu.
For the Bank : Mr. S.M. Obaidullah,
Mr. R.N. Majumder,
MR. S. Chakraborty,
Mr. R. Chowdhuri .
th
Hearing is concluded on : 17 November, 2026.
th
Judgment On : 17 November, 2026 .
Tapabrata Chakraborty, J.
1. The writ petitioner, namely, Amit Kumar Mullick (in short, Amit),
th
being the appellant herein, has taken exception to a judgment dated 29
February, 2016 passed by the learned Single Judge in a writ petition being
WPA 2982 of 2016.
2
2. Records would reveal that Amit joined the then United Bank of India
th
(hereinafter referred to as the Bank) on 13 August, 1976 in the post of
Cash Clerk. He was promoted thereafter from time to time and he had no
th
antecedents. Prior to his retirement scheduled on 30 September, 2017, he
th
was served a Charge Sheet (hereinafter referred to as CS) dated 6 June,
2014, with a request to submit a written statement of defence. Pursuant
rd
thereto, Amit filed his reply on 23 June, 2014. The Enquiry Officer
(hereinafter referred to as EO) appointed thereafter conducted an enquiry
th
and submitted the Enquiry Report (hereinafter referred to as ER) on 18
th
September, 2013. Amit replied to the ER on 4 October, 2014 and
considering the same, the Disciplinary Authority (hereinafter referred to as
st
DA) by an order dated 31 October, 2014 decided to impose upon Amit a
major penalty of ‘removal from service which shall not be a disqualification for
future employment’ in terms of the Regulation 4(i) of the United Bank of
India Officer Employees’ (Discipline and Appeal) Regulations, 1976
(hereinafter referred to as the 1976 Regulations). Aggrieved thereby, Amit
th
preferred a statutory appeal on 15 December, 2014. The same was
considered by the appellant authority (hereinafter referred to as AA) and
th
dismissed by an order dated 20 November, 2015. Aggrieved thereby, Amit
preferred a writ petition and the judgment delivered in the same has been
impugned in the present appeal.
3. Mr. Bhattacharyya, learned advocate, assisted by Mr. Kundu, learned
advocate, appearing for the appellant primarily argues that the documents
upon which the prosecution placed reliance in course of the enquiry were
brought on record in a manner unknown to law and the same could not
3
have been considered as legal evidence. In the present case, the prosecution
had tendered and exhibited documents before Amit could peruse the same
and furnish his objections as to the admissibility of the same. The said
documents brought on record without following due process of law could not
have been relied upon by the EO and that as such the findings arrived at in
the ER suffers from perversity and is based on no evidence. The EO acting in
a quasi-judicial authority is in a position of an independent adjudicator. It
was his obligation to call for all the records referred to by Amit in course of
enquiry which were retained by the Bank in the official files. In absence
thereof, the EO could not have returned the findings on the allegations
levelled in the CS. Such failure to call for records and non-consideration of
the same has prejudiced Amit and deprived him of an opportunity to
establish his version. In support of such contention, reliance has been
placed upon the judgment delivered by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the
case of State of Uttar Pradesh vs. Ram Prakash Singh reported in (2025) SCC
Online SC 891 .
4. In the ER, the EO observed inter alia that ‘the undersigned finds
through corroboration of documents at the Enquiry that the CSO is at fault in
every step. He has not handled his task as a Manager of a Branch. He seems
to be dishonest to the institution in as much it tells upon his character or the
type of human being. Cheating and defrauding the Bank seems to be his
agenda. In most of the cases end use of fund is not seen. Misappropriation
and defalcation of Bank’s fund cannot be ruled out’ . According to Mr.
Bhattacharyya, such observations clearly reveal that the EO had proceeded
in a biased manner and with a pre-conceived notion that Amit had illegally
4
disbursed loans to the borrowers and such argument could not have been
discounted by the learned Single Judge on a purported plea that Amit was
not in a position to cite any previous incident as a result whereof the EO
would turn against him and that such emotional observation at the foot of
the findings cannot detract from the substance of the report or the reasons
given therein accepting the charges.
5. He further submits that the DA did not consider Amit’s reply to the ER
and the order imposing punishment is nothing but a reiteration of the
observations made by the EO. The said order has been passed mechanically
and based on mere surmises without taking into account the extenuating
circumstances.
6. Mr. Bhattacharyya further argues that Amit filed the statutory appeal
incorporating specifically the grounds of challenge but a perusal of the order
passed by the AA would also reveal that the issues urged by Amit have been
glossed over and the appeal has been dismissed without any independent
application of mind. The right to appeal is a statutory right and it was
incumbent upon the AA to arrive at a finding after consideration of all facts
and records. The appellate order does not reveal any such endeavour.
7. He argues that the punishment imposed is thoroughly
disproportionate. The alleged irregularities do not warrant the imposition of
the major penalty of removal from service more so when the Bank had not
suffered any monetary loss. Amit had been penalized on the rudiments of an
assumption that the Bank had been exposed to a financial risk. No criminal
proceeding was also initiated against Amit.
5
8. Mr. Obaidullah, learned advocate appearing for the Bank and its
functionaries denies and disputes the contention of Mr. Bhattacharyya and
submits that Amit was granted ample opportunity to contest the DA. He was
given inspection of all the documents relied upon by the Bank and he did
not raise any objection when such documents were tendered and exhibited.
Amit was given the assistance of a defence representative, who was a Senior
Manager. The EO granted opportunity to Amit to submit defence documents,
to inspect the documents relied upon by the Bank and to cross-examine the
witness. In support of such the question nos. 8, 16 to 18, 148 and 244 to
249 in the enquiry proceedings have been referred to.
9. He contends that the power of the Writ Court to interfere with the
disciplinary action is limited and it cannot, in exercise of power of judicial
review, re-appreciate the evidence or sit in appeal over the orders passed by
the DA and the AA. It is not a case that the impugned judgment results in
inconsistent treatment of similarly placed personnel, creating inconsistency
in judicial outcomes and possible complications.
10. He argues that the scope of review in matters concerning imposition
of punishment by the DA is strictly confined to procedural compliance,
observance of natural justice, adherence to statutory rules and freedom
from extraneous or mala fide consideration, rather than assessing the
correctness of the decision, re-appreciating evidence or evaluating its
adequacy, reliability or sufficiency. It is not a case that Amit had been found
guilty on the basis of mere surmises. His guilt stands established through
the specific findings in the report of the EO as well as in the order of the DA.
6
11. Mr. Obaidullah submits the contents of the ER need to be considered
together and not in isolation. A particular clause cannot be picked up and
highlighted. The observation of the EO in the penultimate paragraph of the
ER needs to be read with the entirety of the report. The documents produced
corroborate the charges and upon granting due opportunity to Amit to cross
examine and to object to the documents, the EO arrived at specific findings.
12. According to Mr. Obaidullah, the DA has passed the final order
incorporating appropriate reasoning and the said order also reveals an
independent application of mind. So far as the order of the AA is concerned,
Mr. Obaidullah submits that the same is a reasoned one and has been
passed dealing with the grounds of appeal as urged, and as such no
interference is called for.
13. The charges established against Amit are very serious and such
activities of Amit are most unbecoming of a Senior bank officer. A bank
official is required to exercise high standard of honesty and integrity as he
deals with money of depositors and the customers. He is required to take all
possible steps to protect the interest of the depositors and to discharge his
duties with utmost integrity, honesty, devotion and diligence.
14. We have heard the learned advocates appearing for the respective
parties at length and we have given our anxious consideration to the facts
and circumstances as well as documents disclosed before us.
15. From the CS it appears that while serving as Manager at Survey Park
th th
Branch of the bank during the period from 17 May, 2010 to 13 July,
2011, Amit sanctioned 19 loans out of which seven were sanctioned to
borrowers who are either the same person or relations thereof. The charges
7
were proved on the basis of 41 documents detailed in the list of documents
to the CS. Amit did not raise any objection regarding marking of documents
through the Management witness. Amit was granted due opportunity to
inspect all the documents relied upon by the bank and also to cross-
examine the witness. In the said conspectus, the argument of Mr.
Bhattacharyya that the authorities have not adhered to the statutory rules
and had violated the principles of natural justice is not acceptable to this
Court. Amit had also failed to establish any arbitrariness or
unreasonableness against the respondents.
16. If fairness is shown by the decision-makers to the man proceeded
against, the form, features and the fundamentals of such essential
processual propriety being conditioned by the facts and circumstances of its
situation, no breach of natural justice can be complained of.
17. The expression ‘sufficiency of evidence’ postulates existence of some
evidence which links the charges of misconduct alleged against the
delinquent and in the instant case, the documents reveal that there was a
clear nexus of Amit with the charges and no procedural irregularities have
been committed.
18. The argument that no monetary loss was suffered by the bank has
also been rightly discounted by the learned single Judge since the loans
advanced had exposed the bank to an aggregated financial risk of above Rs.
2 crores. Question of interference with the order of punishment does not
arise and such punishment is also not disproportionate to the established
charges more so when a bank officer is required to exercise high standard of
honesty and integrity.
8
19. An appellate power interferes not when the judgment appealed is not
right but only when it is clearly wrong. Such interference is called for
primarily when the subordinate Court had acted wholly without jurisdiction
or in excess of it or where the discretion exercise is not supported with
reasons or when the decision is perverse. Having regard to this constellation
of considerations, carefully viewed in the jurisprudential setting above
silhouetted, we are not inclined to interfere with the judgment impugned,
more so when, the learned Single Judge upon dealing with the factual issues
arrived at specific findings supported with detailed reasons.
20. Accordingly, the appeal being FMA 1814 of 2018 is dismissed.
21. Records would reveal that the applications being CAN 3 of 2022 and
th
CAN 4 of 2022 have already been disposed of by an earlier order dated 28
July, 2025. Registry is directed to record such disposal.
22. There shall, however, be no order as to costs.
23. Urgent photostat certified copy of this order, if applied for, be
supplied to the parties upon compliance of all necessary formalities.
(Partha Pratim Roy, J.) (Tapabrata Chakraborty, J.)