Ashlesha Mehta vs All India Radio

Court
Central Administrative Tribunal

:: 1 :: OA No 393/2024





CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL
AHMEDABAD BENCH
Original Application No. 393/2024

th
Dated this the 30 day of October, 2026.


Reserved On: 16.10.2026
Pronounced On: 30.10.2026


CORAM:
Hon’ble Shri Jayesh V Bhairavia, Member (J)
Hon’ble Shri Sanjiv Kumar, Member (A)

Smt. Ashlesha Mehta W/o Late Shri Mihir Mehta,
Age: 61 years, Ex-TREX of the respondents
Residing at M/14/159, Vidyanagar Flats,
132 Feet Ring Road, B/h. Himmatlal Park-II,
Ahmedabhad – 380 015.
… Applicants

(By Advocate Mr. M S Trivedi)

V/s.

1. Union of India Through
The Secretary, Govt. of India,
Ministry of Information and Broadcasting
Vigilance Section, Shashtri Bhavan,
New Delhi – 110 001.

2. The Director General,
O/o. DG All India Radio
Akashwani Bhavan, Sansad Marg,
New Delhi – 110 001.

3. The Deputy Director General (Engineering)
O/o The Deputy Director General (Engineering)
Doordarshan Kendra,
Thaltej Tekra, Ahmedabad – 380 054.
… Respondents

(By Advocate Mr. H D Shukla)




P ANUKUMA

:: 2 :: OA No 393/2024




ORDER

Per: Hon’ble Shri Sanjiv Kumar, Member (A)
1. The applicant has filed the present OA, under Section 19 of the
Administrative Tribunals Act, 1985, seeking the following reliefs:
(A) That the Hon’ble Tribunal be pleased to allow this
petition.
(B)That the Hon’ble Tribunal further be pleased to
hold/declare that impugned ex-facie, illegal, arbitrary and
unconstitutional action on the part of the respondents
regarding issuance of order No. C-14012/2/2024-Vig., dtd.
6/08/2024, issued by the respondents, regarding imposition
of penalty of withholding of 100% of monthly pension
otherwise admissible to applicant and withholding of the
entire gratuity due to her permanently is non-est in the eyes
of law.
(C) That, the Hon’ble Tribunal further be pleased to quash
and set-aside impugned ex-facie, illegal, arbitrary and
unconstitutional action on the part of the respondents
regarding issuance of order No. C-14012/2/2024-Vig., dtd.
6/08/2024, issued by the respondents, regarding imposition
of penalty of withholding of 100% of monthly pension
otherwise admissible to applicant and withholding of the
entire gratuity due to her permanently.
(D) Such other and further relief/s may be deemed just and
proper in view of the facts and circumstances of the case
may be granted.
2. Brief facts of the case as stated by the applicant are as under: -
2.1 The applicant joined the department on 30.10.1993 and was
working as a Transmission Executive in All India Radio. She was
confirmed in service on 30.10.1995 and retired on superannuation
with effect from 30.04.2023.
2.2 During her service, two criminal cases were registered by the
Central Bureau of Investigation against the applicant and others.
The present proceedings arise out of CBI Special Case No. 31 of
2009, corresponding to FIR No. RC-18(A)/2008-GNR, registered
on 31.10.2008 for alleged floating of a firm, M/s Maanisha
Creatives.
P ANUKUMA

:: 3 :: OA No 393/2024



2.3 As far as criminal case No. 31/2009 is concerned the Sp. Judge
CBI Court, Ahmedabad by its final order / decision dtd.
22/8/2023 had convicted the applicant and had passed order as
under :
For offences u/s 168 of I.P.C., Simple Imprisonment of Three (3)
months and fine of Rs.1,000/- and in default of payment of fine,
she shall further undergo further Simple Imprisonment for seven
(7) days.

For offences u/s 420 r/w 120-B of I.P.C., Simple Imprisonment of
Two (2) years and fine of Rs.10,000/- and in default of payment of
fine, she shall further undergo Simple Imprisonment for six (6)
months.

For offences u/s Section 13(1)(d) read with 13(2) of PC Act, 1988,
sentenced to undergo two (2) years of Rigorous Imprisonment
(RI) and fine of Rs.10,000/-; and in default of payment of fine,
she shall further undergo Simple Imprisonment of six (6) months.

2.4 The applicant challenged the said judgment before the Hon’ble
High Court of Gujarat by filing Criminal Appeal No. 2168 of
2023. By order dated 08.08.2024, the Hon’ble High Court
suspended the execution of the sentence during the pendency of the
criminal appeal and directed that the applicant be released on bail.
2.5 In the meantime, the respondents issued a memorandum dated
07.05.2024 under Rule 8 of the Central Civil Services (Pension)
Rules, 2021, read with Rule 19(i) of the Central Civil Services
(Classification, Control and Appeal) Rules, 1965, proposing action
in view of the applicant’s conviction. The applicant submitted her
written representation dated 02.07.2024, opposing the proposed
action and raising, inter alia, the grounds of suspension of
sentence, double jeopardy, financial hardship and the need for a
personal hearing.
2.6 After considering the representation, the competent authority
passed the impugned order dated 06.08.2024, withholding 100% of
the applicant’s monthly pension and the entire gratuity payable to
her permanently. Hence, the present OA.
3. Submissions on behalf of the applicant
P ANUKUMA

:: 4 :: OA No 393/2024



3.1 Learned counsel for the applicant submitted that the applicant had
requested for an opportunity of personal hearing to explain her
case, but no such opportunity was granted before passing the
impugned order.
3.2 It was further contended that the applicant has challenged her
conviction before the Hon’ble High Court of Gujarat in Criminal
Misc. Application (For Suspension of Sentence) No. 1 of 2023 in
R/Criminal Appeal No. 2168 of 2023 and that the execution of the
sentence has been suspended by order dated 08.08.2024 and
observed as under: -
“5…….. And without entering into the merits of the
case, this court is of the opinion that the application requires
consideration and accordingly, is allowed. The execution of the
sentence in the judgment and order of conviction dated
22.08.2023 passed in CBI Special Case No. 31/2009 by the
learned Special Judge CBI, Court No.3, City Sessions Court,
Ahmedabad is suspended during pendency of the Criminal
Appeal and the applicant is ordered to be released on bail
furnishing personal bond of Rs. 10,000/- (Rupees ten
Thousand Only) with surety of the like amount to the
satisfaction of the trial court and on the following conditions
that the applicants;”

Learned counsel argued that the respondents ought to have
considered the effect of the said order and refrained from imposing
the extreme penalty of permanent withholding of the entire pension
and gratuity while the criminal appeal remains pending.
3.3 Learned counsel also argued that the applicant had already suffered
a penalty of withholding 10% of her monthly pension for a period
of one year pursuant to the departmental proceedings concluded by
the order dated 01.06.2023 (Annexure A/4). The subsequent
penalty imposed by the impugned order amounts to double
punishment for the same underlying conduct and is impermissible.
3.4 It was further submitted that pension is an important source of
livelihood after retirement and that permanent deprivation of the
entire pension and gratuity causes severe financial hardship.
P ANUKUMA

:: 5 :: OA No 393/2024



Learned counsel contended that the competent authority ought to
have considered the applicant’s financial circumstances, the nature
of the alleged misconduct, the pendency of the criminal appeal and
the proportionality of the proposed penalty before passing the
impugned order.
3.5 On the above grounds, learned counsel for the applicant prayed
that the impugned order dated 06.08.2024 be quashed and set
aside.
4. Submissions on behalf of the respondents
4.1 Per contra, learned counsel for the respondents opposed the OA
and submitted that the impugned order has been passed by the
competent authority in accordance with the applicable statutory
provisions and after following the prescribed procedure.
4.2 Learned counsel submitted that the applicant was convicted by the
competent criminal court in CBI Special Case No. 31 of 2009 by
judgment dated 22.08.2023. The conviction concerns offences
involving abuse of official position and offences under the
Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988. According to the respondents,
the conviction and the gravity of the misconduct warranted action
under Rule 8 of the Central Civil Services (Pension) Rules, 2021.
4.3 Learned counsel further submitted that the applicant was issued a
show-cause memorandum dated 07.05.2024 and was afforded an
opportunity to submit her explanation. The applicant availed
herself of that opportunity by submitting a detailed written
representation dated 02.07.2024. The competent authority duly
considered the representation, including the objections relating to
the suspension of sentence, alleged double jeopardy and financial
hardship, before passing the impugned order.
4.4 It was argued that the suspension of execution of a sentence by an
appellate court does not set aside or nullify the conviction recorded
by the trial court. As the conviction has not been overturned or set
P ANUKUMA

:: 6 :: OA No 393/2024



aside, and only the operation of the sentence has been stayed till
final disposal of the appeal, the respondents were entitled to take
consequential action after consideration in accordance with Rule
19(i) of the Central Civil Services (Classification, Control and
Appeal) Rules, 1965, read with Rule 8 of the Central Civil
Services (Pension) Rules, 2021. As per Rule 8 of CCS (Pension)
Rules, 2021, when a pensioner is convicted/found guilty of grave
misconduct or negligence in judicial proceedings, the competent
authority can withhold or withdraw pension and/or gratuity
permanently, in light of the judgment of the court relating to such
conviction. Since the Appointing Authority in respect of the post
from which the applicant, a Group ‘B’ government servant, retired
was an authority subordinate to President, the competent authority
to take necessary action under Rule 8 of the CCS (Pension) Rules,
is Secretary, Ministry of Information and Broadcasting.
4.5 Learned counsel for the respondents further submitted that the
earlier penalty of withholding 10% of the applicant’s monthly
pension for one year was imposed in separate departmental
proceedings under Rule 14 of the Central Civil Services
(Classification, Control and Appeal) Rules, 1965. The penalty
under challenge, on the other hand, was imposed in consequence of
the applicant’s criminal conviction. The two proceedings have
distinct legal bases and purposes, and the subsequent action cannot
be invalidated merely because an earlier departmental penalty had
been imposed.
4.6 It was also contended that the amended Rule 8 of the Central Civil
Services (Pension) Rules, 2021 empowers the competent authority
to withhold or withdraw pension and gratuity, either in full or in
part, where the pensioner is found guilty of grave misconduct or
negligence in judicial or departmental proceedings. The Secretary,
Ministry of Information and Broadcasting, the Competent
Authority, imposed the said penalty after taking into consideration
her written representation/contention of Interim Relief granted by
P ANUKUMA

:: 7 :: OA No 393/2024



Court, Double Jeopardy and financial stress which were
specifically addressed/examined and rejected.
4.7 Learned counsel for the respondents submitted that the approval
for grant of provisional pension to the Applicant was received vide
letter dated 19.07.2023. Accordingly, the Applicant was entitled to
provisional pension calculated at 50% of her last basic pay of
₹94,100/- plus Dearness Allowance at the applicable rate of 42%,
amounting to ₹66,811/- per month.
4.8 It is further submitted that, vide Order dated 01.06.2023, the
Ministry of Information and Broadcasting directed withholding of
10% of the Applicant’s monthly pension. However, no deduction
was made from the pension paid to the Applicant for the period
from May 2023 to August 2024. The pension was regularly
disbursed for the period from May 2023 to August 2024.
4.9 It is also submitted that, pursuant to the Memorandum dated
06.08.2024 issued by the Vigilance Section, Ministry of
Information and Broadcasting, a penalty of withholding 100% of
the Applicant’s monthly pension was imposed with effect from
September 2024. Therefore, the Respondents submit that the
pension payments were made in accordance with the applicable
provisional pension arrangements, and the subsequent withholding
of pension was pursuant to the aforesaid memorandum.
4.10 Learned counsel accordingly submitted that the impugned order
does not suffer from any illegality or procedural infirmity
warranting interference by this Tribunal and the present application
is nothing but a sheer abuse of process of law.
5. Applicant has filed rejoinder and submitted the Applicant was
convicted by the learned Special Judge, CBI vide judgment dated
22.08.2023 in Special Case No. 31/2009, the respondents issued a
show-cause notice dated 07.05.2024 under Rule 19(i) of the CCS
P ANUKUMA

:: 8 :: OA No 393/2024



(CCA) Rules, 1965, proposing punishment on the basis of the said
conviction.
5.1 The applicant submitted a detailed reply dated 02.07.2024 to the
show-cause notice. However, the respondents failed to consider the
grounds and submissions raised therein and passed the impugned
order dated 06.08.2024 without due application of mind. The
Applicant had also brought to the notice of the respondents the
filing of an appeal and miscellaneous application challenging the
conviction and sentence. Subsequently, the Hon’ble High Court of
Gujarat allowed the Applicant’s miscellaneous application and
stayed the conviction and sentence imposed by the learned Special
Judge, CBI Court.
5.2 In these circumstances, the applicant contends that the impugned
order dated 06.08.2024 is arbitrary, unjustified and unsustainable
in law. It is further submitted that the separate penalty order dated
25.09.2024, arising out of the memorandum/charge-sheet dated
11.09.2009, is already under challenge in O.A. No. 474/2024 and
is distinct from the grievance raised in the present OA.
6. Heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the material
available on record.
7. The principal issue that arises for our consideration is whether the
impugned order dated 06.08.2024, whereby the respondents have
ordered permanent withholding of 100% of the applicant’s
monthly pension and the entire gratuity, warrants interference by
this Tribunal.

8. It is an admitted position that the applicant was convicted by the
learned Special Judge, CBI Court No. 3, Ahmedabad, vide
judgment dated 22.08.2023 in Special Case No. 31/2009. The
applicant preferred Criminal Appeal No. 2168 of 2023 before the
Hon’ble High Court of Gujarat, which, by order dated 08.08.2024,
suspended the execution of the sentence during the pendency of the
P ANUKUMA

:: 9 :: OA No 393/2024



appeal and ordered her release on bail. However, the order, as
reproduced in the pleadings, does not indicate that the conviction
itself was stayed or set aside. Therefore, mere suspension of the
execution of the sentence cannot be treated as nullification of the
conviction recorded by the trial court.
9. As regards the challenge to the impugned order on the ground of
denial of a personal hearing, the record indicates that the
respondents issued a show-cause memorandum dated 07.05.2024
and that the applicant submitted a detailed representation dated
02.07.2024. The respondents maintain that the representation,
including the grounds relating to suspension of sentence, double
jeopardy and financial hardship, was duly considered by the
competent authority. In the absence of material establishing that
the prescribed procedure was violated or that the applicant’s
defence was not considered, the mere fact that a separate personal
hearing was not granted would not be sufficient to invalidate the
impugned order.
10. The applicant has also contended that the impugned action
amounts to double punishment, as an earlier order dated
01.06.2023 provided for withholding 10% of her monthly pension
for a period of one year. However, the respondents have explained
that the earlier penalty arose from separate departmental
proceedings, whereas the impugned order was passed in
consequence of the applicant’s criminal conviction. The two
actions, having been initiated on distinct legal grounds, cannot be
held to constitute double punishment merely because both affect
the applicant’s pensionary benefits. Nevertheless, the legality of
each action must be assessed with reference to its respective
statutory basis.
11. We further observe that pension and gratuity are valuable
retirement benefits, and an order permanently depriving a
pensioner of such benefits must strictly conform to the applicable
P ANUKUMA

:: 10 :: OA No 393/2024



statutory provisions. Rule 8 of the Central Civil Services (Pension)
Rules, 2021, as amended, empowers the competent authority to
withhold or withdraw pension and gratuity, subject to the
conditions prescribed therein. The authority exercising such power
must act within its jurisdiction, consider the relevant material and
record a legally sustainable decision.
12. The main contention of the applicant is that, by the order dated
08.08.2024 passed in Criminal Misc. Application (For Suspension
of Sentence) No. 1 of 2023 in R/Criminal Appeal No. 2168 of
2023, the Hon’ble High Court of Gujarat has stayed her conviction,
and that the respondents therefore could not have imposed the
penalty of withholding 100% of her pension. A plain reading of the
operative portion of the said order, extracted in para 3.2 above,
shows that the Hon’ble High Court, “without entering into the
merits of the case”, has suspended only “the execution of the
sentence” during the pendency of the Criminal Appeal and ordered
her release on bail. The order neither stays nor sets aside the
conviction recorded by the learned Special Judge, CBI, by
judgment dated 22.08.2023, and no order staying the conviction
has been placed before us. The assertion in the rejoinder that the
conviction has been stayed is, therefore, not borne out by the order
itself. Suspension of the execution of sentence only defers the
undergoing of the sentence; the conviction continues to operate
until it is set aside in appeal. The conviction of the applicant,
including under Section 13(1)(d) read with Section 13(2) of the
Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988, thus subsists, and it is a
finding of guilt in judicial proceedings within the meaning of Rule
8 of the Central Civil Services (Pension) Rules, 2021. It may also
be noted that the order of the Hon’ble High Court suspending the
sentence was passed on 08.08.2024, i.e., two days after the
impugned order dated 06.08.2024. On the date the impugned order
was passed, therefore, the conviction stood without even the
sentence having been suspended, and the subsequent suspension of
P ANUKUMA

:: 11 :: OA No 393/2024



the sentence cannot affect the validity of an order already passed.
The respondents were, therefore, entitled to take action under Rule
8 on the basis of that conviction.
13. In view of the foregoing discussion, we hold that the impugned
order dated 06.08.2024, withholding 100% of the applicant’s
monthly pension and the entire gratuity permanently, has been
passed in accordance with law and calls for no interference. The
same is upheld.
14. Accordingly, the OA is dismissed.
15. There shall be no order as to costs.
16. MA Pending if any, also stands disposed of.


(Sanjiv Kumar) (Jayesh V Bhairavia)
Member (A) Member (J)



//Anu//
P ANUKUMA