praDipsinh B thakor vs BHARAT SANCHAR NIGAM LIMITED
- Court
- Central Administrative Tribunal
:: 1 :: OA No.302/2023
CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL
AHMEDABAD BENCH
Original Application No. 302/2023
th
Dated this the 30 day of October, 2026.
Reserved On: 14.10.2026
Pronounced On: 30.10.2026
CORAM:
Hon’ble Shri Jayesh V Bhairavia, Member (J)
Hon’ble Shri Sanjiv Kumar, Member (A)
Shri Pradipsinh S/o. Shri Bhagwansinh
Thakor aged about: 54 years, male,
Religion: Hindu, Resident at: 41, Shayona Prasad Bungalow,
R.C.Technical Road, Ghatlodia, Ahmedabad – 61.
… Applicants
(By Advocate Mr. Maheshkumar Bhavsar)
V/s.
1. Union of India,
Notice to be served through, Secretary to the Government of India,
Ministry of Communication, Department of Telecommunication,
Sanchar Bhavan, New Delhi.
2. Bharat Sanchar Nigam Ltd.
Chief General Manager (Electrical)
Corporate Office, Electrical Wings,
Room No.8, I.R.Hall, Eastern Court,
Janpath, New Delhi – 110 001.
3. Director (HR), B.S.N.L. Bhavan,
Janpath, New Delhi – 110 001.
4. Superintending Engineer (Electrical),
th
5 Floor, Telephone Bhavan,
Off. C,.G. Road, Navrangpura, Ahmedabad – 380 009.
5. Shree Sanjay B. Jajoo
Executive Engineer (Electrical),
2th Floor, Telephone Exchange,
Navrangpura, Off. C.G.Road, Ahmedabad – 380 009.
… Respondents
(By Advocate Mr. H D Shukla)
P ANUKUMA
:: 2 :: OA No.302/2023
ORDER
Per: Hon’ble Shri Sanjiv Kumar, Member (A)
1. The applicant has filed the present OA, under Section 19 of the
Administrative Tribunals Act, 1985, seeking the following reliefs:
“A) Your Honor may be pleased to admit and allow this
application;
B) Your Honor may be pleased to quash and set aside the
impugned inaction on the part of the respondent authorities
not granting promotion to the petitioner to the post of
Executive Engineer (Electrical) with all consequential
benefits as the petitioner is entitled to get the said
promotion w.e.f. 01.01.2016 in the interest of justice.
C) Your Honor may be pleased to pass an appropriate
order directing the respondent authorities to grant deemed
date promotion to the petitioner to the post of Executive
Engineer (Electrical) w.e.f. 01/01/2016 with all
consequential benefits in the interest of justice.
D) Your Honor may be pleased to quash and set aside the
impugned action on the part of the respondents wrongly
granting promotion to the Respondent no.5 who is at all not
qualified for the Post of Executive Engineer (Electrical), in
the interest of justice.
E) Your Honor may be pleased to grant such other and
further relief(s) that may be deemed fit, just and proper in
the interest of justice;
F) Your Honor may be pleased to grant such other and
further relief(s) that may be deemed fit, just and proper in
the interest of justice;
G) Your Honor may be pleased to pass an appropriate
order or direction to the respondents authorities to grant
deemed date promotions to the petitioner to the post of
Superintending Engineer w.e.f 01/01/2020 as per BSNL
MSRR – 2009 and thereafter to grant deemed date
promotion to the petitioner to the next post, w.e.f.
01/01/2024 as per BSNL MSRR-2009/BSNLMSRR-2023 in
the interest of justice.
2. Brief facts of the case as stated by the applicants are as under: -
2.1 The applicant was appointed as Junior Engineer (Electrical) in the
Department of Telecommunications on 21.01.1991. He acquired
the qualification of AMIE (Electrical Engineering) in 1997 and
was subsequently absorbed in Bharat Sanchar Nigam Limited
(BSNL) upon its incorporation on 01.10.2000.
P ANUKUMA
:: 3 :: OA No.302/2023
2.2 The applicant was initially appointed/promoted to the post of
Assistant Engineer/Sub-Divisional Engineer (Electrical) on an
officiating basis with effect from 26.02.2001. He was subsequently
granted regular promotion to the post of Sub-Divisional Engineer
(Electrical) (SDE) with effect from 16.02.2010 and joined the said
post on 15.03.2010.
2.3 The applicant relies upon the BSNL Management Services
Recruitment Rules, 2009, (MSRR 2009) and the subsequent
instructions and clarifications concerning eligibility for promotion
to the grade of Executive Engineer/Assistant General Manager
(Electrical). According to him, upon completion of the requisite
qualifying service, he became eligible for promotion but was not
considered for the same.
2.4 The applicant submitted a representation dated 18.04.2023 seeking
redressal of his grievance. He filed this OA on 25.09.2023. The
representation was rejected by communication dated 30.10.2023,
while the OA was pending.
3. The submissions made on behalf of the applicant are as follows.
3.1 Learned counsel for the applicant has submitted that the applicant
possesses the requisite technical and educational qualifications for
promotion to the post of Executive Engineer (Electrical).
3.2 Learned counsel submits that upon completion of the prescribed
qualifying service as SDE (Electrical), the applicant became
eligible for consideration for promotion to the next higher post.
The respondents, however, failed to extend the benefit of
promotion to him despite his fulfilling the applicable eligibility
conditions.
3.3 Learned counsel has further contended that the promotion granted
to respondent No. 5 is liable to be examined in the light of the
educational qualifications prescribed under the relevant
Recruitment Rules. Respondent No. 5 did not possess a degree in
Electrical Engineering and was, therefore, not eligible for
promotion to the post in question.
P ANUKUMA
:: 4 :: OA No.302/2023
3.4 Learned counsel has also referred to the earlier proceedings before
this Tribunal and the Hon’ble High Court of Gujarat and submits
that the applicant’s claim for appropriate consideration for
promotion deserves to be examined in accordance with the
governing rules.
3.5 Learned counsel relied on the judgment of the Hon'ble High Court
of Gujarat dated 19.07.2011 in SCA No. 8786/2011 (Annexure
A/5). He submitted that it shows that the promotion rules cannot be
overridden by executive action. He also relied on the common
order of this Tribunal dated 29.06.2016 in OA No. 394/2012 and
OA No. 417/2012 (Annexure A-6). According to him, that order
dealt with the eligibility conditions under MSRR 2009. It shows
that the question of treating a diploma as equal to a degree has
already been litigated, and that BSNL has long been aware of it.
He further relied on the judgments of the Hon'ble High Court of
Gujarat dated 03.10.2016 in SCA No. 14581 of 2016 and dated
18.10.2016 in SCA No. 16060 of 2016 (Annexures A-7 and A-8).
He submitted that, under these judgments, promotions in BSNL
must meet the test of Articles 14 and 16. BSNL, he said, cannot
promote to higher engineering posts, such as Executive Engineer
or Superintending Engineer, officers who do not hold the
minimum qualification laid down in the Recruitment Rules.
3.6 On the aforesaid grounds, learned counsel for the applicant has
prayed that the OA be allowed and the promotion order dated
29.06.2018, concerning respondent No. 5, be set aside; and the
respondents be directed to grant the applicant promotion to the
post of Executive Engineer (Electrical) with effect from
01.01.2016 with all consequential benefits.
4. On the other hand, the respondents filed their reply and denied the
claim of the applicant.
4.1 Learned counsel for the respondents submits that the applicant
seeks retrospective promotion with effect from 01.01.2016 and
also challenges the promotion order dated 29.06.2018, whereas the
present OA was filed in 2023. It is contended that no satisfactory
P ANUKUMA
:: 5 :: OA No.302/2023
explanation has been furnished for the substantial delay in
questioning the promotion and that the applicant has not sought
condonation of delay by filing an appropriate application.
4.2 In support of the objection concerning delay, learned counsel has
relied upon the decisions of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in P.S.
Sadasivaswamy v. State of Tamil Nadu, (1975) 1 SCC 152, and
Union of India v. M.K. Sarkar, (2010) 2 SCC 59 and submitted
that a stale claim for retrospective promotion cannot be revived
merely by submitting a subsequent representation to the
authorities.
4.3 It is submitted that the applicant had earlier approached this
Tribunal by way of filing OA No. 417 of 2012 , and the order dated
29.06.2016 passed therein was challenged before the Hon’ble High
Court of Gujarat in Special Civil Application No. 14581 of 2016
wherein the Hon’ble High Court upheld the relevant findings
concerning the applicant’s claim to reckon his officiating service
for promotional purposes.
4.4 Learned counsel has also referred to the proceedings culminating
in the judgment dated 18.10.2016 in Special Civil Application No.
16060 of 2016, wherein the Hon’ble High Court of Gujarat
considered the challenge concerning the treatment of a diploma in
engineering with ten years of technical experience as equivalent to
a degree for the relevant promotional purposes. It is submitted that
the applicant cannot reagitate the same issue which is already
adjudicated by the competent courts and the same is barred by
principles of res judicata laid down in the State of U.P. Vs. Nawab
Hussain (1977) 2 SCC 806 in which it was held that a plea which
might and ought to have been raised in earlier proceedings cannot
be permitted to be raised in subsequent proceedings. The present
OA is therefore abuse of process of law.
4.5 During the course of the argument, learned counsel for the
respondents has also placed reliance on the judgment passed by the
Hon’ble Apex Court in the case of Shiba Shankar Mohapatra &
P ANUKUMA
:: 6 :: OA No.302/2023
Ors. v. State of Orissa & Ors., AIR 2010 SC 706 : (2010) 12 SCC
471, decided on 12.11.2009.
4.6 Learned counsel has relied upon the MSRR 2009, as amended
from time to time. It is submitted that promotion to the grade of
Executive Engineer/Assistant General Manager (Electrical) is
governed by the prescribed eligibility conditions, including
qualifying service and seniority-cum-suitability.
4.7 Further, it was submitted that the applicant was granted regular
promotion to the post of SDE (Electrical) with effect from
16.02.2010 and, consequently, had not completed seven years of
qualifying regular service as on 01.01.2017 and could be
considered for promotion only in the year 2018, subject to the
other applicable conditions.
4.8 Learned counsel has further stated that in the provisional seniority
list dated 03.11.2016, the applicant was placed at serial number
380, whereas respondent No. 5 was placed at serial number 122.
Respondent No. 5 was consequently considered for promotion in
the promotion exercise culminating in the order dated 29.06.2018.
4.9 It is further submitted that promotions were subsequently granted
to 53 officers by order dated 09.11.2022, but the applicant could
not be promoted owing to his position in the seniority list and the
claims of officers senior to him. Hence, the OA is liable to be
dismissed being barred by limitation and devoid of merit.
5. The applicant has filed a rejoinder and reiterated the submissions
made in the OA. Additionally, the applicant submitted as under:-
5.1 That the Respondents’ preliminary objection regarding delay and
limitation is completely misconceived because the grievance of the
applicant arises from the continuous denial of promotion and
consequential service benefits, which legally constitutes a
continuing and recurring cause of action. The Applicant
consistently pursued his grievances through official channels. It is
settled law that every subsequent promotion exercise conducted by
the Respondents, wherein an eligible employee is overlooked,
gives rise to a fresh and distinct cause of action.
P ANUKUMA
:: 7 :: OA No.302/2023
5.2 Learned counsel for the applicant contended that the Hon’ble
Principal Bench, New Delhi (O.A. No. 2905/2015, decided on
14.11.2025) held that the Office Memorandum dated 26.05.1977
relied upon by BSNL to create this equivalence was false and
fictitious, and quashed the order dated 16.07.2015. Further, it is
submitted that the Hon’ble Chandigarh Bench (O.A. No.
892/2018, decided on 14.10.2025) similarly set aside the
16.07.2015 equivalence policy. It is further submitted that a
Review Petition (Diary No. 605/2026) filed against the Principal
Bench judgment was dismissed on 24.02.2026, so that those
findings have become final. It is also stated that contempt
proceedings ( CP No. 183/2026 before the Principal Bench and
CP No. 45/2026 before the Chandigarh Bench) have been initiated
against BSNL for failing to implement these judgments. Therefore,
according to the applicant, the Respondents cannot sustain a
defence built upon a quashed policy.
5.3 It is stated that as observed by this Tribunal in O.A. No. 292/2015,
the determination of educational equivalence falls strictly within
the academic domain. According to the applicant, once the
foundational document (O.M. dated 26.05.1977) was found to be
false, all consequential promotions granted to Diploma holders
became legally unsustainable.
5.4 Further, learned counsel for the applicant submits that applicant’s
APAR/ACR entries for the relevant periods were entirely
satisfactory, and he maintained a clean record with no adverse
vigilance or disciplinary proceedings. Therefore, the Applicant was
legally entitled to be promoted to SDE (Electrical) effective from
10.06.2008 instead of 15.03.2010. Consequently, upon finishing
his qualifying service he became fully eligible for consideration to
the post of Executive Engineer (Electrical) effective from
01.01.2016, along with all subsequent promotional avenues.
6. We have heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the
material on record.
7. The following points arise for determination:
P ANUKUMA
:: 8 :: OA No.302/2023
7.1 Whether the OA is within time for each of the reliefs claimed, and,
if not, whether the delay should be condoned.
7.2 Whether the applicant is entitled to promotion as Executive
Engineer (Electrical) with effect from 01.01.2016, or from any
later date, and to the further promotions claimed in Prayer G.
8. The following facts are not in dispute:
8.1 The applicant joined the Department of Telecommunications as
Junior Engineer (Electrical) on 21.01.1991. He was absorbed in
BSNL from 01.10.2000.
8.2 He officiated as AE/SDE (Electrical) from 26.02.2001. He was
regularly promoted as SDE (Electrical) with effect from
16.02.2010, and joined on 15.03.2010.
8.3 Both sides proceed on the basis that MSRR 2009 requires seven
years of regular service as SDE for promotion of engineering
graduates to Executive Engineer/Assistant General Manager
(Electrical). The applicant does not dispute this condition. He
disputes only the date from which his regular service should count.
The relevant clause of the MSRR 2009 is reproduced herein below
which reads as under:-
Sr.
No
Grade
(Equivalent)
Method of
Recruitment
Whethe
Field of selection and the
minimum qualifying service
r
selectio
.
IDA Pay
Scale in Rs
for promotion
n by
Merit
or
Selectio
n cum
Seniorit
y or
Non-
selectio
n post
1 2 3 4 5
1 Assistant
General
Manager/(Eq
uivalent of
STS i.e., E4)
14,500-350-
18,700 (Post
Based
Promotion)
Promotion
from Group
“B”
Executives
Selectio
n-Cum-
Seniorit
y
(a) From JTS grade having
4 years of regular service in
the grade
(b) From regular SDE/AE
or equivalent grade of
concerned stream, who are
engineering
graduate/graduate (as
detailed at note 2 below)
from on Indian
Institute/University
P ANUKUMA
:: 9 :: OA No.302/2023
recognized under India
Laws, with total qualifying
service of 7 years as on “1
January of the year”
8.4 In the provisional seniority list dated 03.11.2016, the applicant was
at serial number 380. Respondent No. 5 was at serial number 122.
Respondent No. 5 was promoted by order dated 29.06.2018. By
order dated 09.11.2022, 53 officers were promoted. The applicant
was not among them.
8.5 The applicant made a representation on 18.04.2023 and filed this
OA on 25.09.2023. The representation was rejected on 30.10.2023,
while the OA was pending. No application for condonation of
delay has been filed.
9. We first take up the question of delay. Under Section 21(1) of the
Administrative Tribunals Act, 1985, an OA must be filed within
one year from the date on which the final order is made or, where a
representation has been made and no final order has been made on
it within six months, within one year from the expiry of that
period. Under Section 21(3), the Tribunal may admit an OA filed
later only if the applicant shows sufficient cause for not filing it in
time. The applicant has not filed any application for condonation
of delay. The OA also gives no reason for the delay.
9.1 The OA raises three separate claims, and each arises on a different
date. The first is the challenge to the promotion of Respondent No.
5 by order dated 29.06.2018. The second is the claim, made in para
5.4 of the rejoinder, that the applicant's regular promotion as SDE
should date from 10.06.2008 and not 16.02.2010. The third is the
claim to promotion as Executive Engineer (Electrical) from
01.01.2016, with the further promotions that follow from it.
9.2 The promotion of Respondent No. 5 was made on 29.06.2018. The
period of one year for challenging it ended on 28.06.2019. This
OA was filed on 25.09.2023, more than four years after that date.
The representation dated 18.04.2023 was made nearly five years
after the promotion. In Union of India v. M.K. Sarkar, the Hon'ble
Supreme Court held that a representation made on a stale claim,
P ANUKUMA
:: 10 :: OA No.302/2023
and the decision on it, do not give a fresh starting point for
limitation. In P.S. Sadasivaswamy v. State of Tamil Nadu, the
Hon'ble Supreme Court held that a person aggrieved by the
promotion of another must come to court within a reasonable time,
and that settled promotions should not ordinarily be disturbed after
many years. In Shiba Shankar Mohapatra v. State of Orissa, the
Hon'ble Supreme Court held that seniority and promotion must be
questioned within a reasonable time, and that those who stay silent
cannot later unsettle them. Respondent No. 5 has held the higher
post since 2018. The applicant has offered no explanation for the
delay. We, therefore, decline to condone the delay in respect of
Prayer D. As the delay is not condoned, we express no opinion on
whether Respondent No. 5 held the required educational
qualification. This also disposes of the submissions in paras 3.3,
3.5, 5.2 and 5.3, insofar as they are directed against the promotion
of Respondent No. 5.
9.3 The claim to an earlier date of regular promotion as SDE is not
part of any prayer in the OA. It was raised for the first time in the
rejoinder. A party cannot make out a new case in a rejoinder
without amending the OA. In any case, the regular promotion
dated 16.02.2010 was made more than thirteen years before this
OA was filed. The applicant was aware of his grievance about
counting his officiating service at least from the time of OA No.
417 of 2012 (para 4.3). No reason is given for the delay. We,
therefore, decline to condone the delay in respect of this claim as
well, and express no opinion on its merits. In view of this, we need
not decide the respondents' objection (paras 4.3 and 4.4) that the
question was already decided in OA No. 417 of 2012 and the
connected Special Civil Applications.
9.4 The applicant submits (para 5.1) that the denial of promotion is a
continuing wrong, and that each promotion exercise gives a fresh
cause of action. A claim to be considered in a particular promotion
round arises when that round is held. The order dated 09.11.2022,
by which 53 officers were promoted, falls within one year before
P ANUKUMA
:: 11 :: OA No.302/2023
the filing of this OA. The applicant says he was passed over in that
round as well. We, therefore, examine his claim to promotion on
its merits.
10. We now take up the applicant's claim to promotion as Executive
Engineer (Electrical) from 01.01.2016. An employee has a right to
be considered for promotion according to the Recruitment Rules.
He has no right to be promoted from a date of his choice. As noted
in para 8.3, promotion requires seven years of regular service as
SDE. The applicant's regular service as SDE began on 16.02.2010.
He completed seven years on 15.02.2017. He did not have the
required service on 01.01.2016, nor on 01.01.2017. His service as
SDE on an officiating basis from 26.02.2001 is not regular service.
The applicant has not pointed to any provision of MSRR 2009 that
allows officiating service to be counted for this purpose. His claim
to an earlier date of regular promotion has not been entertained
(para 9.3). The applicant was, therefore, not eligible for promotion
on 01.01.2016.
10.1 The applicant relies on his satisfactory APAR/ACR record and the
absence of any disciplinary or vigilance case (para 5.4). These
matters are relevant to his suitability for promotion. They cannot
make up for the qualifying service that the Rules require.
10.2 We next consider the later promotion rounds. According to the
respondents (para 4.7), the applicant could be considered from the
year 2018. The rejoinder does not dispute this. Promotion is made
on seniority-cum-suitability. In the provisional seniority list dated
03.11.2016, the applicant was at serial number 380. The
respondents state that he could not be reached in the rounds of
2018 and 2022 because officers senior to him had to be considered
first (paras 4.8 and 4.9). The applicant has not shown that any
officer junior to him was promoted in either round. He has not
challenged the seniority list dated 03.11.2016 or the order dated
09.11.2022. He has, therefore, not shown any right to promotion in
any round held before this OA was filed.
P ANUKUMA
:: 12 :: OA No.302/2023
10.3 The applicant also relies (paras 5.2 and 5.3) on the orders of the
Principal Bench in OA No. 2905/2015 and of the Chandigarh
Bench in OA No. 892/2018, which concern the equivalence order
dated 16.07.2015. These orders, and the pending contempt cases,
may affect the promotion of particular officers. But no officer
promoted under that equivalence, other than Respondent No. 5, is
a party before us. The challenge to the promotion of Respondent
No. 5 is barred (para 9.2). We cannot, in this OA, undo the
promotion of officers who have not been heard. We, therefore,
express no view on the effect of these orders, or of the judgment of
the Hon'ble High Court of Gujarat dated 18.10.2016 in SCA No.
16060 of 2016, on the equivalence question.
10.4 The claims in Prayer G, for promotion as Superintending Engineer
from 01.01.2020 and to the next post from 01.01.2024, depend on
the applicant first being promoted as Executive Engineer
(Electrical) from 01.01.2016. As that claim fails, these claims also
fail.
11. On examination of the issues, we find that:
(i) The challenge to the promotion of Respondent No. 5 by
order dated 29.06.2018 was filed more than four years late,
without any application or explanation, and we decline to
condone the delay;
(ii) The claim to regular promotion as SDE from 10.06.2008
was raised for the first time in the rejoinder and is also
barred, and we decline to condone the delay;
(iii) The applicant did not have seven years of regular service as
SDE on 01.01.2016, and has not shown a right to promotion
in any later round, being at serial number 380 in the
seniority list; and
(iv) The claims for promotion as Superintending Engineer and to
the next post depend on promotion to earlier grade and fail
on this account.
11.1 The view we have taken on delay accords with the recent decisions
of the Hon’ble Supreme Court. In V. Vincent Velankanni v.
P ANUKUMA
:: 13 :: OA No.302/2023
Union of India & Ors., 2024 INSC 748 (decided on 30.09.2024),
the Hon’ble Supreme Court held that a seniority list, once listed,
should not be reopened after a long period, as doing so would be
unjust to employees whose rights to seniority, rank and promotion
have crystallized in the meantime. In state of Tamil Nadu & Anr.
V. R. Sasipriya & Anr., 2026 INSC 446 (decided on 04.05.2026),
the Hon’ble Supreme Court reiterated that “a court exercising
public law jurisdiction does not encourage the agitation of stale
claims”, and that fence-sitters cannot be permitted to raise a dspute
relating to seniority and consequential promotion” once third-party
rights have crystallized.
12. In view of the above facts:
(i) The challenge to the promotion of Respondent No. 5 (Prayer
D) and the claim to an earlier date of regular promotion as
SDE are dismissed as barred by limitation, without any
expression of opinion on their merits.
(ii) The claims for promotion as Executive Engineer (Electrical)
from 01.01.2016 and to the higher posts (Prayers B, C and
G) are dismissed on merits.
(iii) Pending Miscellaneous Applications, if any, are disposed of.
(iv) There shall be no order as to costs.
(Sanjiv Kumar) (Jayesh V Bhairavia)
Member (A) Member (J)
//Anu//
P ANUKUMA