Hariom Meena vs M/o Railways

Court
Central Administrative Tribunal

: 1: OA No.120/403/2021

CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL
AHMEDABAD BENCH

Original Application No.403 of 2021

Reserved on: 21.09.2026
Order pronounced on: 06.11.2026


CORAM:

Hon’ble Mr. Jayesh V Bhairavia, Member (J)
Hon’ble Mr. Sanjiv Kumar, Member (A)

1. Shri Hariom Meena
S/o. Kanchan Lal Meena
Aged 38 years
Designation: Depot Material Superintendent
(DMS) under Senior Divisional Material. Manager,
DRM Office, RAJKOT.
R/O. V/P: RAGHOPURA
TEH: BAMANWAS
DIST: SAWAI MADHOPUR
Rajasthan 322211
… Applicant
(By Advocate Shri Joy Mathew)

V/s.

i). Union of India,
Notice to be served through
General Manager, Western Railway,
Churchgate, Mumbai-400020.

ii) Principal Chief Material Manager of Stores,
Western Railway,
Churchgate, Mumbai-400020.

iii) Deputy Chief Material Manager,
Western Railway,
Sabarmati, Anmedabad-380019.
iv) Senior Divisional Material Manager,
Western Railway,
DRM Office,
Rajkot-360001.
… Respondents
(By Advocate Shri H.D. Shukla)

ORDER

Per: Hon’ble Shri Jayesh V Bhairavia, Member (J)
1. The grievance of the applicant is that the respondents, vide impugned
Office Order dated 07.10.2021, have illegally withdrawn his
2026.11.06
PRATIK VYAS
14:02:28+05'30'

: 2: OA No.120/403/2021

promotions to the posts of Senior Clerk, Office Superintendent and
Depot Material Superintendent (DMS), and reverted him to the post of
Senior Clerk with effect from 28.02.2020, while also revising his pay.
2. By filing the instant OA under Section 19 of the Administrative
Tribunals Act, 1985, the applicant is seeking the following reliefs:-
“8.1 Lord ships be pleased to admit this petition. And be pleased to
issue order quash and setting aside office order No. E/56/2021
dated 07.10.2021 as Annexure A/1, which is reversion with
retrospective effect which is not permissible.
8.2 Be allow to restore original position with all consequential due
promotion at par with his juniors.
8.3 That the Hon'ble Tribunal may be kindly pleased to call for the
entire record of the applicant in possession of the respondent for its
kind perusal.
8.4 Any other relief which the Hon’ble Tribunal deems fit.
8.5 That the Hon’ble Tribunal in the facts and circumstances of the
present case may further be pleased to grant cost of the application
to the applicant.”.

3. FACTS OF THE CASE
3.1 While working as Khalasi, the applicant appeared in the selection
process for the post of Junior Clerk in the pay scale of Rs. 5200–20200
+ Grade Pay Rs.1900/-. Having successfully qualified in the
examination, he was placed in the panel dated 09.09.2011 with effect
from 07.09.2011. Accordingly, he was promoted to the post of Junior
Clerk vide order dated 12.09.2011, subject to the condition that he
would clear the typing test within two years, failing which he would be
liable to be reverted.
3.2 The typing test was conducted on 13.04.2013, nearly after the expiry
of the stipulated period of two years, but the same was cancelled by
the respondents vide Memorandum dated 20.06.2013. Immediately
thereafter, vide communication dated 27.06.2013, another typing test
was scheduled to be conducted on 18.07.2013. The result of the said
test was declared on 01.10.2013, wherein all the employees, except
one, were declared unsuccessful.
2026.11.06
PRATIK VYAS
14:02:28+05'30'

: 3: OA No.120/403/2021

3.3 Aggrieved by the reversion order and the result of the typing test, the
applicant, along with other similarly situated employees, approached
this Tribunal by filing OA No. 315/2013 ( Annexure A/5 refer). The
Tribunal, vide Order dated 15.02.2017, directed the respondents as
under:
“The applicants shall be given an opportunity to appear for one more
typing test specifically conducted for them. The test shall be organized
within one month of receipt of copy of order.”
3.4 In compliance with the aforesaid directions, the respondents conducted
the typing test on 18.04.2017 and declared its result on 04.05.2017,
wherein the applicant was declared successful. According to the
applicant, the result was given effect from the date of the original
panel, i.e., 19.09.2011.
3.5 Thereafter, the respondent No. 3, vide letter bearing No. 839/7/Part-
VI dated 21.07.2017 ( Annexure A/6 refer) sought advice from
respondent No. 1 regarding fixation of the applicant's seniority and
further promotion at par with other candidates of the panel.
3.6 Subsequently, respondent No. 3 issued a reminder to respondent No. 1
vide letter bearing No. E.939/7/Part-VI dated 06.11.2017 ( Annexure
A/7 refer), seeking clarification regarding the applicant's seniority and
further promotion.
3.7 The respondent No. 1, vide letter bearing No. E/Stores/1025/9/2 (Min)
dated 16.11.2017 ( Annexure A/8 refer) advised respondent No. 3 to
deal with the matter in accordance with the Master Circulars and
instructions issued by the Railway Board from time to time concerning
promotion and seniority rules.
3.8 The respondent No. 3, vide letter bearing No. E/839/7(II) Part-6 dated
07.03.2018, forwarded a proposal to respondent No. 1, inter alia ,
recommending that the applicant be granted upgradation to the post of
Senior Clerk in Grade Pay Rs. 2800/- with effect from 01.11.2013 and
consequential promotion to the post of Office Superintendent in Grade
Pay Rs. 4200/- with effect from 29/31.12.2015 ( Annexure A/9 refer).
2026.11.06
PRATIK VYAS
14:02:28+05'30'

: 4: OA No.120/403/2021

3.9 The respondent No. 1 accepted the proposal concerning his promotion
to the post of Senior Clerk and, vide letter bearing No.
E/Stores/1025/9/2 (Min) Vol. II dated 26.04.2018, advised respondent
No. 3 to grant the said promotion and submit a fresh proposal for his
promotion to the post of Office Superintendent in Grade Pay Rs.
4200/-, enclosing the promotion orders issued in the grade of Senior
Clerk ( Annexure A/10 refer)
3.10 The respondent No. 3 issued Office Order No. E/07/2018 dated
18.05.2018, placing his name at Serial No. 8 in the eligibility list for
promotion to the post of Senior Clerk ( Annexure A/11 refer).
3.11 The respondent No. 3 also issued Office Order No. E/35/2018 dated
18.05.2018, granting him proforma promotion to the post of Senior
Clerk in the pay band of Rs. 5200–20200 + Grade Pay Rs. 2800/- with
effect from 01.11.2013 ( Annexure A/12 refer)
3.12 Thereafter, the respondent No. 3, vide letter bearing No. E/839/1/Mini.
Vol. I dated 14.06.2018, forwarded a proposal to respondent No. 1 for
his promotion to the post of Office Superintendent in Grade Pay Rs.
4200/- ( Annexure A/13 refer).
3.13 In response to the aforesaid proposal dated 14.06.2018, respondent No.
1 issued letter bearing No. E/Stores/1025/9/2 (Min) Vol. II dated
28.06.2018, returning the original copies of the benchmarking/service
records, APARs/working reports and assessment sheets of the
employees, duly approved by CMM (E&G), for further necessary
action ( Annexure A/14 refer).
3.14 Thereafter, the respondent No. 3, vide Office Order No. E/52/2018
dated 10.07.2018, granted him proforma promotion to the post of
Office Superintendent with effect from 29.12.2015 ( Annexure A/15
refer).
3.15 The applicant made a representation dated 28.09.2018, requesting that
he be given an option to opt for the Non-Ministerial category
2026.11.06
PRATIK VYAS
14:02:28+05'30'

: 5: OA No.120/403/2021

( Annexure A/16 refer). It is stated that he opted for the Non-
Ministerial category.
3.16 The respondent No. 3, vide letter bearing No. E/1030/1 Part-II dated
17.01.2019, sought advice from respondent No. 1 regarding his
entitlement to the Non-Ministerial option ( Annexure A/17 refer).
3.17 The respondent No. 1, vide letter bearing No. E/Store/1029/2 dated
18.03.2019, sought all relevant correspondence and a statement from
the applicant explaining why the option had not been given to him
earlier ( Annexure A/18 refer).
3.18 The respondents’ Headquarters, vide letter bearing No.
E/Stores/1025/0/2 (Min) dated 14.06.2019, advised respondent No. 3
to obtain the applicant's option ( Annexure A/19 refer).
3.19 The respondent No. 3, vide letter bearing No. E/1030/1 Part-II dated
02.07.2019, directed the applicant to submit the option form in
triplicate within one week ( Annexure A/20 refer).
3.20 Accordingly, the applicant exercised his option for the Non-Ministerial
category on 02.07.2019 ( Annexure A/21 refer).
3.21 The respondent No. 3, vide letter bearing No. E/839/1 Non-Mini Part-I
dated 21.08.2019, sought approval from respondent No. 1 for filling up
six posts of Depot Material Superintendent (DMS). The Headquarters
subsequently approved the promotions to the said posts vide letter
bearing No. E/Stores/1025/9/2 (Non-Min) dated 12.09.2019
( Annexures A/22 and A/23 , respectively refer).
3.22 The respondents’ Headquarters, vide letter bearing No.
E/Stores/1025/9/2 (Non-Min) dated 17.12.2019, approved the
eligibility list of employees working as Office Superintendent
(Ministerial) in the scale of Rs. 9300–34800 + Grade Pay Rs. 4200/-
(Level-6) for promotion to the post of Depot Material Superintendent
(Non-Ministerial) in the corresponding pay scale ( Annexure A/24
refer).
2026.11.06
PRATIK VYAS
14:02:28+05'30'

: 6: OA No.120/403/2021

3.23 The respondent No.3 issued Office Letter No.E/20/2019 dated
18.12.2019, placing his name in the panel for promotion to the post of
DMS ( Annexure A/25 refer).
3.24 The respondent No. 3, vide Office Order No. E/75/2019 dated
24.12.2019, promoted him to the post of Depot Material
Superintendent (DMS) and posted him at Rajkot under the Senior
Divisional Material Manager, Rajkot ( Annexure A/26 refer).
3.25 The applicant made a representation dated 08.01.2020 for making an
entry of 14 performance certificates in his service sheet ( Annexure
A/27 refer).
3.26 The respondents’ Headquarters, vide letter bearing No.
E/Stores/1025/9/2 (Min) Vol. III dated 26.05.2021 ( Annexure A/4
refer), advised respondent No. 3 as under:
“In view of the extant rules, the promotion given to Shri Meena as Sr.
Clerk in 2011 and thereafter as OS in 2013 needs to be withdrawn.
SBI should be advised to take necessary action in this regard.
Responsibility should be fixed as to how erroneous promotion was
given.”
According to the applicant, the aforesaid communication was issued
without assigning any reasons.
3.27 The respondents’ Headquarters, vide letter bearing No.
E/Stores/1025/9/2 (Min) Vol. III dated 19.08.2021, advised respondent
No. 3 to correct the dates of his promotion to the posts of Senior Clerk
and Office Superintendent, which were earlier shown as 2011 and
2013, respectively, to 2013 and 2015, in accordance with the records
( Annexure A/3 refer).
3.28 The respondent No. 3 issued a show-cause notice bearing No. E.839/1
Non-Mini Part-02 dated 26.08.2021, proposing withdrawal of his
promotions to the posts of Senior Clerk and Office Superintendent
granted in 2013 and 2015, respectively. The respondents proposed to
regularise him as Junior Clerk from the date of passing the typing test,
i.e., 04.05.2017, and accordingly indicated his existing and proposed
positions ( Annexure A/2 refer).
2026.11.06
PRATIK VYAS
14:02:28+05'30'

: 7: OA No.120/403/2021

3.29 The applicant submitted his reply dated 06.09.2021 to the aforesaid
show-cause notice ( Annexure A/28 refer).
3.30 Being aggrieved by the aforesaid show-cause notice, the applicant
approached this Tribunal by filing OA No.360/2021, wherein this
Tribunal passed an order dated 14.09.2021 ( Annexure A/29 refer).
The relevant paras of the same are reproduced as under:-
“2. The present OA has been filed against the show cause notice dated
26/08/2021 whereby the applicant has been called upon to give his
reply/representation within 15 days’ time with respect to the
proposed action of his reversion to the post of Junior Clerk.
Pursuant to the said show cause notice, the applicant herein has
submitted his representation dated 06/09/2021 Annexure A/27. It is
noticed that before the said representation of the applicant is
considered and decided by the respondent, he approached this
Tribunal by way of this OA. Since the OA is premature, we are not
inclined to entertain it at this stage.
The learned counsel for the applicant submits that she does
not press this OA and requests to allow her to withdraw this
OA. Considering the said request on behalf of the applicant,
we allow the applicant to withdraw this OA at this stage. It is
expected that the respondent will consider the pending reply
of the applicant in accordance with the rules and as also in
accordance with the principle of natural justice.
3. In view of the above, the OA stands dismissed as withdrawn at
admission stage.”
3.31 The respondent No. 3, vide letter bearing No. E.839/1 Non-Mini Part-
02 dated 30.09.2021, recorded its remarks on the reply to the show-
cause notice, according to the applicant, without duly considering the
facts and circumstances of the case ( Annexure A/30 refer).
3.32 The applicant again submitted a representation dated 01.10.2021 to the
Deputy Chief Materials Manager (Dy. CMM), requesting that the
matter be referred to the higher authorities for clarification and that he
be granted a personal hearing ( Annexure A/31 refer).
3.33 The respondent No. 3, vide letter bearing No. E.839/1 Non-Mini Part-
02 dated 04.10.2021, directed him to appear personally on 06.10.2021
for a hearing ( Annexure A/32 refer).
3.34 It is also stated by the applicant that he was on sanctioned leave from
04.10.2021 to 16.10.2021 on account of his mother's illness at his
native place in Rajasthan. The Senior Divisional Material Manager,
2026.11.06
PRATIK VYAS
14:02:28+05'30'

: 8: OA No.120/403/2021

vide letter bearing No. S/E/839/2021/1 dated 05.10.2021, informed the
Deputy Chief Materials Manager about the applicant's sanctioned
leave ( Annexure A/33 refer). The applicant further stated that, despite
being on sanctioned leave, he was willing to appear before the Deputy
Chief Materials Manager for a personal hearing.
3.35 Despite being aware of his sanctioned leave, the Deputy Chief
Materials Manager proceeded to pass Office Order No. E/56/2021
dated 07.10.2021, without waiting for his appearance or affording him
an effective opportunity of personal hearing ( Annexure A/1 refer). By
the said order, the respondents withdrew his promotions to the posts of
Senior Clerk, Office Superintendent and DMS and reverted him to the
post of Senior Clerk with effect from 28.02.2020, fixing his pay at Rs.
31,000/-. The applicant further stated that his pay was also revised
without proper application of mind as the aforesaid promotions had
been granted pursuant to the decisions of the Selection Committee, the
same could not have been cancelled or withdrawn by a single authority
without approval of the competent higher authority. According to him,
the impugned order adversely affects his pay, post, status and
consequential promotional avenues. Hence, this OA.
4. Pursuant to notice issued by this Tribunal, the respondents have filed
their reply opposing the claim of the applicant to which the applicant
has also filed his rejoinder.
5. CONTENTIONS OF THE APPLICANT’S LEARNED
COUNSEL
5.1 Learned counsel for the applicant, while assailing the impugned order
dated 07.10.2021, submitted that the action of respondent No. 3 in
withdrawing the applicant's promotions and reverting him is illegal,
arbitrary, contrary to the applicable Railway rules and instructions, and
violative of the principles of natural justice. Learned counsel
contended that the impugned order deserves to be quashed and set
aside on the following grounds:
5.2 Learned counsel submitted that the impugned order is contrary to the
instructions issued by Headquarters vide letter dated 19.08.2021
2026.11.06
PRATIK VYAS
14:02:28+05'30'

: 9: OA No.120/403/2021

( Annexure A/3 ), wherein respondent No. 3 was advised to correct the
dates of promotion of the applicant to the posts of Senior Clerk and
Office Superintendent from 2011 and 2013 to 2013 and 2015,
respectively, as per the records. Learned counsel contended that, in
disregard of the aforesaid instructions, respondent No. 3 proceeded to
regularise the applicant's service as Junior Clerk with effect from
04.05.2017 and revise his promotions, thereby acting beyond its
authority.
5.3 Learned counsel further submitted that the applicant's promotions and
upgradations had been granted pursuant to the recommendations of the
Selection Committee and with the approval of the Chief Materials
Manager/Headquarters. Therefore, respondent No.3 lacked the
authority to withdraw or cancel such promotions unilaterally without
obtaining approval of the competent higher authority. Learned counsel
argued that respondent No.3 had virtually assumed the role of an
appellate authority over the decisions of Headquarters, which was
impermissible in law.
5.4 Learned counsel submitted that this Tribunal, vide order dated
15.02.2017 passed in OA No. 315/2013 ( Annexure A/5 refer),
specifically directed the respondents to provide the applicant and
similarly situated employees another opportunity to appear in the
typing test. The applicant successfully cleared the said test conducted
on 18.04.2017, and his result was declared on 04.05.2017. Learned
counsel contended that the respondents, having granted consequential
promotions and upgradations in accordance with the selection of 2011,
could not subsequently withdraw the same by disregarding the
aforesaid judicial directions.
5.5 Learned counsel contended that respondent No. 3 had misinterpreted
Railway Board Circular RBE No. 02/2017 dated 16.01.2017
( Annexure A/34 refer), particularly when the said circular expressly
provides that cases already decided in the past need not be reopened.
Learned counsel submitted that the applicant's case had already been
considered and his promotions granted after due approval; hence,
2026.11.06
PRATIK VYAS
14:02:28+05'30'

: 10: OA No.120/403/2021

reopening the same and withdrawing the benefits already extended to
him was unjustified.
5.6 Learned counsel drew our attention to Paragraph 20 of Railway Master
Circular No. 34 ( Annexure A/35 refer), which provides as follows:
“20. Sometimes due to Administrative error, staff are overlooked
for promotion to higher grades. This could be either on account of
wrong assignment of relative seniority of the eligible staff or full
facts not being placed before the Selection Board. Broadly, there
can be two types: -
a. Where a person has not been promoted at all because of
administrative error; and
b. where a person has been promoted but not on the date from
which he would have been promoted but for the
administrative error.
20.1 Each such case should be dealt with on merits. Staff who have
not been promoted on administrative error, should on promotion,
be assigned correct seniority vis-a-vis their juniors already
working, irrespective of the date of promotion.
20.2 The orders of notification, promotion or appointment of a
Railway employee in a substantive or officiating capacity to a post
is latter found to be erroneous on the basis of facts, should be
cancelled and the Railway servant should immediately be brought
to the position which he would have held but for the incorrect
order of promotion on appointment, following the procedure
stipulated for the same.
20.3 Service rendered by the Railway servant concerned in the post
to which he was promoted wrongly should not be reckoned for
purpose of increment or for any other purpose in that grade.
20.4 Any consequential promotions/appointments made as a result
of the erroneous promotion will also be required to be regulated on
the lines indicated above.”
5.7 Learned counsel contended that the aforesaid provisions recognise the
entitlement of employees to appropriate seniority and consequential
promotions where they have suffered on account of administrative
errors. Accordingly, the applicant, having successfully passed the
typing test pursuant to the Tribunal's directions, was entitled to
consequential promotion and seniority at par with other employees of
the 2011 panel.
2026.11.06
PRATIK VYAS
14:02:28+05'30'

: 11: OA No.120/403/2021

5.8 Learned counsel further relied upon Paragraphs 16 and 17 of Railway
Master Circular No. 31 ( Annexure A/36 refer), dealing with removal
of names from panels and reversion of employees, and submitted that
the respondents had failed to follow the prescribed procedure while
withdrawing the applicant's promotions and altering his service
position.
5.9 Learned counsel also submitted that the applicant had also appeared in
a subsequent selection for the post of Clerk, wherein he qualified in the
written examination and his name was included in the provisional
panel. Learned counsel pointed out that other candidates of the said
selection were working in Grade Pay Rs. 4200/-. In this regard,
reliance was placed upon Office Letter No. E/14/2016 dated
28.07.2016 ( Annexure A/37 refer). Learned counsel contended that
the applicant's eligibility and merit had been repeatedly recognised by
the respondents and that his subsequent reversion was discriminatory
and unjustified.
5.10 Learned counsel further submitted that respondent No. 3, vide letter
bearing No. E.839/1 Non-Mini Part-01 dated 05.02.2021 ( Annexure
A/38 refer), incorrectly informed respondent No. 1 that the applicant
had been afforded three opportunities to pass the typing test but had
failed. Learned counsel contended that respondent No. 3 deliberately
failed to disclose the additional opportunity granted pursuant to the
Tribunal's order dated 15.02.2017, which the applicant had
successfully availed of. Thus, the proposal submitted to Headquarters
was based upon incomplete and incorrect facts, resulting in an
erroneous decision affecting the applicant's service benefits.
5.11 Learned counsel also submitted that the applicant is a meritorious
employee, who has rendered satisfactory service and has been issued
several performance certificates by the respondents from time to time.
Learned counsel contended that, despite his satisfactory performance
and continuous service in higher posts, the respondents had subjected
him to repeated harassment and deprived him of legitimate
promotional benefits.
2026.11.06
PRATIK VYAS
14:02:28+05'30'

: 12: OA No.120/403/2021

5.12 Learned counsel further submitted that respondent No. 3, vide
seniority list/letter dated 26.02.2021 ( Annexure A/41 refer), fixed the
applicant's seniority in the Non-Ministerial cadre in Grade Pay Rs.
4200/- at Serial No. 13, below Shri Pavnesh Singh and above Shri
Rajuram, despite the applicant and certain other employees belonging
to the same selection panel for the post of Junior Clerk. Learned
counsel contended that the applicant's seniority had been incorrectly
determined and that the respondents had placed incorrect facts before
Headquarters, thereby adversely affecting his promotional prospects.
5.13 Learned counsel also submitted that the applicant had repeatedly
approached the Railway Trade Union, the Labour Court at Ahmedabad
and the National Commission for Scheduled Tribes, Jaipur, seeking
redressal of his grievances regarding seniority and promotion in the
Non-Ministerial cadre. Learned counsel pointed out that the National
Commission for Scheduled Tribes had issued notice to the respondents
vide letter dated 02.12.2020 ( Annexure A/42 refer), in connection
with the applicant's grievance concerning promotion to the post of
Chief Depot Material Manager in Grade Pay Rs. 4600/-.
5.14 Learned counsel contended that the applicant had not been relieved
from the post of Depot Material Superintendent till the date of filing of
the OA, notwithstanding the impugned order withdrawing his
promotions. Learned counsel contended that such circumstances
further demonstrate the inconsistency in the respondents' action and
the prejudice caused to the applicant.
5.15 Lastly, learned counsel submitted that the impugned action is violative
of Articles 14, 16 and 21 of the Constitution of India, being arbitrary,
discriminatory and contrary to the principles of natural justice.
Learned counsel argued that the applicant was deprived of his
legitimate service benefits, seniority, promotional avenues and
financial entitlements without following the prescribed procedure and
without affording him an effective opportunity of hearing.
Accordingly, learned counsel prayed that the impugned Office Order
dated 07.10.2021 ( Annexure A/1 refer) be quashed and set aside and
2026.11.06
PRATIK VYAS
14:02:28+05'30'

: 13: OA No.120/403/2021

that the applicant be restored to his promotional position with all
consequential benefits, including seniority, pay fixation and further
promotional benefits.
6. Per contra, learned counsel appearing for the respondents by referring
to the counter reply filed on behalf of the respondents submitted that
the applicant was initially promoted to the post of Junior Clerk on an
ad hoc basis vide Office Order No. BLAQ/0011 dated 12.09.2011,
subject to the condition that he would qualify the prescribed typing test
within a period of two years. In order to provide reasonable
opportunities to all eligible candidates, the Railway Administration
conducted typing tests on 29.02.2012, 25.09.2012 and 18.07.2013, in
accordance with the prescribed schedule. Thus, the contention of the
applicant that the typing test was conducted after an inordinate delay
of almost two years was stated to be factually incorrect. Learned
counsel further submitted that the typing test scheduled for 30.04.2013
was cancelled for administrative reasons vide notification dated
20.06.2013 and was subsequently conducted on 18.07.2013 after due
intimation to all eligible candidates. Although only one candidate
qualified in the typing test held on 18.07.2013, the applicant, along
with three other candidates, had failed to qualify in all the three typing
tests conducted on 29.02.2012, 25.09.2012 and 18.07.2013. In this
regard, the respondents relied upon the relevant record placed on
record as Annexure R-1 refer.
6.1 Learned counsel further submitted that the applicant, along with other
unsuccessful candidates, had challenged the order of reversion before
this Tribunal in OA No.315/2013, which was disposed of with a
direction to provide all the applicants therein one further opportunity
to appear in a specially conducted typing test. In compliance with the
said directions, the respondents provided the applicant and other
similarly situated candidates an additional opportunity to appear in the
typing test. However, the applicant alone qualified in the said
additional typing test. His result was accordingly declared ( Annexure
R-3 refer). The respondents specifically disputed the applicant's
2026.11.06
PRATIK VYAS
14:02:28+05'30'

: 14: OA No.120/403/2021

assertion that the date 19.09.2011 had been reflected anywhere in the
result, as alleged by him.
6.2 With regard to the applicant's promotion to the post of Office
Superintendent, learned counsel submitted that the applicant had
accepted the promotion vide Office Order dated 10.07.2018 and had
also resumed duties on the higher post on the same date without
raising any objection at that stage. It was only subsequently, by way of
a representation dated 28.09.2018, that the applicant sought
consideration of his option for a non-ministerial position. The
respondents, therefore, contended that the applicant's subsequent
objection was an afterthought. In support of this submission, reliance
was placed upon the applicant's resumption report ( Annexure R-4
refer).
6.3 Learned counsel further submitted that, upon examination of the entire
service record and the relevant facts, the competent authority at the
Headquarters found that the promotions granted to the applicant to the
posts of Senior Clerk and Office Superintendent were erroneous and,
therefore, liable to be withdrawn. In this regard, reference was made to
Headquarters' communications bearing No. E/Stores/1025/9/2(Min.)
Vol. III dated 26.05.2021 and the subsequent clarification dated
19.08.2021. Learned counsel contended that the latter communication
was merely a clarification of the earlier communication and that the
applicant had selectively relied upon certain expressions therein to
advance his case. The relevant clarification, as reproduced by the
respondents, reads as under:
“In view of the extant rules, the promotion given to shri Meena as Sr.
Clerk in 2013 and thereafter as OS in 2015 needs to be withdrawn, he
should be advised to take necessary action in this regard. Responsibility
should also be fixed as to how erroneous promotion was given.
stand corrected vide clarification dated 19.08.2021” *
6.4 The respondents’ counsel also submitted that, in view of the aforesaid
directions of the competent authority, the applicant was required to be
restored to the position which he would have held but for the
2026.11.06
PRATIK VYAS
14:02:28+05'30'

: 15: OA No.120/403/2021

erroneous promotions. The relevant Headquarters' communications
were relied upon which are at Annexure R-5 refer.
6.5 Learned counsel further contended that, pursuant to the decision of the
competent authority dated 19.08.2021, a show-cause notice bearing
Letter No. E/839/1 (Non-Mini.) Vol. II dated 26.08.2021 was issued to
the applicant, thereby affording him a reasonable opportunity to
explain his position and defend himself in accordance with the
principles of natural justice ( Annexure R-6 refer).
6.6 Learned counsel further submitted that the applicant had earlier
approached this Tribunal in respect of the same controversy, and OA
No. 315/2013 had been disposed of in terms of the aforesaid direction
for providing one additional typing test. Learned counsel pointed out
that the applicant had subsequently filed another petition, which was
dismissed as withdrawn at the admission stage vide order dated
14.09.2021. While disposing of the said matter, this Tribunal had
observed as follows:
“it is expected that the respondent will consider the pending
reply of applicant in accordance with the rules and as also
in accordance with the principle of natural justice.”
According to the respondents, the applicant's representation dated
06.09.2021 was duly considered and replied to after taking into
account the relevant facts and circumstances.
6.7 Learned counsel submitted that the procedure prescribed under Para
228 of the Indian Railway Establishment Manual (IREM) governing
erroneous promotions had been duly followed and a reasoned decision
was communicated to the applicant. Despite the same, the applicant
continued to submit repeated representations seeking a personal
hearing and reconsideration of the matter by the Headquarters. The
respondents maintained that the decision had already been taken by the
competent authority after examining the entire service record and
relevant rules. In this context, learned counsel drew attention to the
provisions governing erroneous promotions contained in Rule 1326 of
2026.11.06
PRATIK VYAS
14:02:28+05'30'

: 16: OA No.120/403/2021

the Indian Railway Establishment Code, Volume II, 1987 Edition,
which, inter alia , provide as follows:
“(a) The orders of notification of promotion or appointment of a railway
servant should be cancelled as soon as it is brought to the notice of
the appointing authority that such a promotion or appointment has
resulted from a factual error and the railway servant concerned,
should, immediately on such cancellation, be brought to the
position which he would have held but for the incorrect orders of
promotion or appointment.
In the case, however, of a railway servant, who has been
erroneously promoted and appointed to a post in a substantive
capacity, procedure prescribed in Board's letter No. E50/RCI/16/3
dt. 23-7-1954 for rescinding the irregular confirmation of a
railway servant should be followed/and only thereafter the railway
servant concerned should be brought down to the position which he
would have held but for the erroneous promotion/appointment by
the issue of orders as mentioned above. Service rendered by the
Railway servant concerned in the post to which he was wrongly
promoted/appointed, as a result of the error should not be
reckoned for the purpose of increments or for any other purpose in
that grade/post to which he would not normally be entitled but for
the erroneous promotion/appointment.
(b) Any consequential promotion or appointments of other railway
servants made on the basis of the incorrect promotion or
appointment of a particular railway servant will also be regarded
as erroneous and such cases also will be regulated on the lines
indicated in the preceding paragraph.
(c) Except where the appointing authority is the Railway Board or the
President, the question whether the promotion/appointment of a
particular railway servant to a post was erroneous or not should be
decided by an authority next higher than the appointing authority
in accordance with the established principles governing
promotions/appointments. Where the appointing authority is the
Railway Board or the President, the decision should rest with the
President and shall be final.
(d) Cases of erroneous promotion/appointment in a substantive or
officiating capacity should be viewed with serious concern, and
suitable disciplinary action should be taken against the officers and
staff responsible for such erroneous promotion or appointment.”
6.8 A ccordingly, learned counsel contended that the applicant's case fell
within the ambit of the aforesaid provisions and that the action taken
by the respondents was in conformity with the applicable rules.
6.9 Addressing the grounds raised by the applicant, learned counsel
submitted that the decision to withdraw the erroneous promotions had
been taken by the competent authority at the Headquarters, which was
one level higher than the concerned appointing authority, namely, the
Deputy Chief Materials Manager. Thus, the requirement under Para
2026.11.06
PRATIK VYAS
14:02:28+05'30'

: 17: OA No.120/403/2021

228 of the IREM had been duly complied with. Learned counsel
further submitted that the present controversy was not one concerning
the removal of the applicant's name from a promotion panel but related
to the correction of an erroneous promotion. Therefore, the applicant's
reliance upon provisions concerning promotion panels was stated to be
misplaced.
6.10 Learned counsel also contended that the order passed by this Tribunal
in OA No. 315/2013 merely directed the respondents to provide one
further opportunity to the applicant to qualify in the typing test and did
not confer upon him any general or specific right regarding the date of
promotion, placement in the panel or seniority. The respondents
asserted that the additional opportunity had been duly granted and that
no further benefit could be claimed by the applicant on the basis of the
said order.
6.11 Learned counsel further submitted that the applicant's request for a
personal hearing had also been duly considered. He was advised to
appear personally on 06.10.2021. However, the applicant was on
sanctioned leave from 04.10.2021 to 16.10.2021, as communicated by
his controlling authority. Learned counsel contended that the applicant
did not bring forward any fresh facts or relevant material in his
subsequent representation dated 01.10.2021 warranting reconsideration
of the decision. The respondents maintained that a personal hearing
was not mandatory in the circumstances, particularly when reasonable
opportunities had already been afforded to the applicant. Learned
counsel also pointed out that the applicant appeared for the personal
hearing only on 28.10.2021, after a considerable lapse of time from the
expiry of his sanctioned leave.
6.12 With regard to the applicant's subsequent change of category, learned
counsel submitted that the same had been considered on the basis of
the applicant's own representation, even after he had resumed charge
as Office Superintendent at Bhavnagar Para. Consequently, Office
Order No. E-75/19 dated 24.12.2019 was issued posting him as DMS
at Rajkot, keeping in view the administrative requirements. Learned
2026.11.06
PRATIK VYAS
14:02:28+05'30'

: 18: OA No.120/403/2021

counsel alleged that the applicant had not complied with the said
posting order for more than one year.
6.13 Lastly, learned counsel submitted that the respondents had followed
the prescribed procedure under the applicable Railway Rules,
examined the applicant's service particulars and communicated a
reasoned decision after consideration by the competent authority.
Learned counsel contended that the applicant had failed to establish
any illegality or procedural infirmity in the decision to withdraw his
erroneous promotions. The respondents, therefore, submitted that no
prima facie case had been made out in favour of the applicant and
prayed that the Original Application be dismissed.
7. In rebuttal to the aforesaid submissions of the learned counsel for the
respondents, learned counsel for the applicant, by referring to
rejoinder, reiterated the averments made in the OA and controverted
the submissions advanced by the respondents. Learned counsel
submitted that the applicant, who was initially appointed as Khalasi on
31.05.2006, was senior-most in his cadre and had been promoted to the
post of Junior Clerk vide Office Order dated 12.09.2011. However, his
name was initially omitted from the list of eligible candidates issued
on 27.05.2011 and was included only after his representation dated
14.06.2011. In this regard, reliance was placed upon the appointment
order annexed as Annexure A/47 .
7.1 Learned counsel further submitted that, pursuant to the directions
passed by this Tribunal in OA No. 315/2013, the applicant was granted
one additional opportunity to appear in the typing test and, having
successfully qualified therein, was entitled to consequential benefits in
accordance with the panel dated 12.09.2011. Learned counsel also
contended that the respondents could not deny such benefits by
subsequently treating his promotion as erroneous. Further, it is
submitted that the applicant had consistently sought consideration for
the Non-Ministerial cadre and that the omission to obtain his option
was attributable to the administration. In this regard, reference was
made to the applicant's representations and the correspondence
2026.11.06
PRATIK VYAS
14:02:28+05'30'

: 19: OA No.120/403/2021

exchanged between the authorities, collectively forming part of
Annexures A/16 to A/21 and A/48 . Learned counsel denied that the
representation dated 28.09.2018 was an afterthought and submitted
that the applicant had already expressed his preference for the Non-
Ministerial cadre.
7.2 With regard to the communications dated 26.05.2021 and 19.08.2021,
forming part of Annexure R-5 , learned counsel submitted that the
latter communication merely corrected the dates of promotion as 2013
and 2015, respectively, and did not authorise the respondents to
undertake the impugned reversion in the manner adopted. Learned
counsel contended that Respondent No. 3 had exceeded the scope of
the Headquarters' clarification by altering the applicant's service status
and pay fixation without properly examining his service particulars
and entitlement. The applicant further alleged that his reply to the
show-cause notice was not duly considered, notwithstanding the
observations made by this Tribunal while disposing of the earlier OA
on 14.09.2021.
7.3 Learned counsel also submitted that the applicant was on sanctioned
leave from 04.10.2021 to 16.10.2021 on account of the illness of his
aged mother and that the reversion order was issued before he could
effectively avail himself of the opportunity of personal hearing. In
support thereof, reliance was placed upon the railway tickets and
representations annexed as Annexures A/49 to A/52 . Learned counsel
contended that the respondents had failed to appreciate the applicant's
genuine circumstances and had proceeded mechanically with the
reversion.
7.4 Learned counsel reiterated that the applicant's promotion had been
granted after following the prescribed selection/DPC procedure,
whereas the impugned reversion had been effected without obtaining
the requisite DPC advice or following the corresponding procedure.
Learned counsel contended that the applicant had successfully
qualified in the typing test and that the respondents could not
2026.11.06
PRATIK VYAS
14:02:28+05'30'

: 20: OA No.120/403/2021

retrospectively declare his promotion erroneous without establishing
the same in accordance with the applicable rules.
7.5 Learned counsel further pointed out that several junior candidates, who
appeared in the typing test held on 12.06.2018 and qualified thereafter,
had been promoted to the Grade Pay of Rs. 4200/-. In this regard,
reliance was placed upon the typing test result dated 02.07.2018 and
the promotion order dated 11.12.2020 ( Annexures A/43 and A/44
respectively refer). Learned counsel contended that the denial of
similar benefits to the applicant, despite his seniority and earlier
qualification, was discriminatory.
7.6 Learned counsel also submitted that the applicant had been discharging
his duties as DMS diligently and had received recognition for his
outstanding performance from the Railway Administration. In this
regard, reliance was placed upon the award communication and
Certificate of Merit for the year 2020-2021 ( Annexure A/45 refer), as
well as the typewriting competition certificate dated 05.10.2013
( Annexure A/46 refer). The applicant further relied upon Annexure
A/53 , concerning his service particulars, and Annexure A/54 ,
comprising the First Class pass certificate and muster roll for January
2022, to contend that he continued to discharge duties as DMS.
7.7 Lastly, learned counsel submitted that the respondents had failed to
properly consider the applicant's seniority, entitlement to the Non-
Ministerial cadre and the applicable provisions of Railway Board's
Master Circular No. 34. Learned counsel contended that the impugned
action was arbitrary, discriminatory and violative of Articles 14, 16
and 21 of the Constitution of India, besides being contrary to the
principles of natural justice. Accordingly, learned counsel prayed that
the impugned reversion order be quashed and the applicant be granted
the reliefs sought in the Original Application, including restoration of
his rightful service position with consequential benefits.
8. ANALYSIS
2026.11.06
PRATIK VYAS
14:02:28+05'30'

: 21: OA No.120/403/2021

8.1 We have carefully considered the pleadings of the parties, the rival
submissions advanced by their learned counsel, the documents placed
on record and the relevant provisions of the Indian Railway
Establishment Manual (IREM), the Railway Establishment Code and
the Railway Board's instructions governing erroneous promotions. The
principal question which arises for our consideration is whether the
respondents were justified in withdrawing the applicant's promotions
to the posts of Senior Clerk, Office Superintendent and Depot Material
Superintendent (DMS), and reverting him to the post of Senior Clerk
with retrospective effect from 28.02.2020, together with revision of his
pay, vide impugned Office Order dated 07.10.2021.
8.2 Before examining the rival contentions, it would be appropriate to
notice the settled legal position governing erroneous promotions. In
Union of India & Another v. Narendra Singh , reported in (2008) 2
SCC 750, the Hon’ble Supreme Court considered a case where an
employee had been promoted despite being ineligible under the
applicable statutory rules. While upholding the correction of the
erroneous promotion, the Hon'ble Supreme Court observed as follows:
“32. It is true that the mistake was of the Department and the respondent
was promoted though he was not eligible and qualified. But, we cannot
countenance the submission of the respondent that the mistake cannot be
corrected. Mistakes are mistakes and they can always be corrected by
following due process of law . In ICAR v. T.K. Suryanarayan [(1997) 6
SCC 766] it was held that if erroneous promotion is given by wrongly
interpreting the rules, the employer cannot be prevented from applying
the rules rightly and in correcting the mistake. It may cause hardship to
the employees but a court of law cannot ignore statutory rules.”
(emphasis supplied)
The Hon'ble Supreme Court further held that an erroneous promotion
granted by incorrectly interpreting the applicable rules cannot be
perpetuated merely because the mistake was committed by the
administration itself. The employer is entitled to correct such an error
by applying the rules correctly, subject, however, to compliance with
the prescribed procedure and principles of natural justice.
8.3 In the present case, it is an admitted position that the applicant was
initially promoted to the post of Junior Clerk vide Office Order dated
2026.11.06
PRATIK VYAS
14:02:28+05'30'

: 22: OA No.120/403/2021

12.09.2011, subject to the specific condition that he would qualify the
prescribed typing test within two years, failing which he would be
liable to reversion. The applicant did not qualify in the typing tests
conducted on 29.02.2012, 25.09.2012 and 18.07.2013. It is also not
disputed that he ultimately qualified in the additional typing test
conducted on 18.04.2017, pursuant to the directions issued by this
Tribunal in OA No.315/2013, and that the result thereof was declared
on 04.05.2017.
8.4 The applicant has sought to derive an entitlement to consequential
promotions from the panel of 2011, contending that his successful
qualification in the typing test pursuant to the Tribunal's directions
entitled him to the same benefits as other employees of that panel. We
are unable to accept this contention in its entirety. The Order dated
15.02.2017 passed in OA No.315/2013 merely directed the
respondents to provide the applicants therein one further opportunity to
appear in a specially conducted typing test. The said Order did not
expressly direct that successful candidates should be deemed to have
qualified within the original period of two years, nor did it confer any
automatic right to retrospective promotion or seniority from the date of
the original panel.
8.5 Consequently, the fact that the applicant successfully qualified in the
additional typing test in 2017 cannot, by itself, be construed as
validating his earlier promotions with retrospective effect from 2013 or
2015. The respondents were, therefore, not precluded from examining
whether the subsequent promotions granted to him were in accordance
with the applicable Railway rules. In this regard, the principle laid
down by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Union of India v. Narendra
Singh (supra) squarely applies, inasmuch as an erroneous promotion
cannot be perpetuated merely on the ground that it was granted by the
administration.
8.6 At the same time, we find considerable substance in the contention of
the applicant that his successful qualification in the additional typing
test, the subsequent correspondence exchanged between the Railway
2026.11.06
PRATIK VYAS
14:02:28+05'30'

: 23: OA No.120/403/2021

authorities and the promotions granted to him thereafter were required
to be examined in their entirety before arriving at a conclusion that his
promotions were erroneous. The respondents could not have proceeded
merely on the assumption that his entire subsequent service career was
liable to be annulled without determining the precise nature of the
error, the applicable rules and the consequences flowing therefrom.
8.7 We may now advert to the provisions governing erroneous
promotions. Paragraph 228 of the IREM, inter alia , provides that
where a promotion or appointment is subsequently found to have been
erroneous on the basis of facts, the employee concerned should be
restored to the position which he would have held but for the incorrect
order of promotion. The said provision further stipulates that the
question whether a promotion was erroneous should ordinarily be
decided by an authority next higher than the appointing authority, in
accordance with the established principles governing promotions and
appointments.
8.8 The aforesaid provision is also reflected in the relevant provisions of
Rule 1326 of the Railway Establishment Code, Volume II, 1987
Edition, relied upon by the respondents. The statutory and
administrative scheme, therefore, recognises the power of the Railway
Administration to correct an erroneous promotion. However, the
exercise of such power is not unfettered and must be preceded by an
objective determination of the factual and legal basis of the alleged
error, by the competent authority, after following the prescribed
procedure.
8.9 In the instant case, the respondents have relied upon the Headquarters'
communications dated 26.05.2021 and 19.08.2021, forming part of
Annexure R-5 . The communication dated 26.05.2021 specifically
advised withdrawal of the applicant's promotions to the posts of Senior
Clerk and Office Superintendent on the ground that the same were
erroneous. The subsequent communication dated 19.08.2021 clarified
the dates of the said promotions as 2013 and 2015, respectively.
2026.11.06
PRATIK VYAS
14:02:28+05'30'

: 24: OA No.120/403/2021

8.10 We do not find merit in the applicant's contention that the
communication dated 19.08.2021 merely corrected the dates of
promotion and altogether withdrew the earlier direction concerning
erroneous promotions. A conjoint reading of the aforesaid
communications indicates that the Headquarters had directed the
Railway Administration to examine and correct the erroneous
promotions granted to the applicant. The clarification concerning the
dates cannot, therefore, be read in isolation so as to nullify the
substantive direction contained in the earlier communication.
8.11 However, the applicant's further contention that respondent No.3 was
not competent to independently withdraw the promotions granted to
him also requires consideration. In this regard, we notice that
Paragraph 228 of the IREM specifically contemplates that the question
whether a promotion was erroneous should be decided by an authority
next higher than the appointing authority, except in cases where the
appointing authority itself is the Railway Board or the President.
8.12 The respondents have asserted that the decision regarding erroneous
promotions was taken by the competent authority at Headquarters,
which was higher than the appointing authority, and that respondent
No.3 merely implemented the said decision. If the original record
establishes that the competent authority at Headquarters had duly
examined the applicant's case and decided the question of erroneous
promotion in accordance with Paragraph 228 of the IREM, the
objection concerning lack of competence of respondent No.3, merely
on the ground that it issued the consequential office order, would not
be sustainable.
8.13 Nevertheless, the impugned order dated 07.10.2021 does not
sufficiently disclose the independent determination of the competent
authority concerning the applicant's entitlement to the different
promotional posts, particularly the post of DMS. It is also not evident
from the pleadings as to whether the withdrawal of the promotion to
the post of DMS was specifically examined and approved by the
competent authority in accordance with the applicable rules, or
2026.11.06
PRATIK VYAS
14:02:28+05'30'

: 25: OA No.120/403/2021

whether it was treated merely as an automatic consequence of the
withdrawal of the earlier promotions.
8.14 In our considered opinion, the promotion to the post of DMS, being a
separate promotion in the Non-Ministerial cadre, required an
examination of the applicant's eligibility, the relevant selection/panel,
his exercise of option for the Non-Ministerial category and the
approval accorded by Headquarters. The mere fact that the earlier
promotion to the post of Office Superintendent was found erroneous
would not dispense with the requirement of examining the subsequent
promotion to DMS in the light of the applicable recruitment and
promotion rules.
8.15 The next and equally important issue relates to compliance with the
principles of natural justice. The applicant has contended that although
he submitted his reply dated 06.09.2021 to the show-cause notice
dated 26.08.2021, the same was not duly considered. He has further
contended that, notwithstanding his sanctioned leave from 04.10.2021
to 16.10.2021 on account of his mother's illness, the respondents
proceeded to pass the impugned order dated 07.10.2021 without
affording him an effective opportunity of personal hearing.
8.16 On the other hand, the respondents have submitted that the applicant
was afforded a reasonable opportunity to submit his explanation; his
reply was duly considered; and the personal hearing scheduled for
06.10.2021 was not mandatory, particularly when he had already been
afforded an opportunity to submit his written representation. They
have further pointed out that the applicant appeared for the personal
hearing on 28.10.2021, after the expiry of his sanctioned leave.
8.17 It is well settled that even where an administrative authority possesses
the power to correct an erroneous promotion, such power cannot be
exercised in a manner which deprives the affected employee of a
reasonable opportunity to controvert the factual and legal basis of the
proposed action, particularly when the order entails serious civil
2026.11.06
PRATIK VYAS
14:02:28+05'30'

: 26: OA No.120/403/2021

consequences concerning his post, pay, seniority and promotional
avenues.
8.18 In Rajendra v. State of Maharashtra , reported in (2008) 11 SCC 90, the
Hon'ble Supreme Court disapproved the cancellation of an approval
without hearing the affected party, observing:
“We also disapprove the action taken by the second respondent in
abruptly cancelling the approval even without hearing the appellant or,
as the case may be, the Managing Committee.”
The aforesaid principle emphasises that an administrative decision
adversely affecting an existing service position cannot ordinarily be
taken without affording the affected person an appropriate opportunity
to put forth his case.
8.19 The Hon’ble Delhi High Court, in Lt. Governor of Delhi & Others v.
Dr. Davindera Kumar , W.P.(C) No.11186/2025, decided on
05.08.2025, while examining an order cancelling promotion and
reverting an employee, held that reversion after grant of promotion
entails civil consequences and cannot be effected without compliance
with the principles of natural justice. The Hon’ble High Court
specifically observed that:
“5. ……. Reversion after the grant of promotion entails civil
consequences and, therefore, cannot be affected without complying
with the Principles of Natural Justice.”
The Hon’ble High Court further held that the notices issued to the
employee, which merely sought information and documents, were
insufficient where no specific show-cause notice had been issued
concerning the proposed reversion and its consequences.
8.20 Applying the aforesaid principles to the facts of the present case, we
find that the applicant was indeed issued a show-cause notice dated
26.08.2021 specifically proposing withdrawal of his promotions to the
posts of Senior Clerk and Office Superintendent and indicating the
proposed alteration in his service position. Thus, unlike the case before
the Hon’ble Delhi High Court in Dr. Davindera Kumar (supra), the
applicant had been put on notice concerning the proposed withdrawal
of at least those promotions.
2026.11.06
PRATIK VYAS
14:02:28+05'30'

: 27: OA No.120/403/2021

8.21 However, the subsequent course of events assumes significance. The
applicant submitted his reply on 06.09.2021, which was pending
consideration when he approached this Tribunal in OA No.360/2021.
While disposing of the said OA on 14.09.2021 as withdrawn, this
Tribunal specifically observed that:
“It is expected that the respondent will consider the pending reply
of the applicant in accordance with the rules and as also in
accordance with the principle of natural justice.”
Thus, the respondents were under an obligation to consider the
applicant's pending reply in a fair and objective manner before taking a
final decision.
8.22 We notice that the respondents issued a communication dated
30.09.2021 recording their remarks on the applicant's reply.
Thereafter, the applicant submitted a further representation dated
01.10.2021 requesting reference of the matter to the higher authorities
and seeking a personal hearing. The respondents scheduled his
personal hearing for 06.10.2021. However, the applicant was
admittedly on sanctioned leave from 04.10.2021 to 16.10.2021, a fact
which was duly communicated by his controlling authority vide letter
dated 05.10.2021.
8.23 In these circumstances, the respondents ought to have considered
whether the applicant could reasonably attend the hearing on the
scheduled date or whether an alternative date could be fixed,
particularly when the hearing had been arranged by the respondents
themselves and the applicant had expressed his willingness to appear.
The passing of the impugned order on 07.10.2021, immediately after
the scheduled hearing date and during the applicant's sanctioned leave,
without awaiting his appearance, raises a legitimate concern regarding
the effectiveness of the opportunity afforded to him.
8.24 We are conscious of the settled principle that a personal hearing is not
an indispensable requirement in every administrative proceeding and
that compliance with natural justice depends upon the facts and
circumstances of the case. However, where an authority itself decides
2026.11.06
PRATIK VYAS
14:02:28+05'30'

: 28: OA No.120/403/2021

to afford a personal hearing and the employee is unable to attend on
account of sanctioned leave duly communicated to it, the authority
ought not to proceed in a manner which renders the offered
opportunity illusory, particularly when the proposed order is likely to
affect the employee's service status and financial entitlements
substantially.
8.25 The respondents' contention that the applicant appeared for the
personal hearing on 28.10.2021 does not, by itself, cure the aforesaid
infirmity. The impugned order had already been passed on 07.10.2021.
Any hearing afforded thereafter could be relevant only if the
competent authority had genuinely reopened the matter and
reconsidered the applicant's objections before passing a fresh decision.
The respondents have not demonstrated that the impugned order was
reconsidered or modified following the applicant's appearance on
28.10.2021.
8.26 We, therefore, find that although the applicant had been served with a
show-cause notice and had submitted his written reply, the manner in
which the final decision was taken, particularly in relation to the
scheduled personal hearing and the applicant's sanctioned leave, does
not inspire confidence that the opportunity afforded to him was fully
effective.
9. We may now examine the applicant's contention that the respondents
failed to consider his option for the Non-Ministerial cadre and thereby
deprived him of his rightful promotional avenues. The applicant has
placed reliance upon the correspondence exchanged between the
Railway authorities during 2018 and 2019, particularly Annexures
A/16 to A/21 , to contend that he had consistently sought consideration
for the Non-Ministerial category and that the omission to obtain his
option at the appropriate stage was attributable to the administration.
9.1 The aforesaid contention cannot be brushed aside merely by describing
the representation dated 28.09.2018 as an afterthought. The
correspondence placed on record indicates that the respondents
2026.11.06
PRATIK VYAS
14:02:28+05'30'

: 29: OA No.120/403/2021

themselves subsequently initiated the process of obtaining the
applicant's option and ultimately accepted his option for the Non-
Ministerial category on 02.07.2019. The applicant was thereafter
included in the panel for promotion to the post of DMS and promoted
vide Office Order dated 24.12.2019.
9.2 Consequently, the question whether the applicant's earlier service in
the Ministerial cadre, his option for the Non-Ministerial cadre and the
subsequent promotion to DMS were correctly dealt with required a
separate and reasoned examination. The respondents were required to
determine whether the applicant's promotion to DMS was
independently valid under the applicable rules or whether any
consequential correction was warranted on account of the alleged
erroneous promotion to the post of Office Superintendent.
9.3 We also notice that the applicant has relied upon the promotion orders
dated 11.12.2020 concerning certain other employees, who allegedly
qualified in the typing test conducted on 12.06.2018 and were
thereafter promoted to the Grade Pay of Rs.4200/-. However, mere
comparison with other employees would not, by itself, establish the
applicant's entitlement to a particular promotion. The principle of
equality under Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution cannot be
invoked to perpetuate an illegality or an erroneous benefit, if the
applicant's own promotion is found to be contrary to the applicable
rules.
9.4 Nevertheless, where the applicant claims that similarly situated
employees have been treated differently despite possessing comparable
eligibility and service particulars, the respondents are required to
examine such contention objectively and demonstrate the
distinguishing circumstances, if any. The applicant's plea of
discriminatory treatment, therefore, deserves consideration on the basis
of the relevant service records, panels, selection proceedings and
applicable promotion rules.
2026.11.06
PRATIK VYAS
14:02:28+05'30'

: 30: OA No.120/403/2021

9.5 The applicant's reliance upon Paragraphs 20 and 20.2 of Railway
Master Circular No.34 also requires clarification. The aforesaid
provisions deal with cases involving administrative errors and
erroneous promotions. While Paragraph 20 recognises the entitlement
of employees who have been overlooked on account of administrative
error to appropriate seniority vis-à-vis their juniors, Paragraphs 20.2 to
20.4 specifically provide for correction of erroneous promotions and
regulation of consequential promotions.
9.6 Thus, the aforesaid provisions cannot be construed as conferring an
unconditional right upon the applicant to retain all promotions granted
to him, irrespective of his eligibility under the applicable rules. At the
same time, the respondents cannot rely upon the provisions concerning
erroneous promotions mechanically, without examining whether the
original promotion was erroneous, the extent of the error, the
competent authority empowered to correct it and the consequences
flowing from such correction.
10. Another important aspect of the matter is that the impugned order
dated 07.10.2021 has not merely withdrawn the applicant's promotions
but has also reverted him to the post of Senior Clerk with effect from
28.02.2020 and revised his pay to Rs.31,000/-. The applicant has
contended that such retrospective alteration is impermissible and has
adversely affected his financial entitlements and promotional avenues.
10.1 In this regard, it is necessary to distinguish between correction of an
erroneous promotion and recovery of financial benefits already
received by an employee. The Hon'ble Supreme Court in Union of
India v. Narendra Singh (supra) recognised the authority's power to
correct an erroneous promotion in accordance with the rules. However,
the question of recovery of excess payments, if any, is governed by
separate legal principles and cannot automatically follow from the
cancellation of promotion.
10.2 In State of Punjab v. Rafiq Masih (White Washer) , reported in (2015)
4 SCC 334, the Hon'ble Supreme Court laid down circumstances in
2026.11.06
PRATIK VYAS
14:02:28+05'30'

: 31: OA No.120/403/2021

which recovery of excess payments made to employees would be
impermissible, particularly where such recovery would be inequitable
or unduly harsh. The said judgment, however, concerns recovery of
monetary benefits and does not, by itself, prohibit correction of an
erroneous promotion or lawful refixation of pay. The relevant para of
the Hon’ble Supreme Court judgment is reproduced as under:-
“18. It is not possible to postulate all situations of hardship which
would govern employees on the issue of recovery, where payments
have mistakenly been made by the employer, in excess of their
entitlement. Be that as it may, based on the decisions referred to
hereinabove, we may, as a ready reference, summarise the
following few situations, wherein recoveries by the employers,
would be impermissible in law:
(i) Recovery from the employees belonging to Class III and Class
IV service (or Group C and Group D service).
(ii) Recovery from the retired employees, or the employees who are
due to retire within one year, of the order of recovery.
(iii) Recovery from the employees, when the excess payment has
been made for a period in excess of five years, before the order of
recovery is issued.
(iv) Recovery in cases where an employee has wrongfully been
required to discharge duties of a higher post, and has been paid
accordingly, even though he should have rightfully been required
to work against an inferior post.
(v) In any other case, where the court arrives at the conclusion,
that recovery if made from the employee, would be iniquitous or
harsh or arbitrary to such an extent, as would far outweigh the
equitable balance of the employer's right to recover.”
10.3 In the present case, the respondents have not satisfactorily
demonstrated, in the impugned order, the precise basis for fixing the
applicant's pay at Rs.31,000/- with effect from 28.02.2020, particularly
in view of his subsequent promotion to DMS and the service actually
rendered by him in the higher posts. The question of pay fixation,
therefore, requires determination in accordance with the applicable
Railway rules, the nature of the promotions held erroneous and the
consequences prescribed under Paragraph 228 of the IREM and Rule
1326 of the Railway Establishment Code.
2026.11.06
PRATIK VYAS
14:02:28+05'30'

: 32: OA No.120/403/2021

10.4 We also find that the impugned order does not adequately distinguish
between the applicant's promotions to the posts of Senior Clerk and
Office Superintendent on the one hand and his subsequent promotion
to DMS on the other. Such a distinction was necessary because the
applicant's promotion to DMS was made under the Non-Ministerial
cadre after obtaining the requisite option and approval of
Headquarters. The respondents were required to determine whether
that promotion was independently sustainable or liable to be regulated
as a consequential promotion under the relevant provisions.
11. In view of the foregoing discussion, we hold that the respondents were
not precluded from examining and correcting an erroneous promotion
merely because the same had been granted by the administration or
had continued for some time. The applicant cannot claim an
indefeasible right to retain a promotion which is found to be contrary
to the applicable Railway rules. The principle laid down by the
Hon'ble Supreme Court in Union of India v. Narendra Singh (supra)
squarely governs this aspect of the matter.
12. However, the power to correct an erroneous promotion must be
exercised by the competent authority in accordance with Paragraph
228 of the IREM and the relevant provisions of the Railway
Establishment Code, after objectively considering the employee's
explanation and the factual and legal basis of the alleged error. The
correction of an erroneous promotion cannot be undertaken
mechanically or in disregard of the principles of natural justice.
13. In the present case, we find that the applicant was issued a show-cause
notice and submitted his reply. Nevertheless, the circumstances
surrounding the personal hearing scheduled for 06.10.2021, the
applicant's sanctioned leave duly communicated to the respondents and
the passing of the impugned order on 07.10.2021, without awaiting his
appearance, indicate that the opportunity of hearing was not rendered
fully effective. Further, the impugned order does not sufficiently
demonstrate an independent examination of the applicant's promotion
to DMS, his option for the Non-Ministerial cadre, the consequential
2026.11.06
PRATIK VYAS
14:02:28+05'30'

: 33: OA No.120/403/2021

alteration of his service position and the basis for retrospective pay
fixation.
14. We are, therefore, of the considered view that the matter warrants
reconsideration by the competent authority, rather than outright
restoration of all the promotions claimed by the applicant. Such a
course would balance the applicant's right to a fair consideration of his
service claims with the respondents' legitimate authority to correct
erroneous promotions in accordance with the applicable rules.
15. Accordingly, we deem it appropriate to set aside the impugned Office
Order dated 07.10.2021 and remit the matter to the competent
authority at Headquarters for fresh consideration.
16. The competent authority shall, while reconsidering the matter:
(i) examine the applicant's eligibility and entitlement to promotion
to the posts of Senior Clerk and Office Superintendent, keeping
in view the condition of passing the typing test, the result of the
additional typing test conducted pursuant to the Tribunal's order
dated 15.02.2017 and the applicable Railway rules;
(ii) examine independently the applicant's promotion to the post of
Depot Material Superintendent, including his option for the
Non-Ministerial cadre, the relevant panel, the approval accorded
by Headquarters and the applicability of the provisions
governing consequential promotions;
(iii) determine whether the promotions in question were erroneous
within the meaning of Paragraph 228 of the IREM and Rule
1326 of the Railway Establishment Code, and ensure that the
decision is taken by the competent authority prescribed therein;
(iv) consider the applicant's reply dated 06.09.2021, subsequent
representation dated 01.10.2021 and the relevant material placed
on record, including his claim concerning the treatment of
similarly situated employees;
2026.11.06
PRATIK VYAS
14:02:28+05'30'

: 34: OA No.120/403/2021

(v) afford the applicant an effective opportunity of personal hearing,
if he so desires, before passing a fresh order; and
(vi) determine the consequential issues relating to his service
position, seniority, pay fixation and promotional avenues in
accordance with the applicable rules and the findings recorded.
17. The aforesaid exercise shall be completed by the competent authority
by passing a reasoned and speaking order within a period of three
months from the date of receipt of a certified copy of this order.
18. In the circumstances, the Original Application is partly allowed to the
extent as indicated above.
19. There shall be no order as to costs.

(Sanjiv Kumar) (Jayesh V. Bhairavia)
Member (A) Member (J)



/pv/
2026.11.06
PRATIK VYAS
14:02:28+05'30'