The State Of Bihar vs Nandeshwar Kumar
- Court
- Supreme Court
2026 INSC 1094
NON-REPORTABLE
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
CIVIL APPEAL NO.13079 OF 2026
(@SLP (CIVIL) NO. 33783 OF 2026)
THE STATE OF BIHAR AND ORS. ...APPELLANTS
VERSUS
NANDESHWAR KUMAR …RESPONDENT
J U D G M E N T
SHEEL NAGU, J.
1. This civil appeal assails the Division Bench order
of High Court of Judicature at Patna rendered in LPA
No.669 of 2022, arising out of Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case
No.14676 of 2022.
1.1 The Division Bench in LPA No.669 of 2022 has
reversed the order of the Single Bench rendered in CWJ
Case No.14676 of 2022 and directed the respondent herein
to be reinstated with all consequential benefits including
monetary, to be granted within four months.
Signature Not Verified
Digitally signed by
JATINDER KAUR
Date: 2026.10.07
17:48:35 IST
Reason:
Page 1 of 11
2. The factual matrix involved herein are, for
convenience, reproduced in tabular illustration
chronologically: -
Date Events
02.01.1995 Respondent is issued Senior Teacher
Training Certificate by Dr. B. C. Roy
College of Education, Calcutta.
01.07.1995 NCTE Act is made effective.
11.09.2007 The respondent on the strength of the said
certificate is appointed as Trained Block
Teacher under the Bihar Panchayat
Elementary Teacher (Employment and
Service Conditions) Rules, 2006.
31.10.2015 The District Programme Officer finds
certificate of respondent to be issued by an
unrecognized institution.
26.11.2015 Consequently, a show-cause notice is
issued to the respondent along with three
others to explain as to why services be not
terminated.
28.11.2015 Respondent responds by submitting that
educational qualification was obtained
much before the NCTE Act came into effect
and also that the certificate obtained was
from Dr. B. C. Roy College of Education,
Calcutta which was registered as a society
Page 2 of 11
under the West Bengal Societies
Registration Act, 1961 and also that
another candidate by the name Vinod
Kumar son of Jageshwar Das., who had
obtained certificate from the same college
continues to serve as Trained Block
Teacher.
02.12.2015 Respondent suffers termination of service
owing to the said certificate having been
issued by an unrecognized institution.
11.01.2016 On respondent filing CWJ Case No.19322
of 2015 the High Court disposed of the
same without entering into merits by
relegating the respondent to avail remedy
before the District Teacher Appellate
Authority.
20.02.2016 The District Teacher Appellate Authority
set aside the termination and directed for
reinstatement with all consequential
benefits.
16.09.2022 State Appellate Authority reversed the
finding and order of the District Teacher
Appellate Authority by holding thus;
(i) In view of the finding rendered in
order dated 14.09.2012 in LPA No.244 of
2011 whereby Dr. B. C. Roy College of
Education, Calcutta was found neither
Page 3 of 11
recognized by NCTE nor by Government
of Bihar;
(ii) Reliance was also placed on an earlier
decision rendered on 30.03.2005 in LPA
No.235 of 2004 by the Division Bench of
Jharkhand High Court which had the
occasion to assess the legality and
validity of the certificates issued by nine
institutes including Dr. B. C. Roy College
of Education, Calcutta. However, in the
absence of any assistance from the rival
parties, the Division Bench in LPA
No.235 of 2004, embarked upon a self-
assessing exercise to adjudge the legality
of certificate issued by these nine
institutes. This exercise led to the
recording of following observations: -
(a) The formats of certificates
issued by all the nine institutes
including Dr. B. C. Roy College of
Education, Calcutta were same.
(b) Signatures of Principal of all
institutes were same.
(c) Signature of examiner in 4-5
institutes were common.
(d) The address of some of the
institutes were common.
Page 4 of 11
(e) Dr. B. C. Roy College of
Education, Calcutta was found to
exist on paper.
Thus, on the basis of above
observations, the Division Bench in LPA
No.235 of 2004, declined relief of
appointment to various appellants
(selected candidates) by upholding the
decision of the State Government and the
Single Bench dated 04.03.2004,
challenged before Division Bench.
10.11.2022 Aggrieved, the respondent herein
Nandeshwar Kumar, one of the terminated
Trained Block Teachers unsuccessfully
approached the Single Bench of High Court
of Judicature at Patna in CWJC No.14676
of 2022.
2022 Respondent feeling aggrieved preferred
LPA No.669 of 2022 assailing the order of
Single Bench dated 10.11.2022.
08.07.2025 LPA No.669 of 2022 was allowed reversing
the order and findings of Single Bench and
directing the respondent to be reinstated
with all consequential benefits after finding
thus: -
“ 4 …… Reading of the paragraph Nos.5 and
8 of the aforementioned decision, it is
squarely covered in favour of the appellant,
the same has not been apprised by the
Page 5 of 11
learned Single Judge and so also not
apprising the fact that appellant was in
possession of senior teacher training
certificate on 09.01.1995 and NCTE Act,
1993 which is in vogue with effect from
01.07.1995 has no application to the case
in hand. Further, in order to ascertain
whether Dr. B.C. Roy College of Education,
Calcutta, State of West Bengal is recognized
or not recognized, to that effect there is no
material information and that too from the
competent authority of the State of West
Bengal. The State has also not ascertained
from the State of West Bengal whether Dr.
B. C. Roy College of Education, Calcutta,
State of West Bengal is a genuine institution
and other correspondence so as to contend
that the appellant is not in possession of
valid teacher training certificate. These are
all the issues which have not been
adjudicated by the learned Single Judge,
therefore, appellant has made out a case so
as to interfere with the order of learned
Single Judge dated 10.11.2022 passed in
CWJC No.14676 and the impugned order
dated 16.09.2022 before the learned Single
Judge are set aside.”
2025 Aggrieved by the order and judgment in
LPA No.669 of 2022, the State of Bihar is
before this Court in the instant Civil
Appeal.
3. In the backdrop of aforesaid factual matrix, it is
palpable that on two occasions when the case came up for
assessing the legality and validity of the certificates issued
by various institutes including that of Dr. B. C. Roy College
Page 6 of 11
of Education, Calcutta, the High Court indulged in self-
assessment owing to want of assistance rendered by either
of the parties. In the first instance, the exercise of self-
assessment was undertaken while deciding LPA No.235 of
2004 judgment dated 30.03.2005 (vide Annexure P-16,
page no.64 of Rejoinder of appellant-State of Bihar). The
second time the self-assessment exercise was undertaken
by the Court in the impugned order, which is evident from
the above extracted para 4 of impugned order.
3.1 From the aforesaid discussion, it is obvious that in
the absence of any assistance extended by the rival parties
at both the stages of adjudication of LPA No.235 of 2004
and LPA No.244 of 2011, the High Court did not have
cogent material to come to a conclusive finding as to
whether the certificates issued by Dr. B. C. Roy College of
Education, Calcutta were fake or not.
3.2 It is for this reason that the Apex Court in Seema
1
Kumari & Ors. vs. State of Jharkhand & Ors. , set
aside the observations and findings made by Jharkhand
High Court in LPA No.235 of 2004, by expressing doubt as
1
(2006) 12 SCC 215
Page 7 of 11
to the genuineness of the institutions including Dr. B. C.
Roy College of Education.
3.3 We were inclined in this judgment to take a
different course, but there is an aspect which glares in the
face and is palpable enough to dissuade us from doing so.
The respondent was appointed on 11.09.2007 as Trained
Block Teacher, when he did not have the requisite and
statutory qualification in terms of Bihar Panchayat
Elementary Teacher (Employment and Service Conditions)
Rules, 2006, in particular Rule 8(a), which for ready
reference and convenience is reproduced below in toto:-
“Rule – 8. For appointment :
(a) Eligibility
For Block Teacher: -
(i) Should be a citizen of India and a resident of the
state of Bihar.
(ii) Must have passed Higher Secondary or
Intermediate or equivalent examination from a
government recognized educational institution.
(iii) Two-year teacher training, diploma or certificate
from a training institute recognized by the
National Council for Teacher Education
(N.C.T.E.) or Graduate in Elementary Education
(B.L. Ed.) Or B. Ed or equivalent qualification.
Minimum two years certificate (C.P.Ed) or equivalent
qualification for physical education teacher.
But under this rule, in the first employment, those
candidates can also be employed who have passed
matriculation or equivalent examination from a
government recognized school and obtained two years
of teacher training examination / B.Ed./2 years
certificate of physical training (CP Ed) from a
Page 8 of 11
recognized training school or recognized college before
the National Council for Teacher Education (N.C.T.E.)
Act came into force.”
3.4 From the aforesaid statutory 2006 Rules, the
respondent at the time of his appointment (i.e. 11.09.2007)
was though holding a certificate but the same was not
recognized by the National Council for Teacher Education
(N.C.T.E.). It is not disputed that the 2006 Rules were
invoked when the respondent was appointed. It is also not
disputed by the respondent that the certificate issued by
Dr. B. C. Roy College of Education, Calcutta (Annexure P-
1, at page No.31 of the SLP) was not recognized by
N.C.T.E., for the obvious reason that the N.C.T.E. Act,
1995 had not come into being on the date of issuance of
the said certificate which was issued as early as in January
1995.
3.5 The N.C.T.E. Act came into force from 01.07.1995
which impelled the State of Bihar to frame the 2006 Rules
stipulating that diploma/certificate ought to have been
issued by a training institute recognized by N.C.T.E.
3.6 Thus, on the date of appointment as Trained Block
Teacher i.e., 11.09.2007, respondent was not eligible as
Page 9 of 11
per 2006 Rules, for not having obtained certificate from an
institute recognized by N.C.T.E.
4. A bare perusal of the impugned order of Division
Bench reveals that the Division Bench fell into error by
holding that N.C.T.E. Act had no application to the case of
respondent since the N.C.T.E. norms would only be
applicable prospectively w.e.f. 01.07.1995 and not prior
thereto.
4.1 This view taken in the impugned order is
misplaced, inasmuch as, the eligibility of a candidate for
appointment to any public office is seen on the last date of
submission of application forms or at best latest by the
date of appointment, which clearly stipulated that the
same is being offered to respondent in terms of Bihar
Panchayat Elementary Teacher (Employment and Service
Conditions) Rules, 2006. It goes without saying that as
mentioned above, the eligibility of becoming a Trained
Block Teacher was diploma/certificate from an institute
recognized by N.C.T.E., which the respondent at the
relevant point of time did not possess.
Page 10 of 11
4.2 Be that as it may, we are of the considered opinion
that the candidature of respondent could not have been
considered as eligible under the 2006 Rules at the time of
his appointment in 2007. Having held so, we feel that the
impugned order of Division Bench rendered in LPA No.669
of 2022 by the High Court of Judicature at Patna deserves
to be and is accordingly set aside.
5. Consequently, the present Civil Appeal No.13079
of 2026 filed by the State of Bihar stands allowed and the
LPA No.669 of 2022 of respondent stands dismissed.
……………………………...J.
(DIPANKAR DATTA)
…...………………………...J.
(SHEEL NAGU)
NEW DELHI;
OCTOBER 07, 2026
Page 11 of 11