Ratandas S/O Murlidas (Decd.) Lrs Maheshdas Through Lrs Maheshdas S/O Ratandas Bairagi vs The State Of Madhya Pradesh Through The Collector
- Court
- Madhya Pradesh High Court
-1-
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-IND:24093
First Appeal No. 59/1968
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
AT INDORE
BEFORE
HON’BLE SHRI JUSTICE VINAY SARAF
FIRST APPEAL No. 59 of 1968
RATANDAS S/O MURLIDAS (DECD.) LRS MAHESHDAS
THROUGH LRS MAHESHDAS S/O RATANDAS BAIRAGI
Versus
THE STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH THROUGH THE COLLECTOR
AND OTHERS
Appearance:
Shri Rishiraj Trivedi - Advocate for the appellant.
Shri Anshul Rajpurohit – Government Advocate for the respondent
no. 1 /State.
Shri Veer Kumar Jain, learned Senior Advocate with Shri Makbool
Ahmad Mansoori - Advocate for the respondent [LRs of Res. No.7]
Judgment reserved on : 21.08.2026
Judgment pronounced on : 25.08.2026
JUDGMENT
1. This First Appeal has been filed by the original plaintiff on
03.10.1968 impugning the judgment and decree dated 28.06.1968
passed by Additional Judge to the Court of District Judge, Ujjain in
Civil Original suit No. 22/1954 (New No. 11A/1968), whereby the
suit filed by the appellant on 24.12.1954 for the relief of declaration
and perpetual injunction was dismissed.
PLAINT AVERMENTS (in short) :
2. The original plaintiff Ratandas S/o Murlidas Bairagi filed the
suit on 24.12.1954, seeking the decree of declaration and perpetual
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: TRILOK SINGH
SAVNER
Signing time: 25-08-2026
12:12:46
-2-
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-IND:24093
First Appeal No. 59/1968
injunction against the State of Madhya Pradesh through Collector
and the private respondents in their personal capacity and as
representatives of Maheshwari Community (Samaj) stating that a
temple known as Shree Ram Mandir having the idol of Shreeramji
and other Gods has been established by Baba Mayaramdasji in
Samvad 1584, which is situated in town Khachrod, District Ujjain
and as per the lineage customs, grandfather of the plaintiff Mahant
Shri Gopaldasji was managing the temple and the attached movable
and immovable properties of the temple and performing the duties
of a priest (pujari).
3.
After the death of Mahant Shri Gopaldasji his disciple Shri
Murlidasji, the father of the plaintiff had taken over the charge of
seat of Mahant of Shreeram Temple, Rammohalla, Khachrod and
started managing the temple and its movable and immovable
properties attached to the temple and was performing the duties of
priest (pujari). As per the plaintiff Shri Mayaramdas established the
temple Shree Ram Mandir, who was the ancestor of the plaintiff.
4. It is alleged that some members of the Maheshwari
community were the devotees of the temple and used to visit at the
temple frequently. By taking undue advantage of the old age of the
Mahant Gopaldasji, the devotees of Maheshwari community
(Samaj) by practicing fraud and under active confidence of Mahant
Gopaldasji, got executed a will by Mahant Gopaldasji in favour of
the Panchans of Maheshwari Samaj, which is illegal and invalid.
Mahant Gopaldasji was not competent to transfer the management
of the temple by way of execution of a will and therefore the
alleged will is null and void ab-initio and was never acted upon.
5. After the death of Mahant Gopaldasji, Mahant Murlidas being
the disciple of Mahant Gopaldas and son, became the successor of
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: TRILOK SINGH
SAVNER
Signing time: 25-08-2026
12:12:46
-3-
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-IND:24093
First Appeal No. 59/1968
the Gaadi and started managing the temple and the properties
attached to the temple, however, during the life time of Mahant
Murlidasji some influential persons of Maheshwari Samaj
especially original defendant No. 2 Onkarlal and defendant No. 3
Mishrilal started unnecessary interference in the possession and
management of the temple and its properties. Facing day to day
problem due to unwanted interference of the defendants No. 2 and
3, Mahant Murlidas applied to Auqaf Department with a prayer to
take over the temple and the properties attached to the temple under
the protection and management of the State and consequently by
order dated 15.10.1930 passed by Home Member of the Auqaf
Department, the management and control of Shreeram Temple and
its properties were taken over by the Auqaf Department under the
supervision of the State.
6. On 5.11.1930, the Tehsildar, Khachrod appointed Mahant
Murlidas as Priest (pujari) in the said temple and authorized to
manage the temple and the properties attached to the temple on
behalf of Auqaf Department. Mahant Murlidas continued to perform
the duties of priest in the temple and managing the properties
attached to the temple during his life time till his death in the year
1937.
7. The plaintiff and his three brothers Narayandas, Ramdas and
Kanhaiyalal were found eligible for performing the duties of the
priest, however, two other brothers Dayaldas and Manohardas were
not found fit, as they were convicted in criminal case earlier. The
representatives of Ascetic (Sadhus) (Panchan Sadhwan) decided
that the plaintiff Ratandas will be the successor of Mahant Murlidas
and priest of the temple to perform the duties as pujari and manage
the properties attached to the temple. Consequently, Bhekh
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: TRILOK SINGH
SAVNER
Signing time: 25-08-2026
12:12:46
-4-
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-IND:24093
First Appeal No. 59/1968
customary ceremony was performed and the plaintiff was appointed
as Mahant of the Gaadi . Thereafter, the plaintiff applied to Auqaf
Department of the Pargana Khachrod and Auqaf Department by
order dated 06.02.1948 accepted the proposal and appointed the
plaintiff as priest with an authority to manage the properties
attached to the temple. Manohardas and Dayaldas, those who were
not considered eligible due to their conviction, filed their objection
upon the appointment of plaintiff before Standing Committee of
erstwhile Gwalior State, which was rejected and the appointment of
the plaintiff was maintained and since then the plaintiff started
performing the duties of priest and managing the properties of the
temple.
8. By way of amendment, it is incorporated by the plaintiff that
the temple belongs to Ramanand Sect and attached with Shri
Digambar Akhada and, therefore, as per the customs of Ramanand
Sect, the Mahant or priest of the temple has no authority, right or
power to transfer the management of the temple and its properties to
someone else and, therefore, Mahant Gopaldas was not competent
to transfer the management of the temple through will to the
members of Maheshwari Community and the will executed by
Mahant Gopaldas was invalid and void ab initio being contrary to
Ramanand Sect.
9. The plaintiff further incorporated the averment that the priest
of the Shreeram Temple of Khachrod considered as Mahant and
belongs to Bairagi community and the ascetic of the Ramanand Sect
collectively decided the successor of the sect Mahant and the Priest
for the temple by performing the customs. Once the ascetic of
Bairagi community of Ramanand Sect decides the successor, the
State also issued the certificate accordingly. After the death of
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: TRILOK SINGH
SAVNER
Signing time: 25-08-2026
12:12:46
-5-
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-IND:24093
First Appeal No. 59/1968
Mahant Murlidas, ascetics (sadhus) collectively decided and
appointed plaintiff as new priest of the temple for worship as well
as maintaining the properties attached to the temple.
10. The plaintiff further pleaded that after the appointment of the
plaintiff by the State, the Commissioner Jaagir by order dated
06.02.1948 permitted the plaintiff to manage the temple and the
properties and handed over the possession of the temple and
properties on 12.09.1948. After taking over the charge of priest on
12.09.1948 the plaintiff started performing the duties of priest. On
27.09.1948 President of Auqaf Committee further permitted the
plaintiff to deal with the offerings.
11. After getting the knowledge of the appointment of the
plaintiff, the defendants No. 2 and 3 and some other members of the
Maheshwari Community started interference in the management of
the temple and stopped the plaintiff from operating the bank
account and thereafter on 28.11.1948, the plaintiff filed an
application before President, Auqaf Committee cum Tehsildar,
Paragana, Khachrod for payment of monthly honorarium. At the
behest of the members of Maheshwari Community, one Ranchod
complained to the President of Auqaf Department that plaintiff is
not performing the puja and the charge of the temple be given to the
priest appointed by defendant No. 3 Mishrilal and thereafter
defendant No. 3 and the priest appointed by him with the help of
police on the basis of an order passed by President Auqaf tried to
take over the possession of the temple from the plaintiff on
07.12.1948, however, the plaintiff stopped them.
12. The plaintiff filed an appeal before the Collector, District
Ujjain assailing the order dated 07.12.1948 passed by Tehsildar cum
President, Auqaf Committee, Khachrod, whereby he permitted the
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: TRILOK SINGH
SAVNER
Signing time: 25-08-2026
12:12:46
-6-
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-IND:24093
First Appeal No. 59/1968
priest appointed by respondent No. 3 to perform the duties of
priest, however the Collector stayed the order on 13.12.1948. The
stay order was duly served upon the President, Pargana Auqaf
Committee, Khachrod. Thereafter, the defendants No. 2 and 3 along
with some other persons of Maheshwari community challenged the
order of Collector dated 13.12.1948 before the Commissioner and
obtained ex-parte order from Commissioner, Jaagiri and Inaam on
24.12.1948, by which it was directed to the plaintiff to handover all
the movable and immovable properties of the temple to the
President of Auqaf Committee, Pargana, Khachrod.
13.
In the year 1951 the President Pargana Committee, Auqaf cum
Tehsildar started auctioning the rooms situated in the northern
portion of the temple and south east portion of the temple for the
purpose of letting out, whereas the Tehsildar had no authority to
auction the rooms. The Tehsildar started accepting the rent and also
had taken into custody a community hall named ‘house for marriage
purpose’ in his custody. Rest of all movable and immovable
properties continued in the possession of the plaintiff and plaintiff
also continued to perform the duties of priest and managing the
temple.
14. As per the plaintiff, Shriram Mandir, Kachrod is receiving
annual grant (‘Nemnuk’) from the Auqaf department and the
income from the rent of the rooms situated in the campus is also
being used for the purpose of managing the temple. The plaintiff
claimed that the possession of the President of Auqaf Committee
over the community hall and rooms are constructive possession on
behalf of the plaintiff. The plaintiff issued a notice through his
lawyer on 11.04.1953 to the Collector and State, which was replied
on behalf of North Central, Maal Vibhaag of Government of India
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: TRILOK SINGH
SAVNER
Signing time: 25-08-2026
12:12:46
-7-
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-IND:24093
First Appeal No. 59/1968
on 27.11.1953 and it was informed to the plaintiff that the
department is ready to handover the possession to the plaintiff, but
the representatives of Maheshwari community and others have
raised objection therefore, it was directed that the parties should
approach to the competent court for deciding their rights.
15. Thereafter the plaintiff filed the subject suit seeking relief of
declaration that the plaintiff is entitled to manage the Shreeram
Mandir, Khachrod and the properties attached with the temple. The
plaintiff is also entitled for taking the possession of all the
properties of the temple and further declaration that Maheshwari
community or defendant Nos. 2 and 3 have no right, title or interest
in the management of the temple or over the properties of the
temple. The plaintiff also sought for decree of declaration to declare
that all the orders issued after 12.09.1948 are without jurisdiction,
illegal and not binding on the plaintiff. The plaintiff prayed for
perpetual injunction against the defendant Nos. 2 and 3 from
interfering in the management of Shriram temple, Khachrod and the
movable and immovable property attached to the temple.
PLEADINGS OF DEFENDANT NO. 1/ STATE:
16. Defendant No.1 i.e. State of M.P. through Collector filed the
written statement and pleaded that the existence of Shree Ram
Mandir in the town Khachrod is admitted, however it is not
admitted that Baba Mayaramdas established the temple. As per the
record this temple belongs to Maheshwari Community and the
claim of the plaintiff that family of the plaintiff is performing the
duties of priest as per the lineage tradition, is not acceptable. The
State accepted that Late Gopaldas and Murlidas were priest of the
temple, however it is denied in the absence of knowledge that
Murlidas was the son of Gopaldas. It is stated that as per the
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: TRILOK SINGH
SAVNER
Signing time: 25-08-2026
12:12:46
-8-
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-IND:24093
First Appeal No. 59/1968
knowledge Mayaramdas and Gopaldas were ascetics and Nihang
( Nihang means a person who follows the discipline and remain
unmarried for the purpose of religious services ), therefore, plaintiff
cannot claim that he is the lineage of them.
17. It is stated that the members of the Maheshwari community
are the devotees of the temple and participated in the management
of the temple since long. The knowledge of the State that Gopaldas
had executed a will bequeathing the authority to manage the temple
to the Panch of Maheshwari community was also pleaded by the
State. It is denied that the will was got executed by practicing fraud
with Gopaldas and under active confidence and the will is illegal
and void.
18. It is pleaded that Murlidas was appointed by the Auqaf
Department on payment of annual grant (Nemnuk), however the
said appointment had no effect on the validity of the will and he
was appointed only on the post of priest. It is admitted that Murlidas
during his lifetime approached to the Auqaf Depatment for taking
the temple in their control and by order dated 15.10.1930 the
management of the Shree Ram Mandir, Khachrod and the properties
attached to the temple were taken in the supervision of Auqaf
Department and after the death of Murlidas in the year 1937, the
appointment of the plaintiff was recommended by the ascetics
considering the plaintiff as Nihang , which was accepted and it is
pleaded that the plaintiff was appointed on annual grant ( Nemnuk )
and a certificate was also issued in his favour. However, later on it
came to the knowledge that plaintiff has performed the marriage
and lost the status of Nihang . Consequently he lost the right to
perform the Pooja at temple. The appointment of plaintiff as priest
was admitted by the State, however it is submitted that the temple
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: TRILOK SINGH
SAVNER
Signing time: 25-08-2026
12:12:46
-9-
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-IND:24093
First Appeal No. 59/1968
and the properties attached to the temple were taken into control
and supervision of the Auqaf Department.
19. The State further pleaded that upon the request of the
representatives of Maheshwari community and upon receipt of the
complaint against the plaintiff on 06.02.1948, the Auqaf
Department had taken the possession of the temple under its
control. However, it is accepted that on 12.09.1948 the possession
of the temple and its properties were handed over to the plaintiff. It
is stated that when the appointment of the plaintiff was set aside by
Commissioner, Jagir, the possession of the temple was again taken
into custody on 29.09.1948. All these proceedings were carried out
at the behest of the representatives of Maheshwari community and
in compliance of the order passed by the Collector, Ujjain,
Commissioner, Jagir and Revenue Department of erstwhile Gwalior
State.
20. The State pleaded that though the plaintiff is performing the
duties of priest, however he is not having any title or interest in the
temple and he is only a licensee of the Auqaf Department. The
committee has already resumed the possession of the rooms and
community hall and is managing the same for the purpose of letting
out on rent. The State denied the other plaint allegations and
submitted that the plaintiff has no right to manage the movable and
immovable properties of the temple and he can only perform the
Pooja as priest appointed by Auqaf Department on annual grant
( Nemnuk ). The State prays for dismissal of the suit and raised the
objection that the reliefs have not been valued properly and proper
court fee has not been paid by the plaintiff. The objection of the
maintainability of the suit was raised on the ground that the
properties are in possession of Auqaf Department and, therefore, the
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: TRILOK SINGH
SAVNER
Signing time: 25-08-2026
12:12:46
-10-
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-IND:24093
First Appeal No. 59/1968
suit for mere relief of declaration is not maintainable.
21. It is pleaded by the State that the members of the Maheshwari
community have invested money in renovation of the temple, and
the community hall and rooms were constructed by members of
Maheshwari community from their funds, therefore, plaintiff has no
right to manage those immovable properties and plaintiff can claim
only the right to perform the duties of priest under the supervision
of Auqaf Department. Prayer was made for dismissal of the suit.
PLEADINGS OF DEFENDANT No. 2 & 3:
22. The defendants No. 2 & 3 in their personal capacity and being
representatives of Maheshwari community filed the written
statement and denied the plaint allegations in toto. It is denied by
them that the temple was established by Baba Mayaramdas. They
claimed that this temple is an ancient temple of Maheshwari
community, built and established by the community and Gopaldas
and Murlidas were appointed as priest in the temple for the purpose
of performing Pooja. Murlidas was not the son of Gopaldas and
plaintiff is not the lineage of Mayaramdas. Mayaramdas and
Gopaldas both were ascetics and Nihang.
23. The members of Maheshwari community are the devotees of
the temple and used to visit to the temple daily. They denied that the
will was got executed by the members of the community from
Gopaldas by practicing fraud and under active confidence. It is
pleaded that the will was a valid and genuine will and it was duly
acted upon. Only by appointment of Murlidas as priest in the
temple, the effect of the will cannot be disregarded. When the
representatives of the Maheshwari community raised the objection
towards the mismanagement of temple by Murlidas, he malafidely
submitted an application before the Auqaf Department for taking
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: TRILOK SINGH
SAVNER
Signing time: 25-08-2026
12:12:46
-11-
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-IND:24093
First Appeal No. 59/1968
the temple in their control.
24. As per the defendant Nos. 2 & 3, the ascetics of Ramanand
recommended the plaintiff for appointment as priest, as the plaintiff
was Nihang at that time. Murlidas executed an agreement in favour
of the defendant Nos. 2 & 3 and as per the terms of the agreement,
the plaintiff is not entitled for appointment on the post of priest of
the temple and his conduct was not in conformity with the act of the
priest, therefore, after the death of Murlidas in the year 1937 and
considering the misconduct of the plaintiff, the Maheshwari
community applied to the Auqaf Department to permit the priest
appointed by Maheshwari community to perform the Pooja. If any
order is passed by the Commissioner, Jagir, the same was ultra vires
and without jurisdiction as the Commissioner, Jagir had no right to
appoint the priest of subject temple, without deciding the
application submitted by them and by order dated 12.09.1948 the
plaintiff was permitted to manage the temple, which was opposed
by the defendants.
25. The plaintiff had no authority to operate the bank account and
deal with the amount already deposited in the bank and if any
permission was granted by the President, Auqaf committee, the
same was without jurisdiction. The plaintiff had no authority to
operate bank account and, therefore, around 29.09.1948 the
defendant No. 2 and 3 made a request to the bank to stop the
operation of the bank account by the plaintiff. As the plaintiff was
not performing the duties properly, the members of the Maheshwari
community opposed the same and made the complaints to the Auqaf
Department. After considering all the complaints, on 07.12.1948 the
President of Auqaf Committee permitted the priest appointed by
defendant No. 3 to perform the Pooja and plaintiff illegally tried to
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: TRILOK SINGH
SAVNER
Signing time: 25-08-2026
12:12:46
-12-
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-IND:24093
First Appeal No. 59/1968
interfere in the order passed by the Auqaf committee and without
any knowledge of the defendants obtained the stay order. However,
no right, title or interest accrued to the plaintiff on the strength of
the stay order and the plaintiff is not in possession of any of the
properties of the temple. He is only performing the duties of a priest
and residing in the residential premises attached to the temple,
wherein the priest is permitted to reside. He is a servant or licensee.
26. The rooms and the community hall for marriage functions
were since beginning in the possession of the Auqaf Committee and
are managed by Tehsildar. Plaintiff is getting Rs. 270/- per year as
annual grant ( Nemnuk) and he is a servant of Auqaf Committee. The
possession of the Tehsildar is not constructive possession and he is
not custodia legis . The members of the Maheshwari community
have invested huge amounts in the temple and developed the temple
campus and they are entitled to remove the priest from his post and
as the plaintiff has challenged the rights of defendant Nos. 2 & 3, he
is not entitled to continue as priest. The plaint is completely vague
and is not maintainable. The suit has been filed against the
defendant Nos. 2 and 3 in their representative capacity, which is
also not maintainable. The plaintiff has not paid the advalorem
court fee as per the valuation of the rooms and community hall and
consequently the suit is liable to be dismissed due to improper
valuation and nonpayment of proper court fee.
27. The defendant Nos. 2 and 3 pleaded that earlier also the
plaintiff filed a suit for declaration in respect of the same temple
and made the similar allegations in the suit, which was filed in the
Court of Civil Judge, Khachrod registered as COS No. 261-A/1951,
which ultimately dismissed due to the absence of plaintiff and his
pleader. Thereafter the plaintiff filed an application for restoration
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: TRILOK SINGH
SAVNER
Signing time: 25-08-2026
12:12:46
-13-
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-IND:24093
First Appeal No. 59/1968
of the suit, which was also dismissed and plaintiff has not
challenged the said order before any higher court, therefore, the
same has attained finality and thus the suit filed by the plaintiff is
not maintainable.
28. It is submitted that the plaintiff is claiming the rights through
Gopaldas and Murlidas, whereas Gopaldas and Murlidas during
their lifetime on 19.12.1907 and on 28.04.1919 respectively
accepted that the temple belongs to the Maheshwari community
and, therefore, the plaintiff has no right. The appointment of
plaintiff as priest was accepted by the Maheshwari community,
subject to the condition that they may appoint any other priest, if
occasion arises. The declaration of Gopaldas and Murlidas are
binding on the plaintiff and on the basis of the declaration of
Gopaldas and Murlidas, the Maheshwari community has spent
approx. Rs.70,000/- for raising construction in the temple
compound.
29. In alternate, it is pleaded that if any lineage customs are
proved, even then the plaintiff will not get any benefit of it, as the
Gopaldas and Murlidas have already waived their rights and now
the plaintiff cannot assert the same. Both of them have already
accepted the rights of the Maheshwari community. If the plaintiff is
appointed as Manager of the temple, the properties of the temple
will be misappropriated by the plaintiff, as he is incompetent to
perform the duties of manager and priest. He cannot be appointed
against the orders of Auqaf committee. He is not a Nihang . The
authority to appoint the priest is with the Maheshwari community
and they do not want to appoint the plaintiff as priest of the temple.
Therefore, no relief can be granted to the plaintiff.
30. The mother of the plaintiff was not the legally wedded wife of
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: TRILOK SINGH
SAVNER
Signing time: 25-08-2026
12:12:46
-14-
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-IND:24093
First Appeal No. 59/1968
Mahant Murlidas and, therefore, plaintiff has no authority to claim
the rights on the basis of alleged lineage custom. The defendant
pleaded that as the plaintiff has not impleaded his brothers as party
in the suit, the suit is liable to be dismissed due to non-joinder of the
necessary parties. It is stated that the Maheshwari community wants
that the temple be remained under the supervision of Auqaf
committee and earlier Murlidas had also applied for the same.
Therefore, the plaintiff cannot claim any independent rights. The
simplicitor suit for mere declaration is not maintainable. The
possession of Maheshwari community is since 1907 and, therefore,
the suit is time barred.
31. During the pendency of the suit, the defendant Nos. 2 and 3
died and were substituted by their legal representatives. After
coming on record, the legal representatives of deceased-defendant
Nos. 2 & 3 filed separate written statements and denied the plaint
allegation in toto. Some additional objections were raised in respect
of the maintainability of the suit on the ground that the subject
temple is an open temple for all the persons and, therefore, amounts
to a public trust and as per Section 32 of M.P. Public Trust Act, the
suit is not maintainable.
ISSUES SETTLED BY THE TRIAL COURT :
32. On the basis of the averments of the parties, the Trial Court
framed the following issues:
1. Whether the temple was originally established by Baba
Mayaramdas and belongs to Romanandi sect of Bairagis?
2. (a) Whether there is a Gadi of Mahant associated with this
temple?
(b) Whether it is the seat of Nihangas only?
(c) Whether the plaintiff is the son of Murlidas?
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: TRILOK SINGH
SAVNER
Signing time: 25-08-2026
12:12:46
-15-
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-IND:24093
First Appeal No. 59/1968
(d) Whether the plaintiff is entitled to continue on the seat even
after his marriage?
3. (a) Whether the plaintiff is simply a Pujari and lives in the
temple as licensee and employee of the trust?
(b) Whether the plaintiff has forfeited his right to continue as
Pujari due to his misconduct?
(c) Whether Maheshwari Samaj has a right to terminate his
services?
4. (a) Whether the succession to the office of Mahant is
customarily recognized by a Bhekh Ceremony?
(b) Whether such Bhekh ceremony was actually performed?
(c) If so, how far did it confer the rights of Mahantship upon
the plaintiff?
5. (a) Whether the execution of the Will was obtained from
Gopaldas:
(i) by fraud
(ii) by undue influence after taking him in active confidence.
(b) Whether the Will was bad because it was never acted upon?
6. (a) Whether Gopaldas transferred the trust property by Will?
(b) If so, whether he was competent to do so?
(c) Whether the Will can be challenged even after the lapse of
such a long period?
7. (a) Whether Maheshwari Samaj endowed the property to the
temple with the condition that it will be managed by Okaf
department?
(b) Whether Murlidas consented to that arrangement?
(c) Whether the plaintiff is now stopped from challenging the
rights of Maheshwari Samaj?
(d) Whether Maheshwari Samaj has a right to appoint or
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: TRILOK SINGH
SAVNER
Signing time: 25-08-2026
12:12:46
-16-
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-IND:24093
First Appeal No. 59/1968
remove the Pujari of the temple?
8. Whether the defendants No.2 to 4 have been sued in
representative capacity?
9. (a) What is the effect of release of the property in favour of the
plaintiff by the Okaf department?
(b) Whether the officer concerned had jurisdiction to rescind
that ex parte order?
10. Whether the suit is bad for non-joinder of the other brothers of
the plaintiff?
11. (a) Whether the suit is properly valued?
(b) Whether the plaintiff has paid proper Court fee?
12. Whether the suit for mere declaration is maintainable without
a prayer for consequential relief?
13. Whether the suit is barred by limitation?
14. Whether the suit is barred by Section 32 of M.P. Public Trust
Act?
15. Whether suit is barred by res-judicata or u/O2 Rule2 of CPC?
16. Relief and costs?
33. The plaintiff examined Jankidas (PW/1), Raghuwardas
(PW/2), Sawai Singh (PW/3), Narayandas (PW/4), Keshar Singh
(PW/5), Rajaram (PW/6), Komal Singh (PW/7), Nathulal (PW/8),
Shivnarayan (PW/9), Rameshwardas (PW/10), Santdas (PW/11),
Ratandas (PW/12), Narsinghdas (PW/13), Kanhaiyadas (PW/14),
Ghanshyamdas (PW/15) and Narottamdas (PW/16) in support of his
case, whereas the defendant examined Ratanlal (DW/1), Ramdas
(DW/2), Nandlal (DW/3), Thawarji (DW/4), Chandmal (DW/5),
Chunnilal (DW/6), Haridas (DW/7), Tulsiram (DW/8), Manaklal
(DW/9), Sagarmal (DW/10), Ranchhodlal (DW/11) and Kamaldas
(DW/12) in support of their case.
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: TRILOK SINGH
SAVNER
Signing time: 25-08-2026
12:12:46
-17-
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-IND:24093
First Appeal No. 59/1968
FINDINGS OF THE TRIAL COURT :
34. The learned Trial Court by judgment and decree dated
26.06.1968, dismissed the suit with cost by holding that the plaintiff
has failed to prove that the temple was originally established by
Baba Mayaramdas and belongs Ramanand Sect of Bairagis. There
is no Gadi of Mahant attached with this temple and this seat of
Priest of the temple is of Nihangs only. The Trial Court held that the
plaintiff is the son of Murlidas, however, not entitled to continue on
the seat after his marriage. The Trial Court further held that the
plaintiff is a Pujari and lives in the residential part of the temple as
licensee and is employee of the Pargana Auqaf Committee and not
having any right, title or interest in the temple and its properties.
35.
The Trial Court further held that the plaintiff misconducted
and failed to fulfill the duties of the Priest and, therefore, has
forfeited his rights to continue as Priest and the Maheshwari Samaaj
has a right to terminate his services, as he was appointed by Auqaf
Committee as Priest upon the recommendation of the Maheshwari
Samaj. The Trial Court held that there is evidence of performance
of Bhekh Ceremony, and generally speaking, such ceremony is
performed for recognizing the succession of Mahant of a Math , but
by mere performance of such ceremony and in the absence of any
conclusive proof of the fact that the temple is Math , the ceremony,
which was performed in favour of the plaintiff has no significance
in the case in hand.
36. As per Trial Court the plaintiff has failed to prove that the
Maheshwari Community got executed the Will from Gopaldas by
committing fraud or under influence after taking him in active
confidence. The Will is genuine, effective and valid. Gopaldas did
not transfer the Trust property by the Will and he was not competent
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: TRILOK SINGH
SAVNER
Signing time: 25-08-2026
12:12:46
-18-
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-IND:24093
First Appeal No. 59/1968
to transfer the Trust property as he was not the title holder of the
temple and the properties attached thereto and the Will cannot be
challenged after the lapse of long period.
37. It is also held by the Trial Court that though the Maheshwari
Community endowed the property to the temple with the condition
that it will be managed by Auqaf Department, but such endowment
was not permanent in nature and the Maheshwari Community is
entitled to manage the temple and appoint the Priest. The Trial
Court further held that the arrangement made by the Maheshwari
Community was duly consented by Mahant Murlidas and now the
plaintiff being a son of Mahant Murlidas and claiming the right
through Mahant Murlidas is stopped from challenging the rights of
Maheshwari Community and the Maheshwari Community has a
right to appoint or remove the Priest of the temple.
38. The Trial Court further held that such property was released
by the Auqaf Department in compliance of the order of
Commissioner, but the same has no effect to the merits of the case
and the Officer concerned had the jurisdiction to rescind that ex
parte order. The Trial Court held that the brothers of the plaintiff are
not proper and necessary party in the suit and as the suit for
possession has not been filed by the plaintiff, the plaintiff has
valued the suit properly and paid the proper Court fees.
39. As per the Trial Court, in the absence of seeking the relief of
possession, the suit for mere declaration is not maintainable and the
plaintiff was under obligation to seek the consequential relief. The
Trial Court further held that the suit was barred by limitation,
because the cause of action for the suit was accrued to the plaintiff
for the first time on 12.09.1948 and the suit has been filed on
25.12.1954. In view of the Trial Court, the suit is not barred by
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: TRILOK SINGH
SAVNER
Signing time: 25-08-2026
12:12:46
-19-
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-IND:24093
First Appeal No. 59/1968
Section 32 of M.P. Public Trust Act as well as by the doctrine of res
judicata or under the provisions of Order II Rule 2 of CPC. After
considering the pleadings of the parties, evidence and arguments of
the parties, the learned Trial Court by a detailed judgment,
dismissed the suit filed by the plaintiff.
40. Hence, the present appeal has been preferred by the plaintiff
with a prayer for setting aside the decree passed by the Trial Court
and decreeing the suit filed by the plaintiff.
41. Earlier this appeal was decided by learned Single Judge of this
Court vide judgment and decree dated 10.07.1993 and the appeal
was allowed after setting aside the judgment and decree passed by
the trial court.
42. Judgment dated 10.07.1993 was assailed by the respondent
Nos. 2 and 3 before the Supreme Court of India in Civil Appeal No.
157/2016, which was decided by order dated 26.02.2020 and the
appeal was allowed by setting aside the judgment and decree passed
by the learned Single Judge of this Court in this appeal on
10.07.1993 with an order of remand to this Court to decide the First
Appeal afresh on merits specifically dealing with all the issues and
contentions in accordance with law. All the contentions of the
parties are left open. As it was informed to the Supreme Court that
the appellant is in possession of the suit property pursuant to the
judgment and decree passed by learned Single Judge of this Court
on 10.07.1993, the Supreme Court ordered that the possession
would not be disturbed, but would be subject to the outcome of the
First Appeal and in case the appeal is dismissed, appropriate orders
and directions in exercise of the power of restitution and u/S.144 of
the Code of Civil Procedure would be issued and applied with.
43. In compliance of the directions issued by the Supreme Court
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: TRILOK SINGH
SAVNER
Signing time: 25-08-2026
12:12:46
-20-
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-IND:24093
First Appeal No. 59/1968
of India in Civil Appeal No. 157/2016 by order dated 26.02.2020,
with the consent of the parties, arguments heard for the purpose of
final disposal of this First Appeal afresh on merits dealing with all
the issues and contentions raised by the parties.
DISCUSSION:
44. For the purpose of deciding this first appeal, the following
question arises in this appeal for consideration:
“Whether the Trial Court has committed an error of facts or law
in passing the impugned judgment and decree dated 26.06.1968
dismissing the suit filed by the appellant / plaintiff ?”
45. It is also essential to examine the pleadings of the parties, oral
and documentary evidence adduced by the parties and relevant
provisions of law, judgments relied by the parties and the arguments
advanced by the learned counsels for the parties. In view of this
Court, for deciding the aforesaid question, first it is essential to
answer some other questions involved in the case inter alia : who
built or established the Shree Ram Mandir, Khachrod, whether any
Will was executed by Mahant Gopaldas on 19.12.1907 under
influence and active confidence of the members of Maheshwari
Community, whether the members of Maheshwari Community
borne thousands of rupees for development of the campus of Shree
Ram Temple under the impression that Mahant Gopaldas has
authorized Maheshwari Community to manage the temple, whether
Mahant Murlidas executed an agreement in favour of Maheshwari
Samaaj on 28.04.1919 and acknowledged the authority of the
Maheshwari Samaaj to manage the temple, whether Mahant
Murlidas applied to the Auqaf Department for taking the temple and
the properties under their supervision, whether the lineage of
Mahant Murlidas has lost all the alleged rights in the temple and the
properties due to execution of Will by Gopaldas and agreement by
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: TRILOK SINGH
SAVNER
Signing time: 25-08-2026
12:12:46
-21-
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-IND:24093
First Appeal No. 59/1968
Murlidas, whether after the death of Murlidas, the plaintiff was
recommended by Ascetics of Ramanand Sect and appointed
plaintiff as Mahant of the temple by performing the Bhekh
Ceremony, whether upon the recommendation of the Ascetics of
Ramanand Sect, Auqaf Committee appointed plaintiff as Priest of
the temple and authorized to manage the properties of the temple,
whether the plaintiff is entitled to perform the duties of Priest and
manage the temple and the properties attached to the temple as per
the alleged lineage tradition or customs, whether the plaintiff was
not competent to continue as Priest after performing the marriage,
whether the possession of the temple and the properties were taken
over by the Auqaf Committee and whether plaintiff was performing
the duties of Priest on the date of filing of the suit and during the
pendency of this appeal.
46. Learned Senior Advocate appearing on behalf of the
respondent no. 2 submits that as per the provisions of Order 41 Rule
22 of CPC, the respondents can challenge the finding of any issue
without filing the cross objection in the case, if the respondent is not
seeking any relief on the basis of challenging the finding. He relied
on the judgment delivered by the Supreme Court in the matter of
1
Banarsi & Ors.Vs. Ram Phal , wherein the Supreme Court has
held that if the decree is entirely in favour of the respondents
though an issue has been decided against the respondents or the
decree is entirely in favour of the respondents and all the issues
have also been answered in favour of the respondents, but there is a
finding in the judgment which goes against the respondents, the
respondents may support the decree without filing cross objection
and challenge the finding on any issue in the appeal. The relevant
1
Banarsi & Ors.Vs. Ram Phal, (2003) 9 SCC 606.
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: TRILOK SINGH
SAVNER
Signing time: 25-08-2026
12:12:46
-22-
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-IND:24093
First Appeal No. 59/1968
paragraphs reads as under:-
“10. The CPC amendment of 1976 has not
materially or substantially altered the law except
for a marginal difference. Even under the
amended Order 41 Rule 22 sub-rule (1) a party in
whose favour the decree stands in its entirety is
neither entitled nor obliged to prefer any cross-
objection. However, the insertion made in the text
of sub-rule (1) makes it permissible to file a
cross-objection against a finding. The difference
which has resulted we will shortly state. A
respondent may defend himself without filing any
cross-objection to the extent to which decree is in
his favour; however, if he proposes to attack any
part of the decree he must take cross-objection.
The amendment inserted by the 1976 amendment
is clarificatory and also enabling and this may be
made precise by analysing the provision. There
may be three situations:
(i) The impugned decree is partly in favour of the
appellant and partly in favour of the respondent.
(ii) The decree is entirely in favour of the
respondent though an issue has been decided
against the respondent.
(iii) The decree is entirely in favour of the
respondent and all the issues have also been
answered in favour of the respondent but there is
a finding in the judgment which goes against the
respondent.
11. In the type of case (i) it was necessary for the
respondent to file an appeal or take cross-
objection against that part of the decree which is
against him if he seeks to get rid of the same
though that part of the decree which is in his
favour he is entitled to support without taking any
cross-objection. The law remains so post-
amendment too. In the type of cases (ii) and (iii)
pre-amendment CPC did not entitle nor permit
the respondent to take any cross-objection as he
was not the person aggrieved by the decree.
Under the amended CPC, read in the light of the
explanation, though it is still not necessary for
the respondent to take any cross-objection laying
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: TRILOK SINGH
SAVNER
Signing time: 25-08-2026
12:12:46
-23-
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-IND:24093
First Appeal No. 59/1968
challenge to any finding adverse to him as the
decree is entirely in his favour and he may
support the decree without cross-objection; the
amendment made in the text of sub-rule (1), read
with the explanation newly inserted, gives him a
right to take cross-objection to a finding recorded
against him either while answering an issue or
while dealing with an issue. The advantage of
preferring such cross-objection is spelled out by
sub-rule (4). In spite of the original appeal
having been withdrawn or dismissed for default
the cross-objection taken to any finding by the
respondent shall still be available to be
adjudicated upon on merits which remedy was
not available to the respondent under the
unamended CPC. In the pre-amendment era, the
withdrawal or dismissal for default of the
original appeal disabled the respondent to
question the correctness or otherwise of any
finding recorded against the respondent.”
47. The learned Senior Advocate further relied on the judgment
delivered by the Supreme Court in the matter of Saurav Jain &
2
Ors. Vs. ABP Design & another , wherein the Supreme Court has
held that there is no need to challenge the adverse finding of the
lower appellate court by filing a formal memorandum of cross
objection and it can be challenged without filing the memorandum
of cross objection. The relevant paragraphs reads as under:-
“27. The effect of the amendment was considered
in Banarsi v. Ram Phal [Banarsi v. Ram Phal,
(2003) 9 SCC 606] , where this Court held that
after the 1976 Amendment, the respondent could
file cross-objections against the “findings” of the
lower court, while previously cross-objections
could only be filed when the decree of the lower
court was partly against the respondent. R.C.
Lahoti, J. (as the learned Chief Justice then was),
speaking for the two-Judge Bench observed :
2
Saurav Jain & Ors. Vs. ABP Design & another, (2022) 18 SCC 633
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: TRILOK SINGH
SAVNER
Signing time: 25-08-2026
12:12:46
-24-
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-IND:24093
First Appeal No. 59/1968
(SCC pp. 616-17, paras 10-11)
“10. … There may be three situations:
(i) The impugned decree is partly in favour of the
appellant and partly in favour of the respondent.
(ii) The decree is entirely in favour of the
respondent though an issue has been decided
against the respondent.
(iii) The decree is entirely in favour of the
respondent and all the issues have also been
answered in favour of the respondent but there is
a finding in the judgment which goes against the
respondent.
11. In the type of case (i) it was necessary for the
respondent to file an appeal or take cross-
objection against that part of the decree which is
against him if he seeks to get rid of the same
though that part of the decree which is in his
favour he is entitled to support without taking
any cross-objection. The law remains so post-
amendment too. In the type of cases (ii) and (iii)
pre-amendment CPC did not entitle nor permit
the respondent to take any cross-objection as he
was not the person aggrieved by the decree.
Under the amended CPC, read in the light of the
explanation, though it is still not necessary for
the respondent to take any cross-objection laying
challenge to any [Ed. : The words between two
asterisks has been emphasised in original as
well.] finding [Ed. : The words between two
asterisks has been emphasised in original as
well.] adverse to him as the decree is [Ed. : The
words between two asterisks has been
emphasised in original as well.] entirely in his
favour and he may support the decree without
cross-objection; the amendment made in the text
of sub-rule (1), read with the explanation newly
inserted, gives him a right to take cross-objection
to a [Ed. : The words between two asterisks has
been emphasised in original as well.] finding
recorded against him either while answering an
issue or while dealing with an issue. The
advantage of preferring such cross-objection is
spelled out by sub-rule (4). In spite of the
original appeal having been withdrawn or
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: TRILOK SINGH
SAVNER
Signing time: 25-08-2026
12:12:46
-25-
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-IND:24093
First Appeal No. 59/1968
dismissed for default the cross-objection taken to
any finding by the respondent shall still be
available to be adjudicated upon on merits which
remedy was not available to the respondent under
the unamended CPC. In the pre-amendment era,
the withdrawal or dismissal for default of the
original appeal disabled the respondent to
question the correctness or otherwise of any
finding recorded against the respondent.”
(emphasis supplied)
28. Order 41 Rule 22(2)CPC states that a “cross-
objection shall be filed in the form of a
memorandum, and the provisions of Rule 1, so far
as they relate to the form and contents of the
memorandum of appeal, shall apply thereto”. This
Court in S. Nazeer Ahmed v. State Bank of Mysore
[S. Nazeer Ahmed v. State Bank of Mysore, (2007)
11 SCC 75] elaborated on the form of objections
made under Order 41 Rule 22CPC. In Nazeer
Ahmed [S. Nazeer Ahmed v. State Bank of Mysore,
(2007) 11 SCC 75] , the respondent had filed a suit
for enforcement of an equitable mortgage. In
deciding the suit, the trial court rejected the
argument of the appellant-defendant and held that
the suit was not barred by Order 2 Rule 2CPC.
However, the court dismissed the suit on grounds of
limitation. On an appeal filed by the respondent
before the High Court, the High Court observed
[State Bank of Mysore v. S. Nazeer Ahmed, 2003
SCC OnLine Kar 928] that although the suit was
barred by Order 2 Rule 2CPC, the appellant had
not challenged this finding of the trial court by
filing a memorandum of cross-objection. Thus, the
High Court granted the respondent a decree against
the appellant. When this finding of the High Court
was assailed before this Court, P.K.
Balasubramanyam, J. held that a memorandum of
cross-objection needs to be filed while taking
recourse to Order 41 Rule 22 only when the
respondent claims a relief that had been rejected by
the trial court or seeks an additional relief apart
from that provided by the trial court. The Court
held that a memorandum of objection need not be
filed when the appellant only assailed a “finding”
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: TRILOK SINGH
SAVNER
Signing time: 25-08-2026
12:12:46
-26-
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-IND:24093
First Appeal No. 59/1968
of the lower court : (Nazeer Ahmed case [S. Nazeer
Ahmed v. State Bank of Mysore, (2007) 11 SCC 75]
, SCC p. 80, para 7)
“7. The High Court, in our view, was clearly in
error in holding that the appellant not having
filed a memorandum of cross-objections in
terms of Order 41 Rule 22 of the Code, could
not challenge the finding of the trial court that
the suit was not barred by Order 2 Rule 2 of the
Code. The respondent in an appeal is entitled to
support the decree of the trial court even by
challenging any of the findings that might have
been rendered by the trial court against himself.
For supporting the decree passed by the trial
court, it is not necessary for a respondent in the
appeal, to file a memorandum of cross-
objections challenging a particular finding that
is rendered by the trial court against him when
the ultimate decree itself is in his favour. A
memorandum of cross-objections is needed only
if the respondent claims any relief which had
been negatived to him by the trial court and in
addition to what he has already been given by
the decree under challenge. We have therefore
no hesitation in accepting the submission of the
learned counsel for the appellant that the High
Court was in error in proceeding on the basis
that the appellant not having filed a
memorandum of cross-objections, was not
entitled to canvas the correctness of the finding
on the bar of Order 2 Rule 2 rendered by the
trial court.”
(emphasis supplied)
29. It is apparent from the amended provisions of
Order 41 Rule 22CPC and the above authorities
that there are two changes that were brought by the
1976 Amendment. First, the scope of filing of a
cross-objection was enhanced substantively to
include objections against “findings” of the lower
court; second, different forms of raising cross-
objections were recognised. The amendment sought
to introduce different forms of cross-objection for
assailing the findings and decrees since the
amendment separates the phrase “but may also
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: TRILOK SINGH
SAVNER
Signing time: 25-08-2026
12:12:46
-27-
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-IND:24093
First Appeal No. 59/1968
state that the finding against him in the court below
in respect of any issue ought to have been in his
favour” from “may also take any cross-objection to
the decree” with a semi colon. Therefore, the two
parts of the sentence must be read disjunctively.
Only when a part of the decree has been assailed
by the respondent, should a memorandum of cross-
objection be filed. Otherwise, it is sufficient to raise
a challenge to an adverse finding of the court of
first instance before the appellate court without a
cross-objection.
30. The applicability of the principle in Order 41
Rule 22CPC to proceedings before this Court under
Article 136 of the Constitution was considered by a
Constitution Bench in the decision in Ramanbhai
Ashabhai Patel v. Dabhi Ajitkumar Fulsinji
[Ramanbhai Ashabhai Patel v. Dabhi Ajitkumar
Fulsinji, 1964 SCC OnLine SC 29 : AIR 1965 SC
669] . J.R. Mudholkar, J. overruled the judgment of
the three-Judge Bench in Vashist Narain Sharma v.
Dev Chandra [Vashist Narain Sharma v. Dev
Chandra, (1954) 2 SCC 32 : AIR 1954 SC 513]
which had rejected the argument of the respondent
that a party could raise arguments on the
“findings” that were against him, while supporting
the judgment. It was held that Order 41 Rule
22CPC does not have application to an appeal
under Article 136. In Ramanbhai Ashabhai Patel
[Ramanbhai Ashabhai Patel v. Dabhi Ajitkumar
Fulsinji, 1964 SCC OnLine SC 29 : AIR 1965 SC
669] , this Court held that the provisions of Order
41 Rule 22CPC are not applicable to the Supreme
Court and the rules of the Supreme Court do not
provide for any analogous provisions. However, it
was held that this deficiency must be supplemented
by drawing from CPC : (Ramanbhai Ashabhai
Patel case [Ramanbhai Ashabhai Patel v. Dabhi
Ajitkumar Fulsinji, 1964 SCC OnLine SC 29 : AIR
1965 SC 669] , SCC OnLine SC para 18)
“18. … Apart from that we think that while
dealing with the appeal before it this Court has
the power to decide all the points arising from
the judgment appealed against and even in the
absence of an express provision like Order 41
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: TRILOK SINGH
SAVNER
Signing time: 25-08-2026
12:12:46
-28-
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-IND:24093
First Appeal No. 59/1968
Rule 22 of the Code of Civil Procedure it can
devise the appropriate procedure to be adopted
at the hearing. There could be no better way of
supplying the deficiency than by drawing upon
the provisions of a general law like the Code of
Civil Procedure and adopting such of those
provisions as are suitable. We cannot lose sight
of the fact that normally a party in whose
favour the judgment appealed from has been
given will not be granted special leave to
appeal from it. Considerations of justice,
therefore, require that this Court should in
appropriate cases permit a party placed in
such a position to support the judgment in his
favour even upon grounds which were
negatived in that judgment.”
(emphasis supplied)
31. Expanding on this further, a two-Judge Bench
(R.C. Lahoti, J. speaking for himself and Brijesh
Kumar, J.) of this Court in Jamshed Hormusji Wadia
v. Port of Mumbai [Jamshed Hormusji Wadia v. Port
of Mumbai, (2004) 3 SCC 214] , observed : (SCC
pp. 245-46, para 35)
“35. A few decisions were brought to the notice
of this Court by the learned Additional Solicitor
General wherein this Court has made a reference
to Order 41 Rule 22CPC and permitted the
respondent to support the decree or decision
under appeal by laying challenge to a finding
recorded or issue decided against him though the
order, judgment or decree was in the end in his
favour. Illustratively, see Ramanbhai Ashabhai
Patel [Ramanbhai Ashabhai Patel v. Dabhi
Ajitkumar Fulsinji, 1964 SCC OnLine SC 29 :
AIR 1965 SC 669] , Northern Railway Coop.
Credit Society Ltd. [Northern Railway Coop.
Credit Society Ltd. v. Industrial Tribunal, 1967
SCC OnLine SC 73 : AIR 1967 SC 1182] and
Bharat Kala Bhandar (P) Ltd. [Bharat Kala
Bhandar (P) Ltd. v. Municipal Committee,
Dhamangaon, (1966) 59 ITR 73 : 1965 SCC
OnLine SC 170 : AIR 1966 SC 249] The learned
Additional Solicitor General is right. But we
would like to clarify that this is done not because
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: TRILOK SINGH
SAVNER
Signing time: 25-08-2026
12:12:46
-29-
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-IND:24093
First Appeal No. 59/1968
Order 41 Rule 22CPC is applicable to appeals
preferred under Article 136 of the Constitution; it
is because of a basic principle of justice
applicable to courts of superior jurisdiction. A
person who has entirely succeeded before a court
or tribunal below cannot file an appeal solely for
the sake of clearing himself from the effect of an
adverse finding or an adverse decision on one of
the issues as he would not be a person falling
within the meaning of the words “person
aggrieved”. In an appeal or revision, as a matter
of general principle, the party who has an order
in his favour, is entitled to show that even if the
order was liable to be set aside on the grounds
decided in his favour, yet the order could be
sustained by reversing the finding on some other
ground which was decided against him in the
court below. This position of law is supportable
on general principles without having recourse to
Order 41 Rule 22 of the Code of Civil Procedure.
Reference may be had to a recent decision of this
Court in Nalakath Sainuddin v. Koorikadan
Sulaiman [Nalakath Sainuddin v. Koorikadan
Sulaiman, (2002) 6 SCC 1] and also Banarsi v.
Ram Phal [Banarsi v. Ram Phal, (2003) 9 SCC
606] . This Court being a court of plenary
jurisdiction, once the matter has come to it in
appeal, shall have power to pass any decree and
make any order which ought to have been passed
or made as the facts of the case and law
applicable thereto call for. Such a power is
exercised by this Court by virtue of its own
jurisdiction and not by having recourse to Order
41 Rule 33CPC though in some of the cases
observations are available to the effect that this
Court can act on the principles deducible from
Order 41 Rule 33CPC. It may be added that this
Court has jurisdiction to pass such decree or
make such order as is necessary for doing
complete justice in any cause or matter pending
before it. Such jurisdiction is conferred on this
Court by Article 142 of the Constitution and this
Court is not required to have recourse to any
provision of the Code of Civil Procedure or any
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: TRILOK SINGH
SAVNER
Signing time: 25-08-2026
12:12:46
-30-
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-IND:24093
First Appeal No. 59/1968
principle deducible therefrom. However, still, in
spite of the wide jurisdiction being available, this
Court would not ordinarily make an order,
direction or decree placing the party appealing to
it in a position more disadvantageous than in
what it would have been had it not appealed.”
(emphasis supplied)
32. On a perusal of the above authorities, it is
evident that the principle stipulated in Order 41
Rule 22CPC can be applied to petitions under
Article 136 of the Constitution because of this
Court's wide powers to do justice under Article
142 of the Constitution. Since the principle in
Order 41 Rule 22CPC furthers the cause of justice
by providing the party other than the “aggrieved
party” to raise any adverse findings against them,
this Court can draw colour from Order 41 Rule
22CPC and permit objections to findings.
48. Considering the above legal position, the private respondents
were permitted to challenge the finding in recorded by the trial
Court on any issue in favour of the plaintiff.
Issue No. 1, 2 (a), (b), (c), (d), 3 (a), (b), (c), 4 (a), (b), (c), 5 (a) (i),
(ii), (b), 6 (a), (b), (c), 7 (a), (b), (c) (d):
49. Shri Rishiraj Trivedi, learned counsel appearing behalf of the
appellant opened his arguments stating that the appellant is not
claiming any title over the temple and the properties attached to the
temple. Shri Veer Kumar Jain, learned senior counsel with Shri
Maqbool Mansoori, Advocate appearing on behalf of the private
respondents submits that the private respondents are also not
claiming any title over the temple or the properties attached to the
temple. As per the counsel for the appellant and counsel for the
private respondents, the dispute is in respect of management of the
temple and the properties attached to it.
50.
It is not in dispute that the subject temple of Shree Ram
Chandra is an ancient temple and established several generations
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: TRILOK SINGH
SAVNER
Signing time: 25-08-2026
12:12:46
-31-
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-IND:24093
First Appeal No. 59/1968
ago having the deity of God Shree Ram, Janki Ji, Laxman Ji,
Hanuman Ji, Laxminarayan Ji and Gopal Ji. The plaintiff claimed
that the temple was built and the deity was installed there by the
ancestral of the plaintiff Baba Mayaramdas Ji in Samvat 1584 and
as per the lineage custom, the disciple of the Mahant succeeded the
seat of Mahant after the death of earlier Mahant and the grand-guru-
father of the plaintiff, Mahant Gopaldas Ji was the Mahant of this
Shrine in the year 1907.
51. In support of the pleadings of the plaintiff that Baba
Mayaramdas Ji built the temple and installed the deity of Lord
Shree Ram in Samvat 1584, the plaintiff has examined Narayandas
(PW/4), who stated that he is the Bhat of Bairagi Community and
his ancestors used to maintain the record of the lineage of the
temple and the Gadi attached to the temple and as per the record
maintained by his ancestors, the temple was built in Samvat 1584.
Mahant Gopaldas Ji was the lineage of Baba Mayaramdas Ji as per
the guru-disciple customs. He produced the book maintained by his
ancestors Exhibit P/4 and the lineage record Exhibit P/2 & Exhibit
P/3, wherein it is mentioned that the temple was established by
Mahant Mayaramdas Ji. The plaintiff (PW/12) also stated in his
statement that this temple was established by Mahant Mayaramdas
Ji in Samvat 1584, however, accepted in the cross-examination that
his information is solely based on the information supplied by
Narayandas (PW/4), who is the Bhat of the Bairagi Community.
52.
The plaintiff has examined some other witnesses also who
simply stated in their oral statement that the temple was built up by
Mahant Mayaramdas Ji, but there is no documentary evidence
available on record that the temple was built by Mahant
Mayaramdas Ji in Samvat 1584. The statement of the plaintiff is
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: TRILOK SINGH
SAVNER
Signing time: 25-08-2026
12:12:46
-32-
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-IND:24093
First Appeal No. 59/1968
based on information supplied by Narayandas, however, the copy of
the book produced by Narayandas does not appear to be a credible
document and only on the basis of the said book, it cannot be
accepted that the temple was built in 1584 by Mahant Mayaramdas.
The trial court has not committed any error in deciding the issue
No. 1 that there is no evidence that the Shrine was built up by
Bairagis of Ramanand Sect in Samvat 1584 by Mahant
Mayaramdas Ji by installing the deity of Lord Shree Ram.
53. So far as the contention of private respondents that the subject
temple is an ancient temple of Maheswari Community, there is no
evidence on record to support the contention that the temple was
built up by Maheswari Community and whatever record has been
produced in the court are in relation with the period of Mahant
Gopaldas Ji, Mahant Murlidas ji and plaintiff Ratanlal. Therefore,
the Shrine cannot be considered as an ancient temple of Maheswari
Community, though it is proved by the private respondents and duly
accepted by the plaintiffs that members of Maheswari Community
are the devotees of the Shrine and spent huge amount for
development and maintenance of the Shrine and campus. DW-1
Ratanlal s/o Hukmichand, DW-3 Nanalal, DW-4 Thawarji, DW-5
Chandmal, DW-7 Haridas and DW-10 Sagarmal duly proved by
oral and documentary evidence that the Panchaas of Maheshwari
Samaj spent huge amount for renovation, maintenance and new
construction in the temple. It is also proved that they were having
active participation in the management of temple even during the
lifetime of Mahant Murlidas. In view of the above facts, it can be
safely held that the Deity is the owner of the Shrine including
other movable and immovable properties and members of
Maheshwari Samaj are the devotees of the temple and spent
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: TRILOK SINGH
SAVNER
Signing time: 25-08-2026
12:12:46
-33-
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-IND:24093
First Appeal No. 59/1968
huge amount for betterment and maintenance of the temple.
54. Insofar as the management of temple by Mahant Gopaldas Ji
is concerned, the plaintiff has produced several documentary
evidences and even the private respondents as well as the State have
not denied this fact.
55. The plaintiff (PW/12) in his statement has produced the
certified copies of Mafi register obtained from the office of Mafi
Officer, wherein the subject Shrine and the lands attached to the
Shrine were recorded as Mafi land and the name of Mahant
Gopaldas Ji was duly recorded in the register. Annexure P/9 is the
certified copy of the register of Samvat 1958 and thereafter,
continuously, the same were recorded in the name of Mahant
Gopaldas Ji as a Mafi land.
56. In the erstwhile, Gwalior State, the State established a Mafi
and Jageer department and the properties those were used for
religious, educational and charitable purposes were exempted from
the land revenue and other taxes and the power to grant the
exemption was with the Mafi Officer and the department of Mafi
and Jageer used to maintain register of the properties in respect of
which the exemption of land revenue and / or tax has been granted.
The plaintiff obtained the certified copies of Mafi register and
produced the same, which proved that the subject Shrine and the
properties attached to the Shrine were duly recorded in the name of
Mahant Gopaldas Ji S/o Mahant Govinddas Bairagi and were
exempted ( Mafi ) lands and properties, therefore, the fact that
Mahant Gopaldas Ji was managing the property is duly proved by
producing these documents. Even otherwise, the defendants have
not challenged the fact that Mahant Gopaldas Ji was managing the
properties and on the contrary, the private respondents are claiming
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: TRILOK SINGH
SAVNER
Signing time: 25-08-2026
12:12:46
-34-
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-IND:24093
First Appeal No. 59/1968
their right of management on the basis of the alleged Will executed
by Mahant Gopaldas Ji on 19.12.1907, wherein Mahant Gopaldas Ji
allegedly bequeathed the Shebait rights in favour of the Panchas of
Maheshwari Community. The fact that Mahant Gopaldas Ji was
managing the Shrine and the properties has not been disputed by the
State also. Therefore, it is held that the plaintiff is able to prove
that Mahant Gopaldas Ji was managing the properties.
57. As per the plaintiff, the subject Shrine is a Math and,
therefore, the Ascetics of the Ramanand Sect have authority to
decide that who will be the next Mahant of the Seat ( Gadi ). The
plaintiff has come with a case that the villagers of 175 villages of
Bairagi Community are main devotees of the temple and the temple
has been recognized as Math , therefore, after the death of Mahant
Gopaldas Ji, Mahant Murlidas Ji, the father of the plaintiff was
holding the seat of Mahant as per the decision taken by the Ascetics
of Ramanand Sect and Bhekh Ceremony was also performed, which
is essential for appointment of Mahant. In the Bhekh Ceremony, the
Ascetics used to offer Kanthi and Chaddar to the newly appointed
Mahant in a Bhandara to be organized by the Math .
58. Normally, the Shrine wherein the idols or deity are available is
called a temple were the dedicated devotees frequently visit for
worship and offer their prayers. However, a Math is a spiritual
institute, which serves as a residence for disciples of the Math and
ordinarily, it is a centre for teaching religious philosophy and
traditions. The Math focuses on the theoretical and monastic side of
a spiritual tradition. It serves as a home and training ground for
Ascetics led by senior ascetic (Guruji), whereas the temple is
usually managed for the community and focuses on the practical
and devotional worship of holy icons (Murtis). Temple is ordinarily
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: TRILOK SINGH
SAVNER
Signing time: 25-08-2026
12:12:46
-35-
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-IND:24093
First Appeal No. 59/1968
open to the general public for daily rituals, festivals and offerings,
whereas Math may have restricted entries.
59. Though, the several witnesses of the plaintiff have stated that
this Shrine is a Math and is recognized by the Ramanand Sect and is
a branch of Shri Digamber Akhada of Ayodhya, however, no such
evidence could be brought on record by the plaintiff that in the
subject premises, any religious educational activities were
organized and the young Ascetics used to reside there for the
purpose of getting religious education.
60. For the purpose of deciding the issue that weather the Priest of
a temple should be Nihang (Bachelor) or even a married household
person can perform the duties of Priest, it is essential to understand
the nature of the Shrine, because if the subject Shrine is a Math ,
then this restriction is applicable that only a Nihang can perform the
Puja in the temple of a Math , but if the subject Shrine is only a
temple, then no such restriction can be imposed on the Priest as per
the Hindu customs and the statements of the plaintiff witnesses PW-
10, PW-13, PW-14 and PW-16.
61. To understand the meaning of a Math , the definition of a Math
provided in Section 2(2) of the M.P. Public Trust Act, 1951 is
helpful, which provides that Math means an institution for the
promotion of Hindu religion presided over by a person, whose duty
is to engage himself in imparting religious institutions or rendering
spiritual service to a body of disciples or who exercises or claims to
exercise hardship over such a body and includes places of religious
worship or institution, which are appurtenant to the institution. As
per this definition, for the purpose of considering a Shrine as a
Math , the existence of religious and spiritual institution is essential.
As there is no evidence available in the case at hand that any
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: TRILOK SINGH
SAVNER
Signing time: 25-08-2026
12:12:46
-36-
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-IND:24093
First Appeal No. 59/1968
religious or spiritual institution is established in the campus of
Shree Ram temple, Rammohalla, Khachrod, the temple cannot be
treated as Math . In the absence of religious or spiritual
institution, the subject Shrine cannot be treated as a Math and
therefore it is not essential that only a Nihang can be appointed
as Priest of the Temple.
62. The case of the private respondents are mainly based on the
Will allegedly executed by the Mahant Gopaldas Ji on 19.12.1907,
whereby Mahant Gopaldas Ji reduced that he has attained the age of
60 years and there is no certainty of his life. He has only one
disciple, who is not residing there, therefore, till his lifetime, he will
continue to manage and worship the temple and in future, if he
accepts anyone else as his disciple during his lifetime, the disciple
will be his successor of seat, however, the Panchas will ensure that
he works punctually, properly and maintains the temple. He reduced
his wish that disciple will remain Naga (Bachelor) and in case he
performs the marriage, he will continue to manage the temple with
the consent of the Panchas and the Panchas will have right to take a
decision in this respect. He appointed Mr. Jawaharchand Kakani,
Rupaji, Dhulji, Gulabchand Nawaal and Ghisaji Rathi as Panchas.
63. From bare reading of the Will, it appears that Mahant
Gopaldas Ji recorded that his disciple is not available in the temple
and he will continue to manage the temple during his lifetime and if
during this period, any new disciple joins him, the disciple will be
his successor, who will perform the duties promptly with all the
dignities and customs as followed by the Mahant Gopaldas Ji. He
recorded his wish that his successor remain Naga (Bachelor) and in
case he performs the marriage, the Panchas appointed by the
testator will take decision for his continuation. Meaning thereby, the
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: TRILOK SINGH
SAVNER
Signing time: 25-08-2026
12:12:46
-37-
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-IND:24093
First Appeal No. 59/1968
Shebait rights were not completely bequeathed to the Panchas of
Maheswari Community by Mahant Gopaldas Ji as claimed by them.
The Will is a registered Will and produced by the defendant Nos. 2
and 3 in the Court.
64. Shebait is the human custodian and manager of a Hindu deity
and its temple property. Because an idol is treated as juristic person,
but cannot manage physical or financial affairs on its own, the
Shebait acts as its legal guardian, earthly representative and servant.
65. The plaintiff has raised the objection that the Will has not
been duly proved by the defendants as per the provisions of Section
63(c) of the Indian Succession Act and Section 68 of the Indian
Evidence Act.
66. Learned counsel for the appellant raised the objection that the
right of management cannot be bequeathed by a will and the alleged
will was neither properly proved as per the provisions of Section 68
of the Evidence Act, nor as per the provisions of Section 63 of the
Indian Succession Act. No witness was examined by the private
defendant to prove the will. He further submits that the provisions
of Section 90 of the Evidence Act do not apply to a will and the will
is always required to be proved as per the provisions of Section 68
of the Evidence Act. He relied on the judgment delivered by the
Supreme Court in the matter of Kavita Kanwar Vs. Pamela Mehta
3
and others , wherein the Supreme Court has laid down the
principles governing the adjudicatory process concerning proof of
will, which reads as under:-
“(i) Ordinarily, a will has to be proved like any other
document; the test to be applied being the usual test of
the satisfaction of the prudent mind and proof of
3
Kavita Kanwar Vs. Pamela Mehta and others, (2021) 11 SCC 209.
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: TRILOK SINGH
SAVNER
Signing time: 25-08-2026
12:12:46
-38-
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-IND:24093
First Appeal No. 59/1968
mathematical accuracy is not to be insisted upon.
(ii) Since as per Section 63 of the Succession Act, a will
is required to be attested, it cannot be used as evidence
until at least one attesting witness has been called for
the purpose of proving its execution, if there be an
attesting witness alive and capable of giving evidence.
(iii) The unique feature of a will is that it speaks from
the death of the testator and, therefore, the maker
thereof is not available for deposing about the
circumstances in which the same was executed. This
introduces an element of solemnity in the decision of
the question as to whether the document propounded is
the last will of the testatos. The initial onus, naturally,
lies on the propounder but the same can be taken to
have been primarily discharged on proof of the
essential facts which go into the making of a will.
(iv) However, presence of suspicious circumstances
makes the onus heavier on the propounder and,
therefore, in cases where the circumstances attendant
upon the execution of the document give rise to
suspicion, the propounder must remove all legitimate
suspicions before the document can be accepted as the
last will of the testator.
(v) If a person challenging the will alleges fabrication
or alleges fraud, undue influence, coercion, etc. in
regard to the execution of the will, such pleas have to
be proved, but even in the absence of such pleas, the
very circumstances surrounding the execution of the
will may give rise to the doubt or as to whether the will
had indeed been executed by the testator and/or as to
whether the testator was acting of his own free will. In
such eventuality, it is again a part of the initial onus of
the propounder to remove all reasonable doubts in the
matter.
(vi) A circumstance is "suspicious" when it is not
normal or is 'not normally expected in a normal
situation or is not expected of a normal person'. The
suspicious features must be 'real, germane and valid
and not merely the 'fantasy of the doubting mind'.
(vii) As to whether any particular feature or a set of
features qualify as "suspicious" would depend on the
facts and circumstances of each case. A shaky or
doubtful signature; a feeble or uncertain mind of the
testator; an unfair disposition of property; an unjust
exclusion of the legal heirs and particularly the
dependants; an active or leading part in making of the
will by the beneficiary thereunder etc. are some of the
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: TRILOK SINGH
SAVNER
Signing time: 25-08-2026
12:12:46
-39-
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-IND:24093
First Appeal No. 59/1968
circumstances which may give rise to suspicion. The
circumstances above-noted are only illustrative and by
no means exhaustive because there could be any
circumstance or set of circumstances which may give
rise to legitimate suspicion about the execution of the
will. On the other hand, any of the circumstance
qualifying as being suspicious could be legitimately
explained by the propounder. However, such suspicion
or suspicions cannot be removed by mere proof of
sound and disposing state of mind of the testator and
his signature coupled with the proof of attestation.
(viii) The test of satisfaction of the judicial conscience
comes into operation when a document propounded as
the will of the testator is surrounded by suspicious
circumstance(s). While applying such test, the Court
would address itself to the solemn questions as to
whether the testator had signed the will while being
aware of its contents and after understanding the
nature and effect of the dispositions in the will?
(ix) In the ultimate analysis, where the execution of a
will is shrouded in suspicion, it is a matter essentially
of the judicial conscience of the Court and the party
which sets up the will has to offer cogent and
convincing explanation of the suspicious circumstances
surrounding the will.”
67. Learned counsel for the appellant submits that as the burden to
prove the will was on the private respondents, but they failed to
prove the will. He further relied upon the judgment delivered by the
Supreme Court in the matter of Ashutosh Samanta and others Vs.
4
Ranjan Bala Dasi and others , wherein the Supreme Court has
held that in case both the witnesses have died, the will is required to
be proved by any person, who can identify the signatures of
testators and/or witnesses. He submits that only on the ground that
will is more than 30 years old and registered, it cannot be presumed
that the will was executed and the execution of will and contents of
the will cannot be admitted, which have to be proved in terms of
Section 63(c) of the Indian Succession Act, 1925 and Section 68 of
the Indian Evidence Act, 1872. The relevant paragraphs of the
4
Ashutosh Samanta and others Vs. Ranjan Bala Dasi and others, (2023) 19 SCC 448.
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: TRILOK SINGH
SAVNER
Signing time: 25-08-2026
12:12:46
-40-
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-IND:24093
First Appeal No. 59/1968
judgment reads as under:-
“ 11 . The main argument of the appellant is that the
application for letters of administration was made after
a considerable delay, and that the courts below should
not have relied on Section 90 of the Evidence Act,
1872, which reads as follows:
" 90. Presumption as to documents thirty years old .
Where any document, purporting or proved to be
thirty years old, is produced from any custody
which the Court in the particular case considers
proper, the Court may presume that the signature
and every other part of such document, which
purports to be in the handwriting of any particular
person, is in that person's handwriting, and, in the
case of a document executed or attested, that it was
duly executed and attested by the persons by whom
it purports to be executed and attested.
Explanation. Documents are said to be in proper
custody if they are in the place in which, and under
the care of the person with whom, they would
naturally be; but no custody is improper if it is
proved to have had a legitimate origin, or if the
circumstances of the particular case are such as to
render such an origin probable.
This explanation applies also to Section 81."
12. This Court, in M.B. Ramesh v. K.M. Veeraje Urs
while dealing with a similar argument regarding
applicability of Section 90 in the case of proof of will,
held as follows: (SCC p. 499, paras 17-18)
"17. At the same time we cannot accept the
submission on behalf of the Respondents as well that
merely because the will was more than 30 years old,
a presumption under Section 90 of the Evidence Act,
1872 ("the Evidence Act" for short) ought to be
drawn that the document has been duly executed and
attested by the persons by whom it purports to have
been executed and attested. As held by this Court in
Bharpur Singh v. Shamsher Singh, a presumption
regarding documents 30 years old does not apply to
a will. A will has to be proved in terms of Section
63(c) of the Succession Act read with Section 68 of
the Evidence Act.
18. That takes us to the crucial issue involved in the
present case viz. with respect to the validity and
proving of the will concerned. A will has to be
executed in the manner required by Section 63 of the
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: TRILOK SINGH
SAVNER
Signing time: 25-08-2026
12:12:46
-41-
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-IND:24093
First Appeal No. 59/1968
Succession Act. Section 68 of the Evidence Act
requires the will to be proved by examining at least
one attesting witness. Section 71 of the Evidence Act
is another connected section 'which is permissive
and an enabling section permitting a party to lead
other evidence in certain circumstances', as
observed by this Court in para 11 of Janki Narayan
Bhoir v. Narayan Namdeo Kadam and in a way
reduces the rigour of the mandatory provision of
Section 68. As held in that judgment Section 71 is
meant to lend assistance and come to the rescue of a
party who had done his best, but would otherwise be
let down if other means of proving due execution by
other evidence are not permitted."
13. In view of the above decision, wills cannot be
proved only on the basis of their age the presumption
under Section 90 as to the regularity of documents
more than 30 years of age is inapplicable when it
comes to proof of wills, which have to be proved in
terms of Section 63(c) of the Succession Act, 1925, and
Section 68 of the Evidence Act, 1872.”
68. In reply to the objection raised by counsel for the appellant,
the learned Senior Advocate appearing on behalf of the private
respondents submits that in the case in hand the plaintiff himself has
pleaded that the Panchas of Maheshwari community got executed a
will from Mahant Gopaldas by practicing fraud and under
influence, therefore, so far as the execution of will is concerned, the
execution is admitted and admission is the best evidence as per
Section 58 of the Evidence Act. He relied on the judgment delivered
by the Supreme Court in the matter of Executive Officer, Arulmigu
Chokkanatha Swamy Koil Trust Virudhunagar Vs. Chandran and
5
others , wherein the Supreme Court has held that admission is the
best evidence and if any fact is admitted by a party to the case, the
opposite party is not required to prove the same fact.
69. The learned Senior Advocate further submits that as the
execution of the will is admitted, the onus of proving the will was
5
Executive Officer, Arulmigu Chokkanatha Swamy Koil Trust Virudhunagar Vs. Chandran and
others (2017) 3 SCC 702.
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: TRILOK SINGH
SAVNER
Signing time: 25-08-2026
12:12:46
-42-
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-IND:24093
First Appeal No. 59/1968
not on the defendant, whereas the onus was on the plaintiff to prove
that the will was got executed by practicing fraud and under undue
influence and active confidence. He submits that the plaintiff is
miserably failed to prove that the will was got executed by
practicing fraud or under undue influence.
70. So far as the objection raised by counsel for the appellant that
the right of management cannot be bequeathed by will is concerned,
learned Senior Advocate relied on the judgment delivered by the
6
Supreme Court in the matter of Ram Rattan Vs. Bajrang Lal ,
wherein the Supreme Court has held that Shebaitship is like
immovable property. It is hereditary and heritable office and at the
same time Shebaitship is not having any right to sale the office, nor
it can be mortgaged or leased, but a will can be executed to
bequeath the Shebaitship right. Shebaitship being a property, it
devolves like any other hereditary property, therefore, Mahant
Gopaldas was competent to execute the will in respect of the right
of management of the subject temple.
71. It is also not in dispute that in the case in hand after the death
of Mahant Gopaldas, Mahant Murlidas who was his disciple, was
declared as Mahant and Murlidas was started worshiping and
managing the temple and its properties. The name of Murlidas was
duly mutated in the revenue records, municipality and Mafi register.
The plaintiff has filed the certified copies of the documents of
municipality, Mafi register and revenue records, wherein the name
of Murlidas was duly recorded. Even it is not the case of private
defendants that Murlidas had not taken over the charge of
Mahantship after the death of Mahant Gopaldas, though it is an
admitted position on record that Murlidas was not the son of
6
Ram Rattan Vs. Bajrang Lal, AIR 1978 SC 1393.
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: TRILOK SINGH
SAVNER
Signing time: 25-08-2026
12:12:46
-43-
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-IND:24093
First Appeal No. 59/1968
Gopaldas, as Gopaldas was Nihang.
72. Since the appointment of Murlidas the dispute arose between
Maheshwari panchas and Murlidas and Maheshwari Panchas were
raising objections in respect of the management of the temple.
However, during this period one agreement was allegedly executed
between Maheshwari panchas and Murlidas with an object to settle
the dispute, which is produced by the defendants and exhibited as
Ex. D/2, wherein on 28.4.1919 Murlidas, Guru Gopaldas Bairagi
acknowledged the execution of will by his Guru Gopaldas on
19.11.1907 and also acknowledged that the testator had given the
authority to the Panchas. Murlidas was managing the shrine and
performing the duties of priest with the consent of the Panchas,
however Murlidas reduced that he was not able to manage the
temple and, therefore, by the agreement handed over the properties
of the temple to the Panchas with a condition that the Panchas will
permit him to collect the rent and offerings and from the receipt of
the amount of rent and offerings, he will manage his family, as he
was a married person and he was continued to perform the duties of
the priest. In the agreement the details of the movable properties
were also mentioned along with the details of immovable
properties. The agreement was registered and on the basis of that
agreement also, the Panchas of Maheshwari community claimed
that they were entitled to manage the temple and appoint the priest
there. The whole dispute is in respect of management that who is
having the authority to act as Shebait.
73. Mahant Murlidas in his statement recorded before the
Tehsildar dated 23.7.1927 (Ex.D/18) accepted that he executed an
agreement in favour of Maheshwari panchas. Maheshwari panchas
also spent huge money for development of the campus and
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: TRILOK SINGH
SAVNER
Signing time: 25-08-2026
12:12:46
-44-
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-IND:24093
First Appeal No. 59/1968
constructed some rooms, community hall and renovated the temple.
However, from the record it appears that the dispute between the
Maheshwari panchas and Mahant Murlidas was continued, which
was originally started even from the date of taking charge by
Murlidas as Mahant. Several documents have been filed and
exhibited in respect of various disputes, which reached up to the
Court of Tehsildar and Tehsildar passed various orders time to time.
As it is not essential to refer those orders, applications, replies here,
therefore they are not described in this order.
74. In the State of Gwalior has established an Auqaf Department,
which worked for the Mafi and management of religious and
charitable properties. It was a unique administrative legacy in the
erstwhile Gwalior State and mainly the department was working
under the control of Commissioner, Mafi and Jagir. It was a
dedicated wing under the State’s revenue administration to manage
public religious land grants. The Tehsildar was the head of the
Auqaf Department of Pargana, Khachrod.
75. From the statements of the witnesses and the documents
exhibited by the parties, it is evident that when the dispute between
the Mahant Murlidas and Maheshwari panchas continued, Murlidas
applied to the Tehsildar, Khachrod, who was working as President
of Auqaf Department, Pargana, Khachrod for taking over the
control and management of Shrine and the properties attached to the
Shrine on 14.9.1927. The Tehsildar immediately considered the
application and issued a direction to Mahant Murlidas to discharge
the duties of the priest properly and continue the services of the
deity and not to stop any devotee to offer the prayer and avoid the
disputes. The Tehsildar forwarded the request of Mahant Murlidas
to the President, Central Auqaf Committee passed the resolution on
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: TRILOK SINGH
SAVNER
Signing time: 25-08-2026
12:12:46
-45-
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-IND:24093
First Appeal No. 59/1968
18.10.1927 for making special arrangement in respect of the Shree
Ram Mandir. On 17.2.1928 the Auqaf Committee, Pargana,
Khachrod recommended for formation of a sub-committee for the
purpose of management of the temple and appoint Murlidas as
Pujari. On 11.6.1930, the Central Committee accepted the
recommendation of Auqaf Committee, Pargana, Khachrod. Once
again Mahant Murlidas applied to the State for taking control of the
management of the temple and make arrangements for his children.
Ultimately on 23.9.1930 the home member of the Auqaf
Department passed the order that Mahant Murlidas will punctually
perform the duties of the priest and will not create any hindrance in
the worship of the idol by public or members of Maheshwari
community and on 15.10.1930 an order was passed by home
member to take Shree Ram Mandir and its properties under the
supervision and control of the State.
76. The control and supervision of the temple was taken over
by the Auqaf Department of State upon the request of the
Mahant Murlidas and the said action has attained finality and
the State duly acknowledged the title of the deity over the entire
shrine and its movable and immovable properties and the State
through Auqaf Department (now it is merged in revenue
department) is the manager of the entire shrine and its
properties.
77. Thereafter Mahant Murlidas continued to worship and
perform the duties of priest in the temple. The devotees of
Maheshwari community gifted the constructed rooms and
community hall and other structures to the deity by executing a gift
deed on 18.6.1930. Even after the management of the temple was
taken under the supervision of the Auqaf Department, the disputes
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: TRILOK SINGH
SAVNER
Signing time: 25-08-2026
12:12:46
-46-
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-IND:24093
First Appeal No. 59/1968
between the Maheshwari community and Mahant Murlidas
continued and they used to file complaints and take actions against
each other. However, Mahant Murlidas continued to perform the
duties of the priest till his death in the year 1937 and during this
period he was managing the properties of the shrine also under the
supervision of Auqaf Department.
78. From the statements of the witnesses and the documents
produced in evidence, it is established that Mahant Gopaldas was
the undisputed Mahant of the seat Shree Ram Mandir, Khachrod
and was enjoying the rights of Shebait. After his death, Mahant
Murlidas had taken over the seat of Mahant, however there were
serious disputes between Mahant Murlidas and the devotees of
Maheshwari community and ultimately upon the application of
Mahant Murlidas the supervision of the management of temple was
taken over by the Auqaf Department and in this way the temple was
being managed by the State since 1930. The Auqaf Department was
paying the salary to Murlidas @ Rs.10/- per month in addition to
the annual offerings (Nemnook).
79. After the death of Mahant Murlidas, the Panchas of
Maheshwari community did not agree on the name of the plaintiff
Ratandas for his appointment as priest in place of Murlidas. Plaintif
witness Narsinghdas (PW-13), Kanhaiyadas (PW-14),
Ghanshyamdas (PW-15) and Narottamdas (PW-16) have stated in
their statements that the ascetics of Ramanand sect gathered at the
temple and unanimously decided to nominate the plaintiff Ratandas
as new Mahant and the Bhekh ceremony was performed and a
Kanthi and Chaddar were given by the ascetic Manohardas to
Ratandas and all of them enjoyed Bhandara and in this way
Ratandas became the Mahant of Shree Ram Mandir, Khachrod.
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: TRILOK SINGH
SAVNER
Signing time: 25-08-2026
12:12:46
-47-
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-IND:24093
First Appeal No. 59/1968
These witnesses were cross-examined at length, however nothing
could be brought in their cross-examination to disbelieve the
statement of these witnesses.
80. Ratandas started working as priest, however at the same time
the defendant No. 2 Mishrilal also appointed someone else to
perform the duties of the priest. Ratandas applied to Auqaf
Department for permitting him to continue as priest and name of
Ratandas was mutated in the record of the municipality also. By Ex.
P/29 the Auqaf committee Pargana, Khachrod passed the resolution
No. 16 dated 01.06.1944, whereby it was agreed that Ratandas be
appointed as priest of the temple as he has been certified by the
ascetics of the Ramanand sect. His name was recommended for
appointment by the President, Auqaf Committee to the Central
Committee and the charge of the priest was handed over to the
plaintiff by the receiver duly appointed by Auqaf committee on
12.09.1948 to Ratandas and the document of handing over the
charge has been proved and exhibited as Ex. P/7 in the evidence.
Before that by Ex. P/6 dated 30.08.1948 Auqaf Department
appointed Ratandas as priest of the temple for performing the Pooja
and managing the temple and its properties. After the order of the
Commissioner, Mafi and Jagir, the charge was taken back from
plaintiff Ratandas on 29.09.1949, however Ratandas continued to
perform the worship to the deity and act as priest, even without
receiving any monthly salary from the Auqaf Department.
81.
The private respondents examined several witnesses to prove
that Ratanlal was never approved by ascetics of Ramanand Sect as
Mahant and he could not continue as priest after performing the
marriage. DW-2 Ramdas, DW-7 Haridas, DW-8 Tulsidas and DW-
12 Kamaldas were examined by the defendant nos. 2 and 3 to
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: TRILOK SINGH
SAVNER
Signing time: 25-08-2026
12:12:46
-48-
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-IND:24093
First Appeal No. 59/1968
support their contention that Ratanlal was never approved by
ascetics and he cannot continue after marriage. These all witnesses
belongs to Ramanand Sect, however their statements do not appear
to be credible and based of personal inferences only and on the
basis of these statements only, it cannot be accepted that no Bhekh
ceremony was held and the plaintiff was not approved as Mahant
and not entitled to continue after marriage as priest of the Shree
Ram and Ramolla Temple.
82. When Ratandas was appointed, he was bachelor, however
later on he performed the marriage and the Maheshwari Panchas
started raising objection that a married person cannot act as priest in
the temple, as this is a seat of Nihang. Ratandas opposed this
contention of the Maheshwari Panchas and the matter once again
went to the Court of Tehsildar. As per the Ratandas, it was not
essential that only Nihang (bachelor) can work as priest. His father
Murlidas was also a married person having household and wherever
the seat is attached with the temple of Ramanand sect, a married
priest may work. The plaintiff examined Rameshwardas (PW-10),
Santdas (PW-11) and Narottamdas (PW-16) in support of his
contention before the trial Court that the married person may also
act as Mahant. Several examples were given by these witnesses and
even after detailed cross-examinations they remained constant on
this issue.
83. The only basis of taking objection by the private respondents
that the priest of the temple should be Nihang is the will executed
by Mahant Gopaldas, except that there is no evidence to prove this
contention. Upon examining the will executed by Mahant Gopaldas
(Ex.A), it appears that Mahant Gopaldas had shown his wish that
his disciple, who will succeed the seat of temple be continued as
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: TRILOK SINGH
SAVNER
Signing time: 25-08-2026
12:12:46
-49-
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-IND:24093
First Appeal No. 59/1968
Naga (bachelor) and if he performs the marriage and becomes
household, the Maheshwari panchas will decide that whether he
should continue or not, meaning thereby though it was mentioned in
the will that this is a seat of Nihangs, but it was not essential to
appoint ascetic only and a married person may also work as a priest.
84. As discussed hereinabove, as this shrine is only a temple and
no religious institute is attached with this shrine, this temple cannot
be considered as Math and as per the Hindu customs the
requirement of remaining Naga is only for the Math , wherein the
religious and spiritual education is given to the young ascetics
residing in the Math itself. No such Math is attached with the
temple and it is a temple of Ramanand sect and several other
Mahant or priest appeared in the evidence and have stated that a
married person may also perform the duties of a priest, the plaintiff
able to prove that a married person can perform the duties of
Mahant/priest in Shree Ram Mandir, Khachrod.
85. When the plaintiff was repairing his residential portion, the
Maheshwari panchas raised objection and, therefore, the plaintiff
filed Suit No. 261/1951 on 20.11.1951 in the Court of Civil Judge,
Khachrod seeking the relief of injunction against the Maheshwari
panchas, which was dismissed in default. Copy of the plaint is
exhibited as D/3. Thereafter the plaintiff issued a notice through
counsel to the Chief Secretary, Madhya Bharat Government,
Gwalior and Collector, Ujjain (Ex.P/32) on 11.4.1953 to prevent the
Maheshwari panchas from interfering in the peaceful enjoyment of
the properties of the temple and management of the temple. Reply
(Ex.P/33) was received from the Office of Under Secretary, wherein
it was advised to both the parties to approach to the competent
Court for obtaining decision on their rights. Thereafter, the suit was
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: TRILOK SINGH
SAVNER
Signing time: 25-08-2026
12:12:46
-50-
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-IND:24093
First Appeal No. 59/1968
filed by the plaintiff.
86. The trial Court has not committed any error in deciding the
Issue No.2(a) that there is no seat attached to the temple, however
the trial Court committed error in deciding the Issue No.2(b) by
holding that the office of the priest of this temple was customarily
always occupied by Nihang. When the trial Court was of the view
that the subject temple is not a Math and no seat is attached with the
temple, the trial Court committed an error in holding that there is a
custom that only Nihang can perform the Pooja. This requirement is
attached only with the Math . As there is no seat, therefore, it is not
essential that the priest should be Nihang. The Issue No.2(c) has
rightly been decided by the trial Court that the plaintiff is the son of
Murlidas, however Issue No.2(d) has been erroneously decided by
the trial Court based on the fining of Issue No.2(b) that the plaintiff
is not entitled to continue as priest after performing the marriage.
The trial Court has considered the Maheshwari panchas as Trustee
of the temple, whereas the existence of Trust was proved. So far as
the Shebait or Pujari is concerned, it is not essential that he should
be Nihang. Issue No.2(d) has been wrongly decided by the trial
Court.
87. Issue No. 3(a) has been correctly decided by the trial Court by
holding that the plaintiff is simply a Pujari and lives in the temple as
licensee and employee, however he is not the employee of the Trust,
he is employee of Auqaf Department (Revenue Department). Issue
No. 3(b) has been wrongly decided that the plaintiff has forfeited
his right to continue as Pujari due to his misconduct. The
defendants and their witnesses could not bring any material on
record that the plaintiff committed misconduct of such a nature,
which may be resulted in forfeiture of his rights to work as Pujari.
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: TRILOK SINGH
SAVNER
Signing time: 25-08-2026
12:12:46
-51-
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-IND:24093
First Appeal No. 59/1968
This issue has been wrongly decided. Issue No.3(C) has also been
wrongly decided by the trial Court by holding that Panchas of
Maheshwari community are having right to terminate the services
of the plaintiff. The plaintiff has been appointed as priest by the
Auqaf Department and his appointment can be cancelled only by
the Auqaf Department. The panchas of Maheswhari community
have no right to terminate the services of the plaintiff.
88. Issue No. 4(a) has been correctly decided by the trial Court
that for appointment of the Mahant as per the customs of Ramanand
sect, Bhekh ceremony is essential. However, in the case in hand it
has been held that the subject temple is not a Math , therefore,
performance of Bhekh ceremony is not having any relevance to the
case in hand. Issue No. 4(b) has rightly been decided by the trial
Court that Bhekh ceremony was actually performed. Similarly Issue
No. 4(c) has also been correctly decided that by Bhekh ceremony
the rights of the Mahantship has not been conferred upon the
plaintiff as the plaintiff has been appointed by the Auqaf
Department.
89. The Issue No. 5(a)(i) & (ii) have been correctly decided by the
trial Court. The plaintiff has failed to prove that the will was
obtained from Gopaldas by practicing fraud or under any undue
influence after taking the testator in active confidence.
90. Issue No. 6(a) has also been correctly decided by the trial
Court by holding that by the will dated 19.12.1907 Mahant
Gopaldas has not transferred any property of the deity in favour of
the beneficiaries of the will. Issue No. 6(b) has also been decided
correctly, however Issue No. 6(c) has not been decided properly by
holding that after the lapse of such a long period Will cannot be
challenged. As per the law, Will is always required to be proved by
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: TRILOK SINGH
SAVNER
Signing time: 25-08-2026
12:12:46
-52-
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-IND:24093
First Appeal No. 59/1968
the propounder of the Will.
91. Issue No. 7(a) has not been dealt with by the trial Court
properly. The endowment of the property to the temple by the
Maheshwari community was not conditional and there cannot be a
conditional endowment and thus the issue should be decided in a
manner that Maheshwari community gifted the property to the deity
of the temple without any condition. It is proved that Murlidas
executed the agreement (Ex.D/2) on 28.4.1919 and he consented to
the arrangement. Consequently Issue No. 7(b) has been decided
correctly. Issue No. 7(c) has not been decided correctly, because
neither Mahant Gopaldas nor Mahant Murlidas could transfer the
Shebait right to the Panchas of Maheshwari community, either by
Will or under any agreement. The right of management of the
property is with the Auqaf Department (Revenue Department). The
property belongs to the deity and, therefore, the Panchas of
Maheshwari community have no independent right. The issue is
decided accordingly. Similarly the Issue No. 7(d) has also been
decided wrongly by the trial Court by giving right to the
Maheshwari community to appoint or remove the priest of the
temple. Only Auqaf Department, which is now Revenue
Department work under the control of the Collector can appoint or
remove the Pujari.
ISSUE NO. 8,10,11(a),(b),14
92. These issues have been correctly decided by the trial court by
holding that the defendants No. 2 to 4 have been sued in the
representative capacity. The suit is properly valued. Proper court fee
has been paid and suit is not barred by the provisions of Section 32
of M.P. Public Trust Act. The Trial Court has correctly decided that
the brothers of the plaintiff are not necessary party in the case.
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: TRILOK SINGH
SAVNER
Signing time: 25-08-2026
12:12:46
-53-
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-IND:24093
First Appeal No. 59/1968
ISSUE NO. 9(a), (b)
93. These issues have been framed to consider the effect of the
release of the properties by Auqaf Department in favour of the
plaintiff. The trial court has held that the ex-parte order passed by
the Auqaf Department for releasing the subject Shrine from the
supervision and management was not in accordance with law. Once
a Shrine is taken under the supervision of the Auqaf Department,
thereafter the same cannot be released and the trial court has
correctly decided that the release order has no effect and the
concerned officer has no jurisdiction to rescind the ex-parte order.
ISSUE NO. 12
94. The plaintiff has filed the suit for declaration and injunction
and the defendant has raised the objection that a suit merely seeking
declaration and injunction without seeking consequential relief of
possession is not maintainable.
95. Learned Senior Advocate appearing on behalf of the
respondents No. 1 and 2 submits that the plaintiff has not prayed for
the relief of possession and in the absence of the relief of possession
the simplicitor suit for grant of declaration was not maintainable
according to the proviso to Section 34 of the Specific Relief Act.
He relied on the judgment delivered by Supreme Court in Vasantha
7
Vs. Rajalakshmi and in Saurav Jain & Ors. Vs. ABP Design &
2 7
another . In the matter of Vasantha , the Supreme Court has held
that the suit for declaration of title without seeking recovery of
possession is not maintainable when the plaintiff is not in
possession. The relevant part of the judgment reads as under:-
“49. We now proceed to examine the law on this issue.
As submitted by the learned Senior Counsel for the
appellant, in Vinay Krishna v. Keshav Chandra [Vinay
7
Vasantha Vs. Rajalakshmi, (2024) 5 SCC 282.
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: TRILOK SINGH
SAVNER
Signing time: 25-08-2026
12:12:46
-54-
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-IND:24093
First Appeal No. 59/1968
Krishna v. Keshav Chandra, 1993 Supp (3) SCC 129]
(two-Judge Bench), this Court while considering
Section 42 of the erstwhile Specific Relief Act, 1877 to
be pari materia with Section 34 of SRA, 1963 observed
that the plaintiff's not being in possession of the
property in that case ought to have amended the plaint
for the relief of recovery of possession in view of the bar
included by the proviso.
50. This position has been followed by this Court in
Union of India v. Ibrahim Uddin (two-Judge Bench),
elaborated the position of a suit filed without the
consequential relief. It was observed : (SCC p. 173,
paras 55-58)
“55. The section provides that courts have
discretion as to declaration of status or right,
however, it carves out an exception that a court
shall not make any such declaration of status or
right where the complainant, being able to seek
further relief than a mere declaration of title, omits
to do so.
56. In Ram Saran v. Ganga Devi [Ram Saran v.
Ganga Devi, (1973) 2 SCC 60] this Court had
categorically held that the suit seeking for
declaration of title of ownership but where
possession is not sought, is hit by the proviso to
Section 34 of the Specific Relief Act, 1963 and,
thus, not maintainable. In Vinay Krishna v. Keshav
Chandra [Vinay Krishna v. Keshav Chandra, 1993
Supp (3) SCC 129] this Court dealt with a similar
issue where the plaintiff was not in exclusive
possession of property and had filed a suit seeking
declaration of title of ownership. Similar view has
been reiterated observing that the suit was not
maintainable, if barred by the proviso to Section 34
of the Specific Relief Act. (See also Gian Kaur v.
Raghubir Singh [Gian Kaur v. Raghubir Singh,
(2011) 4 SCC 567 : (2011) 2 SCC (Civ) 366] .)
57. In view of the above, the law becomes crystal
clear that it is not permissible to claim the relief of
declaration without seeking consequential relief.
58. In the instant case, the suit for declaration of
title of ownership had been filed, though
Respondent 1-plaintiff was admittedly not in
possession of the suit property. Thus, the suit was
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: TRILOK SINGH
SAVNER
Signing time: 25-08-2026
12:12:46
-55-
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-IND:24093
First Appeal No. 59/1968
barred by the provisions of Section 34 of the
Specific Relief Act and, therefore, ought to have
been dismissed solely on this ground. The High
Court though framed a substantial question on this
point but for unknown reasons did not consider it
proper to decide the same.”
51. In Venkataraja v. Vidyane Doureradjaperumal
[Venkataraja v. Vidyane Doureradjaperumal, (2014) 14
SCC 502 : (2015) 1 SCC (Civ) 360] (two-Judge Bench),
the purpose behind Section 34 was elucidated by this
Court. It was observed that the purpose behind the
inclusion of the proviso is to prevent multiplicity of
proceedings. It was further expounded that a mere
declaratory decree remains non-executable in most
cases. This Court noted that the suit was never
amended, even at a later stage to seek the consequential
relief and therefore, it was held to be not maintainable.
This position of law has been reiterated recently in
Akkamma v. Vemavathi [Akkamma v. Vemavathi, (2021)
18 SCC 371] (two-Judge Bench).
52. This Court in Arulmigu Chokkanatha Swamy Koil
Trust v. Chandran [Arulmigu Chokkanatha Swamy Koil
Trust v. Chandran, (2017) 3 SCC 702 : (2017) 2 SCC
(Civ) 334] (two-Judge Bench), while reversing the High
Court decree, observed that because of Section 34 of
the SRA, 1963, the plaintiff not being in possession and
claiming only declaratory relief, ought to have claimed
the relief of recovery of possession. It was held that the
trial court rightly dismissed the suit on the basis that
the plaintiff has filed a suit for a mere declaration
without relief for recovery, which is clearly not
maintainable.”
6
96. In Saurav Jain the Supreme Court has held that a simplicitor
suit for declaration without seeking the consequential relief is not
maintainable. He submits that the trial court has correctly decided
the Issue No. 12 that without seeking the relief of possession, the
simplicitor suit for declaration and injunction was not maintainable
and thus no relief can be granted to the plaintiff in this appeal also.
He prays for dismissal of appeal on this ground.
97. Learned Government Advocate appearing on behalf of the
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: TRILOK SINGH
SAVNER
Signing time: 25-08-2026
12:12:46
-56-
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-IND:24093
First Appeal No. 59/1968
State supported the arguments of the learned Senior Advocate and
submits that the shrine and the properties attached to the temple was
in possession of Auqaf Department and the plaintiff filed the
simplicitor suit for declaration without seeking the relief of
possession and, therefore, the suit of the plaintiff was not
maintainable and was liable to be dismissed. The learned
Government Advocate also brought a letter of SDM on record,
whereby the SDM has informed to the learned Government
Advocate that as on 19.08.2026 the Shreeram Temple and Ramolla
Temple, Khachrod are under the control of the State and registered
as Devsthan and Collector is the manager of the temple. No land is
attached with the temple and Shri Maheshdas Bairagi, one of the
Legal Heirs of the appellant is appointed as Pujari by the State. List
of the government temples registered as Devsthan has also been
placed, which reflects that the subject temple is registered as
government temple. He submits that as the revenue department of
the State is managing the temple, without seeking the relief of
possession, the suit was not maintainable. Hence, the appeal is also
liable to be dismissed.
98. Learned counsel for appellant submits that the suit filed by the
plaintiff was maintainable as the plaintiff has not sought the relief
of declaration of title over the subject temple and its properties and
the plaintiff has just sought the right of Shebait and priest, therefore,
there was no occasion for the plaintiff to seek the relief of
possession. The possession of the temple is with the plaintiff and
the possession of some of the rooms and community hall are with
the Tehsildar and his possession is a constructive possession and he
is custodia legis , therefore, the suit without seeking the relief of
possession was maintainable.
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: TRILOK SINGH
SAVNER
Signing time: 25-08-2026
12:12:46
-57-
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-IND:24093
First Appeal No. 59/1968
99. After considering the arguments advanced by learned counsel
for parties, in the case in hand the plaintiff has not sought the
declaration of title of the temple and the deity is the owner of the
temple and the properties are attached to the temple. The plaintiff
was seeking the Shebait right to perform the duties of priest as
Mahant of Ramanand Sect and the plaintiff has been appointed by
the Auqaf Department, Pargana, Khachrod as priest of the temple,
therefore, there was no need to seek the relief of possession. The
property belongs to deity and managed by Collector and the
possession was with the Collector through Tehsildar, therefore, the
plaintiff, who was seeking right of management and worship was
not under obligation to seek any consequential relief and in fact no
consequential relief could be granted to the plaintiff. Consequently,
the objection raised by learned Senior Advocate on behalf of the
respondents is not acceptable. The trial court has wrongly decided
the issue No. 12 and the suit was maintainable without seeking the
relief of possession.
ISSUE NO. 13
100. This issue was framed upon the plea of the defendant
that the charge from the plaintiff was taken back on 12.09.1948;
therefore, the cause of action accrued to the plaintiff on 12.09.1948
for a suit for declaration, however, the present suit has been filed on
25.05.1954, which is barred by limitation.
101. Learned Senior Advocate on behalf of the respondents
submits that the suit for declaration should be filed within a period
of three years from the date of accruing the cause of action, whereas
the present suit has been filed after a period of five years and the
same cannot be treated in limitation. He submits that the charge was
given to the plaintiff by the Auqaf Committee on 12.09.1948 and
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: TRILOK SINGH
SAVNER
Signing time: 25-08-2026
12:12:46
-58-
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-IND:24093
First Appeal No. 59/1968
thereafter the charge was taken back from the plaintiff on
29.09.1949, therefore, the cause of action accrued to the plaintiff on
29.09.1949 to seek declaration in respect of the rights of the
plaintiff to manage the temple and thus the trial court has not
committed any error in deciding the issue against the plaintiff.
102. Counsel for appellant submits that the present suit has been
filed by the plaintiff seeking declaration in respect of the
management rights and performing the duties of the priest. As per
the plaint allegations even after taking back the charge of the
temple, the plaintiff continued to worship there and therefore, there
was no cause of action to file a suit for declaration and the suit was
within limitation.
103. After perusal of the record, it appears that the plaintiff was
appointed on 30.08.1948 as Pujari by the State government and
thereafter he had taken over the charge on 12.09.1948 from official
Manager appointed by Auqaf Department, thereafter an order was
passed and plaintiff was directed to handover the charge back to the
receiver, which was immediately complied with and plaintiff
returned the charge along with all the belongings to the government
receiver on 29.09.1949, however, the plaintiff continued to
discharge his duties as priest. No adverse order was passed against
the plaintiff. Even otherwise the right of worship is a continuous
right and thus the cause of action accrued continuously. Notice Ex.
P.32 was issued by the plaintiff through the Lawyer on 11.04.1953,
which was replied by the Under Secretary on behalf of the Madhya
Bharat State, Maal Department, Gwalior, whereby the plaintiff was
advised to approach to the competent court for decision of the
dispute and in furtherance of that the plaintiff has filed the present
suit within a period of three years from that day. For the purpose of
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: TRILOK SINGH
SAVNER
Signing time: 25-08-2026
12:12:46
-59-
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-IND:24093
First Appeal No. 59/1968
filing a suit for declaration the cause of action would arose to the
plaintiff on 27.11.1953, when the reply was issued by the State to
the notice of the plaintiff and consequently the suit filed by the
plaintiff was within limitation.
ISSUE NO. 15
104. The Senior Advocate on behalf of the respondents submits
that earlier the plaintiff filed a suit Ex. D/3 for permanent injunction
against the respondents in respect of the same property on the basis
of some allegations, which was dismissed in default on 27.03.1952,
thereafter it was not restored and plaintiff filed the second suit in
respect of the same property, therefore, the second suit is not
maintainable in view of the provisions of Order 9 Rule 9 of CPC,
because the earlier suit was not restored. He submits that if some
reliefs were not sought in the earlier suit, the plaintiff was precluded
from claiming those reliefs in the subsequent suit as the provisions
of Order 2 Rule 2 of CPC mandates that every suit shall include the
whole of the claim for which the plaintiff is entitled to seek in
respect of the cause of action and where plaintiff omits to sue or
intentionally relinquishes any portion of his claim, he would not
afterwards sue in respect of the portion omitted in relief. If a person
entitled for more than one relief in respect of the same cause of
action and omits to claim any of such relief, afterwards he cannot
sue for any such relief. He submits that considering the provisions
of Order 9 Rule 9 of CPC and Order 2 Rule 2 of CPC, the suit filed
by the plaintiff was not maintainable.
105. Counsel for appellant submits that the present suit was in
respect of different cause of action and the dismissal of earlier suit
had no bearing on the present suit. The trial court has already
considered this issue and decided that the suit has been filed against
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: TRILOK SINGH
SAVNER
Signing time: 25-08-2026
12:12:46
-60-
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-IND:24093
First Appeal No. 59/1968
the defendants in representative capacity after obtaining the
permission under Order 1 Rule 8 of CPC and in the earlier suit no
such permission was sought, therefore, both the suits cannot be
considered for the same relief in respect of same property by the
same parties in the same capacity, thus, the suit was maintainable.
106. After hearing learned counsel for parties and in view of the
observations made by this Court in respect of Issue No. 13 that the
present suit is filed in respect of a different cause of action accrued
to the plaintiff on 27.11.1953, when the reply was issued by Under
Secretary of the Madhya Bharat State that the plaintiff should
approach to the Civil Court for decision on the alleged rights or
authority to manage the temple. Earlier the Auqaf Department had
no objection in continuing the plaintiff and plaintiff continued to
perform the duties of the priest, however possession of the rooms
and community hall were taken by the Tehsildar, but the plaintiff
has been seeking only Shebait rights. The present suit is based on
different cause of action and earlier suit was based on different
cause of action, therefore, neither the provisions of Order 2 Rule 2
of CPC are applicable nor the provisions of Order 9 Rule 9 of CPC
bars the suit and the suit was maintainable.
CONCLUSIONS :
107. In view of the above discussion, this Court is of the view that
it is proved in the case that the Shreeram temple Khachrod is an
ancient temple having the idol of Lord Shreeram, Jankiji,
Laxmanji, Hanumanji, Laxminarayanji and Gopalji and deity is the
owner of the entire shrine and the properties attached to the temple.
Mahant Gopaldas was managing the temple and after his death his
disciple Mahant Murlidas was managing the temple, who requested
to Auqaf Department of Gwalior State to take over the charge of the
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: TRILOK SINGH
SAVNER
Signing time: 25-08-2026
12:12:46
-61-
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-IND:24093
First Appeal No. 59/1968
temple, which was accepted and the temple was registered as
government temple in the records and Mahant Murlidas was
appointed as priest on monthly salary by Auqaf Department,
however, after the death of Mahant Murlidas the Maheshwari
panchas raised the objection on the claim of the plaintiff in respect
of the succession of the seat.
108. The ascetics of Ramanand Sect performed the Bhekh
ceremony and nominated the plaintiff as Mahant of the seat by
handing over him the kanthi and chaddar and thereafter the name of
the plaintiff was duly mutated in the record as Mahant of the seat.
Auqaf Department also appointed plaintiff as priest by order dated
30.08.1948 and handed over the charge on 12.09.1948, however,
upon the complaint of Maheshwari Panchaas the charge was taken
back on 29.09.1949.
109. Thereafter when the plaintiff issued a notice to the
government and Collector, it was replied that the plaintiff should
approach to the court to seek redress of his rights and the plaintiff
has filed the present suit.
110. It is also proved by the respondent nos. 2 and 3 that the
Maheshwari Panchaas and members of Maheshwari Community are
the devotees of the temple and had gifted / donated huge amount for
the purpose of development of the temple campus and maintenance
of the temple.
111.
In the opinion of this court, the trial court has committed an
error in dismissing the suit, whereas the plaintiff has proved his
status of priest (Pujari) by oral and documentary evidence.
Consequently the appeal is partly allowed to the following extent :-
[a] The judgment and decree dated 28.06.1968 passed by
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: TRILOK SINGH
SAVNER
Signing time: 25-08-2026
12:12:46
-62-
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-IND:24093
First Appeal No. 59/1968
Additional Judge to the Court of District Judge, Ujjain in Civil
Original suit No. 22/54 (New No. 11A/68) is hereby set aside.
[
[b] It is declared that deity of Shriram is the absolute owner
of Sheeram temple, Ramolla, Khachrod and all the movable
and immovable properties attached to that temple.
[c] It is declared that Sheeram temple, Ramolla, Khachrod
is being managed by State under the Revenue Department.
[d] It is also declared that the Auqaf Department had
authority to appoint the Pujari and the plaintiff Ratandas was
duly appointed as Pujari of the temple on 30.04.1948 and had
rights to perform the duties of Pujari in the temple.
[e] The members of Maheshwari Samaj are the devotees of
the temple, and decree of perpetual injunction for restraining
them is declined.
[f] No order as to costs.
Accordingly, the appeal is partly allowed. Decree be drawn up.
Record of the trial court be returned along with the copy of this
judgment and decree.
( VINAY SARAF )
JUDGE
Trilok/VM
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: TRILOK SINGH
SAVNER
Signing time: 25-08-2026
12:12:46