Pooja Upadhyay vs Chandramani And Anr.

Court
Gauhati High Court

Page No.# 1/13
GAHC010043752025

2026:GAU-AS:14280
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : Crl.Pet./251/2025
POOJA UPADHYAY
D/O JAGDISH UPADHYAY
R/O VILL-BALEMU
PIN-790002
DIST. WEST KAMENG, ARUNACHAL PRADESH.
VERSUS
CHANDRAMANI AND ANR.
S/O VINDHYACHAL PATHAK
R/OVILL-KANT DIHESH
P.O. BHUJAINI
DIST.SANT KABIR NAGAR,
PIN-272175, UTTAR PRADESH.
2:THE STATE OF ASSAM
REP BY THE PP
ASSAM
: BEFORE ::
HON’BLE MRS. JUSTICE SHAMIMA JAHAN


For the Petitioner :
Mr. M. Nath, Senior Adv.
Mr. A. Bhattacharjee, Adv.
For the Respondent : Mr. B. Sharma, APP
Petitioner in Person

Page No.# 2/13
Date of Hearing : 11.09.2026
Date of Judgment : 25.09.2026

JUDGMENT & ORDER
1. Heard Mr. M. Nath, learned Senior Counsel assisted by Mr. A.
Bhattacharjee, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner and Mr. B.
Sharma, learned APP for the state as well as the Petitioner in Person
as Respondent No. 1.
2. By this application, filed under Section 528 read with Sections 438
and 442 of the BNSS, 2023, the petitioner has prayed for quashing of
the complaint case registered as C.R. Case No. 616/2024 under
Sections 195/384 of the IPC pending before the Court of the learned
st
Judicial Magistrate, 1 Class, Kamrup (M), Guwahati, Assam. The
petitioner has also challenged the order dated 09.09.2024 passed by
st
the learned Judicial Magistrate, 1 Class, Kamrup (M) in C.R. Case No.
616/2024 whereby the final report submitted by the police was
rejected, the FIR was accepted and a direction was issued for
registration of the complaint case. The petitioner has further
challenged the order dated 13.11.2024 passed by the learned JMFC,
Kamrup (M) whereby cognizance of the offences under Sections
195/384 of the IPC was taken against the petitioner in the aforesaid
complaint case. Furthermore, the petitioner has challenged the orders
dated 28.11.2024 and 20.01.2025 whereby the learned Judicial
st
Magistrate, 1 Class, Kamrup (M) issued bailable warrants of arrest
against the petitioner in the said complaint case.

Page No.# 3/13

3. It is the case of the petitioner that she is working as a teacher in
Arunachal Pradesh and that she was introduced through social media
to the brother of Respondent No. 1, namely, Chandan Pathak who was
working as an Assistant Engineer in the PWD at Bayrampur, in the
State of Uttar Pradesh. The petitioner further stated that over time
their friendship grew and that the brother of Respondent No. 1 took
her nude photographs through video calls and thereafter started
blackmailing her by making continuous calls. The petitioner further
stated that the brother of Respondent No. 1 demanded an amount of
Rs. 5 lakhs from her and called her to a hotel where he allegedly
mixed intoxicating substances in her coffee and forcibly raped her. She
further stated that when she tried to resist and call the police
personnel he broke her mobile phones and attempted to kill her. She
thereafter stated that the brother of Respondent No. 1 had introduced
her to his parents and had promised to marry her. She further stated
that sindoor was put on her head after taking her to the Kamakhya
Temple. However, she subsequently stated that when she requested
him to marry her, he threatened to kill her and further threatened to
post her nude photographs and videos on social media. Stating the
aforesaid facts, the petitioner lodged a complaint before the Senior
Superintendent of Police, Guwahati, Paltan Bazar which was registered
as Paltan Bazar P.S. Case No. 97/2023. It is the further case of the
petitioner that on 12.03.2023, the brother of Respondent No. 1 asked
her to meet him in Guwahati and directed her to book a hotel in
Guwahati. She stated that under threat she was asked to book the
hotel by representing themselves as a married couple.

Page No.# 4/13

4. The petitioner further stated that the brother of Respondent No. 1
reached Guwahati by train on 15.02.2023 at around 9:30 p.m. and
asked her to decorate the hotel room to which she agreed and that
photographs were also taken on that night. Thereafter, the petitioner
stated that on 17.02.2023, the brother of Respondent No. 1 took her
to the Kamakhya Temple and after returning to the hotel she
requested him to get coffee. He brought coffee from outside and after
consuming the same she became unconscious. She alleged that at
that juncture, the brother of Respondent No. 1 raped her. When she
tried to call the police he broke her telephone. She further stated that
he had promised to marry her and had put sindoor on her head and
by calling his father pretended that he was serious about her and
would marry her. However, he subsequently refused to marry her.
5. It is the further case of the petitioner that the police investigated the
case pursuant to the FIR lodged by her and upon finding a prima facie
case submitted a charge-sheet on 18.11.2023 vide Charge-Sheet No.
460/2023. Thereafter, the petitioner stated that Respondent No. 1
went to her house in Arunachal Pradesh, abused her father and
demanded money. In respect of the aforesaid incident she filed a
complaint case on 13.01.2024 which was thereafter forwarded to the
police for investigation. Upon completion of the investigation, the
police submitted a charge-sheet on 23.09.2024 under Section 500
read with Section 34 of the IPC against Respondent No. 1 as well as
the brother of Respondent No. 1, namely, Chandan Pathak.
6. In the meantime, Respondent No. 1 filed a cross-case on 08.10.2023

Page No.# 5/13
before the Officer-in-Charge of Paltan Bazar Police Station which was
registered as Paltan Bazar P.S. Case No. 450/2023 under Section 420
of the IPC. In the said FIR, Respondent No. 1 stated that the
petitioner along with a group of persons went to Hotel Chirom and
manipulated the records of the said hotel particularly the hotel
register. It was alleged that the petitioner by using whitener inserted
the name of his brother in the hotel register against the date
15.02.2023. He further stated that at the time mentioned in the said
entry, his brother was travelling by train from Lucknow to Guwahati.
Respondent No. 1 stated that the petitioner had reached Guwahati
one day prior to the arrival of his brother, i.e. on 14.02.2023 at around
1:09 p.m. and that she had manipulated the date in the register of the
said hotel by inserting the time of arrival at 12:57 p.m. on 15.02.2023.
7. The petitioner stated that the police investigated the said case and
submitted a final report on 30.12.2023. Thereafter, on 07.09.2024
Respondent No. 1 filed a protest petition being Protest Petition No.
3869/2024. By order dated 09.09.2024, the learned Judicial
st
Magistrate, 1 Class, Kamrup (M) rejected the final report and upon
accepting the protest petition directed registration of a complaint case.
The petitioner further stated that the learned Court upon perusal of
the initial statements of Respondent No. 1 and his brother observed
that the Investigating Officer had submitted the final report in a
routine and casual manner. Pursuant thereto the complaint case was
registered as C.R. Case No. 616/2024 and cognizance was taken on
13.11.2024 for the offences under Sections 195/384 of the IPC against

Page No.# 6/13
the petitioner. The petitioner further stated that subsequent thereto a
bailable warrant of arrest was issued against her. The petitioner also
stated that Respondent No. 1 had lodged another complaint case on
06.04.2024 which was registered as C.R. Case No. 272/2024.
However, it was stated that Respondent No. 1 did not appear in the
said case and as a result the case remained pending before the
learned JMFC, Kamrup (M), Guwahati. The petitioner further stated
that the brother of Respondent No. 1 had lodged complaint cases in
the State of Uttar Pradesh which resulted in submission of final reports
on the ground of want of jurisdiction. She thereafter submitted that
the brother of Respondent No. 1 had also filed protest petitions in
those cases which are pending disposal. The present proceeding
relates to the complaint case registered as C.R. Case No. 616/2024
which has been challenged by the petitioner along with the order
taking cognizance and the orders issuing warrants of arrest.
8. The learned Senior Counsel appearing on behalf of the petitioner
submitted before this Court that the protest petition filed by
Respondent No. 1 on 07.09.2024 was not maintainable inasmuch as
an application had already been filed by Respondent No. 1 and his
brother on 06.04.2024. He submitted that the final report in respect of
the FIR lodged by Respondent No. 1 had already been submitted by
the police on 30.12.2023. Thereafter, Respondent No. 1 and his
brother had filed a complaint case under Section 210 read with
Section 200 of the Cr.P.C. praying for taking cognizance of the
offences punishable under the relevant provisions of the IPC and other
statutes along with the police report submitted under Section 173(2)

Page No.# 7/13
of the Cr.P.C. by discarding the said report on the ground of defective
investigation. A further prayer was made for a direction for fair
investigation into the complaint by an independent agency. The
learned Senior Counsel thereafter submitted that the instant complaint
case was filed after submission of the final report by the police and is
in substance, in the nature of a protest petition filed by Respondent
No. 1 and his brother. He submitted that the prayers made in the said
complaint also demonstrate that Respondent No. 1 and his brother
were aware of the final report and had specifically prayed for
discarding the same.
9. The learned counsel thereafter submitted that Respondent No. 1
subsequently filed a protest petition on 07.09.2024 seeking
substantially the same reliefs, rejection of the conclusion of the
Investigating Officer in FIR No. 450/2023 as reflected in Final Report
No. 4949/2023 and taking of cognizance of the offences. He submitted
that the said protest petition was not maintainable as Respondent No.
1 had already instituted a complaint case seeking to challenge the
report submitted by the Investigating Officer. In support of his
submission the learned counsel placed reliance upon the judgment of
the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Subrata Choudhury @ Santosh
Choudhury v. State of Assam reported in AIR 2024 SC 5690 wherein
according to the learned counsel it has been held that a second
complaint is maintainable only where the earlier complaint petition
had been dismissed for default and not on merits. The learned counsel
appearing for the petitioner also placed reliance upon the judgment of
the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Kusha Daruka v. State of Odisha,

Page No.# 8/13
reported in AIR 2024 SC 790 wherein the Hon'ble Supreme Court
deprecated the practice of suppression of material facts. He submitted
that the complaint filed by Respondent No. 1 and his brother on
06.04.2024 is still pending and as such the subsequent complaint case
being C.R. Case No. 616/2024 is not maintainable. He therefore
submitted that the subsequent orders passed in the said complaint
case are also liable to be quashed.
10. On the other hand, Respondent No. 1 appearing in person submits
before this Court that he had filed a complaint on 08.10.2023 which
was registered as Paltan Bazar P.S. Case No. 450/2023 alleging
manipulation by the petitioner in the register of the hotel where she
and his brother had stayed from 15.02.2023 to 19.02.2023. He
submits that the said allegation was not properly investigated. He
further submits that having received information in that regard he filed
a complaint under Section 210 read with Section 200 of the Cr.P.C.
which was registered as C.R. Case No. 272/2024. Respondent No. 1
appearing in person submits that neither he nor his brother had any
knowledge regarding submission of the final report as they had not
received any notice from the concerned Court. He further submits that
the Investigating Officer had indicated his intention to submit a
closure report and being aggrieved thereby he filed the aforesaid
complaint case not only under Section 200 of the Cr.P.C. but also
under Section 210 CrPC thereof. He submits that the expression
“report” used in the prayer portion of the said complaint does not
refer to the final report submitted by the Investigating Officer but to a
report contemplated under Section 210 of the Cr.P.C. He further

Page No.# 9/13
submits that he was informed that the final report would be submitted
before the Court on 07.09.2024 and accordingly he filed the protest
petition against the same. By the said protest petition, he prayed that
the Court should reject the conclusion of the Investigating Officer and
take cognizance of the offences. He submits that the said protest
petition is not a second protest petition as alleged by the learned
counsel for the petitioner. Respondent No. 1 appearing as petitioner in
person, in support of his submissions has placed reliance upon the
judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Shiv Shankar Singh v. State
of Bihar & Anr. reported in AIR Online 2011 SC 447 as well as the
judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Pradeep S. Wodeyar v.
State of Karnataka rendered in Criminal Appeal No. 1288/2021.
11. I have heard the learned counsel for the parties and have carefully
perused the records of the case. It is the mandate of law that upon
submission of a final report by the Investigating Officer, notice ought
to be issued to the informant by the Court before which the final
report is submitted. In the present case, it is seen that Respondent
No. 1 and his brother are residents of the State of Uttar Pradesh and
that the brother of Respondent No. 1 is working as an Assistant
Engineer in the PWD in the State of Uttar Pradesh. However, the
informant in the case registered at Paltan Bazar Police Station was
Respondent No. 1 and not his brother. There is therefore a possibility
that notice was issued to Respondent No. 1 but that he did not receive
the same. It is further noticed that after a period of almost four
months from the submission of the final report in Paltan Bazar P.S.
Case No. 450/2023, Respondent No. 1 and his brother filed a

Page No.# 10/13
complaint before the learned Chief Judicial Magistrate, Kamrup (M),
Guwahati under Section 200 read with Section 210 of the Cr.P.C. In
the said complaint petition Respondent No. 1 and his brother stated
that it was the petitioner who had checked into the hotel room on
14.02.2023 and that the brother of Respondent No. 1 had reached the
hotel on 15.02.2023 at around 9:45 p.m.
12. It is further stated in the said complaint that after some time the
petitioner along with a group of persons had gone to the said hotel
and manipulated the records by changing the date and time of check-
in to 15.02.2023 at 12:47 p.m. allegedly in connivance with the hotel
staff. It was specifically stated in the said complaint that the
Investigating Officer had indicated his intention to submit a closure
report and that being aggrieved thereby Respondent No. 1 and his
brother had instituted the complaint case. Had Respondent No. 1 been
aware of the submission of the final report there would have been no
occasion for him to invoke Section 210 of the Cr.P.C. Section 210 of
the Cr.P.C. contemplates that where a complaint case is instituted and
it comes to the notice of the Court that an investigation by the police
in respect of the same offence is pending, the Court shall stay the
proceedings of the complaint case and call for a report from the police
officer conducting the investigation.
13. It is this provision that Respondent No. 1 appears to have invoked
apprehending that the Investigating Officer would submit a final report
in connection with the case lodged by him. It can also reasonably be
concluded that the reference to the “report” in the prayer made by

Page No.# 11/13
Respondent No. 1 was in the context of Section 210 of the Cr.P.C. The
other prayer made in the said application seeking a direction for a fair
investigation also indicates that Respondent No. 1 was not aware of
the submission of the final report. Further, it is seen that during the
pendency of the said complaint case being C.R. Case No. 272/2024
although the complainant was not personally present, he took steps in
the matter on subsequent dates. It is further noticed that on
07.09.2024 Respondent No. 1 filed a protest petition against Final
Report No. 4949/2023 dated 30.12.2023 submitted by the
Investigating Officer in connection with Paltan Bazar P.S. Case No.
450/2023. A bare perusal of the said protest petition makes it
abundantly clear that Respondent No. 1 had expressed his grievance
by alleging that the petitioner along with others had gone to the hotel
and altered the guest entry register by inserting the name of his
brother therein along with other particulars.
14. By the said protest petition, Respondent No. 1 prayed for rejection
of the conclusion arrived at by the Investigating Officer in connection
with the said Paltan Bazar P.S. case and for taking cognizance of the
offences. The prayers made in the two applications, i.e., the complaint
case being C.R. Case No. 272/2024 and the subsequent C.R. Case No.
616/2024 are however materially different. It cannot therefore be said
that the complaint case filed on 07.09.2024 was a second complaint or
that the complaint case filed on 06.04.2024 was the first protest
petition. It also cannot be said that Respondent No. 1 had filed one
complaint after another as the two proceedings stand on different
footing. Accordingly, this Court does not deem it appropriate to quash

Page No.# 12/13
C.R. Case No. 616/2024 or the subsequent orders passed therein.
15. The Hon'ble Supreme Court in Mahesh Chand v. B. Janardhan
Reddy & Anr. reported in AIR 2003 SC 702 dealt with a somewhat
similar situation. In that case, the complainant had lodged an FIR
pursuant to which investigation was conducted. In the meantime,
being dissatisfied with the investigation carried out by the police
authorities, the complainant filed a criminal complaint before the
Court. Upon completion of the investigation in connection with the
first FIR the police submitted a final report against which the
complainant filed a protest petition. The Court however accepted the
final report and simultaneously closed the complaint case filed by the
complainant. Thereafter, the complainant filed a third complaint on the
same set of facts. The said complaint was challenged on the ground
that it was barred and the High Court quashed the same. The matter
was carried before the Hon'ble Supreme Court and the Court held that
the view taken by the High Court that the second complaint was
completely barred was not correct. The Hon'ble Supreme Court
observed that there is no statutory bar against filing a second
complaint on the same facts. It was further held that where a previous
complaint is dismissed without assigning any reasons, a second
complaint is maintainable. In the present case, the distinguishing
feature is that the earlier complaint case was not closed and on the
basis of the protest petition the learned JMFC, Kamrup (M) took
cognizance of the offences against the petitioner. The order taking
cognizance therefore cannot be said to be unsustainable in law. The
case relied upon by the learned counsel for the petitioner in Subrata

Page No.# 13/13
Choudhury (supra) stands on a different footing. In the said case, it
was noticed that the learned Chief Judicial Magistrate had accepted
the final report after hearing the complainant on the protest petition
and that the subsequent complaint on the same set of allegations was
held to be barred. The facts of the present case however are different.
16. In the present case, the respondent had earlier filed a complaint
petition being dissatisfied with the investigation conducted by the
police. Upon subsequently coming to know that the final report had
been submitted the respondent filed a protest petition challenging the
said final report. The said protest petition was thereafter considered
by the learned JMFC, Kamrup (M) and cognizance was taken. In the
facts and circumstances of the present case, this Court is of the
considered view that the said proceeding is not barred under any
provision of law.
17. Accordingly, the present petition stands dismissed and disposed of.


JUDGE
Comparing Assistant