Safiuddin Ali vs The State Of Assam

Court
Gauhati High Court

Page No.# 1/25
GAHC010269512025

2026:GAU-
AS:17224-DB

THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : CRL.A(J)/192/2025
SAFIUDDIN ALI
S/O- LATE IBRAHIM ALI, R/O- BIDYAPARA PT-II, P.S. AND DIST. DHUBRI,
ASSAM
VERSUS
THE STATE OF ASSAM
REPRESENTED BY THE PUBLIC PROSECUTOR, ASSAM
2:SHARIF ALI
S/O LATE SHAHAJAHAN
BIYAPARA PART-II
DHUBRI
DHUBRI
ASSAM
INDIA
MOBILE NO. 91-789670011
Advocate for the Petitioner : , DR. P AGARWAL, LEGAL AID COUNSEL
Advocate for the Respondent : PP, ASSAM, MS. S NATH, LEGAL AID COUNSEL FOR R 2

BEFORE

HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE MICHAEL ZOTHANKHUMA
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJEEV KUMAR SHARMA

Page No.# 2/25
Date on which judgment is reserved : 12.11.2026
Date of pronouncement of judgment : 20.11.2026
Whether the pronouncement is of the : N/A
operative part of the judgment ?
Whether the full judgment has been : Yes
pronounced?

JUDGMENT & ORDER (CAV)
(Sanjeev Kumar Sharma, J)

Heard Dr. P Agarwal, learned Legal Aid Counsel appearing for the appellant.
Also heard Ms. B Bhuyan, learned Legal Aid Counsel & Addl. Public Prosecutor,
assisted by Ms. R Saloi, as well as Ms. S Nath, learned Legal Aid Counsel
representing for the respondent No. 2/informant.
2. This is a jail appeal against the judgment dated 09.09.2025 passed by the
Court of the Additional Sessions Judge-cum-Special Judge, POCSO, Dhubri, in
Special Case No. 431/2024, arising out of Dhubri P.S Case no. 68/2024, by
which the appellant has been convicted under Section 6 of the POCSO Act.
3. The factual matrix :
1. The brief fact of the case of the prosecution is that the complainant
namely Sharis Ali lodged an ejahar against the accused namely Safiuddin Ali
before the Bazar TOP of Dhubri Police Station on 05.03.2024 alleging inter-alia

Page No.# 3/25
that on 05.03.2024 at about 11 AM, the informant's had a minor daughter aged
about 7 years 4 months, and the accused enticed and took her to his house and
committed rape upon her. After that, the victim came out from the house of the
accused and informed about the matter to her mother by crying that accused
had done wrong with her by putting off her pant and when she tried to raise
hue and cry, the accused gagged her mouth with his hand and for that reason
she was unable to raise alarm.
Accordingly, the informant is praying for taking necessary action.
2. After getting the information police registered the case being Dhubri
P.S. Case No. 68/24 under section 376AB of IPC and R/W section 6 of the
Protection of Children from Sexual Offence Act, 2012 (hereinafter referred as
POCSO Act) and investigated the same and after completion of investigation
police has submitted the charge-sheet against the accused Safiuddin Ali under
section 376AB of IPC R/W Section 6 of POCSO Act.
3. On appearance, copy was furnished to the accused person. Formal
charges are framed against the accused person under section 376AB of IPC R/W
section 6 of the POCSO Act. The charge so framed are read over to the accused
person to which he pleaded not guilty and claimed to be tried.

Page No.# 4/25
4. In support of the prosecution case, prosecution side examined 10
(Ten) witnesses, including the victim and the complainant. The statement of the
accused person was recorded under Section 313 Cr.P.C. and thereafter both
sides' arguments were heard at length. Defence has adduced no evidence.
4. The trial culminated with the conviction and sentencing of the accused
appellant as above. Hence, this appeal.
5. The evidence:
1. PW-1/Sharis Ali @ Sarif Ali stated in his evidence-in-chief that he is the
informant in this case. The victim is his daughter. He knows the accused,
Safiuddin Ali, who was present at the dock that day. The incident took place
about four months ago. His victim daughter was aged 7 years and 2 months. On
the day of the incident, he went to pay the electricity bill. Thereafter, his wife
called him and informed him that the villagers had seen the accused taking his
daughter to his house and locking the door. Then, his wife, along with some
villagers, went to the house of the accused and knocked on the door. The
accused opened the door and, on seeing the people, ran away. His daughter
also ran away from the house of the accused and, due to fear, concealed herself
in the house of their neighbour. Thereafter, he brought his daughter from the

Page No.# 5/25
house of their neighbour, and his daughter informed his wife that she had been
raped by the accused, Safiuddin Ali. Thereafter, he went to the police station
along with his daughter to lodge this case. After the case was filed, the police
sent his daughter for recording her statement under Section 164 Cr.P.C. and also
sent her for medical examination. Ext. P-1/PW-1 is the ejahar, and Ext. P-
1(1)/PW-1 is his signature. During the course of investigation, the police seized
the birth certificate of his daughter, which was given in his zimma. Ext. P-2/PW-
1 is the seizure list, and Ext. P-2(1)/PW-1 is his signature.
2. In his cross-examination, he stated that the house of the accused is
adjacent to his house and, hence, the accused is his neighbour. His house is
situated on the eastern side and the house of the accused is situated on the
western side. The accused uses his land to enter and exit.
He denied that, for the aforesaid reason, there is a dispute between him
and the accused. He also denied that the case was falsely lodged against the
accused.
The accused has four sons and three daughters-in-law. Only one son and
his wife have been living in that house with the accused. The grandchildren of
the accused are aged about 5 years, 2 years and 1 year. The wife of the
accused also resides in the same house. The neighbours who saw the accused

Page No.# 6/25
closing the door after taking his daughter inside his house are Sahinuri Khatun,
Sahera Begum, Beli, etc. On the western side of the accused's house is the
house of Sahera Begum; on the northern side is the house of Beli; and on the
southern side is the house of Sahinur Khatun. The police went to their houses.
He denied that he had not stated in his statement recorded before the
police that, "On the day of the incident, he went to pay the electricity bill. Then
his wife called him and informed him that the villagers had seen the accused
taking his daughter to his house and locking the door of his house. Then his
wife, along with some villagers, went to the house of the accused and knocked
on the door of his house." He denied that there was a land dispute between him
and the accused and that, for that reason, he had falsely filed this case. He also
denied that the accused did not commit rape upon his daughter.
The area where his house is situated is thickly populated. The incident
took place on the 5th, but he cannot remember the month. The incident took
place at about 11:15 AM. At around 11:00 AM, people generally remain at their
respective houses. The age of the accused is below 70 years.
He denied that there is no approach road to his house and that he has to
use the land of the accused to enter and exit his house, due to which there is a
dispute between them and, for that reason, he lodged this false case against

Page No.# 7/25
the accused. He also denied that the accused is not related to this case.
3. PW-2/Victim, in her evidence-in-chief, stated that she told her mother
that the accused (Baro Abba) had committed a misdeed with her. The accused
brought her inside his house and locked the door. Out of fear, she started
crying, and the accused gagged her mouth with his hands.
4. In her cross-examination, she stated that she does not know the name
of the accused.
5. PW-3/Morzina Khatun, in her evidence-in-chief, stated that the
informant is her husband and the victim is her daughter. She knows the
accused, Safiuddin Ali, who was present at the dock that day. The incident took
place about two months ago. Her daughter was aged 7 years and 2 months. On
the day of the incident, the daughter of her brother-in-law called her daughter
to play. When the victim was not found, she asked the daughter of her brother-
in-law about her whereabouts, and the latter told her that the victim was in the
house of her brother-in-law. Thereafter, Sumaiya, the daughter of her brother-
in-law, went to the house of the accused and knocked on the door. The accused
then opened the door, and they saw that the victim was there in a half-naked
condition. She was not wearing her frock. Thereafter, her daughter ran away to
the house of a neighbour, and her husband brought her home. Subsequently,

Page No.# 8/25
her husband lodged this case.
6. In her cross-examination, she deposed that the house of the accused is
adjacent to her house. The accused uses her land to enter and exit. The
accused demanded that the pathway be treated as part of his house. There is a
dispute between them and the accused regarding the pathway. The accused has
three sons and three daughters-in-law. The accused has one granddaughter and
two grandsons who reside in the same house. There are about 8–10 persons
residing in the house of the accused. Her house is situated on the eastern side,
and the house of the accused is situated on the western side. On the western
side of the accused's house is the house of her other brother-in-law, whose
name she does not know, and four persons also reside in that house. On the
northern side of the accused's house is the house of a person whose name she
cannot remember. On the southern side is the house of another person whose
name she cannot remember. All their neighbours are their relatives.
She denied that there are land disputes between them and others. She
also denied that the victim was not found in a half-naked condition and that she
was wearing her frock.
She had not witnessed the incident in this case. Her daughter had also not
stated anything to her about the incident. She denied that this case is a false

Page No.# 9/25
case.
She brought her daughter from the house of one of their neighbours,
namely, Jamila, who is her sister-in-law, at 12:00 PM. The area where her house
is situated is thickly populated. About 200–300 persons reside in their locality.
She cannot state the names of the neighbours. She also cannot say who have
been cited as witnesses by the I.O. She denied that she deposed falsely that
day. The police came to the place of occurrence. She was not present when the
police came. She cannot say whether the police seized anything in connection
with this case or not. She denied that the accused is not involved in this case.
7. PW-4/Mofizul Hoque, in his evidence-in-chief, stated that he knows the
informant in this case. He also knows the victim, who is the daughter of the
informant. He knows the accused, Safiuddin Ali, who was present at the dock
that day. The incident took place about 11 months ago. His house is adjacent to
the houses of both the informant and the accused. On the day of the incident,
his wife called him and told him that she had heard some hue and cry from the
house of the complainant and asked him to come home. When he came home,
he found many people gathered at the house of the complainant. He does not
know what had happened at the house of the informant or why the accused
was apprehended.

Page No.# 10/25
8. In his cross-examination, he stated that he does not know anything
about the case. He also does not know why the hue and cry took place at the
house of the informant.
9. PW-5/Salim Ali, in his evidence-in-chief, stated that the informant in this
case is his brother and the victim is his niece. He knows the accused, Safiuddin
Ali, who was present at the dock that day. The incident took place about one
year ago. At the time of the incident, the victim was about 10 years old. His
house is adjacent to the houses of both the informant and the accused. On the
day of the incident, he was present at his grill shop. Thereafter, his wife called
him and asked him to come home. When he came home, he came to know from
his wife that the accused had tried to commit rape upon the victim. When he
came home, he did not find the accused or the victim there. Thereafter, he went
to the police station and found the victim there.
10. In his cross-examination, he stated that, at the time of the incident,
he was present at his shop. The name of his wife is Sainuri Khatun. She called
him from a mobile phone, but the police did not collect her phone number from
him. When he returned home, he did not find the victim or the accused there,
nor did he find any proof of any incident. He denied that the accused did not try
to commit rape upon the victim. He did not state where he went after returning

Page No.# 11/25
home. He denied that the informant had a land dispute with the accused. He
cannot state the exact date and time of the incident. The police did not make
his wife a witness in this case. He denied that his wife did not call him on the
date of the incident. He also denied that his brother had lodged this case falsely
in conspiracy with him. He denied that the accused is not related to this case.
11. PW-6/Tasmina Khatun, in her evidence-in-chief, stated that the
informant in this case is her brother. She also knows the victim. She knows the
accused, Safiuddin Ali, who is also her brother and was present at the dock that
day. The incident took place about one year ago. On the day of the incident, she
was present at her father's house. The house of the accused is situated near her
father's house. She was preparing to go back to her matrimonial house at
Natabari. Then her sister-in-law, who is the mother of the victim, came to her
parents' house and asked her about the whereabouts of the victim girl. She
replied that the victim was not at her parents' house and might have been
playing with her daughter. However, her daughter replied that the victim was
not with her. Thereafter, the mother of the victim searched for her, but she
could not be found. After that, the mother of the victim started crying and
stated that the victim had been ruined. Then all the neighbourhood people
gathered there. Thereafter, the father of the victim brought her from the house
of her paternal aunt. At the time of the incident, the victim was about 7 years

Page No.# 12/25
old. At that stage, the witness was declared hostile.
12. In her cross-examination by the prosecution, she denied having stated
before the police that the mother of the victim came crying and alleged that the
accused, Safiuddin, had committed a misdeed with the victim girl. She further
denied having stated that, initially, she did not believe the allegation, but later,
when she asked the victim, the victim told her that her uncle had asked her to
bring a 'bidi' for him and that, when she brought the 'bidi', her uncle pulled
down and removed her pant. Thereafter, he made her sit on the bed, separated
her legs and pushed her backwards. Then her uncle removed his 'lungi' and
inserted his penis into her vagina. Thereafter, her stomach was paining and she
suffered bleeding. She resisted the act, but he did not stop. However, she did
not know what her uncle had done to her. Thereafter, they brought the victim to
the police station. She denied that, as the accused is her brother, she had
deposed falsely before the Court that day in order to save him. She also denied
that she was present at the place of occurrence and had witnessed the incident.
13. In her cross-examination by the defence, she stated that she had not
stated before the police that the mother of the victim came crying and alleged
that the accused, Safiuddin, had committed a misdeed with the victim girl. She
further stated that she had not made any statement regarding the alleged

Page No.# 13/25
incident involving the victim and her uncle, as narrated above. The informant is
also her brother.
14. PW-7/Sumaiya Sultana, in her evidence-in-chief, stated that the
informant in this case is her paternal uncle. The victim is her sister and the
daughter of the informant. She knows the accused, Safiuddin Ali, who is also
her paternal uncle and was present at the dock that day. The incident took place
about one year ago. On the day of the incident, at about 10:00–11:00 AM, the
mother of the victim was searching for her daughter, but she could not be
found. She was also searching for the victim and went to the house of the
accused in search of her. There, she found the victim lying on a bed inside the
house of the accused. The victim was naked, and the accused was lying over
her body. At that time, the accused was committing rape upon the victim.
Thereafter, she returned home. When the victim returned from the house of the
accused, she asked her about the incident, and the victim told her that the
accused had committed rape upon her. Thereafter, she informed the mother of
the victim about the incident. The police recorded her statement.
15. In her cross-examination, she stated that the house of the accused is
situated adjacent to their house. She denied that there are land disputes
between the accused and the informant. At the time of the incident, she was

Page No.# 14/25
playing outside her house. She went to the houses of Sahera Bibi and Hamida in
search of the victim. The accused has four sons, three of whom are married.
The eldest son of the accused has three children, while the second eldest son
has one child. The wife of the accused is alive. All of them reside together in the
house of the accused.
She denied that she had deposed falsely that she was also searching for
the victim and had gone to the house of the accused in search of her, where she
found the victim lying on a bed, naked, with the accused lying over her body.
She denied that there are land disputes between her family and the
accused and that, for that reason, this case was filed to harass the accused. She
also denied that she had not stated before the police that the victim was naked.
She further denied that she did not visit the house of the accused on the
relevant day.
She had not seen the police taking any wearing apparel of the victim. On
the day of the incident, she went to school to appear for an examination. She
was a student of Class VII at Sankar Azan Adarsha Vidyalaya, which is situated
at M.K. Road. She went to school alone that day. The informant is her own
uncle. She denied that the accused did not commit rape upon the victim. She
also denied that she had deposed falsely that day.

Page No.# 15/25
16. PW-8/Dr. Safiya Begum, in her evidence-in-chief, stated that on
05.03.2024, she was working as a Medical and Health Officer at Dhubri Medical
College & Hospital, Dhubri. On that day, upon police requisition, she examined
the victim, a resident of Bidyapara, Bhatigaon Part-2, P.S. and District Dhubri,
Assam, aged about 8 (eight) years, who was brought by LNK 210 Runu Bala Ray
in connection with Bazar TOP GDE No. 63 dated 05.03.2024. Upon examination,
she recorded the following findings:
At the time of the examination, the victim narrated the brief history of the
case and stated before her that, on 05.03.2024, during the morning hours, the
accused had asked her to bring a bidi for him from a shop. When the victim
came to the house of the accused to give him the bidi, the accused undressed
the victim by removing her pants and made her sit on a chair. Thereafter, the
accused separated the victim's legs and inserted his male organ into her vagina.
According to the victim, ejaculation took place outside the vagina. Thereafter,
the victim urinated and cleaned her genitals with water following the sexual
assault.
6. The M.O. further deposed that upon examination, she found the hymen
of the victim intact, but there was redness around the vulva with fresh
fourchette tear with slight bleed. There was also evidence of stain detected on

Page No.# 16/25
her undergarment, but no spermatozoa or gonococcus was detected upon
microscopic examination of the smears pertaining to the vaginal swabs taken
over the hymen and the perineum.
According to the opinion of the Medical Officer, there was no evidence of
recent sexual intercourse. However, there is evidence of recent genital
manipulation detected on her person.
7. During cross-examination, the M.O. stated that redness around the vulva
may be caused due to infection also. She further stated that there is no exact
time of the occurrence mentioned in the narration of the victim before her body
or wearing garments. Accordingly, he submitted his report. Ext. P-4/PW-9 is the
medical examination report, and Ext. P-4(1) to P-4(9)/PW-9 are his signatures.
8. The Medical Officer's findings regarding the victim's medical examination
remained unchallenged during cross-examination.
9. PW-9 is the doctor who examined the accused/appellant. The said P.W
deposed that no evidence of sexual intercourse was detected on the person of
the accused/appellant; that he had sustained injuries on his body; and that no
stains were detected on his body or wearing garments.

Page No.# 17/25

10. It is pertinent to reproduce herein the statement of the accused person, as
recorded by PW-9, which is as follows:
“At the time of the examination the person narrated that the survivor is
known to him. She visited him on her own in the morning hours on
05.03.2024. He confessed to have undressed her and then he touched her
vulva and vagina and denied any kind of penetration. Thereafter, she left
and he too left for fishing. Later, when he returned home, he saw the
family members of the survivor were engaged in a fight with his daughter-
in-law. Police was informed by the father of the survivor about the
incident and the accused was then brought to the police station.”
11. During cross-examination, it was suggested to PW-9 that the accused did
not state so before him, which suggestion was denied.
12. PW-10/SI Utpal Roy stated in his evidence-in-chief that on 05.03.2024 he
was posted as I/C of Bazar TOP at Dhubri. On that day they have received a
verbal information from the informant namely Sorif Ali that his minor daughter
was sexually assaulted by the accused person namely Safiuddin Ali @ Basu.
After receiving the information they made a GD entry being numbered as 63
dated 05.03.2024. The victim was brought to the police station by the
complainant. On the basis of the GD entry the victim was sent for medical
treatment. Then he proceeded to visit the place of occurrence and apprehended

Page No.# 18/25
the accused Safiuddin. He has prepared the sketch map of place of occurrence.
Ext. P-5/PW-10 is the sketch map and Ext. P-5(1)/PW-10 is his signature.
On that day they have received the written ejahar. They have informed the
matter to CWC and as per advice of CWA they kept the victim at Child Care
Home, Bilasipara. On 06.03.2025 the accused was forwarded to judicial custody
after arrest.
Thereafter, he recorded the statement of complainant and seized the birth
certificate of victim. Ext. P-2 is the seizure list and Ext. P-2(2)/PW-10 is his
signature. Thereafter, the statement of victim was recorded and sent to Court
for recording her statement.
13. On completion of investigation, he submitted the charge sheet, under
Section 376 IPC read with Section 6 of the POCSO Act, which he exhibited as P-
6/PW-10, wherein exhibit P-6(1)/PW-10 is his signature.
14. During cross-examination, he stated that the ejahar was received on
05.03.2024. He visited the place of occurrence at about 11:00 AM. He has not
made Sofikul Islam, Raju, Ibrahim Ali and Bodior Rahman as witness whom he
has shown in the sketch map. He has visited the place of occurrence along with

Page No.# 19/25
his 2-3 staff. He cannot remember their names right now. He has not taken the
family details of the accused PW-1/Sorif All did not state before him that on the
day of incident he went to pay electricity bill and villagers saw the accused took
the victim to his house and locked the door of his house.
He collected the birth certificate of the victim girl from the complainant
but he did not make any seizure witness. He has given the zimma of original
birth certificate to the complainant. He did not verify the authenticity of the birth
certificate from Dharmasala Block PHC. He knows that both the parties are close
neighbor of each other but he does not know whether they are relative or not.
When he reached the place of occurrence for the first time he did not fine the
accused and his family members but other people were present in the locality.
There are other 4-5 houses near the place of occurrence. When he went to
place of occurrence for the first time for investigation he did not find anyone
present there. He has not given any note in the case diary about the numbers of
children of complainant. He has not seized any wearing apparel of the victim
except the birth certificate of the victim. He has not seen any seized articles that
day in the court. He has not made Gitanjali Pathak as witness in this case with
whom the victim was taken for medical examination.
Submissions on behalf of the appellant:

Page No.# 20/25

15. Dr. P. Agarwal, learned Legal Aid Counsel appearing for the appellant,
submitted that, upon a perusal of the evidence of the victim, it is evident that all
she had stated was that the accused/appellant had committed a “misdeed” with
her. There was no allegation of any penetrative sexual assault. Therefore, the
learned Trial Court fell into error in convicting the appellant for the offence of
aggravated penetrative sexual assault by placing reliance on the statement of
the victim recorded under Section 183 of the BNSS, which is not a substantive
piece of evidence. In her statement before the Magistrate, the victim had stated
that the accused/appellant had used his finger, but she did not state so before
the Court. Furthermore, the victim had given contradictory versions before the
Medical Officer and the Magistrate. Before the Medical Officer, she stated that
the accused had penetrated his male organ into her vagina, but gave a different
account before the Magistrate. Therefore, her testimony lacks credibility.
16. Learned counsel also pointed out that PW-7, who is a prime prosecution
witness, claimed to have gone in search of the victim and, upon going to the
house of the accused, found the victim lying naked on a bed, with the accused
lying over her and committing rape upon her. However, during cross-
examination, she stated that she was a student of Class VII, that her school was
situated at M.K. Road, and that she had gone to school on that day to appear
for her examination.

Page No.# 21/25

17. It was submitted that the normal school timing was from 9 a.m. to 1 p.m.,
and the alleged incident had also taken place during that period. Therefore, PW-
7 could not have witnessed the incident in the manner deposed to by her.
18. It was further submitted that the medical evidence also does not
conclusively establish that there was any degree of penetration.
19. Per contra, Ms. B. Bhuyan, learned Senior Counsel and Additional Public
Prosecutor, submitted that the victim was a very young child of about 8 years of
age and could not depose specifically as to the actual act committed by the
accused/appellant. She had, however, used the word “misdeed”, which is
commonly understood to mean an act of a sexual nature.

20. It was further submitted that this was supported by the fact that the victim
had also stated in her deposition that, when she started crying, the
accused/appellant had gagged her mouth. Moreover, the medical evidence also
supported the allegation that a sexual act had been committed and that the act
was penetrative in nature.
21. Ms. S. Nath, learned Legal Aid Counsel, strenuously urged that the medical
evidence, which revealed a tear of the fourchette and redness of the vulva,
together with the medical opinion that there had been genital manipulation,
clearly indicated that the accused/appellant had inserted his finger into the

Page No.# 22/25
victim's vagina. It was further submitted that even a slight degree of penetration
is sufficient to constitute penetrative sexual assault.
22. We have given our anxious consideration to the rival submissions.
23. The victim, in her deposition before the Court, categorically stated that the
accused had brought her inside his house and locked the door. This was not
challenged in cross-examination. PW-3, the mother of the victim, deposed that
Sumaiya Sultana, the daughter of her brother-in-law, went to the house of the
accused and knocked on the door. The accused then opened the door,
whereupon they saw the victim there in a half-naked condition, without her
frock. The victim then ran away to the house of a neighbour. Sumaiya Sultana,
who was examined as PW-7, also deposed that the mother of the victim was
searching for her and that she was also doing the same. She went to the house
of the accused and found the victim lying on a bed in a naked condition, with
the accused lying over her.
24. Although, during cross-examination, the defence elicited from her that she
had gone to school on that day to appear for her examination, nothing could be
elicited from her as to the time during which she was present at school so as to
rule out the possibility of her presence at the place of occurrence, as deposed to
by her. Her evidence could not be shaken in any other manner during cross-

Page No.# 23/25
examination.
25. From the evidence of the aforesaid witnesses, it is evident that the victim
was found in the house of the accused, that the door was locked from inside,
and that the accused was also present there.
26. However, the version of PW-7 to the effect that the accused/appellant was
lying on top of the victim, who was in a naked condition, and was committing
rape upon her at that time is difficult to accept in view of the statement of the
victim before the Magistrate, wherein she had only stated that the accused had
put his finger into her vagina. Thus considered, the allegation that the accused
had committed rape by penetrating his male organ into the victim's vagina
cannot be sustained.
27. The learned Trial Court did not elicit any explanation as to what the victim
meant by the word “misdeed”.
28. In this regard, therefore, the Court has to rely upon the medical evidence,
which clearly indicated genital manipulation, though no evidence of sexual
intercourse was found.
29. At this stage, we may take into account what the accused/appellant had
stated before PW-9, the doctor who examined him. According to PW-9, the
accused/appellant stated that he had undressed the victim and touched her

Page No.# 24/25
vulva and vagina, while denying any kind of penetration. This statement of the
appellant can be regarded as an extra-judicial confession, which can be used to
corroborate the evidence of the victim, who stated that the accused had
committed a “misdeed” with her. Although it was suggested to PW-9 that the
accused/appellant had not made such a statement before him, there is no
reason to believe that PW-9, the Medical Officer, who did not know the accused
or the informant, would falsely depose in this regard.
30. However, in view of the fact that the prosecution has not adduced
sufficient evidence or placed any medical literature either before the Trial Court
or at the appellate stage to establish conclusively that the injuries found upon
medical examination of the victim could be caused only by penetration, the
benefit of doubt must go to the accused. Although the defence had raised a
plea of false implication on account of a land dispute between the informant and
the accused, and suggestions in this regard were made to the prosecution
witnesses and denied, the accused himself, in his statement in defence, did not
utter a word about any land dispute between him and the informant.
Furthermore, PW-6, who is the sister of both the informant and the accused and
who was declared hostile, did not depose during her cross-examination by the
defence regarding any land dispute between the informant and the accused, nor
was any such suggestion made to her by the defence. Moreover, the plea of

Page No.# 25/25
false implication can also be safely ruled out on account of the positive evidence
adduced by the witnesses, the medical evidence, and the statement made by
the appellant before the Medical Officer.
31. Resultantly, we are of the view that a case of aggravated sexual assault
has been made out against the accused/appellant rather than one of aggravated
penetrative sexual assault. Accordingly, we alter the conviction to one under
Section 10 of the POCSO Act and set aside the conviction and sentence
recorded by the learned Trial Court under Section 6 of the POCSO Act. Further,
we sentence the appellant to undergo rigorous imprisonment for 7 years and to
pay a fine of Rs. 15,000/-, in default of payment of fine, to undergo simple
imprisonment for 2 (two) months. The fine amount shall be paid to the victim as
compensation. The period of detention already undergone shall be set off.
32. The appeal stands partly allowed to the aforesaid extent. The Trial Court
Record be sent back.
33. We record our appreciation for the assistance rendered by the learned
Legal Aid Counsel appearing for the appellant as well as the learned counsel
appearing for respondent No. 2.
JUDGE JUDGE
Comparing Assistant