PUNEET SHARMA vs THE STATE OF HP AND OTHERS
- Court
- High Court of Himachal Pradesh
IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA
CWP No.14465 of 2026
High Court of H.P.
rd
Decided on: 3 November, 2026
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Puneet Sharma …..Petitioner
Versus
State of H.P. and others .....Respondents
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Coram
Ms. Justice Jyotsna Rewal Dua
1
Whether approved for reporting? Yes.
For the Petitioner: Mr. Peeyush Verma, Senior Advocate
with Mr. Anuj Bali, Advocate.
For the Respondents: Mr. Rajat Choudhry, Assistant Advocate
General, for respondents No.1 to 3.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Jyotsna Rewal Dua, Judge
For petitioner’s non-joining at the transferred
station and in view of a complaint filed against him by a co-
employee, respondent No.2 suspended the petitioner and
also directed to initiate departmental proceedings against
him. Feeling aggrieved, he has preferred this writ petition.
2. The Case:-
2(i). Petitioner was posted as Assistant Sub-
Inspector, Government Railway Police (GRP), Traffic, Tourist
and Railways (TTR) Wing, Shimla. On 06.03.2026, he was
1
Whether reporters of print and electronic media may be allowed to see the order? Yes.
::: Downloaded on - 05/11/2026 18:11:46 :::CIS
2
transferred to OPGRP Kandrori. Apparently, the aforesaid
High Court of H.P.
transfer order was not enforced. The petitioner proceeded
on medical leave w.e.f. 06.03.2026 to 27.03.2026 and
joined duty on 28.03.2026.
2(ii). On 24.06.2026 (Annexure P-1), respondent
No.2-the Director General of Police, Himachal Pradesh
th
transferred the petitioner from TT&R to 4 IRBn
(Jangalberi). On 30.06.2026 (Annexure P-11), petitioner,
through his immediate Controlling Officer-Deputy Inspector
General of Police, Traffic, Tourist & Railways, Himachal
Pradesh (respondent No.3), filed a representation to
respondent No.2, seeking cancellation of the transfer order
dated 24.06.2026. For seeking cancellation of his transfer,
petitioner highlighted his decorated service record, his
tenure in the current unit being less than six months, his
mother suffering from stomach carcinoma, his wife’s
employment and his son being a school-going child etc.
2(iii). Respondent No.3-the immediate Controlling
Officer of the petitioner also sent an office letter on
01.07.2026 (Annexure P-12) to respondent No.2,
recommending cancellation of petitioner’s transfer ordered
on 24.06.2026. While recommending cancellation of
th
petitioner’s transfer to 4 IRBn, respondent No.3 apart
::: Downloaded on - 05/11/2026 18:11:46 :::CIS
3
from reiterating adverse family circumstances highlighted
High Court of H.P.
by the petitioner in his representation, also mentioned that
petitioner had an unblemished record of honesty, integrity,
and devotion to duty; Petitioner’s tenure in the present unit
was less than six months; and TTR Wing was facing acute
shortage of NGO-I staff. Respondent No.3 also highlighted
therein that pending consideration of the representation,
compliance of the transfer order was kept awaiting. Portion
relevant to the context from the recommendations made by
respondent No.3 to respondent No.2 is as under:-
“I have also perused his Service Book and Character
Roll, which reflect an unblemished record of honesty,
integrity and devotion to duty. His tenure in the present unit
is less than six months, and the TTR Wing is presently facing
an acute shortage of NGO-I staff.
In view of the exceptional family circumstances, his
impeccable service record and the administrative requirement
of the TTR Wing, I recommend that the transfer order dated
24.06.2026, insofar as it relates to ASI Puneet Sharma, may
kindly be cancelled on compassionate grounds. The
favourable decision to cancel the transfer orders of Applicant
will instill confidence/motivation in the application and prove
supporting step to uplift welfare measures towards Police
official, who is passing through distress on account of
extreme adverse family circumstances.
In view of above mentioned representation, concerns of
applicant’s mentioned therein, hence compliance of transfer
order kept awaiting till decision on the instant
representation. Application/representation submitted by ASI
Puneet Sharma is also enclosed herewith for further course
of action at your end please.
Encls. A/A.
Yours faithfully,
Sd/-
(Sanjeev Kumar Gandhi) IPS
Deputy Inspector General of Police
Traffic, Tourist & Railways, H.P. Shimla-2.”
::: Downloaded on - 05/11/2026 18:11:46 :::CIS
4
2(iv). It appears that petitioner’s representation dated
High Court of H.P.
30.06.2026, seeking cancellation of his transfer order dated
24.06.2026, went un-responded and so was the fate of the
recommendations made by respondent No.3 to respondent
No.2 for cancelling petitioner’s transfer. What came out in
the process was an order issued by respondent No.2 on
20.07.2026 (Annexure P-2), suspending the petitioner on
two counts, i.e. (i) Petitioner had not joined duty at his new
place of posting under order dated 24.06.2026; and (ii) A
complaint had been submitted by Ct. Driver Pankaj No.62
in GRPS Shimla against the petitioner regarding
harassment and mental torture. The gist of the complaint,
as culled out in the suspension order (as translated in the
writ petition), is as under:-
“I respectfully submit that my wife, Ambika
Sharma, is currently in her month of pregnancy and
requires your presence and support during this crucial
and sensitive period, 1 personally informed ASI Puneet
about my wife's condition and requested that my family
circumstances be taken into consideration, as she is
undergoing treatment at Kamala Nehru Hospital,
Shimla. Despite being fully aware of my actual family
circumstances, I have allegedly been continuously
harassed and a temporary transfer order has been
issued against me to GRPS, Kangra. I strongly suspect
that I am being targeted because I received a
Commendation Certificate (Class-1) from the Director
General of Police, Himachal Pradesh. Following the
incident, certain comments were allegedly made about
me in my absence, including allegations that I am an
informant of the Director General of Police, Himachal
Pradesh. I am facing mental harassment due to such
::: Downloaded on - 05/11/2026 18:11:46 :::CIS
5
comments and ASI Puneet also pressurized me to wash
the personal car of the suspended officer, to which the
applicant refused and a harassing environment is being
created against me on this issue.”
On the aforesaid two counts, the petitioner was
High Court of H.P.
suspended on 20.07.2026 with immediate effect. His
th
headquarter was fixed at his new place of posting, i.e. 4
th
IRBn, Jangalberi. The Commandant, 4 IRBn, Jangalberi
was directed to initiate regular departmental inquiry
against the petitioner.
2(v). Now was the turn of respondent No.3-the
immediate Controlling Officer of the petitioner, who on
01.07.2026, had recommended for cancelling petitioner’s
th
transfer to 4 IRBn, Jangalberi and had kept petitioner’s
transfer order in abeyance, to address the issue of
petitioner’s suspension. Respondent No.3 addressed a
detailed office letter on 23.07.2026 (Annexure P-14) to
respondent No.2. The said office letter termed as ‘Report
regarding suspension, premature transfer and initiation of
departmental proceedings’ against the petitioner, inter alia ,
records:
(A). Concerning complaint lodged against the
petitioner by Ct. Driver Pankaj:-
The allegations of Ct. Driver Pankaj leveled
against the petitioner were absolutely misplaced. Petitioner
::: Downloaded on - 05/11/2026 18:11:46 :::CIS
6
had no role in the temporary deployment of Ct. Driver
High Court of H.P.
Pankaj. Deployment of Ct. Driver Pankaj was made on
administrative grounds by the office of respondent No.3 in
view of operational requirements. Details of such
operational requirements were also mentioned in the
aforesaid office letter/report dated 23.07.2026. The report
highlighted that Ct. Driver Pankaj was the only available
Driver for temporary deployment to GRPS Kangra; He had
hardly been deputed for outstation duties in the last six
months; That he had been extended considerable
administrative flexibility to attend his family responsibilities
for several months. Several other administrative reasons
were given in the report concerning deployment of
Ct. Driver Pankaj by the office of respondent No.3,
repeatedly putting forth that petitioner had no role
whatsoever in such action; That it was the office of
respondent No.3, which had exercised independent
discretion in the matter; Respondent No.3 impressed upon
having an objective assessment in the larger administrative
context before taking any drastic action upon the complaint
made by Ct. Driver Pankaj.
::: Downloaded on - 05/11/2026 18:11:46 :::CIS
7
th
(B). With respect to petitioner’s transfer to 4 IRBn/
his non-joining at the transferred station:-
Respondent No.3 in the aforesaid report dated
High Court of H.P.
23.07.2026 again detailed the reasons, requesting for
th
cancellation of petitioner’s transfer to 4 IRBn. Respondent
No.3 for all practical reasons, owned up the responsibility
for not relieving the petitioner from his current place of
posting. That under the applicable Police Rules and
procedure, issuance of a Command Certificate by the Head
of Office is a pre-requisite before the officer is relieved
pursuant to a transfer order. Since petitioner’s
representation was pending before the competent authority
and respondent No.3 had also recommended to respondent
No.2 for cancelling petitioner’s transfer, the Command
Certificate had not been issued by respondent No.3,
awaiting decision of petitioner’s representation and also
awaiting action upon the recommendations made by
respondent No.3.
Respondent No.3 gave elaborate reasons for his
having made the recommendations for cancelling
th
petitioner’s transfer to 4 IRBn, Jangalberi. Respondent
No.3 also expressed his anguish that being the supervisory
authority, having direct administrative control and first-
::: Downloaded on - 05/11/2026 18:11:46 :::CIS
8
hand knowledge of work, conduct & performance of the
High Court of H.P.
petitioner, his views were also required to be considered
and the matter was required to be examined objectively
after affording due opportunity to all concerned.
2(vi). On 27.07.2026, petitioner represented to the
Chief Secretary to the Government of Himachal Pradesh
against ‘arbitrary premature transfer, retaliatory
suspension and initiation of departmental proceedings’. On
31.07.2026 (Annexure P-3), respondent No.2 addressed a
letter to respondent No.3, with copy endorsed to the
petitioner, to the effect that petitioner had not even
represented against his suspension, transfer or the
proposed departmental proceedings; The departmental
remedies wherever available were not invoked by the
petitioner before approaching the competent authority.
Respondent No.2 further conveyed to respondent No.3 that
suspension, transfer and initiation of departmental
proceedings are distinct administrative and disciplinary
matters governed by separate legal principles and service
rules; Suspension is ordinarily an interim measure and not
a punishment; Transfer is an incidence of service to be
examined with reference to administrative exigencies and
competent authority’s jurisdiction; and initiation of
::: Downloaded on - 05/11/2026 18:11:46 :::CIS
9
departmental proceedings depends upon the existence of
High Court of H.P.
prima facie material disclosing misconduct. Respondent
No.2 further informed respondent No.3 that his report did
not clearly specify the order sought to be reviewed, the
authority that passed it, the legal grounds of challenge or
the precise intervention expected from the Police
Headquarters in respect of any of these matters. This was
in essence first ever response that came from respondent
No.2, which in a roundabout manner, declined to accept
petitioner’s plea and the recommendation made by
respondent No.3.
2(vii). Respondent No.3 addressed an another report
on 10.08.2026 (Annexure P-19) regarding the above office
letter issued by respondent No.2, to the Additional Chief
Secretary (Home) to the Government of Himachal Pradesh.
On 11.08.2026 (Annexure P-20), petitioner preferred a
representation to respondent No.2, seeking review/
reconsideration of the order initiating departmental
proceedings and rejecting his representation against
th
transfer to 4 IRBn.
2(viii). While under suspension, on 19.08.2026
(Annexure P-5), petitioner was relieved from duty with
th
direction to report at 4 IRBn Jangalberi. Vide a separate
::: Downloaded on - 05/11/2026 18:11:46 :::CIS
10
order passed on the same day, i.e. on 19.08.2026, the
High Court of H.P.
earned leave sanctioned in favour of the petitioner, was
cancelled with immediate effect.
The above led the petitioner to institute this writ
petition on 20.08.2026.
3. Following order was passed in the matter on
21.08.2026:-
“After hearing learned Senior Counsel for the
petitioner for some time, this Court is of the considered
view that in light of the issues flagged by learned Senior
Counsel qua the ill health of mother of the petitioner as
also the petitioner, at this stage, the Court directs the
petitioner to approach the Director General of Police
seeking his adjustment etc./cancellation of transfer by
filing an appropriate representation within three days.
The petitioner shall be at liberty to file the
representation directly before the concerned Authority.
As from the date of receipt of the representation,
Director General of Police is requested to decide the
same within a period of one week after hearing to the
petitioner. This Court hopes and expects that the
Authority concerned shall sympathetically pass
appropriate orders on the representation of the
petitioner in case he indeed is facing the difficulties
which have been so enunciated in the petition. In the
meantime, no coercive action be taken against the
petitioner.
As prayed for, list on 07.09.2026.”
Pursuant to the directions issued in the
aforesaid order, respondent No.2 vide order dated
29.08.2026 (Annexure P-22), rejected petitioner’s
representation. Thereafter, the writ petition was permitted
to be amended for assailing the order dated 29.08.2026 as
::: Downloaded on - 05/11/2026 18:11:46 :::CIS
11
well. The substantive reliefs prayed for by the petitioner are
High Court of H.P.
as under:-
“i) the impugned Transfer Order dated 24.06.2026 passed
by respondent No.2 whereby the petitioner has been
th
transferred from TT&R Shimla to 4 IRBn Jangleberi,
and permit the petitioner to complete his normal tenure
at the present place of posting;
ii) the Suspension Order dated 20.07.2026 passed by
respondent No.2 placing the petitioner under
suspension and initiating departmental proceedings
against him;
iii) the communication dated 31.07.2026 whereby the
representation/recommendations in favour of the
Petitioner were rejected and intervention was declined;
iv) the order dated 19.08.2026 whereby the earned leave
sanctioned in favour of the petitioner in advance on
10.08.2026 was cancelled;
v) the relieving order dated 19.08.2026 whereby the
petitioner was relieved from his duties and directed to
report at the transferred station;
vi) the subsequent order dated 29.08.2026 passed by
respondent No.2/Director General of Police, Himachal
Pradesh, whereby the representation dated 21.08.2026
submitted by the petitioner pursuant to the order dated
21.08.2026 passed by this Hon'ble Court was rejected
and the transfer of the petitioner from TT&R Wing,
th
Shimla to 4 IRBn Jangleberi, District Hamirpur, was
upheld and;
vii) direct the respondents to permit the petitioner to
continue at his existing place of posting at TT&R Shimla
and to restore all consequential service benefits.”
During the course of today’s hearing, learned
Assistant Advocate General placed on record an office order
th
dated 15.10.2026 issued by the Commandant, 4 IRBn,
Jangalberi, in terms of which, a regular departmental
inquiry has been ordered against the petitioner and an
::: Downloaded on - 05/11/2026 18:11:46 :::CIS
12
Officer has been appointed for conducting the departmental
High Court of H.P.
inquiry. The said order also directs the Inquiry Officer to
submit his report within three months.
4. Heard and considered the case file. In order to
maintain brevity, the submissions made by learned counsel
for the parties and the discussion thereupon has been
elaborated hereinafter.
4(i). The respondents in their reply have given the
following incumbency position of the petitioner:-
“(A) Date of appointment:- 01.07.2008
(B) Place(s) of posting:-
Sr.
No.
Unit/Place of Posting Period
st
1. 1 Bn Junga 01.07.2008 to 09.08.2023
2. Distt. Shimla 10.08.2023 to 02.03.2026
3. TTR 03.03.2026 to 24.06.2026
th
4. Under transfer to 4
IRBn
24.06.2026 to date”
According to the respondents, the petitioner had
practically remained posted throughout his service career
in and around Shimla. He was transferred on 24.06.2026 to
th
4 IRBn, Jangalberi. Petitioner disobeyed this transfer
order. Additionally, one Ct. Driver Pankaj leveled allegations
against the petitioner of having exercised influence in
deployment of the aforesaid Driver at GRPS, Kangra and
the allegations of mental harassment caused to Ct. Driver
Pankaj owing to certain comments attributed to the
::: Downloaded on - 05/11/2026 18:11:46 :::CIS
13
petitioner. Therefore, the petitioner was suspended on
High Court of H.P.
20.07.2026.
4(ii). It is well settled that ordinarily, it is not for the
Court to interfere in case of suspension, as it is in the
exclusive domain of the competent authority, who can
always review its order of suspension, being an inherent
power conferred upon it by the applicable Rules/
Regulations. It is, however, also a principle of law that
power of suspension should not be exercised in an arbitrary
manner and without any reasonable ground or as vindictive
misuse of power. Suspension should be ordered only where
a strong prima facie case is there against the delinquent
employee involving moral turpitude, grave misconduct or
indiscipline or refusal to carry out the orders of superior
authority, which if proved, would ordinarily result in
reduction in rank, removal or dismissal from service. The
authority should take into account all the available material
as to whether in a given case, it is advisable to allow the
delinquent to continue to perform his duties of the office or
his retention in the office is likely to hamper or frustrate the
inquiry. Suspension is a device to keep the delinquent out
of the mischief range. The purpose is to complete the
proceedings unhindered. Suspension is an interim measure
::: Downloaded on - 05/11/2026 18:11:46 :::CIS
14
in the aid of disciplinary proceedings, so that the
High Court of H.P.
delinquent may not gain custody or control of papers or
take any advantage of the position. In this regard, it will be
appropriate to refer to Union of India and another Versus
2
Ashok Kumar Aggarwal , relevant paras of which read as
under:-
“21. The power of suspension should not be exercised in an
arbitrary manner and without any reasonable ground or
as vindictive misuse of power. Suspension should be
made only in a case where there is a strong prima facie
case against the delinquent employee and the
allegations involving moral turpitude, grave misconduct
or indiscipline or refusal to carry out the orders of
superior authority are there, or there is a strong prima
facie case against him, if proved, would ordinarily
result in reduction in rank, removal or dismissal from
service. The authority should also take into account all
the available material as to whether in a given case, it
is advisable to allow the delinquent to continue to
perform his duties in the office or his retention in office
is likely to hamper or frustrate the inquiry.
22. In view of the above, the law on the issue can be
summarised to the effect that suspension order can be
passed by the competent authority considering the
gravity of the alleged misconduct i.e. serious act of
omission or commission and the nature of evidence
available. It cannot be actuated by mala fide,
arbitrariness, or for ulterior purpose. Effect on public
interest due to the employee's continuation in office is
also a relevant and determining factor. The facts of each
case have to be taken into consideration as no formula
of universal application can be laid down in this regard.
However, suspension order should be passed only
where there is a strong prima facie case against the
delinquent, and if the charges stand proved, would
ordinarily warrant imposition of major punishment i.e.
2
(2013) 16 SCC 147
::: Downloaded on - 05/11/2026 18:11:46 :::CIS
15
removal or dismissal from service, or reduction in rank,
etc.
High Court of H.P.
26. The scope of interference by the Court with the order of
suspension has been examined by the Court in a large
number of cases, particularly in State of M.P. v. Shardul
3
Singh , P.V. Srinivasa Sastry v. Comptroller & Auditor
4 5
General , ESI v. T. Abdul Razak , Kusheshwar Dubey v.
6
Bharat Coking Coal Ltd. , Delhi Cloth & General Mills
7
Ltd. v. Kushal Bhan , U.P. Rajya Krishi Utpadan Mandi
8
Parishad v. Sanjiv Rajan , State of Rajasthan v. B.K.
9 10
Meena , Prohibition and Excise Deptt. v. L. Srinivasan
11
and Allahabad Bank v. Deepak Kumar Bhola , wherein
it has been observed that even if a criminal trial or
enquiry takes a long time, it is ordinarily not open to the
court to interfere in case of suspension as it is in the
exclusive domain of the competent authority who can
always review its order of suspension being an inherent
power conferred upon them by the provisions of Article
21 of the General Clauses Act, 1897 and while
exercising such a power, the authority can consider the
case of an employee for revoking the suspension order,
if satisfied that the criminal case pending would be
concluded after an unusual delay for no fault of the
employee concerned. Where the charges are baseless,
mala fide or vindictive and are framed only to keep the
delinquent employee out of job, a case for judicial
review is made out. But in a case where no conclusion
can be arrived at without examining the entire record in
question and in order that the disciplinary proceedings
may continue unhindered the court may not interfere. In
case the court comes to the conclusion that the authority
is not proceeding expeditiously as it ought to have been
and it results in prolongation of sufferings for the
delinquent employee, the court may issue directions.
The court may, in case the authority fails to furnish
proper explanation for delay in conclusion of the
enquiry, direct to complete the enquiry within a
stipulated period. However, mere delay in conclusion of
3
(1970) 1 SCC 108
4
(1993) 1 SCC 419
5
(1996) 4 SCC 708
6
(1988) 4 SCC 319
7
AIR 1960 SC 806
8
1993 Supp (3) SCC 483
9
(1996) 6 SCC 417
10
(1996) 3 SCC 157
11
(1997) 4 SCC 1
::: Downloaded on - 05/11/2026 18:11:46 :::CIS
16
enquiry or trial cannot be a ground for quashing the
suspension order, if the charges are grave in nature.
But, whether the employee should or should not
continue in his office during the period of enquiry is a
matter to be assessed by the disciplinary authority
concerned and ordinarily the court should not interfere
with the orders of suspension unless they are passed in
mala fide and without there being even a prima facie
evidence on record connecting the employee with the
misconduct in question.
High Court of H.P.
27. Suspension is a device to keep the delinquent out of the
mischief range. The purpose is to complete the
proceedings unhindered. Suspension is an interim
measure in the aid of disciplinary proceedings so that
the e delinquent may not gain custody or control of
papers or take any advantage of his position. More so,
at this stage, it is not desirable that the court may find
out as to which version is true when there are claims
and counterclaims on factual issues. The court cannot
act as if it is an appellate forum de hors the powers of
judicial review.”
State of Orissa Versus Bimal Kumar
12
Mohanty holds that order of suspension should be
passed after taking into consideration the gravity of the
misconduct sought to be inquired into or investigated and
the nature of the evidence placed before the appointing
authority and on application of mind by the disciplinary
authority. It should not be as an administrative routine or
an automatic order to suspend an employee, but the
appointing/disciplinary authority should consider the
relevant factors and decide whether it is expedient to keep
an employee under suspension pending inquiry/
12
(1994) 4 SCC 126
::: Downloaded on - 05/11/2026 18:11:46 :::CIS
17
contemplated inquiry. Suspension is not a punishment, but
High Court of H.P.
it only forbids or disables an employee to discharge the
duties of the office or post held by him, in order to restrain
him to avail further opportunity to perpetrate the alleged
misconduct or remove the impression amongst members of
service that dereliction of duty would pay fruits and the
offending employee could get away even pending inquiry
without any impediment. Relevant portion from the decision
is as under:-
“13. It is thus settled law that normally when an appointing
authority or the disciplinary authority seeks to suspend
an employee, pending inquiry or contemplated inquiry
or pending investigation into grave charges of
misconduct or defalcation of funds or serious acts of
omission and commission, the order of suspension
would be passed after taking into consideration the
gravity of the misconduct sought to be inquired into or
investigated and the nature of the evidence placed
before the appointing authority and on application of the
mind by disciplinary authority. Appointing authority or
disciplinary authority should consider the above
aspects and decide whether it is expedient to keep an
employee under suspension pending aforesaid action. It
would not be as an administrative routine or an
automatic order to suspend an employee. It should be
on consideration of the gravity of the alleged misconduct
or the nature of the allegations imputed to the
delinquent employee. The Court or the Tribunal must
consider each case on its own facts and no general law
could be laid down in that behalf. Suspension is not a
punishment but is only one of forbidding or disabling an
employee to discharge the duties of office or post held
by him. In other words it is to refrain him to avail
further opportunity to perpetrate the alleged misconduct
or to remove the impression among the members of
service that dereliction of duty would pay fruits and the
offending employee could get away even pending
::: Downloaded on - 05/11/2026 18:11:46 :::CIS
18
inquiry without any impediment or to prevent an
opportunity to the delinquent officer to scuttle the
inquiry or investigation or to win over the witnesses or
the delinquent having had the opportunity in office to
impede the progress of the investigation or inquiry etc.
But as stated earlier, each case must be considered
depending on the nature of the allegations, gravity of
the situation and the indelible impact it creates on the
service for the continuance of the delinquent employee
in service pending inquiry or contemplated inquiry or
investigation. It would be another thing if the action is
actuated by mala fides, arbitrary or for ulterior purpose.
The suspension must be a step in aid to the ultimate
result of the investigation or inquiry. The authority also
should keep in mind public interest of the impact of the
delinquent's continuance in office while facing
departmental inquiry or trial of a criminal charge.”
High Court of H.P.
4(iii). In the background of above legal position,
coming to the facts of this case, petitioner was transferred
th
to 4 IRBn, Jangalberi on 24.06.2026. Admittedly, he did
not join at the transferred station. He preferred a
representation on 30.06.2026 to respondent No.2, through
proper channel, seeking cancellation of his transfer, citing
certain reasons, which according to him, called for
cancellation of his transfer. Respondent No.3-the immediate
Controlling Officer of the petitioner, while recommending
cancellation of petitioner’s transfer in his office letter dated
01.07.2026, has practically owned up the responsibility for
not relieving the petitioner from GRP, TTR Wing, Shimla.
Petitioner’s non-joining at the station, where he was
transferred under order dated 24.06.2026, therefore, is not
::: Downloaded on - 05/11/2026 18:11:46 :::CIS
19
solely attributable to him. Petitioner though was not
High Court of H.P.
th
interested to join at 4 IRBn in view of the grievances
highlighted by him in his representation, but his immediate
Controlling Officer-respondent No.3 also supported
petitioner’s representation and kept the relieving of the
petitioner/implementation of the transfer order dated
24.06.2026 on hold, awaiting decision of respondent No.2
upon petitioner’s representation/action upon respondent
No.3’s recommendation.
In the given facts and circumstances,
petitioner’s suspension on 20.07.2026 by respondent No.2,
inter alia , on the ground that petitioner had not complied
with the transfer order dated 24.06.2026, cannot be said to
be justifiable. The said suspension order does not even
satisfy the parameters laid down in the aforesaid decisions
for testing the justifiability of the suspension order. It has
not been demonstrated as to in what manner petitioner’s
continuation in service would have caused prejudice to the
respondents or required the petitioner to be placed under
suspension. It was not the case where petitioner had not
obeyed the orders passed by respondent No.2, rather,
respondent No.3 had himself owned up the responsibility
for not issuing the necessary and consequential orders for
::: Downloaded on - 05/11/2026 18:11:46 :::CIS
20
th
petitioner’s joining at 4 IRBn, having recommended
High Court of H.P.
cancellation of his transfer to respondent No.2. It is though
another issue (irrelevant to present controversy) that
according to respondent No.2, no further order was
required for relieving the petitioner.
4(iv). Insofar as the second ground taken in the
impugned order for suspending the petitioner is concerned,
the same also cannot be sustained. Just because
respondent No.2 received a complaint from one employee
(Ct. Driver Pankaj) against the petitioner, of latter allegedly
having influenced in former’s getting deployed at another
place, is no ground to straightaway order for petitioner’s
suspension. This ground, even otherwise, has been falsified
in view of the stand taken by respondent No.3 in his office
letters addressed to respondent No.2. Respondent No.3 has
owned up the responsibility for deputing Ct. Driver Pankaj
to the place, where he was sent and assigned the reasons
for such deployment. Respondent No.3 has clearly held out
that he had independently exercised his discretion in
ordering deployment of Ct. Driver Pankaj without any
external influence whatsoever.
No clear decision on petitioner’s representation
dated 30.06.2026, seeking cancellation of his transfer, has
::: Downloaded on - 05/11/2026 18:11:46 :::CIS
21
been placed on record (save & except the order passed on
High Court of H.P.
29.08.2026 pursuant to the directions of the Court).
Respondent No.3 had informed respondent No.2 on
01.07.2026 of his having kept petitioner’s relieving at TTR
Wing on hold awaiting decision of petitioner’s
representation and action upon respondent No.3’s
recommendation.
4(v). Respondent No.2 had ordered suspension of the
petitioner on 20.07.2026, whereas it was only on
31.07.2026 that he had given his mind in a roundabout
manner for not accepting respondent No.3's
recommendations for cancelling petitioner’s transfer.
Petitioner’s suspension is continuing as on date.
Admittedly, no charge-sheet has been issued to the
petitioner till date, though more than three months have
passed. During hearing of the case, learned Assistant
Advocate General placed on record copy of order dated
15.10.2026, whereunder, an Inquiry Officer has been
appointed. But it defies logic as to how in the absence of
any charge-sheet having been issued to the petitioner and
in the absence of petitioner having been given an
opportunity to file his reply to the charge-sheet, the
respondents have proceeded ahead and appointed an
::: Downloaded on - 05/11/2026 18:11:46 :::CIS
22
Inquiry Officer. Such procedure cannot be said to be in
High Court of H.P.
consonance with the principles of natural justice and
settled service jurisprudence. In the given facts and
circumstances, it has to be held that suspension of the
petitioner ordered on 20.07.2026 was absolutely uncalled
for.
5. In view of above, this writ petition is allowed to
the extent that suspension of the petitioner ordered on
20.07.2026 (Annexure P-2) is quashed and set aside.
Respondents are directed to permit the petitioner to join his
duties forthwith at the transferred station in terms of order
dated 24.06.2026 (Annexure P-1). Liberty is, however,
reserved to the petitioner to seek appropriate remedy for the
redressal of his surviving grievances in accordance with law
at an appropriate stage, in case necessity so arises. Pending
miscellaneous application(s), if any, also stand disposed of.
Jyotsna Rewal Dua
November 03, 2026 Judge
Mukesh
::: Downloaded on - 05/11/2026 18:11:46 :::CIS