LAKSHMI SHAW vs THE STATION MANAGER,WBSEDCL AND ORS

Court
Calcutta High Court

IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
CONSTITUTIONAL WRIT JURISDICTION
APPELLATE SIDE

Present:
The Hon’ble Justice Rai Chattopadhyay

WPA 17777 of 2026

Lakshmi Shaw
Vs.
The West Bengal State Electricity Distribution Co. Ltd. &
Ors.



For the Petitioner : Mr. Lakshmi Shaw (in person)





For the WBSEDCL : Dr. Madhusudan Saha Roy

Heard on : 13.11.2026

Judgment on : 17.11.2026

Uploaded on : 17.11.2026

Rai Chattopadhyay, J. :-
1.
The subject premises is 23, West Ghosh Para Road, Kankinara
Bazar, North 24 Parghanas, Pin-743126, where the petitioner
once resided with her both parents and presently with her
mother alone due to death of her father and seeks that the
respondent WBSEDCL do provide a separate new electricity
service connection over there, in her name. Hence, she has
made application to that effect dated June 4, 2026. This writ
petition has been filed by her to seek redress of her grievances
that despite her making application for new connection and
willingness to comply with all the legal formalities for grant of
such connection, the respondent has till now been allegedly

Page 2 of 13

inactive and negligent to respond to her such application by
providing her, as prayed for. Hence, in this writ petition, the
petitioner has sought for relief that the respondent/WBSEDCL
be directed to provide separate electricity connection to her at
her residence without putting up and obstruction as regards
the same.

2.
The writ petitioner appearing in person has submitted that at
the subject premises, electricity line has been disconnected by
the respondent since from March 23, 2026, which stood in the
name of her deceased father. That after death of her father, the
mother of the writ petitioner used to enjoy and maintain the
same. Allegedly however, due to disturbances created by the
respondent authority and as a result of fraud and harassment
practiced by the same, the said consumer faced serious
difficulty in utilizing the service.

3. The petitioner has submitted that she being the member of the
same family and residing permanently in the subject premises
should be entitled for a new connection over there, particularly
for the purpose of her separate earmarked professional
chamber and adjacent places, as per provision of the law. She
has submitted that being devoid of any electricity connection,
her profession has been affected severely and a new connection
is a dire urgent need of the hour. She submits further that the
respondent’s inaction in providing her separate electricity
connection, is not only arbitrary but also in stark violation of
the statutory provisions and settled law. It is informed that
pursuant to her application, the WBSEDCL authority has not
even conducted an inspection over the premises, which,
according to her, signifies its premeditated mala fide intentions,

Page 3 of 13

to defy the petitioner’s statutory rights by not providing
separate service connection to her. Hence, the writ petitioner
has prayed for the above relief, in the instant writ petition.

4. The contentions and prayer of the writ petitioner has been
vehemently objected to by the respondent WBSEDCL,
represented by Dr. Madhusudan Saha Roy, learned advocate. It
is denied that the petitioner would be eligible for a separate
electricity connection in her name at a premises where a service
connection already existed. It is submitted further that
inspection though attempted to be done, could not be
accomplished due to non-cooperation of the petitioner and her
mother to give the officers of the respondent free access to the
existing meter board at the premises. The respondent has
conceded to the fact that a service connection was earlier
granted at the subject premises in the name of the deceased
father of the writ petitioner, being Meter No. SL020604
Consumer No. 155003153.

5. Dr. Saha Roy, learned advocate submits that previously several
unsuccessful attempts have been made by the mother of the
writ petitioner by filing writ petitions and appeals before this
Court, to secure some undue benefit with respect to restoration
of connection, not permissible under the law. It is categorically
stated that the mother of the writ petitioner, on advice of the
petitioner, who happens to be the representing advocate of her
mother, has even ignored and violated the Court’s order. Like in
WPA 10160 of 2026, the petitioner/mother of the present writ
petitioner was directed to take steps for transfer of her name in
place and stead of the erstwhile deceased consumer, but in

Page 4 of 13

vain. Neither the said petitioner has taken any step to
surrender the meter lied in the name of a deceased person.

6. So far as the online application of the writ petitioner for new
connection is concerned, the respondent says that the same is
not in accordance with law and even at times pages thereof
have remained unendorsed with signature of the applicant and
her photograph. It is further submitted that the technical
compliances like installation of installation of ‘main switch’ for
new connection as per Regulation 2.1 (o) of the Regulations
No.55 or formalities under the West Bengal Electricity
Regulatory Commission Notification No.46 – are not
accomplished by the writ petitioner.

7.
The authority has submitted that the same is ready and willing
to provide connection to the petitioner as prayed for, subject to
fulfilment of the statutory and legal formalities by her, as a
prospective consumer is obliged to meet the same up, in order
to obtain new connection.

8. Let it be noted that the earlier supply has been disconnected on
March 23, 2026, where as the writ petitioner has applied for a
new connection on June 4, 2026. The interval between these
two dates is substantially less than the statutory 180 days,
which is the statutory time limit of continuous disconnection,
under Regulation 4.6.1 of 2012 Supply Code [West Bengal
Electricity Supply Code, 2012] to treat the supply agreement as
deemed to be terminated.

9. Till a new connection is provided to the present petitioner, if at
all, she should be categorized as within the same unit of

Page 5 of 13

beneficiaries, who have enjoyed service under the Consumer
No. 155003153, though supply was granted in name of her
father as the grantee consumer. The circumstances leading to
disconnection of the earlier electricity connection require
consideration in the proper factual perspective. It appears from
the judgment and order dated July 24, 2026 passed in WPA
10160 of 2026, arising out of the earlier proceedings in WPA
5357 of 2026, that the electricity connection bearing Meter No.
SL020604 and Consumer No. 155003153 was disconnected on
March 23, 2026, following repeated failure on the part of the
then occupant to provide access to the officials of WBSEDCL for
inspection and recording of meter readings, notwithstanding
prior notices dated February 23, 2026 and February 27, 2026
and a specific direction of this Court dated March 9, 2026
requiring cooperation at the time of inspection. The said
proceedings further disclose that the existing meter,
manufactured in May, 2002, had outlived its guarantee period
in July, 2007 and had become ineffective for accurate recording
of electricity consumption, thereby necessitating its
replacement. The Court also noticed that the existing
connection continued in the name of a deceased consumer and
that the requisite formalities for change of ownership had not
been completed. Ultimately, the disconnection was upheld in
view of the provisions of Section 163 of the Electricity Act, 2003
read with Clause 8 of the WBERC Regulations No. 55, which
has provided for access to the premises for meter reading,
validation, testing, repair and other authorised purposes.
Accordingly, disconnection of meter was held justified.

10. In this factual background the decisive consideration should
not merely be as to the independent statutory right of the

Page 6 of 13

present petitioner as an occupier of the same premises,
completely unrelated to the liabilities and circumstances
emanating from the consequences of the earlier service and
consumption. Rather during subsistence of the agreement
period and as the beneficiary of the supply granted earlier in
the same premises, the petitioner’s independent right under the
statute as a new consumer should be espoused with much care
and circumspection in order to avoid any possible revenue loss,
particularly when the petitioner’s nexus with the previous
consumer is yet to be established by the authority after expiry
of the agreement period. The petitioner cannot necessarily
change the character of an existing consumer relationship
merely by introducing a fresh application in the name of
another member of the same beneficiary unit, particularly when
the effect of doing so would be to circumvent the consequences
of the subsisting agreement and avoid examination of liabilities
arising from the original connection.


11. It is necessary to examine the petitioner's claim for a fresh
electricity connection in the background of the entire chain of
events concerning the earlier connection bearing Meter No.
SL020604 and Consumer No. 155003153. Undoubtedly,
Section 43 of the Electricity Act, 2003 recognises the statutory
entitlement of an owner or occupier of premises, to seek supply
of electricity. Such entitlement, however, cannot be considered
in isolation from the existing contractual and regulatory
relationship concerning the very same premises, particularly
where the applicant is not an unrelated subsequent occupier
but admittedly belongs to the same family and the same unit of
beneficiaries who had been enjoying the electricity supplied
through the earlier connection. The original connection stood in

Page 7 of 13

the name of the petitioner's deceased father, but following his
death, the electricity supplied through the said connection
continued to be enjoyed and maintained by the petitioner's
mother, who had been residing at the same premises. The
present petitioner, being the daughter of the original consumer
and a permanent resident of the same premises, was also a
member of the household and a beneficiary enjoying the benefit
of the existing connection. More significantly, she was not an
uninvolved stranger to the earlier disputes concerning the said
connection. The respondent has specifically contended that she
had been advising and representing her mother in the previous
proceedings before this Court, including WPA 10160 of 2026, in
which directions had been issued requiring steps for transfer of
the existing connection in the mother's name. The said
directions were admittedly not complied with. Neither was the
earlier connection surrendered nor were the requisite steps
taken to regularise the consumer relationship. In such
circumstances, the petitioner’s application dated June 4, 2026,
seeking a supposedly independent fresh connection at the very
same premises, cannot be examined merely by isolating the
petitioner from the history and legal incidents of the existing
connection. The question is not whether she, considered as an
individual, is otherwise capable of becoming a consumer under
Section 43, but whether, having regard to her relationship with
the original consumer, the continued enjoyment of the supply
by her mother and the subsisting regulatory consequences of
the earlier connection, the present application represents a
genuine independent requirement or is merely an attempt to
obtain indirectly what could not be obtained directly through
the earlier proceedings. The statutory entitlement under Section
43 cannot be employed as an instrument to circumvent a

Page 8 of 13

subsisting consumer agreement, avoid the lawful determination
of liabilities arising therefrom or defeat the consequences of an
earlier judicial adjudication. The doctrine that what cannot be
achieved directly cannot be permitted to be achieved indirectly
is attracted, where the subsequent proceeding is demonstrably
designed to circumvent an existing legal impediment. The Court
must, therefore, look at the substance and real object of the
application rather than merely its description as an application
for a new connection.

12. Regulation 4.6.1 of the West Bengal Electricity Regulatory
Commission (Electricity Supply Code) Regulations, 2012,
provides that where supply to a consumer remains
disconnected continuously for 180 days, provided such
disconnection has been effected in compliance with the Act or
Regulations, the agreement between the licensee and the
consumer shall be deemed to have been terminated upon expiry
of the said period. The provision is not merely procedural; it
determines the point of time at which the existing contractual
relationship comes to an end by operation of law. In the present
case, the earlier supply was disconnected on March 23, 2026,
whereas the present petitioner submitted her application for a
new connection on June 4, 2026. Thus, on the date of the
application, only approximately seventy-three days had elapsed
from the date of disconnection. The statutory period of 180 days
had not expired and, consequently, the original agreement had
not, on that date, undergone deemed termination by operation
of Regulation 4.6.1. The legal relationship concerning the earlier
connection was, therefore, still governed by the existing
regulatory framework. The petitioner cannot, merely by
submitting an application in her individual name during the

Page 9 of 13

subsistence of that agreement, seek to create a legal fiction that
the earlier consumer relationship and its attendant liabilities
have ceased to exist. Such an interpretation would permit
members of the same beneficiary unit to successively change
the identity of the applicant, thereby rendering the statutory
period prescribed under Regulation 4.6.1 and the consequences
contemplated under Regulation 4.6.4 substantially nugatory.

13. Regulation 4.6.4 of the 2012 Regulations assumes significance
in this context, inasmuch as it provides that where deemed
termination of the earlier agreement has taken place, a new
service connection in the same premises can be provided only
upon clearance of the outstanding dues against the deemed-
terminated consumer together with the applicable late payment
surcharge. The provision contains a non-obstante clause and is
intended to prevent the grant of a fresh service connection in
the same premises without settlement of the outstanding
liabilities attaching to the deemed-terminated connection. The
Hon'ble Supreme Court in K.C. Ninan v. Kerala State
Electricity Board [(2023) 14 SCC 431] , while considering the
corresponding provisions of the West Bengal Electricity Supply
Code, specifically noticed the effect of Regulations 4.6.1 and
4.6.4 and recognised that the statutory consequences of
deemed termination and the requirement of clearance of
outstanding dues cannot be disregarded while considering an
application for a new service connection in the same premises.
The decision, particularly paragraphs 316 to 321, makes it clear
that the regulatory framework must be given effect to according
to its terms. The Court is conscious that Regulation 4.6.4
operates upon deemed termination under Regulation 4.6.1 and
cannot be invoked prematurely as though the 180-day period

Page 10 of 13

had already expired. Nevertheless, the fact that the application
was submitted before expiry of that period is itself relevant to
the examination of the petitioner's real intention, particularly
when the applicant was admittedly benefitted under and
enjoyed the original connection and had knowledge of the
earlier proceedings and the outstanding issues relating to the
original connection. The petitioner cannot claim that the mere
description of her application as one for a fresh connection,
automatically severs the factual and legal continuity of the
earlier consumer relationship. The provisions must be read
harmoniously so that Section 43 of the 2003 Act does not
become an instrument for defeating the specific regulatory
safeguards contained in the Supply Code.

14.
Applying the aforesaid principles to the facts of the present
case, this Court finds that the petitioner's application cannot be
treated as an ordinary application by an independent
subsequent occupier, having no connection with the previous
consumer or the circumstances surrounding the disconnection.
The petitioner is admittedly the daughter of the original
consumer, resides in the same premises, belongs to the same
household and a beneficiary of the service and was aware of the
proceedings concerning restoration and transfer of the earlier
connection. The fact that her mother continued to enjoy the
electricity supply after the death of the original consumer,
coupled with the petitioner's participation in the earlier
litigation and the failure to comply with the directions
concerning transfer of the existing connection, assumes
considerable significance. Instead of first complying with the
directions of the Court and resolving the legal and regulatory
position concerning the earlier connection, the petitioner has

Page 11 of 13

sought to initiate a parallel course by submitting an application
in her own name for a fresh connection at the same premises,
while the original agreement had not yet undergone deemed
termination. The timing and circumstances of such application,
viewed cumulatively, give rise to a serious apprehension that
the present proceeding is intended to secure indirectly the
benefit which could not be obtained through the earlier
proceedings, without first addressing the consequences arising
from the existing consumer relationship. Such a course cannot
be encouraged by a Court exercising its equitable jurisdiction
under Article 226 of the Constitution. The principle that a
litigant cannot approbate and reprobate, or seek to achieve by
an indirect way what the law does not permit directly, assumes
relevance in these circumstances. The Court is, therefore,
unable to accept the petitioner's claim that her application
must be considered as an entirely independent statutory
demand, divorced from the earlier connection and the
proceedings relating thereto. This finding does not rest merely
upon her relationship with the deceased consumer, but upon
the cumulative effect of her participation in the earlier
proceedings, her continued association with the same
beneficiary family unit, the failure to regularise the existing
connection and the timing of the subsequent application.

15. Accordingly, this Court is of the view that the petitioner's claim
for a fresh connection cannot be allowed to operate as a device
for avoiding the legal consequences, if any, attaching to the
earlier consumer agreement. The respondent is entitled to
examine and determine the outstanding liabilities, if any, in
accordance with the applicable provisions of the Supply Code,
including Regulations 3.4.2, 4.6.1 and 4.6.4, as applicable to

Page 12 of 13

the relevant facts and period. At the same time, the respondent
cannot act arbitrarily or impose any liability upon the petitioner
without establishing the necessary statutory ingredients. The
petitioner's application must, therefore, be considered in the
context of the existing consumer relationship and the applicable
regulatory provisions, and not merely as an isolated application
by an unrelated new consumer. Any fresh connection, if
otherwise permissible, shall remain subject to the lawful
determination and discharge of the liabilities attaching to the
earlier connection and fulfilment of all applicable statutory and
technical requirements. For this purpose, the respondent shall
be at liberty to conduct inspection over the premises and the
existing meter and board, upon notice to the occupiers and the
occupiers would be liable as per the statutory provisions, to give
free access to the officials of the respondent to do such
inspection. In case of any obstruction is faced from anybody at
the time of inspection, the respondent authority shall be at
liberty to call for police help from the local police station, who
shall be obliged to provide the same immediately, if sought for,
cost of which may be recovered from the petitioner herein.

16.
Consequent upon such inspection and on the basis of finding
thereof the respondent authority shall take each and all
necessary appropriate steps in accordance with law, which may
also include its decision regarding the petitioner’s application
dated June 4, 2026. The entire exercise as directed should be
concluded by the respondent authority within a period of 12
weeks from the date of this judgment.

17. The present writ petition being No. WPA 17777 of 2026 is
disposed of with the directions as above.

Page 13 of 13


18. Urgent certified copy of this judgment, if applied for, be
supplied to the parties upon compliance with all requisite
formalities.
(Rai Chattopadhyay, J.)