STATE OF KARNATAKA vs SRI. SATHISHA

Court
Karnataka High Court

- 1 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62769
CRL.A No. 1875 of 2016


CNR: KAHC010526062016





IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU

TH
DATED THIS THE 12 DAY OF NOVEMBER, 2026


BEFORE

THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE G BASAVARAJA

CRIMINAL APPEAL NO.1875 OF 2016 (A)

BETWEEN:

STATE OF KARNATAKA
BY VENUR POLICE STATION,
REP BY SPP HIGH COURT BUILDING,
BENGALURU - 560 001
…APPELLANT
(BY SRI. K.NAGESHWARAPPA, HCGP)

AND:

SRI. SATHISHA
AGED ABOUT 28 YEARS,
S/O BABU POOJARY,
R/AT HENNALA HOUSLE,
HIREBANDARY VILLAGE,
PUTTUR, DAKSIHNA KANNADA - 574 201
…RESPONDENT

(BY SRI. KETHAN KUMAR, ADVOCATE)

THIS CRL.A IS FILED UNDER SECTION 378(1) & (3) OF
CR.P.C PRAYING TO a) GRANT LEAVE TO APPEAL AGAINST THE
JUDGEMENT AND ORDER OF ACQUITAL DATED 08.07.2016
PASSED IN C.C.NO.1001/2013 ON THE FILE OF THE ADDL.
CIVIL JUDGE AND JMFC, BELTHANGADY ACQUITTING THE
RESPONDENT-ACCSED OF THE OFFENCE PUNISHABLE UNDER
SECTIONS 279, 304(A) OF IPC; AND ETC

THIS APPEAL COMING ON FOR FINAL HEARING THIS
DAY, JUDGMENT WAS DELIVERED THEREIN AS UNDER:












Digitally signed by
LAKSHMINARAYAN N
Location: High Court of
Karnataka

- 2 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62769
CRL.A No. 1875 of 2016


CNR: KAHC010526062016



CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE G BASAVARAJA

ORAL JUDGMENT


1. The State has preferred this appeal against the
Judgment of Acquittal dated 08.07.2016 passed in
C.C.No.1001/2013 by the Addl. Civil Judge and JMFC,
Belthangady (for short, 'the trial Court').


2. For the sake of convenience, the parties herein are
referred as per the status before the trial Court.


3. Brief facts leading to this appeal are that, the Circle
Inspector of Police, Venur Circle submitted charge sheet
against the accused for the offence under Sections 279,
304A of IPC and Section 134(a) of IMV Act. It is alleged
by the prosecution that, on 30.07.2013 at about 12:45 pm
in a place called Hosangadi village of Belthangady Taluk,
Moodabidire-Venur State-Highway Road, opposite to
Hosangadi Panchayath, the accused being the driver of
Bus bearing Reg.No.KA-19-D-859, drove the same in a
high speed, rash and negligent manner so as to endanger

- 3 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62769
CRL.A No. 1875 of 2016


CNR: KAHC010526062016



human life by driving on extreme right side of the road.
Thus, the accused has committed the alleged offence
under Sections 279 and 304A of IPC. Further, it is alleged
that after the accident, the accused failed to secure
medical attention for the injured person, thus he has
committed the offence punishable under Section 134(a)
(187) of IMV Act.


4. After filing the charge sheet, case was registered,
accused enlarged on bail. The substance of plea was
recorded. Accused pleaded not guilty and claimed to be
tried.


5. To prove the guilt of the accused, prosecution has
examined in all, 8 witnesses as PWs.1 to 8 and 16
documents were marked as Exs.P1 to P16. On closure of
prosecution side evidence, statement under Section 313 of
Cr.P.C was recorded. Accused has totally denied the
evidence of prosecution witnesses and adduced the

- 4 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62769
CRL.A No. 1875 of 2016


CNR: KAHC010526062016



evidence of DW1-Accused Sathisha. However, no
documents got marked on behalf of accused.


6. Having heard the arguments on both sides, the trial
Court has acquitted the accused. Being aggrieved by the
said judgment, the State has preferred this appeal.


7. The learned HCGP, Sri K Nageshwarappa would
submit that the impugned judgment of acquittal is not
sustainable under law. The trial Court has not properly
appreciated the evidence on record in accordance with law
and facts. In his evidence PW1, who is the eye-witness
and complainant, has clearly deposed that he was
proceeding towards his shop on two-wheeler. He
witnessed the accident at 100 feet distance and
respondent drove the vehicle in a very rash and negligent
manner and he took his bus to the extreme right side and
dashed it to the opposite vehicle.

- 5 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62769
CRL.A No. 1875 of 2016


CNR: KAHC010526062016




8. The post-mortem report reveals that the deceased
died due to multi organ damage resulting from a road
traffic accident. The same was not considered by the trial
Judge. DW1 denied any negligence on his part and he
alleged that the negligence was on the part of the
deceased while overtaking a rickshaw. He also stated that
he assisted the deceased by accompanying him to the
hospital, which shows that the accused was present at the
spot. However, the trial Court has not considered this.
On all these grounds, it is sought for allowing this appeal.



9. As against this, the learned counsel for the
respondent Sri Kethan Kumar would submit that, PWs.1,
2, 3 and 5 are the eye-witnesses. Out of them, PWs.2, 3
and 5 have deposed that they went to the spot only after
the accident. Therefore, it is clear that they are not the
eye-witnesses to the alleged incident.


10. PW3 has not fully supported to the case of the
prosecution. That, there is no cogent and convincing

- 6 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62769
CRL.A No. 1875 of 2016


CNR: KAHC010526062016



evidence by the prosecution. The trial Court has properly
appreciated the evidence on record in accordance with law
and facts and passed the impugned judgment of acquittal
and accordingly, sought for dismissal of the appeal.


11. Having heard the arguments on both sides and on
perusal of the materials placed before this Court, the
following points would arise for my consideration:
(1) Whether the State has made out grounds
to interfere with the judgment of acquittal?
(2) What order?

12. My answer to the above points as under:
Point No.1: In Negative.
Point No.2: As per final order.

Regarding Point No.1:

13. Before appreciation of evidence on record, it is
necessary to mention as to the judgments of the Hon'ble
Apex Court in the case of CONSTABLE 907 SURENDRA
SINGH AND ANOTHER v. STATE OF UTTARAKHAND
reported in (2025)5 SCC 433; BABU SAHEBGOUDA

- 7 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62769
CRL.A No. 1875 of 2016


CNR: KAHC010526062016



RUDRAGOUDAR AND OTHERS v. STATE OF KARNATAKA
reported in (2024)8 SCC 149; CHANDRAPPA v. STATE OF
KARNATAKA reported in (2007)4 SCC 415; and H.D.
SUNDARA v. STATE OF KARNATAKA reported in (2023)9
SCC 581. The principles governing exercise of appellate
jurisdiction while dealing with an appeal against judgment
of acquittal under section 378 of Code of Criminal
Procedure are, the acquittal of the accused further
strengthens the presumption of innocence; the appellate
court, while hearing an appeal against acquittal, is entitled
to re-appreciate the oral and documentary evidence; the
appellate court, while deciding an appeal against acquittal,
after re-appreciating the evidence, is required to consider
whether the view taken by the trial court is a possible view
which could have been taken on the basis of the evidence
on record; if the view taken is a possible view, the
appellate court cannot overturn the order of acquittal on
the ground that another view was also possible; and the
appellate court can interfere with the order of acquittal

- 8 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62769
CRL.A No. 1875 of 2016


CNR: KAHC010526062016



only if it comes to a finding that the only conclusion which
can be recorded on the basis of the evidence on record
was that the guilt of the accused was proved beyond a
reasonable doubt and no other conclusion was possible.
The interference by an appellate court for reversing the
judgment of acquittal recorded by the trial court in favour
of the accused has to be exercised only if the judgment of
acquittal suffers from patent perversity; the same is based
on a misreading/omission to consider material evidence on
record; and that no two reasonable views are possible and
only the view consistent with the guilt of the accused is
possible from the evidence available on record.


14. I have examined the materials placed before this
Court. This case arises out of the complaint filed by PW1-
Complainant as per Ex.P1. Same reads as under:
" (62)
ಷಯಃ ನನ  ಕ ಪ ಗುಣ ಾ ೈ ರವರು ಾಹನ ಅಪ ತಂದ
.
ಮೃತಪಟ# ಬ%ೆ&
- , -
'ಾನು (ೕ*ಾ +,ದ -ಾಸದ/0 ತಂ1ೆ 2ಾ3 4ೆಂಡ6 ಮಕ -ೆ7ಂ%ೆ
. .
ಾಸಾ8ರುವ9ದು 'ಾನು ಕೃ:ಕ'ಾ8ರು2ೆ;ೕ'ೆ 'ಾನು ಪಡ<ಂದಡ ದ/0 ಒಂದು

- 9 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62769
CRL.A No. 1875 of 2016


CNR: KAHC010526062016



.
ಅಂಗ>ಯನು  4ೊಂ ರು2ೆ;ೕ'ೆ ಅಂಗ>ಯ/0 4ೆ@ಾA8 ನನ  ತಂ1ೆಯವರು
. .
ಇರು2ಾ;Cೆ DೆಲFಂದು GಾH ಅಂಗ>ಯ/0 'ಾನೂ ಇರು2ೆ;ೕ'ೆ
30.07.2013
ಈ ನ 'ಾಂಕ ರಂದು 'ಾನು ಅಂಗ>%ೆ ಪಡ<ಂದಡ Dೆ
12.40
4ೋಗGೇDೆಂದು ಮ'ೆ3ಂದ ಸುJಾರು ಗಂKೆ ಸಮಯDೆ ನನ  Gಾಬು;

LಚಕN ಾಹನದ/0 ಕುOತು 4ೊರಟು ಪಡ<ಂದಡ Dೆ ಮೂಡP1ೆN ೇಣೂರು QಾJಾರು

ರRೆ;ಯ/0 4ೋಗು2ಾ; ನನ  ಮುಂ Sಂದ ನನ  ಕ ಪ ಗುಣ ಾ ೈರವರು
. . .21- -4295
ಅವರ Gಾಬು; ಇ'ೊ ೕವ DಾT ನಂ Dೆ ಎ ಎಂ 'ೇದನು 
.
ಚ*ಾ3,Dೊಂಡು ೇಣೂರು ಕQೆ%ೆ 4ೋಗು6;ದVರು 'ಾವ9 ಮುಂದDೆ 4ೋಗು2ಾ;
.
Dಾರು 4ೊಸಂಗ> %ಾN ಪಂ@ಾಯW ಕXೇHಯ ಮುಂYಾಗ QಾJಾರು ರRೆ;ಯ/0

4ೋಗು6;ದVಂ2ೆZೕ DಾHನ [ಂYಾಗದ/0 LಚಕN ಾಹನದ/0 4ೋಗು6;ದV 'ಾನು
12.45
'ೋಡು6;ದVಂ2ೆZೕ ಗಂKೆ ಸುJಾH%ೆ ೇಣೂರು ಕQೆ3ಂದ ಅ6ೕ ೇಗ

4ಾಗೂ ಅ ಾಗರೂಕ2ೆ3ಂದ ಮೂಡP1ೆN ಕQೆ%ೆ ಚ*ಾ3,Dೊಂಡು ಬರು6;ದV
. . . .19- -859
> ೈ ಮ,\ ಬ] ನಂ , Dೆ ಎ > 'ೇದನು  ಅದರ @ಾಲಕ ಸ6ೕಶ
. .21- -4295
ಎಂGಾತನು ರRೆ;ಯ 6ೕರ ಬಲDೆ ಚ*ಾ3, Dಾರು Dೆ ಎ ಎಂ 'ೇದDೆ
.
>_ 4ೊQೆದ ಪH`ಾಮ Dಾರು [ಂದDೆ ಸHದು ಮಣುa `ೆaಯ (ೕ*ೆ Sಂ6ತು

>_ 4ೊQೆದದVನು  'ೋ>ದ 'ಾನು ನನ  LಚಕN ಾಹನವನು S/0, ಸbಳDೆ 4ೋ8
,
'ೋ>1ಾಗ %ಾಯ%ೊಂಡು ರಕ;RಾNವ ಆಗು6;ದುV ಆ ಕೂಡ*ೆ ಶಬV DೇO ಸbಳDೆ

ಬಂದ ಸ6ೕe ಕುJಾT ಮತು; Dೇಶವರವರು RೇH %ಾಯ%ೊಂ>ದV ನನ 

ಕ ಪ ನನು DಾHSಂದ 4ೊರDೆ 2ೆ%ೆದು ಒಂದು ಾಹನದ/0 _2ೆf%ೆಂದು
.
ಮೂಡP1ೆN ಆ-ಾL] ಆಸ 2ೆN%ೆ Rಾ8,1ೆವ9 ನನ  ಕ ಪ ಗುಣ ಾ ೈರವH%ೆ
.
ತ*ೆಯ ಬಲYಾಗDೆ ಗಂgೕರ ಾದ %ಾಯ ಾ8ತು; _2ೆf%ೆಂದು ಆಸ 2ೆN%ೆ ತಂ1ಾಗ
1.30
ಆಸ 2ೆNಯ/0 ಪHೕh,ದ ೈದiರು ಮjಾiಹ  ಗಂKೆ%ೆ ಮೃತಪk#ರುವ91ಾ8
.
6O,ದರು

ಈ ಮರಣDೆ Dಾರಣ ೇ'ೆಂದCೆ ಗುಣ ಾ ೈರವರು ಅವರ Gಾಬು; Dಾರು
. .21- -4295
Dೆ ಎ ಎಂ 'ೇದನು  ಅವರು ಮೂಡP1ೆN ಕQೆ3ಂದ ೇಣೂರು ಕQೆ%ೆ
12.45
Cಾಜi 4ೆ1ಾVH ರRೆ;ಯ/0 ಚ*ಾ3,Dೊಂಡು 4ೋಗು2ಾ; ಗಂKೆ%ೆ

4ೊಸಂಗ> %ಾNಮ ಪಂ@ಾಯW ಕXೇH ಎದುರು ತಲುm1ಾಗ ಎದುರುಗQೆ3ಂದ
. .19-
ಅಂದCೆ ೇಣೂರು ಕQೆ3ಂದ ಮೂಡP1ೆN ಕQೆ%ೆ ಬ] > ೈ ಮ,\ Dೆ ಎ
-859
> 'ೇದರ @ಾಲಕ ಸ6ೕe ಎಂGಾತನು ಅ6ೕ ೇಗ 4ಾಗೂ

- 10 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62769
CRL.A No. 1875 of 2016


CNR: KAHC010526062016



. .21- -
ಅ ಾಗರೂಕ2ೆ3ಂದ ರRೆ;ಯ 6ೕರ ಬಲYಾಗDೆ ಚ*ಾ3, Dಾರು Dೆ ಎ ಎಂ
4295
'ೇದDೆ >_ 4ೊQೆ,ದ ಪH`ಾಮ ತ*ೆಯ ಬಲYಾಗDೆ ಉಂKಾದ ಗಂgೕರ
. . .19- -859
%ಾಯ ಂದ ಮೃತಪಟ#1ಾV8ರುತ;1ೆ ಆದVHಂದ ಬ] Dೆ ಎ > 'ೇದರ

@ಾಲಕ ಸ6ೕಶನು >_ 4ೊQೆ,ದ ಬOಕ >_ oಾದ @ಾರವನು oಾHಗೂ

6Oಸ1ೇ %ಾoಾಳpವನು  _2ೆf%ೆ ಆಸ 2ೆNಗೂ Rಾ8ಸ1ೇ ಸbಳ ಂದ

ಪCಾHoಾ8ದುV ಸ N @ಾಲಕನ ರುದq Dಾನೂನು ಕNಮ ಜರು8ಸGೇDೆಂದು
."
DೇODೊಳpr2ೆ;ೕ'ೆ


15. PW1-A Sharmith Kumar, has deposed in his evidence
that on 30-7-2013 at about 12:40 pm when he was going
to his shop situated at Paddandhatka on his bike, he saw
his unlce Gunapal Jain driving his Innova car bearing
No.KA 21 M 4295 in front of his bike. When he reached
Parinje Gram Panchayath, the Bus bearing No.KA 19 D
859 driven in a rash manner on extreme right, dashed to
Innova car. Immediately, he along with CW4, CW5 and
general public went to the spot and saw his uncle Gunapal
Jain with grievous injuries. He secured Gunapal Jain out
from the car and took him to Alvas Hospital for treatment,
but he was reported dead at 1:30 PM. He also identified
the accused before the court and also deposed about

- 11 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62769
CRL.A No. 1875 of 2016


CNR: KAHC010526062016



lodging the complaint and also witnessing the complainant
before the Court.


16. PW2-Sathish Kumar has deposed in his evidence
that, on 30-7-2013 he left his office for lunch at 12:30 pm
and at about 12:45 pm he witnessed the Divine Mercy Bus
bearing No. KA 19 D 859 driven in rash and negligent
manner, dashed to the Innova car No. KA 21 N 4295 and
due to the impact, the driver Gunapal Jain sustained
injuries. Immediately, he along with CW1 and CW5 took
the deceased Gunapal Jain to Alvas Hospital, but he was
reported dead. He also identified the accused before the
court. But he deposed that he heard the sound of accident,
but has not witnessed the accident.


17. PW3-Keshava who is one of the eye-witnesses, has
deposed in his evidence that on 30-7-2013 at about 12:45
pm he witnessed the Divine Mercy Bus bearing No.KA 19 D
859 driven in rash and negligent manner and dashed the
Innova car no. KA 21 N 4295. Immediately, he approached

- 12 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62769
CRL.A No. 1875 of 2016


CNR: KAHC010526062016



the spot and found the injuries on Gunapal Jain.
Immediately, he along with CW1 and CW4 took the
Gunapal Jain to Alvas Hospital in Tata Sumo jeep, but he
was reported dead. He also identified the accused before
the court. But he deposed that he heard the sound of
accident and then he went to the spot. This witness is
treated as partly hostile witness and cross-examined by
the Public Prosecutor.


18. PW4-Sharath Jain, another eye-witness has deposed
in his evidence that on 30-7-2013 when he along with his
friend CW7-Prashanth Hegde were on the way to
Moodabidire, witnessed the Divine Mercy Bus bearing No.
KA 19 D 859 driven in rash and negligent manner and
dashed the Innova car No. KA 21 N 4295. Immediately, he
along with CW7 reached the spot and found the injured
was Gunapal Jain. Immediately, he along with CW7
assisted the CW1, CW4 and CW5 in sending the deceased
Gunapal Jain to Alvas Hospital. He also identified the
accused before the court. He also deposed about the

- 13 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62769
CRL.A No. 1875 of 2016


CNR: KAHC010526062016



preparation of mahazar and sketch and he also about
seizure of vehicles involved in the accident.


19. PW5-Prashanth Hegde, the another eye-witness has
deposed that on 30-7-2013 when he along with his friend
CW6-Sharath Jain B.G were on the way to Moodabidire,
have witnessed the Divine Mercy Bus bearing no. KA 19 D
859 driven in rash and negligent manner on extreme right
side and dashed the Innova car no. KA 21 N 4295. He
along with CW6 reached the spot and found the injured
was Gunapal Jain. He along with CW6 assisted CW1, CW4
and CW5 secured Gunapal Jain out of the car and sent him
to Alvas Hospital. He also deposed that, before he could
reach the spot, the driver of bus had fled away from the
spot. This witness has been treated as hostile witness with
the permission of Court and cross-examined by the
prosecution.

- 14 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62769
CRL.A No. 1875 of 2016


CNR: KAHC010526062016




20. PW7-Sudhath Jain another mahazar witness has
deposed as to the mahazar conducted by the Police and
also preparation of sketch.


21. PW8-Abdul Khader, PSI and PW9-Bhaskar Rai, CPI,
have deposed as to their respective investigation.


22. On careful examination of the entire evidence on
record, the trial Court has appreciated the evidence on
record in Paragraphs 30 to 40 of the judgment. Same
reads as hereunder:
"30
. On conclusion of the prosecution evidence, the
defence adduced his evidence as DW1, but not
produced any document or marked in support of his
case. He deposed that on 30-7-2013 he drove the
bus towards Moodabidre and it was heavy rain. So he
drove the bus slowly. When he reached Hosangady
Gram Panchayath, the Innova car overtook the
Rikshaw and dashed the bus and he immediately
approached the car and found the driver injured. He
secured out and took him to Alvas hospital for
treatment. He left key in the bus and the people
gathered at spot have moved the bus. The police

- 15 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62769
CRL.A No. 1875 of 2016


CNR: KAHC010526062016



secured him to station and thereby prayed to acquit
him from the case.

31
. In his cross examination he has admitted about
20 to 30 passengers being in bus. He deposed about
he giving information of accident to Venoor police
station. he also admitted that he alone has not
accompanied the injured to hospital, but he along
with other persons had accompanied the injured to
hospital. He also admitted that, about the
defence/grounds taken in chief examination is for the
first time. He also admitted that he has given the
complaint against the driver of Innova car and that
he has not produced the copy of complaint to court.

32.
In this case, the PW1 is the eye witness and
complainant and the person who assisted the
deceased Gunapal Jain in taking to hospital. The PW2
and PW3 are also the eye witnesses who witnessed
the accident and the persons who have assisted in
taking Gunapal Jain to Hosptial. PW4 is the eye
witness and a person who also assisted in sending
Gunapal Jain to hospital and the person who shown
the spot to the police. Likewise, PW5 is also another
eyewitness who witnessed the accident and the
person who assisted in taking care of deceased
Gunapal Jain to hospital. Pw6 & Pw7 are the mahazar
witnesses. Pw8 the PSI who registered the case and

- 16 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62769
CRL.A No. 1875 of 2016


CNR: KAHC010526062016



Pw9 CPI who investigated the case and filed charge
sheet against the accused.

33.
In the case on hand though the accident and
death is not disputed, but the prosecution has to
prove the rash and negligent act on the part of the
accused beyond all reasonable doubts, because in
order to attract ingredients of alleged offences there
must be direct nexus between the death and the
alleged rash and negligent act on the part of the
accused.

34.
The prosecution has examined all the eye
witnesses in support of its case. No doubt, all the
witnesses have narrated about the occurrence of
accident, but on gathering their evidence it goes to
show there are lot of omissions and contradictory
evidence between these witnesses. Now coming to
the evidence of PW2 who is said to be eye witness,
though deposed about the accident, but he clearly
admitted that he has not witnessed the accident and
only on hearing sound he reached the spot and found
the injured. Though the prosecution has treated the
witness partly hostile and cross examined him and
took the admission of witnessing the accident, but
again during in the course of cross examination by
defence side, the witness clearly admitted about he
hearing the sound of accident and then he reaching

- 17 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62769
CRL.A No. 1875 of 2016


CNR: KAHC010526062016



the spot. So the evidence of this witness goes to
show about he not witnessing the accident, but only
after hearing the sound of accident, he reaching the
spot. So when he has not witnessed the accident, so
certainly he would not be able to depose the rash
and negligent manner of driving. No doubt, the
witness has deposed about he witnessing the bus at
a distance of 100 meters, but again he has not
specifically made it clear about the manner of driving
and its speed at a particular distance. Likewise, the
another eye witness the PW3 also clearly deposed
about he not witnessing the accident, but only after
hearing the sound of accident he reached the spot.
Again this witness was treated partly hostile and in
the cross examination by APP got admitted about he
witnessing the accident and also he witnessing the
accused as a driver of the bus. Though this witness
not whispered about he witnessing the accident or
witnessing the accused or getting the name of
accused at the time of accident in his evidence, but
in cross examination by APP, he admits all these
aspects and supports the prosecution case. But again
during the course of cross examination by defence
side, he again reverts and admits about he not
witnessing the accident and he reaching the spot
after 10 minutes only on hearing the sound of
accident. He also clearly admits about he not

- 18 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62769
CRL.A No. 1875 of 2016


CNR: KAHC010526062016



witnessing the accused at the spot on he reaching
the spot. So again this witness is not particular about
witnessing the accident. No doubt, the witness not
witnessing the accused at the spot alone shall not
support the defence case, but the omissions would
certainly would support the defence case. Because, it
is not the case of accused that he was not the driver
of the bus on the alleged day. That apart, as per the
reply issued towards the notice u/s 133 of IMV Act, it
clearly goes to show the accused was the driver of
the bus at the time of accident. But as stated supra,
the omission so far he giving the statement before
the police about he witnessing the accident and
identifying the accused and his appearance at the
spot makes much importance. Likewise the PW4 who
is also the eye witness who has specifically admitted
about he not witnessing the vehicles coming on the
opposite direction as he was behind the bus. He also
clearly admitted about he not knowing as to how the
accident was occurred. Again the PW5 the another
eye witness who also has admitted about he not
witnessing the accused at the spot. Even this witness
was treated partly hostile and was permitted to cross
examine the witness and again the witness admitted
about he witnessing the accused at spot. The PW1
who is material witness has admitted about he
witnessing the bus at about 100 feet at a distance

- 19 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62769
CRL.A No. 1875 of 2016


CNR: KAHC010526062016



and he reached the spot immediately after the
accident by stopping his bike at 60 to 70 feet at a
distance from the spot. Was this witness able to
witness the accident from the said distance.
Admittedly all the eye witnesses are related or
interested witnesses in one way or other. As per the
PW1, the deceased is his uncle. Deceased is well
known to PW2. He belongs to same community of
pw4 and well known to PW3 & PW5. As per the
evidence of prosecution side, there were many
people’s gathered at the spot. Shops were adjacent
and passengers of the bus were present. Any of the
said persons could have made as a witness to the
case. This is one aspect.

35
. Now coming further, the PW1 has deposed that
immediately after the accident he went to the spot
and after securing the injured from the car, they took
the injured in Tata Sumo jeep. Like wise the PW3
also deposed about taking the injured in Tata Sumo
jeep. But contradictorily the PW2 who is also one of
the eye witness and the person who assisted and
accompanied in taking the injured to the hospital has
deposed about they taking the injured in a
autoriskaw till 3 km and then shifting in 108
ambulance. Again contradictorily the PW4 deposed
about sending the injured in Omni car to hospital.

- 20 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62769
CRL.A No. 1875 of 2016


CNR: KAHC010526062016



Admittedly, the pw1 to PW4 are all the eye witness
and who accompanied the injured to hospital except
PW4. When the witnesses are contradictorily
deposing to each other, then which version is
believable creates reasonable doubt. Certainly their
presence at spot creates doubts.

36
. The accused has taken a defence that, the
accident was occurred due to the negligence of
deceased while overtaking a rickshaw and he also
assisted the deceased by accompanying to the
hospital. Admittedly, the charges is leveled against
the accused for the offence punishable u/s 134(A) of
IMV Act for not assisting medical treatment to
deceased Gunapal Jain. Though the accused has
taken the defence of he assisting in taking care of
treatment to deceased, but no sufficient evidence is
placed on record to appreciate his defence. Though
the PW3 & PW5 have deposed about they not
witnessing the accused in the bus immediately after
the accident and they were treated as hostile to that
effect and admitted the accused presence at spot,
but the said evidence is suffice to hold that the
accused was not at the spot after the occurrence of
accident. No evidence is forthcoming to come to
conclusion about the presence of accused at spot.
Admittedly, it was the bounded duty of the accused

- 21 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62769
CRL.A No. 1875 of 2016


CNR: KAHC010526062016



to give the assistance to deceased in giving the
medical treatment admittedly not forth coming.

37
. So far the Mahazar is concerned, the pw6 the
mahazar witness has clearly admitted about he not
knowing the contents of the documents on which he
signed. Likewise, the PW4 the person who showed
the spot to police and signed the mahazar has
deposed about the preparation of mahazar was
between 1:30 to 2:00pm which is again
contradictory. Because, the mahazar is prepared
6:15 to 7:15 pm. Nodoubt, this witnesses have
contrarily deposed, but the PW7 the another
mahazar witness has clearly supported the
prosecution case by narrating the preparation of
mahzar and sketch. It was pointed about even this
witness being the interested witness as he has
admitted about the deceased being the owner of the
building where he is working. But the I.O. the pw9
has clearly narrated about the preparation of mahzar
and preparation of sketch. Nothing worth was elicited
from the I.O to discredit the presence of mahzar
witness and also the preparation of mahzar and
sketch. So even though the other mahazar witness
have not supported the drawing of mahazar and
sketch, but relying on the evidence of I.O, it could be
said the mahazar and sketch is proved. Again coming

- 22 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62769
CRL.A No. 1875 of 2016


CNR: KAHC010526062016



further the involvement of vehicle is not in dispute,
but the rash and negligent act on part of the accused
is required to be proved.

38
. It is pertinent to note that only the involvement
of the vehicle is not the criteria to bring home the
guilt of the accused for the alleged offences. No
doubt the mahazar is proved but in the case in hand,
there is no strong and positive evidence on record
from the independent witnesses about the rash and
negligent driving of the accused to cause the alleged
accident. In such circumstances it is very difficult to
effectively assess the evidence on record. Now
coming to the evidence of Pw8, it pertains about the
receiving the complaint and its registration. The
evidence of Pw9 pertains to the investigation process
and of filing the chargesheet and much discussion is
not necessary so far these witnesses are concerned.

39
. Learned APP has relied upon the decision report
in ILR 2004 KAR 689 Borayya V/s State Police, ILR
2004 KAR 1456 Eshwar V/s State of Karnataka, ILR
1999 KAR 1498 State by Bidadi Police Station V/s S.
B. Marigowda, 2014(1) Crimes 550(P&H)Kashmir
Singh V/s State of Punjab & 2006(1)Crimes 291(SC)
State of Andra Pradesh V/s Rayappa and others. It
was the argument of learned APP that any slight
discrepancy in evidence of prosecution shall not be

- 23 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62769
CRL.A No. 1875 of 2016


CNR: KAHC010526062016



the sole ground to discredit their evidence and that
the immediately reaching the spot by hearing the
sound is sufficient to prove his presence at spot and
also the witnesses cannot be rejected only
considering they are interested witness to case and
prayed to convict the accused on relying the decision
refereed above. Admittedly, the decision reported in
ILR 2004 KAR 689 wherein lordship has held that any
slight discrepancy in evidence of the village witness
shall not be the sole ground to discredit their
evidence , but in the case on hand it cannot be
treated the witnesses are not well versed with day to
day activities. All the witnesses are educated and
they know the importance of their evidence. So
certainly, the decision relied by APP will be of no help
for prosecution. Now coming to decision reported in
ILR 2004 KAR 1456 wherein the lordship has
convicted the accused for he driving his vehicle in a
rash and negligent manner on extreme right
direction. But in case in hand, no witness has
specifically deposed about the accused driving his
vehicle on extreme right side. Again in ILR 1999 KAR
1498 wherein lordship has held that when the
witness heard a sound and turned back and saw the
body dragging is sufficient to hold the rash and
negligent driving for causing accident. But the facts
and circumstance narrated in the said case is

- 24 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62769
CRL.A No. 1875 of 2016


CNR: KAHC010526062016



different to the case in hand. The witnesses are not
particular about their presence at spot, because they
have given their evidence contradictorily to their
statements. So again this decision would also in no
way helps the prosecution case. In the decision
reported in 2014(1) Crimes 550(P&H), the accused
had denied the driving the vehicle involved in the
accident. In the said case, he had disputed his
identity. But in case in hand, the accused has not
disputed his presence at spot or of driving his
vehicle. It is his defence that the accident was not
caused due to his fault. In the decision of 2016(1)
Crimes 219(SC) the lordship has held that testimony
of witness otherwise inspiring the confidence cannot
be discarded on ground that he being a relation of
deceased was an interested witness. Certainly the
prosecution witness were interested witnesses and
no one where independent witnesses. Certainly, their
evidence creates doubt about their presence at spot.
So looking the evidence on record it could be said
that the decision relied by learned APP would no way
helps its case.

40
. In case of Section 279 and 304A of IPC, the
prosecution has to prove that the driver of the
vehicle has driven his vehicle in rash and negligent
manner in public road. But in the present case on

- 25 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62769
CRL.A No. 1875 of 2016


CNR: KAHC010526062016



hand there is no material evidence before the court
to prove the ingredients of Section 279 and 304A of
IPC. On gathering the evidence on record, it could be
said that the prosecution has failed to prove the
alleged ingredients of Section 279 and 304A of IPC,
but has proved the offence punishable u/s 134(A) of
IMV Act. Hence, the prosecution has failed to prove
the offences u/s 279, 304(A) of IPC alleged against
the accused, but proved the offence punishable u/s
134(A) of IMV Act. Therefore taking in to
consideration of above discussion narrated above, I
hold that in absence of strong and cogent evidence
from the independent witnesses to corroborate the
accused guilt, the burden of doubt is required to be
given to the accused so far section 279, 304(A) of
IPC.
40.. Wherefore looking from the discussion narrated
above I come to a conclusion that the prosecution
has failed to prove its case beyond the shadow of
doubts so as to bring home the guilt of the accused
for the offences punishable u/s 279, 304(A) of IPC.
In the result benefit of doubt is to be given to the
accused for the offence punishable u/s 279, 304(A)
of IPC and shall be acquitted for the alleged offences
and shall be convicted for the offence punishable u/s
134(A) of IMV Act Hence, I answer point No.1 and 2
in the negative and point No.3 in the affirmative."

- 26 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62769
CRL.A No. 1875 of 2016


CNR: KAHC010526062016




23. On re-appreciation/re-consideration/re-examination
of the entire evidence on record, I do not find any legal or
factual error in the impugned Judgment of acquittal passed
by the trial Court. Considering the facts and circumstances
of the case and also keeping in mind the aforesaid
decisions of the Hon'ble Supreme Court, I answer point
No.1 in Negative.
Regarding Point No.2

24. For the aforestated reasons and discussions,
I proceed to pass the following:
O R D E R
Appeal is dismissed .

Sd/-
(G BASAVARAJA)
JUDGE




DHA
List No.: 1 Sl No.: 69