D DUSHYANTHAN vs Kendriya Vidyalaya Sangathan
- Court
- Central Administrative Tribunal
1 OA/310/00451/2019
CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL
CHENNAI BENCH
OA/310/00451/2019
st
Dated this the 1 day of September, Two Thousand Twenty Six
CORAM :
HON'BLE MR. M. SWAMINATHAN, MEMBER (J)
AND
HON'BLE MR. M.L. SRIVASTAVA, MEMBER(A)
D. Dushyanthan,
S/o (Late) G. Dhandapani
Retired Principal, Kendriya Vidyalaya
WAP-Yelahanka, Bangalore
R/o 24/1, Krishnamurthy Street,
West Mambalam.
Chennai 600 033 .. Applicant
By Advocate M/s. K. S. Govinda Prasad
Vs.
1. Union of India
rep by The Commissioner,
Kendriya Vidyalaya Sangathan,
18, Institutional Area,
Shahid Jeet Singh Marg,
New Delhi.
2. The Additional Commissioner (Admn)
Kendriya Vidyalaya Sangathan,
18, Institutional Area,
Shahid Jeet Singh Marg,
New Delhi.
3. The Assistant Commissioner (Finance)
Kendriya Vidyalaya Sangathan, (HQ)
18, Institutional Area,
Shahid Jeet Singh Marg,
New Delhi.
2 OA/310/00451/2019
4. The Assistant General Manager,
State Bank of India Code No. 4470,
Centralised Pension Processing Centre,
No.112/4, Kaliamman Koil Street,
Virugambakkam, Chennai.
5. The Deputy Commissioner (Finance),
Kendriya Vidalaya Sangathan (HQ),
18, Institutional Area,
Shahid Jeet Singh Marg,
New Delhi.
6. Union of India
rep by The Secretary to Govt of India,
Ministry of Human Resource Development Department
Shastri Bhavan,
New Delhi.
7. Union of India
rep by The Secretary to Government of India,
Department of Pension & Pensioners' Welfare
Shastri Bhavan,
New Delhi. .. Respondents
By Advocate Mr. M. Vaidhiyanathan (R1 to R3)
Mr. K. Chandrasekaran (R4)
Mr. Su. Srinivasan, SCGSC (R5 & R6)
3 OA/310/00451/2019
ORAL ORDER
(Pronounced by Hon'ble Mr. M. Swaminathan, Judicial Member)
In the instant OA the applicant is seeking the following relief:
“(i) To call for the records relating to the impugned order
bearing No. F.18(1547)/94/KVS/P&I/1128, dated
11.03.2019 issued by the 2nd respondent herein namely the
Additional Commissioner (Admn), Kendriya Vidyalaya
Sangathan (HQ), 18, Institutional Area, Shahid Jeet singh
Marg, New Delhi 110 016, set aside the same as non-est in
the eye of law and thus render justice;
(ii) To issue suitable directions to the 1st respondent herein
namely the Commissioner, Kendriya Vidyalaya Sangathan,
18, Institutional Area, Shahid Jeet Singh Marg, New Delhi
110 016, to re-fix the pension of the Applicant at Rs.14,960/-
per month with usual dearness Relief and other admissible
allowances from 1.1.2017 and continue to pay the same
every month to the Applicant and thus render justice;
(iii) To issue suitable directions to the 1st respondent herein
namely the Commissioner, Kendriya Vidyalaya Sangathan,
18, Institutional Area, Shahid Jeet Singh Marg, New Delhi
110 016, to pay the difference amount from 1.1.2017 at
Rs.1469 x 28 = Rs.41132/- plus usual Dearness Relief and
other admissible allowances within a time-frame that may be
fixed by this Hon'ble tribunal and thus render justice;
(iv) To issue suitable directions to the 1st respondent herein
namely the Commissioner, Kendriya Vidyalaya Sangathan,
18, Institutional Area, Shahid Jeet Singh Marg, New Delhi
110 016, not to effect any recovery from the pension of the
Applicant and thus render justice;
(v) To issue suitable directions to the 1st respondent
herein namely the Commissioner, Kendriya Vidyalaya
Sangathan, 18, Institutional Area, Shahid Jeet Singh Marg,
4 OA/310/00451/2019
New Delhi 110 016, to pay interst @ 18% per annum from
1.11.2016 being the reduced pension paid to the Applicant
on the above said difference amount within a time-frame
that may be fixed by this Hon'ble Tribunal and thus render
justice;
(vi) To award exemplary costs payable by the Respondents
to the Applicant herein and thus render justice. To grant such
other relief which may be prayed for and/ or which this
Tribunal may deem fit, proper and just to be granted in the
facts and circumstances of the case and thus render justice.”
2. Brief facts of the case, as submitted by the applicant are as follows:
The Applicant is a retired Headmaster/Principal of Kendriya Vidyalaya
Sangathan, WAP–Yelahanka, Bengaluru, who retired from service on
31.03.1994 after rendering 29 years, 7 months and 21 days of service with
the Respondent-Kendriya Vidyalaya Sangathan. Prior to joining the
Kendriya Vidyalaya Sangathan, he served as a School Assistant in Mani
Higher Secondary School, Coimbatore, from 26.09.1956 to 06.08.1963.
The Applicant’s grievance was that his service rendered in the said school
was not counted for pensionary benefits. He relied upon G.O. 3D No.31
dated 02.07.1993 issued by the Government of Tamil Nadu, the order of
this Tribunal in OA No.899 of 2001, and the order of the Hon’ble High
Court in W.P. No.46241 of 2002. However, the Respondents consistently
rejected his request on the ground that service rendered in a private school
aided by the Government of Tamil Nadu could not be counted for pension.
5 OA/310/00451/2019
Aggrieved, the Applicant filed OA Nos.1018 of 2009 and 1429 of 2010.
By order dated 12.09.2026, the Tribunal directed the Respondents to count
the Applicant’s service in Mani Higher Secondary School, Coimbatore, a
fully aided school under the Government of Tamil Nadu, for pensionary
benefits in terms of G.O. dated 02.07.1993, and to refix his pension and
disburse the arrears within three months. The Respondents challenged the
said order before the Hon’ble High Court in W.P. Nos.19450 and 19451 of
2013, which were dismissed. Despite the orders of the Tribunal and the
Hon’ble High Court, the Respondents failed to implement the same,
compelling the Applicant to file CA No.159 of 2013 in OA No.1429 of
2010. The said CA was closed upon production of the Office Order dated
27.02.2015, whereby the Respondents acknowledged and counted the
Applicant’s service in Mani Higher Secondary School for pensionary
benefits. Consequently, the Applicant had a total service of 37 years, 6
months and 20 days, which was restricted to 33 years as he had the
requisite qualifying service for maximum pension. Thereafter, by order
dated 15.05.2015, the Deputy Commissioner (Finance), Kendriya
Vidyalaya Sangathan, fixed the Applicant’s pension at Rs.14,960/- per
month with effect from 01.04.2014. However, by order dated 31.05.2017,
the pension was reduced to Rs.13,481/- per month. Challenging the
reduction, the Applicant filed OA No.786 of 2017, which was disposed of
6 OA/310/00451/2019
on 07.06.2017 with a direction to submit a comprehensive representation,
and to the Respondents to pass a reasoned and speaking order in
accordance with law and the applicable rules. Meanwhile, the Applicant
filed OA No.1555 of 2017 challenging the recovery of Rs.36,000/- from
his pension for the period from 30.06.2017 to 30.08.2017. By order dated
17.12.2018, the Tribunal directed the Applicant to make a representation,
particularly in view of the Respondents’ failure to indicate whether the
proposed recovery had been considered in terms of the DoPT OM dated
02.03.2016, issued pursuant to the Hon’ble Supreme Court’s order dated
18.12.2014 in the White Washer case. The Respondents were directed to
consider the representation and pass a reasoned and speaking order. CA
No.124 of 2017 filed in OA No.786 of 2017 was also closed on the basis
of the speaking order dated 17.11.2017 passed by the Respondents. While
the Applicant expected his pension to be restored to Rs.14,960/- per
month, the 2nd Respondent, by order dated 11.03.2019, reiterated that the
pension of Rs.13,491/- per month with effect from 01.01.2006 was
correctly fixed. Aggrieved by the said order and the continued denial of
the pensionary benefits claimed by him, the Applicant has filed the present
OA seeking the aforementioned reliefs.
7 OA/310/00451/2019
3. When the matter was taken up for hearing, learned counsel for the
applicant contended that the impugned order dated 11.03.2019 issued by
the 2nd Respondent is highly arbitrary, illegal, unjust, and unfair. The said
order constitutes a vindictive and colourable exercise of power, executed
at the whims and fancies of the concerned officials, and directly violates
the provisions of Article 21 of the Constitution of India. He also contends
that the impugned order runs contrary to the Respondents' own prior
orders as well as the established orders of this Tribunal. Furthermore, it is
explicitly submitted that there was no misrepresentation or fraud on the
part of the Applicant regarding the re-fixation of his pension. Therefore,
the impugned order dated 11.03.2019 is non-est in the eyes of the law and
is liable to be set aside.
4. The learned counsel for the Applicant submits that the Applicant is a
senior citizen aged approximately 86 years and is in the evening of his life.
Any recovery initiated pursuant to the impugned order dated 11.03.2019,
especially without prior notice would cause undue hardship. The Applicant
strongly relies on the landmark judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in
State of Punjab & Ors. v. Rafiq Masih (White Washer) , which strictly
prohibits recoveries from retired employees under such circumstances. It is
further submitted that pension is the Applicant's sole source of income. A
8 OA/310/00451/2019
major portion of this income is spent on medical expenses due to his
advanced age. The prolonged delay by the Respondents in issuing orders
for the revision of his pension with effect from 01.01.2006 has severely
impacted his financial position and well-being.
5. The Applicant states that he is similarly situated to the individuals
covered under the relevant Official Memorandums (OMs) governing
pension revision. In the interest of justice, equity, and fair play, the
Applicant prays that this Tribunal may be pleased to direct the 1st
Respondent to issue orders revising the Applicant's pension with effect
from 01.01.2006 and disburse the consequential arrears within a time-
bound period fixed by this Tribunal.
6. The learned counsel for the Respondents, strongly relying upon the
reply statement filed on record, submits that the fixation of the Applicant’s
pension is legally valid, accurate, and in strict compliance with governing
directives. It is submitted that the Ministry of Human Resource
Development (MHRD), vide Clarification Letter No. 3-44/2016-UT-2
dated 18.10.2016, explicitly clarified the pension mechanism for KVS
Principals who retired prior to 01.01.2006. As per the said mandate, the
pension and family pension must be fixed strictly in accordance with the
9 OA/310/00451/2019
amounts specified in Columns 9 and 10 of the Annexure to the Department
of Pension & Pensioners' Welfare (DoP&PW) Official Memorandum
(OM) dated 28.01.2013. This corresponds to the pre-01.01.2006 scale of
pay—specifically Rs. 12,600/- and Rs. 7,560/ - respectively, a criteria
uniformly applicable across all matching employee categories.
7. The learned counsel further submit that the pension of the Applicant
(an Ex-Principal) was reviewed de novo in thorough alignment with
DoP&PW OM No. 38/37/08-P&PW(A) dated 06.04.2016, alongside the
MHRD clarification dated 18.10.2016. Following this comprehensive re-
examination, the Applicant's revised pension was legally fixed at Rs.
13,491/- per month, effective from 01.01.2006. It is submitted that this
lawful revision was duly executed via Pension Payment Order (PPO) No.
F.18(1547)1448/94/KVS/P&I dated 31.10.2016, grounded firmly in the
DoP&PW OM dated 22.01.2013. The fixation is entirely in order, free
from error, and requires no judicial interference. With respect to the
specific issue of recovery raised by the Applicant, the learned counsel for
the Respondents has no further submission.
8. Heard the submissions made by the learned counsel for the parties,
perused the pleadings and the materials available on record.
10 OA/310/00451/2019
9. The issue that arises for our consideration in the OA is whether the
alleged recovery advice including re- fixation of pension issued to the
applicant, especially after the retirement of the applicant, is legally
sustainable or not.
10. At the time admission of this OA on 29.03.2019, this Tribunal
observed that the grievance of the applicant that his request was not
considered in terms of the OM dated 02.03.2016 of the DOPT, in respect
of recovery of excess payment alone, the following interim order was
passed:
“Accordingly, it is directed that no recovery shall be made
from the pension of the applicant in terms of the impugned
order dated 11.03.2019 or any order issued before such date
till the next date of hearing.”
11. The Applicant, having already superannuated on 31.03.1994, was
not in a position to withstand or mitigate such an abrupt financial burden.
Moreover, the impugned recovery is contrary to the law laid down by the
Hon’ble Supreme Court in Thomas Daniel vs. State of Kerala & Others
(Civil Appeal No. 7115 of 2010, judgment dated 02.05.2022). In the said
decision, the Apex Court, after considering the settled principles governing
recovery, held that recovery from retired employees, or those due to retire
11 OA/310/00451/2019
within one year from the date of the recovery order, is impermissible. It
was further observed that attempting recovery after a prolonged lapse of
time is unjustified. The relevant extract of the judgment is reproduced
below:
“9 . This Court in a catena of decisions has consistently
held that if the excess amount was not paid on account of
any misrepresentation or fraud of the employee or if such
excess payment was made by the employer by applying a
wrong principle for calculating the pay/allowance or on
the basis of a particular interpretation of rule/order which
is subsequently found to be erroneous, such excess
payment of emoluments or allowances are not
recoverable. This relief against the recovery is granted not
because of any right of the employees but in equity,
exercising judicial discretion to provide relief to the
employees from the hardship that will be caused if the
recovery is ordered. This Court has further held that if in a
given case, it is proved that an employee had knowledge
that the payment received was in excess of what was due
or wrongly paid, or in cases where error is detected or
corrected within a short time of wrong payment, the
matter being in the realm of judicial discretion, the courts
may on the facts and circumstances of any particular case
order for recovery of amount paid in excess.
xxxxx xxxxx
13 . In State of Punjab Vs Rafiq Masih (White Washer)
(2015) 4 SCC 334) wherein this court examined the
validity of an order passed by the State to recover the
monetary gains wrongly extended to the beneficiary
employees in excess of their entitlements without any fault
or misrepresentation at the behest of the recipient. This
Court considered situations of hardship caused to an
employee, if recovery is directed to reimburse the
employer and disallowed the same, exempting the
beneficiary employees from such recovery. It was held
thus:
12 OA/310/00451/2019
“ 8. As between two parties, if a determination is
rendered in favour of the party, which is the
weaker of the two, without any serious detriment
to the other (which is truly a welfare State), the
issue resolved would be in consonance with the
concept of justice, which is assured to the
citizens of India, even in the Preamble of the
Constitution of India. The right to recover being
pursued by the employer, will have to be
compared, with the effect of the recovery on the
employee concerned. If the effect of the recovery
from the employee concerned would be, more
unfair, more wrongful, more improper, and more
unwarranted, than the corresponding right of the
employer to recover the amount, then it would be
iniquitous and arbitrary, to effect the recovery. In
such a situation, the employee's right would
outbalance, and therefore eclipse, the right of the
employer to recover.
xxxxxxxxx
18. It is not possible to postulate all situations of
hardship which would govern employees on the issue
of recovery, where payments have mistakenly been
made by the employer, in excess of their entitlement.
Be that as it may, based on the decisions referred to
hereinabove, we may, as a ready reference,
summarise the following few situations, wherein
recoveries by the employers, would be impermissible
in law:
(I) Recovery from the employees belonging to Class
III and Class IV service (or Group C and Group D
service).
(ii) Recovery from the retired employees, or the
employees who are due to retire within one year, of
the order of recovery.
(iii) Recovery from the employees, when the excess
payment has been made for a period in excess of five
years, before the order of recovery is issued.
(iv) Recovery in cases where an employee has
wrongfully been required to discharge duties of a
higher post, and has been paid accordingly, even
13 OA/310/00451/2019
though he should have rightfully been required to
work against an inferior post.
(v) In any other case, where the court arrives at the
conclusion, that recovery if made from the employee,
would be iniquitous or harsh or arbitrary to such an
extent, as would far outweigh the equitable balance of
the employer's right to recover.”
12. In view of the foregoing discussion, the present case squarely falls
within the categories identified by the Hon’ble Supreme Court wherein
recovery of excess payment is impermissible. It is also brought to our
notice that, prior to effecting the recovery, no notice was issued to the
applicant, thereby denying him an opportunity to put forth his case.
13. As regards the revision of the applicant’s pension, we find that the
competent authorities have examined the matter afresh in terms of the
Government of India, Department of Pension & Pensioners’ Welfare, O.M.
No. 38/37/08-P&PW(A) dated 06.04.2016, and the clarification issued by
the Ministry of Human Resource Development vide letter No. 3-44/2016-
UT-2 dated 18.10.2016. Pursuant thereto, the applicant’s pension was
revised to Rs.13,491/- per month with effect from 01.01.2006, vide PPO
No. F.18(1547)1448/94/KVS/P&I dated 31.10.2016, in accordance with
the Government of India, Department of Pension & Pensioners’ Welfare,
O.M. dated 22.01.2013. We find the said revision to be in order and do not
14 OA/310/00451/2019
find any infirmity in the impugned order dated 11.03.2019 insofar as it
relates to the revision of pension.
14. In the aforesaid circumstances, and having regard to the judgment of
the Hon’ble Apex Court cited supra, the impugned order dated 11.03.2019
is hereby quashed and set aside to the extent it directs recovery from the
applicant. The interim order passed by this Tribunal is accordingly made
absolute insofar as the recovery is concerned. The respondents are directed
to refund to the applicant the amount, if any, already recovered pursuant to
the impugned order, without interest, within a period of three months from
the date of receipt of a copy of this order. However, insofar as the revision
of pension is concerned, the impugned order dated 11.03.2019 is upheld,
there being no infirmity warranting interference by this Tribunal.
15. In the result, the OA is disposed of on the terms indicated above.
There shall be no order as to costs.
(M.L. SRIVASTAVA) (M. SWAMINATHAN)
MEMBER(A) MEMBER(J)
01.09.2026
mas
M A
SUNDAR
Digitally signed by M A
SUNDAR
Date: 2026.09.28
15:40:31 +05'30'