Gurnam Singh vs State Of Pb.

Court
Punjab and Haryana High Court

CRA-S-1096-SB-2005 1
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA
AT CHANDIGARH
51 CRA-S-1096-SB-2005
Date of decision: 19.11.2026
GURNAM SINGH
......APPELLANT
Versus
STATE OF PUNJAB
...... RESPONDENT
CORAM: HON'BLE MR.JUSTICE SURYA PARTAP SINGH
Present : Mr. Chahit Bansal, Advocate
for the appellant.
Ms . Gagandeep Kaur, DAG, Punjab.
*
SURYA PARTAP SINGH, J.
1. The appellant/convict, hereinafter being referred to as appellant,
who is aggrieved of the judgment of conviction dated 02.06.2005, hereinafter
being referred to as ‘impugned judgment’, and order on quantum of sentence
dated 02.06.2005, hereinafter being referred to as ‘impugned order’, has
preferred this appeal.
2 The record reveals that the appellant was sent to face trial for the
commission of offence punishable under Sections 307 & 506 IPC in a case
pertaining to FIR No.12 dated 13.01.2002, Police Station Division No.2,
Ludhiana. T he above-mentioned trial was conducted in the Court of Sessions,
i.e. in the Court of learned Additional Sessions Judge, hereinafter being
referred to as trial Court. The above-said trial culminated into conviction of
appellant. Thus, following sentences were awarded to the appellant:-
VIPIN KUMAR
2026.11.19 20:54
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

CRA-S-1096-SB-2005 2
Offence under
Section Sentence
Rigorous imprisonment for a period of four years and
307 IPC to pay a fine of Rs.5000/-. In default thereof to undergo
further imprisonment (rigorous) for a period of three
months.
Rigorous imprisonment for a period of six months.
506 IPC
All the sentences were ordered to run concurrently.
3. In nut-shell the facts emerging from record are that the FIR of this
case came into being at the instance of ‘Harish Singh’, hereinafter being
referred to as complainant only. The pith and substance of the above-
mentioned complaint was that on 13.01.2002 at about 01:30 P.M. he alongwith
‘Harnam Dass Johar’ paid homage in the temple and after that when he sat in
car ‘Gurnam Singh @ Pappa’ (the appellant herein) suddenly came out of the
crowd gathered there. As per complainant, the appellant was carrying a dagger
in his hand and with an intention to kill him (the complainant), he assaulted the
complainant with that dagger, but ‘Resham Singh’ kicked the above-named
assailant due to which dagger fell down. It was also stated by the complainant
that thereafter, the assailant proclaimed that he would not spare the
complainant and would kill him. According to complainant after the above-
mentioned threat the assailant fled from the spot.
4. In the above-mentioned statement, it was also alleged by the
complainant that motive behind the above-mentioned attack was that brother of
appellant namely ‘Pritpal Singh @ Happy’ was accused in a case of rape, and
that in the community meeting (Panchayat), with regard to above-mentioned
incident, the complainant had supported the family of girl.
5. It was a case of the prosecution that pursuant to above-mentioned
VIPIN KUMAR
2026.11.19 20:54
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

CRA-S-1096-SB-2005 3
statement formal FIR of this case was lodged and the investigation was taken
up. According to prosecution during the course of investigation all the essential
formalities pertaining to investigation of the case such as spot inspection,
collection of evidence, arrest of the accused were performed. As per
prosecution on completion of investigation the final report under Section 173
Cr.P.C. was filed in the Court.
6. Heard.
7. While assailing the impugned judgment of conviction, it has been
contended by learned counsel for the appellant that the learned trial Court
committed an error of judgment when it failed to appreciate that the story set-
out by the prosecution was so unnatural and improbable that it should have
been disbelieved at the threshold itself. According to learned counsel for the
appellant the evidence adduced by the prosecution in the instant case, wherein
no injury, whatsoever, was suffered by the complainant, was grossly
inadequate and self-contradictory. It has been further contended by learned
counsel for the appellant that material witnesses were withheld by the
prosecution, and that the eye-witness account comprising of the testimonies of
eye-witnesses was self-contradictory. In view of above, the learned counsel for
the appellant has contended that merely on the basis of assumptions and
presumptions the unreliable evidence adduced by the prosecution has been
believed by the learned trial Court, and therefore, there is need for interference
and indulgence in the impugned verdict.
8. While controverting the above-mentioned arguments, the learned
counsel for the respondent/State has defended the impugned judgment and
impugned order. According to learned counsel for the respondent/State despite
VIPIN KUMAR
2026.11.19 20:54
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

CRA-S-1096-SB-2005 4
being the case of no injury, the act and conduct of the appellant, which was
duly proved with the help of testimonies of two eye-witnesses and one official
witness, would go to show that the above-said attack was launched by the
appellant with an intention to kill the complainant. As per learned counsel for
the respondent/State each and every component required for proving the
charge for the offence under Sections 307 and 506 IPC were duly established
by the prosecution, and therefore, there is no scope for indulgence or
interference in the impugned judgment.
9. The record has been perused carefully.
10. A perusal of record shows that in order to bring home guilt of the
accused the prosecution had relied upon oral evidence only. In its evidence
only three witnesses were examined by the prosecution. One of them was the
complainant himself, examined as PW-1. Another was an eye-witness of the
occurrence namely ‘Resham Singh’ examined as PW-2. The third and last
witness examined by the prosecution was ASI Harbans Lal, examined as PW3.
The PW-1 and PW-2 in their respective examination-in-chief duly supported
and corroborated the prosecution case by reproducing the fact that on
13.01.2002 at about 01:30 P.M. the above-mentioned incident had taken place.
As per PW-1 and PW-2, both, an attempt to kill the complainant (PW-1) with
the help of a dagger was made by the appellant.
11. The Investigating Officer of the case, who was examined as PW-
3, too, supported the prosecution case by deposing the fact that firstly he
lodged the FIR of this case as Ex.PB/1, thereafter visited the spot and prepared
site plan of the place of occurrence as Ex.PC. As per PW-3 thereafter, he
arrested the accused and recovered the dagger used for the commission of
VIPIN KUMAR
2026.11.19 20:54
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

CRA-S-1096-SB-2005 5
offence. The sketch of dagger was proved by the PW-3 as Ex.P-1, alongwith
seizure memo of the dagger as Ex.PE. The site plan of place of recovery was
proved by PW-3 as Ex.PF.
12. As far as the above-mentioned evidence adduced by the
prosecution was concerned a careful evaluation of the same would go to show
that:-
(a) in the instant case as per story set-out by the prosecution in
the FIR itself, no injury, whatsoever, was inflicted on the
person of complainant;
(b) the incident had taken place at a crowded place in broad
day light as depicted in the FIR itself. The co-passengers of
the complainant and other workers were present on the spot
at the time of occurrence. The presence of so many
supporters/workers of the complainant on the spot makes it
apparent that the situation was not conducive for anybody
to launch an attack upon the complainant. Thus, on the face
of it the story set-out by the prosecution looked to be
unnatural and improbable;
(c) as per story set out by the prosecution the appellant was
part of the crowd gathered on the spot and he came out of
the crowd all of a sudden, attacked the complainant and
then threatened him. As per prosecution case thereafter, the
appellant managed to run away from the spot. The above-
mentioned fact-situation showed that after the attack the
appellant had stayed on the spot. Though, such stay might
VIPIN KUMAR
2026.11.19 20:54
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

CRA-S-1096-SB-2005 6
have been for few seconds only, such a time was sufficient
for the gathering to catch hold of the appellant on the spot,
particularly, when due to kick suffered by the appellant
dagger had fallen on the ground. Thus, the above-
mentioned factor was an additional factor going against the
story of the prosecution.
(d) the motive behind the above-mentioned attack was also
alleged in the FIR, but no evidence was placed on record to
show that the appellant or his brother was ever accused of a
rape case.
(e) as per story set-out by the prosecution one more person, i.e.
‘Anil Jeet Singh Bedi’ was also present on the spot, and
travelling in the same car, but he was not examined as a
witness, and withheld by the prosecution without any
explanation;
(f) Although the prosecution story with regard to identity of
the driver of the vehicle, wherein the complainant was
travelling, was silent, but in the witness-box, the PW-1
deposed that vehicle of the complainant was being driven
by ‘Jony’. The prosecution either in the final report
under Section 173 Cr.P.C. or in the list of witnesses did not
mention the name of ‘Jony’. Thus, the above-named
witness, who was another eye-witness of the occurrence,
too, was withheld by the prosecution without any
justification.
VIPIN KUMAR
2026.11.19 20:54
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

CRA-S-1096-SB-2005 7
(g) the description of manner in which the incident took place,
and the complainant was rescued, would go to show that
such event was impossible. As deposed by eye-witnesses
PW-1 and PW-2 the appellant launched an assault when
complainant (PW-1) and his co-passenger ‘Resham Singh ‘
had already boarded the vehicle and closed their door. In
the above-mentioned circumstances, it was impossible for
‘Resham Singh’ to kick the appellant from inside the car.
Thus, the story of rescue set-out by the prosecution was
improbable, rather impossible.
13. In addition to above-mentioned deficiencies/improbabilities in the
prosecution story, there were other factors also which would go against the
prosecution case. Those factors were the contradictions which had surfaced in
the depositions of PW-1 and PW-2. Such as:-
(i) in the FIR it was mentioned that brother of the appellant
was an accused in the case of rape, but as per PW-2 the
appellant himself, alongwith his brother (both), was
involved in the above-mentioned case.
(ii) in the FIR there was no reference of ‘Jony’ as driver of the
vehicle, but the above-mentioned fact was deposed by
PW-1 for the first time in the Court during the course of his
cross-examination.
(iii) as per PW-1 the incident had taken place at ‘Vishawakaram
Chowk’, but as per PW-2 at ‘Bhagwan Chowk’.
(iv) as per PW-1 the incident had taken place at 01:30 P.M., but
VIPIN KUMAR
2026.11.19 20:54
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

CRA-S-1096-SB-2005 8
as per PW-2 at 02:00 P.M.
(v) as per PW-1 the dagger was in the hand of the assailant, but
as per PW-2 below the belt.
14. Since there was no independent corroboration of the above-
mentioned eye-witness account, in my considered opinion the above-
mentioned contradictions were material contradictions.
15. In the present case, if the events as depicted by PW-1 and PW-2
would have been carefully analyzed, the contents of the depositions of PW-1
and PW-2 would go to show that as per narration of events contained in the
testimony of PW-1 and PW-2, the complainant was sitting on rear seat behind
the driver alongwith PW-2 ‘Resham Singh’, which would means that ‘Resham
Singh’ was sitting on the left side of the complainant. As per PW-1 and PW-2
(both), the appellant came from right side of the vehicle, which meant that
when attack was launched by the appellant upon the complainant (PW-1),
‘Resham Singh’ was sitting on the left side of PW-1 and door of the vehicle
was closed. In such a situation it was next to impossible for ‘Resham Singh’ to
acts swiftly in such a manner that through windowpane of the vehicle he was
able to kick the assailant and rescue the complainant, despite the fact
complainant was between the assailant and PW-2. In fact in the limited space
available on rear seat of the vehicle such a task was impossible. Thus, in the
given situation it could safely be inferred that the story set-out by the
complainant was not the true story.
16. In addition to above, the story set out by the prosecution would go
to show that the driver and other co-passengers of the vehicle did not react at
all, which was also a very unnatural circumstance.
VIPIN KUMAR
2026.11.19 20:54
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

CRA-S-1096-SB-2005 9
17. If the cumulative effect of all the above-mentioned factors
discussed in the aforesaid paragraphs would have been taken into consideration
it would have transpired that the story set-out by the prosecution was
improbable and the prosecution evidence being self contradictory and
uncorroborated from any independent evidence, was unable to meet the
required standard prescribed under the law for proving a charge. Thus, in my
considered opinion an error of judgment was committed by the learned trial
Court when it failed to appreciate the above-mentioned factors and merely on
the basis of conjectures and surmises returned a finding of conviction of the
appellant. In my considered opinion, the above-mentioned judgment is not
sustainable and deserves to be set aside.
18. As a sequel to above-mentioned observations, it is hereby held
that present appeal has got merits and therefore, it deserves to be allowed. The
appeal is hereby allowed , accordingly. The ‘impugned judgment’ and
‘impugned order’ are hereby set aside and the appellant is hereby acquitted of
the charge framed against him.
19. Pending miscellaneous application(s), if any, shall stand disposed
of.
20. Ordered accordingly.
(SURYA PARTAP SINGH)
JUDGE
19.11.2026 Whether speaking/reasoned Yes/No
vipin Whether reportable Yes/No
VIPIN KUMAR
2026.11.19 20:54
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document