SIDDHI VINAYAK HIMGHAR (P) LTD. AND ORS. vs PUNJAB NATIONAL BANK AND ANR.
- Court
- Calcutta High Court
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
(CONSTITUTIONAL WRIT JURISDICTION)
ORIGINAL SIDE
Present :
The Hon’ble Justice Partha Sarathi Chatterjee
WPO 339 of 2024
Siddhi Vinayak Himghar (P) Ltd. & Ors.
Vs.
Punjab National Bank & Anr.
For the petitioner : Mr. Debabrata Ray, Sr. Adv.,
Mr. S. Nag,
Mr. Dwaipayan Basu Mullick,
Mr. Rajesh Upadhyay,
Mr. Subhankar Das,
Mr. S. Biswas,
Mr. Shoham Sanyal.
For the PNB : Mr. Swatarup Banerjee,
Mr. Sailendra Kr. Tiwari,
Mr. Shambhu Mahato,
Ms. T. Bose,
Ms. M. Jalan.
Heard on : 13.10.2026
Judgment on : 20.11.2026
Partha Sarathi Chatterjee, J.:-
Prelude:
1. The present writ petition has been preferred by the petitioners, being the
borrower-company and its Directors, challenging the show-cause notice dated
2
21st December, 2023 issued by the respondent-Punjab National Bank (in
short, “the Bank”), whereby the petitioners were called upon to show cause as
to why their loan account should not be classified and reported as a “fraud
account”, as also the subsequent communication dated 21st March, 2024,
whereby the petitioners were intimated that their loan account had been
classified as a “fraud account”.
Petitioners’ case:
2. The facts leading to the filing of the present writ petition, as pleaded by the
petitioners, may be noticed briefly. The petitioners are engaged, inter alia, in
the business of manufacture of organic manure and allied activities. Petitioner
nos. 2 and 4 were initially partners of a partnership firm which was enjoying a
credit facility of Rs.24 lakhs from Canara Bank. The said credit facility was
subsequently taken over by the erstwhile United Bank of India and was
enhanced to Rs.50 lakhs.
3. It is the case of the petitioners that, at the instance of the erstwhile United
Bank of India, they subsequently acquired several NPA/closed cold storage
units and commenced business through different companies. According to the
petitioners, in the process, their overall credit exposure increased
substantially. The petitioners further claim that the concerned entities were
registered as Micro, Small and Medium Enterprises under the applicable
statutory framework.
4. The petitioners have attributed the subsequent financial stress to, inter alia,
demonetisation, decline in demand in the potato market and other adverse
market conditions. They have further relied upon various circulars issued by
3
the Reserve Bank of India and the erstwhile United Bank of India concerning
restructuring of stressed MSME accounts and have asserted that proposals
submitted by them for restructuring were not duly considered.
5. It is the further case of the petitioners that, during the intervening period, the
COVID-19 pandemic occurred and the Reserve Bank of India issued directions
providing, inter alia, for moratorium and restructuring measures. According
to the petitioners, notwithstanding their request for restructuring, their loan
accounts were classified as NPA.
6. The petitioners had earlier challenged the action of the Bank in proceedings
being WPA 9820 of 2021. The prayer for interim relief was declined by a
coordinate Bench by order dated 8th July, 2021. The said order was carried in
appeal in MAT No.643 of 2021, wherein, by order dated 26th July, 2021, the
parties were directed to maintain status quo for a period of eight weeks or
until further orders, whichever was earlier.
7. In the meantime, the erstwhile United Bank of India was amalgamated with
Punjab National Bank. Thereafter, the Punjab National Bank (hereinafter,
referred to as the Bank) instituted OA No.410 of 2022 before the Debts
Recovery Tribunal under Section 19 of the Recovery of Debts and Bankruptcy
Act, 1993. The petitioners entered appearance and filed their written
statement and also raised a counter-claim.
8. It is in the aforesaid backdrop that the Bank issued the impugned show-cause
notice dated 21st December, 2023, calling upon the petitioners to show cause
as to why their loan account should not be classified as a “fraud account”.
Upon receipt of the said notice, the petitioners, by a letter, requested the Bank
4
to furnish the documents relied upon by it in issuing the said notice. However,
the said request was not acceded to. Subsequently, by a communication dated
21st March, 2024, the petitioners were informed that their loan account had
been classified as a “fraud account”.
9. The principal grievance of the petitioners is that the procedure contemplated
under the Reserve Bank of India (Frauds Classification and Reporting by
Commercial Banks and Select FIs) Directions, 2016 was not followed. It is
contended that the forensic audit report (for short, FAR), on the basis of
which the fraud classification was made, was not supplied to the petitioners
and that, consequently, they were deprived of an effective opportunity to deal
with the material relied upon against them.
Respondents’ case:
10. The respondent bank contested the writ petition by filing an affidavit-in-
opposition, wherein it was, inter alia, contended that the petitioners had
availed themselves of various credit facilities from the respondent no. 1/bank,
either by way of fresh sanction or renewal-cum-enhancement thereof, upon
execution of the requisite loan and security documents. It was further
contended that, as security for the said credit facilities, the petitioners had
created equitable mortgages over certain immovable properties and had also
created hypothecation over various movable assets, including stocks, book
debts and other current assets of the petitioner no. 1.
11. However, upon the petitioners' failure to adhere to the stipulated repayment
schedule, the respondent bank classified the loan accounts as Non-Performing
Assets (for short, NPA), in accordance with the Reserve Bank of India's (for
5
short, RBI) Master Directions on Frauds – Classification and Reporting by
Commercial Banks and Select FIs, dated 1st July, 2016, as updated on 23rd
July, 2016, and the circular/guidelines issued by the Head Office, Recovery
Division of the bank, being FRMD Circular No. 70/2023 dated 20th October,
2023 (for short, FRMD circular)
12. Subsequently, the respondent bank, in its capacity as a secured creditor,
initiated measures under the Securitisation and Reconstruction of Financial
Assets and Enforcement of Security Interest Act, 2002 (for short, the
SARFAESI Act), for enforcement of its security interest. The petitioners
assailed the said measures by instituting a writ petition, being WPO 9820 of
2021. By an order dated 8th July, 2021, a coordinate Bench of this Court
declined to grant any interim relief to the petitioners. Aggrieved thereby, the
petitioners preferred an intra-court appeal, being MAT 643 of 2021. The said
appeal was disposed of by an order dated 23rd December, 2021, whereby the
respondent bank was restrained from taking any measures under the
SARFAESI Act until disposal of the writ petition.
13. Subsequently, by an order dated 5th August, 2025, the writ petition, being
WPO 9820 of 2021, was allowed. The respondent bank has assailed the said
order in an intra-court appeal, being MAT 1887 of 2025, which is presently
pending adjudication. In the interregnum, and in terms of the order dated
23rd December, 2021, the respondent bank initiated proceedings under
Section 19 of the Recovery of Debts Due to Banks and Financial Institutions
Act, 1993, by instituting an Original Application, being OA 410 of 2022, which
is also pending final adjudication.
6
14. The respondent bank contended that the borrowers had violated various
terms and conditions governing the sanction of the credit facilities and that
the statements of account disclosed certain unlawful, illegal and suspicious
transactions. It was further contended that a report in that regard had been
forwarded to the competent authority for necessary action in terms of the
Master Directions of 2016. Consequently, a forensic auditor was appointed to
examine the accounts and the transactions undertaken therein. The bank
alleged that, despite repeated requests, the petitioners failed to extend the
requisite cooperation to the forensic auditors in the course of the audit.
Thereafter, by a notice dated 21st December, 2023, the respondent bank
called upon the petitioners to show cause and submit their written
representations within fifteen days from the date of receipt of the said notice,
as to why their loan account should not be classified as 'fraud account'.
15. The respondent bank contended that extracts and relevant portions of the
forensic audit report had been furnished to the petitioners along with the
show cause notice dated 21st December, 2023. It was further asserted that the
said notice also contained excerpts from the FAR highlighting the
circumstances and findings indicative of the alleged fraudulent activities. The
bank alleged that, instead of submitting a reply to the show cause notice, the
petitioners, by placing an erroneous interpretation upon the decision of the
Hon'ble Supreme Court in State Bank of India vs. Rajesh Kumar Agarwal &
Ors. , reported in (2023) 6 SCC 1 , addressed a letter dated 4th January, 2024,
calling upon the bank to furnish certain documents, without due application
of mind. The bank contended that the said letter dated 4th January, 2024
7
could not, by any stretch of interpretation, be construed as a reply to the show
cause notice.
16. The respondent bank further contended that, upon affording the petitioners a
reasonable opportunity of hearing and in the absence of any reply to the show
cause notice within the stipulated period, the competent authority of the
respondent no. 1/bank proceeded to classify the loan account of the
petitioners as 'fraud account' by passing a reasoned order. The said decision
was duly communicated to the petitioners vide a communication dated 21st
March, 2024.
Contents of affidavit-in-reply:
17. In the affidavit-in-reply, the petitioners, inter alia, contended that the bank
ought to have furnished the forensic audit report in its entirety, upon which
reliance had been placed for the purpose of classifying their loan account as
‘fraud account’, instead of merely supplying extracts or selected pages thereof.
It was contended that, in the absence of the complete report, the petitioners
were deprived of an effective opportunity to submit their reply. The
petitioners further specifically alleged that the order dated 11th March, 2024
was a document of anterior date, purportedly brought into existence to
mislead the Court and to conceal the deficiencies in the decision-making
process, and that the same had neither been brought to the notice of the
learned Single Bench or the Hon’ble Division Bench of this Court nor
communicated to the petitioners. It was also contended that the letter dated
21st March, 2024, whereby the petitioners were intimated of the classification
of their account as ‘fraud account’, made no reference whatsoever to the order
8
dated 11th March, 2024. The petitioners asserted that the classification of
their account as ‘fraud account’ was made in brazen disregard of the settled
principles of law and the fundamental requirements of natural justice.
Submissions:
18. The parties have advanced elaborate arguments and have also filed their
respective written notes of submissions.
19. Mr. Saha Roy, learned Senior Counsel appearing for the petitioners, submitted
that it is an admitted position that, although the bank had placed reliance
upon the FAR for the purpose of classifying the petitioners’ account as ‘fraud
account’, the said report, in its entirety, was never furnished to the petitioners.
He submitted that the bank, in its affidavit, had admitted that only extracts
and/or certain pages of the FAR had been forwarded to the petitioners. He
further contended that the petitioners had not, in fact, been furnished even
with the extracts and/or relevant pages of the FAR, which the bank claimed to
have forwarded to them.
20. He contended that immediately upon receipt of the show cause notice, the
petitioners, by their letter dated 4th January, 2024, requested the bank to
furnish certain documents, including a copy of the FAR or any other audit
report relied upon by the bank. However, the bank failed to accede to such
request, thereby depriving the petitioners of a reasonable opportunity to
submit an effective reply to the show cause notice.
21. He argued that the petitioners were merely furnished with a one-page
intimation informing them that their accounts had been classified as ‘fraud
accounts’. The said letter of intimation dated 21st March, 2024, was cryptic in
9
nature and disclosed no reasons whatsoever for such classification. It was
further submitted that the letter did not indicate the documents or materials
upon which the bank had placed reliance in arriving at such a decision. He
further contended that, even before the order of classification was made
available to the petitioners, their account had already been classified as ‘fraud
account’ and the same had been reported to the Reserve Bank of India on 16th
March, 2024.
22. He submitted that the present writ petition was initially allowed by a
Coordinate Bench by an order dated 29th April, 2024, whereby the letter of
intimation dated 21st March, 2024, was set aside on the ground that the FAR
had not been furnished to the petitioners. The said order was, however,
carried in appeal by the bank, and the appeal was allowed by an order dated
16th September, 2025, solely on the ground that the writ petition had been
disposed of without affording the bank an opportunity to file its affidavit-in-
opposition. Consequently, the matter was remanded for fresh consideration.
He further submitted that it was only in the affidavit-in-opposition filed
pursuant to such remand that the bank, for the first time, disclosed an order
dated 11th March, 2024, which, according to the bank, constituted the final
order classifying the petitioners’ account as ‘fraud account.
23. He referred to the order dated 11th March, 2024, appearing at page 22 of the
affidavit-in-opposition, and submitted that the expression ‘For Approval’,
appearing at the top of the said order, clearly indicates that the same was not a
final order and was not intended to be communicated to the petitioners. He
further drew my attention to the concluding portion of the order, wherein it
was specifically recorded that the bank’s decision was to be suitably
10
communicated to the concerned party in terms of Annexure-5(B) of FRMD
Circular No. 70/2023 dated 20th October, 2023, and an acknowledgement of
receipt of such communication was to be kept on record. According to him,
the aforesaid direction clearly demonstrates that the order dated 11th March,
2024, which the bank now claims to be the final order classifying the
petitioners’ account as ‘fraud account’, had never been communicated to the
petitioners. Referring to the postal receipt appearing at page 19 of the
affidavit-in-reply, he submitted that the weight of the consignment was
recorded as only 15 grams. He pointed out that a 17-page order dated 11th
March, 2024, could not possibly have weighed so little. He, therefore,
contended that the said order had never actually been sent to the petitioners.
24. He argued that the bank, being a State within the meaning of Article 12 of the
Constitution, had made false statements in its affidavit-in-opposition with the
apparent intention of misleading the Court. He further submitted that the
bank had failed to adhere either to the requirements stipulated in the relevant
RBI circulars or to the provisions of its own circulars while undertaking the
exercise of classifying the petitioners’ account as ‘fraud account’.
25. He placed reliance upon the judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in State
Bank of India & Ors. v. Rajesh Agarwal & Ors (supra), and submitted that
classification of a borrower's account as fraudulent entails serious civil
consequences and, therefore, strict compliance with the principles of natural
justice is imperative before such a decision is taken. He also relied upon the
decision of the Hon’ble Supreme Court reported in 2026 INSC 323 (State
Bank of India v. Amit Iron Private Limited & Ors.), wherein the scope and
effect of the decision in Rajesh Agarwal and the borrower's entitlement to a
11
copy of the FAR have been authoritatively considered. He submitted that
furnishing the FAR to the borrower is the rule and that only such portions
thereof as may adversely affect the interests of third parties can be withheld,
that too upon recording appropriate reasons. He contended that, in the
present case, the FAR was never furnished to the petitioners, nor were they
afforded an effective opportunity to controvert the allegations of
misappropriation, criminal breach of trust and diversion of funds levelled
against them. He, therefore, submitted that the aforesaid lapses furnished
sufficient grounds for interference by this Court in exercise of its writ
jurisdiction. To reinvigorate his submissions, he cited another decision,
reported in 2024 SCC OnLine Cal 1012 (Hemanta Kanoria vs. Bank of India &
Ors.).
26. In rebuttal, Mr. Banerjee, learned counsel appearing for the bank, on the other
hand, submitted that the petitioners were duly served with a show cause
notice and were afforded an opportunity to submit their response thereto. He
contended that the bank had sufficient materials before it to conclude that the
loan funds had been diverted and/or utilised for purposes other than those for
which the credit facilities had been sanctioned. There were also materials
indicating misappropriation of funds and criminal breach of trust. He,
therefore, submitted that upon due compliance with the prescribed procedure,
the petitioners’ account was classified as ‘fraud account’ in conformity with
the applicable RBI circulars as well as the bank’s own circulars.
27. Referring to a footnote appended to the bank’s FRMD Circular No. 70 of 2023
dated 20th October, 2023, Mr. Banerjee submitted that the said circular had
been framed in consonance with the principles laid down by the Hon’ble
12
Supreme Court in the decision of Rajesh Agarwal (supra) and prescribes the
procedure to be followed while undertaking the exercise of classifying an
account as a ‘fraud account’. He further contended that the petitioners had
neither challenged the aforesaid FRMD circular nor the RBI Master Circular
of 2016, which contains the guidelines governing the classification of account
as fraud account. In the absence of any such challenge, according to him, the
FRMD circular remains binding upon the petitioners. He submitted that, in
accordance with the procedure prescribed therein, the show cause notice was
issued in the prescribed format under Annexure-5(A), and the letter of
intimation was also issued in the format prescribed under Annexure-5(B),
both appended to the said circular.
28. Referring to the relevant portion of the FRMD circular, he submitted that it is
the bank’s policy to furnish relevant extracts of the FAR along with the show
cause notice, while withholding sensitive internal information, details relating
to the role of bank officials, third-party entities and the bank’s internal
policies and procedures. He contended that, in keeping with the said policy,
the relevant extracts of the FAR had been made available to the petitioners.
According to the bank, the complete report contains statements and
information concerning bank officials as well as third parties, and disclosure
of such information may expose the persons concerned, whether employees of
the bank or representatives of the account holder, to certain risks. In such
circumstances, the bank considered it inappropriate to disclose the entire
report.
29. He submitted that the procedure prescribed under the FRMD guideline
involves three authorities, namely, the Initiative Authority, the Reviewing
13
Authority and the Final Authority. The Initiative Authority, in the present case
being the Fit Level Committee, is empowered to issue a show cause notice on
the direction of the Final Authority, following the consideration by the
Reviewing Authority, which in the present case is the Committee of General
Managers. He further submitted that, since the amount involved in the alleged
fraud exceeds Rs. 3 crores but is less than Rs. 50 crores, the Executive
Director is the designated Final Authority. As per the guidelines, whenever
fraud is suspected in any account, the findings, investigation report and
primary forensic audit report are required to be placed before the Final
Authority, and the decision taken by the Final Authority is thereafter to be
reported to the Reserve Bank of India. Mr. Banerjee contended that, in the
case at hand, the Bank had duly followed the procedure prescribed under the
guidelines.
30. Mr. Banerjee contended that the decisions relied upon by the petitioners are
distinguishable on facts. Referring to the decision in Rajesh Agarwal (supra),
he submitted that the said decision merely emphasised the necessity of
adhering to the principles of audi alteram partem , which, according to him,
had been duly complied with in the present case. He further contended that
nowhere in the said decision was it directed that the entire FAR must be
furnished to the account holders. With regard to the decision in Amit Iron
(supra), he submitted that the Hon’ble Supreme Court had recognised that
any portion of the FAR could be withheld where its disclosure might affect the
privacy or interests of third parties. He further sought to distinguish the
decision in Hemanta Kanoria & Anr. (supra) by pointing out that the writ
petitioner therein was a director of the company whose account had been
14
classified as fraud account and had himself been declared a perpetrator of
fraud. In such circumstances, the Coordinate Bench had directed the Bank to
furnish the entire FAR to enable the petitioner therein to effectively defend
himself against the allegations levelled against him.
Analysis and conclusion:
31. The question which, therefore, arises for consideration is whether the
procedure adopted by the Bank before classifying the petitioners’ loan account
as “fraud” satisfies the requirements of natural justice, the applicable RBI
framework and settled principles of law.
32. In State Bank of India v. Rajesh Agarwal (supra), the Hon’ble Supreme Court
held that classification of a borrower’s account as fraud entails serious civil
consequences and, therefore, the borrower must be afforded an opportunity to
explain the material relied upon by the Bank before such classification is
made. The principle of audi alteram partem must be read into the provisions
of the Master Directions on Frauds to save them from the vice of arbitrariness.
The principles of natural justice require that the borrower be served with a
notice, afforded an opportunity to explain the findings of the forensic audit
report (FAR) and permitted to make a representation before the Bank/JLF
(Joint Lenders’ Forum) prior to classification of the account as fraud under
the Master Directions on Frauds. The Hon’ble Supreme Court further held
that the decision classifying a borrower's account as fraudulent must be
supported by a reasoned order.
33. Reaffirming the principles enunciated in Union of India v. Tulsiram Patel,
reported in (1985) 3 SCC 398, the Hon’ble Supreme Court, in State Bank of
15
India v. Rajesh Agarwal (supra), reiterated that, in conformity with the rule of
audi alteram partem , a person against whom an order prejudicial to his
interests is proposed to be passed must be made aware of the allegations and
charges levelled against him and afforded an opportunity to submit his
explanation thereto. He must also be made aware of the evidence on which the
proposed action is founded, be afforded an opportunity to inspect the
documents relied upon against him and be permitted to adduce evidence in
support of his defence.
34. For the effective adjudication of the present writ petition, it would be apposite
to reproduce the concluding portion of the decision rendered in State Bank of
India v. Amit Iron Private Limited & Ors. (supra), which reads as follows:
“ In view of the discussions hereinbefore, we hold:-
a) Rajesh Agarwal (supra) did not recognize any right in the borrower
to a personal hearing by the banks before classifying their account
as a fraud account;
b) The RBI in its Master Directions of 15.07.2024 correctly understood
the scope of Rajesh Agarwal (supra) and incorporated Clause 2.1.1.1,
2.1.1.2, 2.1.1.3, and 2.1.1.4 as the procedure to be followed before
classifying an account as a fraud account;
c) The procedure set out in Rajesh Agarwal (supra) which has
been incorporated in the Master Directions of 2024 strikes a fair
balance between promptitude and fairness and duly comports with
the principles of natural justice ensuring fairness to the borrower
whose account is likely to be classified as a fraud account.
16
d) Wherever audit reports are available, including forensic audit
reports, the same shall be furnished to the borrower and their
representation on the report, including on the findings and
conclusions be elicited, in case the banks consider the audit report
relevant for classifying the account as fraud account. In view of the
same, disclosure by furnishing copies of the audit report, including
the forensic audit report to the borrower is mandatory. Supply of
reports in digital form will be valid compliance;
e) As held in T. Takano (supra) , if the banks, for reasons to be
recorded establish that the disclosure of any part of the report
would effect the privacy of third parties, in that exceptional
situation banks would be justified to withhold those portions of the
report which concern third party rights;
f) We reiterate that the rule is to supply the audit reports, including
the forensic audit reports since even under Clause 4 of Chapter IV of
the 15.07.2024 Master Directions post the red-flagging of the
account banks use the audit mechanism for further investigation.
Even in the exceptional cases we hope and expect that the banks will
not unreasonably use the power of redaction since that will only end
up delaying the culmination of proceedings. Clause 4.1.4 also
reiterates that banks shall ensure the principles of natural justice.
That this was the legal position even under the 2016 Master
Directions is clear from para 95 of Rajesh Agarwal (supra);
17
g) The judgments of the High Courts which have taken a contrary view
to what we have held hereinabove would stand overruled.”
35. Therefore, the decision in State Bank of India v. Amit Iron Private Limited &
Ors. (supra) has, however, clarified the precise content of such procedural
protection. The Hon’ble Supreme Court has held that Rajesh Agarwal does not
recognize a right in the borrower to a personal or oral hearing before classification of
an account as fraud. The requirements of natural justice are satisfied by issuance of a
show-cause notice, disclosure of the material relied upon, opportunity to submit a
representation and consideration thereof by the competent authority, followed by a
reasoned decision.
36. At the same time, the Hon’ble Supreme Court has made it clear that the supply of
the forensic audit report is the rule. The Court has specifically held that furnishing
merely the findings and conclusions of the audit report would not amount to
compliance with the principles of natural justice, since the reasons and the material
forming the basis of such findings are contained in the body of the report.
37. The Hon’ble Supreme Court has, however, recognized a limited exception. Where
the Bank, for reasons to be recorded, establishes that disclosure of a particular
portion of the report would affect the privacy or rights of third parties, such portion
may be withheld or redacted. The Court has nevertheless cautioned that such power
of redaction should not be used unreasonably.
38. In the present case, the Bank does not dispute that a forensic audit report was
relied upon for arriving at the decision to classify the petitioners’ account as “fraud”.
The Bank admitted that the entire forensic audit report has not been supplied to the
petitioners. Its case is that relevant extracts thereof were furnished and that the
18
remaining portions were withheld as the report contained statements and
information relating to Bank officials and/or third parties.
39. Before proceeding further, it would be apposite to deal with the contention of the
respondent Bank that the FRMD Circular No. 70/2023 dated 20th October, 2023 is
binding upon the petitioners and that, in the absence of any challenge to the said
circular or the RBI Master Directions of 2016, the petitioners cannot question the
procedure adopted by the Bank in purported compliance therewith. Such contention,
in the opinion of this Court, is devoid of merit. The mere fact that the petitioners
have not assailed the validity of the FRMD Circular does not, by itself, render every
action taken thereunder immune from judicial scrutiny. The said circular, being an
internal guideline governing the procedure to be followed by the Bank, cannot
override or dilute the law declared by the Hon’ble Supreme Court.
40. It is a settled principle that the law declared by the Hon’ble Supreme Court is
binding on all authorities under Article 141 of the Constitution of India.
Consequently, even if the Bank has acted in conformity with its own circular, such
compliance cannot, by itself, validate an action which is otherwise inconsistent with
the law laid down by the Hon’ble Supreme Court. The question, therefore, is not
whether the FRMD Circular is binding upon the petitioners, but whether the
procedure adopted by the Bank in purported compliance therewith satisfies the
requirements of law and the principles of natural justice.
41. In view of the law now declared by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Amit Iron
(supra), the aforesaid explanation, by itself, cannot constitute sufficient compliance
with the requirements of natural justice. The Bank was required to furnish the entire
forensic audit report to the petitioners, subject only to such redaction or withholding
19
as may be justified by reasons referable to the rights or privacy of third parties. The
fact that the report may contain statements of Bank officials does not, by itself, justify
withholding the report in its entirety. The Bank was required to identify the
particular portions, if any, which could legitimately be withheld and to record
reasons for such withholding.
42. This Court is conscious of the fact that the allegations against the petitioners are
serious and that the Bank may have material to support its decision. The Court is also
not required, in exercise of jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution, to
undertake an adjudication as to whether the petitioners have in fact committed the
acts constituting fraud. That determination falls within the domain of the competent
authority, subject to the applicable statutory and regulatory framework.
43. The issue before this Court is narrower, namely, whether the decision-making
process preceding the impugned classification complied with the requirements of
natural justice. In view of the law declared by the Hon’ble Supreme Court, this Court
is of the view that the petitioners were entitled to the forensic audit report relied
upon by the Bank, subject to permissible redaction of those portions which the Bank
is able to justify as affecting the privacy or rights of third parties.
44. It is also necessary to clarify that the petitioners are not entitled, as a matter of
right, to a personal or oral hearing before the Bank. A written representation after
disclosure of the relied-upon material would meet the requirement of natural justice,
provided such representation is duly considered and a reasoned decision is thereafter
taken.
45. In the circumstances, the communication dated 21st March, 2024, whereby the
petitioners were informed of the classification of their account as “fraud”, cannot be
20
sustained at this stage. However, this Court does not propose to examine the merits
of the allegations of fraud or to record any finding either in favour of or against the
petitioners on that aspect.
46. Accordingly, the communication dated 21st March, 2024 is set aside. The show-
cause notice dated 21st December, 2023 shall stand revived. The respondent-Bank
shall furnish to the petitioners the forensic audit report relied upon for the proposed
classification, subject to permissible redaction strictly in accordance with the
principles laid down by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in State Bank of India v. Amit
Iron Private Limited & Ors. (supra). In the event the Bank seeks to withhold any
portion of the report, it shall record reasons identifying the particular portion sought
to be withheld and the basis on which such withholding is considered necessary.
47. Upon receipt of the forensic audit report, the petitioners shall be afforded
reasonable opportunity to submit their representation dealing with the findings and
conclusions contained therein and the other material relied upon by the Bank. The
competent authority of the Bank shall thereafter consider the representation
independently and pass a fresh, reasoned and speaking order in accordance with the
applicable RBI Directions.
48. It is made clear that this Court has expressed no opinion on the merits of the
allegations of diversion or misuse of funds or misappropriation of funds or criminal
breach of trust, or on the question as to whether the petitioners’ account ultimately
warrants classification as a “fraud account”. All such questions are left open for
determination by the competent authority of the Bank in accordance with law.
49. It is further made clear that order shall not prevent the Bank from pursuing the
proceedings before the Debts Recovery Tribunal in accordance with law.
21
50. The writ petition is accordingly disposed of in the aforesaid terms.
51. There shall be no order as to costs.
52. Urgent photostat certified copy of this order, if applied for, be supplied to the
parties upon compliance with the requisite formalities.
(Partha Sarathi Chatterjee, J.)