Bharat Sanchar Nigam Ltd vs Adesh Jain
- Court
- Delhi High Court
$~136
* IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
# CNR No. DLHC010540182026
+ W.P.(C) 16590/2026 & CM APPL. 77801/2026, CM APPL.
77802/2026, CM APPL. 77803/2026
BHARAT SANCHAR NIGAM LTD .....Petitioner
Through: Mr. Piyush Sharma and Mr.
Ravinder Singh Rawat, Advs.
versus
ADESH JAIN ....Respondent
Through: Mr. Ashish Kumar and Mr.
Shailesh Chandra Jha, Advs. for R-1, R-3,
R-4 and R-5.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE C. HARI SHANKAR
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE NIVEDITA ANIL SHARMA
JUDGMENT (ORAL)
% 05.11.2026
C. HARI SHANKAR, J.
1. This writ petition is directed against judgment dated 14
1
November 2025 passed the Central Administrative Tribunal in OA
2
2905/2015 , as well as the subsequent order dated 13 July 2026,
passed by the Tribunal in RA 4449/2026, whereby review of the
earlier judgment dated 14 November 2025 supra was sought.
2. The issue in controversy before the Tribunal fundamentally
revolved around the sustainability, or otherwise, of a Circular dated 16
1
“the Tribunal” hereinafter
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:YOGESH
KUMAR
Signing Date:18.11.2026
12:39
W.P.(C) 16590/2026 Page 1 of 11
July 2015, issued by the Corporate Office of BSNL, which read as
under:
“ BHARAT SANCHAR NIGAM LIMITED
CORPORATE OFFICE
[PERSONNEL - I SECTION]
th
4 Floor, Bharat Sanchar Bhawan, Janpath, New Delhi-110 001
No. 400-106/2013-Pers.I
th
Dated: July 16 , 2015
All Heads of Telecom Circles/
Metro Districts/Maintenance Regions/
Projects/Stores/BRBRAITT/ALTTC.
All other Administrative Units,
Bharat Sanchar Nigam Limited
Subject: Educational qualification for promotion to the grade of
EE(Civil/Elect.) - Degree in Engineering and its equivalence in
note 2 under Schedule IB of BSNL MSRR-2009.
This refers to the provision of educational qualification required for
promotion to the grade of Executive Engineer in Civil/Electrical
streams under Schedule IB of BSNL Management Services
Recruitment Rules, 2009. The note 2 under Schedule IB provides
that:
“Educational qualification for executives to be promoted to
the grade of AGM/EE/Arch shall be degree in engineering
or equivalent in respect of Civil & Electrical disciplines
whereas degree in Architecture or equivalent and valid
registration as Architect with the Council of Architects for
Architectural discipline.”
The issue of qualifications equivalent to Degree in Engineering and
related matters of promotions to the grade of EE(C/E) is being
agitated for quite some time. The matter has been considered in
view of a recent document of DoT (O.M. no.19-13/2012-CWG,
dt.11-Feb-2015) elaborating the judgments of Hon'ble Principal
Bench of CAT, New Delhi and Hon'ble High Court of Delhi
whereby the equivalence of Diploma in Engineering in appropriate
discipline plus total ten years of technical experience in the
appropriate fields with a Degree in Engineering has been
established in the background of Ministry of Education & Social
Welfare O.M. no.F.18-15/75/T-2, dt.26-05-1977. The judicial
2
Adesh Jain & Others v. Union of India & Ors.
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:YOGESH
KUMAR
Signing Date:18.11.2026
12:39
W.P.(C) 16590/2026 Page 2 of 11
pronouncements have further been endorsed in the communications
between DoT and DoP&T.
In view of the above endorsements, it has been decided by
management to clarify that for promotions to Executive Engineer
grade in Civil/Electrical streams, a 'diploma in appropriate field of
engineering with 10 years of experience' shall be construed to be
equivalent to 'Degree in Engineering' in appropriate field as per the
requirements of note 2 under Schedule IB of BSNL MSRR-2009.
Sd/-
[Manish Kumar]
Deputy General Manager (Pers.)”
3. Circular dated 26 May 1977, issued by the Ministry of
Education (Technical), to which para 2 of the Circular dated 16 July
2015 makes reference, reads thus:
“No. F 18-19/75/T-2
Ministry of Education & Social Welfare
(Deptt. Of Education Technical)
New Delhi-110001 Dated 26 May, 1977
Sub: Recognition of Technical & Professional Qualifications.
On the recommendations of the Board of Assessment Educational
qualifications and recommendations of Defence Director (Tech.),
the Government of India have decided to recognize a Diploma in
Engineering in appropriate discipline plus total ten years of
technical experience in the appropriate fields is recognized as
equivalent to Degree in Engineering. It is considered valid for the
purpose of selection to Gazetted posts and Services under the
Central Government or State Government.
Sd/-
(V.R. Reddy)
Director (Tech.)
The published in Gazette of India & NCO Code Book.
Copy to:
All Ministries, Departments of the Government of India / State
Government / Regional Offices / State Public Service
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:YOGESH
KUMAR
Signing Date:18.11.2026
12:39
W.P.(C) 16590/2026 Page 3 of 11
Commissions etc.
Attested Sd/-Asstt. Superintendent HRD, Govt. of India New
Delhi.”
4. Respondents 1 to 6 in the present writ petition assailed the
aforesaid Circular dated 16 July 2015 before the Tribunal in OA
2905/2015.
5. The Tribunal has, by the impugned judgment dated 14
November 2025, allowed OA 2905/2015. Para 8 of the impugned
judgment, which contains the entirety of the reasoning of the Tribunal,
reads thus:
“8. We have given our thoughtful consideration to the rival
submissions; examined the relevant documents and records and
perused the concerned decisions and judgments of Hon’ble Apex
Court, High Court and Coordinate Bench of CAT Chandigarh
Bench in OA No. 892/2018 dated 14.10.2025 which has already
been discussed in the foregoing paras and which touches all the
four corners of this OA. In the light of the Gazette of India
notification by Ministry of Human Resource Development
(Department of Higher Education) dated 23.03.2016, we are
absolutely convinced that the OM dated 26.05.1977 is false and
fictitious; being not issued by the erstwhile Ministry of Education
and Social Welfare. It is a settled principle in administrative law
and service jurisprudence that once the foundation of the edifice is
established to be illegal than the entire building is bound to be
demolished. Therefore, we are inclined to follow the decision of
the Chandigarh Bench. The instant OA has merit; deserves to be
allowed and is accordingly allowed.”
6. In arriving at its decision, the Tribunal has placed reliance on
judgment dated 25 November 2024 passed by this Court in WP (C)
3
2671/2017 , from which the following passages have been extracted
by the Tribunal in the impugned judgment:
3
Union of India & Another vs. Central PWD Engineers Association & Ors.
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:YOGESH
KUMAR
Signing Date:18.11.2026
12:39
W.P.(C) 16590/2026 Page 4 of 11
“4. The fulcrum of dispute before the Tribunal was whether the
respondents were, or were not, eligible for consideration for
promotion as Executive Engineer (Civil).
5. The respondents, before the Tribunal, relied on a
Notification dated 26 May 1977 which read thus:
"No.F16-19/75/T-2
Ministry of Education & Social Welfare (Deptt. of
Education Technical)
New Delhi-110001 Dated 26 May, 1977
Sub: Recognition of Technical & Professional
Qualification"
On the recommendation of the Board of Assessment
for Educational Qualifications and recommendation of
Defence Director (tech;), the Government of India have
decided to recognize a Diploma in Engineering in
appropriate discipline plus total ten years of technical
experience in the appropriate fields in recognized as
equivalent to Degree in Engineering. It is considered valid
for the purpose of selection to Gazetted posts and services
under the Central Government or State Government.
(V.R. Reddy)
Director (Tech.)
To be published in Gazette of India and NCO Code Book.
Copy to:- All Ministries, Departments of the Government
of India/State Government/Regional Offices/State Public
Service Commissions etc.”
6. Further, reliance was also placed by the respondent on the
judgment of a Division Bench of this Court in UOI v M. P. Shrivas
and T R Sharma v UOF', which also relied on the said Notification.
7. Predicated on the aforesaid judgments and the Notification dated
26 May 1977, the Tribunal proceeded to allow the respondents
original application.
8. Aggrieved thereby, the petitioners have approached this
Court by means of the present writ petition.
9. Before this Court, a specific stand was taken by the
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:YOGESH
KUMAR
Signing Date:18.11.2026
12:39
W.P.(C) 16590/2026 Page 5 of 11
petitioners, on 19 February 2018, that the Notification dated 26
May 1977 was a fictitious notification which had never been
published in the Official Gazette. It is worthwhile to reproduce the
order passed by the Division Bench of this Court on 19 February
2018, apropos the said contention:
“1. The petitioner/UOI is aggrieved by the order dated
27.10.2016 passed by the Central Administrative Tribunal in O.A.
1348/2015 filed by the respondents wherein, the Tribunal had
followed two judgments of two High Courts, including the High
Court of Delhi in W.P.(C) No.6922/2014 entitled UOI & Ors, vs.
M.P. Srinivas & Ors. decision dated 13.10.2014 and that of the
Tribunal in O.A. No. 2651/2012 entitled T.R. Sharma & Ors. vs.
Union of India & Ors. decided on 26.4.2013 and had declared that
"the respondents be considered for promotion to the post of EE
(Civil and Electrical) by considering their diploma in Engineering
with ten years experience in the field (Civil and Engineering) as
equivalent to degree in Engineering".
2. The sole ground taken by the petitioner/UOI to assail the
impugned judgment is that the Notification dated 26.5.1977
referred to in the decisions of two High Courts (High Court of
Delhi and High Court of Punjab & Haryana) may have been
fictitious and does not appear to be published in the Gazette of
India. To fortify the said submissions, learned counsel refers to the
Notification dated 23.3.2016, issued by the Ministry of Human
Resource Development, Department of Higher Education, which
states as under: -
"F. No. 11-11/2015 TSII/TC The Ministry of Human Resource
Development (Department of Higher Education) hereby clarify that
matter containing in File No. 18-19/75 T-2, dated 26th May 1977,
under the subject "Recognition of Technical and Professional
Qualifications purportedly issued by the erstwhile Ministry of
Education and Social Welfare (Department of Education) has been
declared fictitious by the Hon'ble Central Administrative Tribunal
Chandigarh Bench at Chandigarh vide its judgment in O.A. No.
th
343-PB-2013 was pronounced on 15 December, 2015.”
3. In our view, the aforesaid Notification is of no avail unless
and until the Gazette Branch of the UOI certifies that after perusing
its record, no such O.M. dated 26.5.1977 on the subject of
"Recognition of Technical and Professional Qualifications" was
ever published by the Department. The petitioner is directed to
approach the Gazette Branch of the UOI and obtain a certificate in
that regard. In the absence of any such document, we will have no
option but to dismiss the present petition. Needful shall be done
within six weeks, with a copy to the counsel for the respondents.
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:YOGESH
KUMAR
Signing Date:18.11.2026
12:39
W.P.(C) 16590/2026 Page 6 of 11
4. List on 08.8.2018.
5. Interim orders to continue.
10. Though the petitioner has, regrettably, not placed on record
any efforts made by it, in terms of directions contained in para 3 of
the order dated 19 February 2018, to
verify from the Gazette Branch as to whether the OM dated
26 May 1977 was or was not fictitious, Mr. T. Hari Harasudhan,
learned Counsel for the petitioner, has handed
over, across the Bar, a clarification dated 22 May 2015, by
the Directorate of Publications, to the effect that the Notification
dated 26 May 1977 was not traceable.
11. This also stands reflected in subsequent communications dated
7 September 2018, issued by the Department of Higher Education,
Ministry of Human Resource Development and 9 October 2023,
issued by the CPWD itself.
12. Once the Directorate of Publications, which is the nodal
office for gazetting of notifications, has specifically certified and
confirmed that the Notification dated 26 May 1977 is not traceable,
it is not possible for us to uphold the reliance, by the Tribunal, on
the said Notification.
13. Mr. Adesh Jain, who appears in person and was permitted
to intervene in the present proceedings, has placed certain
additional documents on record. Among the said documents is a
judgment dated 17 January 2023 of the Division Bench of the High
Court of Punjab and Haryana in
LPA 26/2018 (O&M), in which the following specific finding has
been returned:
"Having regard to the stand taken by the Secretary of the Ministry
of the Human Resource Development in the counter-affidavit dated
11.12.2017 referred to above, it is not possible to hold that the
notification dated 26.05.1977 was in fact issued by the Union of
India and grant relief to the appellants as if the said notification is
valid and subsisting.”
(Emphasis supplied)
14. Thus, there is also a finding by the High Court of Punjab
and Haryana that it was not possible to hold that the
Notification dated 26 May 1977 was in fact issued by the Union of
India.
15. As the impugned judgment of the Tribunal has proceeded
on the basis of the said Notification, it cannot sustain.
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:YOGESH
KUMAR
Signing Date:18.11.2026
12:39
W.P.(C) 16590/2026 Page 7 of 11
16. For the aforesaid reasons, the impugned judgment is
quashed and set aside.
17. OA 1348/2015 stands remitted to the Tribunal for
consideration afresh de hors the Notification dated 26 May 1977 or
any judgments which were based on the said Notification.
18. We do not express any opinion on whether the respondents.
would be entitled to the reliefs sought from the Tribunal de hors
the aforesaid Notification dated 26 May 1977.
19. In order to expedite matters, let the parties appear before
the Tribunal on 10 December 2024. We request the Tribunal to
decide the matter as expeditiously as possible, as this writ petition
itself has remained pending before this Court for quite some time.
20. The writ petition stands allowed to the aforesaid extent.”
7. The Tribunal has, therefore, proceeded on the premise that the
Notification dated 26 May 1977 of the MES was false and fictitious,
and that, as the said Notification was the basis of the BSNL Circular
dated 16 July 2015, the Circular had also to perish.
8. Mr. Piyush Sharma, learned Counsel for the BSNL, has
however, drawn our attention to a judgment of the High Court of
Gujarat, rendered on 11 January 2022 in Special Civil Application
4
No.223/2022 , para 5.5 of which reads:
“5.5 In other words, the benefits already granted to the
respondent-employee under the Assured Career Progression
Scheme was sought to be cancelled on the ground that the
respondent did not possess the qualification of Degree in
Engineering, which was not permissible in law in view of the
Circular of the BSNL treating Diploma in Engineering with ten
years’ service to be equivalent with Degree in Engineering and as
upheld by the High Courts. The law is laid down treating the
4
Bharat Sanchar Nigam Limited v. Mamta Gadura
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:YOGESH
KUMAR
Signing Date:18.11.2026
12:39
W.P.(C) 16590/2026 Page 8 of 11
Diploma in Engineering with ten years’ experience as equivalent
and at par with Degree in Engineering is followed by the Tribunal
committing no error .”
(Emphasis supplied)
9. The decision of the High Court of Gujarat in Mamta Gadura
was taken to the Supreme Court by way of SLP (C) 21264-
21265/2022, which was dismissed in limine by order dated 16 April
2025.
10. Mr. Sharma’s contention is that the Circular dated 16 July 2015
has thus been accorded the imprimatur of the High Court of Gujarat in
its judgement in Mamta Gadura and, that therefore, the Tribunal
could not have passed an order setting aside and striking down the
said circular or directing the BSNL to act in violation thereof. Else,
submits Mr. Sharma, the BSNL would be faced with contrary judicial
directives, once striking down the Circular dated 16 July 2015, as has
been done by the Tribunal in the impugned judgment, and the other by
the High Court of Gujarat in Mamta Gadura , directing the BSNL
itself to act in accordance with the said circular, against which SLP
already stands dismissed.
11. The issue, undoubtedly, requires consideration.
12. The judgment of the High Court of Gujarat in Mamta Gadura
was highlighted, and relied upon, by the petitioner BSNL in RA
4449/2026, which sought a review of the judgment dated 14
November 2025 in the OA. The Tribunal has, however, not
condescended to enter into the effect or impact of the judgment of the
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:YOGESH
KUMAR
Signing Date:18.11.2026
12:39
W.P.(C) 16590/2026 Page 9 of 11
High Court of Gujarat in Mamta Gadura and the dismissal of the SLP
thereagainst, on the ground that the said examination fell outside the
scope of review jurisdiction.
13. We are not, for the present, entering into the correctness of that
opinion. There is a body of case law which holds that, if the
correctness of a judgment, of which review is sought, is questioned on
the ground of binding judicial precedents, which have not been
noticed in the judgment, even if they were not cited, the Court must
not demur from examining that aspect, even in review jurisdiction.
14. We, are also of the opinion that an order such as that passed in
the present RA, which renders clear findings on the merits of the RA,
could not have been passed in circulation.
15. We are, therefore, of the opinion that RA 4449/2026 deserves to
be re-examined on merits.
16. Accordingly, we quash and set aside the judgment dated 13 July
2026 passed by the Tribunal in RA 4449/2026 and remand the RA to
the Tribunal for re-consideration on merits afresh, after hearing
learned counsel for the parties.
17. We direct the learned counsel for the parties in the RA to appear
before the Tribunal on 23 November 2026. No party would be entitled
to seek any adjournment on that day.
18. We also request the Tribunal to deal with the matter
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:YOGESH
KUMAR
Signing Date:18.11.2026
12:39
W.P.(C) 16590/2026 Page 10 of 11
expeditiously, as it involves a large number of employees of the
BSNL and a challenge to the Circular dated 16 July 2015, which
prescribes qualifications.
19. We also make it clear that we have not expressed any opinion,
one way or the other, on the merits of RA and that it would be for the
Tribunal to take a view in that regard keeping in mind all the facts and
circumstances and all the existing legal position.
20. We also request the Tribunal to take a decision on the RA
within a period of four weeks from today.
21. The writ petition is allowed to the aforesaid extent, with no
order as to costs.
C. HARI SHANKAR, J.
NIVEDITA ANIL SHARMA, J.
NOVEMBER 5, 2026/A
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:YOGESH
KUMAR
Signing Date:18.11.2026
12:39
W.P.(C) 16590/2026 Page 11 of 11