HARI KISHAN BHATT vs STATE OF UTTARAKHAND

Court
Uttarakhand High Court

UKHC010112012025

2026:UHC:10631


Judgment reserved on: 17.11.2026

Judgment delivered on: 20.11.2026

HIGH COURT OF UTTARAKHAND AT NAINITAL
Writ Petition Criminal No. 780 of 2025

Hari Kishan Bhatt

--Petitioner
Versus
State Of Uttarakhand
2: Director General Of Police
3: Senior Superintendent Of Police
4: Investigating Officer
5: C. B. C. I. D.
6: C. B. I.
7: Km. Ashruti Bhatt Alias Prachi
8: Shri Piyush

--Respondents


----------------------------------------------------------------------
Presence :-

Mr. Ramji Shrivastava, learned counsel for petitioner.
Mr. Sandeep Sharma, learned A.G.A. for the State.
None is present for C.B.I.
----------------------------------------------------------------------


Hon'ble Pankaj Purohit, J.

The petitioner has filed the writ petition with the
following reliefs.

(i) “A suitable writ order or direction in the nature of
mandamus commanding the respondent No. 1, 2 and
3 to transfer the investigation of FIR No.29 of 2024
under Section 306 of IPC, Police Station Nehru
Colony District Dehradun (Annexure no.3 to the writ
petition) to any independent investigation agency
particularly C.B.C.I.D or C.B.I. from respondent no.4
and direct the respondent no.5 or 6 to investigate
the matter in accordance with law.”

2. Brief facts of the case are that the eldest son
1

UKHC010112012025

2026:UHC:10631


of the petitioner namely Mukul Bhatt aged about 24
years left for Delhi on 25.11.2023 at around 7:50 p.m.
in a Taxi for railway station Dehradun. On the next
morning i.e. 26.11.2023 when the petitioner called his
son to enquire whether he has safely reached Delhi the
call was picked by police of police station Nehru Colony
who informed the petitioner that his son has died after
he met with an accident by train. The petitioner
thereafter rushed to Nehru Colony Police Station where
he was informed that his son has been taken to
Coronation Hospital, Dehradun. He was also informed
that his son got cut under train near Hanuman Temple
Mohkampur. As the petitioner believed that his son
could not commit suicide he asked the Nehru Colony
Police Station to register an FIR. After a preliminary
enquiry he was informed by the police that he called
one person named Piyush before his death and talked
to him for about 20 minutes. He was also informed that
he made more than 25 calls to Ashruti but the police
did not register an FIR thereafter he moved an
application to the S.S.P. which was also not paid any
heed. Thereafter, he filed an application to the Judicial
Magistrate under Section 156 (3) who in turn ordered
to register an FIR. The petitioner suspects that the local
police is conducting the investigation in a hazy manner,
therefore, he is before this Court to transfer the
investigation to C.B.I./C.B.C.I.D.
3. Learned counsel for the petitioner submits
that the police did not register the FIR even after
repeated request and it was only after the direction of
2

UKHC010112012025

2026:UHC:10631


the Judicial Magistrate that the FIR was registered. The
counsel further states that even after being aware of
the fact that the deceased contacted two persons
namely Piyush and Ashruti multiple times before his
death they have not examined them. He further states
that the Google location of the deceased was inside
GTM flats on the alleged date of incident but the police
has not collected the CCTV footage from GTM. He
further states that the police has failed to collect
scientific evidence and even after sending the phones
to FSL they have not been able to retrieve the chats.
4. Learned State Counsel in turn submits that
the investigation on the aforesaid FIR is being done in
a proper manner and in accordance with law. He states
that during the investigation no evidence has come
which implicates Piyush or Ashruti regarding the
murder of the deceased or any kind of abetment to his
suicide. He further states that the FSL Shimla retrieved
certain chats from the mobile of the deceased which
show no signs of abetment to suicide. He further
states that the Google location of the deceased was
not inside GTM Flats but behind GTM Flats from where
the railway line goes. He further states that the police
during investigating has also checked the visitors
register in GTM Flats and it shows that the deceased
did not enter in GTM Flats on the alleged date of
incident. The police during investigation also
interrogated a Zomato Deliver partner who deliver
food to the deceased under Mohkampur Fly Over at
02:48 a.m. on the alleged date of incident. The
3

UKHC010112012025

2026:UHC:10631


Zomato boy during inquiry told the police that the
deceased seemed to be slightly drunk. The police also
recovered a bag from the place of accident which
contained clothes, documents, two mobile phones and
a bottle of liquor which was half empty. He further
states that no evidence has come to implicate any
person in abetting the suicide of the deceased and
some of the chats could not be recovered as none of
the family members of the deceased could tell the
password of the mobile phone.
5. Learned Counsel for the C.B.I. relying upon
the counter affidavit states that it is a settled principle
of law that the High Court should be slow in
transferring each and every investigation to C.B.I and
such orders should not be passed as a matter of
routine or merely because a party has leveled some
allegations against the local police.
6. Learned counsel for the petitioner relying on
the basis of rejoinder affidavit stated that the
investigation in the present case has not been
conducted properly and has been done in hasty
manner which is clear from the fact that the police
officials fail to register the FIR and also fail to provide
the progress report despite repeated request made to
them. He further states that the police officials are
themselves admitting that the entire data could not be
recovered from the mobile phones of the deceased
therefore, conclusions could not be drawn that the
accused persons are not involved in abetting the
suicide of the deceased.
4

UKHC010112012025

2026:UHC:10631


7. He further relied in the case of Minor
Irrigation & Rural Engineering Services U.P. and
others Vs. Sahngoo Ram Arya and another
(2002(5) SCC 521 in which the Hon’ble Apex Court
observed that the High Court has power to order CBI
enquiry if after considering the material on record it
comes to a conclusion that such material discloses
prima facie case calling for investigation by the CBI or
any other similar agency.
8. Having heard the submissions made by
learned counsel for the parties and after perusal of the
material available on record and taking into
consideration that the alleged incident is of the year
2023 and after going through the counter affidavit of
respondent nos. 1 to 4 this Court is of the considered
opinion that the police has conducted the investigation
in a proper and lawful manner with due diligence. The
police has conducted a thorough investigation in
collecting the evidence viz: recovering the CDR,
recovering the chats, duly taking the statements of
Zomato delivery boy, GTM guards, GRP personnels and
collecting the Google location of the deceased. The
investigation conducted did not implicate any person in
abetting the suicide of the deceased. Therefore, it
cannot be said that any greater good will happen if the
investigation is transferred to CBI/C.B.C.I.D. moreover
Hon’ble Apex Court in multiple judgments has opined
that the investigation should not be transferred to CBI
in a routine manner and should only be transferred in
exceptional situations where it become necessary to
5

UKHC010112012025

2026:UHC:10631


provide credibility to the investigation. Recently, in
Royden Harold Buthello & Anr. Vs. State of Chattisgarh
& Ors., SLP (Crl.) No. 2454 of 2022 , decided on
28.02.2023, the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India has
declined to refer an investigation to CBI and observed
that “That extraordinary power must be exercised
sparingly, cautiously and in exceptional situations
where it becomes necessary to provide credibility and
instill confidence in investigations or where the incident
may have national and international ramifications or
where such an order may be necessary for doing
complete justice and enforcing the fundamental rights.
Otherwise, CBI would be flooded with a large number
of cases and with limited resources, may find it difficult
to properly investigate even serious cases and in the
process lost it credibility and purpose with
unsatisfactory investigations.”
9. Accordingly, the writ petition is dismissed.



(Pankaj Purohit, J.)

Nahid









6