Nanhe Kumar Singh vs The State of Bihar

Court
Patna High Court

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT PATNA
Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No.14944 of 2026
CNR No. BRHC010954482026
======================================================
1. Nanhe Kumar Singh S/O Triveni Singh, R/o Village- Bhore, P.O.- Bhore,
P.S.- Bhore, District Gopalganj, Bihar.
2. Harishankar Kumar Singh S/o Vishwamitra Singh, Resident of Village-
Nautan, P.O. and P.S.-Vijayipur, District- Gopalganj, Bihar.
3. Kishor Kumar Verma S/o Kashi Prasad, Resident of Village-Sansarpur, P.O.
and P.S.- Bhore, District- Gopalganj, Bihar.
4. Jitendra Kumar Singh S/o Bairister Singh, Resident of Village-
Bikhachhapar, P.O. and P.S Bhore, District- Gopalganj, Bihar.
5. Radhika Devi, W/o Manji Prasad Chaurasiya, Resident of Village- Bithua,
P .O. and P.S- Bhore, District- Gopalganj, Bihar.
6. Pramila Devi W/o Vijay Kumar, Resident of Village- Bithua, P .O. and P.S.-
Bhore, District- Gopalganj, Bihar.
7. Rajiv Kumar Mishra S/o Narsingh Mishra, Resident of Village- Bharpurwa,
P.O. and P.S.-Vijayipur, District- Gopalganj, Bihar.
8. Anita Pandey W/o Satydev Pandey, Resident of Village- Bharpurwa, P.O.
and P.S.- Vijayipur, District- Gopalganj, Bihar.
9. Punam Dixit W/o Chandracharu Chaubey, Resident of Village- Dikshitauli,
P.O. and P.S.-Hussepur, District- Gopalganj, Bihar.
10. Harinarayan Singh S/o Vishwamitra Singh, Resident of Village- Nautan,
P.O. and P.S.- Vijayipur, District- Gopalganj, Bihar.
11. Namita Singh W/o Harinarayan Singh, Resident of Village- Nautan, P.O. and
P.S.- Vijayipur, District- Gopalganj, Bihar.
12. Kamlesh Kumar Singh S/o Sitaram Singh, Resident of Village- Lamichaur,
P.O. and P.S.- Bhore, District- Gopalganj, Bihar.
13. Kumari Anjali W/o Bachcha Singh, Resident of Village- Nautan, P.O. and
P.S.- Vijayipur, District- Gopalganj, Bihar.
14. Abhishek Kumar S/o Late Upendra Rai, Resident of Village- Koreya, P.O.-
Jigna Dubey, P.S.-Bhore, District- Gopalganj, Bihar.
15. Mohammad Noor Alam@Noor Alam Ansari S/o Abdul Ajij Ansari, Resident
of Village- Bakhariya, P.O.-Jigna Dueby, P.S.- Bhore, District- Gopalganj,
Bihar.
16. Maya Prasad Yadav @ Maya Kumar Yadav S/o Adalat Yadav, Resident of
Village- Sirisiya, P.O.-Mushari Bazar, P.S.- Bhore, District- Gopalganj,
Bihar.
17. Shashirekha Singh W/o Harshchandra Singh, Resident of Village- Balwa,
P.O.-Mushari Bazar, P.S.- Bhore, District- Gopalganj, Bihar.
18. Binod Kumar S/o Sheonath Singh, Resident of Village- Dumar Narendra,
P.O.-Dumar Narendra, P.S.- Bhore, District- Gopalganj, Bihar.
19. Keshari Kumar Pandey S/o Sharwanand Pandey, Resident of Village-

Patna High Court CWJC No.14944 of 2026 dt.19-11-2026
2/108
Jyotish Tola, P.O.-Dumar Narenda, P.S.- Bhore, District- Gopalganj, Bihar.
20. Rimmee Kumari S/o Dharmendra Kumar Singh, Resident of Village- Bhore,
P.O. and P.S.- Bhore, District- Gopalganj, Bihar.
21. Renu Shukla W/o SatyaPrakash Gurg, Resident of Village- Naru Chakewa,
P.O. and P.S.- Bhore, District- Gopalganj, Bihar.
22. Naveen Kumar Chaturvedi S/o Dinanath Singh, Resident of Village- Ward
no.13, Bhikha Chhapar, P.O.-Rudalpur, P.S.- Bhore, District- Gopalganj,
Bihar.
23. Purnima Tripathi W/o Raju Kumar Mishra, Resident of Village Lamichaur,
P.O.-Lamichaur, P.S.- Bhore, District- Gopalganj, Bihar.
24. Nagendra Pandey @ Nagendra Nath Pandey S/o Kamlakant Pandey,
Resident of Village- Koila Dewa, P.O.-Koila Dewa, P.S.-Phulwariya,
District- Gopalganj, Bihar.
25. Dhananjay Mishra S/o Surendra Mishra, Resident of Village- Belaura, P.O.-
Baghi Bazar, P.S.-Kateya, District- Gopalganj, Bihar.
26. Suresh Singh S/o Pramhans Singh, Resident of Village Bhore, P.O. and P.S.-
Bhore, District-Gopalganj, Bihar.
27. Bipin Bihari Singh S/o Sakaldhari Singh, Resident of Village- Belwa
Thakurai, P.O. and P.S.- Bhore, District- Gopalganj, Bihar.
28. Upendra Pandey S/o Akshayber Pandey, Resident of Village- Mushari, P.O.-
Mushari Bazar, P.S.- Bijayipur, District- Gopalganj, Bihar.
29. Sangram Singh S/O Shardanand Singh, R/o Village- Suaraha, P.O.- Mushari
Bazar, P.S.-Bijaipur, District - Gopalganj, Bihar.
30. Durgesh Kumar Rai S/O Suresh Ray, R/o Village- Kishunpura, P.S.-
Majhaulia, District Gopalganj, Bihar.
31. Jagat Ram, S/O Dhuri Ram, R/o Village- Piparahi, P.O.- Matiyari, P.S.-
Matiyari, District Gopalganj, Bihar.
32. Gautam Pandey S/O Mundrika Pandey, R/o Village- Kishunpura, P.S.-
Majhaulia, District -Gopalganj, Bihar.
33. Pratibha Devi W/O Kamlesh Kumar, R/o Village- Patkhauli, P.S.- Kateya,
District Gopalganj, Bihar.
34. Shyam Murari Sharma S/O Ramayan Sharma, R/o Village Mathia, P.O.-
Bhore, P.S.-Goplaganj, District - Gopalganj, Bihar.
35. Amrisha Rai, D/O Ram Pravesh Rai, R/o Village-Korauli, P.O- Gontha, P.S.-
Gontha, District Mau, Uttar Pradesh.
36. Dileep Kumar S/O Shukdev Prasad, R/o Village- Ramnagar, P.O.- Mushari
Bazar, P.S.- Bijaipur, District - Gopalganj, Bihar.
37. Abhinandan Rai @ A Rai S/O Guptar Rai, R/o Village- Mushari, P.O.-
Mushari Bazar, P.S.-Bijaipur, District - Gopalganj, Bihar.
38. Anand Kumar Gupta @ Anand Kumar S/O Bridhichand Gupta, R/o Village-
Mushari, P.O.-Mushari Bazar, P.S.- Bijaipur, District - Gopalganj, Bihar.
39. Nuralam Siddqui @ Nuralam S/O Nizamuddin Siddqui, R/o Village- Sitta
Patti, P.O.- Banjariya, P.S.- Banjariya, District - Deoria, Uttar Pradesh. 14

Patna High Court CWJC No.14944 of 2026 dt.19-11-2026
3/108
40. Ajamat Ansari, S/o Rauf Ansari, Resident of Village- Sabea, P.S.- Bhore,
District- Gopalganj, Bihar.
41. Arbind Kumar Yadav S/O Brijlal Yadav, R/o Village- Sarupai Tola Khape,
Jagdishpur, P.O.-Bijaipur, P.S.- Bijaipur, District - Gopalganj, Bihar.
42. Devendra Kumar Verma S/O Sunner Prasad Verma, R/o Village- Patkhauli,
P.S.- Mushari Bazar, District - Gopalganj, Bihar.
43. Sangeeta Verma W/O Jitendra Kumar Verma, R/o Village- Patkhauli, P.S.-
Mushari Bazar, District - Gopalganj, Bihar.
44. Prem Sheela Singh W/O Shyambadan Singh, R/o Village- Patkhauli, P.S.-
Mushari Bazar, District - Gopalganj, Bihar.
45. Laxmi Devi W/O Akhilesh Ram, R/o Village- Patkhauli, P.S.- Mushari
Bazar, District - Gopalganj, Bihar.
46. Yogendra Chauhan S/o Gorakh Nath Chauhan, Resident of Village-
Khiridih, P.O- Bharpurwa, P.S.-.Bijaipur, District- Gopalganj, Bihar.
47. Shailesh Kumar Shukla S/o Saryu Prasad Shukla, Resident of Village-
Kamchar, P.O-Jagdishpur, P.S.-Vijayipur, District- Gopalganj, Bihar
48. Dewakar Manjhi S/o Brijdev Manjhi, Resident of Village- Jagdishpur, P.O-
Jagdishpur, P.S.-Vijayipur, District- Gopalganj, Bihar.
49. Rahmat Ansari @Rahmat Ali Ansari S/o Abdul Rasid Ansari, Resident of
Village- Sabeya, P.O and P.S.- Sabeya, District- Gopalganj, Bihar
50. Sunil Chaubey S/o Dhaneshwar Chaubey, Resident of Village- Jaisauli, P.S.-
Kateya, District- Gopalganj, Bihar.
51. Dinesh Mishra S/o Mukhut Mishra, Resident of Village- Shamdas Bagahi,
P.S.- Kateya, District- Gopalganj, Bihar.
52. Bibha Kumari W/o Chandrashekhar Rai, Resident of Village- Patkhauli,
Sidhwania, P.S.-Kateya, District- Gopalganj, Bihar.
53. Lokesh Rai S/o Prabhunath Rai, Resident of Village- House No.3,
Khurahuriya, Ward no.11, P.S.- Kataiya, District- Gopalganj, Bihar. 13
54. Ram Balak Mishra S/o Byash Mishra, Resident of Village Malpura, P.O.-
Jasauli, P.S.-Kateya, District- Gopalganj, Bihar.
55. Satish Chandra Ojha S/o Mahendra Ojha, Resident of Village- Amahi
Banke, P.S.-Kateya, District- Gopalganj, Bihar.
56. Ashok Kumar Yadav S/o Ramanand Yadav, Resident of Village Amahi
Banke, P.S.-Kateya, District- Gopalganj, Bihar.
57. Sunil Kumar Sharma S/o Ramdeni Sharma, Resident of Village- Durga
Mandir, Sohaniya, P.S.-Kateya, District- Gopalganj, Bihar.
58. Ramesh Kumar Ram S/o Bunilal Ram, Resident of Village Belhi Dih, Belahi
Khas, P.S.-Kateya, District- Gopalganj, Bihar.
59. Dinesh Kumar S/o Mohan Prasad, Resident of Village- Ward no.14,
Magahiya, P.O.-Bhore, P.S.-Kateya, District- Gopalganj, Bihar.
60. Yogendra Prasad Bhagat S/o Hira Prasad Bhagat, Resident of Village-
Mohanpur, Belhi Khas, P.S.-Kateya, District- Gopalganj, Bihar.
61. Kumari Nittoo Prasad W/o Jagat Ram, Resident of Village- Vijaypur,

Patna High Court CWJC No.14944 of 2026 dt.19-11-2026
4/108
Piparahi, P.O-Bhore, P.S.-Kateya, District- Gopalganj, Bihar.
62. Chandrika Ram S/o Durjan Ram, Resident of Village- Belhi Khas, P.S.-
Kateya, District-Gopalganj, Bihar.
63. Md Sakil Ansari S/o Md. Dilsattar Ansari, Resident of Village- Belahi Dih,
Belahi Khas, P.S.-Kateya, District- Gopalganj, Bihar.
64. Nikhat Parveen S/o Shaheed Ansari, Resident of Village- Madar, P.O-
Vijayipur, P.S.-Vijayipur, District- Gopalganj, Bihar.
65. Usha Kumari W/o Harikesh Prasad, Resident of Village- Awrd no.3, Kateya,
P.S.-Kateya, District-Gopalganj, Bihar.
66. Kumari Mamta Gupta W/o Manoj Prasad, Resident of Village Phulwaria,
P.S.-Phulwaria, District- Gopalganj, Bihar.
67. Premlata Kumari W/o Umesh Baitha, Resident of Village- Patkhauli,
Sidwania, P.S.-Kateya, District- Gopalganj, Bihar.
68. Chhabila Ram S/o Dukhan Ram, Resident of Village- Rupi Baghai, P.S.-
Kateya, District-Gopalganj, Bihar.
69. Sushma Dwivedi W/o Harendra Dwivedi, Resident of Village Chakiya
Gahni, Raipura, Patkhauli, P.O.-Simaria, P.S.-Kateya, District- Gopalganj,
Bihar.
70. Suman Lata W/o Nagendra Sharma, Resident of Village- Raipura, Patkhauli,
P.S.-Kateya, District-Gopalganj, Bihar.
71. Antosh Kumar Diwedi S/o Shambhu Nath Dwivedi, Resident of Village-
Jajwalia, P.O. and P.S.-Bajudih Mahuawa, District- Gopalganj, Bihar.
72. Sanjoli Singh D/o Ram Pratap Singh, Resident of Village- H. no. 132, Belwa
P.O.-Gauri Badya Purwa, P.S.- Belwa, District- Maharajganj, Uttar Pradesh.
73. Sanju Pandey W/o Rajesh Kumar Pandey, Resident of Village-Maheshpur,
P.O.-Maheshpur, P.S.- Vijayipur, District- Gopalganj, Bihar.
74. Manoj Kumar Pandey S/o Rajendra Pandey, Resident of Village-Maheshpur,
P.O-Maheshpur, P.S.- Vijayipur, District- Gopalganj, Bihar. 13
75. Mritunjay Kumar Singh S/o Dinanth Singh, Resident of Village-Bhika
Chhappar, Ward no.13, P.O and P.S.- Bhore, District- Gopalganj, Bihar. 13
76. Kumari Mamta Singh W/o Ranjan Kumar, Resident of Village- Dumar
Narendra, P.O.-Dumar Narendra, P.S. Bhore, District- Gopalganj, Bihar.
77. Akanksha Yadav W/o Ramesh Yadav, Reside at of Village- Ward no.12,
Bahrwa Tola, P.O.-Majhauli Raj, P.S.- Salempur, District- Deoria, Uttar
Pradesh.
78. Jai Prakash Singh S/o Ganga Bishun Singh, Resident of Village- Dumar
Narendra, P.O.-Dumar Narendra, P.S.- Bhore, District- Gopalganj, Bihar.
79. Om Prakash Singh S/o Rajinandan Verma, Resident of Village- Bhore, P.O.
and P.S.- Bhore, District-Gopalganj, Bihar.
80. Harikesh Kumar Chauhan S/o Ramjiyawan Chauhan, Resident of Village-
Banktajagidari, P.O.- Banktajagidari, P.S.- Bhore, District- Gopalganj, Bihar.
81. Sumit Kumar Rai S/o Gyanchandra Rai, Resident of Village- Khoribari,
P.O.-Rampur, P.S.-Bhatni, District-Deoria, Uttar Pradesh.

Patna High Court CWJC No.14944 of 2026 dt.19-11-2026
5/108
82. Sandhya Tiwari W/o Anand Tiwari, Resident of Village- Jagirdari
Bagahawa, P.S.- Motipur, District-Gopalganj, Bihar.
83. Bijay Kumar Pandey S/o Rishideo Pandey, Resident of Village-
Bandhuchhapar, P.O.-Bhore, P.S.- Motipur, District- Gopalganj, Bihar.
84. Sanjay Kumar Yadav S/o Ramdeo Yadav, Resident of Village- Bagahwa
Tiwari, Sisai, P.O.-Sisai, P.S.- Motipur, District- Gopalganj, Bihar.
85. Jitendra Yadav S/o Bairister Yadav, Resident of Village- Amawa, P.O. and
P.S.- Bhore, District-Gopalganj, Bihar.
86. Sarita Kumari W/o Dharmendra Yadav, Resident of Village Basdila Khas,
P.S.- Bhore, District- Gopalganj, Bihar.
87. Vijay Kumar Yadav S/o Banvari Yadav, Resident of Village- Balwa, P.O.-
Mushari Bazar, P.S.-Bhore, District- Gopalganj, Bihar.
88. Akhilesh Kumar Mishra S/o Mahanth Mishra, Resident of Village-
Dharahara, P.O.-Sisai, P.S.- Motipur, District- Gopalganj, Bihar.
89. Dharamshelela Devi, W/o Prem Chandra Singh, Resident of Village- Noniya
Chhapar, P.O.-Sisai, P.S.- Motipur, District- Gopalganj, Bihar.
... ... Petitioner/s
Versus
1. The State of Bihar through the Additional Chief Secretary, Education
Department, Government of Bihar, Patna.
2. The Additional Chief Secretary, Education Department, Government of
Bihar, Patna.
3. The Director, Primary Education, Government of Bihar, Patna.
4. The Regional Deputy Director of Education, Saran Division, Chapra, Bihar.
5. The District Education Officer, Gopalganj, Bihar
6. The District Programme Officer (Est.), Gopalganj, Bihar
... ... Respondent/s
======================================================
with
Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No. 14952 of 2026
CNR No. BRHC010954482026
======================================================
Neelam Kumari Wife of Kishore Sanjay, Resident of Village- Muhabbatpur,
P.S.- Mohabbatpur, District- Muzaffarpur, presently posted as Exclusive
Teacher, Primary School, Hari Lakhnawri, Block- Paru, District- Muzaffarpur.
... ... Petitioner/s
Versus
1. The State of Bihar through the Additional Chief Secretary, Education
Department, Government of Bihar, Patna, District- Patna.
2. The Director, Primary Education, Education Department, Government of
Bihar, Patna, District- Patna.

Patna High Court CWJC No.14944 of 2026 dt.19-11-2026
6/108
3. The Deputy Secretary, Education Department, Government of Bihar, Patna,
District- Patna.
4. The District Magistrate, Muzaffarpur, District- Muzaffarpur.
5. The District Education Officer, Muzaffarpur, District- Muzaffarpur.
6. The District Programme Officer (Establishment), Muzaffarpur, District-
Muzaffarpur.
... ... Respondent/s
======================================================
with
Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No. 14971 of 2026
CNR No. BRHC010954482026
======================================================
1. Munna Kumar Son of Nand Kishor Singh, Resident of Bikarampur, PO-
Bikrampur PS Cheriya Bariyarpur, Begusarai (Bihar) 851132, presently
posted as Exclusive Teacher, Rajeshwari High School Cheria Bariyarpur,
District- Begusarai.
2. Durgesh Kumar Son of Ramkrishna Singh, Son of Ramkrishna Singh,
Resident of Village- Mohanpur, PO-Mohanpur, PS- Muffasil, Begusarai,
Bihar- 851131, presently posted as Exclusive Teacher, Excellent
Government Middle School, Mohanpur, District- Begusarai.
3. Shyam Narayan Sahu Son of Shivaram Sahu, Resident of Village-
Mohanpur, PO-Mohanpur, PS- Mufassil, Begusarai, Bihar 85113, presently
posted as Exclusive Teacher, Excellent Government Middle School,
Mohanpur, District- Begusarai.
4. Arvind Kumar Son of Ram Birksh Singh, Resident of Village Mohanpur, PO
Mohanpur, PS Mufassil, Begusarai, Bihar 851131, presently posted as
Exclusive Teacher, Excellent Government Middle School, Mohanpur,
District- Begusarai.
5. Priti Bharti Wife of Shubhankar Pathak, Resident of Ward No 15, near
Mobile Tower, Pipra, Dumri, PO Dumri, PS Ratanpur, District- Begusarai,
Bihar 851117, presently posted as Exclusive Teacher, Excellent Government
Middle School, Mohanpur, District- Begusarai.
6. Rajesh Kumar Jha Son of Kameshwar Jha, Resident of Gayatri Niwas,
Kapasiya East, Nagdah, PO Nagdah, District Begusarai, presently posted as
Exclusive Teacher, Excellent Government Middle School, Mohanpur,
District- Begusarai.
7. Ranju Devi Wife of Jai Jai Ram Rai, Resident of Village and PO- Birpur,
PS- Birpur, District- Begusarai, presently posted as Exclusive Teacher,
Upgraded Girls Middle School, Birpur, District Begusarai.
... ... Petitioner/s
Versus
1. The State of Bihar through the Additional Chief Secretary, Education
Department, Government of Bihar, Patna, District- Patna.
2. The Director, Primary Education, Education Department, Government of

Patna High Court CWJC No.14944 of 2026 dt.19-11-2026
7/108
Bihar, Patna, District- Patna.
3. The Deputy Secretary, Education Department, Government of Bihar, Patna,
District- Patna.
4. The District Education Officer, Begusarai, District- Begusarai.
5. The District Programme Officer (Establishment), Begusarai, District-
Begusarai.
... ... Respondent/s
======================================================
with
Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No. 15058 of 2026
CNR No. BRHC010954482026
======================================================
1. Yogendra Paswan S/O Joka Paswan, R/O Vill. Tikulia, P.O. Tikulia, P.S.
Pipara, Dist. East Champaran.
2. Ram Pravesh Bhagat, S/O Basudeo Bhagat, R/O Village Chintamanpur, P.O.
Chintamanpur, P.S. Pipara, Dist. East Champaran.
3. Manoj Kumar, S/O Ram Bilas Yadav, R/O Vill. Milki Dath, P.O.
Jayanthipur, P.S. Bahera, Dist. Darbhanga.
4. Sudhir Kumar Singh, S/O Ganesh Singh, R/O Vill. Katma, P.O. Bahuarwa,
P.S. Mangachhi, Dist. Darbhanga.
... ... Petitioner/s
Versus
1. The State of Bihar through the Principle Secretary Education Department,
Govt. of Bihar, Patna.
2. The Additional Chief Secretary, Education Department, Govt. of Bihar,
Patna.
3. The Director, (Secondary Education), Education Department, Govt. of Bihar,
Patna.
4. The Director, (Primary Education) Education Department, Govt. of Bihar,
Patna.
5. The Deputy Director, (Secondary Education), Education Department, Govt.
of Bihar, Patna.
6. The Deputy Director, (Primary Education), Education Department, Govt. of
Bihar, Patna.
7. The Joint Director, (Secondary Education), Education Department, Govt. of
Bihar, Patna.
8. The Joint Director, (Primary Education), Education Department, Govt. of
Bihar, Patna.
9. The Divisional Commissioner, Tirhut Division, Muzaffarpur.
10. The Regional Deputy Director, Education, Tirhut Division, Muzaffarpur.
11. The District Magistrate, Vaishali.

Patna High Court CWJC No.14944 of 2026 dt.19-11-2026
8/108
12. The District Education Officer, Vaishali.
13. The District Program Officer (Establishment), Vaishali.
14. The Divisional Commissioner, Darbhanga Division, Darbhanga.
15. The Regional Deputy Director Education, Darbhanga Division, Darbhanga.
16. The District Magistrate, Darbhanga.
17. The District Education Officer, Darbhanga.
18. The District Program Officer (Establishment), Darbhanga.
... ... Respondent/s
======================================================
with
Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No. 15118 of 2026
CNR No. BRHC010954482026
======================================================
1. Thakur Rajnish Kumar Singh S/o Thakur Surendra Narayan Singh, R/o At -
Rajpur Colony H.No - 248, Hajipur, P.S. - Industrial Area, District - Vaishali.
2. Sidhraj Kumar Singh S/o Krishnadev Singh, R/o Village - Kurwa, P.O. and
P.S. - Desari, District - Vaishali.
3. Praveen Kumar S/o Umakant Singh, R/o At - North Vir Kuvar Singh
Colony, Pokhara Mohalla, Hajipur, P.S. - Town Thana, District - Vaishali.
4. Ashutosh Kumar, S/o Madhusudan Prasad Sinha, R/o At - Bhagwatpur
Patedha, P.O. and P.S. - Sarai, District - Vaishali
5. Amlesh Kumar S/o Late Indra Narayan Mandal, R/o At and P.O. - Lashkari,
Ward No - 9, P.S. - Udakishungan, District - Madhepura.
6. Roshani Kumari D/o Ram Pravesh Prasad, R/o At - Sonversha, Ward No -
06, P.S. - Shankarpur, District - Madhepura.
7. Amit Kumar S/o Sitaram Sah, R/o At - Adarsh Nagar, Ward No - 07, P.S. -
Madhepura, District - Madhepura.
8. Narendra Kumar S/o Bindeshuari Paswan, R/o Village - Jay Prakash Nagar
Madhepura, Ward No - 06, P.S. - Madhepura, District - Madhepura.
9. Dr Ruby D/o Bijay Kumar Bimal, R/o At - Near Girls High School
Madhepura, P.S. - Madhepura, District - Madhepura.
10. Om Prakash S/o Gajendra Prakash, R/o At - Sikiyaha, P.O. - Bhatni, Ward
No - 11, P.S. - Kumarkhand, District - Madhepura.
11. Soni Kumari, D/o Bishwambhar Prasad Yadav, R/o At - Jay Pal Patti
Madhepura, P.S. - Madhepura, District - Madhepura.
12. Manoj Paswan S/o Surendra Paswan, R/o At and P.O - Mahinath Nagar, P.S.
- Beldour, District - Khagariya.
13. Akhilesh Kumar S/o Anirudh Sharma, R/o Village - Kubri, P.O. - Ushri, P.S.
- Shahar Telpa, District - Arwal.
14. Sri Narayan Sharma S/o Lal Mohan Sharma, R/o Village - Shivnagar, P.O. -
Fakharpur, P.S. - Karpi, District - Arwal.

Patna High Court CWJC No.14944 of 2026 dt.19-11-2026
9/108
15. Nand Kishore Singh S/o Ram Bishnu Singh, R/o Village - Bajitpur Mathiya,
P.O. - Bajitpur, P.S. - Karpi, District - Arwal.
16. Md. Imtiaz Hussain S/o Md Mustafa Hussain, R/o At - Amna House Shahab
Colony, New Khajoor Banna Sultanganj, P.S. - Sultanganj, District - Patna.
17. Deepak Kumar, S/o Late Lalit Kumar Verma, R/o Mohalla - Lodipur,
Keshav Lal Road Lichi Bagan, Patna, P.S. - Budhha Colony, District - Patna.
18. Binit Kumar S/o Binod Narayan Singh, R/o At - Yugal Niwas, Near Behat
Middle School Jhanjharpur, Ward No - 03, P.S. - Jhanjharpur, District -
Madhubani.
19. Kanchan Kumari D/o Surya Kant Roy, R/o Village - Manharan Lal Mohalla,
Sakmapool, Mirzapur Road, P.S. - Darbhanga Town, District - Darbhanga.
20. Jayvir Singh Yadav S/o Madan Roy, R/o Village - Dhanhar, P.O. and P.S. -
Warisnagar, District - Samastipur.
21. Amlesh Kumar Jha S/o Pratap Narayan Jha, R/o Village and P.O. - Pali, P.S.
- Ghanshyapur, District - Darbhanga.
22. Pankaj Kumar S/o Dharm Lal Bhandari, R/o Village - Gullowara
Basantganj, P.S. - Town Thana, District - Darbhanga.
23. Sudhir Kumar S/o Ram Balak Sahu, R/o Village - Maranchi Ujagar, P.O. and
P.S. - Hasanpur, District - Samastipur.
24. Shakti Kumari D/o Kedar Nath Santosh, R/o Village - Bakarganj, P.S. -
Laheriasarai, District - Darbhanga.
25. Chandan Kumar S/o Satyanarayan Sharma, R/o Village - Barri Bhawanipur,
P.S. - Katra, District - Muzaffarpur.
26. Kiran Kumari D/o Parmanand Prasad Gupta, R/o Village - Dhanushi, P.S. -
Lalmaniya, District - Madhubani
27. Jyoti Bharti D/o Shiv Kumar Roy, R/o Mohalla - Laxmisagar, P.O. -
Laxmisagar, P.S. - L.N.M.U, District - Darbhanga
28. Anita Kumari Jha D/o Siteshwar Jha, R/o Village - Balbhadrapur, Ward No -
44, P.S. - Laheriasarai, District - Darbhanga.
29. Naseema Khatoon D/o Md. Qaisar Ahmad, R/o Village - Rahamganj, P.O. -
Lalbag, P.S. - Laheriasarai, District - Darbhanga.
30. Kumari Deepti D/o Ved Narayan Choudhary, R/o Village - Kurson, P.O. -
Kurson Nadiyami, P.S. - Sakatpur, District - Darbhanga.
31. Vartika Kumari D/o Kedar Nath Santosh, R/o Village - Bakarganj, Ward No
- 41, P.S. - Laheriasarai, District - Darbhanga.
32. Sweta Mishra, D/o Rajendra Nath Mishra, R/o Village - Mishra Tola, Ward
No - 26, Lalbag, P.S. - Darbhanga Nagar, District - Darbhanga.
33. Shilpa Shalini D/o Manoj Kunwar, R/o Village - Belwaganj, P.S. -
Laheriasarai, District - Darbhanga.
34. Sangeet Kumar Vishal S/o Ganeshh Sharma, R/o Mohalla - Balughat, Ward
No - 06, Near Shiv Temple, P.S. - L.N.M.U. Darbhanga, District -
Darbhanga.
35. Vikrant Kumar S/o Vishwanath Tripathi, R/o Village - Rajkumar Ganj, Old
Bus Stand, P.S. - L.N.M.U. Darbhanga, District - Darbhanga.

Patna High Court CWJC No.14944 of 2026 dt.19-11-2026
10/108
36. Rupesh Kumar Gupta S/o Krishna Kumar Gupta, R/o Village -
Shubhankarpur, P.S. - Nagar Thana, District - Darbanga.
37. Anita Kumari S/o Bishwanath Prasad, R/o Village - New Ganga Sagar, P.S. -
Laheriasarai, District - Darbhanga.
38. Sunil Kumar Das S/o Sarva Nand Das, R/o Village - Prabhat Colony, P.S. -
K. Hat, District - Purnia.
39. Namrata Prasad S/o Jai Nandan Prasad, R/o Village - Samrat Chowk Tatma
Toli, P.S. - Maranga, District - Purnia.
40. Shadma Jabin W/o Md. Zahid Akhter, R/o Village - Masjid Tola Rambagh,
P.S. - Sadar, District - Purnia.
41. Pawan Kumar Bishwas, S/o Parmanand Bishwas, R/o At - Bijulia, P.O. -
Ahilgaon, P.S. - Jalalgarh, District - Purnia.
42. Sharat Chandra Pandey S/o Birbhadra Pandey, R/o Village - Prashastadih,
P.S. - Sabour, District - Bhagalpur.
43. Kumar Shashi Kant S/o Kunj Bihari Mistry, R/o Village - Bhikhanpur, P.S. -
Ishakchak, District - Bhagalpur.
44. Rupam Kumari, D/o Ganesh Prasad Choudhary, R/o Village - Vishnupur,
P.S. - Shambhuganj, District - Banka.
45. Abhinandan Kumar Panda S/o Mahendra Prasad Panda, R/o Village -
Rangram, P.S. - Tarapur, District - Munger.
46. Mithilesh Kumar S/o Arun Kumar, R/o Village - Kajraili, P.S. - Kajaili,
District - Bhagalpur.
47. Md. Aftab Alam S/o Md. Nazir Uddin, R/o Village - Bishanpur, P.S. -
Dhoraiya, District - Banka.
48. Gazala Parween D/o Md. Shamshul Haque, R/o Village - Islamnagar
Madhopara, P.S. - K. Hat, District - Purnia.
49. Kumari Shyamla D/o Sureshwar Prasad, R/o Village - Bari Khanjarpur, P.S.
- Barari, District - Bhagalpur.
50. Jaya Shay D/o Arun Kishor Sahay, R/o Village - Bhikhanpur, P.S. -
Ishakchak, District - Bhagalpur.
51. Rakesh Ranjan S/o Shashi Bhushan Khargaha, R/o At - Near Reperal
Hospital Campus Dam Road, Bounsi Banka, P.S. - Bounsi, District - Banka.
52. Beby Kumari, W/o Vinay Kumar Rai, R/o Village - Milki Bihpur, P.S. -
Bihpur, District - Bhagalpur.
53. Rajeev Kumar S/o Mahendra Thakur, R/o Village - Amarpur Road Babutola,
P.S. - Banka, District - Banka.
54. Nitu Kumari D/o Sureshh Prasad Rajak, W/o Lalan Kumar Rajak, R/o
Village - Arya Tola, P.S. - Sabour, District - Bhagalpur.
55. Rani Kumari D/o Bhola Prasad, R/o Village - Nurpur, P.S. - Madhusudan
Nathnagar, District - Bhagalpur.
56. Dr. Smita Sinha D/o Jagdish Prasad Sinha, R/o Village - Aadampur, P.S. -
Jagdishpur, District - Bhagalpur.
57. Dr. Unmani D/o Rishi Kumar Singh, C/o Amit Kumar Alok, R/o Village -

Patna High Court CWJC No.14944 of 2026 dt.19-11-2026
11/108
Amla Tola, P.S. - Purnia, District - Purnia.
58. Manujendra Kumar S/o Kasturi Prasad Sharma, R/o At - Parbatta, P.O. -
Sahu Parbatta, P.S. - Ismailpur, District - Bhagalpur.
59. Neeraj Kumar S/o Late Parmanand Prasad, R/o At - RBI Colony Laluchak
Bhatta, P.S. - Ishakchak, District - Bhagalpur.
60. Puspa Kumari D/o Sahdeo Singh, W/o Late Brajesh Kumar Singh, R/o At -
Sarai Vivekanand Colony Bhagalpur, P.S. - Tatapur, District - Bhagalpur.
61. Pankaj Kumar Thakur S/o Ram Narayan Thakur, R/o Village - Rangra, P.S. -
Rangra Chowk, District - Bhagalpur.
62. Gopa Kumari D/o Late Kapil Kant Dubey, R/o At - M.G. Path B.B. Ghose
Lane, P.S. - Adampur, District - Bhagalpur.
63. Kumari Sheela Kumari W/o Nageshwar Paswan, R/o At - Cilkawar Asouta
Majhouni, P.S. - Rajoun, District - Banka.
64. Banti Kumar Sharma S/o Ranjeet Kumar Sharma, R/o At - Ramsar
Bhagalpur, P.S. - Tatapur, District - Bhagalpur.
65. Siddharth Shankar S/o Prasanna Kumar Choudhary, R/o Village - Pataili,
P.S. - Ujiarpur, District - Samastipur.
66. Avinash Kumar S/o Yugeshwar Sharma, R/o Village - Usari Dih, P.O. -
Usari, P.S. - Mehandia, District - Arwal.
67. Dharamnath Ray S/o Ram Nagina Ray, R/o Village - Mayil, P.S. - Bidupur,
District - Vaishali.
... ... Petitioner/s
Versus
1. The State of Bihar through, the Additional Chief Secretary Education
Department, Government of Bihar, Patna.
2. The Additional Chief Secretary, Education Department, Government of
Bihar, Patna.
3. The Secretary, Education Department, Government of Bihar, Patna.
4. The Deputy Secretary, Education Department, Government of Bihar, Patna.
5. The Director Secondary Education, Government of Bihar, Patna.
6. The District Education Officer, Vaishali, District- Vaishali, Bihar.
7. The District Education Officer, Madhepura, District- Madhepura, Bihar.
8. The District Education Officer, Arwal, District- Arwal, Bihar.
9. The District Education Officer, Patna, District- Patna, Bihar.
10. The District Education Officer, Rohtas at Darbhanga, District - Darbhanga,
Bihar.
11. The District Education Officer, Purnia, District - Purnia, Bihar.
12. The District Education Officer, Bhagalpur, District Bhagalpur, Bihar.
13. The District Education Officer, Samastipur, District Samastipur, Bihar.
14. The District Programme Officer (Establishment) Education, Vaishali,
District - Vaishali, Bihar.

Patna High Court CWJC No.14944 of 2026 dt.19-11-2026
12/108
15. The District Programme Officer (Establishment) Education, Madhepura,
District - Madhepura, Bihar.
16. The District Programme Officer (Establishment) Education, Arwal, District -
Arwal, Bihar.
17. The District Programme Officer (Establishment) Education, Patna, District -
Patna, Bihar.
18. The District Programme Officer (Establishment) Education, Darbhanga,
District - Darbhanga, Bihar.
19. The District Programme Officer (Establishment) Education, Purnia, District
- Purnia, Bihar.
20. The District Programme Officer (Establishment) Education, Bhagalpur,
District - Bhagalpur, Bihar.
21. The District Programme Officer (Establishment) Education, Samastipur,
District - Samastipur, Bihar.
... ... Respondent/s
======================================================
with
Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No. 15225 of 2026
CNR No. BRHC010954482026
======================================================
1. Chandra Shekhar Kumar Son of Maheshwar Kunwar, resident of Village
Hariyari, P.O. Suggapatti, P.S. Phulparas, District Madhubani, Bihar 847409.
2. Chandra Deo Prasad, Son of Ram Dahin Yadav, resident of Village Bharha,
P.O. Bathnaha, Via Khutauna, P.S. Phulparas, District Madhubani, Bihar -
847227.
3. Pranav Kumar, Son of Dhanik Lal Mandal, resident of Village Dhanuki, P.O.
Kariyaut, P.S. Laukahi, District Madhubani, Bihar - 847108.
4. Dinesh Kumar, Son of Surya Narayan Yadav, resident of Village Ramnagar,
P.O. Suriyahi, P.S. Phulparas, District Madhubani, Bihar 847409.
5. Akhilesh Kumar, Son of Ram Lalit Ram, resident of Village Jiroga, P.O.
Bharfori, P.S. Andhramath, Block Laukahi, District Madhubani, Bihar
847108.
6. Mahesh Prasad, Son of Chandeshwar Prasad Yadav, resident of Village and
P.O. Dhabahi, P.S. Laukahi, District Madhubani, Bihar-847108.
7. Anita Kumari, Daughter of Baleshwar Prasad, resident of Village and P.O.
Siswa Barhi, P.S. Phulparas, District Madhubani, Bihar - 847409.
8. Rakesh Kumar, Son of Munna Ram, Resident of Village and P.O.- Bagha
Kusmar, P.S. Khutauna, Via Phulparas, District Madhubani, Bihar- 847409.
9. Shyam Narayan Singh, Son of Mahendra Singh, resident of Village
Balanser, P.O. Sonpatahi, P.S. Babubarhi, District Madhubani, Bihar 847401.
10. Arjun Kumar Yadav, Son of Satya Narayan Yadav, resident of Village
Nanpatti, P.O. Narahia, P.S. Laukahi, District Madhubani, Bihar 847108.

Patna High Court CWJC No.14944 of 2026 dt.19-11-2026
13/108
... ... Petitioner/s
Versus
1. The State of Bihar through the Additional Chief Secretary. Education
Department, Government of Bihar, Patna.
2. The Additional Chief Secretary, Education Department. Government of
Bihar, Patna.
3. The Director, Primary Education, Education Department, Government of
Bihar, Patna.
4. The Regional Deputy Director of Education, Darbhanga Division,
Darbhanga, Bihar.
5. The District Education Officer, Madhubani, District Madhubani, Bihar.
6. The District Programme Officer (Establishment), Education, Madhubani,
District Madhubani, Bihar.
7. The Deputy Secretary, Education Department, Government of Bihar, Patna.
8. The Deputy Development Commissioner, Madhubani.
... ... Respondent/s
======================================================
with
Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No. 15265 of 2026
CNR No. BRHC010954482026
======================================================
Manoj Kumar son of Late Ram Padarath Singh, resident of village Dawan
Fatehpur, P.S.-Khizersarai, District- Gaya, at present residing at Maksudpur
House, Moriyaghat, P.S.-Kotwali, District- Gayaji.
... ... Petitioner/s
Versus
1. The State of Bihar through the Additional Chief Secretary, Department of
Education, Government of Bihar, Patna.
2. The Deputy Secretary, Department of Education, Government of Bihar,
Patna.
3. The Director, Primary Education, Department of Education, Govt. of Bihar,
Patna.
4. The District Magistrate, Gayaji.
5. The Regional Deputy Director, Magadh Division, Gayaji.
6. The District Education Officer, Gayaji.
7. The District Programme Officer (Establishment), Gayaji.
8. The Head Master, Mahavir Middle School, Gayaji, District-Gayaji.
... ... Respondent/s
======================================================
with
Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No. 15292 of 2026

Patna High Court CWJC No.14944 of 2026 dt.19-11-2026
14/108
CNR No. BRHC010954482026
======================================================
1. Rajeev Nayan Jha S/o- Ram Kumar Jha, R/o- Goraul, P.S and P.O Goraul,
District-Vaishali, Bihar, Pin-844118.
2. Sanjeev Shah, S/o- Raghunath Shah, R/o-Raghunathpur Donwan, Sakra,
P.O- Dholi, Dist.- Muzaffarpur, Bihar, Pin-843105.
3. Bhagya Narayan S/o- Hari Nandan Bhakta, R/o- Bhailwara Bhual, Bhual,
Muzaffarpur, Bihar-844111.
4. Bal Mukund Kumar S/o- Niwash Singh, R/o- Gorihari, Horiari, P.O.
Dariyapur Kafen, Dist- Muzaffarpur, Bihar, Pin-844127.
... ... Petitioner/s
Versus
1. The State of Bihar through The Additional Chief Secretary, Education
Department, Govt. of Bihar, Patna.
2. The Additional Chief Secretary, Education Department, Government of
Bihar, Patna.
3. The Director Primary Education, Government of Bihar, Patna.
4. The District Education Officer, Muzaffarpur, District - Muzaffarpur, Bihar.
5. The District Education Officer, Vaishali, District - Vaishali, Bihar.
6. The District Programme Officer (Establishment) Education, Muzaffarpur,
District - Muzaffarpur, Bihar.
7. The District Programme Officer (Establishment) Education, Vaishali,
District - Vaishali, Bihar.
... ... Respondent/s
======================================================
Appearance :
(In Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No. 14944 of 2026)
For the Petitioner/s : Mr. Saurav Singh, Adv
For the Respondent/s : Mr. Rajendra Prasad Sah, G.A.-21
Mr. Sunny Kumar A.C. to G.A.-21
(In Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No. 14952 of 2026)
For the Petitioner/s : Ms. Parishmita Bora, Adv
For the Respondent/s : Mr. Abhiyudan Anand, J.C. to GA-5
Mr. Prakash Chandra Agrawal, G.A.-5
(In Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No. 14971 of 2026)
For the Petitioner/s : Mr. Tarun Kumar, Adv
For the Respondent/s : Ms. Priya Gupta, G.P.-6
Mr. Atulya Anand, AC to G.P.-6
Mr. Aman Kumar, AC to G.P.-6
(In Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No. 15058 of 2026)
For the Petitioner/s : Mr. Shashi Bhushan Kumar, Adv
For the Respondent/s : Mr. Standing Counsel (22)
(In Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No. 15118 of 2026)
For the Petitioner/s : Mr. Mrityunjay Kumar, Adv
Mr. Mukesh Kr. Singh, Advocate
Mr. Shivam Kumar, Adv

Patna High Court CWJC No.14944 of 2026 dt.19-11-2026
15/108
For the Respondent/s : Ms. Dimpal Kumari AC to G.P.-20
(In Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No. 15225 of 2026)
For the Petitioner/s : Mr. Prince Kumar Mishra, Adv
For the Respondent/s : Mr. Addl. Advocate General (02)
(In Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No. 15265 of 2026)
For the Petitioner/s : Mr. Onkar Kumar, Adv
For the Respondent/s : Mr. Standing Counsel (11)
(In Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No. 15292 of 2026)
For the Petitioner/s : Mr. Keshab Raj, Adv
For the Respondent/s : Mr. Additional Advocate General (16)
======================================================
CORAM: HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE RITESH KUMAR
CAV JUDGMENT
Date : 19-11-2026
1. Heard the learned counsel for the petitioners in all
the cases and the learned counsel appearing on behalf of the
State in all the cases. The Secretary, Department of Higher
Education had also appeared in person on 05.10.2026, on the
request made by this Court, to the learned Counsel for the State
to request the Secretary for appearing on 05.10.2026, for
answering to some queries in the mind of this Court, specially
the query that what will happen to the Surplus Teachers, who
did not give any option on the e-shikshakosh portal and what
will happen to the teachers, who are in the Dying Cadre, in the
present exercise.
2. Since the prayers in the present batch of writ
petitions are almost identical, therefore, with the consent of the
parties, the matters were heard together and judgment was
reserved vide order dated 05.10.2026.
3. In C.W.J.C. No.14944 of 2026, the prayer of the
writ petitioner is as follows:-

Patna High Court CWJC No.14944 of 2026 dt.19-11-2026
16/108
“a. For issuance of a writ in the nature of
Certiorari or any other appropriate
writ/order/direction to quash/set aside the
Letter No.1936, dated 22.06.2026 issued by
the Director, Primary Education,
Government of Bihar, Patna, whereby and
whereunder the standard setting (Manak
Nirdharan) of transfer and posting of
teachers at elementary schools has been
issued which creates large number of
surplus teachers at elementary schools and
the impugned letter is also in conflict with
the earlier standard setting (Manak
Nirdharan) for appointment and posting of
elementary teachers (For Class I to V and
VI to VIII), contained in Letter No.321,
dated 27.01.2025 issued by the Director
Primary Education, Bihar, Patna and which
is/was the basis of appointment and posting
of the Government Elementary School
Teachers recruited under TRE 3 by the
BPSC, Patna and the same standard had
been being adopted in earlier recruitment
and posting of teachers at elementary
schools.
b. Further For issuance of a writ in the
nature of Certiorari or any other
appropriate writ/order/direction for
issuance of writ/order/directions to
quash/set aside the Provisions contained in

Patna High Court CWJC No.14944 of 2026 dt.19-11-2026
17/108
Clause-5 and 8 (i) and (ii) of Memo No.797,
dated 21.07.2026 issued by the Deputy
Secretary, Education Department,
Government of Bihar, Patna, whereby and
whereunder guidelines for posting of
surplus teachers has been issued, which is
contradictory to each other of the impugned
provisions and the impugned memo is also
violative of the provisions contained in Rule
3 (ix) and (x) of the Bihar State Teacher
Transfer, Rules, 2026 (Annexure-P/11).
c. Further For issuance of a writ in the
nature of appropriate Mandamus or any
other writ/order/direction to stay the
impugned Letter No.1936, dated-22.06.2026
(Annexure-P/1) as well as Memo No.797,
dated 21.07.2026 (Annexure-P/2) till final
disposal of the instant writ application.
d. Further for any other order/ orders as
your Lordships may deem fit and proper in
the given facts and circumstances of the
case.”
4. In C.W.J.C. No. 14952 of 2026, the prayer of the
writ petitioner is as follows:-
“i. To issue a writ in the nature of Certiorari
or any other appropriate writ to quash the
arbitrary, illegal, and unconstitutional
action/order of the Respondents declaring
Petitioner a Surplus Teacher at Primary

Patna High Court CWJC No.14944 of 2026 dt.19-11-2026
18/108
School Lakhnauri, Ward 14, Block Paru,
District Muzaffarpur, despite her recent
valid posting there via mutual transfer on
18.08.2025 and in direct violation of
statutory student-teacher ratio norms, where
the current strength of up to 100 students
(66 registered on E-Shikshakosh) lawfully
mandates a minimum of 3 teachers, which
precisely matches the school’s existing
strength including the Petitioner and further
for a writ of Mandamus restraining the
Respondents from disturbing or transferring
her current posting during the pendency of
this case.
ii. For any other relief or reliefs to which
the Petitioner may be found entitled under
the facts and circumstances of the case.”
5. In C.W.J.C. No.14971 of 2026, the prayer of the
writ petitioner is as follows:-
“i. For issuance of writ in the nature of
Certiorari for quashing the impugned
notification contained vide MEMO No.797
dated 21/07/2026 issued by Deputy
Secretary, Primary Education, Patna,
whereby and whereunder standard operating
procedure for posting/transfer of surplus
teachers has been issued in blatant violation
of Rule 3 (IX) and (X) of the Bihar State
Teachers Transfer Rules, 2026.

Patna High Court CWJC No.14944 of 2026 dt.19-11-2026
19/108
ii. For setting aside Letter No.1936 dared
22.06.2026 issued by the Director, Primary
Education’ Government of Bihar, Patna
whereby and whereunder the standard
setting for transfer and posting of teachers
at elementary schools has been issued
without proper exercise in arbitrary and
whimsical manner, and creates large number
of surplus teachers at elementary schools in
Bihar and further the said impugned letter is
also in conflict with the earlier standard
setting for appointment and posting of
elementary teachers contained in letter
No.321 dated 27.01.2025 issued by Director
Primary Education, Bihar which was the
basis of appointment and posting adopted in
recruitment and posting of petitioners at
elementary schools.
iii. For commanding and directing the
respondents not to give effect to the
impugned notification contained in Memo
No.797 dated 21.07.2026, letter No.1936
dated 22.06.2026 and further not to take any
coercive action against the petitioners till
pendency of the present writ application.
iv. For any other relief/reliefs for which the
petitioners may be deemed entitled under the
facts and circumstances of the case.”
6. In C.W.J.C. No.15058 of 2026, the prayer of the

Patna High Court CWJC No.14944 of 2026 dt.19-11-2026
20/108
writ petitioner is as follows:-
“I. A writ in the nature of certiorari to
quash the resolution contained in memo
no.797 dated 21.07.2026 (Annexure-P/14)
issued by the Deputy Secretary Education
Department, Government of Bihar, as being
unconstitutional, arbitrary and violative of
Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution of
India.
II. A writ in the nature of Mandamus for
directing the respondents to refrain from
executing any coercive transfers or
rationalization listings (“Samanuyojan”)
under the criteria listed in Point 8 and Point
9 of the impugned notification dated
21.07.2026..
III. A writ in the nature of Mandamus for
directing the respondents to strictly protect
the postings of vulnerable categories,
including teachers with certified serious
illnesses. Physical disabilities, and those
accommodated under spouse-posting
guidelines, from being declared surplus.
And/or for any other appropriate relief(s) as
per facts and circumstances of the case.”
7. In C.W.J.C. No.15118 of 2026, the prayer of the
writ petitioner is as follows:-
“(i) For issuance of a writ in the nature of
Certiorari or any other appropriate

Patna High Court CWJC No.14944 of 2026 dt.19-11-2026
21/108
writ/order/direction to quash/set aside the
Letter No.647, dated 20.06.2026 issued by
the Director, Secondary Education,
Government of Bihar, Patna, so far it relates
to the petitioners, whereby and whereunder
the Standard Operating Procedure (SOP) for
posting of teachers at Government
(Rajkiya/Rajkiyakrit/Project/Upgraded/Newl
y Created) Secondary and Senior Secondary
Schools (For Class-IX-X and XI-XII) has
been issued which creates arbitrarily a large
number of surplus teachers at the above-said
schools. The SOP has been prepared/made
without any basis and also without
considering the object of quality education
of the children of the State of Bihar.
(ii) Further, For issuance of a writ in the
nature of Certiorari any other appropriate
writ/order/direction to quash/set aside the
Provisions as provided/directed in Clause-5
and 8 (1) and (ii) of Notification contained
in Memo No.797 dated 21.07.2026 issued by
the Deputy Secretary, Education
Department, Government of Bihar, Patna, so
far it relates to the petitioners, whereby and
whereunder guidelines for transfer and
posting of surplus teachers has been issued.
Clause-5 of the Guidelines says that
calculation of requirement of school-wise
teacher shall be on the basis of admission

Patna High Court CWJC No.14944 of 2026 dt.19-11-2026
22/108
taken by children/students in Sessions 2025-
26 and not the current Session 2026-27.
Clause 8 (i) of the Guidelines says that at the
schools where, teachers who are posted
since five or more than five years, the senior
most teacher shall be identified as surplus
teacher. Further, Clause 8 (ii) of the
Guidelines says that the schools where the
services of all the teachers who are posted
since less than five years, junior most
teacher shall be identified as surplus
teacher. These provisions are contradictory
to each other and the impugned memo is
also violative of the provisions contained in
Rule-3 (ix) and (x) of the Bihar State
Teacher Transfer, Rules, 2026 (Annexure-
P/10).
(iii) Further, For issuance of a writ in the
nature of Mandamus or any other
appropriate writ/order/direction to stay the
impugned Letter No.1936, dated-22.06.2026
(Annexure-P/1) as well as Memo No.797,
dated 21.07.2026 (Annexure-P/2) and also
direct the respondents not to disturb the
petitioner from discharging their duties at
his present posting place/school (Annexure-
P/12) till final disposal of the instant writ
application so far it relates to the
petitioners.
(iv) Further for any other order/ orders as

Patna High Court CWJC No.14944 of 2026 dt.19-11-2026
23/108
your Lordships may deem fit and proper in
the given facts and circumstances of the
case.”
8. In C.W.J.C. No.15225 of 2026, the prayer of the
writ petition is as follows:-
“(a) For issuance of an appropriate writ,
order or direction in the nature of certiorari
quashing and setting aside Letter No.1936
dated 22.06.2026 issued under the signature
of the Director, Primary Education,
Education Department, Government of
Bihar, Patna, whereby and whereunder the
standard setting (Manak Nirdharan) for the
posting of teachers at Government
elementary schools has been prescribed
afresh, thereby reducing the number of
sanctioned teaching posts and artificially
creating a large number of surplus teachers,
being in conflict with the earlier standard-
setting contained in Letter No.321 dated
27.01.2025 and being arbitrary, illegal and
violative of Articles 14, 16 and 21 of the
Constitution of India;
(b) For issuance of an appropriate writ,
order or direction in the nature of certiorari
quashing and setting aside the provisions
contained in Clause-5 and Clause-8(i) and 8
(ii) of Memo No.797 dated 21.07.2026
issued under the signature of the Deputy

Patna High Court CWJC No.14944 of 2026 dt.19-11-2026
24/108
Secretary, Education Department,
Government of Bihar, Patna, whereby and
whereunder guidelines for the identification
and posting of surplus teachers have been
issued, the said provisions being mutually
contradictory and being violative of Rule
3(ix) and 3(x) of the Bihar State Teachers
Transfer Rules, 2026, and being arbitrary,
illegal and violative of Articles 14, 16 and
21 of the Constitution of India, to the extent
they operate to classify the Petitioners as
“surplus teachers” and to identify them for
transfer/displacement from their respective
present schools on the strength of their
seniority:
© For issuance of an appropriate writ,
order or direction in the nature of
mandamus commanding the Respondent-
authorities to forbear from transferring,
displacing or disturbing the Petitioners from
their present schools by treating them as
surplus while permitting teachers junior to
them to continue in the very same schools;
(d) For issuance of an appropriate writ,
order or direction in the nature of
mandamus directing the Respondent-
authorities that any exercise of
rationalization/identification of surplus
teachers, if at all warranted, be carried out
strictly in accordance with Rule 3(ix) and

Patna High Court CWJC No.14944 of 2026 dt.19-11-2026
25/108
3(x) of the Bihar State Teachers Transfer
Rules, 2026, the norms under the Right of
Children to Free and Compulsory Education
Act, 2009, and the settled principle of “last
come, first go”. whereunder the junior-most
and not the senior teacher is liable to be
shifted from the school concerned;
(e) For issuance of an appropriate interim
order directing the Respondent-authorities
to maintain status quo, as existing on the
date of institution of the present writ
petition, with regard to the posting and
transfer of the Petitioners, during the
pendency of the present writ petition, in
parity with the interim protection already
granted by this Hon’ble Court in C.W.J.C.
No.12741 of 2026 and C.W.J.C. No.12326 of
2026;”
(f) For such other order or orders as Your
Lordships may deem fit and proper in the
facts and circumstances of the present case.
9. In C.W.J.C. No.15265 of 2026 th1e prayer of the
writ petitioner is as follows:-
“1) That this is an application for issuance
of an appropriate writ(s), order(s) for
commanding the Respondents to
delete/remove the name of the petitioner
from the list of Surplus teacher in Mahavir
Middle School, Gayaji on E-shikshakosh

Patna High Court CWJC No.14944 of 2026 dt.19-11-2026
26/108
portal and further restrain the respondents
from transferring the petitioner from
Mahavir Middle School, Gayaji to any other
schools on the ground of being classified as
surplus teacher.
And during pendency of this application
may restrain the respondents from
classifying the petitioner from being surplus
teacher as well as his transfer to any other
school from Mahavir Middle School,
Gayaji.”
10. In C.W.J.C. No.15292 of 2026, the prayer of the
writ petitioner is as follows:-
“1) For the issuance of an appropriate writ,
order, or direction, including a writ in the
nature of Mandamus directing the
respondents for incorporating provisions for
consultation with NCC Directorate Bihar &
Jharkhand while transferring NCC ANOs as
was directed through Notification No.4575
dated 29.10.1997 vide Para 4, as addition to
Rule 12, sub rule (e) IX..
( ) For the issuance of an appropriate writ, ⅱ
order, or direction, including a writ in the
nature of Mandamus for not to act on Letter
no.11(Ni)/Vi-33/2026 797 dated 21.07.2026.
(iii) For the issuance of an appropriate writ,
order, or direction, including a writ in the
nature of Mandamus granting interim relief

Patna High Court CWJC No.14944 of 2026 dt.19-11-2026
27/108
by staying the transfer of ANOs/petitioners
in the State of Bihar, till disposal of this
petition.
(iv) For grant of any other relief reliefs that
the petitioners may be found to be entitled to
in facts and circumstances of the present
case.
BRIEF FACTS
11. The case of the petitioners in C.W.J.C. No.14944
is that all of them were employed/appointed in the year 1994,
except the petitioner no.24, who was employed/appointed in the
year 1993, the petitioner no.25, who was employed/appointed in
the year 2002 and the petitioner no.26, who was
employed/appointed in the year 1993, on their respective posts
of regular teacher. Vide resolution no.1079 dated 20.06.2002,
the Government of the Bihar issued guidelines for employment
of Panchayat Shiksha Mitra at all the Elementary Schools in the
State of Bihar on a fixed remuneration of Rs.1500/- for 11
month. The guideline of 2002 was amended in the year 2004
and 2005 and accordingly the selection process was completed
in the year 2005. Subsequently, the Bihar Panchayat Elementary
Teachers (Employment/Appointment and Service Condition)
Rules, 2006 for employment/appointment of Panchayat and
Block Teacher was notified vide notification no.974 dated

Patna High Court CWJC No.14944 of 2026 dt.19-11-2026
28/108
01.07.2006. As per Rule 20 of the said Rules, the services of all
the Shiksha Mitra, including the petitioners, who were
continuing on their respective posts till 01.07.2006, were
deemed to be absorbed. The services of the teachers were to
continue up to 60 years of age. The remuneration of Rs.5000/-
was fixed for trained Block/Panchayat Teachers and Rs.4000/-
for untrained Block/Panchayat Teachers. In terms of the 2006
Rules, fresh advertisements were also published and the
employment/selection process was completed in the year 2007.
The petitioners were appointed in terms of Rules 2006 and have
given their respective joining, details whereof are mentioned in
Annexure-P/3 to the writ petition. Subsequently, 2006 Rule was
amended w.e.f. 25.08.2008. In the year 2009 for the purposes of
providing better education to the students, some amendments
were made in Rule 2006 and the same were notified in 2009
vide notification no.1056 dated 03.07.2009, wherein it was
provided that after completion of every three years (maximum
two time) Teacher Evaluation/Efficiency Test (Dakshta)
Examination will be conducted and a teacher who will fail in the
said examination twice, will be removed from his/her post. In
terms thereof, the examinations were conducted and all the
petitioners appeared and cleared the said examination. The

Patna High Court CWJC No.14944 of 2026 dt.19-11-2026
29/108
Government of the India framed the Right of Children to Free
and Compulsory Education Act 2009 (RTE Act 2009), which
was published on 26.08.2009 and came into effect from
01.04.2010. Rule 23 of the RTE Act provides for requisite
qualification for appointment and terms and conditions of the
services of the teachers. Vide notification no.61-03/20/2010
dated 23.08.2010 issued by the Ministry of Human Resources
Development Department, Government of India, the minimum
qualification for teacher was fixed, wherein the qualifying the
Teacher Eligibility Test (TET) was made an essential
qualification for a candidate desirous of being appointed on the
post of Elementary Teacher. In terms of the said notification of
the Union of India, the first T.E.T. was held in the year 2011 by
the State of Bihar, wherein the petitioners appeared and were
declared successful. Subsequently, the State of Bihar framed
new rules, which were notified on 03.04.2012 and the same was
named as Bihar Panchayat Elementary Teacher (Appointment
and Service Condition) Rules, 2012. A policy decision was
taken by the State of Bihar vide resolution no.1530 dated
11.08.2015 for fixation of payscale for the Local Bodies
Teachers and Librarians and accordingly the payscale of
Rs.5200/- 20200/- was granted to the petitioners and other local

Patna High Court CWJC No.14944 of 2026 dt.19-11-2026
30/108
bodies teachers working in
Primary/Elementary/Secondary/Senior Secondary Government
Schools with grade pay of Rs.2000/- for Basic grade (Trained)
Teacher and Rs.2400/- for Graduate grade (Trained) Teacher.
th
Some other benefits were also provided. The benefits of 7 Pay
Revision was also provided to the teachers at different local
bodies vide resolution dated 21.06.2017 and the payscale of the
petitioners and other teachers was also revised. Vide notification
contained in memo no.709 dated 21.08.2020, the Department of
Education notified new Rules, which was named as Bihar
Panchayat Elementary School Service (Appointment,
Promotion, Transfer, Disciplinary Action and Service Condition)
Rules 2020. Again, in 2023, the same was amended and notified
vide notification no.743 dated 10.04.2023. In terms of the 2023
Rules for appointment on the post of teachers at Government
Primary, Middle, Secondary and Senior Secondary Schools
through the recruitment process held by the Bihar Public
Service Commission, Patna. In terms of the 2023 Rules, some of
the petitioners i.e. petitioner nos.35, 59, 72 and 77 also qualified
the Teacher Recruitment Examination TRE-I, II, and III and
they joined on the post according to the Rule 2023. The Bihar
School Exclusive Teacher Rule 2023 was notified vide

Patna High Court CWJC No.14944 of 2026 dt.19-11-2026
31/108
notification no.2460 dated 26.12.2023, for granting benefits at
par with School teachers to the Local Bodies teachers after
passing the competency test to be conducted by Bihar School
Examination Board. All the petitioners qualified the said
competency test and gave their respective joining on the post of
Exclusive Teacher in terms of the 2023 Rules. Vide letter no.321
dated 27.01.2025 issued under the signature of the Director,
Primary Education the Standard Setting (Manak Nirdharan) for
posting of Elementary Teachers at Government Elementary
Schools was notified. It was provided that the standard posting
of teachers at Government Primary School (For Class-I to V)
will be Four (04) teacher for 01 to 120 students/children.
Likewise at Government Middle School (For Class-VI to VIII)
standard posting of teachers was fixed as four (04) teachers for
1 to 104 students/children. The appointment and posting of
teachers, who had qualified the TRE-III examination held by the
B.P.S.C. was done according to the standard setting dated
27.01.2025 and earlier posting of teachers was also made in
terms of the said notification dated 27.01.2025. Again, vide
letter no.1936 dated 22.06.2026 issued under the signature of
the Director, Primary Education, Government of Bihar, Patna a
provision/guideline for Standard posting of teachers at

Patna High Court CWJC No.14944 of 2026 dt.19-11-2026
32/108
Government Elementary School was notified. The standard for
posting of teachers at Government Elementary School has been
issued by which only two (02) teachers for 01 to 60 students at
Primary School has to be posted. The said letter also states that
at Government Middle Schools ( Class VI to VIII) only three
teachers (03) will be posted for up to 104 students and the post
of English teacher has been abolished in such school, where the
students are below 104. It also provides that if the numbers of
students will increase from 105-140 at the Government Middle
School, then an extra fourth teacher of English shall be posted.
It further provides that after increase in number of students from
140-175, the next extra teacher will be of Sanskrit or Urdu and
if the number of students will increase from 175, then as per the
requirement, teachers will be posted. Similarly, the letter dated
22.06.2026 also provides that at the Primary School, if the
number of students increases from 61-90, then one extra teacher
shall be posted and from 91-120 again one extra teacher will be
posted and then from 121-150 again extra teacher will be
posted. Thereafter, the number of teachers shall be increased on
every 30 students. In terms of the Rule notified on 22.06.2026,
the standard setting of transfer and posting of teachers at
Elementary School has been issued, which creates large number

Patna High Court CWJC No.14944 of 2026 dt.19-11-2026
33/108
of Surplus teachers at Elementary School and the said letter is in
conflict with the earlier Standard setting for appointment and
posting of Elementary teachers (For Class-I to V) and (Class-VI
to VII) which was issued vide letter dated 27.01.2025 and which
was the basis of appointment and posting of the Government
Elementary School Teachers, recruited under TRE-3 and the
same standard has been adopted in earlier recruitment and
posting of teachers at Elementary School. Subsequently, a
memo no.797 dated 21.07.2026 has been issued under the
signature of the Deputy Secretary, Department of Education,
Government of Bihar, Patna wherein the SOP has been issued
for implementation of the Rule notified, which is named as
Bihar State Teacher Transfer Rules 2026. As per the provisions
contained in Clause-5 and 8 (i) & (ii) of the notification dated
21.07.2026, the guidelines for posting of Surplus teacher has
been issued, which is contradictory to each other of the
impugned provisions and the impugned memo is also in
violation of the provisions contained in Rule 3 (ix) & (x) of the
Bihar State Teachers Transfer Rule 2026.
SUBMISSION ON BEHALF OF THE PETITIONERS
12. The learned counsel for the petitioner in C.W.J.C.
No.14944 of 2026 submits that after going through the Standard

Patna High Court CWJC No.14944 of 2026 dt.19-11-2026
34/108
setting dated 22.06.2026, it is clear that two posts of teachers of
Primary Schools (For Class-I to V) and one post of Government
Middle School (Class-VI to VIII) has been abolished, as
compared to the Standard setting dated 27.01.2025. He submits
that as per the Standard setting dated 27.01.2025, for number of
students in the range of 01-120, the Standard posting of teachers
was 04, however, the same has been reduced by the Standard
setting dated 22.06.2026, wherein for the number of students
between 01-60, the same has been reduced to two Standard
posting of teachers. Similarly, for the students in the range of
121-150 as per the Standard setting notified on 27.01.2025, five
teachers were required to be posted, whereas as per the Standard
setting dated 22.06.2026 for the student in the range of 61-90
only three teachers are required to be posted. He submits that
similarly, if the students were to exceed from 150 then as per the
Standard setting notified on 27.01.2025, one teacher upon every
40 students/children was required to be posted, whereas in terms
of the Standard setting dated 22.06.2026, if the students ratio is
in between 91-120, then four teachers will be required to be
posted. Similarly, for the Government Middle School, if the
number of students was/is in between 01-104, then in terms of
earlier Standard setting dated 27.01.2025, total four teachers

Patna High Court CWJC No.14944 of 2026 dt.19-11-2026
35/108
were to be posted, out of which one teacher was from Science
and Math, one from Social Science, one from language (Hindi)
and one from language (English). However, as per the Standard
setting notified on 22.06.2026, the same has been changed to
one teacher of Science/Math, one of Social Science and one
teacher of langue (Hindi) and if the number of students
increases to 105, then as per the Standard setting dated
27.01.2025, one teacher on every 35 students was to be notified,
whereas in terms of the Standard setting dated 26.06.2026, if the
number of students is in between 105-140 then one teacher of
English will be posted and if the number of students increases
from 140-175 then one teacher of either Sanskrit or Urdu has to
be posted and if the number of student increases to above 175,
then the teacher has to be posted as per requirement. He submits
that from bare perusal of the Transfer Rule 2026, it appears that
Rule 3(ix) of the Rules provides that generally the transfer of
teachers shall be taken place after completion of five years of
service and as per Rule 3 (x) of the transfer Rule 2026, such
teachers shall not be transferred automatically nor mandatory. It
also provides that in special circumstances, the competent
committee shall consider the case of transfer of a teacher, even
before completion of his/her five years of service, on the ground

Patna High Court CWJC No.14944 of 2026 dt.19-11-2026
36/108
of health, disability, husband-wife posting and other grounds
notified by the department. He submits that in other words, the
respondents have got no authority to compel any teacher for his
transfer/posting to another school. He next submits that as per
the provision contained in Clause-5 of the notification dated
21.07.2026, the calculation of students/children for Standard
posting of teacher will be done according to the admission of
children/student in the Session 2025-26, which may not fulfill
the object of the Standard posting of teachers, since admission
in Session 2026-27 has been taken and the classes are going on
and without calculating the students/children of Session 2026-
2027, therefore, the ratio of teacher/student cannot be fulfilled.
He submits that as per Clause-8(i) of the notification dated
21.07.2026, it has been provided that the teachers who were
posted at a school since five years or above, the senior most
teacher will be identified as Surplus teachers, however, on the
other hand, the impugned provisions contained in Clause-8 (ii)
of the notification dated 21.07.2026 provides that the teachers
who are posted for less than five years, the junior most teachers
will be identified as Surplus teacher. He submits that the above-
mentioned provisions are baseless and arbitrary and
discriminatory. All the petitioners have been appointed and

Patna High Court CWJC No.14944 of 2026 dt.19-11-2026
37/108
working on a vacant and sanctioned post and if there is any
Surplus teacher, according to the impugned letter dated
22.06.2026, then he/she should be those teachers who have been
appointed and joined on their respective posts without vacancy
and he/she should be identified as a Surplus teacher. He submits
that the notification dated 21.07.2026 has created several
discrepancies, such as due to non-consideration of admission of
students for the Session 2026-27, the object of standard posting
of teachers cannot be fulfilled, several teachers have been
identified as Surplus teachers, who have been transferred and
posted in the year 2025. As per the government policy, several
teachers, who have been transferred and have joined in the year
2025 at their transferred place on the grounds of health,
disability, husband/wife posting have also been identified as
Surplus teachers. Several teachers have been identified as
Surplus teacher, those he/she does not come under the category
of senior most teacher among the teachers posted for more than
five years, nor he/she comes under the junior most teachers
amongst the teachers posted for less than five years. A single
teacher of any of the subjects at Government Middle School has
also been identified as a Surplus teacher and teacher of
English/Sanskrit/Urdu have been identified as Surplus teacher

Patna High Court CWJC No.14944 of 2026 dt.19-11-2026
38/108
of Government Middle School, where the total number of
students is up to 105, even though there are students of such
subjects.
13. The learned counsel for the petitioners submits
that it is well settled principle that when a school has
extra/surplus teacher, the junior most teacher based on cadre or
service seniority is typically identified and adjusted or
transferred first. Therefore, the impugned provision contained in
Clause-8 of the notification dated 21.07.2026 is arbitrary and
discriminatory in nature. He submits that the Hon’ble Supreme
Court of India as well as this Hon’ble Court has consistently
held that teachers, who joined institution/school most recently
should be identified as Surplus first and moved first before the
senior staff. The adjust mentor redeployment must follow the
“last come first go rule”. The petitioners are working on their
respective post at their respective school since more than 10-20
years and a large number of junior teachers have been appointed
and posted at their respective school in between the year 2023 to
2025 and as such the respondents have to identify the
surplus/extra teachers among those teachers, who have been
recently posted, therefore the action of the respondents is in
violation of the fundamental rights, guaranteed under Articles

Patna High Court CWJC No.14944 of 2026 dt.19-11-2026
39/108
14, 16 and 21 of the Constitution of India. He submits that the
Primary grievance of the petitioners is with respect to the
process of rationalization undertaken by the State of Bihar,
whereby the teachers from the schools, where the number of
teacher is greater than the required, as per the pupil/teacher ratio
or prescribed standard, are being adjusted by identifying the
excess (being referred to as surplus teacher) and providing them
a voluntary opportunity to seek posting in such schools of their
choice, whereby the number of teachers is less than required, as
per the pupil/teacher ratio or prescribed standard. The entire
exercise is being carried out by the Education Department,
Government of Bihar through the online portal namely E-
shikshakosh, which digital platform is also used by the
teachers/headmasters of the schools and its officials for
managing school related information and administrative
function, such as marking daily attendance, making leave
application, maintain teacher profile and updating number of
students enrolled etc. He submits that so far as the pupil/teacher
ratio or prescribed standard for posting of a teacher is
concerned, the norms and standard for a school has been
prescribed at Schedule attached with the RTE Act, 2009.
Section 25 of the RTE Act, 2009 interalia, prescribes that within

Patna High Court CWJC No.14944 of 2026 dt.19-11-2026
40/108
six months from the date of commencement of this Act, the
appropriate Government and the local authority shall ensure that
the pupil/teacher ratio, as specified in the Schedule, is
maintained in each school.
14. The learned counsel for the petitioner in C.W.J.C.
No.14971 of 2026 submits that the petitioners were appointed as
Bihar School Exclusive Teachers (Vishisth Shikshak) in terms of
the Bihar School Exclusive Teachers Rules, 2023, after passing
the Statutory competency examination and in terms of Rule 3
(1) of the 2023 Rules, they constitute a distinct, unified District
Cadre. The petitioners have assailed the Standard Operating
Procedure which has been issued on 25.07.2026 and the forced
transfer order dated 08.09.2026. Under the pretext of Surplus
teacher rationalization, the Education Department deployed
automated algorithms on the E-Shikshakosh Portal to
unilaterally brand teachers as Surplus and forcibly displaced
them without declaring or publishing verified School wise
sanctioned units or cadre vacancy list. The automated portal
algorithm generated a staggering 1,06,287 Surplus designated
teachers State wise. Crucially, the States own counter affidavit
admits that total 33481 teachers i.e. 31.5% actively refused to
submit Portal options, exposing widespread rejection of this

Patna High Court CWJC No.14944 of 2026 dt.19-11-2026
41/108
coercive scheme and completely dismantling the States false
plea of a voluntary, choice-based transfer framework. He
submits that while issuing the notification dated 25.07.2026, the
State authorities violated the RTE Act/Rule 2010 and overriding
Statutory sanctioned post. He submits that under Section 25 read
with the Schedule of the Right of Children to Free and
Compulsory Education (RTE Act 2009) and the Bihar RTE Rule
2011, every school is statutorily mandated to have fixed budget
approved sanctioned posts/teacher units, not less than the pupil
teacher ratio. The impugned transfer rules and SOP issued on
25.07.2026 unlawfully attempt to override and bypass the
Statutory sanctioned post, without officially declaring/notifying
redetermined posts or legally altering them through due process.
The binding bench mark of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India
in a case reported in 2021 (17) SCC 1 ( Rajneesh Kumar
Pandey & Ors. VS The Union of India & Ors .) has been
violated wherein in paragraph no. 40 it has been held as under.
“40. Needless to observe that the norms and
standards, in particular regarding pupil-
teacher ratio, specified in the Schedule of the
2009 Act, are only to delineate the minimum
benchmark. It is open to the State
Government, being the appropriate
Government, to provide for a higher

Patna High Court CWJC No.14944 of 2026 dt.19-11-2026
42/108
benchmark for ensuring imparting of quality
education by the schools within its
jurisdiction. Further, besides the benchmark
specified in the Schedule or by the
appropriate Government, as the case may
be, it is always open to the school
management to appoint more teachers on
their own than the notified pupil-teacher
ratio, if they so desire, for ensuring
imparting of quality education to its
students.
15. The learned counsel for the petitioners further
submits that the judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of
India in the case of Rajneesh Kumar Pandey (supra) read with
paragraph nos.28, 34 and 64 of the said judgment authoritatively
held that maintaining the Statutory pupil teacher ratio (PTR)
under Section 25 of the RTE Act is an absolute Statutory
mandate and indispensable component of the fundamental right
to quality education under Article 21A of the Constitution of
India. The automated algorithm mechanically declared 6 out of
13 teachers as Surplus, which resulted in 46.1% of the faculty
being wiped out, resulting in collapsing the faculty to seven
teachers for 742 enrolled students. He submits that this explored
the PTR i.e. pupil teacher ratio from 57.1.1 to an
unconstitutional pupil teacher ratio of 106.1(3.5 times of the

Patna High Court CWJC No.14944 of 2026 dt.19-11-2026
43/108
RTE limit) and eliminated the schools sole Urdu and English
subject teacher. He submits that while routine administrative
transfer within an existing, identified sanctioned post is an
incident of service, however, transferring teachers against
unverified or non-existent vacancies is wholly illegal, as the
RTE Act mandates fixed sanctioned positions per school unit.
The State possess the authority to redetermine the sanctioned
post, but only through due Statutory process, objective
assessment and official notification, not through automated
portal algorithm or executive SOPs. He next submits that one
Mr. Nitesh Nath Tiwary was transferred to a destination school
without vacancy verification and his joining was officially
declined by the Principal of the concerned school, on account of
Zero sanctioned and Zero student enrollment for Music, leaving
the teacher stranded. He submits that as endorsed by the
Headmaster, Government Middle School, Mohanpur, no
redetermined school units or school vacancy matrix was ever
published or communicated to the school logins, before
executing forced Surplus tagging. Under Rule 22 (Central Rules
2010) and Rule 20 of the Bihar rules 2011, each school is a
distinct sanctioned teacher unit, with legally fixed post tied to
student enrollment and other conditions, reading the status of

Patna High Court CWJC No.14944 of 2026 dt.19-11-2026
44/108
the area and neighborhood of the school under Section 25 and
the Schedule of the RTE Act 2009. The State cannot declare an
individual teacher as Surplus via automated software algorithm
without first officially determining and publishing the updated
sanctioned unit for each school. He submits that transferring
teachers from established budget sanctioned posts into
unverified posts, without following the Statutory unit allocation
under Rule 20 (2011 Bihar Rule) and Rule 22 of the 2010
Central Rule renders the entire exercise ultra vires and
constitutionally void under Articles 14 & 21A of the
Constitution of India.
16. The learned counsel for the petitioner next
submits that the school operate with diverse cadres (Regular
Teacher (dying cadre), Niyojit Teachers, Exclusive/Vishisth
Teachers and BPSC TRE Teachers). He submits that the regular
teacher of dying cadre is non-transferrable post and as per the
vacancy position on 31.03.2026, no post is available. The
Niyojit teacher has been excluded from the present transfer
Rule, whereas Exclusive teacher of the dying cadre is
transferrable on vacancy, however no post is available as on
31.03.2026. Similarly, the school teachers appointed through
BPSC are transferrable and the same is ongoing recruitment. He

Patna High Court CWJC No.14944 of 2026 dt.19-11-2026
45/108
submits that the departments top down, random surplus tagging
fails to harmonize cadre structure or consult school heads,
leading to a situation, where single subject instructors are
arbitrarily declared Surplus and put in a provisional list. Under
Rule 3(1) of the Bihar School Exclusive Teacher Rule 2023, the
petitioners belonging to a unified Article 309 District cadre of
the Exclusive teachers. The E-Shikshakosh portal and the SOP
memo dated 21.07.2026 completely lack cadre wise vacancy
matrices. This unlawfully commingles Exclusive teachers with
local body Niyogit Teachers (explicitly excluded under Rule 2
(vii) of the 2026 Transfer Rules), rendering the transfer exercise
ultra vires and void ab initio. He next submits that the
petitioners belong to a unified District cadre of Exclusive
teachers. The SOP unlawfully commingles Exclusive teachers
with non-interchangeable cadres, such as local body Niyojit
teachers (explicitly excluded under Rule 2 (vii) of the 2026
Transfer Rules) and BPSC teachers. Similarly, Rule 3(2)
mandates that vacancies arising from retirement, resignation or
termination of Exclusive teachers are statutorily earmarked,
with a fixed percentage result exclusively for promotion of
serving Exclusive teachers (under Rule 9) and the remainder for
school teachers. Forcibly absorbing alleged surplus teachers

Patna High Court CWJC No.14944 of 2026 dt.19-11-2026
46/108
against these specific resulting vacancies illegally Cannibalizes
and wipes out the statutorily promotional channel of Exclusive
teachers. Similarly, Rule 7 mandates the prior
preparation/publication and finalization of District wise
seniority list and sanctioned vacancy chart, before executing
transfer. Initiating forced transfer without fulfilling Rule 7
renders the entire process ultra vires and void ab initio. The
Exclusive teacher’s cadre is a dying cadre, created exclusively
to absorb local teachers who passed competency test, with no
future direct recruitment.
17. The learned counsel for the petitioners further
submits that the SOP dated 21.07.2026 was issued in total non-
application of mind, triggering State wise chaos and coercive
litigation, whereby almost 33481/31.5% teachers have refused
the portal choice under duress. He submits that Clause-9 of the
SOP collides with Rule 10 of the Rule notified on 22.06.2026
(coercive choice submission). Furthermore, in a judgment
reported in 1975 (3) SCC 765 ( Madeva Upendra Sinai VS.
The Union of India , it has been held that the difficulty removal
powers under Rule 7 cannot be used ultra vires, to override
parent Article 309 Rules. Similarly, in a case reported in 2004
(11) SCC 402 (State of U.P VS. Gobardhan Lal) the Hon’ble

Patna High Court CWJC No.14944 of 2026 dt.19-11-2026
47/108
Supreme Court of India held that the doctrine of incident of
service does not insulate statutory violation and manifest
arbitrariness from judicial review under Article 226. He next
submits that Clause-8 of the SOP violates the established service
jurisprudence and the industrial law, which mandate the last
come first go principle in Surplus identification. Clause-8
creates a mutually destructive dual mechanism since Clause-8
(i) targets senior most teacher as Surplus teacher if posted for
5+years, whereas Clause-8 (ii) reverses the criteria to target the
junior most teachers, if all served under 5 years. Reversing
criteria purely based on crossing an arbitrary 5 years block
tenure is self-contradictory, manifestly arbitrary and violative of
Article 14 of the Constitution of India. He submits that Clause-9
of SOP dated 21.07.2026 collides directly with Rule 10 of the
2026 Transfer Rules, notified on 22.06.2026, unilaterally
branding teachers as Surplus on a public portal, forces them
under duress to fill up to 30 choices to avoid unguided, arbitrary
administrative displacement under Clause-9, if option fails. The
State cannot falsely portray forced option submission as a
voluntary transfer request. He next submits that as established
by the Headmaster’s official endorsement, Government Middle
School, Mohanpur, the State failed to determine, publish or

Patna High Court CWJC No.14944 of 2026 dt.19-11-2026
48/108
communicate school wise teacher units (staffing norms) or the
required deficit matrices to school logins, before executing
Surplus tagging. Conducting Surplus tagging in total opacity,
violates mandatory conditions precedents.
18. The learned counsel for the petitioner refers to and
relies upon a judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India
in a case reported in 2004 (11) SCC 402 (The State of U.P. VS.
Gobardhan Lal along with its analogues cases) , wherein the
Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in paragraph no.9 has held as
follows:-
9. “Even as the position stands, avenues are
open for being availed of by anyone
aggrieved, with the authorities concerned,
the courts and tribunals, as the case may be,
to seek relief even in relation to an order of
transfer or appointment or promotion or any
order passed in disciplinary proceedings on
certain well-settled and recognized grounds
or reasons, when properly approached and
sought to be vindicated in the manner
known to and in accordance with law. No
such generalized directions as have been
given by the High Court could ever be given
leaving room for an inevitable impression
that the courts are attempting to take over
the reins of executive administration.

Patna High Court CWJC No.14944 of 2026 dt.19-11-2026
49/108
Attempting to undertake an exercise of the
nature could even be assailed as an
onslaught and encroachment on the
respective fields or areas of jurisdiction
earmarked for the various other limbs of the
State. Giving room for such an impression
should be avoided with utmost care and
seriously and zealously courts endeavor to
safeguard the rights of parties.”
19. The learned counsel for the petitioner further
refers to and relies upon a judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme
Court of India reported in 1975 (3) SCC 765 ( Madeva
Upendra Sinai and Ors. Vs. The Union of India and Anr.
with its analogues cases), wherein the Hon’ble Supreme Court
of India in paragraph no.39 has held as under.
“39. To keep pace with the rapidly
increasing responsibilities of a welfare
democratic State, the Legislature has to turn
out a plethora of hurried legislation, the
volume of which is often matched with its
complexity. Under conditions of extreme
pressure, with heavy demands on the time of
the Legislature and the endurance and skill
of the draftsman, it is well-nigh impossible to
foresee all the circumstances to deal with
which a statute is enacted or to anticipate all
the difficulties that might arise in its working
due to peculiar local conditions or even a

Patna High Court CWJC No.14944 of 2026 dt.19-11-2026
50/108
local law. This is particularly true when
Parliament undertakes legislation which
gives a new dimension to socio-economic
activities of the State or extends the existing
Indian laws to new territories or areas
freshly merged in the Union of India. In
order to obviate the necessity of approaching
the Legislature for removal of every
difficulty, howsoever trivial, encountered in
the enforcement of a statute, by going
through the time-consuming amendatory
process, the Legislature sometimes thinks it
expedient to invest the Executive with a very
limited power to make minor adaptations
and peripheral adjustments in the statute, for
making its implementation effective, without
touching its substance. That is why the
“removal of difficulty clause”, once frowned
upon and nick-named as “Henry VIII
clause” in scornful commemoration of the
absolutist ways in which that English King
got the “difficulties” in enforcing his
autocratic will removed through the
instrumentality of a servile Parliament, now
finds acceptance as a practical necessity, in
several Indian statutes of post-independence
era.”
20. The learned counsel for the petitioner in C.W.J.C.
No.14952 of 2026 adopts the argument advanced by the learned

Patna High Court CWJC No.14944 of 2026 dt.19-11-2026
51/108
counsel appearing in C.W.J.C. No.14971 of 2026. She, in
addition thereto submits that without any rhyme and reason, the
Director Primary Education issued the impugned
provisions/guidelines for Standard posting of teachers at
Government Elementary School contained in letter no.1936
dated 22.06.2026 whereby the Standard setting for posting of
teachers at Government Elementary School have been issued.
She submits that despite the fact that the petitioners husband is
currently serving as a Headmaster at U.M.V. Harpur Kapdafaura
within the same block in the Paro district of Muzaffarpur, the
respondent authorities have acted in a completely arbitrary,
discriminatory and illegal manner by denying and omitting to
extend the benefits of husband-wife teacher category posting
policy to the petitioner during the transfer and Surplus
identification exercise, which is in direct violation of the State
transfer Rules meant to protect and accommodate working
teacher spouses. She further submits that even the National
Education Policy provides, that the teachers are seldom to be
transferred and this commitment, as incorporated in the said
Policy, is also being violated, affecting the teaching standards.
She submits that the State Government is required to revisit the
policies framed, which appears to be in violation of the object of

Patna High Court CWJC No.14944 of 2026 dt.19-11-2026
52/108
the Policy as well as Rules framed. She submits that the
declaration of the petitioner as a Surplus teacher is in direct
conflict with the student teacher ratio norms, the Bihar State
Teacher Transfer Rules and the principles of natural justice.
21. The learned counsel for the petitioners in C.W.J.C.
No.15058 of 2026 submits that the arbitrary, unconstitutional
and automated designation of petitioners as Surplus teacher
executed under notification dated 21.07.2026, without providing
the petitioners any prior notice, show cause opportunity or
physical verification of the school level metrics. He submits that
the petitioners are Regular/Exclusive teachers who have
completed more than five years of continuous, unblemished
service (more than 15 years) on a legally sanctioned posts in
different schools and under the guise of rationalization, the
respondents deployed an automated computer script on the E-
Shikshakosh Portal. This system unilaterally flagged the
petitioners as Surplus, based solely on an arbitrary mathematical
filter. Before declaring them Surplus, no show cause notice was
served, no verification of subject requirements was conducted
and no opportunity of hearing was granted. He submits that an
executive notification dated 21.07.2026 cannot override,
extinguish or run contrary to the mandatory provisions of parent

Patna High Court CWJC No.14944 of 2026 dt.19-11-2026
53/108
Statutory Rule, which was notified on 22.06.2026 named as
Bihar State Teacher Transfer Rules, 2026. Clause 5 (xi) of the
Statutory Rule explicitly mandates that prior to finalizing an
administrative or rationalization transfer, a notice must be
issued, giving the teacher a seven working day window to
submit an explanation. He submits that notification dated
21.07.2026 bypassed this Statutory guarantee by introducing an
instant automated classification, making it ultra vires to the
Statute. He submits that in the case of State of Karnataka Vs.
H Ganesh Rao the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India affirmed
that Executive instructions cannot manipulate or override
Statutory Rules. If a Rule specifies a mandatory procedure, any
notification that sidesteps that procedure, lacks legal
enforceability. Clause-8 of the notification uses two
diametrically opposed, irrational metrics to label a teacher
Surplus within the exact same school setup. The system selects
the teacher with the longest tenure, if it exceeds 5 years, but
completely flips to select the teacher with the shortest tenure, if
all the teachers are under 5 years. The petition rightly highlights
that this lacks a uniform governing standard (such as the
established legal standard of “Last Come, First Go”), making
the automated logic hostile, discriminatory, and devoid of any

Patna High Court CWJC No.14944 of 2026 dt.19-11-2026
54/108
rational nexus. The policy mandates that displaced male
teachers must be pushed outside their home blocks and female
teachers outside their home Panchayats. The notification leaves
a massive structural loophole where teachers who choose not to
participate or refuse to log into the online portal, are permitted
to remain comfortably within their home domains. The petition
highlights that this creates an unconstitutional distinction that
penalizes law-abiding employees, who actively engaged with
the system, while rewarding non-compliance, directly violating
the principles of equality under Article 14& 16 of the
Constitution of India. Under established service jurisprudence
(Article 14 & 16 of the Constitution of India), distinct cadres
with separate recruitment pathways, pay structures, and service
conditions cannot be clubbed together to calculate a common
seniority or Surplus metrics. The automated portal system in
Districts like East Champaran and Darbhanga has cross-
calculated Pupil-Teacher Ratio (PTR) by blending Exclusive
Teachers, who cleared the competency exam with newly
recruited BPSC TRE Regular teachers. Marking an Exclusive
Teacher Surplus based on the posting of a Regular BPSC
teacher, without clear cadre-segregated seniority Rules is legally
unsustainable. The notification attempts to run a combined

Patna High Court CWJC No.14944 of 2026 dt.19-11-2026
55/108
calculation of the Pupil-Teacher Ratio (PTR) by grouping
distinct teacher cadres such as Exclusive Teachers, who passed
the competency test and newly recruited BPSC TRE teachers.
Under service jurisprudence, different cadres with separate
recruitment Rules, pay structures, and service conditions cannot
be mixed to declare a particular individual Surplus. The
notification fails to define a clear, independent, cadre-wise
seniority mechanism for rationalization. No administrative
action carrying civil or professional consequences, such as a
compulsory rationalization transfer away from the current
school, can be taken without giving the employee an
opportunity to be heard. The respondents deployed an
automated online algorithm on the E-Shikshakosh Portal that
unilaterally designated the petitioner as a “Surplus teacher”. By
providing no prior notice, no show-cause window and no
opportunity to object before labeling them Surplus, the
respondents directly violated the principles of natural justice. In
case of Maneka Gandhi v. The Union of India (1978 SCC):
the Supreme Court ruled that even in purely administrative
actions, a fair opportunity to be heard is an indispensable
prerequisite and any order passed in violation of natural justice
is void ab initio. Administrative classifications must be based on

Patna High Court CWJC No.14944 of 2026 dt.19-11-2026
56/108
rational matrices and verified data, not arbitrary metrics. Clause-
8 of the notification features an irrational, self-contradictory
logic. It selects the teacher with the longest tenure, if it exceeds
5 years, but flips to select the teacher with the shortest tenure, if
all the teachers are under 5 years. This fluid approach abandons
the established legal doctrine of “Last Come, First Go”
(seniority-based retention). A classification system that reverses
its primary logic based on an arbitrary timeline, creates an
unstable environment that fails the test of a reasonable
classification under Article 14 of the Constitution of India. In
the case of E.P. Royappa VS. State of Tamil Nadu (1974
SCC), the Hon’ble Supreme Court has held that “Arbitrariness
is the antithesis of Article 14.” An administrative action that
ignores ground realities and functions strictly on an automated
mathematical filter is inherently arbitrary. The petitioner was
forced into a strict system deadline where a failure to submit 30
choices under Clause-8 would lead to arbitrary, random, long-
distance routing. Choosing a school to mitigate immediate harm
is administrative coercion, not voluntary consent or a waiver of
due process. In the case of Central Inland Water Transport
Corp. vs. Brojo Nath Ganguly (1986 SCC): the Hon’ble
Supreme Court has held that where an employee has no choice,

Patna High Court CWJC No.14944 of 2026 dt.19-11-2026
57/108
but to sign on the dotted line or comply with an unconstitutional
procedural setup due to unequal bargaining power, such an act
cannot be used to bar the employee from seeking judicial
remedies. The respondents cannot argue that the petitioner
accepted their Surplus status by filling out transfer choices on
the portal. The petitioner was forced into a “do-or-die” portal
environment were failing to input choices would result in
random, punitive administrative routing. Participating in an
online system to mitigate immediate harm constitutes
administrative coercion under protest, not voluntary consent or a
legal waiver of fundamental rights. A fundamental right to due
process cannot be waived under the threat of arbitrary
automated deployment.
22. The learned Counsel for the petitioner next
submits that an Executive instruction, circular, or guideline
(Notification No.797) cannot dilute, override, or extinguish
mandatory safeguards enacted within the Cabinet-approved
parent Statutory Rules (Bihar State Teacher Transfer Rules,
2026). Clause-5(xi) of the parent rules creates an absolute
statutory protection: no teacher can be transferred on
administrative/rationalization grounds without being served a
physical notice and granted an explicit 7working-day window to

Patna High Court CWJC No.14944 of 2026 dt.19-11-2026
58/108
submit an explanation. By executing immediate automated
profile changes, Notification No.797 directly violates and acts
ultra vires to its parent Statute. The absolute premise of this
litigation rests on the undisputed fact that no prior show cause
notice, no physical inspection report and no opportunity of
hearing was ever afforded to the petitioners to contest, clarify, or
dispute whether they were factually “Surplus” or not, before the
digital tag was finalized. The state is using mass punitive
rationalization (Samanu yojan) as a shortcut to fix systemic staff
imbalances. Teachers were legally appointed against sanctioned,
school wise units. Instead of resolving structural vacancies
through valid statutory promotions and cadre restructuring, the
department is uprooting settled teachers, which amounts to a
colorable exercise of administrative power. He submits that the
answering Respondents have heavily relied upon Section 25 of
the Right of Children to Free and Compulsory Education Act,
2009 (RTE Act) to mask an entirely arbitrary, colorable exercise
of administrative power. While the statutory goal of maintaining
an optimal Pupil-Teacher Ratio (PTR) is not disputed, the
execution under Memo No.797 dated 21.07.2026 violates the
very spirit of structured educational delivery. The dynamic
nature of the ongoing enrollment process for the Academic

Patna High Court CWJC No.14944 of 2026 dt.19-11-2026
59/108
session 2026-27, as admitted by the Respondents in Paragraph
no.12 of their Counter Affidavit, conclusively establishes that
the automated “Surplus” classification script was executed
prematurely. Labeling permanent, settled teachers as “Surplus”
while school wise enrollment numbers fluctuate day-by-day
lacks a rational nexus with the objective of educational
continuity. The Respondents have consistently failed to address
the core legal infirmity regarding the integration of separate
teacher cadres. The automated script deployed on the E-
Shikshakosh Portal cross calculates Surpluses by clubbing
“Exclusive Teachers” (Vishisht Shikshak), who were absorbed
into service via statutory competency tests, with newly recruited
“BPSC TRE Regular Teachers.” Under longstanding service
jurisprudence flowing from Articles 14 and 16 of the
Constitution of India, distinct cadres having separate
recruitment processes, historic pay matrices, and non identical
service conditions cannot be clubbed together to determine
common seniority or Surplus status. Blending these cadres to
displace senior Exclusive Teachers constitutes an
unconstitutional homogenization of unequals. The State’s
defense of Clause-8(i) and (ii) of Memo No.797 highlights its
fundamentally hostile and contradictory logic. Identifying the

Patna High Court CWJC No.14944 of 2026 dt.19-11-2026
60/108
teacher with the “longest tenure” if it exceeds 5 years, but
instantly flipping to target the one with the “shortest tenure” if
the institutional baseline falls below 5 years, creates a volatile,
unpredictable standard. This binary mechanism completely
discards the universally accepted service standard of “Last
Come, First Go” (seniority-based retention), transforming a
protective tenure framework into a tool of systemic harassment.
The Respondents’ assertion that the exercise is “purely
voluntary” because 72,806 teachers logged onto the portal is a
gross distortion of reality. The portal was designed as a “do-or-
die” system deadline. Teachers were forced to input preferred
choices under the imminent, systemic threat of random, punitive
long-distance routing. As settled in Central Inland Water
Transport Corp. v. Brojo Nath Ganguly (1986 SCC), actions
taken under an unconstitutional procedural setup due to unequal
bargaining power constitute “participation under protest” and
can never be construed as a voluntary waiver of fundamental
rights or due process. The reliance of the Respondents on State
of U.P. v. Gobardhan Lal (2004) is entirely misplaced. While the
judiciary normally refrains from interfering in routine
administrative transfers, the Hon’ble Apex Court explicitly
carved out exceptions where the administrative action is shown

Patna High Court CWJC No.14944 of 2026 dt.19-11-2026
61/108
to be completely arbitrary, ultra vires the parent rules, or in
blatant violation of the Principles of Natural Justice (Maneka
Gandhi v. Union of India). The present case squarely fits within
these judicial exceptions.
23. The learned counsel for the petitioners in C.W.J.C.
No.15118 of 2026 submits that the petitioners herein, in the
batch of writ petitions are either Exclusive Teachers or School
Teachers. School Teachers have joined on 16.11.2023 onwards
and Exclusive Teachers have joined on 01.01.2025 onwards on
their respective posts. It appears that Exclusive Teachers have
been identified as Surplus teachers in their respective schools,
on the basis of posting of their past/earlier services of more than
5 years as Local Bodies Teachers and School Teachers have
been identified as Surplus teachers on the basis of the principles
of “Last come, first go.” The petitioners are aggrieved by the
impugned Standard Operating Procedure (SOP) contained in
Memo No.647 dated 20.06.2026, which is the basis of creation
of Surplus teachers. The petitioners are further aggrieved by the
impugned Notification contained in Memo no.797dated
21.07.2026 by which the guidelines for identification of Surplus
teachers has been issued, which are not only directly infringes
upon the fundamental rights of the petitioners, but is also

Patna High Court CWJC No.14944 of 2026 dt.19-11-2026
62/108
affecting the quality of education of the students of the schools.
The learned Counsel for the petitioners submits that the SOP as
well as the Notification have been prepared and issued
arbitrarily and without any basis and as such are illegal,
erroneous, bad in law and also on facts. He points out some of
the discrepancies/illegality made by the Respondents in the
impugned SOP which are mentioned herein below:-
(i) From perusal of the Table No.01 (Page No.46 of
the Writ petition), which is for Senior Secondary Schools (For
Class-XI and XII), it is apparent that in the Faculty of Science,
the Respondents have decided to provide either a teacher of
Botany or Zoology, however, both the subjects are compulsory
for the students, who have opted Biology in Senior
Secondary/1.Sc. It means that a teacher of Botany will teach the
subject of Zoology to the students and vice versa, who has not
acquired the qualification of post graduate in Zoology subject
and vice versa. The qualification for a Post Graduate Teacher,
for Class-XI and XII, is that such teacher must be a Post
Graduate in the relevant subject. The SOP will directly affect the
quality education of the poor students and it is an artificial
creation of Surplus teacher for transfer and posting.
(ii) Further, it is apparent that the Respondents have

Patna High Court CWJC No.14944 of 2026 dt.19-11-2026
63/108
provided a teacher of either Sanskrit or Urdu, but there are
several schools, where there are the students of both the
subjects.
(iii) From perusal of Table No.03, it is apparent that in
the Faculty of Science, the Respondents have provided two (02)
teachers in the subject of Mathematics upto 140 students, but for
other subjects of Faculty of Science, Arts, Commerce and even
the teachers of Hindi and English, who teach the students of all
faculty, only one teacher has been provided, which creates extra
burden upon the teachers and which will affect/impact the
quality education of students.
(iv) From perusal of Table No.6 (Page No.62 of the
Writ petition), it is apparent that in the Faculty of Science, the
Respondents have provided three (03) teachers of Mathematics,
but, only one teacher has been provided for Physics, Chemistry,
Botany and Zoology upto 260 students.
(v) From perusal of Table No.7, which is for the
Secondary Schools (For Class-IX & X), it is apparent that the
Respondents have provided only eleven (11) teachers on or
above 420 students, however, there are several Government
(Rajkiya), Pro vincialized/Government Taken Over (Raj
kiyakrit) and Project Secondary Schools, where the numbers of

Patna High Court CWJC No.14944 of 2026 dt.19-11-2026
64/108
students in Class-IX & X are about one thousand.
24. The learned Counsel for the petitioners further
points out the discrepancies/illegality made by the Respondents
in the impugned Notification dated 21.07.2026 which are
mentioned herein below:-
(i) The Respondents have issued guidelines for
identification of Surplus teachers under Clause-8 (i), which is
against the well settled principle of “Last Come, First Go,” and
as such, the Respondents cannot mix-up the principle/criteria of
general transfer, with the transfer on the basis of Surplus.
(ii) The impugned Notification provides under
Clause-12 to 14 the stages of process for transfer and posting of
teachers i.e. (a)Transfer by
Adjustment/Proportionate/Randomization, (b) Mutual Transfer
and (c) General Transfer, but the Respondents have mixed the
process/stages of all kinds of transfer by starting the same at a
time.
25. The learned Counsel for the petitioner submits
that from a conjoint reading of Rule-3(ix) and 3(x) of the
Transfer Rules, 2026, it would transpire that all kinds of transfer
of teachers are optional and as such the right of teachers to opt
their schools for transfer would be up to the stage of his/her

Patna High Court CWJC No.14944 of 2026 dt.19-11-2026
65/108
joining at his/her transferred place/school, as there is no
provision, either under the Transfer Rules, 2026 or under the
impugned Notification. Clause-5.3 of the New Education Policy
says that the harmful practice of excessive teacher transfers will
be halted. Even though, the Respondents have made a general
and mutually massive transfer/posting in the year 2025 itself
and now again they have identified more than one lakh teachers
as Surplus teacher, on the basis of a baseless and arbitrary SOP.
The impugned guidelines for identification of Surplus teacher
does not clarifies that the Exclusive Teachers, who have joined
on 01.01.2025 and onwards, have been identified as Surplus
teacher, on the basis of his/her past services at their respective
school or on the basis of “Last come First Go.” Further, those
teachers who have been transferred and posted in the year 2025,
on the basis of their illness, disability, husband-wife posting,
some of them have also been identified as surplus teacher.
26. The learned counsel for the petitioners in C.W.J.C.
No.15225 of 2026 submits that appointment and posting of the
petitioners and of the Government Elementary School Teachers
recruited through TRE-3 was made in accordance with the
Standard Setting for Posting of teachers contained in letter
no.321 dated 27.01.2025 issued by the Director, Primary

Patna High Court CWJC No.14944 of 2026 dt.19-11-2026
66/108
Education, Department of Education, Government of Bihar,
Patna, which standard had consistently been adopted in the
earlier recruitment and posting of teachers at Elementary
School. Subsequently, the impugned letter no.1936 dated
22.06.2026 has been issued, by which the Standard setting for
posting of teachers at Government Elementary School has been
revised, prescribing that in a Primary School, only two teachers
shall be posted for 01-60 students and at a Government Middle
School, only three teachers shall be posted upto 107 students,
which is in stark reduction of the sanctioned strength, prescribed
under the earlier letter dated 27.01.2025, thereby abolishing
posts and artificially creating large number of Surplus teachers.
He submits that from a comparative reading of Standard setting
contained in letter dated 27.01.2025 and letter dated 22.06.2026,
it is clear that two posts at Primary school and one post at
Government Middle School have been abolished, in
consequence whereof teachers who were appointed and posted
against duly sanctioned and vacant posts have now been notified
as Surplus teacher, which is not permissible in the eyes of law.
He submits that rule 3 (ix) of the Bihar State Transfer Rule 2026
provides that ordinarily the transfer of a teacher shall be effected
only after completion of five years of service and Rule 3 (x)

Patna High Court CWJC No.14944 of 2026 dt.19-11-2026
67/108
provides that such transfer shall neither be automatic nor
mandatory and that only in special circumstances, such as
health, disability, husband-wife posting and other grounds
notified by the department, may the competent committee
consider the transfer of a teacher, even before completion of five
years of service. He submits that the respondent authorities have
got no authority to compel the transfer or displacement of
petitioners in a manner sought to be done. Clause-5 of the memo
dated 21.07.2026 provides that the calculation of students for
Standard posting of teacher shall be made on the basis of
admission of children in the Session 2025-26, which defeats the
very object of Standard posting of teachers, inasmuch as that the
admission for Session 2026-27 have already been taken and
classes are in progress and without reckoning the students for
the Session 2026-27, the teacher student ratio cannot correctly
be arrived at. He submits that the provisions contained in Clause
8(i) of the notification dated 21.07.2026 directs that where
teachers have been posted at a school for five years or more, the
senior most teachers shall be identified as Surplus, whereas
Clause 8 (ii) directs that where teachers have posted for less
than five years, the junior most teacher shall be identified as
Surplus. The said provisions are mutually contradictory,

Patna High Court CWJC No.14944 of 2026 dt.19-11-2026
68/108
arbitrary and discriminatory. The petitioners, who having
worked as Panchayat/Niyojit teacher for a considerable length
of time, therefore, having been appointed as Visisth Shikshak on
qualifying the Sakshamta Pariksha are being identified for
transfer/displacement from their present school and are being
classified as Surplus teachers, whereas persons who are junior to
the petitioners are being permitted to continue in the very same
school, which is arbitrary and discriminatory. He submits that
the impugned classification and consequent identification of the
petitioners as Surplus teachers is squarely in teeth of Rule 3 (ix)
and Rule 3(x) of the 2026 Transfer Rules and the settled
principle, that any exercise of identifying Surplus teachers and
effective consequent transfer, it is the junior most and not the
senior most person/teacher, who is liable to be shifted from said
school. The principles of “last come first go” has been given a
go by the respondent authorities in the present rationalization
process. He submits that the impugned action is also contrary to
the National Education Policy 2020, which expressly provides
that the teacher shall seldom be transferred, so as to preserve the
standard and continuity of teaching, therefore, the impugned
letter, the impugned memo and the exercise undertaken
thereunder, violate the said objects and commitment.

Patna High Court CWJC No.14944 of 2026 dt.19-11-2026
69/108
27. The learned counsel for the petitioner in C.W.J.C.
No.15265 of 2026 submits that as per Clause 8(i) of the SOP
issued by the Government for identifying the Surplus teacher in
the school, it has been provided that if more than one teacher are
posted in a school for more than five years, then the Surplus
teacher will be identified in descending order from the date of
his/her posting in the school. Meaning thereby that if a teacher
is posted in the school for more than 15 years, he will be
identified as Surplus teacher earlier then the teacher who is
working from less than 10 years in the said school. He submits
that the petitioner has been identified as a Surplus teacher by
the respondents in gross violation of the SOP, as one teacher
namely Amarendra Kumar, who is posted/working in the school
as Social Science teacher for more than 13 years has not been
identified as a Surplus teacher, whereas the petitioner has been
posted in the school since 14.05.2019 i.e. about six years and
one month and despite of his lessor posting period in the school,
the petitioner has been identified as a Surplus teacher. He
submits that the action of the respondents is dehors the Rules
and Regulations framed in this regard by the State Government
as well as the notification notifying the Standard Operating
Procedure (SOP) for implementation of the 2026 Transfer

Patna High Court CWJC No.14944 of 2026 dt.19-11-2026
70/108
Rules.
28. The learned counsel for the petitioners in C.W.J.C.
No.15292 of 2026 submits that the petitioners were duly
appointed teachers who have been serving as ANOs with NCC
units and were duly selected and nominated by their respective
Institutions, underwent rigorous pre-commission and orientation
training at the Officer’s Training Academy, Kamptee and were
commissioned as Associates NCC officers under the National
Cadet Corps framework. Considerable public funds, time and
Institution recourse were invested in imparting specialized
military and leadership training to the petitioners, so that they
could effectively train NCC Cadets and contribute to the
objective of character building, discipline, leadership, national
integration and youth development. The Bihar State Teacher
Transfer Rule 2026, under which trained Associate NCC
Officer’s (ANOs) are liable to be transferred from educational
institution having functional National Cadet Corps (NCC Units)
to the institutions were no NCC units exist. The said policy has
omitted the requirement of consultation with the NCC
Directorate, Bihar and Jharkhand, while effecting the transfer of
NCC ANOs in the State of Bihar. He submits that a specific
provision, requiring consultation with NCC Directorate at the

Patna High Court CWJC No.14944 of 2026 dt.19-11-2026
71/108
time of transfer of NCC ANOs has been incorporated on
29.10.1997, whereby under para-4, the said provision was added
to Rule 12 (e) IX. The said provision was incorporated in the
larger public interest. In 2023, the aforesaid policy, which
remained in existence for several decades, was arbitrarily
omitted by notification dated 26.12.2023 named as the Bihar
School Exclusive Teachers Rule 2023. There remained no
provision requiring consultation with the NCC Directorate at the
time of transfer of NCC ANOs. In view of the aforesaid
circumstances the NCC Directorate, Bihar and Jharkhand
approached the Additional Chief Secretary, Department of
Education, Government of Bihar, raising the issue concerning
the posting and transfer of ANO teachers serving in the school,
having NCC units vide its letter dated 08.04.2024. Without
considering the various objections and recommendations made
by the different Stake holders, the Department of Education
notified letter dated 25.06.2026, whereby the new Policy for
transfer of teachers was notified. Subsequently, a SOP has been
issued on 21.07.2026. In terms of the transfer Policy 2023 and
the new transfer Policy 2026, the petitioners have been made
liable to be transferred from institutions having functional NCC
units, to other institutions, where no NCC unit exists. The

Patna High Court CWJC No.14944 of 2026 dt.19-11-2026
72/108
transfer of the petitioners to a non NCC unit will frustrate the
Policy and merits of the petitioners and their scarce resources of
training NCC cadets/students will go in vain. The Associates
NCC Officer is not merely a teacher liable to be transferred
from one educational institution to another, in ordinary course.
The petitioners have undergone specialized training and have
been entrusted with specific responsibility relating to
functioning of NCC unit and the training, guidance and
development of NCC Cadets. The transfer of trained ANO from
an institution having a functional NCC unit, to an institution
where no NCC unit exits, would result in complete mismatch
between the specialized training and the responsibilities of the
petitioners and the institution, to which they may be transferred.
29. The learned counsel for the petitioners submits
that the requirement of consultation with the NCC Directorate,
which was earlier incorporated vide letter dated 29.10.1997, was
based upon a reasonable and practical consideration, namely, to
ensure that ANOs are posted and retained in institutions, where
their specialized services can be effectively utilized. The
omission of such a provision, without considering its practical
consequences, has resulted in the present difficulty. He submits
that the present Policy of transfer insofar as they permit the

Patna High Court CWJC No.14944 of 2026 dt.19-11-2026
73/108
transfer of ANOs from institutions having functional NCC unit,
to institutions, where no NCC units exists, is arbitrary and
unreasonable, as the same failed to take into consideration the
specialized role, training, experience and the responsibilities. He
submits that the transfer of the petitioners, if implemented,
would have direct adverse impact upon the functioning of the
NCC units and the institutions.
SUBMISSION ON BEHALF OF THE RESPONDENT STATE
30. The learned counsel for the State respondents
have filed only one counter affidavit i.e. in C.W.J.C. No.14944
of 2026. It has been submitted that the Common counter
affidavit answers the prayers made in all the writ petitions,
clubbed together. The learned counsel appearing on behalf of
the State in all the cases submits that as per Section 25 of the
Right of Children to Free and Compulsory Education Act 2009
(RTE Act 2009) “within six months from the date of
commencement of this Act, the appropriate Government and the
local authority shall ensure that the Pupil-Teacher Ratio, as
specified in the Schedule is maintained in each school”. Norms
and Standard for school has been prescribed at Schedule
attached with the RTE Act. The impugned memo dated
22.06.2026 is in complete consonance with the Schedule of the
RTE Act. He submits that the present exercise of identifying

Patna High Court CWJC No.14944 of 2026 dt.19-11-2026
74/108
Surplus teachers/rationalization of teachers is being carried out
as per the provisions contained in the Bihar State Teachers
Transfer Rules 2026, which has been framed in exercise of the
powers conferred under the proviso to Article 309 of the
Constitution of India and the Right of Children to Free and
Compulsory Education Act 2009. The petitioners have not
demonstrated in any manner, as to how the impugned memo
dated 22.06.2026 is in violation of their fundamental rights or
otherwise not tenable in the eyes of laws. He submits that the
Bihar State Teacher Transfer Rules 2026 was framed in
accordance with the provision of the RTE Act 2009. Rule 2
(xviii) defines “Schools having Teacher-deficit” to mean a
school where teacher availability is not in accordance with the
norms, RTE/PTR standard, class wise requirement or subject
wise requirement, prescribed by the Department. Rule 2 (xix)
which is “Relatively Surplus school” (i.e. Schools having
Surplus teachers) to mean a school where teacher availability is
found to be more than the norms prescribed by the Department
or other applicable norms. Rule 2 (xx) defines
adjustment/rationalization to mean transfer/posting of teachers
from schools having Surplus teacher, to schools having teacher
deficit on the basis of norms, RTE/PTR standard, class wise

Patna High Court CWJC No.14944 of 2026 dt.19-11-2026
75/108
requirement, subject wise requirement and other applicable
departmental norms, prescribed by the Department, so as to
balance the school wise teacher availability and ensure
educational interest of the students, continuity of teaching,
learning and smooth functioning of schools. Similarly, Rule 2
(xxiv) and Rule 2 (xxv) defines ‘general transfer’ and ‘mutual
transfer’ respectively. The grievance of the petitioners in the
present batch of writ petitions are with respect to Clause-5 and 8
of memo no.797 dated 21.07.2026, which concerns the process
of adjustment/rationalization. Rule-3 of 2026 Rules interalia
prescribes general principles for transfer. Rule-3 (iii) prescribes
that any transfer may be done subject to the Standard norms
(manak mandal) and Standard Operating Procedure (SOP)
issued by the Department for its implementation from time to
time. Rule-3 (ix) prescribes that the transfer of teachers may
generally be done at every 5 years of their respective service.
Rule-3 (xvii) interalia prescribes that all types of transfer shall
be done through the Departmental portal. Rule-3 A prescribes
provisions with respect to adjustment/rationalization. Rule 3-A
(i) prescribes that the department may identify schools having
teacher deficit and schools having Surplus teacher on the basis
of Standard norms, RTE/PTR Standards, class wise requirement,

Patna High Court CWJC No.14944 of 2026 dt.19-11-2026
76/108
subject wise requirement and other departmental norms. Rule-3
A (ii) prescribes that the adjustment/rationalization of teachers
from school having Surplus teachers, to schools having teacher
deficit shall be done, subject to the requirement of the school,
available vacancy, class wise requirement, school wise
requirement, administrative requirement and the educational
interest of the students. Rule-3 A (iii) prescribes that the process
of adjustment/rationalization shall be done on the basis of
updated data available on the departmental portal, teacher
profile, school wise teacher availability, vacancy, Surplus/deficit
position and applicable norms. Rule 3-A (iv) prescribes that the
identification and prioritization of teachers for
adjustment/rationalization, wherever applicable, shall be done as
per the marks-based system mentioned in Annexure-1 of the
2026 Rules and as per the Standard Operating Procedure (SOP)
issued by the Department from time to time. Rule-3 A (v)
prescribes that such adjustment/rationalization shall be done in
such a manner that the minimum prescribed teacher strength,
RTE/PTR norms, availability of essential subjects and
continuity of teaching-learning in a school are not adversely
affected. Rule-3 A (vi) prescribes that eligibility for
adjustment/rationalization, determination of priority, issue of

Patna High Court CWJC No.14944 of 2026 dt.19-11-2026
77/108
orders, joining, release and other procedural matters may be
specified by the Department through guidelines/Standard
Operating Procedure (SOP) as required. He further submits that
Annexure-1 attached along with the 2026 Rules lays out a
transparent mechanism to be applicable in all cases of
transfer/posting under the Rules where it is necessary to
determine the seniority or priority among more than one eligible
teacher The seniority among eligible teachers in transfer and
posting is prescribed to be determined on the basis of a
transparent, objective and marks based system, consisting of
service marks, place of posting marks and seniority/preference
marks. The marks-based seniority list provides an objective
basis for prioritizing teachers eligible for transfer. The “transfer
marks” is prescribed to be a sum total of “place of posting
marks”, “service marks” and “seniority/preference marks”.
Appropriate procedure for calculation of marks under each head
is also prescribed. The petitioners have not challenged the said
process of calculation of transfer marks. Rule-7 of the Rules
2026, prescribes that in case of difficulty in implementation of
the provisions of the Rules, the power to remove such
difficulties has been vested with the Education Department by
way of notification/order. The impugned memo no.797 dated

Patna High Court CWJC No.14944 of 2026 dt.19-11-2026
78/108
21.07.2026 has been issued in exercise of Rule-7 of the 2026
Rule. The issuance of the said memo dated 21.07.2026 is in
consonance with the other provisions of the 2026 Rules,
particularly, Rule-3 (iii), 3 A (iv) and 3 A (vi), which interalia,
prescribes that SOP may be issued by the department from time
to time, for carrying out the process of
transfer/adjustment/rationalizationas per the prescribed Rules.
31. The learned Counsel for the State next submits
that the petitioners have miserably failed to demonstrate as to
how the said memo dated 21.07.2026 is ultra vires or otherwise
not tenable in the eyes of law. Further, Rule-10 interalia
prescribes that upon coming into force of the Rules, all
applications with respect to transfer shall be made online.
Applications received via any other channel shall not be
accepted. Rule-12 prescribes that the provisions of the 2026
Rules shall prevail over earlier Rules, Resolutions and orders
with respect to transfer. He submits that so far, the contention of
the petitioners with respect to Clause-5 of the memo dated
21.07.2026 is concerned, the identification of School having
Teacher-deficit and School having Surplus Teacher is dependent
upon the actual number of students enrolled and the teachers
deployed in a particular school. The enrollment of students in

Patna High Court CWJC No.14944 of 2026 dt.19-11-2026
79/108
the Government Elementary Schools for the academic session
2026-27 is ongoing, therefore, Clause-5 prescribes Academic
Session 2026-27 as the basis for calculation of requirement of
teachers in a particular school, as per the prescribed norms. The
same is in consonance with Rule-3 A (ii) of the 2026 Rules. The
petitioners have not demonstrated that the choice of Session
2025-26 is actuated by any wrong consideration or that it has
been adopted specifically against the petitioners. So far, the
contention of the petitioners with respect to Clause-8 (i) and (ii)
of the memo no.797 dated 21.07.2026 is concerned, the same is
in consonance with Rule-3 (ix) of the 2026 Rules, which states
that the transfer of teachers may generally be done at every 5
years of their respective services. Clause-8 (i) prescribes that a
teacher posted in the concerned school for a period of five years
or more shall be considered as Surplus teacher. If the number of
teachers with a posting period of five years or more is more than
one, then the teacher with the longest tenure/posting period shall
be identified as the Surplus teacher. The same is in consonance
with Rule-3 (ix) of the 2026 Rules. Similarly, Clause-8 (ii)
prescribes that in a situation where the posting period of all
teachers under Surplus category in a school is less than five
years, the teacher with the shortest tenure in that school shall be

Patna High Court CWJC No.14944 of 2026 dt.19-11-2026
80/108
identified as the Surplus teacher. This provision has been
prescribed to attain the prescribed objective of meeting the
requirement of the teacher deficit school, standard norms,
teacher requirement norms, administrative exigencies and in the
academic interest of the students.
32. The learned Counsel for the State further submits
that memo dated 21.07.2026 also does not contemplate that an
identified Surplus teacher would simply be shifted to any place
at the unfettered discretion of the Respondents. Clause-9
provides an opportunity to the Surplus teacher to indicate from
amongst the schools, having teacher deficit through the
departmental portal, subject to the prescribed limit. The memo
No.797 further contains safeguards against an arbitrary
transfer/selection of the destination of an identified Surplus
teacher. The mechanism provides for the concerned Surplus
teacher to indicate preferences from amongst the schools having
deficit teachers through the departmental portal, subject to the
prescribed conditions. In the present exercise of identification of
Surplus teacher, a total of 1,06,287 (One lakh six thousand two
hundred eighty-seven only) teachers were identified as Surplus
teachers, however, only 72,806 (Seventy-two thousand eight
hundred six only) teachers from among the identified Surplus

Patna High Court CWJC No.14944 of 2026 dt.19-11-2026
81/108
teachers have opted for their transfer, as per their sequence of
choice. Moreover, Clause-9 interalia, specifically provides that
if the Surplus teacher is transferred/posted in any of the school
options given by him within the District, then he shall be
transferred to the said school, otherwise, the concerned teacher
shall continue to work in the present school/the school where he
is working, until a decision is taken in this regard by the
competent authority. The entire scheme clearly demonstrates
that the option of transfer, upon being identified as Surplus
is/was purely voluntary and as such only 72,806 (Seventy-two
thousand eight hundred six only), out of 1,06,287 (One lakh six
thousand two hundred eighty-seven only) Surplus teachers have
applied for their transfer. As the entire scheme is based on
voluntary exercise of choice for transfer by the surplus teachers,
no adverse action in the nature of forceful transfer shall be taken
with respect to those teachers, who could not be allotted any
school. from among the choices provided by them in the current
Academic Session. The impugned exercise is also consistent
with the broader object of ensuring proper teacher availability
amongst Government Schools. The object of maintaining
teachers in a Government School is ultimately connected with
the educational needs of the children studying therein. The

Patna High Court CWJC No.14944 of 2026 dt.19-11-2026
82/108
learned Counsel for the State submits that in order to
demonstrate the said scheme of rationalization, the Respondents
have brought on record two examples from amongst the
petitioners i.e. petitioners no.26 and 81 of C.W.J.C. No.14944 of
2026. He submits thatso far, the petitioner no.26 Suresh Singh is
concerned, he was initially posted as a Class-1-V teacher at
Primary School, Bhika Chhapar, Block-Bhore, District-
Gopalganj. In the said school, total number of students in Class-
I-V in the Academic Session 2025-26 are/were 50 only. There
were 3 teachers posted in the said school. As per the norms, the
required number of teachers in the said school shall be 02 only
and in such a situation, one teacher, who was posted in the said
school for the longest period (more than five years) has been
identified as Surplus teacher, as per the prescribed Rules and
Notification. In case of the petitioner no.26, he was posted there
for more than 32 years. Upon receiving his voluntary request for
transfer, he was transferred to Primary School Kateya Raj,
Block Kateya, District-Gopalganj, which was his first choice,
out of the two choices submitted by him for transfer.
Similarly,so far, the petitioner no.81 Sumit Kumar Rai is
concerned, he was initially posted as a Class-VI-VIII Hindi
teacher at Upgraded Middle School, Saurahan Block-Vijaipur,

Patna High Court CWJC No.14944 of 2026 dt.19-11-2026
83/108
District-Gopalganj. In the said school, total number of students
in Class-VI-VIII in the Academic Session 2025-26 are/were
only 100. There were 2 Hindi teachers for Class VI-VIII, posted
in the said school. As per the norms, the required number of
Language teacher in the said school is 01 only. Therefore, one
Hindi Class-VI-VIII teacher, who was posted in the said school
for the longest period (more than five years) has been identified
as a Surplus teacher, as per the prescribed Rules and
Notification. In case of the petitioner no.81, he was posted there
for a period of approximately more than 12 years and upon
receiving his voluntary request for transfer, he was accordingly
transferred to Upgraded Middle School, Pratappur (M) Block-
Manjha, District-Gopalganj, which was his only choice for
transfer.
33. The learned Counsel for the State further submits
that the petitioner’s contention based upon the fact that they
have been serving for several years, also does not create an
indefeasible right to them, to remain in the same school. Length
of service may be relevant in matters specifically governed by
seniority, but it cannot override the State’s objective to
rationally distribute available teachers to the available schools.
The principle, that transfer is ordinarily an incident of service

Patna High Court CWJC No.14944 of 2026 dt.19-11-2026
84/108
and that an employee does not acquire an indefeasible right to
remain posted at a particular place, is equally relevant to the
present matter. The petitioners right, if any, is to continue in
service in accordance with the applicable service Rules, it
cannot automatically extend to a perpetual right to remain at the
same school, notwithstanding a subsequent determination of
teacher requirement. He submits that in the case of Gobarhan
Lal (supra) the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India has held that
transfer is an incident of service and that an employee cannot
claim a right to remain at a particular place, merely because he
or she has been posted there. The Hon’ble Supreme Court has
further held that interference with an order of transfer is not
ordinarily warranted, unless the action is shown to be vitiated by
malafide, violation of a statutory provision or exercise of power
by an incompetent authority. The Hon’ble Supreme Court of
India has further cautioned that Courts should not act as an
appellate authority over administrative transfer decisions or
substitute its own assessment of administrative requirements for
that of the competent authority. Allegations of malafide must
also be supported by concrete material and cannot rest merely
upon allegations. The present cases involve exactly an
administrative exercise of determining the requirement of

Patna High Court CWJC No.14944 of 2026 dt.19-11-2026
85/108
teachers and rationalizing their post. He submits that the
petitioner’s contention that the impugned exercise is contrary to
the educational interest of the children is not tenable, since the
object of determining appropriate staffing in a Primary and
Middle school level is precisely to ensure rational and effective
deployment of available teachers. A system in which some
schools have teacher in excess of their assessed requirement,
while other schools remain deficient, cannot be justified, merely
by reference to a historical posting of individual teachers.
Rationalization seeks to correct such imbalance. He submits
that the entire exercise in this regard is being carried out by the
Department through an online portal namely E-shikshakosh,
which is a digital platform, used by the teachers, the
headmasters, the schools and the officials for managing school
related information and administrative functions such as
marking daily attendance, marking leave applications,
maintaining teacher profile and updating number of students
enrolled etc. He submits that the entire exercise has been carried
out in terms of the Transfer Rules 2026 and the SOP. The
teachers who have been identified as Surplus teacher, an
opportunity was granted to them to provide a choice of
maximum 30 schools, where they can/may be transferred in the

Patna High Court CWJC No.14944 of 2026 dt.19-11-2026
86/108
process of rationalization. The option/choice was to be given
voluntarily and no teacher was forced to submit the choice for
transfer by any means. The teachers, who opted for their
voluntary transfer were allotted the schools as per the choices
provided by them, however, later on many of the teachers have
assailed the notification contained in memo no.1936 dated
22.06.2026, memo no.647 dated 20.06.2026 and different
Clauses of the SOP dated 21.07.2026. He submits that since the
entire scheme is based on voluntary exercise of choice for
transfer by the Surplus teachers, no adverse action in the nature
of forceful transfer shall be taken with respect to those teachers,
who could not be allotted any school, from amongst the choices
provided by them in the current Academic Session. He submits
that so far, the contention of the petitioners that the Exclusive
Teachers belongs to the dying carder and may not be transferred
in the exercise as in the present case is concerned, the
declaration of the post as a dying cadre does not make the post
school specific and ineligible for transfer. In this regard the
Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in a case reported in 2022 (17)
SCC 420 (The State of Bihar Vs. Shyama Nandan Mishra)
examined the restrictions imposed on transfer between Sub-
cadres and the consequences of treating one Sub-cadre as a

Patna High Court CWJC No.14944 of 2026 dt.19-11-2026
87/108
dying cadre. He submits that on the basis of the submissions
made above, the challenge made by the petitioners against the
action of the respondent authorities is devoid of any merit and
the writ petitions are fit to be dismissed.
CONSIDERATION/ANALYSIS
34. Having heard the learned counsels for the
petitioners as well as the learned Counsels for the State in all the
writ petitions and after going through the records, the primary
issue which arises for consideration in the present batch of writ
petitions are that whether the identification of Surplus teachers
by the Education Department, Government of Bihar, on the
basis of the revised Standard setting contained in Letter
No.1936 dated 22.06.2026 and the guidelines contained in
Memo No.797 dated 21.07.2026, is contrary to the provisions of
the Right of Children to Free and Compulsory Education Act,
2009 and whether Clause-5, 8(i) and 8(ii) of the SOP are,not in
consonance with the Bihar State Teachers Transfer Rules, 2026.
35. First of all, it would be appropriate to examine the
Statutory object underlying the exercise undertaken by the State
Government. The Right of Children to Free and Compulsory
Education Act, 2009 (hereinafter referred to as the ‘RTE Act,
2009’) imposes a Statutory obligation upon the appropriate

Patna High Court CWJC No.14944 of 2026 dt.19-11-2026
88/108
Government and the local authority to ensure that the prescribed
Pupil-Teacher Ratio (PTR) is maintained in every school.
Section 25 of the said Act, read with the Schedule appended
thereto, prescribes the minimum norms and standards relating to
the availability of teachers in elementary schools. The object of
prescribing such norms is not merely to ensure the appointment
of teachers in a particular school, but to ensure that every child
receives the benefit of adequate teaching facilities and that no
school is deprived of the requisite number of teachers.
Therefore, the availability of teachers must necessarily be
examined at the level of individual schools and in the context of
the actual strength of students, class wise and subject wise
requirements. The aforesaid statutory obligation cannot be
understood as conferring upon an individual teacher an
indefeasible right to remain posted in a particular school,
irrespective of the actual requirement of teachers in that
Institution. The primary consideration in determining the
deployment of teachers must remain the educational interest of
the children. Where a particular school has teachers in excess of
its assessed requirement, whereas another school is functioning
with an inadequate number of teachers, the State Government
would be justified in undertaking a rationalization exercise,

Patna High Court CWJC No.14944 of 2026 dt.19-11-2026
89/108
provided the same is carried out in accordance with the
applicable statutory provisions and does not result in violation
of the prescribed Pupil-Teacher Ratio.
36. In this regard, the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India
in the case of Rajneesh Kumar Pandey &Ors. (Supra), while
considering the norms and standards prescribed under the RTE
Act, 2009, in paragraph no.40 observed that the norms and
standards, in particular regarding the Pupil-Teacher Ratio,
specified in the Schedule are intended to prescribe a minimum
benchmark and that it is open to the State Government to
provide for a higher benchmark to ensure quality education.
37. The aforesaid principle makes it clear that the
State Government is competent to prescribe appropriate staffing
standards in furtherance of the object of imparting quality
education. The Statutory norms under the RTE Act, 2009
constitute the minimum requirements and cannot be treated as a
restriction upon the State Government from undertaking a
rational and reasonable exercise for determining the actual
requirement of teachers in different schools.
38. It would also be relevant to notice the provisions
of the Bihar State Teachers Transfer Rules, 2026. Rule 2(xviii)
defines a school having teacher deficit with reference to the

Patna High Court CWJC No.14944 of 2026 dt.19-11-2026
90/108
prescribed departmental norms, RTE/PTR standards, class wise
requirements and subject wise requirements. Rule 2(xix) defines
a relatively surplus school as a school where the availability of
teachers is more than the prescribed norms. Rule 2(xx) provides
for adjustment/rationalization of teachers from relatively surplus
schools, to the schools having a shortage of teachers, with a
view to balancing school wise teacher availability and ensuring
the educational interest of students, continuity of teaching-
learning and smooth functioning of schools. Rule 3 of the 2026
Rules further lays down the general principles governing
transfer and posting of teachers. In particular, Rule 3(i) makes
the educational interest of students, continuity of teaching-
learning and smooth functioning of the schools, the foremost
considerations in matters of transfer and posting. Rule 3(ii)
expressly provides that transfer cannot be claimed as a matter of
right. Rule 3(ix) provides that transfer of teachers may generally
be undertaken after every five years of their service. Rule 3(x)
further provides that transfer may be considered after
completion of the minimum prescribed service period, but such
transfer shall neither be automatic nor compulsory and shall
remain subject to vacancy, school requirements, prescribed
norms, administrative requirements and the academic interest of

Patna High Court CWJC No.14944 of 2026 dt.19-11-2026
91/108
students. Further, Rule 3-A specifically deals with
adjustment/rationalization. Under Rule 3-A(i), the Department
is empowered to identify schools having teacher deficit and
schools having relatively surplus teachers, on the basis of the
departmental standards, RTE/PTR standards, class wise and
subject wise requirements. Rule 3-A(ii) contemplates the
adjustment of teachers from surplus schools to schools having a
shortage of teachers, subject to the requirements of the school,
available vacancies, class wise and subject wise requirements,
administrative requirements and the educational interest of
students. Rule 3-A(iii) requires the exercise to be undertaken on
the basis of updated data available on the departmental portal,
teacher profiles, school wise availability of teachers, vacancies
and the existing surplus or deficit position. Rule 3-A(v), in
particular, safeguards the minimum prescribed strength of
teachers, the RTE/PTR standards, availability of essential
subject teachers and continuity of teaching-learning in every
school.
39. A conjoint reading of the aforesaid provisions
leaves no manner of doubt that the 2026 Rules expressly
contemplate a rationalization exercise, for ensuring a balanced
distribution of teachers amongst Government schools. The

Patna High Court CWJC No.14944 of 2026 dt.19-11-2026
92/108
identification of relatively Surplus teachers is, therefore, not an
exercise foreign to the Statutory framework. Rather, it
constitutes an essential step towards achieving the object, for
which Rule 3-A has been incorporated. The State Government
cannot be expected to maintain a situation in which certain
schools continue to have teachers in excess of their assessed
requirements, while other schools remain deficient in the
availability of teachers. Such an arrangement would defeat the
very object of the RTE Act, 2009 and the 2026 Rules, which
seek to ensure that the prescribed teaching facilities are made
available to children in every school.
40. Now coming to the challenge made to letter
No.1936 dated 22.06.2026, this Court finds that the earlier
Standard setting contained in letter No.321 dated 27.01.2025
was an administrative Standard, governing the deployment of
teachers at the relevant point of time. The mere fact that
teachers were appointed or posted in accordance with the earlier
standard does not create an indefeasible right in their favour to
insist that the same staffing pattern must continue permanently,
notwithstanding subsequent changes in student enrolment,
departmental requirements and the educational needs of
different schools. The State Government, being responsible for

Patna High Court CWJC No.14944 of 2026 dt.19-11-2026
93/108
the administration of its educational institutions, is competent to
review and revise the standards relating to the deployment of
teachers, provided that such revision remains consistent with the
minimum Statutory requirements and is not arbitrary,
discriminatory or contrary to the governing service rules.
41. In the present case, the petitioners have primarily
objected to the revised Standard setting on the ground that the
number of teachers prescribed for certain categories of
elementary schools has been reduced, in comparison to the
earlier Standard. However, a comparison with an earlier
administrative standard, by itself, would not render a subsequent
policy decision illegal. The relevant consideration is that
whether the revised standard is consistent with the Statutory
norms prescribed under the RTE Act, 2009 or not and whether it
ensures adequate availability of teachers, having regard to class
wise and subject-wise requirements. It is further required to be
noticed that the RTE Schedule prescribes minimum
requirements for elementary education, namely Classes-I to
VIII. With respect to Secondary and Higher Secondary schools,
the teacher requirement must additionally be examined with
reference to the subject wise availability and the Standards
prescribed by the Education Department in the 2026 Rules. The

Patna High Court CWJC No.14944 of 2026 dt.19-11-2026
94/108
Statutory RTE Schedule cannot be mechanically applied to
classes beyond its prescribed elementary school framework.
42. The contention of the petitioners that the revised
Standard setting has resulted in abolition of sanctioned posts,
also requires consideration. A revision of school wise staffing
norms and identification of relatively Surplus teachers, by itself,
cannot be equated with abolition of a cadre or termination of
sanctioned posts. The present exercise, as explained by the
State, is directed towards rational distribution of the available
teaching strength amongst schools, according to their actual
requirements. There is no material before this Court, at the level
of the common challenge, to establish that the impugned
rationalization exercise has resulted in termination of the
services of the petitioners or extinguishment of their substantive
status in service.
43. Accordingly, the revised standard setting cannot
be declared invalid, merely because it differs from the earlier
administrative arrangement. Needless to observe, however, that
the Department must ensure that any subsequent staffing
determination or consequential transfer does not violate the
applicable Statutory requirements or any binding service
condition.

Patna High Court CWJC No.14944 of 2026 dt.19-11-2026
95/108
44. The next issue relates to the validity of Clause-5
of Memo No.797 dated 21.07.2026, particularly with regard to
the Academic Session and the student enrollment figures, used
for determining the requirement of teachers in a school. The
petitioners contend that the exercise ought to have been
undertaken on the basis of the enrollment for the Academic
Session 2026-2027 and that the use of earlier enrollment figures
would result in an incorrect assessment of the Pupil-Teacher
Ratio.
45. The State, on the other hand, has submitted that
the exercise is based upon the academic requirements of the
relevant Session and the information available on the
departmental portal. In this regard, Rule 3-A(iii) of the 2026
Rules assumes importance, as it requires the rationalization
exercise to be undertaken on the basis of updated data available
on the departmental portal, including student strength, teacher
availability and vacancies.
46. Consequently, the choice of a particular Academic
Session cannot be considered arbitrary in isolation. What is
material is that the data relied upon must be verified and
sufficiently updated, before any consequential transfer or
posting order is issued. Any material alteration in student

Patna High Court CWJC No.14944 of 2026 dt.19-11-2026
96/108
enrollment or subject wise requirements must be taken into
consideration, so that the rationalization exercise does not result
in a school being left with an inadequate number of teachers.
47. The primary objection of the petitioners, however,
is directed against Clause-8(i) and 8(ii) of memo dated
21.07.2026. It is contended that the two provisions prescribe
contradictory criteria, inasmuch as that Clause 8(i) identifies the
teacher having the longest tenure of posting in a particular
school as Surplus, where the teacher has completed five years or
more, whereas Clause-8(ii) identifies the teacher having the
shortest tenure of posting, where all teachers in the Surplus
category have been posted for less than five years.
48. Having considered the aforesaid contention, this
Court finds that the two provisions operate in different factual
situations and cannot be said to be contradictory, merely
because they prescribe different criteria for identifying the
teacher to be adjusted.
Clause-8(i) applies where the teachers in the
concerned school include those, who have completed five years
or more at that school. Where more than one teacher falls within
that category, the teacher having the longest period of posting in
that school is identified as Surplus. The said criterion has a

Patna High Court CWJC No.14944 of 2026 dt.19-11-2026
97/108
rational nexus with Rule 3(ix) of the 2026 Rules, which
contemplates the general transfer of teachers after every five
years of service. The Department, while undertaking
rationalization, is entitled to take into consideration the duration
of posting at a particular school, for identifying the teacher
whose adjustment would best serve the administrative and
academic requirements.
Clause-8(ii), on the other hand, operates in a different
situation, namely, where all the teachers falling within the
Surplus category in a particular school have been posted there
for a period of less than five years. In such a situation, the
teacher having the shortest posting tenure is identified as
Surplus. The object of this provision is to ensure that where no
teacher has completed the ordinary five year period, the teacher
who has the shortest tenure at the concerned institution, is
considered first for adjustment, thereby avoiding unnecessary
disturbance to teachers who have served for a longer period in
that school.
Thus, Clause-8(i) and 8(ii) do not operate
simultaneously upon the same category of teachers. They
provide separate criteria for separate factual situations. The five
year threshold is drawn from the framework contained in Rule

Patna High Court CWJC No.14944 of 2026 dt.19-11-2026
98/108
3(ix) of the 2026 Rules and the different criteria under the two
clauses are intended to facilitate the implementation of the
rationalization exercise.
49. It is also necessary to clarify that the tenure
contemplated under these clauses is the period of posting at the
concerned school, and not necessarily the inter se seniority of
the teachers in their respective cadres. The Department must,
therefore, apply the criteria uniformly and on the basis of
verified service and posting records.
50. At this stage, it is necessary to clarify, that the
identification of a teacher as Surplus under Clause-8(i) or
Clause-8(ii) cannot, by itself, be treated as an automatic or
compulsory transfer order. The provisions of memo dated
21.07.2026 must necessarily be read harmoniously with Rule
3(x) of the 2026 Rules, which expressly provides that transfer
shall not be automatic or mandatory and shall remain subject to
the prescribed conditions.
51. Therefore, where a teacher has not completed the
minimum prescribed service period, any transfer before
completion of such period must be considered strictly in
accordance with Rule 3(x), including the requirement of special
circumstances and consideration by the competent committee,

Patna High Court CWJC No.14944 of 2026 dt.19-11-2026
99/108
wherever applicable. The criteria contained in Clause 8(ii)
cannot be used to override this statutory protection.
52. Similarly, in all cases, the final adjustment must
satisfy Rule-3-A(v), so that the prescribed teacher strength,
Pupil-Teacher Ratio, availability of essential subject teachers
and continuity of teaching-learning are not adversely affected.
The identification of a Surplus teacher is consequently a part of
the rationalization process and does not dispense with the
remaining requirements governing a lawful transfer.
53. The contention that the principle of “last come,
first go” must invariably govern the identification of Surplus
teachers, also cannot be accepted as an inflexible proposition in
the facts of the present case. The exercise under consideration is
not one of retrenchment or termination of services, but an
administrative exercise for rational distribution of teachers
amongst schools. The governing criteria are, therefore, to be
found in the applicable service rules and the educational
requirements of the institutions concerned. The mere fact that a
teacher has rendered longer service in the school or has acquired
seniority in a particular cadre does not, by itself, confer a right
to remain posted in a school where the teacher is found to be in
excess of the actual requirement. At the same time, the

Patna High Court CWJC No.14944 of 2026 dt.19-11-2026
100/108
Department cannot disregard the applicable cadre structure,
service records or the criteria specifically prescribed under the
Rules and the SOP.
54. The aforesaid view also finds support from the
recent judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of
Pratap Singh Baghel vs. Akanksha Shukla (Civil Appeal
arising out of SLP (C) No.5678 of 2025), wherein the Hon’ble
Supreme Court considered a claim for inter-district transfer of a
teacher under the Uttar Pradesh Basic Education (Teachers)
(Posting) Rules, 2008. While considering the request for
transfer, the Hon’ble Supreme Court took into account the
student-teacher ratio prescribed under the RTE Act, 2009 and
held that a teacher cannot claim transfer as a matter of right,
where such transfer would adversely affect the studies of the
children. The Hon’ble Supreme Court emphasized that the
educational system is primarily for the students and not to
further the career or convenience of teachers. The Hon’ble
Supreme Court accordingly upheld the decision refusing
transfer where the movement of the teacher would have resulted
in further deterioration of the Pupil-Teacher Ratio in the school
concerned.
55. Although, the aforesaid judgment arose in the

Patna High Court CWJC No.14944 of 2026 dt.19-11-2026
101/108
context of the transfer provisions applicable in the State of Uttar
Pradesh, the principle enunciated therein is of direct relevance
to the present controversy. The educational interest of children
must remain paramount, while considering the transfer and
posting of teachers. The convenience of an individual teacher
cannot be permitted to override the Statutory obligation of the
State, to maintain the prescribed teaching strength in each
school. The said principle also reinforces the object underlying
the Bihar State Teachers Transfer Rules, 2026.The
rationalization of teachers is intended to ensure that the
availability of teaching personnel is not concentrated in certain
institutions at the cost of schools, which are functioning with a
shortage of teachers. An individual teacher cannot insist upon
continuation at a particular school merely on the ground that he
or she was appointed or posted there under an earlier
administrative arrangement, if the subsequent and valid
assessment of school wise requirements warrants adjustment,
subject to the statutory safeguards.
56. From the records it further appears that in the
present exercise, a total of 1,06,287 teachers were identified as
Surplus and out of whom 72,806 teachers submitted their
preferences, for transfer through the departmental portal. From

Patna High Court CWJC No.14944 of 2026 dt.19-11-2026
102/108
the pleadings on record, brought by the State respondents as an
illustration where schools having a teacher strength in excess of
their assessed requirement were identified and the concerned
teachers were provided an opportunity to seek posting in
schools having a teacher deficit. These instances demonstrate
the administrative object behind the exercise, namely, balancing
teacher availability and ensuring that the educational interests of
students are not adversely affected.
57. From the Counter affidavit filed on behalf of the
State respondent it is clear that a teacher who could not be
allotted any school from the choices furnished through the
portal, would continue to work in the present school, until a
decision is taken by the competent authority. This statement
made on behalf of the State is taken on record and shall be
adhered to by the respondent authorities in the Education
Department.
58. It is also necessary to observe that the exercise of
rationalization cannot be permitted to operate mechanically or
merely on the basis of an unverified automated entry on the
departmental portal. The portal is a mechanism for maintaining
and processing relevant information. The ultimate decision must
remain consistent with the Statutory Rules and the actual

Patna High Court CWJC No.14944 of 2026 dt.19-11-2026
103/108
requirements of the concerned school. Therefore, the
Department must ensure that the identification of a Surplus
teacher is based upon verified school wise enrollment, subject
wise requirements, actual availability of teachers, relevant
service and posting records and the vacancies available in the
schools, where adjustment is proposed. Any factual or
procedural error pointed out by an affected teacher must receive
due consideration in accordance with the grievance redressal
mechanism prescribed under the 2026 Rules. The Rules
themselves recognize the relevance of genuine personal
difficulties of teachers, including serious illness, disability,
husband-wife posting and other notified special circumstances.
Such claims are required to be considered in accordance with
the order of preference and the safeguards prescribed under the
Rules. The rationalization exercise must, therefore, strike a
balance between the legitimate requirements of the educational
institutions and the genuine difficulties of teachers, without
compromising the academic interests of the children.
59. In view of the aforesaid discussion, this Court
holds that the identification of schools having relatively Surplus
teachers and schools having teacher deficit, on the basis of the
prescribed departmental standards, RTE/PTR norms, class wise

Patna High Court CWJC No.14944 of 2026 dt.19-11-2026
104/108
and subject wise requirements, is within the Statutory
framework of the Bihar State Teachers Transfer Rules, 2026.
The exercise is in consonance with the object of Section 25 of
the RTE Act, 2009, insofar as it seeks to ensure the availability
of the requisite number of teachers in Elementary schools and to
maintain the prescribed Pupil-Teacher Ratio.
60. This Court further holds that Clause-8(i) and 8(ii)
of Memo No.797 dated 21.07.2026 are not mutually
contradictory and are capable of being harmoniously read with
Rule 3(ix), Rule 3(x) and Rule 3-A of the 2026 Rules. The said
Clauses prescribe criteria for identification of a teacher for
adjustment in distinct factual situations and cannot be construed
as authorizing an automatic or compulsory transfer, in
derogation of the Statutory safeguards.
CONCLUSION AND DIRECTIONS
61. For the reasons recorded hereinabove, this Court
does not find any ground to interfere with the revised Standard
Setting (Manak Nirdharan) contained in letter No.1936 dated
22.06.2026 or the general validity of Clauses-5, 8(i) and 8(ii) of
Memo No.797 dated 21.07.2026, insofar as the same relate to
the identification and rationalization of Surplus teachers. The
challenge to the aforesaid communications and guidelines is

Patna High Court CWJC No.14944 of 2026 dt.19-11-2026
105/108
accordingly rejected.
62. However, the respondent authorities are directed
to ensure that the rationalization exercise is implemented strictly
in accordance with the Bihar State Teachers Transfer Rules,
2026, and the following safeguards:
(i) The identification of Surplus teachers shall be
based upon updated and verified school wise data relating to
student enrollment, teacher availability, class wise and subject
wise requirements and existing vacancies.
(ii) No consequential transfer or adjustment shall be
made, if such transfer would result in violation of the minimum
prescribed teacher strength, the Pupil-Teacher Ratio under the
RTE Act, 2009, the availability of essential subject teachers or
the continuity of teaching-learning in the concerned school.
(iii) Clauses-8(i) and 8(ii) of memo no.797 dated
21.07.2026 shall be implemented in the manner explained in
this judgment and strictly, subject to Rules 3(ix), 3(x) and 3-A of
the 2026 Rules. Identification as a Surplus teacher shall not, by
itself, result in an automatic or compulsory transfer.
(iv) Any transfer before completion of the minimum
prescribed service period shall be considered only in accordance
with Rule-3(x) and the other applicable provisions of the 2026

Patna High Court CWJC No.14944 of 2026 dt.19-11-2026
106/108
Rules. So far, the teachers of dying cadre are concerned, it is
settled law that a person, who has been appointed on a post in
the dying cadre, he/she carries his/her post on transfer with
him/her at the new place of posting and he/she also carries with
him/her the seniority in his/her cadre, even after transfer. This
fact has been stated/accepted by the Secretary of the
Department, during his oral submissions in the Court and he had
assured this Court that the teachers who have been declared as
Surplus in the present exercise, belonging to the dying cadre,
will carry their post, along with their seniority in their respective
cadre and they will get their salary from their respective
transferred place of posting. The same will be adhered to by the
Department in future, so that the teachers of the dying cadre will
not face any future complications.
(v) In case an individual teacher raises a genuine,
factual or procedural objection, regarding student enrollment,
school wise teacher strength, cadre, subject requirement, posting
tenure or personal eligibility, the same shall be considered by
the competent authority in accordance with the prescribed
grievance redressal mechanism. Any consequential
administrative transfer shall also comply with the applicable
procedural safeguards, including the opportunity contemplated

Patna High Court CWJC No.14944 of 2026 dt.19-11-2026
107/108
under Rule-5(xiii), wherever applicable.
(vi) The respondent authorities shall give due
consideration to genuine cases falling within the special
categories recognized under the Rules, including serious
medical conditions, disability, husband-wife posting and other
notified circumstances, subject to the availability of vacancies
and the academic requirements of the concerned schools.
(vii) The statement made on behalf of the State that
teachers who could not be allotted any school from amongst the
choices furnished by them, shall continue at their existing place
of posting, until a decision is taken by the competent authority,
shall be adhered to by the respondent authorities.
63. It is made clear that this Court has not expressed
any opinion on the correctness of the identification of each
individual petitioner as a Surplus teacher. Any individual
grievance concerning an error in the underlying data, the
calculation of posting tenure, the application of the prescribed
criteria or the eligibility for a particular transfer, shall be
examined independently by the competent authority in
accordance with the 2026 Rules.
64. The writ petitions, insofar as they challenge the
general exercise of identification and rationalization of surplus

Patna High Court CWJC No.14944 of 2026 dt.19-11-2026
108/108
teachers, stand dismissed,Subject to the aforesaid observations
and directions.
65. Pending applications, if any, shall also stand
disposed of in the aforesaid terms.
66. There shall be no order as to costs.

(Ritesh Kumar, J)
krishnakant/-
AFR/NAFR AFR
CAV DATE 05.10.2026
Uploading Date 19.11.2026
Transmission Date NA