VISHAL PATHANGE. G vs BENGALURU DEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY

Court
Karnataka High Court

- 1 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:59479
WP No. 12136 of 2022
C/W RP No. 146 of 2026


CNR: KAHC010273582022



IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU
ND
DATED THIS THE 2 DAY OF SEPTEMBER, 2026
BEFORE
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE M.NAGAPRASANNA
WRIT PETITION NO. 12136 OF 2022 (BDA)
C/W
REVIEW PETITION NO. 146 OF 2026

IN WP No. 12136/2022
BETWEEN:

VISHAL PATHANGE G,
S/O GOPAL KRISHNA RAO,
AGED ABOUT 43 YEARS,
AND R/AT 2082, SHOBHA
CHYRASANTHEMUM, TANISANDRA
MAIN ROAD, NARAYANAPURA,

BENGALURU 560 077.
…PETITIONER
Digitally signed
by RAKESH S
HARIHAR
Location: High
Court of
Karnataka,
Dharwad Bench
(BY SRI ABHINAY Y T, ADVOCATE)
AND:

1. BENGALURU DEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY,
T CHOWDAIAH RAOD,
KUMARAPARK WEST,
BENGALURU 560 020,

REP ̤ BY ITS COMMISSIONER.

2.
DEPUTY SECRETARY -4,
BENGALURU DEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY,

- 2 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:59479
WP No. 12136 of 2022
C/W RP No. 146 of 2026


CNR: KAHC010273582022


T CHOWDAIAH RAOD,
KUMARAPARK WEST,
BENGALURU 560 020.
…RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI K. KRISHNA, ADVOCATE)
THIS WP IS FILED UNDER ARTICLES 226 AND 227 OF
THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA PRAYING TO DIRECT THE
RESPONDENTS TO RENEW /REVALIDATE THE SALE DEED
DATED 27TH OF APRIL 2021 EXECUTED IN FAVOUR OF THE
PETITIONER IN RESPECT OF SITE BEARING NO.1 FORMED IN
BANASHANKARI 6TH STAGE, 7TH BLOCK, (SURVEY NO.19
SOMPURA GRAMA) LAYOUT, BENGALURU TOTALLY MEASURING

258 SQ METERS AS PER ANNEXURE-B.

IN RP NO. 146/2026
BETWEEN:
VISHAL PATHANGE. G,
S/O GOPAL KRISHNA RAO,
AGED ABOUT 47 YEARS,
AND R/AT #2082, SHOBHA CHYRASANTHEMUM,
TANISANDRA MAIN ROAD,

NARAYANAPURA, BENGALURU 560 077 ̤
...PETITIONER
(BY SRI ABHINAY Y T, ADVOCATE)

AND:
1.
BENGALURU DEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY,
T CHOWDAIAH ROAD,
KUMARAPARK WEST,
BENGALURU - 560020,

REP. BY ITS COMMISSIONER ̤

- 3 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:59479
WP No. 12136 of 2022
C/W RP No. 146 of 2026


CNR: KAHC010273582022


2.
DEPUTY SECRETARY - 4,
BENGALURU DEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY,
T CHOWDAIAH ROAD,
KUMARA PARK WEST,

BENGALURU - 560020 ̤
...RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI K. KRISHNA, ADVOCATE)
THIS RP IS FILED UNDER SECTION 114 R/W ORDER
47 RULE 1 OF THE CPC PRAYING TO REVIEW THE ORDER
DATED 02.09.2025 PASSED IN WP NO.12136/2022 AND
CONSEQUENTIALLY ALLOW THE PETITION AS SOUGHT
FOR.
THESE PETITIONS, COMING ON FOR ORDERS, THIS DAY,
ORDER IS MADE THEREIN AS UNDER:

CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE M. NAGAPRASANNA

ORAL ORDER

The petitioner, common in both the petitions, is before
the Court in the subject review petition seeking review of the
order of this Court dated 02-09-2025 in the subject writ
petition.

2. Heard the learned counsel Sri. Abhinay Y.T.,
appearing for the petitioner and the learned counsel Sri. K.
Krishna, appearing for the respondents.

- 4 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:59479
WP No. 12136 of 2022
C/W RP No. 146 of 2026


CNR: KAHC010273582022


3. Facts, in brief, germane are as follows:
3.1. The petitioner had purchased a corner site bearing
th th
Site No.1 at Banashankari 6 stage, 7 block, Bengaluru
measuring 258 square meters from the respondents–Bangalore
Development Authority (‘BDA’) in the e-auction conducted by
the respondents in the year 2020. The sale deed for the said
site was executed in favour of the petitioner after payment of
the entire sale consideration. The petitioner was unable to
register the said sale deed due to the outbreak of the
COVID-19 pandemic. Thereafter, the respondents are said to
have to not revalidated the sale deed that was executed in
favour of the petitioner.

3.2. Respondents/BDA pass an order directing that the
amount of Rs. 40,10,853/- shall be refunded to the petitioner
since the petitioner has been granted only 159 square meters
of land instead of 258 square meters of land for which the sale
deed was executed in favour of the petitioner. The petitioner
makes a representation to the respondents/BDA to revalidate
the sale deed and not bifurcate the property purchased by him
in the e-auction. The petitioner then files the subject writ

- 5 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:59479
WP No. 12136 of 2022
C/W RP No. 146 of 2026


CNR: KAHC010273582022


petition seeking a direction to the respondents to revalidate the
sale deed executed in favour of the petitioner.

3.3. This Court, on 02-09-2025, directed the
respondents/BDA to pay the amount of Rs. 40,10,853/- at 12%
interest per annum from the date it had to be refunded till the
date it would reach the doors of the petitioner since the
petitioner was only granted 159 square meters of land instead
of 258 square meters as aforementioned. The subject review
petition is then filed by the petitioner on the score that the
respondents/BDA have the power to allot alternative sites and
further that the BDA created third party rights qua the
petitioner’s property in the teeth of the interim order granted
by the co-ordinate Bench in the subject writ petition.

4.1. Learned counsel for the petitioner, while taking this
Court through the documents appended to the petitions, would
contend that the respondents/BDA had submitted before this
Court in the subject writ petition that the land measuring 99
square meters out of the 258 square meters allotted to the
petitioner is already allotted to somebody else and construction

- 6 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:59479
WP No. 12136 of 2022
C/W RP No. 146 of 2026


CNR: KAHC010273582022


is put up on the said land. Learned counsel seeks to place
reliance on the resolution of the BDA dated 22-10-2011 to
contend that the BDA has the power to allot alternative sites in
such circumstances.

4.2. Learned counsel would further submit that the
respondents/BDA have violated the interim order granted by
the co-ordinate Bench on 21-06-2022 in the subject writ
petition by executing a sale deed on 06-08-2022 in respect of a
portion of Site No.1, which was numbered as Site No.2 in the
sale deed executed in favour of the purchaser therein.

5. Per contra , learned counsel for the respondents/BDA
would submit that as per Rule 11A of the Bangalore
Development Authority (Allotment of Sites) Rules, 1984
alternate site may be allotted only where possession of the site
could not be given due to the physical non-availability of the
site or due to an order of stay granted by a Court. The
petitioner has agreed to accept the auctioned site at the
reduced measurement and, therefore, amount was refunded to
the petitioner.

- 7 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:59479
WP No. 12136 of 2022
C/W RP No. 146 of 2026


CNR: KAHC010273582022


6. I have given my anxious consideration to the
submissions made by the respective learned counsel and have
perused the material on record.

7. The afore-narrated facts, link in the chain of events are
a matter of record. The petitioner purchases a corner site in
the e-auction conducted by the respondents/BDA and the
auction sale deed is executed in favour of the petitioner on
27-04-2021. Thereafter, the petitioner was unable to register
the sale deed due to the outbreak of the COVID-19 pandemic.
The respondents/BDA issue a direction that the amount of
Rs.40,10,853/- shall be refunded to the petitioner since the
petitioner has been allotted only 159 square meters of land
instead of 258 square meters of land for which the sale deed
was executed. The petitioner then approaches the
respondents/BDA seeking to renew or revalidate the sale deed
executed in his favour and not to bifurcate the property
allocated to the petitioner. The petitioner then files the subject
writ petition.

- 8 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:59479
WP No. 12136 of 2022
C/W RP No. 146 of 2026


CNR: KAHC010273582022


8. This Court, on 02-09-2025, directed the
respondents/BDA to pay the amount of Rs. 40,10,853/- since
the petitioner was only granted 159 square meters of land
instead of 258 square meters as aforementioned. The order of
this Court reads as follows:
“…. …. ….
Therefore, the BDA accepts the fact that the petitioner in
terms of the auction was not made good of the entire
property that was put to auction i.e., 248 sq. meters but
was granted only 159 sq.meters as he draws the other
property was allotted to someone else. Therefore, BDA
becomes diligent and notified the property for auction and
the petitioner has paid the entire amount of
Rs.1,05,00,000/- way back in the year 2021, the
complete amount towards entire auction consideration of
258 sq. meters but petitioner gets only 159 sq.meters, it
is accepted by the BDA.

4. The BDA way back on 2.3.2022 holds that there
has been a mistake and observes that the amount of
Rs.40,10,853/- would be refunded. The amount is not yet
refunded since the petition is pending.

5. Learned counsel for the petitioner is ready and
wiling to take 159 sq. meters that is allotted to him and
further take the refund of Rs.40,10,853/- as observed in
the aforesaid communication. However, would demand
interest and cost of litigation.

6. In the light of the aforesaid reasons, I deem it
appropriate to direct BDA to refund Rs.40,10,853/- along
with interest at the rate of 12 % per annum, from the
date it fell due till the date it reaches the doors of the
petitioner apart from cost of litigation.

7. For the aforesaid reasons, the following:

- 9 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:59479
WP No. 12136 of 2022
C/W RP No. 146 of 2026


CNR: KAHC010273582022


ORDER

[i] Writ Petition is allowed in part with costs of
Rs.50,000/- to be paid to the petitioner by the
respondent-BDA.

[ii] The auction notification in so far as the petitioner is
concerned, stands confirmed to the extent of 159 sq.
meters. The remainder 99 sq. meters which is valued at
Rs.40,10,853/- is directed to be refunded by the BDA
along with 12 % interest per annum from the date it had
to be refunded till the date it would reach the doors of the
petitioner which would be 2.3.2022 till the date it would
reach the doors of the petitioner.”

9. The subject review petition is then filed by the
petitioner on the score that the respondents/BDA ought to have
allotted an alternative site. On the submission of the learned
counsel for the petitioner, this Court on 30-07-2026 had
passed the following order:
The petitioner is before the Court seeking review of
an order dated 02.09.2025 passed in the subject petition.
The writ petition comes to be disposed on the following
order:

“Therefore, the BDA accepts the fact that the
petitioner in terms of the auction was not made
good of the entire property that was put to
auction i.e., 248 sq. meters but was granted only
159 sq.meters as he draws the other property
was allotted to someone else. Therefore, BDA
becomes diligent and notified the property for
auction and the petitioner has paid the entire
amount of Rs.1,05,00,000/- way back in the year
2021, the complete amount towards entire
auction consideration of 258 sq. meters but
petitioner gets only 159 sq.meters, it is accepted
by the BDA.

- 10 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:59479
WP No. 12136 of 2022
C/W RP No. 146 of 2026


CNR: KAHC010273582022



4. The BDA way back on 2.3.2022
holds that there has been a mistake and
observes that the amount of Rs.40,10,853/-
would be refunded. The amount is not yet
refunded since the petition is pending.

5. Learned counsel for the petitioner is
ready and wiling to take 159 sq. meters that is
allotted to him and further take the refund of
Rs.40,10,853/- as observed in the aforesaid
communication. However, would demand interest
and cost of litigation.

6. In the light of the aforesaid
reasons, I deem it appropriate to direct BDA to
refund Rs.40,10,853/- along with interest at the
rate of 12 percent per annum, from the date it
fell due till the date it reaches the doors of the
petitioner apart from cost of litigation.

7. For the aforesaid reasons, the
following:

ORDER

[i] Writ Petition is allowed in part with costs
of Rs.50,000/- to be paid to the petitioner by the
respondent-BDA.

[ii] The auction notification in so far as the
petitioner is concerned, stands confirmed to the
extent of 159 sq. meters. The remainder 99 sq.
meters which is valued at Rs.40,10,853/- is
directed to be refunded by the BDA along with 12
percent interest per annum from the date it had
to be refunded till the date it would reach the
doors of the petitioner which would be 2.3.2022
till the date it would reach the doors of the
petitioner.”

A review has preferred on the score that the BDA
has mislead this Court in directing refund of the amount
to the petitioner on the score that there was no provision
under the BDA Act to grant an alternate site to an auction
purchaser of a corner site.

- 11 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:59479
WP No. 12136 of 2022
C/W RP No. 146 of 2026


CNR: KAHC010273582022


The learned counsel for the petitioner has now
produced the resolution of the BDA, which accords
permission for grant of alternate site to all the auction
purchasers of the corner sites.

The learned counsel for the respondents submits
that it is only for a particular person, it was done.

If it is done for a particular person, without any
provision in law, though in law, there cannot be negative
equality, but the BDA has chosen to frame the law on
looking at the person.

The petitioner is also one of those auction
purchasers. He is also entitled to an alternate site as is
granted to others pursuant to a resolution.

Why the petitioner is being singled out and why
before this Court, it was contended that there is no power
is to be explained by the BDA.

The explanation shall be by way of an affidavit of
the Commissioner of the BDA, by the next date.

List these matters on 20.08.2026 .

Interim order granted earlier, if subsisting in any of
these cases, is extended till the next date of hearing.”

The Commissioner of the BDA was directed to file an affidavit
showing cause as to why an alternate site was not allotted to
the petitioner. The affidavit of the Commissioner of the BDA
reads as follows:
“1. I am the Commissioner, BDA, Bangalore and I am
conversant with the facts of the above case based
on the records available in the office.

- 12 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:59479
WP No. 12136 of 2022
C/W RP No. 146 of 2026


CNR: KAHC010273582022


2. I submit that this Hon'ble Court in the above case
considering the copy of the resolution of the BDA in
Subject No.299/2011 dated 22-10-2011 directed
the Commissioner, BDA to file affidavit explaining
why the petitioner is discriminated in allotment of
alternative site to the Auctioned Corner Site No.1,
7th Block, Bansashankari 6th State layout when
the above resolution provides for allotment of
alternative site for the auction site.

3. I submit that the aforesaid Resolution of the
Authority was passed in terms of Rule 11-A of BDA
(Allotment of Site) Rules 1984 wherein an
alternative site may be allotted only where the
mistake was on the part of the Authority while
making the allotment of site, where the possession
of the said site could not be given due to stay
orders of the Hon'ble Courts or physically non-
availability of the said allotted site. In the present
case, the auctioned site is available and only the
measurement of the site was reduced. Therefore, it
is submitted that there is no provision for allotment
of alternative site where the site is available but
only difference in measurement. The BDA has
offered to refund the entire amount received in
respect of the site in question with interest, if the
petitioner does not want the auctioned site in its
lesser measurement.

4. The petitioner has also agreed to accept the said
site with available measurement of 159 sq. mtrs.
Pursuant to the order passed in the above case by
this Hon'ble Court, BDA has refunded the interest
amount of Rs. 16,87,855/- to the petitioner on
11.06.2026 Through Demand Draft No.349844 and
called upon the petitioner to execute the
rectification deed to the Sale deed in view of
reduction of measurement and to collect the
remaining amount. The copy of the Endorsement
dtd 31.08.2026 calling upon the petitioner to
execute rectification deed to the sale deed is placed
as Annexure-R1. The copy of the Endorsement has
been sent to the petitioner Advocate on Whatsapp
bearing no. 9845073660 and is placed as Annexure-

- 13 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:59479
WP No. 12136 of 2022
C/W RP No. 146 of 2026


CNR: KAHC010273582022


R2. The copy of the Postal Receipt dtd 31.08.2026
bearing no.JK042191155IN made to the petitioner
is placed as Annexure-R3.

5. I submit that the above statement made above are
true and correct to the best of my knowledge,
information and belief.”

The afore-quoted affidavit indicates that the site purchased by
the petitioner is available, albeit the measurement of the site is
reduced. It is further stated in the affidavit that an alternate
site can be granted to the petitioner only when the mistake
was on the part of the BDA where possession of the site could
not be given due to the physical non-availability of the site or
due to an order of stay granted by a Court.

10. Learned counsel for the petitioner would also
submit that the respondents/BDA created third party rights by
executing a sale deed on 06-08-2022 in respect of a portion of
Site No.1, which was numbered as Site No.2 in the sale deed
executed in favour of the purchaser therein. The petitioner
submits that such creation of third party rights is in violation of
the interim order granted by the co-ordinate Bench on
21-06-2022, during the pendency of the subject writ petition. I
deem it appropriate to notice the interim order so granted by

- 14 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:59479
WP No. 12136 of 2022
C/W RP No. 146 of 2026


CNR: KAHC010273582022


the co-ordinate Bench earlier in these proceedings. The interim
order reads as follows:
“ Sri. Rajashekar S., learned panel counsel is
directed to accept notice for respondent Nos.1 and 2.

Learned counsel for the petitioner to furnish copies
of the petition along with annexures on the said counsel.

Objections, if any, to be filed on or before
08.07.2022.

Re-list on 12.07.2022.

In the meanwhile, the respondents have restrained
from creating any third party right towards site No.1
formed at Banashankarai, 6th Stage, 7th Block,
Bengaluru, till the next date of hearing.”

It is un-understandable as to how the BDA allocated the portion
of the property, which belonged to the petitioner to a third
party, in the teeth of the interim order granted by the
co-ordinate Bench.

11. In that light, the subject writ petition suffers from an
error apparent on the face of the record, coming within the
parameters of the law laid down by the Apex Court in the case
1
of KAMLESH VERMA v. MAYAWATI , wherein it is held as
follows:

1
(2013) 8 SCC 320

- 15 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:59479
WP No. 12136 of 2022
C/W RP No. 146 of 2026


CNR: KAHC010273582022


“…. …. ….
20.1. When the review will be maintainable:

( i ) Discovery of new and important matter or
evidence which, after the exercise of due diligence,
was not within knowledge of the petitioner or could
not be produced by him;

( ii ) Mistake or error apparent on the face of
the record;

( iii ) Any other sufficient reason.

The words “any other sufficient reason” have been
interpreted in Chhajju Ram v. Neki [(1921-22) 49 IA 144
: (1922) 16 LW 37 : AIR 1922 PC 112] and approved by
this Court in Moran Mar Basselios Catholicos v. Most Rev.
Mar Poulose Athanasius [AIR 1954 SC 526 : (1955) 1 SCR
520] to mean “a reason sufficient on grounds at least
analogous to those specified in the rule”. The same
principles have been reiterated in Union of India v.
Sandur Manganese & Iron Ores Ltd. [(2013) 8 SCC 337 :
JT (2013) 8 SC 275]

20.2. When the review will not be maintainable:

( i ) A repetition of old and overruled argument is
not enough to reopen concluded adjudications.

( ii ) Minor mistakes of inconsequential import.

( iii ) Review proceedings cannot be equated with
the original hearing of the case.

( iv ) Review is not maintainable unless the material
error, manifest on the face of the order, undermines its
soundness or results in miscarriage of justice.

( v ) A review is by no means an appeal in disguise
whereby an erroneous decision is reheard and corrected
but lies only for patent error.

- 16 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:59479
WP No. 12136 of 2022
C/W RP No. 146 of 2026


CNR: KAHC010273582022


( vi ) The mere possibility of two views on the
subject cannot be a ground for review.

( vii ) The error apparent on the face of the record
should not be an error which has to be fished out and
searched.

( viii ) The appreciation of evidence on record is fully
within the domain of the appellate court, it cannot be
permitted to be advanced in the review petition.

( ix ) Review is not maintainable when the same
relief sought at the time of arguing the main matter had
been negatived.”

(Emphasis supplied)

12. Since the portion of the property which was allotted
to the petitioner has now been allotted to a third party, the
petitioner is entitled to an alternative site. Therefore, the
respondents – BDA are directed to pass a resolution granting
an alternative corner site to the petitioner.

13. With the aforesaid observations, the following:
O R D E R

i. Review petition is allowed .


ii. Writ petition is disposed .

- 17 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:59479
WP No. 12136 of 2022
C/W RP No. 146 of 2026


CNR: KAHC010273582022



iii. The respondents – BDA are directed to pass a
resolution to grant the petitioner an alternative
site.



Sd/-
(M.NAGAPRASANNA)
JUDGE


MCR
List No.: 2 Sl No.: 106