MR. SANTHOSH @ SANTHOSH KUMAR vs MR . ARUN PRABHA
- Court
- Karnataka High Court
- 1 -
MFA No. 3164 of 2023
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU
R
DATED THIS THE 6TH DAY OF NOVEMBER, 2026
BEFORE
THE HON'BLE MRS. JUSTICE GEETHA K.B.
MISCELLANEOUS FIRST APPEAL NO. 3164 / 2023
(MV-I)
BETWEEN:
1. MR. SANTHOSH @ SANTHOSH KUMAR
S/O NARAYANA SALIAN,
AGED ABOUT 28 YEARS,
R/AT KUMER HOUSE, KAKWA, MAILOTTU,
ATHIKARIBETTU VILLAGE, MANGALURU TALUK,
D.K. DISTRICT-575018
…APPELLANT
(BY SRI. RAVISHANKAR SHASTRY G.,ADVOCATE)
AND:
1. MR. ARUN PRABHA
S/O LATE SRIPATHI RAO,
AGED ABOUT 65 YEARS,
R/AT SHISHYAKUNJ, NO 2-12, AIRPORT ROAD,
KOPPALAKAD, YEYYADI, MANGALURU TALUK,
D.K. DISTRICT-575006
2. ICICI LOMBARD GENERAL INSURANCE CO. LTD.
414, VEER SAVARKAR MARG,
NEAR SIDDHI VINAYAKA TEMPLE,
PRABHADEVI, MUMBAI
REPRESENTED BY ITS MANAGER-401305
…RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI.B.PRADEEP, ADVOCATE FOR R2;
R1 SERVED)
Digitally Signed By:
K B GEETHA
- 2 -
MFA No. 3164 of 2023
THIS MFA IS FILED U/S 173(1) OF MV ACT AGAINST THE
JUDGMENT AND AWARD DATED16.02.2023 PASSED IN MVC
NO.625/2016 ON THE FILE OF THE I ADDITIONAL DISTRICT
JUDGE AND MACT-II, D.K.MANGALURU, DISMISSING THE
CLAIM PETITION FOR COMPENSATION.
THIS APPEAL HAVING BEEN HEARD AND RESERVED ON
29.10.2026, COMING ON FOR PRONOUNCEMENT OF JUDGMENT
THIS DAY, THE COURT DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
CORAM: HON'BLE MRS. JUSTICE GEETHA K.B.
CAV JUDGMENT
This is the appeal filed under Section 173 (1) of the
Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 (in short 'M.V.Act') challenging
the judgment and award dated 16.02.2023 in MVC No.
625/2016 on the file of the I Additional District Judge and
MACT-II, D.K. Mangaluru (in short 'the Tribunal').
2. The parties would be referred with their ranks,
as they were before the Tribunal for the sake of
convenience and clarity.
3. The claimant has filed the claim petition before
the Tribunal under Section 166 of M.V. Act praying for
compensation in respect of the injuries suffered by him in
the road traffic accident that has taken place on
16.09.2015 at about 09:30 p.m. in front of Bata
Showroom near KSRTC Bijai Bus Stand, Mangaluru Taluk
Digitally Signed By:
K B GEETHA
- 3 -
MFA No. 3164 of 2023
involving motorcycle bearing registration No.KA-19/EA-
5611 and car bearing registration No.KA-19/Z-8430
(offending car).
4. The case of claimant in nutshell is that he was
the pillion rider of the motorcycle and it was being driven
by one Raghavendra at the time of accident. According to
the claimant, immediately after the accident the claimant
was taken to Government Wenlock District Hospital,
Mangaluru for treatment; he was in-patient in the said
hospital from 17.09.2015 to 05.10.2015 and even then, he
had taken bed rest and advised for follow-up treatment.
He spent ` 30,000/- towards 'medical expenses' and other
miscellaneous expenses. Further ` 30,000/- is required for
his 'future medical expenses'. He was studying in final
year Mechanical Engineering at Shrinivasa College,
Valachhil. He was getting income of ` 6,000/- per month by
conducting tuition classes. He contended that the accident
occurred due to rash and negligent driving of the offending
car. He has filed the claim petition against the respondent
Digitally Signed By:
K B GEETHA
- 4 -
MFA No. 3164 of 2023
Nos.1 and 2 who are the owner and insurance Company of
the offending car.
5. Respondent No.2 has filed its written statement
denying the averments made in the claim petition in toto.
However, admitted that the offending car is validly insured
with the respondent No.2. Hence, prayed for dismissal of
the petition.
6. After framing issues, recording evidence and
hearing arguments of both sides, the tribunal concluded
that the claimant failed to establish that he met with the
accident on the alleged date at alleged place by involving
the offending car and thereby dismissed the claim petition.
7. Aggrieved by the same, the claimant is before
this Court.
8. Heard arguments of both sides.
9. The learned counsel for the appellant Sri G.
Ravishankar Shastry would submit that the Tribunal was
too technical in dismissing the claim petition. His
contention is that the road traffic accident has taken place
on 16.09.2015 at 08:45 p.m. at Bijai near KSRTC Bus
Digitally Signed By:
K B GEETHA
- 5 -
MFA No. 3164 of 2023
Stand of Mangaluru. Immediately, he had been to A.J.
Hospital and then to Government Wenlock District Hospital
and treated at Wenlock District Hospital as in-patient. The
claimant was the pillion rider and the offending car came
from right side in the open divider and dashed against the
motor bike which was being driven by PW.3. Thus, the
claimant has produced all relevant materials before the
Tribunal to prove the accident. Only six months after the
accident, the claimant was again treated before KMC
Hospital wherein the history was narrated as 'skid and fall
from the bike'. But the doctor has admitted in his evidence
that PG students would fill up the history and other details.
Furthermore, the trial Court disbelieved the evidence only
because the place of incident narrated also differs. In the
complaint, it is stated as 'Bijai'. But in discharge summary
of Wenlock District Hospital and in Wenlock District
Hospital's in-patient record, it is mentioned as 'Nanthoor'.
Both are the places in Mangaluru itself. In this regard, the
learned counsel for the appellant places reliance on the
judgment of Hon'ble Apex Court in Rajkumar Das (D)
Digitally Signed By:
K B GEETHA
- 6 -
MFA No. 3164 of 2023
1
Thr. LRs. vs. National Insurance Co.Ltd. . Hence,
prayed for allowing the appeal and to grant compensation
to the claimant. He would further submit that initially the
claim petition was dismissed and then the appeal was filed
in MFA No.7124/2018. At that time, the Co-ordinate Bench
of this Court has remanded the matter to the trial Court
for fresh disposal. Hence, prayed for allowing the appeal.
10. The learned counsel for the respondent Sri B.
Pradeep would submit the discrepancies in the evidence of
PWs.1 and 3 who are the claimant-cum-pillion rider and
rider respectively. He would also point out the discrepancy
in the name, father's name of PW.3 in evidence, in police
records and also in his documents. He would also bring to
the notice of this Court that there is difference of place of
accident narrated in the complaint and in the hospital
records. Further, there is difference about the history in
the initial hospital history and also subsequent history at
KMC Hospital. Hence, prayed for dismissal of the appeal.
1
2026 INSC 541 decided on 25.05.2026
Digitally Signed By:
K B GEETHA
- 7 -
MFA No. 3164 of 2023
11. Having heard arguments of both sides, verifying
the appeal papers and trial Court records, the point that
arises for consideration is:
"Whether the appellant/claimant
establishes that the tribunal erred in
dismissing the appeal?
12. Finding is in 'Negative' for the following:
REASONS
13. The contention of the claimant is that on
16.09.2015 at 08:45 p.m., when he was the pillion rider of
motorcycle near Bijai KSRTC bus stand, the offending car
came from right side of the road in the open divider and
dashed against the motorcycle and thereby caused the
accident.
14. According to the complainant, the place of
accident is Bijai. According to the complaint, the accident
has taken place at 09:30 p.m.; whereas according to
Ex.P.3 wound Certificate it is at 08:45 p.m. As per Ex.P.5-
MLC, there are several overwritings while writing history of
Digitally Signed By:
K B GEETHA
- 8 -
MFA No. 3164 of 2023
RTA and writing the place of accident near Bijai bus stand
but; in Ex.P.10- the discharge summary issued by
Government Wenlock District Hospital and also in Ex.P.15-
inpatient case sheet record, the place and time of accident
is mentioned as 'near Nanthoor' at 08:45 p.m. on
16.09.2015. Thus, the place and time of accident
mentioned in the complaint differs from discharge
summary and in-patient case sheet.
15. About six months after the accident, the
claimant was again treated at KMC Hospital from
07.04.2016 to 12.04.2016. In the discharge summary as
per Ex.P.11, it is mentioned that "patient was apparently
normal 6 months back when he had history of bike skid
and fall following which he went to Government Wenlock
District Hospital where he was diagnosed to have right
Femur Shaft fracture for which he underwent fracture
fixation with nailing. Now patient came with pain and
difficulty in walking which was insidious in onset gradually
progressive. No history of trauma/injury, discharge and
Digitally Signed By:
K B GEETHA
- 9 -
MFA No. 3164 of 2023
fever". Thus according to Ex.P11, the history given by the
claimant was ‘bike skid and fall’.
16. In this regard, in the cross-examination, PW.1
has deposed that said history was given by his brother.
However, the claimant has not examined his brother to
resolve this discrepancy in the history mentioned in the
hospital record and the history stated by him.
17. According to the claimant, one Raghavendra was
the rider of the motorcycle at the time of the accident. He
claims that said Raghavendra is PW.3. In the affidavit
evidence, name of PW.3 is mentioned as Raghavendra son
of M Mahaveera; in the cross-examination, he has stated
that his father's name is Mahaveera Gowda and full name
is not mentioned in the affidavit evidence; he further
admitted that in the summons, his father's name is
mentioned as 'M.D. Hire Gowda'. Exs.P.17 to 22 are
notarized Aadhar card, Passport, PAN card, Driving license,
Voter’s ID card, SSLC marks card of PW.3 and Ex.P.23 is
notarized Aadhar card of his father. In these documents,
name and father’s name of PW.3 is mentioned as
Digitally Signed By:
K B GEETHA
- 10 -
MFA No. 3164 of 2023
'Raghavendra G. M. Hire Gowda' S/o. Mahaveera Gowda.
Thus, there is lot of discrepancy in the name and father's
name of PW.3 in the records and in his evidence.
18. In the cross-examination, PW.3 has deposed
that he has not given statement before police on the date
of accident or within seven days of the accident. A
suggestion put to PW.3 that the petitioner is drinking
alcohol and smoking heavily for which he answered that
he does not know. Further one more suggestion put to
PW.3 that on the date of accident, by drinking alcohol, the
claimant himself was riding the two-wheeler and caused
the accident for which he answered that 'he does not
know'. But he has not denied said suggestion stating that
he was the rider and not the claimant.
19. He has deposed that he has not given complaint
and statement in respect of the accident. Thus, he is not
CW.2 shown in the charge-sheet.
20. It is the contention of the claimant that
immediately after the accident, he was taken to A.J.
Hospital & Research Centre but the doctor told heavy
Digitally Signed By:
K B GEETHA
- 11 -
MFA No. 3164 of 2023
amount for treatment; because he could not pay that
amount, he was shifted to Wenlock District Hospital,
wherein he has taken treatment.
21. In this regard, the report from the A.J. Hospital
& Research Centre is summoned. In that report, it is
stated that after verifying MLC register, they have not
received OP patient Mr. Santosh on 16.09.2015 to A.J.
Hospital & Research Centre. Thus, the say of PW.1 that he
had been to an A.J. Hospital & Research Centre initially is
not substantiated.
22. The doctors at KMC Hospital were examined as
RWs.1 and 2. Dr. Surendra Umesh Kamath/RW.1 has
deposed that he is working as Orthopedician in KMC
Hospital and he produced patient record of the claimant in
said hospital as per Ex.R.2. According to him, the patient
or person accompanied patient usually state the history of
injury. He has stated that the case-sheet dated
07.04.2016 depicts that the history that 'bike skid and fall'
following that he went to Government Wenlock District
Hospital.
Digitally Signed By:
K B GEETHA
- 12 -
MFA No. 3164 of 2023
23. The doctor who has written the history is
examined as RW.2. He is the Resident Medical Officer of
Wenlock District Hospital, Mangaluru. He has produced
the original MLC register and after examining the original,
its extract is marked as Ex.R.4. In this document, the
history is mentioned that 'On 17/09 at 12:45 a.m. history
of RTA on 16.9 at 8:45 p.m. near Nanthoor junction and
then 'Nanthoor junction'; is strike off and then it is written
as Bejai and brought to Wenlock District Hospital by
Santosh.
24. Thus, the place of accident mentioned in MLC
register, in case-sheet and in discharge summary as
'Nanthoor' but it is rectified as 'Bejai' in wound Certificate.
25. RW2 has deposed in the cross-examination that
they depute PG students in casualty for treating the
injured but they will not allow PG students to make entry
in MLC register.
26. The above discussion clearly establishes that
there are four major discrepancies in the case of the
Digitally Signed By:
K B GEETHA
- 13 -
MFA No. 3164 of 2023
claimant which made the Tribunal to disbelieve his
contention.
Firstly , the discrepancy in the name and father's
name of PW.3 mentioned in affidavit evidence, in
his cross-examination, in his documents and in the
charge-sheet. Thus, it is hard to believe that PW.3
was CW.2 in the charge-sheet;
Secondly , the place of accident is different in
different documents;
Thirdly, the history of accident is different in
different documents i.e., before Wenlock District
Hospital and also before KMC Hospital; and
Fourthly , even though the claimant contended
that initially he was taken to A.J. Hospital &
Research Centre, the A.J. Hospital records establish
that there is no material to show that he had taken
at least treatment as outpatient in said hospital.
Digitally Signed By:
K B GEETHA
- 14 -
MFA No. 3164 of 2023
27. All the four above discrepancies made it clear
that the claimant failed to establish that he sustained
injuries in the road traffic accident involving the offending
car on specific date of accident at a specific place.
2
28. In Rajkumar Das's case cited supra at
paragraph Nos.6 to 8 and 12 held as follows:
" 6. The Courts below have denied the claim of
the original claimant on the ground that the occurrence
of accident itself was not established. They relied on
certain discrepancies in the record to hold that the
involvement of the offending vehicle remained
unproved in the accident.
7. The question for consideration before us is not
whether every detail of the occurrence stands proved
with precision, but whether the material on record
reasonably establishes that the injuries sustained by
the original claimant arose out of the accident in
question.
8. At the outset, we would like to reiterate that
the nature of proceedings under the Act are summary
in nature, with an aim to provide expeditious justice.
It is a settled position of law that a claim petition is to
be decided on the touchstone of preponderance of
probability and not proof beyond reasonable doubt.
xxxxxxxxxxx
12. It is a regular practice that medical history
recorded at the time of emergency treatment is
ordinarily based on information supplied by attendants
and its only function is to facilitate the diagnosis. Such
a narration of facts cannot be treated as a precise
reconstruction of the mechanics of the accident. The
FIR, chargesheet and the original claimant's own
2
2026 INSC 541
Digitally Signed By:
K B GEETHA
- 15 -
MFA No. 3164 of 2023
testimony indicate that he was hit by the lorry after he
had got down from the rickshaw. The isolated wording
in the history column cannot displace the cumulative
evidentiary record."
29. Under these circumstances, when the facts and
circumstances of the present case are entirely different
from the facts and circumstances in the above cited case
supra, the said citation is not helpful for the appellant to
prove his contention. Considering these aspects in a right
and proper perspective, the Tribunal rightly, dismissed the
claim petition which requires no interference.
30. Hence, this Court passes the following:
ORDER
The Miscellaneous First Appeal is dismissed .
Digitally Signed By:
K B GEETHA
(GEETHA K.B.)
JUDGE
SSD