Bhagat Singh vs State Of Haryana And Others
- Court
- Punjab and Haryana High Court
CWP-37479-2026, CWP-37497-2026 & CWP-37581-2026
1
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA AT
CHANDIGARH
112+113+116
Date of decision: 16.11.2026
1.
CWP-37479-2026
Karambir
....Petitioner
Versus
State of Haryana and others
....Respondents
2.
CWP-37497-2026
Sona Devi and others
....Petitioners
Versus
State of Haryana and others
....Respondents
3.
CWP-37581-2026
Bhagat Singh
....Petitioner
Versus
State of Haryana and others
....Respondents
CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE HARPREET SINGH BRAR
Present: Mr. Nitin Sharma, Mr. Vinod Kumar Sharma, Mr. Manan
Sharma and Mr. Manohar Rawat, Advocates for the
petitioner in CWP-37479-2026.
Mr. Sandeep Antheri, Advocate for the petitioners in CWP-
37497-2026.
Mr. S.K. Malik, Advocate for the petitioner in CWP-37581-
2026.
Mr. Naveen Singh Panwar, DAG Haryana and Mr. Rahul
Dev Singh, Addl. A.G., Haryana.
PARUL VERMA
2026.11.17 13:07
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this
order/judgment
CWP-37479-2026, CWP-37497-2026 & CWP-37581-2026
2
Mr. Harneet Singh Oberoi, Advocate for respondent NO.3
in CWP-37581-2026.
HARPREET SINGH BRAR J.
1. With the consent of all the parties, the aforementioned writ
petitions are taken up together and are being decided by this common
order. However, for the sake of brevity, the facts are being taken from
CWP-37479-2026.
2. This civil writ petition has been filed under Articles 226/227
of the Constitution of India seeking issuance of appropriate writs, orders
or directions, particularly writs in the nature of mandamus , directing the
official respondents to regularize the services of the petitioner w.e.f. the
year 2002 and extend to him the benefit of the Old Pension Scheme, along
with all consequential benefits and interest @ 12%; further, to consider
and accept the claim of the petitioner in the light of the judgments passed
by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Jaggo v. Union of India and others,
SLP (C) No. 5580 of 2024 , and Dharam Singh and others v. State of U.P.
and another , Civil Appeal No. 8558 of 2018 ; and also to grant the
petitioner equal pay for equal work at par with his counterparts, along
with all consequential benefits and interest @ 12%.
3. Learned counsel for the petitioner in CWP-37479-2026,
inter alia , contends that the petitioner was appointed as part-time
Sweeper in the Education Department in the year 1996 under the policy
dated 11.11.2003 (Annexure P-1). The Government of Haryana decided
to regularize the service of part-time workers on completion of 6 years of
continuous service. The petitioner was fully eligible under the aforesaid
PARUL VERMA
2026.11.17 13:07
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this
order/judgment
CWP-37479-2026, CWP-37497-2026 & CWP-37581-2026
3
policy as similarly situated employees have been regularized. He was
however, regularized only on 28.08.2014.
4. Learned counsel for the petitioners in CWP-37497-2026,
inter alia, contends that he wishes to withdraw the present writ petition
qua petitioner No.7. In view of the above, present writ petition is
dismissed as withdrawn qua petitioner No.7 only. He further submits that
the petitioners were appointed as part-time Class-IV employees on
27.10.1997 and they were regularized on 10.09.2019 as is discernible
from Annexure P-2.
5. Learned counsel for the petitioner in CWP-37581-2026,
inter alia, contends that the petitioners were appointed on 24.09.2002 and
their services were regularized on 14.08.2014 (Annexure P-2).
6. At this stage, learned counsels for the petitioner(s) confines
their prayer only to the extent that since the petitioners have joined the
services prior to 01.01.2006, their case(s) be considered for OPS in the
light of judgment rendered by Full Bench of this Court in Kesar Chand
vs. State of Haryana and others, 1988 (2) PLR 223 ; Harbans Lal vs.
State of Punjab and others, 2012 (3) SCT 362 .
7. Per contra, learned State counsel submits that the petitioners
were initially appointed on part-time/daily wage/ad hoc basis and were
regularized thereafter on above-mentioned dates. However, they are not
in a position to controvert the fact that the past service rendered by the
petitioners is required to be counted in terms of the aforementioned
judgments. He further contends that in case the facts mentioned in the
PARUL VERMA
2026.11.17 13:07
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this
order/judgment
CWP-37479-2026, CWP-37497-2026 & CWP-37581-2026
4
present petition remain undisputed, then the petitioners would be granted
the benefit of Old Pension Scheme (OPS) upon verification.
8. I have heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the
record with their able assistance.
9. From the perusal of the record, it is apparent that the
petitioners were initially engaged on part-time/daily wage/ad hoc basis
and were subsequently regularized pursuant to the applicable
regularization policy.
10. The issue involved in this petition is no longer res integra .
This Court, in Kesar Chand (supra), Harbans (supra); Jai Bhagwan,
2024 NCPHHC 095763 ; and Om Parkash v. State of Haryana and
others, CWP-20263-2024, has held that pre-regularization part-
time/daily wage/ad hoc/temporary service, followed by regular service,
is liable to be counted as qualifying service for the purpose of pensionary
benefits.
11. The same view is also supported by Zile Singh vs. State of
Haryana (CWP-626-2015), decided on 17.03.2015 , which was upheld in
LPA-426-2016, State of Haryana and others vs. Zile Singh, decided on
18.03.2016 , and Jai Bhagwan's case (supra) . Recently, the Hon'ble
Supreme Court in Punjab School Education Board and another vs.
Satnam Singh and others, Civil Appeal No.6865 of 2022, 2026 INSC
965 , has also held that pre-regularization contract/ad hoc/daily-wage
service is liable to be counted as qualifying service for pension, subject
to the applicable facts and law. The operative part of the judgment
PARUL VERMA
2026.11.17 13:07
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this
order/judgment
CWP-37479-2026, CWP-37497-2026 & CWP-37581-2026
5
rendered by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Satnam Singh’s case (supra) ,
reads as follows:
26. Once it is established that the services were
regularized, it remains to be seen whether the service
rendered prior to August 2004 must be counted as
qualifying service for the purpose of retiral benefits.
In this regard, the relevant provisions of the
applicable Punjab School Education Board
(Employees' Pension, Provident Fund and Gratuity)
Regulations, 1991 are reproduced below:
"3. Only such Board employees shall qualify for
pension who were holding substantively
permanent posts on the date of their retirement.
(...)
5. Unless there is anything repugnant in the
subject or context the terms used in these
regulations shall be used in the sense here-in-
alter explained:-
(...)
(i). 'Qualifying Service' generally includes all
periods spent on duty without interruption and
all periods of leave in which leave salary is
paid."
Moreover, Regulation 8(2) states that:
"Pensionary benefits shall be determined with
reference to the qualifying service rendered and
the emoluments/average emoluments last
drawn by him."
27. On the strength of these provisions, we may
briefly re-examine the issue. To quote from the
seminal decision in D.S. Nakara & Others v. Union of
India, 1982 INSC 103, pension is neither a bounty nor
ex-gratia payment but a payment for the past service
rendered. The Constitution Bench of this Court in D.S.
Nakara (supra) had also rightly observed that
payment of pension is a social welfare measure
rendering socio-economic justice. As the above-
mentioned provisions, too, codify, pension is a
deferred wage that must be assessed and paid on the
basis of the service rendered by the employee. When
an employee has rendered long and continuous
service, and stands ultimately regularized, denial of
pensionary benefits based on technicalities or
artificialities is generally unjustified.
28. We note that the respondent-employees have
contended that the question of whether pre-
PARUL VERMA
2026.11.17 13:07
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this
order/judgment
CWP-37479-2026, CWP-37497-2026 & CWP-37581-2026
6
regularization service should be counted toward
qualifying service for pensionary benefits has already
been conclusively settled in a plethora of judgments
and even in an analogous factual matrix by the same
High Court in Harbans Lal v. The State of Punjab &
Others, 2010 SCC OnLine P&H 8181 vide its
decision dated 31.08.2010. Said decision was
ultimately affirmed by a Division Bench of this Court
in SLP (C) No.23578 of 2012. Respondent-employees
also draw our attention to the fact that Harbans Lal
(supra) itself relies on a Full Bench judgment of the
High Court pertaining to a similar controversy,
namely Kesar Chand v. State of Punjab etc. AIR 1988
P&H 265.
29. We find that the Division Bench had
correctly placed reliance on Harbans Lal (supra). To
recapitulate, in that case, the concerned employee
was initially appointed as a Pump Operator on
01.08.1988 on a daily-wage basis. His services were
regularized on 28.03.2005. Pursuant to the direction
of the State Government dated 30.05.2008, the Chief
Engineer had directed that GPF deductions be
stopped for workers (including said employee) who
had entered Government service before 01.01.2004
but were regularized afterwards. The High Court in
those facts had held that the daily-wage service from
1988 until regularization had to be counted as
qualifying service for pension. Because that service
began before 01.01.2004, he was deemed to have
entered Government service before the cut-off date.
Consequently, the new Defined Contribution Pension
Scheme did not apply to him. The High Court further
held that the 30.05.2008 clarification could not
amend or override the statutory amendment to the
Punjab Civil Services Rules, and the employee
therefore remained governed by the GPF Scheme and
was entitled to the pensionary benefits applicable to
Punjab Government employees recruited before
01.01.2004.
30. Here, too, the Single Judge and Division
Bench had rightly held that the services by
respondent-employees rendered on contract/ad
hoc/daily wage basis prior to regularization must be
computed as qualifying service for the purpose of
retiral and pension benefits. The breaks in service
were either 'notional' or artificial/administrative
breaks, or precipitated by Court orders. They must be
ignored and the service should be treated as
continuous.
PARUL VERMA
2026.11.17 13:07
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this
order/judgment
CWP-37479-2026, CWP-37497-2026 & CWP-37581-2026
7
31. The fact that the appellant-Board is an
autonomous body cannot come to its rescue; in fact,
the High Court on 14.12.2001 had upheld that it was
free to adopt or reject the Government Policy dated
23.01.2001, despite it being made expressly
applicable to public sector undertakings,
corporations, boards, local authorities and other
autonomous bodies in the State of Punjab. The
appellant-Board had thereafter voluntarily adopted
the policy mutatis mutandis. In fact, we also find that
this dimension i.e., mutatis mutandis rather than
wholesale adoption, also negatives the appellant-
Board's various contentions such as that the
respondent-employees had to qualify a typewriting
test, complete one year probation period, produce
medical certificate, etc. as this merely indicates
suitable amendment of the regularization policy to
meet the appellant-Board's needs and not fresh
appointment per se.
32. We note that respondent-employees have
also drawn our attention to the fact that employees
similarly situated in other departments have been
granted identical relief by the High Court itself and to
hold the respondents, ineligible now would be prima
facie discriminatory.
33. On a cumulative assessment of the material
on record, therefore, we are satisfied that the
decisions of the Courts below are legally sound and
based on correct application of law to facts, and there
is no illegality or infirmity that would warrant our
interference in appeal. The respondent-employees
were indeed regularized and are entitled to be treated
as having entered Government service prior to
01.01.2004 and therefore fall under Tier II of the
Defined Contributory Pension Scheme. They have the
discretion to choose either the old GPF pension
scheme or the new scheme, if they opt for it.
34. The Appeal is accordingly dismissed. There
shall be no order as to costs.
12. In view of the aforesaid settled position, the respondents
cannot exclude the petitioner's continuous pre-regularization service
while determining qualifying service for the purpose of pensionary
benefits.
13. Accordingly, the present petition is allowed . The
respondents are directed to count the petitioners’ service from the date of
PARUL VERMA
2026.11.17 13:07
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this
order/judgment
CWP-37479-2026, CWP-37497-2026 & CWP-37581-2026
8
initial engagement on part-time/daily wage/ ad hoc basis till
regularization, followed by regular service, as qualifying service for the
purpose of pension and other retiral benefits.
14. The petitioner shall consequently be entitled to the benefit of
the Old Pension Scheme (OPS), subject to verification of the dates and
factual particulars of initial engagement and regularization. Upon such
verification, the respondents shall re-fix the petitioners’ pensionary/retiral
benefits and release the consequential benefits within a period of 03
months from the date of receipt of a certified copy of this order.
15. It is made clear that any amount already contributed or paid
under the New Pension Scheme (NPS) shall be adjusted in accordance
with law.
16. Pending miscellaneous applications, if any, also stand
disposed of.
17. Photocopy of this order be placed on the files of connected
case(s).
(HARPREET SINGH BRAR)
JUDGE
16.11.2026
parul verma
Whether speaking/reasoned: Yes/No
Whether reportable: Yes/No
PARUL VERMA
2026.11.17 13:07
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this
order/judgment