UNION TERRITORY OF J AND K AND OTHERS (REVENUE) vs HOTEL NEW METRO

Court
Jammu and Kashmir High Court


HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT SRINAGAR
LPA No. 137/2026

Reserved on 12.11.2026
Pronounced on 17.11.2026
Uploaded on 17.11.2026
Whether the operative part or
full judgment is pronounced: - Full
1. Union Territory of J&K Through

Commissioner/ Secretary Revenue, Civil

Secretariat, Jammu/Srinagar;



2. Deputy Commissioner, Srinagar

Tankipora, Srinagar;



3. Committee of Officers constituted vide

order dated 05.11.2022 through Sub-

Divisional Magistrate (East Srinagar)
Tankipora, Srinagar;



4. Sub-Divisional Magistrate (East Srinagar)

Tankipora, Srinagar;


5. Tehsildar Khanyar, Srinagar
… Appellants
Mr. Mohsin Qadri, Sr. AAG with
Through:
Ms. Maha Majeed, Assisting Counsel
Vs.
Hotel New Metro

Bishember Nagar Srinagar through its Prop.

Hajj Khazir Mohammad Dar (Aged 85 years)




...Respondent
Through: Mr. Jahangir Iqbal Ganai, Sr. Advocate with
Arif Hameed
Mr. Kamil Nazir, Advocate I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this document
S/o Kh. Mohammad Abdullah Dar
R/o Rajbagh, Srinagar;

17.11.2026 16:20
LPA No. 137/2026 1 | P a g e


CORAM:
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJEEV KUMAR, JUDGE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE MOHD YOUSUF WANI, JUDGE
JUDGEMENT

Per Sanjeev Kumar-J

1. The appellants are aggrieved of and challenge an order and
th
judgment dated 11 February, 2026 passed by the learned
Single Judge of this Court [“the writ Court”] in WP(C) No.
590/2023 titled “Hotel New Metro Vs. Union Territory of
Jammu and Kashmir and others
”, whereby the writ Court
has allowed the writ petition filed by the respondent and,
th
by a writ of certiorari, quashed the order dated 5
th
November, 2022, and the report of the Committee dated 10
February, 2023. The writ Court has further directed the
appellants herein to liquidate claims of the respondent
within a period of eight weeks from the date a copy of the
judgment was made available to the appellants.
2.
Before we advert to the grounds of challenge urged by the
appellants, it would be appropriate to first set out few facts
as are germane to the disposal of this appeal.
3.
Pursuant to an order issued by the Divisional
Commissioner, Kashmir, the hotel of the respondent was
hired for accommodating some Sarpanches, Panches, PRI
Members, Municipal Councillors and PPS, etc., w.e.f
Arif Hameed
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this document
17.11.2026 16:20
LPA No. 137/2026 2 | P a g e

15.11.2020 on a sharing basis. The hotel of the respondent
was hired with a room rent of Rs. 356 per day per room,
with catering charges @ Rs. 225/- per head per day during
summer season, and a room rent of Rs. 242/- per day per
room, with catering charges of Rs. 216/- per head per day
during the winter season. The respondent claims that
pursuant to the hiring and occupation of his hotel, bills
were submitted to the office of the Divisional
Commissioner, Kashmir against proper receipts for
payment.
4. The hotel of the respondent, which was hired by the orders
of the Divisional Commissioner, Kashmir was de-hired
w.e.f 05.10.2021. It is claimed that against the bills submitted
for the period commencing from 15.11.2020 to 05.10.2021,
some amount was paid, whereas the balance amount was
under process. The respondent obviously had no grievance
or dispute with the office of the Divisional Commissioner,
Kashmir on account of hiring and catering charges for the
period commencing from 15.11.2020 to 05.10.2021, on which
date the hotel of the respondent was de-hired.

5. The 19 rooms of the hotel of the respondent were again
hired, this time by the office of the Deputy Commissioner,
Srinagar, in terms of its communication No.
Arif Hameed
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this document
17.11.2026 16:20
LPA No. 137/2026 3 | P a g e

th
DMS/JUD/accommodation/459-473/21 dated 27
October, 2021. These 19 rooms of the hotel of the respondent
remained under the occupation of the various protected
th
persons accommodated by the appellants till 25 October,
2022. The re-hiring of the hotel accommodation of the
respondent was as per the terms and conditions already
decided by the Divisional Commissioner, Kashmir, at the
time of hiring the hotel of the respondent.

6. After the hotel of the respondent was vacated by the
appellants, the respondent submitted his boarding and
lodging bills to the Deputy Commissioner, Srinagar for
release of payment. Instead of clearing the bills and
releasing the payment in favour of the respondent, the
Deputy Commissioner, Srinagar, constituted a Committee
under the Chairmanship of the Sub-Divisional Magistrate
(East Srinagar) for verification of the bills submitted by
various hotel owners, including the respondent, whose
hotels had been hired pursuant to the orders of the Deputy
Commissioner, Srinagar, for accommodating the protected
th
persons with effect from 5 October, 2021. The decision to
constitute the Committee for verification of the bills was
taken by the Deputy Commissioner pursuant to the
directions issued by the Financial Commissioner
Arif Hameed
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this document
17.11.2026 16:20
LPA No. 137/2026 4 | P a g e

(Additional Chief Secretary), Home Department, in a
th
meeting held on 18 January, 2023. The Committee, after
scrutinizing the records, including the daily entry and exit
records of the protected persons, submitted its report
indicating the actual occupancy of the hotel rooms of the
respondent and, accordingly, the Deputy Commissioner
cleared the bills of the respondent on the basis of actual
occupancy and not on the basis of the rental for all the 19
rooms hired for accommodating the protected persons.
7.
Feeling aggrieved by the action of the appellants in
reducing the boarding and lodging charges for the hotel
rooms hired by the appellants, the respondent filed a writ
petition, being WP(C) 590/2023, before the learned Single
Judge of this Court, specifically seeking a writ of certiorari
th
for quashing the order dated 5 November, 2022, whereby
a Committee was constituted to verify the bills on the basis
of actual occupancy. The respondent also prayed for writ of
certiorari for quashing the report submitted by the
Committee and a mandamus to direct the appellants herein
to clear the pending liability towards the respondent in
respect of his hotel.
8. From a reading of the entire writ petition, it is abundantly
clear that in his petition the respondent had restricted his
Arif Hameed
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this document
17.11.2026 16:20
LPA No. 137/2026 5 | P a g e

claim to the hiring and catering charges pertaining to the
th
period commencing from 27 October, 2021 (when the hotel
of the respondent was re-hired by the Deputy
th
Commissioner) till 25 October, 2022 (when it was vacated).
The genesis of the entire dispute raised in the writ petition
was that the respondent was entitled to hiring and catering
charges in respect of all the 19 rooms for the said period,
irrespective of whether or not the rooms were actually
occupied and used by the protected persons for whom the
hotel accommodation had been hired.
9. It is also interesting to know that the Divisional
Commissioner, Kashmir or for that matter the
Administrative Department of Home were not arrayed as
party respondents in the writ petition. This was done by the
respondent for an obvious reason that the dispute pertained
to the period when the hotel rooms of the respondent
remained hired by the Deputy Commissioner, though on
the terms and conditions set out and fixed by the Divisional
Commissioner, Kashmir, from time to time.

10. The writ petition was contested by the appellants, who in
their reply affidavit contended that though, in terms of
orders issued by the Deputy Commissioner, various hotels,
including the hotel of the respondent, had been hired for
Arif Hameed
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this document
17.11.2026 16:20
LPA No. 137/2026 6 | P a g e

th
accommodating the protected persons w.e.f. 27 October,
2021 to 25th October, 2022, yet the payment to be released
was subject to due verification of the bills and the actual
occupancy of the rooms hired.
11. During the pendency of the writ petition, the respondent
also filed a supplementary affidavit, raising a claim for the
balance amount due to him on account of hiring and
catering charges for the period commencing from
15.11.2020, till 05.10.2021. However, neither the writ
petition was formally amended nor the hiring authority,
i.e., Divisional Commissioner, Kashmir was arrayed as
party respondent.
12.
The writ Court, having considered the entire gamut of
controversy raised in the writ petition as well as in the
supplementary affidavit and considering the objections
filed by the appellants, allowed the writ petition filed by the
respondent. The writ Court not only quashed the order
dated 05.11.2022 and the report submitted by the
Committee dated 10.02.2023, but also directed the
appellants to liquidate all the claims of respondent for the
period commencing from 15.11.2020 to 25.10.2022. Thus, the
period during which the hotel remained hired by the
Divisional Commissioner was also included for the purpose
Arif Hameed
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this document
17.11.2026 16:20
LPA No. 137/2026 7 | P a g e

of releasing hiring and catering charges in favour of the
respondent.
th

13. The impugned judgment dated 11 February, 2026 passed
by the writ Court, is challenged by the appellants primarily
on the ground that the writ Court has travelled beyond the
scope of the writ petition and has granted the relief which
was not prayed for. It is contended that the respondent had
not raised any dispute with regard to hiring and catering
charges for the period during which his hotel remained
hired pursuant to the orders of the Divisional
Commissioner, Kashmir, that is the first spell of hiring.
However, the writ Court, by placing reliance upon the
supplementary affidavit, to which the Divisional
Commissioner had no opportunity to rebut or contest,
allowed the claim for the aforesaid period as well.
14. The impugned judgment is also called in question on the
ground that the writ Court failed to appreciate that the
respondent was not entitled to any hiring or catering
charges for the rooms which were not occupied by the
protected persons for whom the hotel in question had been
hired.
15. It is argued that once a room has not been used and the food
Arif Hameed
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this document
has not taken by the protected person, the State cannot be
17.11.2026 16:20
LPA No. 137/2026 8 | P a g e

made liable to pay rental and the catering charges qua the
said room.

16. Having heard learned counsel for the parties and perused
the material on record, we are of the considered opinion
that the judgment impugned, insofar as it pertains to the
period commencing from 15.11.2020, when the hotel of the
respondent was hired by the Divisional Commissioner,
Kashmir, till 05.10.2021, when the hotel was de-hired and
vacated, is not sustainable in law. We are saying so because
there was no case in this regard set up by the respondent in
the writ petition. It is true that in the writ petition there was
a reference to the pending payment on account of hiring
and catering charges in respect of a period commencing
from 15.11.2020 till 05.10.2021. However, no prayer seeking
release of the said amount was made in the writ petition.
17. Rather, it was the case of the respondent that part payment
for the aforesaid period had been released by the office of
the Divisional Commissioner, whereas the balance
payment due to the respondent was under process and
pending consideration before the Divisional Commissioner.
The relevant extract of paragraph 5 of the writ petition
deserves attention and is, therefore, set out below:
Arif Hameed
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this document
17.11.2026 16:20
LPA No. 137/2026 9 | P a g e

“……….it is further submitted that on the
strength of the order bearing No. 361-
Divcom/estt of 2021 dated 1st October, 2021 all
the 14 hotels hired were ordered to be de-hired
w.e.f 5th October, 2021 and in the meantime,
petitioner sought payment on account of boarding
and lodging charges for the said period and
payment due from the office of the Divisional
Commissioner is in the process of being disbursed
as had been disbursed in favour of other hoteliers
who had provided accommodation.”

18. From the above narration, it is evident that the respondent
did not contemplate any dispute with the office of the
Divisional Commissioner, Kashmir, in respect of boarding
and lodging charges for the period commencing from
15.11.2020 to 05.10.2021 and, therefore, neither arrayed the
Divisional Commissioner, Kashmir as party respondent nor
made a prayer for disbursement of the balance amount due
to him from the office of the Divisional Commissioner. It
seems that the aforesaid period came to be introduced
through the medium of the supplementary affidavit filed by
the respondent, wherein a claim for the period commencing
from 15.11.2020 to 05.10.2021 was raised for the first time.

19. Neither the writ petition was amended to include the
aforesaid claim nor the Divisional Commissioner, Kashmir
was made party respondent. In these circumstances, the
Arif Hameed
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this document
17.11.2026 16:20
LPA No. 137/2026 10 | P a g e

claim which could have been lodged against the Divisional
Commissioner could not be contested by the said authority.
The writ Court, therefore, committed an error in allowing
the said claim without even affording an opportunity of
hearing to the Divisional Commissioner, the competent
authority, who was supposed to disburse the amount for
the period commencing from 15.11.2020 to 05.10.2021.
20. The direction of the writ Court, insofar as it pertains to
liquidation of the liability of the respondent for the
aforesaid period is concerned, is certainly beyond the scope
of the writ petition and is otherwise in breach of the
principles of natural justice.
21.
So far as the claim of the respondent for payment of
boarding and lodging charges on the basis of actual hiring
rather than actual occupancy is concerned, we need to
examine the matter in the light of the order of
allotment/hiring passed by the Deputy Commissioner,
Srinagar. As per the order of the Deputy Commissioner,
th
Srinagar, dated 27 October 2021, 19 rooms of the hotel
belonging to the respondent were hired for accommodating
the protected persons, like Sarpanches, Councillors, DDC
Members, Contesting Candidates, etc., of the District
Srinagar. The 19 rooms of the hotel belonging to the
Arif Hameed
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this document
17.11.2026 16:20
LPA No. 137/2026 11 | P a g e

respondent were hired on the terms and conditions already
decided by the office of the Divisional Commissioner, i.e.,
room rent of Rs. 356/- per day per room and catering
charges Rs. 225/- per head per day during summer season,
and room rent Rs. 242/- per day per room and catering
charges of Rs. 216/- per head per day during the winter
season. This is obvious from the Circular of the Divisional
th
Commissioner, Kashmir dated 7 November, 2020.

22. Indisputably, the 19 rooms of the respondent’s hotel were
hired and there was no stipulation in the order of the
th
Deputy Commissioner, Srinagar, dated 27 October, 2021
that the rental/hiring charges would be paid on the basis of
actual occupancy. In the absence of any such clear
th
stipulation in the hiring order dated 27 October, 2021,
passed by the Deputy Commissioner, Srinagar, the
respondent was under an obligation to keep all the 19
rooms un-booked and ready for accommodating all the 38
protected persons named in the order itself.
23. It is not the case of the appellants that the hotel owner, i.e.,
respondent herein, could have hired the rooms which were
not actually occupied by the named protected persons to
the guests and strangers. That being the clear position
emerging from the reading of the order of the Deputy
Arif Hameed
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this document
17.11.2026 16:20
LPA No. 137/2026 12 | P a g e

th
Commissioner, Srinagar dated 27 October, 2021, it would
be highly unjustified and rather ridiculous to say that the
respondent was entitled to receive the rental/hiring
charges on the basis of actual occupancy and not in respect
of all the 19 rooms which remained hired during the period
commencing from 27.10.2021 till 25.10.2022.

24. The report of the Committee, determining actual occupancy
of the rooms and recommending the payment of rentals
only for the period during which the hired rooms remained
under the actual occupation of the protected persons, is
untenable and without any justification. However, we are
of the considered opinion that the payment on account of
catering charges cannot be claimed by the respondent in
respect of all the 38 protected persons. The catering charges
would be payable on the basis of the number of persons
who actually availed themselves of the food services in the
hotel. The order of the Deputy Commissioner, read with the
Circular of the Divisional Commissioner dated 07.11.2020,
makes it clear that catering charges are payable per head per
day. This would mean that if twenty persons availed
themselves of the catering/food services in the hotel, the
respondent would be entitled to charge the amount fixed by
the Divisional Commissioner per head, i.e., for twenty
Arif Hameed
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this document
17.11.2026 16:20
LPA No. 137/2026 13 | P a g e

persons only. Food is prepared by the hotel keeping in view
the number of guests staying therein. It is not the case of the
respondent that he was made to prepare food for all the 38
persons every day, despite the fact that some of the
protected persons who had been allotted the
accommodation in the hotel did not actually occupy the
rooms.
25. Viewed thus, we find substance in the argument of Mr.
Mohsin Qadri, learned Sr. AAG, that catering charges could
not be paid for all the 38 protected persons named in the
allotment letter. Rather, these charges would be payable on
a per head per day basis and as per the actual number of
protected persons availing themselves of the food services
in the hotel.

26. For the forgoing reasons, we allow this appeal partially and
dispose it of by providing as under:

a. The judgment of the writ Court is set aside so
far as it pertains to boarding and lodging
charges for the period commencing from
15.11.2020 when the hotel of the respondent
was hired by the Divisional Commissioner,
Kashmir, till 05.10.2021, when it was de-
hired.
Arif Hameed
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this document
17.11.2026 16:20
LPA No. 137/2026 14 | P a g e


b. The respondent would be at liberty to claim
boarding and lodging charges, if any, due for
the aforesaid period from the office of the
Divisional Commissioner, Kashmir, by
making a representation.
c. Needless to say that, if any, such
representation is made, the same shall be
considered on its merits and, if any, amount
is found payable to the respondent, the same
shall be disbursed by the Divisional
Commissioner, Kashmir, without any further
delay. In case the respondent feels
dissatisfied and aggrieved, he shall be free to
file fresh writ petition.

d. That the respondent would be entitled to
rental/hiring charges qua all the rooms hired
by the Deputy Commissioner, Srinagar for
the period commencing from 27.10.2021 to
25.10.2022 minus the amount, if any, already
paid for the said period. This payment would
be for all the rooms hired, irrespective
whether these rooms were actually occupied
or not.
Arif Hameed
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this document
17.11.2026 16:20
LPA No. 137/2026 15 | P a g e


e. That the catering charges for the period
commencing from 27.10.2021 till 25.10.2022
shall be payable to the respondent on actual
occupancy basis, i.e., as per the actual heads
availing the catering services in the hotel.
The amount, if any, pending on that count
shall also be released forthwith.
f. The appellants shall consider the claims of
the respondent in the light of this judgment
and make the balance payment within a
period of two months from the date of
judgment, failing which the entire amount
shall become payable along with interest
@ 6% per annum, to be calculated from the
date it fell due till it is actually disbursed.

27. With the aforesaid directions and modifications, the
judgment of the writ Court shall stand modified to the
aforesaid extent.

(Mohd Yousuf Wani) (Sanjeev Kumar)
Judge Judge

SRINAGAR:
17.11.2026
“ARIF”

i. Whether the order is reportable? Yes/No.

ii. Whether the order is speaking? Yes/No
Arif Hameed
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this document
17.11.2026 16:20
LPA No. 137/2026 16 | P a g e