MINOR.GOMATHY, AGE 14 vs P.S.RAMAKRISHNA,

Court
Madras High Court

CMA(MD) NO. 448 of 2014
BEFORE THE MADURAI BENCH OF MADRAS HIGH COURT
Reserved On 21.09.2026
Pronounced On 20.11.2026
CORAM
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE K.K.RAMAKRISHNAN
CMA(MD) NO. 448 of 2014
{CNR: HCMD010824382014}
Case QR
Minor Gomathy
(Rep by her father and next
friend Krishnaswamy) ... Appellant
Vs.
1.P.S.Ramakrishna
2.Divisional Manager,
M/s.United India Insurance Company Ltd.,
Branch Office,
Mettupalayam. ... Respondents
PRAYER:- Civil Miscellaneous Appeal is filed under Section 173 of the Motor
Vehicle Act, 1988, to set aside the Fair and Decretal Order dated 26.03.2004 made in
M.C.O.P. No. 280/1999 on the file of the Additional Motor Accident Claims Tribunal
(Principal Sub Court), Tenkasi.
For Appellant : Mr.S.Sivathilakar
For Respondents : Mr.Royce Emmanuel for R2
1/11
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 05:21:28 pm )

CMA(MD) NO. 448 of 2014
2/11
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 05:21:28 pm )

CMA(MD) NO. 448 of 2014
J U D G M E N T
The claimant in M.C.O.P. No.280 of 1999, on the file of the Motor
Accident Claims Tribunal, Principal Sub Court, Tenkasi, has filed the present
C.M.A.(MD).No.448 of 2014, challenging the dismissal of the claim petition by
judgment dated 26.03.2004.
2. Facts of the case:
3/11
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 05:21:28 pm )

CMA(MD) NO. 448 of 2014
2.1.According to the averments in the claim petition, on 06.07.1998 at about
2.00 p.m., the claimant was standing near the Ooty-Mettupalayam Road. At that time,
a vehicle bearing Registration No.TN-37-K-9246, allegedly belonging to the first
respondent insured with the second respondent, was driven by its driver in a rash and
negligent manner and hit the claimant. Due to the accident, the claimant sustained
injuries and was admitted in the hospital. According to him, on account of the injuries,
she was unable to walk normally and was also unable to continue her studies.
Therefore, she filed the claim petition represented by her father seeking compensation
of Rs.3,00,000/-. It was further stated in the claim petition that an FIR had been
registered in Crime No.299 of 1998 against the first respondent.
2.2.The Insurance Company filed its counter denying the manner of the accident
and disputing the involvement of the insured vehicle. It was specifically contended
that the vehicle number mentioned in the claim petition did not correspond to the
alleged Maruti car and that the said registration number related to a different vehicle,
namely a TVS moped. It was therefore contended that the claim was not genuine and
that the vehicle allegedly involved in the accident was not the vehicle insured with the
Insurance Company.
4/11
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 05:21:28 pm )

CMA(MD) NO. 448 of 2014
2.3.In order to establish her case, the claimant was examined as PW1, PW2 and
PW4 were examined and the relevant documents were marked as Ex.P.1 to Ex.P.9.
P.W.3, the doctor, was also examined and the medical examination
certificate/disability certificate was marked as Ex.X1 dated 23.06.2001. On behalf of
the Insurance Company, R.Ws.1 and 2 were examined and the relevant documents
were marked as Ex.R1 to Ex.R.4.
3.Findings of the Tribunal:
3.1.Upon consideration of the entire evidence, particularly the discrepancy
relating to the registration number and the identity of the vehicle, the Tribunal found
that the claimant had failed to establish the involvement of the insured vehicle and
consequently dismissed the claim petition by judgment dated 26.03.2004.
3.2.Aggrieved by the same, the claimant has preferred the present appeal.
4. Submissions of the learned counsel appearing for the appellant /
claimant:
5/11
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 05:21:28 pm )

CMA(MD) NO. 448 of 2014
4.1.The learned counsel appearing for the appellant/claimant submitted that the
Tribunal failed to properly appreciate the medical evidence and the other materials on
record. According to the learned counsel, the evidence established that the claimant
had sustained injuries in a motor accident and that the vehicle involved was a Maruti
car. Merely because there was an error or discrepancy in the registration number, the
entire claim ought not to have been rejected. It was further submitted that there was
sufficient evidence regarding the involvement of the vehicle and that the Tribunal had
failed to appreciate the same in its proper perspective.
4.2.The learned counsel further submitted that the closure of the criminal case
under Section 468 Cr.P.C. could not, by itself, be a ground for rejecting the claim
petition, particularly when the claim before the Tribunal has to be decided on the basis
of the evidence adduced before it.
5. Submissions of the learned counsel appearing for the second
respondent/Insurance Company:
6/11
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 05:21:28 pm )

CMA(MD) NO. 448 of 2014
5.1.Per contra, the learned counsel appearing for the Insurance Company
submitted that the Tribunal had dismissed the claim petition only after appreciating
the evidence on record. The material defect in the claimant's case was the failure to
establish the identity and involvement of the vehicle. It was pointed out that the
registration number mentioned in the FIR was TN-37-K-9237, whereas the
registration number mentioned in the claim petition was TN-37-K-9246. It was further
submitted that the registration number mentioned in the claim petition did not
correspond to Maruti car allegedly involved in the accident and that the Insurance
Company had not insured such a vehicle. Therefore, the learned counsel submitted
that the finding of the Tribunal did not warrant interference.
6.This Court considered the rival submissions and perused the materials
available on record.
7.Discussion and findings:
7.1.The following point arises for determination:
Whether the claimant has established that the vehicle insured with the second
respondent was involved in the accident in question?
7.2.The burden was on the claimant to establish, at least on the basis of the
evidence available before the Tribunal, that the vehicle insured with the second
respondent was involved in the accident and that the injuries sustained by her arose
out of the use of such vehicle.
7/11
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 05:21:28 pm )

CMA(MD) NO. 448 of 2014
7.3.In the present case, there is a material discrepancy with regard to the very
identity of the vehicle. The FIR refers to the vehicle registration number as TN-37-K-
9237 and describes it as a Maruti car. However, in the claim petition, the vehicle
number is stated as TN-37-K-9246. Thus, the registration number mentioned in the
FIR and the registration number mentioned in the claim petition are materially
different.
7.4.The discrepancy does not remain confined to a mere typographical error.
The materials relating to the motor vehicle inspection also refer to a different
registration number. The vehicle corresponding to the number stated in the claim
petition is not shown to be the Maruti car allegedly involved in the accident.
Consequently, the identity of the vehicle itself has not been satisfactorily established.
It is true that the mere closure of a criminal case cannot, by itself, determine the rights
of the parties in a claim proceeding under the Motor Vehicles Act. The Tribunal is
required to independently assess the evidence placed before it. However, in the
present case, the issue is not merely the closure of the criminal case. The major
difficulty faced by the claimant is that the documentary evidence does not consistently
identify the vehicle allegedly involved in the accident.
8/11
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 05:21:28 pm )

CMA(MD) NO. 448 of 2014
7.5.The FIR mentions one registration number, whereas the claim petition
mentions another. There is also no subsequent investigation or final report placed
before the Tribunal establishing that the vehicle bearing the registration number
mentioned in the FIR was involved in the accident and that the same vehicle was
insured with the second respondent.
7.6.The medical evidence may establish that the claimant sustained injuries and
underwent treatment. However, the medical evidence by itself cannot establish the
identity or involvement of the particular motor vehicle in question. In the absence of
reliable evidence connecting the injuries with the vehicle insured by the second
respondent, no liability can be fastened on the Insurance Company.
7.7.The claimant has therefore failed to establish the essential fact that the
vehicle insured with the second respondent was involved in the accident. The
discrepancies in the registration numbers, coupled with the absence of supporting
evidence establishing the identity of the vehicle, create a irreconcilable gap in the
claimant's case.
7.8.In such circumstances, this Court finds no sufficient ground to interfere with
the well-considered finding of the Tribunal. The dismissal of the claim petition cannot
be faulted.
8.Results:
9/11
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 05:21:28 pm )

CMA(MD) NO. 448 of 2014
8.1.In the result, the Civil Miscellaneous Appeal is dismissed , confirming the
judgment and decree dated 26.03.2004 passed in M.C.O.P. No.280 of 1999 by the
Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Principal Sub Court, Tenkasi. There shall be no
order as to costs.
20.11.2026
NCC :Yes/No
Index :Yes/No
Internet :Yes/No
aas
To
1.The Motor Accident Claims Tribunal,
The Principal Sub Court, Tenkasi.
2.The Section Officer,
VR Section,
Madurai Bench of Madras High Court, Madurai.
10/11
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 05:21:28 pm )

K.K.RAMAKRISHNAN,J.
aas
C.M.A.(MD).No.448 of 2014
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 05:21:28 pm )