Darshan Kaur And Ors. vs Swaranjit Singh And Ors.

Court
Punjab and Haryana High Court

-1-
117 IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA AT
CHANDIGARH
FAO-2311-2003
Date of Decision: 16.11.2026
DARSHAN KAUR AND ORS.
...Appellants
Versus
SWARANJIT SINGH AND ORS.
...Respondents
CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE PARMOD GOYAL
Present: None for the appellants.
Mr. Gopal Mittal, Advocate &
Mr. Simranjot Singh, Advocate
for respondent No.3-Insurance Company.

PARMOD GOYAL, J. (ORAL)
Present appeal has been preferred by appellants-claimants [wife
and (four) children] seeking enhancement in compensation awarded vide
award dated 08.01.2003 passed by learned Motor Accident Claims Tribunal,
Ludhiana (hereinafter referred to as ‘ Tribunal ’), whereby appellants-
claimants were awarded total compensation of Rs.2,37,600/- on account of
death of Jaswant Singh (hereinafter referred to as ‘ deceased ’) in motor
vehicular accident dated 20.03.2000 allegedly caused due to rash and
negligent driving of respondent-driver while driving truck bearing
registration No.PB-13-2107 (hereinafter referred to as ‘ offending vehicle ’).
2. Learned Tribunal while allowing claim petition under Section
RAVINDER DHANIA
2026.11.18 09:23
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

FAO-2311-2003 -2-
166 and Section 140 of Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 had found the deceased as
well as respondent No.1 to be rash and negligent in causing the accident and
held the deceased liable for contributory negligence to the extent of 50% .
3. In the present case, learned Tribunal had awarded the following
compensation to appellants-claimants:
Income Rs.5,000/- per month
Deduction 1/3rd
Multiplier 12
Loss of dependency Rs.4,75,200/-
(Rs.3,300/- x 12 x 12)
50% deduction towards contributory
Rs.2,37,600/-
negligence
Total compensation Rs.2,37,600/-
4. Learned counsel for the appellants-claimants has sought
enhancement of compensation on the following grounds:
•
That the learned Tribunal has erred in not assessing the income
of the deceased as pleaded and proved by the claimants.
•
That the learned Tribunal has failed to apply the correct
multiplier, as per age of deceased.
•
That the deduction towards the personal and living expenses of
the deceased is excessive and contrary to the settled principles of
law.
•
That no addition towards future prospects has been made while
calculating the loss of dependency. Future prospects ought to
have been added, as per age of deceased.
•
That the learned Tribunal has also failed to award just and
appropriate compensation under the conventional heads, namely
funeral expenses, loss of estate, and loss of spousal, parental, and
filial consortium, in accordance with the law laid down by the
Hon'ble Supreme Court.
5. In the present case, Appellants-claimants have challenged the
findings of learned Tribunal on both the issues i.e. issue Nos.1 and 2.
RAVINDER DHANIA
2026.11.18 09:23
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

FAO-2311-2003 -3-
Appellants-claimants have claimed that accident was result of sole rash and
negligent driving of respondent-driver while driving offending vehicle and
learned Tribunal had wrongly held the deceased liable for contributory
negligence only on the basis of fact that accident had taken place head on .
6. It is the case of appellants-claimants that on 20.03.2000,
deceased along with Tarlochan Singh, Manjit Singh, Hardev Singh and
others were coming from Anandpur Sahib Gurdwara in Tata Safari bearing
registration No.PB-10AH-4101 being driven by Tejinder Singh alias Pappa.
That when they reached near Bajigar Basti Katani Kalan, District Ludhiana,
offending vehicle being driven by respondent No.1-Swaranjit Singh in rash
and negligent manner came from Ludhiana side and struck against the Tata
safari. Resultantly, Tejinder Singh alias Pappa and deceased-Jaswant Singh
had suffered multiple injuries and had died. It was claimed that the accident
had taken place on account of sole rash and negligent driving of truck
bearing registration No.PB-13-2107. The manner of accident was denied by
respondent Nos.1 and 2.
7. From the pleadings of the parties, following issues were
framed:-
“1. Whether Jaswant Singh died in a motor vehicle accident
on 20.03.2000 at about 9:30 P.M. in the area of Bajigar
Basti, Katani Ludhiana on account of rash and negligent
driving of truck bearing registration No.PB-13-2107 by
respondent No.1?OPP
2. Whether the claimants are entitled to be compensated for
the death of Jaswant Singh. If so by whom and to what
extent?
3. Relief.
8. In order to prove manner of accident, appellants-claimants had
RAVINDER DHANIA
2026.11.18 09:23
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

FAO-2311-2003 -4-
examined one of the occupants of Tata safari and author of FIR Ex.A1
Hardev Singh as AW-3, who had clearly stated that the accident had taken
place on account of rash and negligent driving of truck bearing registration
No.PB-13-2107 driven by respondent-driver rashly and negligently on the
wrong side of the road and which had struck against Tata safari on account
of which deceased had died.
9. It is pertinent to note that respondent-driver had not stepped into
the witness box to state the manner of accident. However, learned Tribunal
after taking into consideration evidence of AW-3, held that the drivers of
both the vehicles were liable for contributory negligence as the accident had
occured due to head on collision.
10. On consideration, I find merit in the present appeal. There is no
principle of law that whenever two vehicles coming from opposite side
collide head on then in said case, drivers of both the vehicles would be liable
for causing the accident. Factum of contributory negligence is dependent
upon facts and circumstances of each case and can only be determined by
appreciating the evidence in the given case. No automatic finding of
contributory negligence can be recorded merely because accident was head
on. The finding of contributory negligence is based upon contribution made
by act of omission or commission of each of the driver involved in the
accident.
11. In present case, AW-3 had clearly stated that accident was
result of sole rash and negligent driving on the part of respondent-driver
while driving offending truck. The evidence of AW-3, that it was
respondent-driver who was rash and negligent and was driving his vehicle at
high speed and had hit the vehicle in which deceased was travelling after
RAVINDER DHANIA
2026.11.18 09:23
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

FAO-2311-2003 -5-
coming to wrong side cannot be challenged especially when respondent-
driver had not dared to step into the witness box for disclosing the manner of
occurrence as was claimed by him in his written statement.
12. The evidence of AW-3 in present case has gone unrebutted
from which it is clearly made out that the accident was result of sole rash
and negligent driving on the part of respondent-driver. Merely because
accident was head on collision, therefore, finding of learned Tribunal on
contributory negligence cannot be sustained and is set aside. Therefore, it is
held that accident had taken place on account of sole rash and negligent
driving of truck bearing registration No.PB-13-2107 and accordingly, issue
No.1 is decided in favour of appellants-claimants.
13. In the present case Appellants-claimants have claimed that the
deceased was aged 42 years at the time of accident and was earning
Rs.10,000/- per month by running his own factory. In order to prove pleaded
income and vocation of deceased appellants-claimants had examined Ranjit
Singh as AW-2, who stated that the deceased was running a workshop under
the name and style of M/s Jaswant Workshop and earning Rs.10,000/- per
month. AW-2 further admitted that the income of deceased disclosed by him
to be Rs.10,000/-per month is only a guess work. No documentary
evidence/material in shape of income tax return was placed on record by the
appellants-claimants to show the income of deceased from the factory
owned by him. Therefore, in absence of any cogent and reliable evidence to
show pleaded income and vocation of deceased, learned Tribunal had rightly
taken the income of deceased to be Rs.5,000/- per month after considering
income of skilled worker in the year 2000. Accordingly, income of deceased
taken by learned Tribunal is upheld.
RAVINDER DHANIA
2026.11.18 09:23
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

FAO-2311-2003 -6-
14. Since deceased was aged 42 years at the time of accident, he
would be entitled to addition of 25% towards future prospects in view of
judgment passed by Hon’ble Supreme Court in National Insurance
Company Ltd. Vs. Pranay Sethi and Ors. , 2017 (16) SCC 680. In view of
age of deceased to be 42 years, multiplier of ‘14’ would be applicable as per
judgment passed by Hon’ble Supreme Court in Smt. Sarla Verma & Ors.
Vs. Delhi Transport Corporation & Anr. , 2009(6) SCC 121. Similarly,
deduction towards personal expenses has to be made on the basis of number
of dependents which are five in present case i.e. wife and four children.
Accordingly, deduction to the extent of 1/4th shall be applicable.
15. The loss of dependency, therefore, has to be determined by
taking monthly income of deceased to be Rs.5,000/- by adding future
prospects to the extent of 25% , by applying multiplier of ‘14’ and by
making deduction of 1/4th towards personal expenses.
16. Apart from compensation for loss of dependency, appellants-
claimants shall also be entitled to Rs . 15,000 /- towards funeral expenses and
Rs . 15,000 /- towards loss of estate . Appellant-claimant No.1 shall be entitled
to compensation of Rs . 40,000 /- towards loss of spousal consortium .
Appellants-claimants No.2 to 5 shall be entitled to compensation of
Rs . 40,000 /- each towards loss of parental consortium . It is however made
clear that in case Hon’ble Supreme Court answer the reference regarding
quantum of compensation under conventional head made in Hasina Yasmin
& Ors. Vs. National Insurance Co. Ltd. , 2025 SCC Online SC 2919 in
favour of appellants-claimants, appellant-claimants shall be free to seek said
amount by moving appropriate application in this regard.
RAVINDER DHANIA
2026.11.18 09:23
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

FAO-2311-2003 -7-
17. Accordingly, reworked compensation is as under :-
Income Rs.5,000/- Rs.5,000/-
per month per month
Future Prospects 25% Rs.6,250/-
(Rs.5,000/-+ 1250)
Deduction 1/4th Rs.4,688/-
(Rs.6,250/- – 1562)
Multiplier 14 14
Total loss of dependency Rs.4,688/-x 14 x 12 Rs.7,87,584/-
Loss of Estate Rs. 15,000/-
Funeral Expenses Rs.15,000/-
Loss of spousal
consortium to claimant
No.1
Rs.40,000/-
Rs.40,000 x 4 Rs.1,60,000/-
Loss of parental
consortium to claimant
Nos.2 to 5
Total Compensation Rs.10,17,584/-
awarded in appeal
Total Compensation Rs.2,37,600/-(after 50%
awarded by the Tribunal deduction towards
contributory negligence)
Enhanced amount of Rs.10,17,584/- (awarded
compensation in appeal) – Rs.2,37,600/-
(awarded by the Tribunal)
Rs.7,79,984/-
18. Appellants/claimants shall be entitled to enhanced
compensation awarded in appeal along with 7.5% interest from the date of
filing of claim petition till realization (except under the conventional heads
i.e. loss of consortium, funeral expenses, loss of estate). Under conventional
heads interest shall be payable from August 2017 onwards till realization.
Apportionment and liability to pay compensation shall be as per award.
19. Appeal is accordingly allowed. Pending application(s), if any,
is/are disposed of accordingly.
(PARMOD GOYAL)
16.11.2026 JUDGE
Ravinder
Whether Speaking/Reasoned : Yes/No
Whether Reportable : Yes/No
RAVINDER DHANIA
2026.11.18 09:23
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document