Anil Kumar vs State Of Haryana And Ors..
- Court
- Punjab and Haryana High Court
LPA-2626-2026 (O&M)
1
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA
AT CHANDIGARH
(107) CM-7009-LPA-2026 &
CM-6420-LPA-2026 in/and
LPA-2626-2026
Date of Decision : November 12, 2026
Anil Kumar ..Appellant
Versus
State of Haryana and others .. Respondents
CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE HARSIMRAN SINGH SETHI
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE MINDERJEET YADAV
Present: Mr. Shreenath A. Khemka, Advocate, for the appellant.
Ms. Anu Pal, Addl. Advocate General, Haryana.
Mr. Balwinder Sangwan, Advocate, for respondent No.3-HPSC.
HARSIMRAN SINGH SETHI, J. (ORAL)
CM-7009-LPA-2026
Present application has been filed for urgent listing of the main
appeal.
Keeping in view facts mentioned in the application, which are
duly supported by an affidavit, the same is allowed and the main appeal is
taken up for hearing today itself.
CM-6420-LPA-2026
Present application has been filed for placing on record
complete copy of AICTE Notification dated 28.04.2017 (Annexure A-1).
HARSHA RANI
2026.11.17 09:21
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
LPA-2626-2026 (O&M)
2
As prayed for, the application is allowed. Notification dated
28.04.2017 as Annexure A-1 is taken on record.
LPA-2626-2026
1. In the present Letters Patent Appeal, the challenge is to the
judgment dated 12.08.2026 passed by the learned Single Judge in CWP
No.3878 of 2023 titled as Anil Kumar vs. State of Haryana and others
whereby, the ineligibility to compete for the post of Lecturer in Auto-mobile
Engineering has been upheld and writ petition filed by the appellant has been
dismissed.
2. Certain facts needs to be mentioned for the correct appreciation
of the issue in hand.
3. An advertisement dated 09.12.2021 was issued advertising
certain posts of Lecturers in Automobile Engineering (Group-B) to be filled
up in the Technical Education Department, Haryana. The qualifications to
be eligible for such post were prescribed in the advertisement itself.
Following is the prescription of the qualification as per the advertisement
dated 09.12.2021:-
“ (i) Bachelors and Masters of Engineering or
Technology degree in Automobile with First Class either in
Bachelors or Masters degree from a recognized
University/Institution.
OR
Bachelors of Engineering or Technology degree in
Mechanical with Automobile Engineering as one of the subject
and Masters of Engineering or Technology degree in
HARSHA RANI
2026.11.17 09:21
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
LPA-2626-2026 (O&M)
3
Automobile with First Class either in Bachelors or Masters
degree from a recognized University/Institution; and
(ii) Hindi or Sanskrit as one of the subjects in Matric or Higher
Education.”
4. A bare perusal of the above would show that Bachelors and
Masters of Engineering or Technology in Automobile with First Class from a
recognized University/Institution or Bachelors Degree in Engineering or
Technology in Mechanical with Automobile Engineering is one of the
subject and Masters degree in Engineering or Technology in Automobile
with First class were the relevant qualification. There was no “equivalent
qualification” or “relevant qualification” made eligible to compete for the
post in question. The appellant applied for the post but concededly, the
appellant did not have had the qualification as prescribed in the
advertisement. In the scrutiny, the appellant was declared ineligible to
compete for the post.
5. It may be noticed that the said ineligibility of the appellant was
declared after referring the case to the Expert Committee so as to decide
whether the qualification which is being possessed by the appellant would be
covered as the prescribed qualification under the advertisement advertised so
as to treat him eligible. The Expert Committee’s report specifically opined
that the said qualification being possessed by the appellant is not a
relevant/appropriate nomenclature in Engineering/Technology hence, claim
of appellant could not be accepted.
6. The said ineligibility of the appellant was made the subject
matter before the learned Single Judge and the learned Single Judge keeping
HARSHA RANI
2026.11.17 09:21
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
LPA-2626-2026 (O&M)
4
in view the qualifications which were prescribed in the advertisement
coupled with the opinion given by the Expert Committee, declined to grant
any benefit to the appellant and upheld the ineligibility as declared by the
Haryana Public Service Commission. The said decision dated 12.08.2026 of
the learned Single Judge has been made the subject matter of the present
appeal.
7. Learned counsel appearing on behalf of the appellant argues that
the qualification which has been prescribed in the advertisement has to be
looked into on the basis of the Notification which has been issued by the
competent authority i.e. All India Council for the Technical Education
(hereinafter referred to as AICTE) dated 28.04.2017 wherein, with regard to
the various engineering branches and corresponding courses, the relevant
and appropriate nomenclature of the under Graduate degree as well as
relevant and appropriate nomenclature of the Postgraduate degrees have
been prescribed and keeping in view the said prescription, the degrees which
are possessed by the appellant are relevant degree to the degree in
Automobile Engineering and therefore, such relevant degree was required to
be brought in operation for considering the eligibility of the appellant, which
has neither been done by the respondent-Commission nor appreciated by the
learned Single Judge while declining the relief.
8. Learned counsel for the appellant submits that once these
nomenclatures are approved by the AICTE, keeping in view the fact that the
same has been done by a superior authority, State of Haryana was bound by
such directions so as to grant the eligibility to the appellant by duly treating
HARSHA RANI
2026.11.17 09:21
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
LPA-2626-2026 (O&M)
5
the qualification possessed by the appellant as a relevant qualification so as
to be considered for the post of Lecturer in Automobile Engineering.
9. We have heard learned counsel for the parties and have gone
through the record with their able assistance.
10. It is a conceded fact that a plain reading of the qualification
prescribed under the advertisement to be considered eligible for deciding the
eligibility qua the post of Lecturer in Automobile Engineering and the
appellant does not possess such qualification. The argument which has been
raised by the learned counsel for the appellant is that even if the appellant
does not have the degree in Automobile Engineering required to be
possessed as per the terms and conditions of the advertisement but once a
relevant degree is possessed by the appellant in terms of the Notification
issued by the AICTE dated 28.04.2017, the appellant has to be treated as
eligible for such post having a relevant degree.
11. It may be noticed that unless and until an equivalent or relevant
degree has been prescribed in the terms and conditions of the advertisement,
even if a relevant or an equivalent degree is possessed by a candidate, such
candidate cannot claim eligibility in absence of such qualification being
prescribed.
12. It is upon the framers of the Rule to prescribe the qualification
to compete for a particular post. In absence of approved relevant or an
equivalent degree to be treated as eligible to compete for the post, the
candidate cannot claim such relevant degree or equivalent degree to be
appropriate to be considered eligible for the post.
HARSHA RANI
2026.11.17 09:21
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
LPA-2626-2026 (O&M)
6
13. The law in this regard is well settled by the Hon’ble Supreme
Court of India in Unnikrishanan CV and others vs. Union of India and
others, 2023 INSC 304 wherein, Court has observed that a relevant degree
or an equivalent degree cannot grant eligibility unless the same is part of the
Rule governing the essential qualification for the post in question and have
been made such in the terms and conditions of the advertisement. The
relevant paragraphs of the said judgment are as under:-
“5. In this background, the qualification as prescribed in
column No. 11 of GREF Rules, 1982 when perused, would
indicate that candidate who is seeking promotion to the post of
Superintendent BR Grade-I has to possess “Diploma in Civil
Engineering” with 5 years regular service in the grade of
General Reserve Engineering Force. Whereas appellants are
possessing Diploma in Draughtsman Estimating and Design
(DED), which fact is not seriously disputed by them. Mr. Tapas
Das, learned counsel appearing for the appellants has fairly
conceded before this Court that an erroneous proposition was
put forth before the High Court, namely, it was contended that
Diploma is equivalent to a Degree and as such negating said
contention, the High Court though justified its conclusion had
erred in ignoring the consistent stand that had been taken by
the Appellants, namely, Diploma in DED possessed by them is
that of 2 years course and though column 11 prescribes
Diploma in Civil Engineering for being promoted as
Superintendent BR-Grade-I is to be treated as equivalent and
this aspect was required to be considered by the High Court is
an argument which looks attractive at first blush. However, on a
careful perusal of the extant Rules as applicable for promotion
to the post of Superintendent BR Grade-II, said contention has
to be necessarily rejected for reasons more than one. Firstly,
HARSHA RANI
2026.11.17 09:21
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
LPA-2626-2026 (O&M)
7
before the High Court appellants attempted to justify their
claim contending “Diploma” is equivalent to a “Degree” and
as such being entitled for promotion which has been negatived
by the High Court and rightly so. Secondly, appellants tried to
justify their claim contending rule as applicable for direct
recruitment would be applicable for recruitment by promotion,
which has not been accepted by the High Court. In so far as the
contention regarding qualification for promotion, the rule itself
is explicit and clear, namely, it prescribes for promotion to
Superintendent BR Grade-I only, those candidates possessing
Diploma in Civil Engineering with 5 years regular service in
the grade in General Reserve Engineering Force would be
eligible. No doubt, said rule is silent with regard to Diploma in
Civil Engineering being either 3 years or otherwise. It is an
undisputed fact that appellants possess ‘Diploma in DED’ and
not ‘Diploma in Civil Engineering’. It is trite law that courts
would not prescribe the qualification and/or declare the
equivalency of a course. Until and unless rule itself prescribes
the equivalency namely, different courses being treated alike,
the courts would not supplement its views or substitute its views
to that of expert bodies.
6. In Guru Nanak Dev University v. Sanjay Kumar Katwal &
Anr.,1 this Court has reiterated that equivalence is a technical
academic matter. It cannot be implied or assumed. Any decision
of the academic body of the university relating to equivalence
should be by a specific order or resolution, duly published.
Dealing specifically with whether a distance education course
was equivalent to the degree of MA (English) of the appellant
university therein, the Court held that no material had been
produced before it to show that the distance education course
had been recognized as such.
HARSHA RANI
2026.11.17 09:21
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
LPA-2626-2026 (O&M)
8
7. In Zahoor Ahmad Rather & Ors. v. Sheikh Imtiyaz Ahmad &
Ors 2 , it was held that the State, as an employer, is entitled to
prescribe qualifications as a condition of eligibility, after taking
into consideration the nature of the job, the aptitude required
for efficient discharge of duties, functionality of various
qualifications, course content leading up to the acquisition of
various 1 (2009) 1 SCC 610 2 (2019) 2 SCC 404 qualifications,
etc. Judicial review can neither expand the ambit of the
prescribed qualifications nor decide the equivalence of the
prescribed qualifications with any other given qualification.
Equivalence of qualification is a matter for the State, as
recruiting authority, to determine.”
14. Further, the Rules as framed by the Government of Haryana
which envisage the essential qualification for appointment to the post are
same as mentioned in the advertisement. Once the Rule or the terms and
conditions of the advertisement does not envisage any relevant or equivalent
degree for the post, even if it is assumed that the degree possessed by the
appellant is relevant to the degree in Auto-mobile Engineering, the same
cannot be read as a degree in Auto-mobile Engineering to be treated eligible.
15. Learned counsel for the appellant has argued that keeping in
view the Notification of AICTE dated 28.04.2017, the Rule which does not
grant the benefit to an equivalent or relevant degree, such Rules become
inoperative and a candidate can approach to claim the benefit of the
Notification of AICTE even without challenging the Rules or terms and
conditions of the Advertisement.
16. It may be noticed that such an argument cannot be accepted.
Once, the Rules governing the service is binding upon the State and also
HARSHA RANI
2026.11.17 09:21
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
LPA-2626-2026 (O&M)
9
other candidates have been made bound by such conditions before
competing for the post, in the absence of any challenge to the Rule which is
inconsonance with the terms and conditions of the Advertisement, cannot be
treated as arbitrary or illegal. Such Rules cannot be ignored merely because
of a Notification of the authority concerned wherein, the relevant degrees
have been notified.
17. Further, nothing has come on record that such relevant degrees
are also to be accepted by the State even if, the Rule does not prescribed
such acceptance.
18. It may be noticed that counsel on behalf of the appellant is
claiming eligibility to be considered on a post without challenging the
advertisement which clearly prescribed the terms and conditions of the same.
It is a settled principle of law settled by the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India
in Mohit Kumar vs. State of Uttar Pradesh and others, 2025 SCC Online
SC 125 wherein, it has been observed that in case a candidate thinks that
there is some grey area in the advertisement qua eligibility and does not raise
such grievance at the first available chance and such candidate compete to
be declared ineligible, such terms and conditions of advertisement cannot be
challenged at the later stage especially when all candidates are uniformly
assessed as per the terms and conditions of the advertisement.
19. In the present case, counsel on behalf of the appellant has not
challenged the terms and conditions prescribed under the advertisement, till
he was declared ineligible. In case aspirant/candidate participate in the
recruitment process without demur, he cannot later on challenge it on ground
HARSHA RANI
2026.11.17 09:21
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
LPA-2626-2026 (O&M)
10
of ambiguity unless constitutional safeguards are breached. The relevant
paragraph of the said judgment is as under:-
“19. It is no longer res integra that terms of an
advertisement issued in connection with a selection process are
normally not open to challenge unless the challenge is founded
on the ground of breach of Article 16 of the Constitution or, for
that matter, Article 14. Once an advertisement is issued inviting
applications for public employment, it is the responsibility, nay
duty, of an aspirant to read and note the terms and understand
what its requirements are. If any aspirant finds any of the terms
ambiguous and there is scope for an inquiry inbuilt in the
advertisement or is provided by any rule/regulation, an effort
ought to be first made to obtain clarity for understanding the
requirements accurately. If no such scope is available, nothing
prevents the aspirant from seeking clarity by making a
representation.
Should such clarity be not provided, the aspirant may
participate in the process without prejudice to his rights and
may question the term even after he is not selected. However, if
the aspirant does not make any such effort and takes a
calculated chance of selection based on his own understanding
of the disputed term in the advertisement and later, he emerges
unsuccessful, ordinarily, it would not be open to him to
challenge the selection on the ground that the disputed term is
capable of being understood differently. In such cases, the
courts should be loath to entertain such plea of ambiguity while
preferring to accept the recruiting authority’s understanding of
the said term. This is for the simple reason that the recruiting
authority is the best judge of what its requirements are and it is
such understanding of the recruiting authority that would matter
most in cases brought up before the courts; hence, after
HARSHA RANI
2026.11.17 09:21
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
LPA-2626-2026 (O&M)
11
commencement of the process wherein aspirants have
participated without raising any demur as to what a particular
terms means, even if any of the terms be ambiguous, the courts
should lean in favour of the recruiting authority.”
20. Keeping in view the totality of the circumstances, the claim
raised by the appellant for being considered eligible for the post of Lecturer
in Automobile Engineering (Group-B), has rightly been declined by the
learned Single Judge and such view taken is not perverse either on facts or
on law so as to need any interference at the hands of this Court.
21. No other arguments have been raised.
22. The order is dictated in the open Court in the presence of the
learned counsel for the parties.
23. Accordingly, the appeal is dismissed.
24. Civil miscellaneous application pending if any, also stands
disposed of.
(HARSIMRAN SINGH SETHI)
JUDGE
(MINDERJEET YADAV)
November 12, 2026 JUDGE
harsha
Whether speaking/reasoned : Yes
Whether reportable : No
HARSHA RANI
2026.11.17 09:21
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document