The Chairman Cum Manging Director Bsnl And Anr vs Udit Gupta

Court
Gauhati High Court

Page No.# 1/5
GAHC010280442024

2026:GAU-AS:16959-DB

THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : WP(C)/372/2025
1. The Chairman cum Managing
Director, Bharat Sanchar Nigam Limited,
th
Corporate Office, 4 Floor,
Bharat Sanchar Bhawan,
Janpath, New Delhi- 110 001

2. The Director (H.R.)
Bharat Sanchar Nigam Limited,
Bharat Sanchar Bhawan,
Janpath, New Delhi- 110 001

…… ..Petitioners
-Versus-
Shri Udit Gupta,
Superintending Engineer (Civil)
Office of Chief Engineer (Civil), BSNL,
Panbazar, Guwahati, Assam,
PIN- 781001
…… ..Respondent

Page No.# 2/5
– B E F O R E –
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. ASHUTOSH KUMAR
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE KAUSHIK GOSWAMI


For the petitioners : Mr. G. Goswami, Advocate
For the respondent : Ms. S. Kanungoe, Advocate

Date of hearing : 17.11.2026
Date of Judgment : 17.11.2026
UDGMENT RDER RAL
J & O (O )
(Ashutosh Kumar, C.J.)

We have heard Mr. G. Goswami, learned Advocate for the
petitioners/ The Chairman cum Managing Director BSNL & Another and
Ms. S. Kanungoe, learned Advocate for the sole respondent/ Udit Gupta .
2. The impugned order dated 19.07.2024 passed by the Central
Administrative Tribunal (hereinafter to be referred as ‘Tribunal’) Guwahati
Bench in O.A. No.040/251/2017 enjoins upon the petitioner/BSNL to hold a
review DPC for the respondent for considering his case for early
promotion/antedated promotion in view of the judgment of the Supreme
Court in Shiv Kumar Sharma and Another vs. Union of India and Others ::
(1997) 11 SCC 112.
3. The petitioner/BSNL has questioned this judgment on several
grounds.

Page No.# 3/5
4. Before we deal with those grounds, it will be necessary to state in
brief as to why the respondent was not promoted earlier to his juniors.
5. The respondent started his service in BSNL in the year 1992 as an
Assistant Executive Engineer (Civil). In the year 2005, he was given ad-hoc
promotion to the post of Superintending Engineer (Civil). He was never
given regular promotion on account of the remarks “below the
benchmark” in his APARs/Annual Confidential Reports, whereas the
eligibility criteria for regular promotion to the post of Superintending
Engineer, as per the Recruitment Rules of 2009 for the scale of Rs.16,000-
400-20,800 (ES), is “very good”; “not adverse” and not more than one
“good”. Four “very good” and one “good” would be sufficient for regular
promotion to the post of Superintending Engineer.
6. The Tribunal, Guwahati Bench, though took note of the fact that the
challenge of the respondent to his assessment and grading him below
the benchmark for promotion never met with any success except to the
extent of a direction from the Central Administrative Tribunal, Madras, to
the BSNL for passing a speaking order, but considering the fact that the
respondent had been topper of his batch of engineers and was denied
time-bound promotion only on account of not meeting the benchmark
gradings in the APAR and that also for the reason of his being a whistle-
blower in the department, the Tribunal applied the principle enunciated
in Shiv Kumar Sharma (supra).
7. In the afore-noted judgment, the Supreme Court had accepted the
suggestion of the Full Bench of the CAT that to meet the ends of justice in
the circumstance of cases that for the period, during which the

Page No.# 4/5
employees shouldered higher responsibilities for higher Class I post, their
gradation should be treated as one level higher than the grading
awarded to them for that period. Though no finding was recorded in the
afore-noted case, but the Supreme Court agreed that in case such
suggestion was accepted by the UPSC, that should put the matter at rest.
8. Thus, applying the afore-noted principle and taking the grading of
the respondent to one higher level, it was found that perhaps the
respondent would have qualified for being promoted to the higher post
much earlier, i.e. when his juniors were considered.
9. Commenting on the afore-noted decision, Mr. Goswami, learned
Advocate for the petitioner/BSNL has submitted that the directions given
by the CAT, Guwahati Bench is flawed for the reason that the challenge
comes after several years, when juniors to the respondent have already
been promoted and most of them have retired from service. While such
order was passed, the Tribunal did not appropriately consider that
antedating the promotion of the respondent would have disturbed the
seniority of 40 other employees, who had been promoted before the
respondent and no effort was taken by the respondent to implead those
40 persons, whose seniority would have been tampered with, should the
respondent been promoted from an early date.
10. It has also been argued on behalf of the petitioner that the
judgment of the Supreme Court in Shiv Kumar Sharma (supra) was in a
separate special circumstance which cannot automatically be applied
in case of the respondent, who is an employee of BSNL which has its own
promotion rules, which are being followed by the letter.

Page No.# 5/5
11. That apart, we find that the respondent was promoted to the post
of Chief Engineer and has now retired. The entire exercise of holding a
DPC for giving antedated promotion to the respondent to the post of
Superintendent Engineer (Civil) would be meaningless and would
unnecessarily disturb the pecking order of seniority of the retired
employees.
12. Thus, we do not find the directions issued by the Tribunal to be
tenable.
13. We are, thus, constrained to set aside the impugned order passed
by the Tribunal.
We order accordingly.

The writ petition, thus, stands allowed.



JUDGE CHIEF JUSTICE

Comparing Assistant