Vinit Kumar vs State Of U.P. Through Secretary
- Court
- Supreme Court
NON-REPORTABLE
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
2026 INSC 997
CIVIL ORIGINAL JURISDICTION
WRIT PETITION (C) NO. 123 OF 2013
VINIT KUMAR & ORS. …. PETITIONERS
VERSUS
STATE OF U.P. THROUGH
SECRETARY & ORS. …. RESPONDENTS
J U D G M E N T
Alok Aradhe, J.
1. At the heart of the present proceedings lies a challenge to a
selection process which commenced in the year 2011 with an
advertisement issued on 04.03.2011 by the Uttar Pradesh Power
Corporation Limited (‘UPPCL’) for filling up 2974 posts of
Technician Grade-2 (Trainee) Electrical. The petitioners, being
unsuccessful candidates, in this writ petition under Article 32 of
the Constitution of India, assail the revised result dated
20.01.2013 and the consequential appointments and seek,
among other reliefs, a fresh exercise of selection and an
investigation by the Central Bureau of Investigation (‘CBI’). In
Signature Not Verified
order to appreciate the grievance of the petitioners, relevant facts
Digitally signed by
KAPIL TANDON
Date: 2026.09.16
16:49:34 IST
Reason:
need mention which are stated infra .
1
FACTS
2. An advertisement was issued by UPPCL, Lucknow inviting
applications from eligible candidates for filling up 2974 posts of
Technician Grade-2 (Trainee) Electrical in Electricity
Distribution Corporations under UPPCL. Of the advertised posts
so advertised, 1778 were earmarked for candidates belonging to
General Category, while 353, 128 and 715 posts respectively
stood reserved for candidates belonging to the Scheduled Castes,
Scheduled Tribes and the Other Backward Classes. The
advertisement prescribed the following eligibility criteria:
(i) A two-year National/State-level Trade certificate in
Electrician Trade;
(ii) High School or equivalent examination of Secondary
Education Board, Uttar Pradesh with Science and
Mathematics as subjects; and
(iii) A certificate of a Course of Computer Concept issued
by the Department of Electronics and Accreditation of
Computer Courses (DOEACC Certificate), to be
produced at the time of interview.
3. A written examination was conducted on 07.08.2011, in which
13,576 candidates participated; of these, 6288 candidates,
including the petitioners, qualified for interview. The interviews
2
of the successful candidates were held between 28.11.2011 and
28.12.2011. The result of the selection to the post in question
was declared on 21.05.2012. A number of candidates who
appeared at the interview were, however, unable to produce their
DOEACC Certificates at that stage. Upon representations made
by such candidates seeking extension of time for production of
the certificates, UPPCL issued press notices extending the
deadline from time to time, finally up to 31.07.2012, with the
caveat that failure to submit would result in automatic
cancellation of the candidate’s selection.
4. Aggrieved by the selection notified on 21.05.2012, the
unsuccessful candidates, including the present petitioners, filed
a batch of writ petitions before the High Court, principally
contending that candidates who had furnished DOEACC
Certificates, between 28.12.2011 and 31.03.2012, as also
candidates whose results had been withheld for non-furnishing
of DOEACC Certificates, had been wrongly included in the select
list. By order dated 30.08.2012, the learned Single Judge
dismissed the writ petitions.
5. The unsuccessful candidates carried the matter in an intra court
appeal. By judgment dated 26.09.2012, the Division Bench of the
High Court held that relaxation of the prescribed rules, was
3
impermissible where the advertisement itself made no provision
for such relaxation, and that only those candidates who had
submitted their DOEACC Certificates prior to 31.03.2012 were
entitled to be included in the select list. The Division Bench,
accordingly, directed the respondents to delete the names of
candidates who had submitted their DOEACC Certificates after
31.03.2012 and to declare the result afresh.
6. In compliance with the directions issued by the Division Bench,
the respondents issued a fresh result of selection on 20.01.2013,
followed by a list of appointment-cum-allotment on 30.01.2013.
The present writ petition, filed on 19.02.2013. The present
petition came to be tagged with a batch of Special Leave Petitions
in which the correctness of the order of the Division Bench was
itself under challenge.
7. In the said batch of Special Leave Petitions, as also in the present
writ petition, this Court, by order dated 14.08.2018, noted that
as on 31.03.2012 only about 1509 candidates possessed
DOEACC Certificates, whereas admittedly 2800 candidates had
been declared successful. The respondents were directed to file a
list of candidates who had submitted such certificates by
31.03.2012, indicating in respect of the remaining candidates,
more than 1500 in number, the dates on which their certificates
4
were filed. In compliance with the said direction, the select list
was filed on 23.10.2018 before a Bench of this Court.
8. By order dated 30.01.2019, a two-Judge Bench of this Court
recorded the ground on which relief was sought in the present
writ petition, namely, that the petitioners stood higher in merit
than the persons who have been selected and appointed, and
that this contention had not been met in the counter affidavit
filed by UPPCL. UPPCL was granted four weeks’ time to file
counter affidavit setting out particulars of marks and ranking of
the petitioners and, should their claim of higher marks be found
correct, the reasons for their non selection and non-appointment
to the post in question. The present writ petition was directed to
be listed after eight weeks, while arguments in the connected
Special Leave Petitions were heard and judgment was reserved.
9. By a common judgment dated 22.02.2019 in Sanjay K. Dixit &
1
Ors. v. State of Uttar Pradesh & Ors. , this Court upheld the
judgment of the Division Bench and dismissed the Special Leave
Petitions. It is in this factual background that the present writ
petition falls for consideration.
1
(2019) 17 SCC 373
5
SUBMISSIONS
10. Mr. Prashant Bhushan, learned counsel for the petitioners
submitted that only the first extension of time for submitting the
DOEACC Certificates was valid, and that the subsequent
extensions were unauthorised. He submitted further that,
though only 715 out of 2974 advertised posts were earmarked
for the OBC Category, as many as 1527 candidates came to be
selected in that category, in blatant violation of the reservation
policy. It was further contended that 2293 candidates had
submitted their certificates within time, however, 2836
candidates stood selected. It was pointed out that, pursuant to
the order dated 14.08.2018, UPPCL had filed a list before this
Court on 23.10.2018, which disclosed several mismatches of
names and roll numbers as against the list published by the
UPPCL on its website on 30.01.2013.
11. It was further submitted that certain candidates who had scored
less than the prescribed cut-off had nevertheless been appointed.
Learned counsel accordingly prayed that the revised result dated
20.01.2013 and the consequential appointment-cum-allotment
list dated 30.01.2013 be quashed, and that a direction be issued
to the respondents for a fresh revision of the select list. It was
also prayed that an independent investigation by the CBI be
6
directed into the alleged manipulation of records and
appointments. In support of the aforesaid submissions, reliance
2
has been placed on decisions of this Court .
12. Mr. Sunil Kumar Jain, learned counsel for the respondents,
submitted that the petitioners were guilty of suppression of a
material fact, namely, that petitioner nos. 8 to 18 had earlier filed
a writ petition that is Writ Petition. No. 2749 of 2012 before the
Lucknow Bench of the Allahabad High Court, seeking identical
relief, which petition was disposed of on 09.11.2012 in terms of
the judgment dated 26.09.2012 of the Division Bench. Therefore,
it was contended that the present writ petition, was on this
ground alone not maintainable. It was further submitted that
petition is liable to be dismissed for non-joinder of necessary
parties. It was further submitted that the petitioners could not
be permitted to agitate new issues in the present writ petition. It
was pointed out that petitioners, belonging to the General
Category, for which the cut-off stood at 98.25 marks, could not
compare their claim with that of candidates selected under the
horizontal sub-categories such as dependants of freedom fighters
and ex-servicemen, for whom lower cut-offs of 65.75 and 80.25
2
State of West Bengal v. Baisakhi Bhattacharyya (Chatterjee) & Ors. 2025 SCC OnLine SC 719;
Manoj Kumar v. Union of India & Ors., (2024) 3 SCC 563 and Dinesh Kumar Kashyap v. South East
Central Railway & Ors., (2019) 12 SCC 798
7
respectively had been prescribed. The petitioners secured less
than 98.25 marks which was prescribed for General Category
and therefore, their names did not appear in the select list issued
on 20.01.2013.
13. It was submitted that the contention that selection of candidates
belonging to OBC category had exceeded the seats reserved for
them in the advertisement, in violation of the 50% ceiling, is
equally unmerited. It was pointed out that a candidate who had
applied in the reserved category and scored marks higher than
the last general category candidate is entitled to be selected in
the open category and such selection is not to be reckoned while
calculating the percentage of reservation. In support of the
aforesaid contentions, reliance has been placed on the decisions
3
of this Court .
14. We have considered the submissions made by learned counsel
for the parties and have perused the record.
15. We are of the view, that the petitioners are not entitled to any
relief in this writ petition for the reasons which we record
hereinafter.
3
J.S. Yadav v. State of Uttar Pradesh & Anr., (2011) 6 SCC 570; Union of India & Anr. v. Satya Prakash
& Ors., (2006) 4 SCC 550; Ritesh R. Sah v. Dr. Y.L. Yamul & Ors., (1996) 3 SCC 253 and R.K. Sabharwal
& Ors., v. State of Punjab & Ors., (1995) 2 SCC 745
8
REASONS
16. Firstly , it deserves notice that in compliance with the judgment
of the Division Bench, UPPCL issued a fresh select list on
20.01.2013. Aggrieved by the judgment of the Division Bench
dated 26.09.2012, the unsuccessful candidates filed Special
Leave Petitions. On 19.02.2013, the petitioners filed the present
writ petition. The aforesaid Special Leave Petitions and the
instant writ petition were tagged together, and a common order
dated 14.08.2018 came to be passed, which reads as under:
“W.P. (C) No. 123/2013
It appears that about 1509 candidates had the
necessary DOEACC certificates on 31.03.2012.
Admittedly, about 2800 candidates were
declared successful.
In the circumstances, it is necessary to have the
details of the candidates who had submitted
DOEACC certificates on the aforesaid date.
We accordingly, direct respondent Nos. 2 and 3
to submit a list of candidates along with their
names who had submitted DOEACC certificates
on 31.03.2012. The list shall also indicate the
date on which the candidates who are more
than 1500 in number file the DOEACC
certificates along with their names.
The entire list shall clearly indicate the date on
which the selected candidates file their
DOEACC certificates. The aforesaid list may be
filed within a period of eight weeks.
List the matters after eight weeks.
9
SLP(C) No. 33506/2012
Learned counsel for petitioner No. 10 seeks
permission to withdraw this petition qua
petitioner No. 10.
Permission sought for is granted. The special
leave petition is dismissed as withdrawn qua
petitioner No. 10.”
17. In compliance with the aforesaid order, the UPPCL filed a list of
selected candidates before a Bench of this Court on 23.10.2018.
Thereafter, on 30.01.2019, the arguments in the Special Leave
Petitions and instant writ petition were heard. The order dated
30.01.2019 is extracted below for the facility of reference:
“The issue in this petition pertains to selection
and appointment to the post of Technician
Grade II (Apprentice) Electrical in Uttar Pradesh
Power Corporation Ltd. (U.P.P.C) pursuant to
advertisement on 10.3.2011. The petitioners
seek relief of setting aside the result dated
21.1.2013 and the list of
appointment/allotment dated 30.1.2013. The
grounds on which the relief is sought is that
they are higher in merit than the persons who
have been selected and appointed. Though the
counter affidavit has been filed by the
Corporation, this contention of the petitioner
has not been dealt with.
U.P.P.C. is permitted to file counter affidavit
within four weeks giving the particulars of the
marks and ranking of the writ petitioners and if
the statement made on behalf of the petitioners
that they are higher in merit is true, the reason
for their not being selected and appointed.
Two weeks time is granted to file rejoinder, if
any.
List after eight weeks.
10
Rest of the matters:
Arguments concluded.
Judgment reserved.”
18. It is thus evident that, before a Bench of this Court, the
petitioners themselves confined the ground of relief to their claim
of higher merit vis-a vis the selected and appointed candidates,
and that the said contention had not been dealt with in the
counter affidavit. Notably, even after the select list came to be
filed on 23.10.2018, no contention regarding irregularities and
discrepancies in that list was urged on behalf of the petitioners.
It was on this basis, and this basis alone, that the Court directed
UPPCL to file a counter affidavit to explaining why the
petitioners, if indeed higher in merit, had not been selected and
appointed.
19. It is trite law that an order is effective inter partes and shall bind
them until it is successfully avoided or challenged in a higher
4
forum . The interim order dated 30.01.2019 accordingly binds
the petitioners, and the scope of scrutiny in this writ petition
stands confined to the contention of the petitioners as recorded
therein.
4
State of Kerala v. M.K. Kunhikannan Nambiar Manjeri Manikoth, Naduvil (D) & Ors., (1996) 1 SCC
435
11
20. The respondents, in their counter affidavit dated 22.02.2019 filed
in compliance of the order dated 30.01.2019, have taken a
categorical stand that the petitioners did not secure the cut-off
marks prescribed for the General Category and were, for that
reason, therefore, not selected. This stand was specifically
pressed by learned counsel for respondents in the course of his
submissions but has been controverted neither in the written
submissions filed on behalf of the petitioners nor in the oral
submissions made before us. It follows, axiomatically, that no
candidate less meritorious than the petitioners has been
selected.
21. Secondly , the respondents have taken a specific stand, in
paragraph 38 of the counter affidavit filed on 30.08.2013, that
petitioners nos. 8 to 18 had filed a Writ Petition No. 2749 of 2013
before the Lucknow Bench of the Allahabad High Court seeking
the same relief and therefore, the instant writ petition is not
maintainable. The said writ petition was disposed on 09.11.2012
in terms of the judgment dated 26.09.2012 of the Division Bench.
This fact, that petitioner nos. 8 to 18 were parties to Writ Petition
No. 2749 of 2013 finds no mention in the present writ petition,
nor have the petitioners disclosed that said writ petition was
disposed of on 09.11.2012, or whether that order was challenged
12
by way Special Leave Petition before this Court. This non-
disclosure amounts to suppression of material facts, and such
conduct, without anything more, disentitles the petitioners to
any relief.
22. Thirdly , the selected candidates have long since been issued
appointment letters and have, for a considerable length of time,
been working on the posts in question. At this point of time,
particularly in their absence before us, their appointments
cannot be disturbed.
23. Fourthly, a Constitution Bench of this Court in State of West
Bengal & Ors. v. Committee for Protection of Democratic
5
Rights, West Bengal & Ors. held that despite wide powers
conferred by Articles 32 and 226 of the Constitution, the Court
must bear in mind the self-imposed limitations on exercise of
such constitutional powers. It was held that direction to CBI to
conduct investigation is not to be issued as matter of routine or
merely because a party has levelled some allegations on local
police. Similar view has been taken by a two-Judge bench of this
Court in Himanshu Kumar and Ors. v. State of Chhattisgarh
6
and Ors . Another two-Judge Bench of this Court in Legislative
5
(2010) 3 SCC 571
6
(2023) 12 SCC 592
13
7
Council U.P. Lucknow and Ors. v. Sushil Kumar and Ors. held
that while issuing directions to CBI, to hold an investigation,
pleadings and material sufficient for CBI inquiry are required to
be looked into. In the instant case, the petitioners have neither
lodged a first information report nor had made any allegations
against the local police. No averments have been made in the writ
petition disclosing the basis for direction for an enquiry by CBI.
Therefore, we are not inclined to accede to the said prayer made
by the petitioners.
CONCLUSION
24. For the foregoing reasons, we do not find any merit in this writ
petition. The same fails and is hereby dismissed. There shall be
no order as to costs. Pending applications, if any, stand disposed
of.
……………..……………………………….J.
[PAMIDIGHANTAM SRI NARASIMHA]
…….…………………………………………J.
[ALOK ARADHE]
NEW DELHI;
SEPTEMBER 16, 2026.
7
2025 INSC 1241
14