M.SUBRAMANIAM vs THE APPELLATE AUTHORITY

Court
Madras High Court

2026:MHC:4599
WP No. 33207 of 2023
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS
DATED: 17-11-2026
CORAM
THE HON'BLE MR.JUSTICE C.KUMARAPPAN
WP No. 33207 of 2023
CNR:{HCMA012098162023}
and
WMP No. 32921 OF 2023
M.Subramoniam
S/o. Muthukumar,
33/78 Methu Street, Athipethu,
Chennai 58.
..Petitioner(s)
Vs
1. The Appellate Authority Cum
Joint Director Of School Education (Secondary)
DPI Complex, Chennai 600 006.
2. The Secretary
P.J. Gupta’s High School,
51/193 MTH Road, Ambattur,
Chennai 53.
..Respondent(s)
Writ Petition filed under Article 226 of the Constitution of India, praying
to issue a Writ of Certiorarified Mandamus, to call for the records relating to the
Order dated 31.05.2023 bearing No. 404 /G2/ T1/ E1/ 2022 passed by the First
respondent and quash the same to the extent of passing an order of punishment
of stoppage of Petitioner’s increment with cumulative effect for 3 years to be
nd
passed by the 2 respondent and direct the respondents to restore the petitioner
in service with full salary and other benefits from 23.07.2021.
__________
Page1 of 11
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 18/11/2026 12:50:58 pm )

2026:MHC:4599
WP No. 33207 of 2023
For Petitioner(s): Mr.S.Rajeni Ramadass
for Rajeni Associates
For Respondent(s): Mrs.Y.Kavitha
AGP For R1
Mr.B.Thiyagarajan for R2
*
ORDER
This Writ Petition has been filed challenging the impugned order dated
Order dated 31.05.2023.
2.The brief facts which are necessary for the disposal of the present Writ
Petition is that, the petitioner joined in the second respondent-school as a
Secondary Grade Teacher on 29.01.1996. Since the petitioner did not report
duty on 20-07-2021, the Headmistress Mrs.Kavitha marked him absent in
pencil. It is the case of the Management that the petitioner came to the School
with an inebriated condition and threatened them in a filthy language and later,
went to the Headmistress' residence and assaulted the headmistress' brother.
Immediately after the above incidents, the petitioner was placed under
suspension on 23-07-2021. Later on, a police complaint was also registered
against the petitioner on 24.07.2021 in CSR No.889 of 2021. Subsequently, the
School Committee approved the suspension and later on extended the
suspension and ultimately initiated the disciplinary proceedings by issuing a
charge memorandum dated 17.09.2021, for which the petitioner has sent an
__________
Page2 of 11
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 18/11/2026 12:50:58 pm )

2026:MHC:4599
WP No. 33207 of 2023
explanation on 29.09.2021. Subsequently, he was called upon to appear before
the School Committee on 15.10.2021 and in the meeting on 25.10.2021, the
School Committee has found him guilty of all charges framed against the
petitioner. Later on, a show-cause notice was issued to him on 18.11.2021 as to
why a major punishment should not be imposed against him. After receipt of
response to such show-cause notice, vide Minutes dated 29.01.2022, decided to
impose a punishment of stoppage of increment with cumulative effect for six
years and for deduction of pension. Such punishment was intimated to the
petitioner on 10.02.2022. Aggrieved with the same, the petitioner preferred an
appeal before the first respondent on 26.03.2022 and the first respondent has
passed the impugned order on 31.05.2023, wherein the Appellate Authority has
modified the punishment only to the extent of withholding of increment for
three years with cumulative effect. Aggrieved with the same, the present writ
petition has been filed.
3.Heard the learned counsel for the petitioner, the learned Additional
Government Pleader appearing for the first respondent and the learned counsel
nd
for the 2 respondent.
4.The main contention put forth by the learned counsel for the petitioner
is that no opportunities were given to the petitioner, and the principles of natural
__________
Page3 of 11
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 18/11/2026 12:50:58 pm )

2026:MHC:4599
WP No. 33207 of 2023
justice have not been followed. While considering the punishment, the
Disciplinary Authority has taken into consideration of the extraneous materials,
which was not at all furnished to him. It is also his contention that no witnesses
were examined and that the petitioner was not given any opportunity to cross-
examine those witnesses. It is also his contention that having the Appellate
Authority has rightly come to the conclusion that the procedures had not been
followed, instead of setting aside the punishment has modified the same, which
is contrary to law. Hence, prayed to interfere with the punishment.
nd
5. Per contra , the learned counsel appearing for the 2 respondent would
vehemently contend that the principles of natural justice had been effectively
followed. She would also contend that all the documents, which were relied by
the Disciplinary Authority, had been forwarded to the petitioner and that the
petitioner had admitted his guilt. Therefore, no necessity arises for the
examination of the witnesses. The learned Additional Government Pleader
would further contend that each and every stage, the petitioner was put on
notice and that only after hearing his objection, the impugned order was passed
imposing the punishment of stoppage of increment with cumulative effect for
six years and the deduction of pension post-retirement. It is the contention of the
nd
learned counsel that the 2 respondent had furnished all the documents to the
__________
Page4 of 11
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 18/11/2026 12:50:58 pm )

2026:MHC:4599
WP No. 33207 of 2023
petitioner and that the petitioner's conduct of assaulting the Headmistress’
brother was admitted by him before the Ambattur Police Station and he had also
given an apology letter before the Ambattur Police Station. It is also her
contention that the petitioner never disputed the suspension order. Therefore,
having not disputed the suspension, now that he cannot find any fault with
respect to the same. It is also her contention that before imposing any
punishment, all the explanations which had been given by the petitioner was
considered. Therefore, there is no legal requirement mandating the cross-
examination of the complainant under these circumstances. It is her further
contention that when the contemporaneous evidence discloses the delinquency
in accordance with the preponderance of probability, the non-furnishing of the
opportunity for cross-examination would in no way prejudice the petitioner's
defence. Hence, prayed to dismiss the writ petition.
6.The above contention was reiterated by the learned Additional
Government Pleader.
7.I have given my anxious consideration to either side submissions.
8.Admittedly, the petitioner was given a charge memorandum on
17.09.2021. The Gist of those charges are as follows:-
○ Violation of Section 21 and Rule 16 read with Annexure II (Code of
Conduct).
__________
Page5 of 11
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 18/11/2026 12:50:58 pm )

2026:MHC:4599
WP No. 33207 of 2023
○ Wilful absence from reporting to school from 19.07.2021 to 29.07.2021
without prior intimation/permission.
○ Reporting to school under the influence of alcohol on 20.07.2021 and
abusing/threatening the Headmistress and office staff.
○ Criminal acts involving moral turpitude, including assaulting the
Headmistress's brother with a knife.
○ Unfitness to discharge teaching duties due to chronic alcoholism, posing
a threat to staff and students.
Undertaking higher studies (M.A. in History at Annamalai University)
○
without obtaining prior permission from the School Committee.
○ Attempting to bring external political influence on thwart disciplinary
proceedings.
9.The petitioner has given an explanation for the above charges. It is the
specific contention of the respondent that, in the explanation, the petitioner had
admitted the charges. But, while reading the explanation, this Court finds that
the petitioner has strongly refuted the charge. However, if at all if there is any
admission, it is only with respect of having a degree from the Annamalai
University without obtaining the prior approval.
10.At this juncture, this Court deems it appropriate to refer the Minutes of
meeting of the School Committee dated 25.10.2021, at 3.30 hours, wherein it
has been stated as follows:-
“6)When Teacher Subramaniam was asked to give a written
apology, he began shouting and using derogatory language, saying
“how dare Vanaja give a complaint against me, I will see to her
later.” He failed to show any remorse for his actions and instead
was disrespectful to the members of the School Committee of
P.J.Gupta’s High School.
__________
Page6 of 11
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 18/11/2026 12:50:58 pm )

2026:MHC:4599
WP No. 33207 of 2023
7)After taking into account the statements and documents
mentioned at point (5) above, along with the apology of
Mr.Subramaniam, the Committee has found Subramaniam guilty of
all the charges against him, based on all the evidence placed on
record. In addition, the Secretary played a recording before the
Committee, which he recorded on his phone, on the date of the
incident, i.e., 20.07.2021, wherein Subramaniam is heard yelling
and abusing Ms.Kavitha.”
11.According to the above Minutes, though it was contended that the
petitioner had admitted the delinquency, admittedly, no such admission was
made by the petitioner in writing. However, it is assumed by the Disciplinary
Authority that the petitioner, though orally admitted, refused to sign in the
written apology. Therefore, the contention that the petitioner had apologised for
his conduct is without any basis. Hence, the same cannot be accepted at all.
Further, while deciding the charge, the respondent has taken into consideration
of an additional material, viz., some digital recordings. Admittedly, such
document was not furnished to the petitioner.
12.In the case in hand, when the petitioner has stoutly denied the very
allegation, he ought to have been given an opportunity to cross-examine the
witnesses. In this regard, the learned counsel for the respondent would contend
that in view of the availability of contemporaneous documents such as FIR and
__________
Page7 of 11
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 18/11/2026 12:50:58 pm )

2026:MHC:4599
WP No. 33207 of 2023
the apology letter given before the police, there is no necessity to afford an
opportunity to the petitioner to cross-examine the witnesses. However, no such
apology letter, which allegedly given by the delinquent to the police, was
furnished to the petitioner. However, the petitioner stoutly denied any such
apology letter given before the police. Even if there is any apology letter,
according to him, it was only due to the coercion and duress, which submissions
cannot be outrightly denied and we very well aware what is happening in the
police station.
13.Though the decision of the School Committee is based on majority,
some of the Members have raised their objections with regard to the
punishment. When there is a specific charge with regard to the inebriation, this
Court is of the firm view that a reasonable opportunity should have been given
to the petitioner to defend himself effectively. Further, the witnesses have to be
examined in the presence of the delinquent, unless it is too difficult for the
authorities to do so. While looking into the punishment, the Disciplinary
Authority has imposed a bunch of punishment, which is prohibited under the
service jurisprudence.
__________
Page8 of 11
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 18/11/2026 12:50:58 pm )

2026:MHC:4599
WP No. 33207 of 2023
14.Here, the Appellate Authority, though modified the punishment, has
given a positive finding that the second respondent did not follow a proper
procedure and has not been given sufficient opportunity to the petitioner and
acted arbitrarily. Against such observation, the Management did not file any
appeal. Therefore, it is amply clear that even according to the findings rendered
by the Appellate Authority, the petitioner was not given any sufficient
opportunity and besides, the conduct of the second respondent was arbitrary.
Therefore, this Court finds all justification to interfere with the impugned order
of the Appellate Authority dated 31.05.2023 and the same is liable to be set
aside.
15.Accordingly, this Writ Petition stands allowed. The impugned order
dated 31.05.2023 is hereby set aside. Consequently, the punishment imposed by
the School Committee through their Minutes dated 29-01-2022 is also set aside.
As a result of which, the matter is remitted back to the second respondent
directing the second respondent to conduct a de novo enquiry, after affording all
opportunities to the petitioner. Until completion of the de novo inquiry, the
petitioner cannot claim for full salary and other benefits. The second respondent
is further directed to complete the disciplinary proceedings within a period of
__________
Page9 of 11
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 18/11/2026 12:50:58 pm )

2026:MHC:4599
WP No. 33207 of 2023
four(4) months from the date of receipt of a copy of this order. If the
disciplinary proceedings not completed within a period of four(4) months for
nd
any reason, the 2 respondent must seek extension of time. If not, the
disciplinary proceedings would be dropped on the completion of the time limit
provided hereinabove. No costs. Consequently, connected WMP is also closed.
17-11-2026
Index: Yes
Speaking order
Neutral Citation: Yes
KMI
To
1. The Appellate Authority
Cum Joint Director Of School Education (secondary)
DPI Complex, Chennai-600 006.
2. The Secretary
P.J. Gupta’s High School,
51/193 MTH Road,
Ambattur, Chennai 53.
__________
Page10 of 11
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 18/11/2026 12:50:58 pm )

2026:MHC:4599
WP No. 33207 of 2023
C.KUMARAPPAN J.
KMI
WP No. 33207 of 2023
AND
WMP No. 32921 of 2023
17-11-2026
__________
Page11 of 11
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 18/11/2026 12:50:58 pm )