H.G.Pattabi vs K.R.Suraj .

Court
Supreme Court

2026 INSC 1041
REPORTABLE
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION

CIVIL APPEAL NO(S). 659 OF 2016


H.G. PATTABI ….APPELLANT(S)

VERSUS

K.R. SURAJ AND OTHERS ….RESPONDENT(S)

J U D G M E N T
Mehta, J.
1. Heard.
2. Perused the records.
3. Learned counsel appearing on behalf of the
1
respondent Nos. 1-3 at the outset submitted that the
statement earlier made before this Court with regard
2
to the demise of Smt. L. Sudha, respondent No. 3
was made inadvertently, and that respondent No. 3
is, in fact, alive. It was further submitted that the
interests of respondent No. 3 are sufficiently
represented by the other respondents and, therefore,
Signature Not Verified

1
Hereinafter, being referred to as “respondent Nos. 1-3/plaintiffs”.
2
Hereinafter, being referred to as “respondent/plaintiff No. 3”.
Digitally signed by
RAJNI MUKHI
Date: 2026.09.23
18:32:07 IST
Reason:
1

no further steps are required to be taken in that
regard. In view of the aforesaid submission, the
matter was heard on merits.
3
4. The appellant in this appeal seeks to assail the
rd
judgment and order dated 23 April, 2010 passed by
4
the High Court of Karnataka at Bengaluru in
Regular First Appeal No. 671 of 2002, whereby the
High Court allowed the First Appeal preferred by
respondent Nos. 1-3/plaintiffs and set aside the
judgment passed by Civil Judge (Senior Division),
5
Chikmagalur dismissing the suit for partition
preferred by respondent Nos. 1-3/plaintiffs.
Brief Facts
5. A brief narration of the facts necessary for the
disposal of this appeal is set out hereinbelow for the
sake of convenience.
6. Respondent Nos. 1 and 2 (plaintiff Nos. 1 and 2)
are the sons and respondent/plaintiff No. 3 is the
wife of one Shri Renukaiah. The said Renukaiah had
settled in Bengaluru in 1971. In 1983, to be precise,
th
on 4 May, 1983, Renukaiah got six items of lands,

3
Hereinafter, being referred to as “appellant/defendant No. 3”.
4
Hereinafter, being referred to as “High Court”.
5
Hereinafter, being referred to as “trial Court”.
2
CIVIL APPEAL NO(S). 659 OF 2016

viz ., Survey Nos. 185/11, 185/8, 185/9, 185/4,
186/1 and 186/2A, situated at Village
Doddamagaravalli, Aldur Hobli, Chikmagalur Taluk,
Karnataka, in a family partition. During the year
1990-1991, Renukaiah constructed a house on a plot
owned by his wife, respondent/plaintiff No. 3 at
Bengaluru. Since Renukaiah was not in a position to
take care of the ancestral lands situated at
Doddamagaravalli, which he received in family
partition, he decided to sell two items of land, viz .,
Survey Nos. 186/1 (admeasuring 1.08 Acres) and
186/2A (admeasuring 2.23 Acres), being the suit
schedule properties.
th
7. On 5 August, 1993, the aforesaid two plots of
land were sold to one Ziauddin (defendant No. 1), by
virtue of a registered sale deed executed by
Renukaiah. Defendant No. 1, Ziauddin, thereafter
sold these lands to one Uddegowda (defendant No. 2).
Renukaiah met with a road accident and passed
nd
away on 22 July, 1995. Respondent Nos. 1-
3/plaintiffs, being the wife and children of
Renukaiah, filed Original Suit No. 106 of 1995 for
partition and separate possession in respect of the
suit schedule properties, being Survey Nos. 186/1
3
CIVIL APPEAL NO(S). 659 OF 2016

and 186/2A, contending that Renukaiah had sold the
lands without there being any legal necessity and
without the consent of respondent Nos. 1-
3/plaintiffs.
8.
During the pendency of the suit, H.G. Pattabi,
i.e., appellant/defendant No. 3, purchased the suit
land from Uddegowda (defendant No. 2), and came to
be impleaded in the suit as defendant No. 3. In the
year 2001, i.e., after six years of the institution of the
suit, respondent Nos. 1-3/plaintiffs filed a replication
stating therein that the remaining four items of land
had been sold to their uncle and, therefore, the same
had not been included in the plaint as properties in
respect of which partition was sought.
6
9. K.R. Suraj (plaintiff No. 1) , son of Renukaiah,
was examined as PW-1 and no further evidence was
led on behalf of respondent Nos. 1-3/plaintiffs. The
said witness, in his examination-in-chief, claimed
that his father, Renukaiah, was addicted to bad vices,
which allegation was beyond the averments made in
the plaint.

6
Hereinafter, being referred to as “respondent/Plaintiff No.1”.
4
CIVIL APPEAL NO(S). 659 OF 2016

10. The defendants examined 3 witnesses in their
respective evidence before the trial Court.
Appellant/defendant No. 3 was examined as DW-3
and, in his evidence, he made a categorical statement
that before purchasing the suit schedule properties,
he had made enquiries regarding the property by
speaking to the widow of Renukaiah, i.e.,
respondent/plaintiff No. 3.
th
11. Vide judgment and decree dated 14 March,
2002, the trial Court dismissed the suit, holding that
the sale proceeds received by Renukaiah had been
utilised towards discharge of the loan incurred for
construction of the house at Bengaluru and,
consequently, the alienation was supported by legal
necessity.
12. In the appeal preferred by respondent Nos. 1-
3/plaintiffs, the High Court, upon reappreciation of
the evidence, principally relied upon the testimony of
respondent/plaintiff No. 1 (PW-1) and concluded that
Renukaiah was addicted to gambling and
consumption of alcohol and, consequently, the
alienation of the suit properties could not be regarded
as having been effected for any bona fide legal
necessity.
5
CIVIL APPEAL NO(S). 659 OF 2016

13. Aggrieved by the aforesaid judgment and decree
of the High Court, the appellant/defendant No. 3 has
approached this Court by way of the present appeal
with special leave.
Submissions on behalf of the appellant
(appellant/defendant No. 3)

14. Learned counsel appearing on behalf of
appellant/defendant No. 3 assailed the impugned
judgment passed by the High Court on the following
counts: -
A. That the High Court erred in decreeing the suit in
favour of respondent Nos. 1-3/plaintiffs without
properly appreciating the pleadings, evidence and
the material available on record. It was submitted
that late Renukaiah had acquired six items of
properties in a family partition, including the suit
schedule properties, whereas respondent Nos. 1-
3/plaintiffs selectively sought partition only in
respect of two items, without seeking partition of
the remaining four items received by Renukaiah.
In their replication, respondent Nos. 1-3/plaintiffs
themselves contended that the other four items
had been sold by Renukaiah in favour of
Chandrasekar, who was the elder paternal uncle
6
CIVIL APPEAL NO(S). 659 OF 2016

of plaintiff Nos. 1 and 2. It was, therefore,
submitted that respondent Nos. 1-3/plaintiffs had
failed to seek an appropriate and comprehensive
relief in respect of the entire property allegedly
available for partition and hence, they were
disentitled to seek partition in respect of the two
suit schedule properties without disclosing the
details of share received by them in respect of the
remaining four properties.
B. That respondent Nos. 1-3/plaintiffs had
th
specifically contended that the sale deed dated 5
August, 1993 executed in favour of Ziauddin
(Defendant No. 1) was not supported by any legal
necessity. However, no relief had been sought for
cancellation of the said sale deed. It was submitted
that, in the absence of a prayer seeking
appropriate relief against the sale deed, the suit,
insofar as it sought to impeach the alienation, was
not maintainable. It was further submitted that
there was no evidence whatsoever that late
Renukaiah was addicted to any bad vices or that
the sale was effected for the discharge of any
Avyavaharika debt. Respondent No. 1 (plaintiff No.
1), was a minor at the time of the first sale
7
CIVIL APPEAL NO(S). 659 OF 2016

transaction made in the year 1993 and admittedly
had no personal knowledge of the circumstances
under which the sale was effected. His mother,
Smt. L. Sudha, (respondent/plaintiff No. 3), who
could have spoken about the relevant
circumstances, did not enter the witness box.
C. That despite noticing the absence of any evidence
regarding bad vices, Avyavaharika debt or the
circumstances rendering the alienation invalid,
the High Court proceeded to make out a case for
respondent Nos. 1-3/plaintiffs which was neither
pleaded nor established by evidence. It was
submitted that the burden lay upon respondent
Nos. 1-3/plaintiffs to plead and prove the facts
necessary to challenge the alienation made by the
karta /father, and that the High Court, in the
absence of such pleadings and evidence, erred in
granting a decree for partition on a ground which
had not been set up by respondent Nos. 1-
3/plaintiffs themselves in the plaint.
D. That the evidence on record, on the contrary,
demonstrated the existence of a legitimate and
pressing financial necessity for the sale of the suit
schedule properties. Late Renukaiah was a driver
8
CIVIL APPEAL NO(S). 659 OF 2016

by profession and, during the years 1991-1992,
had constructed a residential house at Bengaluru
on the plot owned by his wife, Smt. L. Sudha,
(respondent/plaintiff No. 3), after raising loans for
the said purpose. It was submitted that a
residential site had been given to
respondent/plaintiff No. 3, by her sister, upon
which the said house was constructed, and that
the sale of the suit schedule properties was made
by Renukaiah for the purpose of discharging the
loans and meeting the financial obligations
towards the said construction. The recitals
th
contained in the sale deed dated 5 August, 1993,
specifically indicated that late Renukaiah was in
financial difficulty at the relevant time.
On the aforesaid grounds, learned counsel urged that
the impugned judgment of the High Court, having
travelled beyond the pleadings and having failed to
properly appreciate the evidence relating to the
th
circumstances surrounding the sale deed dated 5
August, 1993, deserves to be set aside. It was further
submitted that the decree passed in favour of
respondent Nos. 1-3/plaintiffs could not be
9
CIVIL APPEAL NO(S). 659 OF 2016

sustained in the absence of a specific challenge to the
sale deed and proof of the circumstances rendering
the alienation legally invalid. Accordingly, it was
prayed that this Court may be pleased to allow the
appeal and restore the judgment and decree of the
trial Court.
Submissions on behalf of the contesting
respondents (respondent Nos. 1-3/plaintiffs)
15. Learned counsel appearing on behalf of
respondent Nos. 1-3/plaintiffs supported the
impugned judgment of the High Court and submitted
that the same calls for no interference by this Court,
inter alia , on the following grounds: -
A. That the suit properties had fallen to the share of
late Renukaiah in a partition between himself and
his brothers and, being ancestral/coparcenary
properties, the respondent Nos. 1-3/plaintiffs, as
his wife and sons, had a right therein. It was
submitted that in absence of any financial
necessity for the family’s benefit, late Renukaiah
could not have alienated the coparcenary property
for his personal benefit. The non-inclusion of the
other properties in the suit did not affect the
10
CIVIL APPEAL NO(S). 659 OF 2016

present claim, as the said properties were no
longer available for partition, having been sold to
the elder brother of Renukaiah.
B. That the evidence of respondent No. 1 (PW-1, son
of late Renukaiah) established that late
Renukaiah was addicted to drinking and
gambling, had neglected his family and, on
account of his habits, had incurred substantial
loans. It was further submitted that the suit
schedule properties had been alienated for an
inadequate consideration of merely Rs. 1.45
lakhs, despite their market value at the relevant
time being approximately Rs. 5 lakhs, which itself
cast serious doubt on the and necessity
bona fides
of the transaction. The burden, therefore, lay
upon appellant/defendant No. 3 to establish that
the alienation was supported by legal necessity,
benefit of the estate, benefit of the minors or
discharge of antecedent debts, which burden had
not been discharged in accordance with law.
C. That appellant/defendant No. 3 had failed to
establish that the sale of suit schedule properties
was supported by any legal necessity or
antecedent debt, or that he had made the requisite
11
CIVIL APPEAL NO(S). 659 OF 2016

enquiry as prudence demands before purchasing
the joint family property. It was submitted that
mere recitals in the sale deed regarding financial
difficulties did not establish either the existence of
any antecedent debt or utilisation of the sale
consideration for the benefit or welfare of the joint
family. The contention that the sale was
necessitated for construction of the Bengaluru
house was also untenable, as the said house was
the self-acquired property of Smt. L. Sudha
(respondent/plaintiff No. 3, wife of late
Renukaiah) and the construction thereon was
undertaken long after the death of Renukaiah.
th
Further, the sale deed dated 5 August, 1993
disclosed no particulars regarding the amount or
nature of the alleged debt, the creditor or the date
on which such debt was incurred, nor was any
evidence led by the defendants demonstrating that
the sale proceeds were utilised for discharging any
antecedent debt or for the benefit of the joint
family.
On these grounds, learned counsel submitted that
the findings recorded by the High Court were based
12
CIVIL APPEAL NO(S). 659 OF 2016

upon a proper appreciation of the pleadings and
evidence and do not warrant interference in the
present proceedings. It was accordingly prayed that
the appeal be dismissed.
Analysis and Discussion
16. We have heard learned counsel appearing for
the appellant/defendant No. 3 and learned counsel
appearing for the respondent Nos. 1-3/plaintiffs and
have carefully perused the impugned judgment
passed by the High Court as well as the judgment of
the trial Court. We have also examined the pleadings,
documents and evidence available on record.
17. Before proceeding further, it is pertinent to note
that respondent Nos. 1-3/plaintiffs did not question
the legality or validity of the registered sale deed
executed by Renukaiah in favour of Ziauddin
(defendant No. 1). In this backdrop, the recitals
th
contained in the sale deed dated 5 August, 1993
assume significance for determining the controversy
involved in the present appeal and are, for the sake
of reference, reproduced hereinbelow: -
“This property is far away from the place of my
residence. I am not able to look after the same
and improve the same. Further I am in financial
difficulty and hence it has become necessary to
13
CIVIL APPEAL NO(S). 659 OF 2016

sell the same. When I published that I intend to
sell you have offered highest price of Rs.
1,45,000/- and hence I am executing this sale
deed in your favour. Having got this in a partition I
am legally entitled to sell it. ….”
[Emphasis supplied]

18.
Respondent Nos. 1-3/plaintiffs asserted in the
plaint that the suit schedule properties had been sold
for a paltry consideration of Rs.1,45,000/-, despite
their alleged market value being more than Rs.5
lakhs at the relevant time. However, the said
assertion was not supported by either documentary
or cogent oral evidence. The burden of establishing
the alleged market value of the properties,
particularly when the said assertion was made by
respondent Nos. 1-3/plaintiffs themselves, was upon
them, which they miserably failed to discharge. In
paragraph 6 of his deposition, respondent/plaintiff
nd
No. 1 (PW-1) stated that his father had died on 22
July, 1995 and that, thereafter, he and his mother
made enquiries regarding the suit schedule
properties from their uncle, who informed them that
Renukaiah had sold the same in 1993 for
Rs.1,45,000/-, whereas the value of the suit schedule
properties at the relevant time was Rs.5 lakhs.
14
CIVIL APPEAL NO(S). 659 OF 2016

19. However, the testimony of respondent/plaintiff
No. 1 (PW-1) itself demonstrates that he had no
personal knowledge of the prevailing market value of
the suit schedule properties at the time of the sale. In
his cross-examination, he stated that Rs.1,45,000/-
was not the correct price of the property as on the
date of sale and that he had heard from others that
the property was worth Rs.5 lakhs, but was unable
to recollect their names. Neither any official witness
was examined nor was any Government record
produced to establish the prevailing market or circle
rate of the suit schedule properties. The assertion
regarding their alleged value of Rs.5 lakhs, therefore,
remained wholly unsubstantiated and based on
hearsay evidence.
20. As regards the allegation that Renukaiah was
addicted to gambling and drinking,
respondent/plaintiff No. 1 (PW-1), in his cross-
examination, stated that it was not correct to say that
his father had no bad habits such as gambling and
drinking. He further added that his mother was
aware of such habits. A pertinent admission made by
respondent/plaintiff No. 1 (PW-1) in his cross-
examination was that his senior uncle had got the
15
CIVIL APPEAL NO(S). 659 OF 2016

suit filed. He further admitted that he was unaware
of the other lands which had been allotted to his
father and that he had not read the partition deed,
which was in the possession of his senior uncle.
21.
In the course of his re-examination,
respondent/plaintiff No. 1 (PW-1) admitted that,
apart from the suit schedule properties, other items
of property had also fallen to the share of his father.
During re-examination of the witness, the partition
deed was produced as Exhibit P-13 and, upon being
confronted with the same, respondent/plaintiff No. 1
(PW-1) admitted that the other lands had been sold
to his senior uncle. He did not produce the sale deeds
relating thereto, taking a stand that it was a family
matter. These admissions assume significance in the
context of respondent Nos. 1-3/plaintiffs having
instituted the suit for partition only in respect of the
two suit schedule properties, out of the six properties
which fell into the share of Renukaiah in family
partition.
22. Respondent/plaintiff No. 1 (PW-1) further
admitted that defendant No. 3, i.e., the appellant
herein, had come to Bengaluru to speak to his
mother. He also stated that the house at Bengaluru
16
CIVIL APPEAL NO(S). 659 OF 2016

was a partially constructed house and that one floor
thereof had been constructed during 1991-1992. The
witness, however, was unable to state the amount
spent on such construction. A specific suggestion
was put to him that a loan had been raised for
construction of the house and that the suit schedule
properties had thereafter been sold for repayment of
the said loan, which suggestion he denied. At the
same time, respondent/plaintiff No. 1 (PW-1)
admitted that it was not possible for his father to look
after the lands situated at Doddamagaravalli while
residing at Bengaluru.
23. Uddegowda (defendant No. 2; DW-1), in his
examination-in-chief, stated that the suit lands were
sold by Renukaiah as there was no income from the
same. He further stated that Renukaiah had been
residing in Bengaluru for more than 20 years and,
having faced difficulty in maintaining the lands and
in constructing a house at Bengaluru, had sold the
suit schedule properties to repay the house loan. It
was also stated that the site upon which the house
was constructed stood in the name of Renukaiah’s
wife.
17
CIVIL APPEAL NO(S). 659 OF 2016

24. We may also take note of the fact that the wife
of Renukaiah, i.e., respondent/plaintiff No. 3, was
not examined on behalf of the plaintiffs. The
plaintiffs’ specific case was that the suit properties
had been sold without any family necessity. At the
time of the sale, respondent/plaintiff No. 1 (PW-1)
was admittedly a minor and had no personal
knowledge regarding the manner in which the family
finances were being managed. The precise knowledge
in this regard would naturally have been with
respondent/plaintiff No. 3, wife of Renukaiah and
would be expected to be aware of the family affairs.
Her non-examination assumes significance,
particularly when the sale deed itself contains a clear
recital that Renukaiah was in financial difficulty and
was unable to look after and improve the properties.
25. The selective institution of the suit for partition
in respect of only the suit schedule properties, while
leaving out the remaining four properties which,
according to the admission made by
respondent/plaintiff No. 1 (PW-1), had been sold to
their uncle, is another circumstance which is of
utmost relevance and creates doubts on the bona
fides of the claim made by respondent Nos. 1-
18
CIVIL APPEAL NO(S). 659 OF 2016

3/plaintiffs. The admission of respondent/plaintiff
No. 1 (PW-1) that the suit had been filed at the
instance of his senior uncle further assumes
significance in this very context. Respondent Nos. 1-
3/plaintiffs have offered no satisfactory explanation
as to the circumstances in which the remaining four
properties came to be sold to their uncle, while the
alienation of only the two suit schedule properties
was sought to be challenged in the present
proceedings. The sale deed/deeds, if any, for
alienation of these four properties were never brought
on record.
26. The allegation that Renukaiah was addicted to
vices such as gambling and drinking also appears to
be an improvement made by respondent/plaintiff No.
1 (PW-1) beyond the pleadings and, in any event,
remained a bald assertion unsupported by
independent evidence. Significantly,
respondent/plaintiff No. 1 (PW-1) himself admitted
that his mother (respondent/plaintiff No. 3) was
aware of his father’s alleged bad habits. The
plaintiffs, therefore, should have examined
respondent/plaintiff No. 3 if they were intending to
establish the said allegation and the circumstances
19
CIVIL APPEAL NO(S). 659 OF 2016

in which the sale was effected, but consciously chose
not to do so.
27. Respondent/plaintiff No. 1 (PW-1) also admitted
that one floor of the house standing on the plot gifted
to his mother by her sister had been constructed in
1991-1992. The specific case of the defendants
including appellant/defendant No. 3 was that the
said construction had been undertaken by
Renukaiah by raising a loan and that the suit
properties were subsequently sold for repayment
thereof. If respondent Nos. 1-3/plaintiffs intended to
controvert this specific assertion,
respondent/plaintiff No. 3, being the wife of
Renukaiah and the person presumably having
knowledge of the family affairs/finances, was the
most material witness to establish to the contrary.
Her non-examination, in the facts and circumstances
of the present case, justified the drawing of an
adverse inference against respondent Nos. 1-
3/plaintiffs.
28. It is also significant that respondent Nos. 1-
3/plaintiffs did not seek cancellation or setting aside
of the registered sale deed executed by Renukaiah in
favour of Ziauddin (defendant No. 1). Though the
20
CIVIL APPEAL NO(S). 659 OF 2016

absence of such a prayer, by itself, may not be
determinative of respondent Nos. 1-3/plaintiffs’
claim, the same assumes significance when
considered cumulatively with the selective manner in
which the suit for partition was instituted, excluding
the other properties which had admittedly been dealt
with by the senior uncle of respondent/plaintiff No. 1
(PW-1). These circumstances, taken together,
materially affect the basis upon which respondent
Nos. 1-3/plaintiffs sought relief of partition in respect
of the suit schedule properties.
29. The High Court, while reversing the well-
reasoned judgment of the trial Court, failed to
adequately consider these material circumstances

emerging from the evidence on record, particularly
the absence of reliable evidence regarding the alleged
undervaluation of the properties, the non-
examination of respondent/plaintiff No. 3, the
admissions made by respondent/plaintiff No. 1
regarding the other properties and the circumstances
surrounding the construction of the Bengaluru
house. Instead, the High Court principally relied
upon the assertion of respondent/plaintiff No. 3
regarding the alleged vices of Renukaiah to conclude
21
CIVIL APPEAL NO(S). 659 OF 2016

that the alienation was not supported by bona fide
necessity.
30. Having regard to the facts and circumstances
noticed hereinabove, we are of the considered view
that the impugned judgment of the High Court does
not withstand judicial scrutiny. The judgment of the
trial Court, dismissing the suit for partition upon
appreciation of the evidence and holding that the sale
proceeds had been utilised towards discharge of the
loan incurred for construction of the Bengaluru
house, was based on a plausible and reasoned
appreciation of the material on record. The High
Court, in our view, was not justified in interfering
with the same merely on the basis of the
unsubstantiated allegation regarding the alleged
vices of Renukaiah.
31. Resultantly, the appeal succeeds and is
accordingly allowed. The impugned judgment and
rd
order dated 23 April, 2010 passed by the High Court
th
is set aside and the judgment and decree dated 14
March, 2002 passed by the trial Court are restored.
Decree be drawn accordingly.

22
CIVIL APPEAL NO(S). 659 OF 2016

32. Pending application(s), if any, shall stand
disposed of.

……………..….……………………J.
(AUGUSTINE GEORGE MASIH)


.…………….....……………………J.
(SANDEEP MEHTA)

NEW DELHI;
SEPTEMBER 16, 2026.



23
CIVIL APPEAL NO(S). 659 OF 2016