Dharmendra Arya vs Municipal Corporation Gwalior

Court
Madhya Pradesh High Court

NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-GWL:34834
1
W.A. No. 1002/2026

IN THE HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
A T G W A L I O R

BEFORE
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE G. S. AHLUWALIA
&
HON'BLE SMT. JUSTICE ANURADHA SHUKLA

th
ON THE 18 OF NOVEMBER, 2026

WRIT APPEAL No. 1002 of 2026
CNR No.: MPHC030084442026
DHARMENDRA ARYA
Versus
MUNICIPAL CORPORATION GWALIOR

Appearance:
Shri Prashant Sharma, Advocate for appellant.
Shri Nakul Khedkar, Advocate for respondent.

JUDGMENT

Per : Justice Gurpal Singh Ahluwalia
This writ appeal, under section 2(1) of the M.P. Uchcha Nyayalaya
(Khand Nyaypeeth Ko Appeal) Adhiniyam, 2005 has been filed against
the order dated 4/2/2026 passed by learned Single Judge in M.P.
No.1994/2023.
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: ANAND
SHRIVASTAVA
Signing time: 20-11-2026
10:13:12

NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-GWL:34834
2
W.A. No. 1002/2026

2. Facts of the case, in short, are that appellant challenged his
termination before the Labour Court No. 1, Gwalior. By Award dated
25.11.2022, his termination order was held to be bad in law but instead of
awarding reinstatement with back wages, the Labour Court No. 1,
Gwalior granted compensation of Rs. 1,00,000/- in lieu of reinstatement
and back wages. Being aggrieved by the said Award, appellant preferred
Writ Petition No. 1994 of 2023. The learned Single Judge, while
affirming the Award of compensation in lieu of reinstatement with back
wages, enhanced the compensation amount of Rs. 1,00,000/- to
Rs.2,50,000/-.
3. Challenging the order passed by the learned single Judge, it is
submitted by counsel for appellant that the learned single Judge as well as
the Labour Court No. 1, after declaring the retrenchment of appellant as
illegal, should have directed for reinstatement with back wages.
4. Considered the submissions made by counsel for the appellant.
5. The Supreme Court in the case of Bharat Sanchar Nigam Limited
Vs. Bhurumal , reported in (2014) 7 SCC 177 has held as under:
“33. It is clear from the reading of the aforesaid judgments that
the ordinary principle of grant of reinstatement with full back
wages, when the termination is found to be illegal is not applied
mechanically in all cases. While that may be a position where
services of a regular/permanent workman are terminated
illegally and/or mala fide and/or by way of victimisation, unfair
labour practice, etc. However, when it comes to the case of
termination of a daily-wage worker and where the termination
is found illegal because of a procedural defect, namely, in
violation of Section 25-F of the Industrial Disputes Act, this
Court is consistent in taking the view that in such cases
reinstatement with back wages is not automatic and instead the
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: ANAND
SHRIVASTAVA
Signing time: 20-11-2026
10:13:12

NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-GWL:34834
3
W.A. No. 1002/2026

workman should be given monetary compensation which will
meet the ends of justice. Rationale for shifting in this direction
is obvious.”
6. The Supreme Court in the case of Jayant Vasantrao Hiwarkar
Vs. Anoop Ganaptrao Bobde , reported in (2017) 11 SCC 244 has
upheld the grant of compensation in lieu of reinstatement as the
respondent had merely worked for a period of one year.
7. The Supreme Court in the case Hari Nandan Prasad and Another
Vs. Employer I/R to Management of Food Corporation of India and
Another , reported in (2014) 7 SCC 190 has held as under:-
''19. The following passages from the said judgment would
reflect the earlier decisions of this Court on the question of
reinstatement: (BSNL case, SCC pp. 187-88, paras 29-30)
“29. The learned counsel for the appellant referred
to two judgments wherein this Court granted
compensation instead of reinstatement. In BSNL v.
Man Singh, this Court has held that when the
termination is set aside because of violation of
Section 25- F of the Industrial Disputes Act, it is
not necessary that relief of reinstatement be also
given as a matter of right. In Incharge Officer v.
Shankar Shetty, it was held that those cases where
the workman had worked on daily-wage basis, and
worked merely for a period of 240 days or 2 to 3
years and where the termination had taken place
many years ago, the recent trend was to grant
compensation in lieu of reinstatement.
30. In this judgment of Shankar Shetty, this trend
was reiterated by referring to various judgments, as
is clear from the following discussion: (SCC pp.
127-28, paras 2-4)
„2. Should an order of reinstatement
automatically follow in a case where the
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: ANAND
SHRIVASTAVA
Signing time: 20-11-2026
10:13:12

NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-GWL:34834
4
W.A. No. 1002/2026

engagement of a daily-wager has been
brought to an end in violation of Section
25-F of the Industrial Disputes Act 1947
(for short “the ID Act”)? The course of
the decisions of this Court in recent years
has been uniform on the above question.
3. In Jagbir Singh v. Haryana State
Agriculture Mktg. Board, delivering the
judgment of this Court, one of us (R.M.
Lodha, J.) noticed some of the recent
decisions of this Court, namely, U.P. State
Brassware Corpn. Ltd. v. Uday Narain
Pandey, Uttaranchal Forest Development
Corpn. v. M.C. Joshi, State of M.P. v.
Lalit Kumar Verma, M.P. Admn. v.
Tribhuban, Sita Ram v. Moti Lal Nehru
Farmers Training Institute, Jaipur
Development Authority v. Ramsahai,
GDA v. Ashok Kumar and Mahboob
Deepak v. Nagar Panchayat, Gajraula and
stated as follows: (Jagbir Singh case, SCC
pp. 330 & 335, paras 7 & 14)
“7. It is true that the earlier view
of this Court articulated in many
decisions reflected the legal
position that if the termination of
an employee was found to be
illegal, the relief of reinstatement
with full back wages would
ordinarily follow. However, in
recent past, there has been a shift
in the legal position and in a long
line of cases, this Court has
consistently taken the view that
relief by way of reinstatement
with back wages is not automatic
and may be wholly inappropriate
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: ANAND
SHRIVASTAVA
Signing time: 20-11-2026
10:13:12

NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-GWL:34834
5
W.A. No. 1002/2026

in a given fact situation even
though the termination of an
employee is in contravention of
the prescribed procedure.
Compensation instead of
reinstatement has been held to
meet the ends of justice.
*
14. It would be, thus, seen that by
a catena of decisions in recent
time, this Court has clearly laid
down that an order of
retrenchment passed in violation
of Section 25-F although may be
set aside but an award of
reinstatement should not,
however, be automatically
passed. The award of
reinstatement with full back
wages in a case where the
workman has completed 240
days of work in a year preceding
the date of termination,
particularly, daily-wagers has not
been found to be proper by this
Court and instead compensation
has been awarded. This Court has
distinguished between a daily-
wager who does not hold a post
and a permanent employee.”
4. Jagbir Singh has been applied very
recently in Telegraph Deptt. v. Santosh
Kumar Seal, wherein this Court stated:
(SCC p. 777, para 11)
11. In view of the aforesaid legal
position and the fact that the
workmen were engaged as
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: ANAND
SHRIVASTAVA
Signing time: 20-11-2026
10:13:12

NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-GWL:34834
6
W.A. No. 1002/2026

daily- wagers about 25 years
back and they worked hardly for
2 or 3 years, relief of
reinstatement and back wages to
them cannot be said to be
justified and instead monetary
compensation would subserve
the ends of justice.‟”

21. We make it clear that reference to Umadevi, in the aforesaid
discussion is in a situation where the dispute referred pertained
to termination alone. Going by the principles carved out above,
had it been a case where the issue is limited only to the validity
of termination, Appellant 1 would not be entitled to
reinstatement...........''

8. The Supreme Court in the case of O.P. Bhandari Vs. Indian
Tourism Development Corporation Limited and others , (1986) 4
SCC 337 has held as under :
“ 6. Time is now ripe to turn to the next question as to whether it
is obligatory to direct reinstatement when the concerned
regulation is found to be void. In the sphere of employer-
employee relations in public sector undertakings, to which
Article 12 of the Constitution of India is attracted, it cannot be
posited that reinstatement must invariably follow as a
consequence of holding that an order of termination of service
of an employee is void. No doubt in regard to “blue collar”
workmen and “white collar” employees other than those
belonging to the managerial or similar high level cadre,
reinstatement would be a rule, and compensation in lieu thereof
a rare exception. Insofar as the high level managerial cadre is
concerned, the matter deserves to be viewed from an altogether
different perspective — a larger perspective which must take
into account the demands of National Interest and the resultant
compulsion to ensure the success of the public sector in its
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: ANAND
SHRIVASTAVA
Signing time: 20-11-2026
10:13:12

NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-GWL:34834
7
W.A. No. 1002/2026

competitive co-existence with the private sector. The public
sector can never fulfil its life aim or successfully vie with the
private sector if it is not managed by capable and efficient
personnel with unimpeachable integrity and the requisite vision,
who enjoy the fullest confidence of the “policy-makers” of such
undertakings. Then and then only can the public sector
undertaking achieve the goals of
( 1 ) maximum production for the benefit of the
community,
( 2 ) social justice for workers, consumers and
the people, and
( 3 ) reasonable return on the public funds
invested in the undertaking.
7. It is in public interest that such undertakings or their Boards
of Directors are not compelled and obliged to entrust their
managements to personnel in whom, on reasonable grounds,
they have no trust or faith and with whom they are in a bona
fide manner unable to function harmoniously as a team working
arm-in-arm with success in the aforesaid three-dimensional
sense as their common goal. These factors have to be taken into
account by the court at the time of passing the consequential
order, for the court has full discretion in the matter of granting
relief, and the court can sculpture the relief to suit the needs of
the matter at hand. The court, if satisfied that ends of justice so
demand, can certainly direct that the employer shall have the
option not to reinstate provided the employer pays reasonable
compensation as indicated by the court.”

9. Thus, it is clear that where the termination is set aside on the
ground of non-compliance of mandatory provision of Section 25-F of
the ID Act, compensation can be granted in lieu of reinstatement and
back wages.
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: ANAND
SHRIVASTAVA
Signing time: 20-11-2026
10:13:12

NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-GWL:34834
8
W.A. No. 1002/2026

10. Under these circumstances, this Court is of considered opinion that
no case is made out warranting interference.
11. Accordingly, writ appeal fails and is, hereby, dismissed.

(G. S. AHLUWALIA) (ANURADHA SHUKLA)
JUDGE JUDGE


(and)
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: ANAND
SHRIVASTAVA
Signing time: 20-11-2026
10:13:12