Daya Shankar Dubey vs Union Of India

Court
Madhya Pradesh High Court

NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:91339
1 WP-19177-2011
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
AT JABALPUR

BEFORE
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE ANAND SINGH BAHRAWAT
th
ON THE 17 OF NOVEMBER, 2026
WRIT PETITION No. 19177 of 2011
CNR No.: MPHC010496992011
DAYA SHANKAR DUBEY
Versus
UNION OF INDIA AND OTHERS
Appearance:
Shri A. P. Singh - Advocate and Shri Jatin Sharma - Advocate for the
petitioner.
Shri Ashish Agrawal - Advocate for the respondent.
ORDER
The present petition has been filed seeking the following relief :-
" (i) A Writ of Certiorari quashing the impugned order
(Ann.P-2 &4).
(ii) A command to Respondents to reinstate the
Petitioner with all consequential benefits.
(iii) Any other relief which this Hon'ble Court may
deems fit and proper, including the cost of the litigation.
(iv) Issue a writ of certiorari quashing the impugned
order dated 29.02.2012 (P/6)."
2. Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that the petitioner was
initially appointed to the post of Constable and, at the relevant point of time,
was posted at Guna. A charge-sheet dated 28.06.2010 was issued to the
petitioner, alleging certain acts of misconduct. In response thereto, the
petitioner submitted his explanation/reply to the charge-sheet. However, the
disciplinary authority, without duly considering the explanation submitted by
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: SHALINI
LANDGE
Signing time: 19-11-2026
10:19:36

NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:91339
2 WP-19177-2011
the petitioner, proceeded to appoint an Enquiry Officer and a Presenting

Officer to conduct the departmental enquiry. Thereafter, the Enquiry Officer
conducted the departmental enquiry and submitted his enquiry report to the
disciplinary authority. The disciplinary authority, in turn, supplied a copy of
the enquiry report to the petitioner and called upon him to submit his
explanation/reply against the findings recorded therein. In response thereto,
the petitioner submitted his explanation/reply dated 15.11.2010. However,
the disciplinary authority, vide impugned order dated 29.01.2011, imposed
the penalty of removal from service upon the petitioner. Being aggrieved by
the aforesaid order, the petitioner preferred a departmental appeal dated
25.02.2011 before the appellate authority. Learned counsel for the petitioner
further submits that the petitioner had specifically raised various factual and
legal grounds in the memo of appeal, particularly those containing 6 pages.
However, without adverting to or dealing with the grounds raised by the
petitioner in the appeal, the appellate authority rejected the same vide order
dated 18.10.2011, which is cryptic, non-speaking and devoid of reasons. It is
further contended that the appellate authority, being a quasi-judicial
authority, was under an obligation to independently consider the grounds
raised in the appeal and pass a reasoned and speaking order dealing with the
material contentions advanced by the petitioner. However, the appellate
authority failed to discharge its statutory obligation and rejected the appeal
without assigning any cogent reasons. Thereafter, the petitioner preferred a
revision before the revisional authority, raising the aforesaid grounds and
challenging the legality and validity of the orders passed by the disciplinary
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: SHALINI
LANDGE
Signing time: 19-11-2026
10:19:36

NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:91339
3 WP-19177-2011
and appellate authorities. However, the revisional authority also failed to

consider the material grounds raised by the petitioner and dismissed the
revision without properly examining the petitioner's contentions.
3. Per contra, learned counsel appearing for the respondents submits
that the disciplinary authority, after duly considering the material available
on record, the evidence adduced during the departmental enquiry and the
explanation submitted by the petitioner, has passed the order imposing the
penalty of removal from service. It is further submitted that the appellate
authority has also considered the relevant facts, circumstances and grounds
raised by the petitioner in the memo of appeal and, upon due consideration
thereof, rightly rejected the appeal vide order dated 18.10.2011. Thereafter,
the revisional authority also examined the matter and rightly rejected the
revision preferred by the petitioner. Learned counsel for the respondents
further submits that the scope of judicial review under Article 226 of the
Constitution of India in matters relating to disciplinary proceedings is
limited. This Court, while exercising its writ jurisdiction, does not sit as an
appellate authority over the findings recorded by the disciplinary authority or
the appellate authority, nor is it permissible for this Court to reappreciate the
evidence as if exercising appellate jurisdiction. In the absence of any
illegality, procedural irregularity, violation of the principles of natural
justice, perversity in the findings or any other ground warranting interference
in the exercise of judicial review, no interference with the impugned orders
is called for. Accordingly, learned counsel for the respondents prays for
dismissal of the writ petition.
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: SHALINI
LANDGE
Signing time: 19-11-2026
10:19:36

NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:91339
4 WP-19177-2011
4. Heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the record.

5. The relevant part of appeal rejection order dated
18.10.2011(Annexure P/4) passed by Appellate Authority reads as under:-
" 01.07.2010
उपयु  आरोप प
अपीलाथ  ने दनांक को ा कया
, ,
। उपयु  आरोप प
क  जाँच हेतु ी एस.पी.िसंह िनर %&क रेल सुर &ा
,
बल भोपाल पो )ट को जाँच अिधकार % नािमत कया गया। जाँच

अिधकार % .ारा अपीलाथ  को िनयमानुसार सभी सु /वधाय1 दान करते

हुये /वभागीय जाँच पूण  कर जाँच 4रपोट अनुशासिनक
/ ,
अिधकार % व 4र.म6डल सुर &ा आयु  भोपाल को दनांक
02.11.2010
े/षत क  गई । अनुशासिनक ािधकार% जाँच अिधकार % क 

जाँच 4रपोट से सहमत होते जाँच 4रपोट क  एक ित अपीलाथ  को
हुये

अपना अंितम बचाव अ :यावेदन देने हेतु दनांक दान क  गयी।
15.11.2010
अपीलाथ  .ारा अ :यावेदन िन ;<त समयाविध म 1 दनांक

को अनुशासिनक अिधकार % को े/षत कया गया।
/ /
अनुशासिनक अिधकार % व 4र. म 6डल सुर &ा आयु  भोपाल के =प म

अपीलाथ  को उस पर लगाये गये सभी आरोप > का दोषी पाते हुये आदेश
-17/2011 29.01.2011 "
?मांक दनांक के मा @यम से अपीलाथ  को सेवा
"
से हटाये जाने के द 6ड से द ;6डत कया ।
01.02.2011
उ  द 6डादेश को अपीलाथ  ने दनांक को ा कया तथा

इस द 6डादेश के /व=B िन ;<त समयाविध के दौरान अपीलाथ  ने दनांक
25.02.2011 ,
को अपनी अपील )तुत क  जो व 4र. म 6डल सुर &ा
/
आयु  भोपाल के मा @यम से इस काया लय को ा है।
हुई

अधोह )ता&र% ने स Eपूण केस िमिसल एवं अपीलाथ  .ारा )तुत

अपीलीय अ :यावेदन का @यानपूवक अ @ययन कया । म Fने पाया क

अपीलाथ  पर लगाये गये आरोप /वभागीय जाँच म 1 पूण तः िस B पाये गये

है । अपीलाथ  .ारा कया गया कृ Iय अनुशािसत बल क  J/K से िनंदनीय

एवं घोर अनुशासनह %नता का Mोतक है । म F /वभागीय जाँच एवं

अनुशासिनक ािधकार% .ारा क  गई काय वाह% से पूण तः सहमत हूँ।

म Fने पाया क अपीलाथ  .ारा कये गये कदाचार के अनुपात म

अनुशासिनक अिधकार % .ारा द % गयी सजा उिचत है। अपीलाथ  ने उनक 

अपील म 1 ऐसा कोई भी नया त Oय अथवा तक  )तुत नह %ं कया है

;जसके आधार पर अनुशासिनक अिधकार % .ारा अिधरो /पत द 6ड म

कसी तरह का ह )त&ेप कया जाये । अतः अपीलाथ  क  अपील को

4रजेPट करते अनुशासिनक अिधकार % .ारा दये गये द 6ड को
हुये

यथावत रखने का आदेश देता
हूँ।
, ,
उ  आदेश के /वRB अपीलाथ  चाहे तो महािनदेशक रेल सुर &ा बल
,
रे Sवे बोड  नई दSली को अपनी 4रवीजन /पट%शन िनधा 4रत अविध के
"
भीतर े/षत कर सकते ह F ।
6. After perusal of the record, it is apparent that the appellate authority,
being a quasi-judicial authority, was under an obligation to independently
consider the grounds raised in the appeal and pass a reasoned and speaking
order dealing with the material contentions advanced by the petitioner.
However, the appellate authority failed to discharge its statutory obligation
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: SHALINI
LANDGE
Signing time: 19-11-2026
10:19:36

NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:91339
5 WP-19177-2011
and rejected the appeal without assigning any cogent reasons. Thereafter, the

petitioner preferred a revision before the revisional authority, raising the
aforesaid grounds and challenging the legality and validity of the orders
passed by the disciplinary and appellate authorities. It is a settled position in
law that when a discretion is vested in an authority to exercise a particular
power, the same is required to be exercised with due diligence, and in
reasonable and rational manner. The Hon'ble Supreme Court in catena of
decisions has reiterated time and again the necessity and importance of
giving reasons by the authority in support of its decision. It has been held
that the face of an order passed by a quasi-judicial authority or even by an
administrative authority affecting the rights of parties must speak. The
affected party must know how his case or defence was considered before
passing the prejudicial order.
7. The decision of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of State of
Punjab v/s. Bandip Singh and others reported in (2016) 1 SCC 724 is
relevant to quote. In the said decision it had been held by the Hon'ble
Supreme Court that every decision of an administrative or executive nature
must be a composite and self-sustaining one, in that it should contain all the
reasons which prevailed on the official taking the decision to arrive at his
conclusion.
8. In the same judgment in paragraph 7, the Hon'ble Supreme Court
clarifies that the Government does not have carte blanche to take any
decision it chooses to; it cannot take a capricious, arbitrary or prejudiced
decision. Its decision must be informed and impregnated with reasons.
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: SHALINI
LANDGE
Signing time: 19-11-2026
10:19:36

NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:91339
6 WP-19177-2011
Paragraph 7 of the said decision is quoted as under:-

“7. The same principle was upheld more recently in Ram Kishun v. State of
U.P. (2012) 11 SCC 511 : (2013) 1 SCC (Civ) 382. However, we must hasten
to clarify that the Government does not have a carte blanche to take any
decision it chooses to; it cannot take a capricious, arbitrary or prejudiced
decision. Its decision must be informed and impregnated with reasons.
This has already been discussed threadbare in several decisions of this Court,
including in Sterling Computers Ltd. v. M & N Publications Ltd (1993) 1 SCC
445, Tata Cellular v. Union of India (1994) 6 SCC 651, Air India Ltd. v.
Cochin International Airport Ltd. (2000) 2 SCC 617, B.S.N. Joshi & Sons Ltd.
v. Nair Coal Services Ltd. (2006) 11 SCC 548 and Jagdish Mandal v. State of
Orissa (2007) 14 SCC 517”.
9. Also the decision of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of
Kranti Associates Pvt. Ltd. and another v/s Masood Ahmed Khan and others
cited in (2010) 9 SCC 496 highlights this point. The Hon'ble Supreme Court
in paragraph 15 opined that the face of an order passed by a quasi judicial
authority or even an administrative authority affecting the rights of parties,
must speak. It must not be like the inscrutable face of a sphinx. In paragraph
47 the Honb'le Supreme Court summarized its discussion. The relevant sub-
paragraphs of the said summary are quoted as under:-
"47. Summarising the above discussion, this Court holds:
(f) Reasons have virtually become as indispensable a component
of a decisionmaking process as observing principles of natural
justice by judicial, quasi-judicial and even by administrative
bodies.
(h) The ongoing judicial trend in all countries committed to rule of
law and constitutional governance is in favour of reasoned
decisions based on relevant facts. This is virtually the lifeblood of
judicial decision-making justifying the principle that reason is the
soul of justice.
(i) Judicial or even quasi-judicial opinions these days can be as
different as the judges and authorities who deliver them. All these
decisions serve one common purpose which is to demonstrate by
reason that the relevant factors have been objectively considered.
This is important for sustaining the litigants’ faith in the justice
delivery system.
(n) Since the requirement to record reasons emanates from the
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: SHALINI
LANDGE
Signing time: 19-11-2026
10:19:36

NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:91339
7 WP-19177-2011
broad doctrine of fairness in decision-making, the said
requirement is now virtually a component of human rights and was
considered part of Stasbourg Jurisprudence. See Ruiz torija v.
Spain (1994) 19 EHRR 553, at 562 para 29 and Anya v. University
of Oxford 2001 EWCA Civ 405 (CA), wherein the Court referred
to Article 6 of the European Convention of Human Rights which
requires,“adequate and intelligent reasons must be given for
judicial decisions”.

10. In view of the aforesaid discussion, this Court finds that the
appellate authority, while rejecting the appeal preferred by the petitioner, has
failed to consider and deal with the material facts and grounds raised in the
memo of appeal. The order dated 18.10.2011 passed by the appellate
authority is, therefore, non-speaking and devoid of reasons. Consequently,
the same cannot be sustained in the eyes of law and is hereby quashed and set
aside. Since the revisional order dated 29.02.2012 is consequential to the
aforesaid appellate order, the same is also hereby quashed and set
aside. Accordingly, the matter is remitted to the appellate authority for fresh
consideration. The petitioner shall also be at liberty to submit a fresh
appeal/representation, along with the relevant grounds and documents,
before the appellate authority within a period of three weeks from the date of
this order. In the event of submission of a fresh appeal/representation by the
petitioner within the aforesaid period, the appellate authority shall consider
the same along with the earlier appeal and pass a reasoned and speaking
order, dealing with the material grounds raised by the petitioner, after
affording him an opportunity of personal hearing, in accordance with law.
The aforesaid exercise shall be completed within a period of three months
from the date of receipt of a certified copy of this order.
11. It is made clear that this Court has not expressed any opinion on
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: SHALINI
LANDGE
Signing time: 19-11-2026
10:19:36

NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:91339
8 WP-19177-2011
the merits of the case. The appellate authority shall consider the matter

independently, without being influenced by any observations made in this
order, and shall pass an appropriate order in accordance with law.
12. With the aforesaid directions, the writ petition stands disposed of.
(ANAND SINGH BAHRAWAT)
JUDGE
SSL

Signature Not Verified
Signed by: SHALINI
LANDGE
Signing time: 19-11-2026
10:19:36